Knowledge (XXG)

Sheila Abdus-Salaam

Source 📝

380:, and added that she had been struggling with depression. On April 18, however, police told reporters that the death was considered "suspicious" due to the lack of witnesses and lack of a suicide note. An autopsy, while reaching no conclusion about the cause of Abdus-Salaam's death, found bruises on her neck and water in her lungs; this data indicated that she had likely been alive when she entered the river. The bruising could have been caused by someone choking Abdus-Salaam, or could have resulted from the recovery of her body from the river. On April 21, police said they had recovered video from the night of April 11 that showed Abdus-Salaam, dressed in the clothes in which she was found dead, walking around 348:
to serve as a judge of the New York Court of Appeals, it appears that these reports were incorrect. Following Abdus-Salaam's death, Court of Appeals spokesperson Gary Spencer stated that she had never converted to Islam, but had merely retained the last name of her first husband. However, in an
271:
Before joining the bench, Abdus-Salaam worked as a staff attorney for Brooklyn Legal Services and served in the New York State Department of Law as an assistant attorney general in the civil rights and real estate financing bureaus. She subsequently served on the
1545: 33: 391:
announced that its investigation into the death of Abdus-Salaam was complete, and that investigators believed she had committed suicide. The medical examiner concluded that the cause of death was drowning and that the manner of death was suicide.
281: 994: 349:
article on Abdus-Salaam's death, NBC News described Abdus-Salaam as "the first Muslim woman to serve as a U.S. judge" and added that her family asserted that she " not been a practicing Muslim for 20 years".
713: 321:, a landmark decision allowing the domestic partners of biological parents to seek child custody or visitation in circumstances where the partners had decided to conceive and raise a child together. 1316: 1283: 599: 908: 811: 1119: 1540: 875: 1019: 991: 1052: 842: 1217: 1520: 406: 970: 539: 1500: 1152: 1186: 1560: 1555: 1550: 778: 499: 1252: 1535: 1530: 1475: 1455: 705: 747: 1480: 1460: 1306: 437: 206: 1085: 1275: 1510: 589: 900: 1505: 1470: 1450: 1098:
Sources said it showed no obvious signs of trauma or injuries indicating criminality or foul play, and that her death appeared to be a suicide.
433: 344:
Abdus-Salaam's religious affiliation has been the subject of conflicting reports. While it was widely reported that Abdus-Salaam was the first
234: 1465: 1445: 801: 1111: 678: 867: 1515: 1495: 943: 1011: 1525: 1042: 834: 1209: 306:
to fill the resulting vacancy on New York's highest court. She was confirmed by the New York State Senate without opposition in a
1485: 401: 338: 966: 384:
along the Hudson River for hours. Police added that the final images captured by the camera showed her standing near the water.
1490: 529: 460: 257: 1142: 1178: 561: 285: 638: 770: 489: 1241: 233:, where she grew up in a working-class family with six siblings. She attended public schools there, graduating from 388: 337:. Her third husband was Hector Nova, from whom she was divorced in 2005. Abdus-Salaam married her fourth husband, 1402: 739: 633: 295: 273: 210: 198: 51: 237:
in 1970. While researching her family history as a child, she learned that her great-grandfather was a slave in
425: 358: 1370: 1342: 1143:"Reports of Suicide Still Swirling, NYPD Now Calls NY Judge Sheila Abdus-Salaam's Drowning Death 'Suspicious'" 197:; March 14, 1952 – April 12, 2017) was an American lawyer and judge. In 2013, after having served on the 1247: 1075: 1440: 277: 202: 317:
Abdus-Salaam was seen as a liberal voice on the bench. In 2016, she authored the opinion of the Court in
1347: 280:
in 1993, and served in that capacity from 1993 to 2009. In 2009, she was designated as a justice of the
214: 268:
Turner took her first husband's surname, Abdus-Salaam, and retained it during her professional career.
1435: 1430: 381: 1343:"What Happened to Judge Sheila Abdus-Salaam? How the story of a New York judge's death was botched" 1147: 1047: 461:"Hon. Sheila Abdus-Salaam: First African American Woman Appointed to the New York State High Court" 249: 167: 806: 562:"Public memorial service for the Honorable Sheila Abdus-Salaam | The Episcopal Diocese of Newark" 534: 666: 1395: 299: 86: 934: 311: 230: 218: 130: 998: 334: 245: 158: 38: 938: 330: 288: 1276:"Police Close Investigation Into New York Judge's Death, Saying It Was Likely Suicide" 213:(New York's highest court) and was unanimously confirmed as an Associate Judge by the 1424: 1080: 930: 674: 365:
on the afternoon of April 12, 2017. Her fully clothed body was found floating in the
291:. She served as an associate justice of the Appellate Division from 2009 until 2013. 147: 1307:"NYC medical examiner: Judge whose body was found in Hudson River committed suicide" 1412: 594: 530:"Sheila Abdus-Salaam, Judge on New York's Top Court, Is Found Dead in Hudson River" 366: 303: 98: 74: 32: 253: 628: 1362: 307: 189: 1311: 901:"First black woman on New York's highest court was a 'trail-blazing jurist'" 362: 1546:
New York State Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Department justices
376:
On April 13, police stated that the death of Abdus-Salaam appeared to be a
282:
Appellate Division of the New York Supreme Court, First Judicial Department
1043:"Appeals court judge Sheila Abdus-Salaam found dead on Hudson River shore" 1074:
Moore, Tina; Celona, Larry; Cohen, Shawn; Perez, Chris (April 12, 2017).
238: 771:"New York judge's death a possible suicide, law enforcement sources say" 490:"Sheila Abdus-Salaam, a trailblazing judge, found dead in Hudson River" 377: 835:"NY Top Court Gains 1st Black Woman, Back To Female Majority – Law360" 1012:"United States' first female Muslim judge found dead in Hudson River" 370: 345: 1210:"NYPD treating death of judge found in Hudson River as 'suspicious'" 1110:
Otis, Ginger Adams; Tracy, Thomas; McShane, Larry (April 13, 2017).
1041:
Adams Otis, Ginger; Annese, John; Slattery, Denis (April 12, 2017).
171: 162: 590:"United States' first female Muslim judge found dead in New York" 1112:"Judge Sheila Abdus-Salaam likely committed suicide, police say" 967:"Judge who washed up along Hudson cut husband out of her estate" 276:, from 1992 to 1993. Abdus-Salaam was elected a justice of the 1279: 769:
Ray Sanchez, Madison Park and Brynn Gingras (April 13, 2017).
706:"Death of NY Judge Found in Hudson River 'Suspicious': Police" 494: 459:
Courts, Historical Society of the New York (March 17, 2021).
329:
Abdus-Salaam's second husband, James Hatcher, was the son of
1208:
Cohen, Shawn; Moore, Tina; Golding, Bruce (April 19, 2017).
221:
female judge to serve on the New York Court of Appeals.
528:
Haag, Matthew; Rashbaum, William K. (April 12, 2017).
369:
hours after she was reported missing from her home in
802:"Cuomo Picks Judge in City to Fill Spot at Top Court" 1179:"Video Shows Judge on Hudson Shore Before Her Death" 584: 582: 154: 137: 113: 108: 92: 80: 68: 49: 23: 1240: 407:List of first women lawyers and judges in New York 733: 731: 314:judge to serve on the New York Court of Appeals. 1403:Associate Judge of the New York Court of Appeals 1172: 1170: 700: 698: 696: 1242:"NYPD Completes Investigation of Judge's Death" 895: 893: 523: 521: 519: 517: 483: 481: 862: 860: 430:Appellate Division – First Judicial Department 310:held May 6, 2013. She became the first female 252:in 1977. Among her classmates at Columbia was 1541:Eastern High School (Washington, D.C.) alumni 1076:"Judge Washes up Dead Along the Hudson River" 868:"'Trailblazer' judge found dead in Manhattan" 488:Frehse, Rob; Park, Madison (April 13, 2017). 229:Sheila Turner was born on March 14, 1952, in 8: 660: 658: 656: 1384: 31: 20: 1521:Suicides by drowning in the United States 465:Historical Society of the New York Courts 302:, Abdus-Salaam was nominated by Governor 294:On April 5, 2013, following the death of 244:Turner obtained a bachelor's degree from 1369:Abdus-Salaam, Sheila (August 30, 2016). 1501:Judges of the New York Court of Appeals 1341:Tcholakian, Danielle (April 25, 2017). 1177:Rashbaum, William K. (April 21, 2017). 1141:West Savali, Kirsten (April 19, 2017). 417: 1561:Deaths by drowning in New York (state) 1373:In Re Brooke S.B. v. Elizabeth A. C.C. 911:from the original on December 16, 2018 781:from the original on December 16, 2018 750:from the original on December 15, 2018 623: 621: 619: 617: 434:Supreme Court of the State of New York 319:In Re Brooke S.B. v. Elizabeth A. C.C. 1556:21st-century African-American lawyers 1551:20th-century African-American lawyers 1220:from the original on October 17, 2019 1022:from the original on February 6, 2020 973:from the original on November 6, 2017 845:from the original on December 6, 2020 188: 64:May 6, 2013 – April 12, 2017 16:American judge and lawyer (1952-2017) 7: 1319:from the original on August 20, 2017 878:from the original on October 4, 2017 333:, who worked as a press officer for 209:, Abdus-Salaam was nominated to the 1536:21st-century African-American women 1531:20th-century African-American women 1476:21st-century American women lawyers 1456:20th-century American women lawyers 1305:Eversley, Melanie (July 26, 2017). 1274:McCallister, Doreen (May 4, 2017). 1239:Kanno-Youngs, Zolan (May 4, 2017). 1189:from the original on April 22, 2017 1155:from the original on April 20, 2017 1122:from the original on April 13, 2017 1088:from the original on April 12, 2017 1055:from the original on April 18, 2017 946:from the original on April 13, 2017 814:from the original on April 13, 2017 681:from the original on April 14, 2017 641:from the original on March 29, 2017 602:from the original on April 13, 2017 542:from the original on April 13, 2017 502:from the original on April 13, 2017 440:from the original on April 13, 2017 1481:21st-century American women judges 1461:20th-century American women judges 1255:from the original on April 2, 2019 14: 357:Abdus-Salaam was found dead near 341:Gregory A. Jacobs, in June 2016. 1363:Hon. Sheila Abdus-Salaam profile 1286:from the original on May 8, 2017 716:from the original on May 2, 2019 665:Reisman, Nick (April 13, 2017). 402:List of African-American jurists 1511:New York Supreme Court Justices 800:Santora, Marc (April 5, 2013). 629:"Honorable Sheila Abdus-Salaam" 1001:, Episcopal Diocese of Newark. 258:United States Attorney General 1: 1506:Lawyers from Washington, D.C. 1471:21st-century American lawyers 1451:20th-century American lawyers 965:Marsh, Julia (May 19, 2017). 738:Seiler, Casey (May 7, 2013). 426:"Sheila Abdus-Salaam profile" 1466:21st-century American judges 1446:20th-century American judges 740:"Senate confirms new judge" 248:in 1974 and graduated from 1577: 1516:Lawyers from New York City 1496:Columbia Law School alumni 389:New York Police Department 1526:Suicides in New York City 1409: 1400: 1392: 1387: 634:New York Court of Appeals 296:New York Court of Appeals 274:New York City Civil Court 211:New York Court of Appeals 199:New York City Civil Court 178: 104: 57: 52:New York Court of Appeals 45: 37:Abdus-Salaam speaking at 30: 1380:. New York Court System. 225:Early life and education 1486:African-American judges 1248:The Wall Street Journal 997:April 13, 2017, at the 992:Wedding of Canon Jacobs 50:Associate Judge of the 1491:Barnard College alumni 278:New York Supreme Court 203:New York Supreme Court 667:"Anatomy of an Error" 215:New York State Senate 935:"Ticker Tape U.S.A." 933:(January 20, 1992). 382:Riverbank State Park 217:. She was the first 1116:New York Daily News 1048:New York Daily News 566:dioceseofnewark.org 250:Columbia Law School 235:Eastern High School 185:Sheila Abdus-Salaam 168:Columbia University 25:Sheila Abdus-Salaam 1183:The New York Times 1018:. April 13, 2017. 874:. April 14, 2017. 807:The New York Times 712:. April 19, 2017. 598:. April 13, 2017. 535:The New York Times 207:Appellate Division 1419: 1418: 1410:Succeeded by 671:State of Politics 359:West 132nd Street 300:Theodore T. Jones 182: 181: 1568: 1393:Preceded by 1385: 1381: 1379: 1352: 1329: 1328: 1326: 1324: 1302: 1296: 1295: 1293: 1291: 1271: 1265: 1264: 1262: 1260: 1244: 1236: 1230: 1229: 1227: 1225: 1205: 1199: 1198: 1196: 1194: 1174: 1165: 1164: 1162: 1160: 1138: 1132: 1131: 1129: 1127: 1107: 1101: 1100: 1095: 1093: 1071: 1065: 1064: 1062: 1060: 1038: 1032: 1031: 1029: 1027: 1008: 1002: 989: 983: 982: 980: 978: 962: 956: 955: 953: 951: 927: 921: 920: 918: 916: 897: 888: 887: 885: 883: 864: 855: 854: 852: 850: 830: 824: 823: 821: 819: 797: 791: 790: 788: 786: 766: 760: 759: 757: 755: 735: 726: 725: 723: 721: 702: 691: 690: 688: 686: 662: 651: 650: 648: 646: 625: 612: 611: 609: 607: 586: 577: 576: 574: 572: 558: 552: 551: 549: 547: 525: 512: 511: 509: 507: 485: 476: 475: 473: 471: 456: 450: 449: 447: 445: 422: 339:Episcopal priest 312:African-American 231:Washington, D.C. 219:African-American 196: 144: 131:Washington, D.C. 127: 125: 109:Personal details 95: 83: 71: 62: 35: 21: 1576: 1575: 1571: 1570: 1569: 1567: 1566: 1565: 1421: 1420: 1415: 1413:Paul G. Feinman 1406: 1398: 1377: 1368: 1359: 1340: 1337: 1335:Further reading 1332: 1322: 1320: 1304: 1303: 1299: 1289: 1287: 1273: 1272: 1268: 1258: 1256: 1238: 1237: 1233: 1223: 1221: 1207: 1206: 1202: 1192: 1190: 1176: 1175: 1168: 1158: 1156: 1140: 1139: 1135: 1125: 1123: 1109: 1108: 1104: 1091: 1089: 1073: 1072: 1068: 1058: 1056: 1040: 1039: 1035: 1025: 1023: 1010: 1009: 1005: 999:Wayback Machine 990: 986: 976: 974: 964: 963: 959: 949: 947: 929: 928: 924: 914: 912: 899: 898: 891: 881: 879: 866: 865: 858: 848: 846: 832: 831: 827: 817: 815: 799: 798: 794: 784: 782: 768: 767: 763: 753: 751: 737: 736: 729: 719: 717: 704: 703: 694: 684: 682: 664: 663: 654: 644: 642: 627: 626: 615: 605: 603: 588: 587: 580: 570: 568: 560: 559: 555: 545: 543: 527: 526: 515: 505: 503: 487: 486: 479: 469: 467: 458: 457: 453: 443: 441: 424: 423: 419: 415: 398: 355: 335:John F. Kennedy 327: 266: 246:Barnard College 227: 166: 159:Barnard College 146: 142: 129: 123: 121: 120: 119: 99:Paul G. Feinman 93: 81: 69: 63: 58: 41: 39:Barnard College 26: 17: 12: 11: 5: 1574: 1572: 1564: 1563: 1558: 1553: 1548: 1543: 1538: 1533: 1528: 1523: 1518: 1513: 1508: 1503: 1498: 1493: 1488: 1483: 1478: 1473: 1468: 1463: 1458: 1453: 1448: 1443: 1438: 1433: 1423: 1422: 1417: 1416: 1411: 1408: 1399: 1396:Theodore Jones 1394: 1390: 1389: 1388:Legal offices 1383: 1382: 1366: 1365:, nycourts.gov 1358: 1357:External links 1355: 1354: 1353: 1336: 1333: 1331: 1330: 1297: 1266: 1231: 1200: 1166: 1133: 1102: 1066: 1033: 1003: 984: 957: 931:Booker, Simeon 922: 889: 856: 839:www.law360.com 825: 792: 761: 727: 692: 652: 613: 578: 553: 513: 477: 451: 416: 414: 411: 410: 409: 404: 397: 394: 387:On May 3, the 354: 351: 331:Andrew Hatcher 326: 323: 289:David Paterson 265: 262: 226: 223: 180: 179: 176: 175: 156: 152: 151: 145:(aged 65) 141:April 12, 2017 139: 135: 134: 128:March 14, 1952 117: 115: 111: 110: 106: 105: 102: 101: 96: 90: 89: 87:Theodore Jones 84: 78: 77: 72: 66: 65: 55: 54: 47: 46: 43: 42: 36: 28: 27: 24: 15: 13: 10: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 1573: 1562: 1559: 1557: 1554: 1552: 1549: 1547: 1544: 1542: 1539: 1537: 1534: 1532: 1529: 1527: 1524: 1522: 1519: 1517: 1514: 1512: 1509: 1507: 1504: 1502: 1499: 1497: 1494: 1492: 1489: 1487: 1484: 1482: 1479: 1477: 1474: 1472: 1469: 1467: 1464: 1462: 1459: 1457: 1454: 1452: 1449: 1447: 1444: 1442: 1441:2017 suicides 1439: 1437: 1434: 1432: 1429: 1428: 1426: 1414: 1405: 1404: 1397: 1391: 1386: 1376: 1374: 1367: 1364: 1361: 1360: 1356: 1350: 1349: 1344: 1339: 1338: 1334: 1318: 1314: 1313: 1308: 1301: 1298: 1285: 1281: 1277: 1270: 1267: 1254: 1250: 1249: 1243: 1235: 1232: 1219: 1215: 1214:New York Post 1211: 1204: 1201: 1188: 1184: 1180: 1173: 1171: 1167: 1154: 1150: 1149: 1144: 1137: 1134: 1121: 1117: 1113: 1106: 1103: 1099: 1087: 1083: 1082: 1081:New York Post 1077: 1070: 1067: 1054: 1050: 1049: 1044: 1037: 1034: 1021: 1017: 1013: 1007: 1004: 1000: 996: 993: 988: 985: 972: 968: 961: 958: 945: 941: 940: 936: 932: 926: 923: 910: 906: 902: 896: 894: 890: 877: 873: 869: 863: 861: 857: 844: 840: 836: 833:Brush, Pete. 829: 826: 813: 809: 808: 803: 796: 793: 780: 776: 772: 765: 762: 749: 745: 741: 734: 732: 728: 715: 711: 707: 701: 699: 697: 693: 680: 676: 675:Spectrum News 672: 668: 661: 659: 657: 653: 640: 636: 635: 630: 624: 622: 620: 618: 614: 601: 597: 596: 591: 585: 583: 579: 567: 563: 557: 554: 541: 537: 536: 531: 524: 522: 520: 518: 514: 501: 497: 496: 491: 484: 482: 478: 466: 462: 455: 452: 439: 435: 431: 427: 421: 418: 412: 408: 405: 403: 400: 399: 395: 393: 390: 385: 383: 379: 374: 372: 368: 364: 360: 352: 350: 347: 342: 340: 336: 332: 325:Personal life 324: 322: 320: 315: 313: 309: 305: 301: 297: 292: 290: 287: 283: 279: 275: 269: 263: 261: 259: 256:, the future 255: 251: 247: 242: 240: 236: 232: 224: 222: 220: 216: 212: 208: 204: 200: 195: 191: 186: 177: 173: 169: 164: 160: 157: 153: 149: 148:New York City 140: 136: 132: 118:Sheila Turner 116: 112: 107: 103: 100: 97: 91: 88: 85: 79: 76: 73: 67: 61: 56: 53: 48: 44: 40: 34: 29: 22: 19: 1401: 1372: 1346: 1321:. Retrieved 1310: 1300: 1288:. Retrieved 1269: 1257:. Retrieved 1246: 1234: 1224:February 11, 1222:. Retrieved 1213: 1203: 1191:. Retrieved 1182: 1157:. Retrieved 1146: 1136: 1124:. Retrieved 1115: 1105: 1097: 1090:. Retrieved 1079: 1069: 1057:. Retrieved 1046: 1036: 1024:. Retrieved 1015: 1006: 987: 977:December 13, 975:. Retrieved 960: 948:. Retrieved 937: 925: 915:December 13, 913:. Retrieved 904: 882:December 13, 880:. Retrieved 871: 849:December 13, 847:. Retrieved 838: 828: 816:. Retrieved 805: 795: 785:December 13, 783:. Retrieved 774: 764: 754:December 13, 752:. Retrieved 743: 718:. Retrieved 710:NBC New York 709: 683:. Retrieved 670: 643:. Retrieved 632: 604:. Retrieved 595:The Guardian 593: 569:. Retrieved 565: 556: 544:. Retrieved 533: 504:. Retrieved 493: 468:. Retrieved 464: 454: 442:. Retrieved 429: 420: 386: 375: 367:Hudson River 356: 343: 328: 318: 316: 304:Andrew Cuomo 293: 270: 267: 243: 228: 193: 184: 183: 143:(2017-04-12) 94:Succeeded by 75:Andrew Cuomo 70:Appointed by 59: 18: 1436:2017 deaths 1431:1952 births 1348:The Outline 1026:February 6, 744:Times Union 254:Eric Holder 82:Preceded by 1425:Categories 1407:2013–2017 1323:August 20, 413:References 308:voice vote 205:, and the 124:1952-03-14 1312:USA TODAY 1193:April 22, 1159:April 19, 1126:April 13, 1092:April 13, 1059:April 13, 950:April 13, 905:USA TODAY 818:April 13, 685:April 13, 645:April 12, 606:April 13, 546:April 12, 506:April 13, 470:April 24, 444:April 12, 363:Manhattan 155:Education 60:In office 1317:Archived 1284:Archived 1253:Archived 1218:Archived 1187:Archived 1153:Archived 1148:The Root 1120:Archived 1086:Archived 1053:Archived 1020:Archived 995:Archived 971:Archived 944:Archived 909:Archived 876:Archived 872:NBC News 843:Archived 812:Archived 779:Archived 748:Archived 714:Archived 679:Archived 639:Archived 600:Archived 540:Archived 500:Archived 438:Archived 396:See also 286:Governor 239:Virginia 378:suicide 1290:May 9, 1259:May 2, 720:May 2, 571:May 8, 371:Harlem 346:Muslim 298:Judge 264:Career 201:, the 194:Turner 192:  150:, U.S. 133:, U.S. 1378:(PDF) 353:Death 1325:2017 1292:2017 1261:2019 1226:2020 1195:2017 1161:2017 1128:2017 1094:2017 1061:2017 1028:2020 1016:CNBC 979:2017 952:2017 917:2018 884:2018 851:2018 820:2017 787:2018 756:2018 722:2019 687:2017 647:2017 608:2017 573:2022 548:2017 508:2017 472:2023 446:2017 138:Died 114:Born 1280:NPR 939:Jet 775:CNN 495:CNN 361:in 284:by 190:née 1427:: 1345:. 1315:. 1309:. 1282:. 1278:. 1251:. 1245:. 1216:. 1212:. 1185:. 1181:. 1169:^ 1151:. 1145:. 1118:. 1114:. 1096:. 1084:. 1078:. 1051:. 1045:. 1014:. 969:. 942:. 907:. 903:. 892:^ 870:. 859:^ 841:. 837:. 810:. 804:. 777:. 773:. 746:. 742:. 730:^ 708:. 695:^ 677:. 673:. 669:. 655:^ 637:. 631:. 616:^ 592:. 581:^ 564:. 538:. 532:. 516:^ 498:. 492:. 480:^ 463:. 436:. 432:. 428:. 373:. 260:. 241:. 172:JD 163:BA 1375:" 1371:" 1351:. 1327:. 1294:. 1263:. 1228:. 1197:. 1163:. 1130:. 1063:. 1030:. 981:. 954:. 919:. 886:. 853:. 822:. 789:. 758:. 724:. 689:. 649:. 610:. 575:. 550:. 510:. 474:. 448:. 187:( 174:) 170:( 165:) 161:( 126:) 122:(

Index


Barnard College
New York Court of Appeals
Andrew Cuomo
Theodore Jones
Paul G. Feinman
Washington, D.C.
New York City
Barnard College
BA
Columbia University
JD
née
New York City Civil Court
New York Supreme Court
Appellate Division
New York Court of Appeals
New York State Senate
African-American
Washington, D.C.
Eastern High School
Virginia
Barnard College
Columbia Law School
Eric Holder
United States Attorney General
New York City Civil Court
New York Supreme Court
Appellate Division of the New York Supreme Court, First Judicial Department
Governor

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.