237:
No. 58 of Asher's genuine responsa). "Besamim Rosh" ascribes the following opinions to the neo-Talmudists of the thirteenth century: "Articles of faith must be adapted to the times; and at present the most essential article is that we all are utterly worthless and depraved, and that our only duty consists in loving truth and peace and learning to know God and His works" (l.c.). One of the controversial responsum in the "Besamim Rosh" stated that the historical Jewish customs against mourning for someone who committed suicide and likewise not burying someone who committed suicide in a Jewish cemetery were not applicable because of the terrible difficulties facing the Jews. In other words, it would be permissible to mourn for someone who committed suicide due to depression. This ruling on laws of mourning for death from suicide from the "Besamim Rosh" would be cited by
203:, and then argued deception in a circular letter addressed to Berlin's father, by critically analyzing the responsa and arguing that they were spurious. Levin tried in vain to defend his son. Berlin resigned his rabbinate and, to end the dispute, went to London where he died a few months later. In a letter found in his pocket, he warned everybody against looking into his papers, requesting that they be sent to his father. He expressed the wish to be buried not in a cemetery, but in some lonely spot, and in the same garments in which he died.
242:
to be the author of the two responsa concerning the modification of the ceremonial laws, especially of such that were apparently especially burdensome to the Berlin youth. For instance, it gives permission to Jewish men to shave their beards (No. 18), to drink non-kosher wine, "yayin nesek" (No. 36), and to continue traveling on Friday night if one is in the middle of a journey and can't stop before
183:
171:, where Raphael was chief rabbi, the work and its author was placed under the ban. The dispute that then arose concerning the validity of the ban turned entirely on the question of whether a personal element, like the attack upon the rabbi of Altona, justified such a punishment. Some Polish rabbis supported the ban, while some declared the ban invalid as did
163:
Talmudist, and had considered it their duty to print it and submit it to the judgment of specialists. To secure the anonymity more thoroughly, Berlin and his father were named among those who were to pass upon it. Berlin's statements, especially his personal attacks against those he disagreed with, undermined his cause. When it reached
316:
241:
in a responsum written in Cairo in 1950. Yosef would later also write a haskamah for the 1984 edition of
Besamim Rosh. Ovadia Yosef was aware that the work was considered a forgery but determined that there were valuable teachings in it which were of use in deciding Jewish law. Berlin is also alleged
236:
and its commands can not be gained directly from it or from tradition, but only by means of the philosophico-logical training derived from non-Jewish sources. However, Asher ben Jehiel had condemned the study of philosophy and even of the natural sciences as being un-Jewish and pernicious (compare
231:
wrote an approbation. Berlin said that the work "Besamim Rosh" had been compiled from Asher ben Jehiel's writings in the sixteenth century by Isaac de Molina. Some responsa that arouse suspicion in the work are, for instance, responsum No. 251, that states an insight into the principles of the
162:
Under the name "Ovadiah b. Baruch of Poland," Berlin attempted in this work to ridicule
Talmudic science, and to stigmatize one of its foremost exponents not only as ignorant, but also as dishonest. The publishers declared in the preface that they had received the work from a traveling Polish
226:
attributed to Asher ben Jehiel of the thirteenth century, but which is widely considered a forgery composed by Saul Berlin himself. Besamim Rosh was first published in Berlin in 1793. Berlin added glosses and comments that he called "Kassa de-Harsna" (Fish Fare).
259:
The exact historicity of "Besamim Rosh" is still disputed, with it being unclear which parts are forgeries. The
Besamim Rosh was reprinted in 1881 and 1984, but some of the texts considered most controversial were removed from the later printings of the work.
127:
warmly defended in his own contention with the rabbis while pleading for German education among the Jews. Berlin used humor to describe what he viewed as the absurd methods of the Jewish schools, and alleges how the rabbinic
195:. Berlin said that the work "Besamim Rosh" had been compiled from Asher ben Jehiel's writings in the sixteenth century by Isaac de Molina. However, rabbinic critics of his day suspected that Berlin had forged the work.
190:
Before the excitement over this affair had subsided, Berlin created a new sensation by another work. In 1793 he published in Berlin, under the title "Besamim Rosh" (Incense of Spices), 392 responsa purporting to be by
159:. The latter, one of the most zealous advocates of rabbinic piety, was a rival candidate with Levin for the Berlin rabbinate, which induced Levin's son to represent ha-Kohen as a forbidding example of rabbinism.
409:
Fishman, Talya (1998). "Forging Jewish Memory: Besamim Rosh and the
Invention of Pre-Emancipation Jewish Culture". In Carlebach, E.; Efron, J.; Meyers, D. (eds.).
256:
later wrote that it was prohibited to keep the
Besamim Rosh in one's home and it was permitted to burn it even on a Yom Kippur that falls on Sabbath.
290:
Jost, Gesch. des
Judenthums und Seiner Sekten, iii. 396-400 (curiously enough a defense of the authenticity of the responsa collection Besamim Rosh);
248:. Berlin aroused a storm of indignation from authorities who accused him of fraudulently using the name of one of the most famous rabbis of the
132:âwhich then constituted the greater part of the curriculumâinjures the sound common sense of the pupils and deadens their noblest aspirations.
420:
488:
366:
355:
Anafim : proceedings of the
Australasian Jewish Studies Forum held at Mandelbaum House, University of Sydney, 8-9 February 2004
503:
179:
and a near relation of Berlin. Even the former censured Berlin's actions after circumstances forced him to acknowledge authorship.
513:
518:
103:(where he frequently went to visit his father-in-law), he came into personal contact with the representatives of the
58:
498:
334:
353:
299:
Zunz, Ritus, pp. 226â228, who thinks that Isaac
Satanow had a part in the fabrication of the responsa.
508:
272:
Benet, in
Literaturblatt des Orients, v. 53-55, 140-141 (fragment of his above-mentioned letter to Levin);
390:
309:
81:
483:
478:
144:
104:
329:
493:
253:
416:
362:
70:
192:
80:
Saul Berlin was ordained as a rabbi at age 20. By 1768, aged 28, he had a rabbinic post in
228:
215:
164:
124:
325:
196:
172:
54:
437:
472:
320:
156:
74:
35:
238:
148:
249:
85:
458:
129:
412:
Jewish
History and Jewish Memory: Essays in Honor of Yosef Hayim Yerushalmi
391:"Benefits of the Internet: Besamim Rosh and its History â The Seforim Blog"
182:
223:
319: This article incorporates text from a publication now in the
244:
200:
168:
100:
89:
42:
361:. Australia: Mandelbaum Publishing, University of Sydney. p. 5.
176:
96:
66:
62:
38:
31:
27:
115:
Berlin began his literary career with an anonymous circular letter,
410:
233:
123:) (printed in Berlin, 1794, after the death of the author), which
88:. He married Sarah, the daughter of Rabbi Joseph Jonas Fränkel of
41:
scholar who published a number of works in opposition to rabbinic
53:
He received his general education principally from his father,
65:. Saul, the eldest son, was given an education in both the
296:
M. Straschun, in Fuenn, Kiryah Neemanah, pp. 295â298;
275:
Brann, in the Grätz Jubelschrift, 1887, pp. 255â257;
293:
Landshuth, Toledot Anshe ha-Shem, pp. 84â106, 109;
287:
Horwitz, in Kebod ha-Lebanon, x., part 4, pp. 2â9;
199:
first attempted to prevent the printing of the book in
107:, and became one of its most enthusiastic adherents.
278:Carmoly, Ha-'Orebim u-Bene Yonah, pp. 39â41;
384:
382:
380:
378:
269:Azulai, Shem ha-Gedolim, ed. Wilna, ii. 20, 21;
139:(two place-names in Jos. 15:38; by way of pun
404:
402:
400:
252:to combat rabbinism. The Sochatchover Rebbe,
8:
222:; lit."Choice Spices") is a work of legal
284:Grätz, Gesch. der Juden, xi. 89, 151-153;
438:"Four Methods of Ovadia Yosef (in Heb.)"
181:
143:"Superseder of Yekutiel") (published by
344:
281:Chajes, MinḼat Kenaot, pp. 14, 21;
151:, Berlin, 1789), a polemic against the
135:He later wrote the pseudonymous work,
7:
219:
73:, eventually became Chief Rabbi of
69:and secular subjects. His brother,
14:
459:"Besamim Rosh â The Seforim Blog"
389:Rabinowitz, Dan; Brodt, Eliezer.
328:; et al., eds. (1901â1906).
57:, who had served as rabbi of the
338:. New York: Funk & Wagnalls.
314:
264:Jewish Encyclopedia bibliography
1:
310:Saul Berlin - Heretical Rabbi
30:– November 16, 1794 in
84:in the Prussian province of
535:
489:18th-century German rabbis
26:after his father; 1740 at
186:Besamim Rosh, Berlin 1793
59:Great Synagogue of London
415:. UPNE. pp. 70â88.
16:German rabbi (1740â1794)
352:Apple, Raymond (2006).
335:The Jewish Encyclopedia
147:and his brother-in-law
187:
61:and as chief rabbi of
514:Forgery controversies
185:
82:Frankfort-on-the-Oder
445:Yaacov Herzog Center
105:Jewish Enlightenment
519:Literary forgeries
504:People from GĹogĂłw
254:Avrohom Bornsztain
188:
422:978-0-87451-871-9
175:, chief rabbi of
145:David Friedländer
141:Mitzpah Yekutiel,
71:Solomon Hirschell
526:
463:
462:
455:
449:
448:
442:
433:
427:
426:
406:
395:
394:
386:
373:
372:
360:
349:
339:
318:
317:
221:
193:Asher ben Jehiel
534:
533:
529:
528:
527:
525:
524:
523:
469:
468:
467:
466:
457:
456:
452:
440:
436:Lau, Binyamin.
435:
434:
430:
423:
408:
407:
398:
388:
387:
376:
369:
358:
351:
350:
346:
326:Singer, Isidore
324:
315:
306:
266:
229:Yehezkel Landau
209:
137:Mitzpeh Yokt'el
125:Hartwig Wessely
113:
51:
17:
12:
11:
5:
532:
530:
522:
521:
516:
511:
506:
501:
499:Pseudepigraphy
496:
491:
486:
481:
471:
470:
465:
464:
450:
428:
421:
396:
374:
367:
343:
342:
341:
340:
330:"Berlin, Saul"
312:
305:
302:
301:
300:
297:
294:
291:
288:
285:
282:
279:
276:
273:
270:
265:
262:
208:
205:
197:Mordecai Benet
173:Ezekiel Landau
153:Torat Yekutiel
112:
109:
55:Hirschel Levin
50:
47:
15:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
531:
520:
517:
515:
512:
510:
509:Silesian Jews
507:
505:
502:
500:
497:
495:
492:
490:
487:
485:
482:
480:
477:
476:
474:
460:
454:
451:
446:
439:
432:
429:
424:
418:
414:
413:
405:
403:
401:
397:
392:
385:
383:
381:
379:
375:
370:
368:9780646469591
364:
357:
356:
348:
345:
337:
336:
331:
327:
322:
321:public domain
313:
311:
308:
307:
303:
298:
295:
292:
289:
286:
283:
280:
277:
274:
271:
268:
267:
263:
261:
257:
255:
251:
247:
246:
240:
235:
230:
225:
217:
213:
206:
204:
202:
198:
194:
184:
180:
178:
174:
170:
166:
160:
158:
157:Raphael Cohen
154:
150:
146:
142:
138:
133:
131:
126:
122:
121:Written Truth
118:
110:
108:
106:
102:
98:
93:
91:
87:
83:
78:
76:
75:Great Britain
72:
68:
64:
60:
56:
48:
46:
44:
40:
37:
33:
29:
25:
24:Saul Hirschel
21:
453:
444:
431:
411:
354:
347:
333:
258:
243:
239:Ovadia Yosef
212:Besamim Rosh
211:
210:
207:Besamim Rosh
189:
161:
152:
140:
136:
134:
120:
117:Katuv Yosher
116:
114:
94:
79:
52:
23:
19:
18:
484:1794 deaths
479:1740 births
250:Middle Ages
86:Brandenburg
20:Saul Berlin
494:Talmudists
473:Categories
447:. netu'im.
304:References
49:Early life
220:×׊××× ×¨×׊
130:casuistry
224:Responsa
34:) was a
323::
245:Shabbat
201:Austria
169:Hamburg
101:Breslau
90:Breslau
43:Judaism
419:
365:
216:Hebrew
177:Prague
165:Altona
111:Career
97:Berlin
67:Talmud
63:Berlin
39:Jewish
36:German
32:London
28:Glogau
22:(also
441:(PDF)
359:(PDF)
234:Torah
149:Itzig
417:ISBN
363:ISBN
167:and
99:and
155:of
95:In
475::
443:.
399:^
377:^
332:.
218::
92:.
77:.
45:.
461:.
425:.
393:.
371:.
214:(
119:(
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
