Knowledge (XXG)

Criticisms of corporations

Source 📝

239:
recall Adam Smith's critique of the "joint stock companies" of his day, particularly if management is granted a degree of independence; and his attitude toward the inherent corruption of private power, probably a "conspiracy against the public" when businessmen meet for lunch, in his acid view, let alone when they form collectivist legal entities and alliances among them, with extraordinary rights granted, backed, and enhanced by state power.
24: 127:
the East India Company demonstrated inherent flaws in the corporate form. The division between owners and managers in a joint-stock company, and the limited legal liability this division was based on guaranteed that stockholders would be apathetic about a company's activities as long as the company continued to be profitable. Just as problematic, the
126:
Bribery and corruption were inherent in this type of corporate model because the local managers sought to avoid close supervision by the Courts of Governors, politicians, and Prime Ministers. In these circumstances, Smith did not consider joint-stock company governance to be honest. More importantly,
73:. Some opponents to this granting of "personhood" to an organization with no personal liability contend that it creates a legal entity with the extensive financial resources to co-opt public policy and exploit resources and populations without any moral or legal responsibility to encourage restraint. 226:
Corporations, which previously had been considered artificial entities with no rights, were accorded all the rights of persons, and far more, since they are "immortal persons", and "persons" of extraordinary wealth and power. Furthermore, they were no longer bound to the specific purposes designated
238:
When the corporatization of the state capitalist societies took place a century ago, in part in reaction to massive market failures, conservatives – a breed that now scarcely exists– objected to this attack on the fundamental principles of classical liberalism. And rightly so. One may
249:
Chomsky contends that corporations transfer policy decisions out of the hands of the people and into corporate boardrooms, where public oversight is limited. The extensive financial resources of corporations and the extent to which they're employed to influence political campaigns in the United
122:
Furthermore, the context of the quote points to the complications inherent in chartered joint-stock companies. Each company had a Courts of Governors and day-to-day duties were overseen by local managers. Governor supervision of day-to-day operations was minimal and was exacerbated by the poor
98:
The directors with of such companies, however, being the managers rather of other people's money than of their own, it cannot well be expected, that they should watch over it with the same anxious vigilance with which the partners in a private copartnery frequently watch over their own....
209:
Coca-Cola killed trade unionists in Latin America. General Motors built vehicles known to catch fire. Tobacco companies suppressed cancer research. And Boeing knew that its planes were dangerous. Corporations don't care if they kill people — as long as it's
271:
noted that the corporate businesses which foreign visitors came to see and marvel at, as "showpiece of American industrial achievement," were the very same ones that government attorneys scrutinized in their search for monopolistic wrongdoing.
131:
upon which the corporate form was based allowed for boards of directors to be so autonomous from and unconstrained by stockholder wishes that directors became negligent and ultimately self-interested in the management of the corporation.
258:"No other institution in American history—not even slavery—has ever been so consistently unpopular...with the American public. It was controversial from the outset, and it has remained controversial to this day." 201:, writer and sociologist Nicole Aschoff attributes the "unscrupulous" and "sometimes deadly" behavior of corporations to the "elevation of profit above all else," which she says is "a defining feature of 264:
was one of the first to experience that paradox in a spectacular and personal way. By the last decade of the 19th century, Rockefeller found that he had become "the most hated man in the world."
69:
remains controversial for several reasons, most of which stem from the granting of corporations both limited liability on the part of its members and the status and rights of a
45: 32: 412: 107:
was the joint-stock company. In the 18th century, the joint-stock company was a distinct entity created by the King of Great Britain as
515: 510: 281: 166: 154: 387: 181:
machine (moving its operating costs to external organizations and people), in the same way that a shark is a killing machine.
141: 99:
Negligence and profusion, therefore, must always prevail, more or less, in the management of the affairs of such a company.
147:
describes the modern corporate entity as 'an institutional psychopath' and a 'psychopathic creature.' In the documentary
149: 250:
States has also been implicated as a way in which corporations undermine the democratic institutions in a society.
359: 320: 37: 287: 520: 268: 94:
corporate form because the separation of ownership and management could lead to inefficient management.
86: 261: 222:
and others have criticized the legal decisions that led to the creation of the modern corporation:
153:, Bakan claims that corporations, when considered as natural living persons, exhibit the traits of 91: 197: 192: 178: 162: 116: 408: 205:." She adds that "the catalog of the ethical and moral crimes of corporations is impressive": 70: 302: 391: 297: 504: 128: 108: 454: 384: 292: 219: 428: 158: 66: 202: 144: 81: 23: 112: 407:. New York, New York, United States: Seven Stories Press. p. 175. 227:
by State charter, but could act as they choose, with few constraints.
170: 345: 111:
trading companies. These entities were sometimes awarded legal
333:
An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations
17: 494: 455:"The Corporation and John D. Rockefeller's Bewilderment." 360:"Corporations Would Literally Kill You to Turn a Profit" 115:
in designated regions of the world, such as the British
267:
Around the middle of the 20th century, the economist
103:
The context for Adam Smith's term for "companies" in
405:Profit Over People: Neoliberalism and Global Order 236: 224: 207: 175: 96: 77:Divisions between labor, management, and owners 8: 140:Legal Scholar and Professor of Law at the 48:of all important aspects of the article. 313: 293:Big business#Criticism of big business 44:Please consider expanding the lead to 497:, a corporation watchdog organisation 7: 358:Aschoff, Nicole (January 21, 2020). 123:communications of the 18th century. 288:Multinational corporation#Criticism 65:The notion of a legally sanctioned 14: 442:Reflections of a Neoconservative 215:Analogy with totalitarian regime 22: 155:antisocial personality disorder 36:may be too short to adequately 321:Adam Smith The Lost Legacy.com 142:University of British Columbia 46:provide an accessible overview 1: 429:Corporations Versus Democracy 335:741 (Clarendon, Oxford 1776). 537: 279: 169:candidate for Senate from 478:John Kenneth Galbraith. 385:Noam Chomsky and the Law 516:Criticisms of companies 511:Anti-corporate activism 282:Criticisms of companies 403:Chomsky, Noam (1999). 346:The Corporation (2003) 269:John Kenneth Galbraith 247: 235: 212: 189: 177:The corporation is an 101: 344:Bakan, Joel (writer) 136:Psychopathic behavior 105:The Wealth of Nations 87:The Wealth of Nations 453:Charles Churchyard. 427:Ned Resnikoff. 2007 161:. Also in the film, 480:American Capitalism 469:. NY, 1980. Ch. 36. 444:. NY, 1983. p. 204. 262:John D. Rockefeller 92:joint-stock company 482:. NY, 1956. p. 91. 390:2007-12-14 at the 193:American socialist 163:Robert A. G. Monks 117:East India Company 414:978-1-888363-82-1 63: 62: 528: 483: 476: 470: 465:David F. Hawke. 463: 457: 451: 445: 440:Irving Kristol. 438: 432: 425: 419: 418: 400: 394: 383:Robert Barksky, 381: 375: 374: 372: 370: 355: 349: 342: 336: 329: 323: 318: 303:Evil corporation 245: 233: 191:Writing for the 187: 167:Republican Party 58: 55: 49: 26: 18: 536: 535: 531: 530: 529: 527: 526: 525: 501: 500: 491: 486: 477: 473: 464: 460: 452: 448: 439: 435: 426: 422: 415: 402: 401: 397: 392:Wayback Machine 382: 378: 368: 366: 357: 356: 352: 343: 339: 330: 326: 319: 315: 311: 298:Corporate crime 284: 280:Main category: 278: 256: 246: 243: 234: 231: 217: 188: 185: 150:The Corporation 138: 90:criticized the 79: 59: 53: 50: 43: 31:This article's 27: 12: 11: 5: 534: 532: 524: 523: 518: 513: 503: 502: 499: 498: 490: 489:External links 487: 485: 484: 471: 458: 446: 433: 420: 413: 395: 376: 350: 337: 324: 312: 310: 307: 306: 305: 300: 295: 290: 277: 274: 255: 252: 241: 229: 216: 213: 183: 137: 134: 129:laws of agency 78: 75: 61: 60: 54:September 2016 40:the key points 30: 28: 21: 13: 10: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 533: 522: 521:Global issues 519: 517: 514: 512: 509: 508: 506: 496: 493: 492: 488: 481: 475: 472: 468: 462: 459: 456: 450: 447: 443: 437: 434: 431:. The Nation. 430: 424: 421: 416: 410: 406: 399: 396: 393: 389: 386: 380: 377: 365: 361: 354: 351: 348:(Documentary) 347: 341: 338: 334: 328: 325: 322: 317: 314: 308: 304: 301: 299: 296: 294: 291: 289: 286: 285: 283: 275: 273: 270: 265: 263: 259: 253: 251: 240: 228: 223: 221: 214: 211: 206: 204: 200: 199: 194: 182: 180: 179:externalizing 174: 172: 168: 164: 160: 156: 152: 151: 146: 143: 135: 133: 130: 124: 120: 118: 114: 110: 109:Royal Charter 106: 100: 95: 93: 89: 88: 83: 76: 74: 72: 68: 57: 47: 41: 39: 34: 29: 25: 20: 19: 16: 479: 474: 466: 461: 449: 441: 436: 423: 404: 398: 379: 369:November 14, 367:. Retrieved 363: 353: 340: 332: 331:Adam Smith, 327: 316: 266: 260: 257: 248: 244:Noam Chomsky 237: 232:Noam Chomsky 225: 220:Noam Chomsky 218: 208: 196: 195:publication 190: 176: 148: 139: 125: 121: 104: 102: 97: 85: 80: 71:legal person 64: 51: 35: 33:lead section 15: 210:profitable. 165:, a former 159:psychopathy 67:corporation 505:Categories 309:References 203:capitalism 186:Joel Bakan 145:Joel Bakan 82:Adam Smith 495:CorpWatch 254:Reception 38:summarize 388:Archived 276:See also 242:—  230:—  184:—  173:, says: 113:monopoly 364:Jacobin 198:Jacobin 467:John D 411:  171:Maine 409:ISBN 371:2021 157:or 84:in 507:: 362:. 119:. 417:. 373:. 56:) 52:( 42:.

Index


lead section
summarize
provide an accessible overview
corporation
legal person
Adam Smith
The Wealth of Nations
joint-stock company
Royal Charter
monopoly
East India Company
laws of agency
University of British Columbia
Joel Bakan
The Corporation
antisocial personality disorder
psychopathy
Robert A. G. Monks
Republican Party
Maine
externalizing
American socialist
Jacobin
capitalism
Noam Chomsky
John D. Rockefeller
John Kenneth Galbraith
Criticisms of companies
Multinational corporation#Criticism

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.