Talk:Central bank digital currency

664:

status as other forms of fiat currency. DFC possesses the same characteristics as that of paper fiat currency. Fiat currency is declared legal tender by government regulation and law. For example, in Kenya, it is the Kenyan Shilling, in India it is the Indian Rupee, in Brazil it is the Brazilian Real and so on. DFC is the digital form of fiat notes and coins issued and legalized by the issuing authority of a nation (most commonly the country’s Central Bank). DFC, like its physical counterpart, is ubiquitous and interoperable. It is a subset of the monetary base (M0) and is a final and instant settlement of debt. As legal tender issued by the entity empowered by the law, such as the Central Bank, DFC is a trusted instrument, and is the common unit of account, store of value and medium of exchange. It is a liability on the Central Bank. Just like paper currency, DFC does not require the pubic to hold an account at the central bank.

1428:

interpretation of it for the "not a liability" is problematic. The source for the "is not a liability" basically said that cryptocurrencies are not a liability. There are two ways to take this. One is an absurd overgeneralization...that every possible crypto protected currency is not a liability. The other is to interpret it as referring to the common cryptocurrencies/ common meaning of cryptocurrencies, which is along the lines of bitcoin, not issued or supported by any bank or government. The latter is the only plausible choice and it does not support "not a liability for an issuing bank", so "not a liability" fails verification. So, IMO the "not a liability" clearly can't stay in the article. Justin Goldsborough gave three references to support the "is a liability of the bank" viewpoint. All were large and I admittedly only skimmed them, but that quick skim seems to buttress his argument.

674:

just like Bitcoins, Litecoins and Ethereum. Although CBDC is understood to be a digital currency issued by the Central Bank, it does not carry the same basic principles upheld by a DFC. The definition of a CBDC has been discussed with differing characteristics than that of physical fiat currency. In contrast to DFC, CBDC may be a settlement balance. CBDC may require the general public to hold central bank accounts. Most importantly, CBDC is not defined as fiat, and therefore, it is not accurate to form an immediate parallel between CBDC and Digital Fiat Currency.

1482:

the sentence in the second paragraph under the Characteristics section from "As such, digital fiat money cannot be considered as a liability of the central bank (it is similar to outside money)." This sentence as it reads is false because base money supply issued by the central bank and all forms of currency are a liability of the central bank. As digital fiat currency is part of base money supply, therefore it too is a liability of the central bank. The two sources included below support this point.

1407:- without getting too deeply into the nuances of cryptocurrency and international banking liabilities, if both sides are well argued, why wouldn't a solution be "There are disagreements about whether cryptocurrency should be treated as a bank liability in the traditional sense. According to etc etc etc, it is, because ..., but according to etc etc etc, it is not, because ...." Source both sides by highlighting the issues, let the reader decide. 802:@Stanjourdan and @Justin Goldsborough - thank you for maintaining this page and upkeeping it. I believe there is an important distinction that should be made. CBDC is not possible without the double spend problem being solved. It was not possible prior to distributed ledger technology and you have older examples like Canada's mintchip which was proposing a digital currency but failed due to poor implementation design of the double spend issue. 466: 445: 272: 251: 377: 356: 476: 116: 2071: 64: 179: 158: 1193:

cannot be considered as a liability of the central bank (it is similar to outside money).” This statement is false because base money supply issued by the central bank and all forms of currency are a liability of the central bank. As digital fiat currency is part of base money supply, therefore it too is a liability of the central bank. The two sources included below support this point.

282: 22: 78: 53: 554: 2192: 1140:- summoned by bot. I think we (or at least I) need more context to be able to help with this discussion. What is the main issue here? Why would it matter one way or the other whether or not we list the currency as a liability, and who would make the claim for either argument? Can you flush your request out to better make your case? 1992:

technology works to improve current services ie: "using a blockchain for digital asset management allowed NBC and Soramitsu to implement fiat-backed digital representations of the Khmer riel and US dollar that would be accessible for wholesale interbank transactions as well as everyday retail payments." from

1247:) states "CBDC is not a well-defined term. It is used to refer to a number of concepts. However, it is envisioned by most to be a new form of central bank money. That is, a central bank liability, denominated in an existing unit of account, which serves both as a medium of exchange and a store of value." 2083: 1912:

In today’s modern economy most money takes the form of deposits, but rather than being created by a group of savers entrusting the bank withholding their money, deposits are actually created when banks extend credit (i.e., create new loans). As Joseph Schumpeter once wrote, “It is much more realistic

1854:

Zero reserve: today commercial banks in some countries (US, UK, EU, etc) don't need a reserve requirement anymore . Indeed every time a subject (a person, a corporation, etc) asks for a loan, and that subject offers a loan guarantee (a private property like a car, a building, etc) the bank creates

718:

4. I think we should acknowledge that this whole topic is still very much emerging and fast-changing. Terminologies and concept definitions are therefore not yet 100% clear neither set in stone. In the midst of this uncertainty, I would suggest adopting an open approach by keeping the current page on

715:. We could of course create different articles for both concepts, but given the large and fast-growing literature on CBDC, wikipedia still should have a page on CBDC., while DFC seems to be pretty much a niche, lower-priority topic. It makes more sense to prioritize the development of the CBDC entry. 1481:

Per your comment on March 26, many editors have commented via the RfC above. Multiple comments are in support of editing the article to say digital fiat currency is a liability of the Central Bank. Based on this feedback, do you now feel we could go ahead and make the edit originally requested: Edit

853:

Would you consider changing the sentence: "As such, digital fiat money cannot be considered as a liability of the central bank (it is similar to outside money).”? I believe the opposite is actually true and propose changing it to read as follows: "As such, DFC is a liability of the central bank just

673:

In contrast, a Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) can be an entirely different “thing”. Just like the Bitcoin network issues Bitcoins, a central bank can issue its version of a “bitcoin”. It is not necessarily legal tender and it is not necessarily sovereign currency. It is another “CryptoCoin”

2140:

While I don't expect an explanation of mining in this article, there should be more about it than the one glancing use of the term. In particular, it has been claimed that CBDCs can be created without mining. Since mining is very intensive of computer use, it is considered a significant driver of

1758:

Thanks for the continued discussion. I was under the impression consensus from the RfC was clear that the way the sentence was currently stated (that digital fiat money cannot be considered as a liability of the central bank) was inaccurate and a change was warranted. Would appreciate your thoughts

1433:

As an additional note, to me it appears that Jtbobwaysf's post is self conflicting and I would request them to clarify. It starts with supporting the current "is a liability" version, but their arguments seem to argue against that statement and thus, regarding the existing statement, in favor of

663:

The term “Digital Fiat Currency (DFC)” and the term “Central Bank Issued Digital Currency (CBDC)” have different meanings and cannot be used interchangeably. A Digital Fiat Currency (DFC) is the legal tender and currency of the nation. It is the digital form of the same value and has the same legal

1966:

Of course, as I pointed out Tuesday, Bernanke is pushing to eliminate all reserve requirements in the U.S. If Bernanke has his way, American banks won't even have to borrow from the Fed or other banks after the fact to have reserves. Instead, they can just enter into as many loans as they want and

1620:

Below are two sources that back this argument that digital fiat money is a liability of the Central Bank. Also, per the rfc above, multiple editors have agreed that digital fiat money is a liability of the Central Bank and have asked that the edit be made to the article. But the edit has still not

1192:

Thanks TimTempleton and North8000. I can provide a claim for why digital fiat currency should be considered a liability of the Central Bank. Currently the article states, "Digital fiat currency is part of the base money supply, together with other forms of the currency. As such, digital fiat money

761:

Hi. Happy new year to you as well. Appreciate you sharing your reasoning. Agree with the majority of it, but have one additional edit request for you consider. NOTE: I am proposing this edit on behalf of eCurrency. I am a paid editor for various brands and am aware of the COI guidelines. Hopefully

1991:

After carefully going through the topics, it has come to my attention that there are few instances of an active and functioning CBDC example. Moreover, there is also content claiming that a CBCD does not need blockchain/DLT technology, however, there are examples of instances where the blockchain

1967:

create endless money out of thin air (within Basel I and Basel II's capital requirements - but since governments are backstopping their giant banks by overtly and covertly throwing bailout money, guarantees and various insider opportunities at them, capital requirements are somewhat meaningless).

704:

1. There is a significant overlap between CBDC and DFC. Most of the literature on CBDC referenced in the article defines CBDC very closely with your own definition of DFC (legal tender, equivalent to physical cash, part of m0, liability of CB). Whether people can have an account at the CB is an

1616:

On March 2, 2018 I proposed the following edit request...Would you consider changing the sentence: "As such, digital fiat money cannot be considered as a liability of the central bank (it is similar to outside money).”? I believe the opposite is actually true and propose changing it to read as

608:

Hello, first thank for whoever started this article. Very much needed! May I suggest if there is any prominent reason why this has been titled "Digital Fiat currency"? It seems like the concept has been baptized "central bank digital currency" by most central banks (cf references) so the later

2160:

Given its centralized structure, a CBDC may or may not amplify the destruction of certain catastrophic events such as very large natural disasters or sophisticated nation-state cyberattacks. The fragmented nature of most nations’ current systems tends to confine damage to smaller chunks of an

768:

Would you consider changing this sentence from the article (second paragraph under Characteristics header): "As such, digital fiat money cannot be considered as a liability of the central bank (it is similar to outside money).” I believe the opposite is actually true and propose changing that

772:

Lastly, I am fine with this article content living under the Central Bank Digital Currency umbrella as you've proposed. We do plan to submit a redirect request so that a Digital Fiat Currency article exists. I'll submit that request, but wanted to mention it. Thank you in advance for your

1427:

but they did not make a specific proposal. As a sidebar, it is logical......a currency issued by a bank is an obligation of the bank. I said "sidebar" because in Knowledge, sources are more more important than logical analysis by editors. So let's move on to sources. The sourcing and

1825:

One can argue it is not possible to have a CBDC without distributed ledger technology. If you look at all previous examples prior to Bitt.com's concept of a DLT based CBDC, then you would notice they all failed due to issues around security, double spend and deployment.

1705:(If this is not the RfC you're referring to, please state otherwise.) Owing to that consensus, which seems at odds with your request, and to the lack of agreement on wording with respect to how it should be mentioned, I don't see how this is an actionable edit request. 769:

sentence to read as follows: "As such, DFC is a liability of the central bank just as physical currency is. Also, what do you think about adding the acronym (DFC) after first reference of digital fiat currency and then using DFC on all additional references?

1900:“The banks in their lending business are not only not limited by their own capital; they are not, at least not immediately, limited by any capital whatever; by concentrating in their hands almost all payments, they themselves create the money required….” 934:

Statements regarding whether or not cryptocurrencies are liabilities is a determination which should involve the input of many editors, not just you and I. I suggest that this topic requires further discussions before a change can be made. Regards,

976:

to involve additional editors? Or a different approach? Also, in an attempt to build on this discussion, including two other sources below that claim digital fiat currency is a liability of the central bank. Appreciate your thoughts on next steps.

649:

Thank you for your interest in the article. I wanted to clarify the difference between Central Bank Digital Currency and Digital Fiat Currency and see if you'd be willing to revert back to the original page name and article version

849:

on behalf of eCurrency. I am a paid editor for various brands and am aware of the COI guidelines. Hopefully this additional information will help clarify the relationship between Digital Fiat Currency and the Central Bank.

729:

Making it clear in the article that there are different ways to implement a form of CBDC, with different characteristics, use cases, technology and objectives; make it clear that DFC is a proposal on its own, not a generic

787:

I love this suggestion as the title for CBDC is often referred to as Central Bank Digital Dollars, Central Bank Digital Cash, Central Bank Digital Fiat, Fiat Digital Dollars and it therefore makes sense to include them

1954:(1) Each private bank "creates" loans out of thin air by entering into binding loan commitments with borrowers (of course, corresponding liabilities are created on their books at the same time. But see below); then 1773:

That was my reading of the consensus and what I intended to communicate when I made the closure. I think another RfC would be overkill; I'm willing to make the edit for you as-is, though I would like to know what

1903:“In a pure system of credit, where all payments were made by transference in the bank-books, the banks would be able to grant at any moment any amount of loans at any, however diminutive, rate of interest.” 1928:

In other words, everything we know (fractional reserve) is not just wrong, it's backwards. When banks make loans, they create money. This is because money is really just an IOU (I own you=bank account)....

1230:

The current formulation "As such, digital fiat money cannot be considered as a liability of the central bank" failed verification. It appears the unsourced text that follows it stating "(it is similar to

1858:

CBDCs are fully reserved, so if a person want this form of money, he just buys it from the central bank. In this case commercial banks don't create debt, or new money, and don't earn any interests.

2142: 2122: 1867:

As announced on March 15, 2020, the Board reduced reserve requirement ratios to zero percent effective March 26, 2020. This action eliminated reserve requirements for all depository institutions.

696:

Hi Justin. Thanks for the clarification. I still have however strong preference for keeping CBDC as the main umbrella term, for various reasons listed below, but I hope we can find a common ground?

427: 2365: 1948:

Most people think that banks lend solely from their base of deposits. Some also know that with fractional reserve banking, they can loan out many times more than they actually have in reserves.

1922:

To quote from its own (Bank of England) initial summary: "Rather than banks receiving deposits when households save and then lending them out, bank lending creates deposits (bank account)" ...

2340: 417: 1855:

temporarily a new deposit (money), lends these money to him, and when the borrower pays off the loan plus the interests the initial deposit is deleted, and the bank keeps the interests.

2310: 233: 223: 89:. The project works to allow users to contribute quality articles and media files to the encyclopedia and track their progress as they are developed. To participate, please visit the 2315: 2211: 1970:

The system is no longer based on assets (and remember that the giant banks have repeatedly become insolvent) It is based on creating new debts, and then backfilling from there.

2335: 1913:

to say that the banks 'create credit,' that is, that they create deposits in their act of lending than to say that they lend the deposits that have been entrusted to them.”

1851:

Indeed, in the last century, commercial banks have created money thanks the deposits and other ways. They have used 2 methods: fractional reserve banking and zero reserve.

199: 2305: 2295: 1091:

and implement that as they think makes the most sense, and we can have a further discussion about the specifics if that implementation is found unsatisfactory.

186: 163: 2345: 1963:

It's not just Bernanke ... the central banks and their owners - the private commercial banks - have been running the printing presses for hundreds of years.

1925:"In normal times, the central bank does not fix the amount of money in circulation, nor is central bank money 'multiplied up' into more loans and deposits." 90: 85: 58: 2325: 338: 328: 2355: 2091: 588: 532: 522: 393: 2330: 1973: 1943: 1957:(2) If the bank doesn't have the required level of reserves, it simply borrows them after the fact from the central bank (or from another bank); 1621:

been made. Based on the points made sources provided and the editor consensus in the rfc, would you please go ahead and make the proposed edit?

2360: 1845:

The following sentence is not exact anymore: For example, commercial banks practice fractional reserve banking while CBDCs are fully reserved.

609:

terminology would be in my view the more appropriate one. I'll proceed to the change unless major disagreements appear in the coming 2 weeks.

384: 361: 304: 1993: 1891:

According to the credit creation theory then, banks create credit in the form of what bankers call ‘deposits’, and this credit is money.

839:

was declined. The reviewer would like to request the editor with a COI attempt to discuss with editors engaged in the subject-area first.

2320: 2051: 2039: 498: 2146: 2126: 1914: 2350: 2252: 2202: 2184: 1415: 1288: 1240: 1148: 1951:

But very few people (with the exception of those in the banking industry and financial experts) know where credit really comes from.

2370: 2300: 2161:

economy. I expect this is part of central banks’ planning; this article should address this as reliable sources become available. —

1703:"the article should state that CBDC is a central bank liability, but the issue of how this should be implemented was not discussed." 1935: 2268: 1262: 1932:

There's really no limit on how much (money and loans) banks could create, provided they can find someone willing to borrow it.

1597: 826: 1302: 295: 256: 140: 708:

2. As far as I know, talks about bitcoin-like schemes issued by central banks are fringe and usually not described as "CBDC“.

1607: 1087:

a central bank liability, but the issue of how this should be implemented was not discussed. I would encourage any editor to

1066: 973: 836: 489: 450: 63: 2290: 1764: 1634: 1576:

Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

1502: 1214: 1127: 990: 859: 778: 679: 582: 287: 2229: 1681: 1552: 1358: 1037: 564: 33: 2032:

We're talking about currency here. This is just fiat in newspeak and doesnt need its own article. See Notepad article

567:

require that editors disclose their "employer, client, and affiliation" with respect to any paid contribution; see

762:

this additional information will help clarify the relationship between Digital Fiat Currency and the Central Bank.

1974:

https://www.businessinsider.com/german-central-bank-says-credit-is-created-out-of-thin-air-2010-3?r=US&IR=T

1944:

https://www.businessinsider.com/german-central-bank-says-credit-is-created-out-of-thin-air-2010-3?r=US&IR=T

1792: 1760: 1630: 1498: 1210: 1123: 986: 855: 774: 675: 578: 2055: 2043: 1885:“A bank is therefore not an office for “borrowing” and “lending” money, but it is a Manufactory of Credit.” 1603: 832: 2119: 1876:

This study establishes for the first time empirically that banks individually create money out of nothing.

1831: 807: 793: 726:

Improving the definition by listing the key possible characteristics of CBDC / DFC (possibly with a table);

1413: 1282: 1146: 2255:. Deposits and Real World Assets (RWA) have to be tokenised, unified into a personal (identity) ledger ( 1804: 1781: 1753: 1731: 1094: 742: 629: 614: 572: 39: 1994:

https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/08/cambodias-digital-currency-ishowing-other-central-banks-the-way/

1183: 906: 881: 1960:(3) The central bank, in turn, creates the money which it lends to the private banks out of thin air. 1877: 1827: 803: 789: 2272: 2035: 2002: 1981: 1759:

on next steps here to come to a resolution. Would you recommend another RfC? Other thoughts? Thanks.

1258: 1250: 719:

CBDC as main umbrella page for all kind of legal tender digital currencies issued by central banks.

560: 1915:

https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/022416/why-banks-dont-need-your-money-make-loans.asp

21: 2264: 1589:

on behalf of eCurrency. I am a paid editor for various brands and am aware of the COI guidelines.

1441: 1296: 1165: 134: 1111:

on behalf of eCurrency. I am a paid editor for various brands and am aware of the COI guidelines.

497:

on Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join

392:

on Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join

303:

on Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join

198:

on Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join

2206: 2074:

This article was the subject of a Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment, between

1306: 1114: 1873:

2) Can banks individually create money out of nothing? The theories and the empirical evidence.

1104:

Should digital fiat currency be defined as a liability of the central bank? See sources above.

2260: 1936:

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/mar/18/truth-money-iou-bank-of-england-austerity

1868: 2103: 2017: 1408: 1278: 1141: 2223: 1624:

Committee on Payments and Market Infrastructures (page 3, first paragraph under Taxonomy):

1586: 1460: 1310: 1118: 1108: 980:

Committee on Payments and Market Infrastructures (page 3, first paragraph under Taxonomy):

846: 756: 738: 712: 644: 625: 610: 2276: 2236: 2173: 2150: 2130: 2107: 2059: 2021: 2006: 1835: 1808: 1785: 1768: 1735: 1715: 1638: 1506: 1464: 1445: 1417: 1314: 1266: 1218: 1196:

Committee on Payments and Market Infrastructures (page 3, first paragraph under Taxonomy):

1169: 1150: 1131: 1098: 994: 955: 863: 811: 797: 782: 746: 683: 633: 618: 1998: 1919:

4) The truth is out: money is just an IOU (bank account), and the banks are rolling in it

1485:

Committee on Payments and Market Infrastructures (page 3, first paragraph under Taxonomy)

1254: 481: 1617:

follows: "As such, DFC is a liability of the central bank just as physical currency is."

2141:

global warming. Thus, this non-mining character would be a positive factor for CBDCs.

652:

https://en.wikipedia.org/search/?title=Central_Bank_Digital_Currency&oldid=796947181

1897:

Wicksell (1907) described a credit-based economy in the Economic Journal, arguing that

1798: 1775: 1746: 1723: 1708: 1476: 1292: 1187: 1088: 967: 939: 711:

3. DFC seems in fact to be a specific CBDC proposal, which itself is a sub-category of

568: 389: 130: 475: 465: 444: 2284: 1232: 2099: 2087: 2065:

Wiki Education assignment: Research Process and Methodology - FA22 - Sect 200 - Thu

2013: 1244: 1236: 376: 355: 1801:

has run away, I have made the edit. Please let me know if you need anything else.

271: 250: 2217: 2070: 1456: 1455:* First, as per the BIS quote. Second, that is the whole point of the article. 1380: 1305:), do you have any further comments after Justin Goldsborough's clarifications? 2169: 2163: 2048: 624:

In the absence of any comments, I have processed with renaming the page today.

471: 277: 195: 115: 300: 281: 178: 157: 1656: 1527: 1333: 1012: 494: 2191: 2120:

https://www.newsweek.com/cbdcs-will-end-american-freedom-opinion-1673676

190:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of articles related to 191: 1940:

5) German Central Bank Admits that Credit is Created Out of Thin Air.

1728:

I don't follow. How is his suggestion not in line with the consensus?

1627:

Coindesk (5th paragraph in the Digital Currency Attributes section):

1596: 983:

Coindesk (5th paragraph in the Digital Currency Attributes section):

825: 1199:

Coindesk (5th paragraph in the Digital Currency Attributes section):

2267:(General Manager BIS). Recently project Agora has been started. CGB 1488:

Coindesk (5th paragraph in the Digital Currency Attributes section)

77: 52: 1878:

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1057521914001070

773:

consideration of this edit and for your additions to this article.

722:

Moving forward, I would suggest improving the article in this way:

2209:. Readers of this page are welcome to comment on this redirect at 1982:

https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/knowledgebank/how-is-money-created

1682:"PBOC Researcher: Can Cryptocurrency & Central Banks Coexist?" 1553:"PBOC Researcher: Can Cryptocurrency & Central Banks Coexist?" 1359:"PBOC Researcher: Can Cryptocurrency & Central Banks Coexist?" 1038:"PBOC Researcher: Can Cryptocurrency & Central Banks Coexist?" 2242:

Unified Ledgers, Total Tokenization, Project Agora, Finternet ...

2180: 2118:

Newsweek has a strongly worded critique of using a CBDC system:

1591: 820: 548: 15: 907:"Central Bank Digital Currency: Motivations and Implications" 882:"Central Bank Digital Currency: Motivations and Implications" 2212:

Knowledge:Redirects for discussion/Log/2023 October 5 § Cdbc

1869:

https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/reservereq.htm

592: 114: 1083:

There is consensus that the article should state that CBDC

1882:

In his Theory of Credit Macleod (1891) put it this way:

2197: 651: 125: 1841:

commercial banks practice fractional (disputed/dated)

1158:

Invited by the bot. I echo what TimTempleton said.

1107:

DISCLOSURE: I proposed the original edit March 2 for

571:. For advice about reviewing paid contributions, see 2205:

to determine whether its use and function meets the

1065:

The following discussion is an archived record of a

493:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of 388:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of 299:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of 2366:

Talk pages of subject pages with paid contributions

1075:

No further edits should be made to this discussion.

2341:Mid-importance WikiProject Cryptocurrency articles 1906:3) Why Banks Don't Need Your Money to Make Loans. 2049:https://en.wikipedia.org/Notepad_(disambiguation) 591:) has been paid by FleishmanHillard on behalf of 2311:Mid-importance Finance & Investment articles 972:Thanks for your response. Would you recommend a 1610:was declined. A consensus could not be reached. 208:Knowledge:WikiProject Finance & Investment 2316:WikiProject Finance & Investment articles 1434:Justin Goldsborough's argument. Sincerely, 1078:A summary of the conclusions reached follows. 604:Renaming to "central bank digital currency" ? 211:Template:WikiProject Finance & Investment 8: 654:). Thanks in advance for your consideration. 2336:C-Class WikiProject Cryptocurrency articles 1848:I replace it with the following sentence: 99:Knowledge:WikiProject Articles for creation 2033: 1248: 1058:RfC about digital fiat currency definition 439: 350: 245: 152: 102:Template:WikiProject Articles for creation 83:This article was reviewed by member(s) of 47: 2306:C-Class Finance & Investment articles 2012:No, we're not here to promote Soramitsu. 737:I hope this helps?! happy new year btw 2259:), a new financial architecture, named 2143:2600:6C67:1C00:5F7E:1DEF:F379:3CE0:B974 2123:2600:6C67:1C00:5F7E:1DEF:F379:3CE0:B974 1648: 1519: 1325: 1004: 873: 733:Add more academic references about DFC; 441: 352: 247: 154: 49: 19: 2296:AfC submissions by date/24 August 2017 1894:But how much credit can they create? 1702: 1425:Support Justin Goldsborough's argument 7: 1662:. Bank for International Settlements 1533:. Bank for International Settlements 1339:. Bank for International Settlements 1018:. Bank for International Settlements 487:This article is within the scope of 402:Knowledge:WikiProject Cryptocurrency 382:This article is within the scope of 293:This article is within the scope of 187:WikiProject Finance & Investment 184:This article is within the scope of 2346:WikiProject Cryptocurrency articles 1797:Well, it's been 10 days. Seeing as 1701:The consensus of that RfC was that 1585:NOTE: I am proposing this edit for 845:NOTE: I am proposing this edit for 408:WikiProject Cryptocurrency articles 405:Template:WikiProject Cryptocurrency 38:It is of interest to the following 2253:Bank for International Settlements 2079: 2075: 1241:Bank for International Settlements 14: 2326:Mid-importance Economics articles 1657:"Central Bank Digital Currencies" 1528:"Central Bank Digital Currencies" 1334:"Central Bank Digital Currencies" 1013:"Central Bank Digital Currencies" 214:Finance & Investment articles 86:WikiProject Articles for creation 2356:Mid-importance politics articles 2190: 2082:. Further details are available 2069: 1595: 1572:The discussion above is closed. 824: 705:optional feature in my opinion. 552: 474: 464: 443: 375: 354: 280: 270: 249: 177: 156: 76: 62: 51: 20: 2215:until a consensus is reached. 2156:Resilience against catastrophes 1497:Thanks for your consideration, 1381:"Central bank cryptocurrencies" 527:This article has been rated as 422:This article has been rated as 333:This article has been rated as 313:Knowledge:WikiProject Economics 228:This article has been rated as 123:This article was accepted from 2331:WikiProject Economics articles 2251:are embedded in blueprints by 1121:) at 07:43, 20 May 2018 (UTC). 974:Knowledge:Requests for comment 507:Knowledge:WikiProject Politics 316:Template:WikiProject Economics 129:on 24 August 2017 by reviewer 1: 2361:WikiProject Politics articles 2167:15:58, 18 January 2023 (UTC) 2151:23:20, 14 December 2022 (UTC) 2131:23:15, 14 December 2022 (UTC) 2098:— Assignment last updated by 2022:13:00, 21 February 2022 (UTC) 2007:09:45, 21 February 2022 (UTC) 1836:11:02, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 812:11:01, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 798:10:57, 23 February 2020 (UTC) 684:23:00, 27 December 2017 (UTC) 619:09:18, 10 November 2017 (UTC) 510:Template:WikiProject Politics 501:and see a list of open tasks. 396:and see a list of open tasks. 307:and see a list of open tasks. 288:Business and economics portal 202:and see a list of open tasks. 2174:15:58, 18 January 2023 (UTC) 2108:20:57, 3 December 2022 (UTC) 2046:) 20:32, 23 April 2022 (UTC) 783:19:00, 31 January 2018 (UTC) 634:12:50, 3 December 2017 (UTC) 2237:04:19, 5 October 2023 (UTC) 854:as physical currency is." 747:10:09, 3 January 2018 (UTC) 2387: 2321:C-Class Economics articles 2060:20:33, 23 April 2022 (UTC) 1888:Macleod (1891: II/2, 594) 1132:17:45, 18 April 2018 (UTC) 995:21:14, 13 April 2018 (UTC) 956:22:40, 26 March 2018 (UTC) 533:project's importance scale 385:WikiProject Cryptocurrency 339:project's importance scale 234:project's importance scale 2351:C-Class politics articles 2277:07:28, 16 July 2024 (UTC) 1978:6) how is money created. 1909:Banks in the Real World. 1864:1) Reserve Requirements. 1809:22:16, 21 July 2018 (UTC) 1786:20:10, 11 July 2018 (UTC) 1769:14:49, 11 July 2018 (UTC) 1736:22:44, 26 June 2018 (UTC) 1716:22:03, 25 June 2018 (UTC) 1639:21:06, 25 June 2018 (UTC) 1099:01:32, 11 June 2018 (UTC) 864:17:39, 2 March 2018 (UTC) 526: 459: 421: 370: 332: 265: 227: 172: 122: 71: 46: 2371:Declined requested edits 2301:Accepted AfC submissions 2203:redirects for discussion 2185:Redirects for discussion 1987:Overhaul of this section 1574:Please do not modify it. 1507:03:08, 4 June 2018 (UTC) 1465:23:21, 1 June 2018 (UTC) 1446:23:44, 20 May 2018 (UTC) 1418:18:36, 20 May 2018 (UTC) 1315:07:43, 20 May 2018 (UTC) 1267:18:05, 17 May 2018 (UTC) 1219:03:23, 15 May 2018 (UTC) 1072:Please do not modify it. 205:Finance & Investment 164:Finance & Investment 1170:11:57, 7 May 2018 (UTC) 1151:19:06, 3 May 2018 (UTC) 119: 28:This article is rated 2086:. Student editor(s): 1239:. Your provided text 296:WikiProject Economics 118: 96:Articles for creation 93:for more information. 59:Articles for creation 2291:C-Class AfC articles 1778:was thinking above. 1608:conflict of interest 1606:by an editor with a 837:conflict of interest 835:by an editor with a 561:Wikimedia Foundation 490:WikiProject Politics 2207:redirect guidelines 2201:has been listed at 2114:A possible citation 2028:Essentially Notepad 1793:Justin Goldsborough 1761:Justin Goldsborough 1631:Justin Goldsborough 1499:Justin Goldsborough 1211:Justin Goldsborough 1124:Justin Goldsborough 1067:request for comment 987:Justin Goldsborough 856:Justin Goldsborough 775:Justin Goldsborough 676:Justin Goldsborough 579:Justin Goldsborough 2084:on the course page 319:Economics articles 120: 34:content assessment 2076:22 September 2022 2047: 2038:comment added by 1614: 1613: 1269: 1253:comment added by 1122: 961:Reply 13-APR-2018 954: 930:Reply 26-MAR-2018 843: 842: 601: 600: 547: 546: 543: 542: 539: 538: 513:politics articles 438: 437: 434: 433: 349: 348: 345: 344: 244: 243: 240: 239: 151: 150: 147: 146: 2378: 2235: 2200: 2194: 2172: 2166: 2110: 2092:article contribs 2081: 2077: 2073: 1821:CBDC = DLT Based 1807: 1805:Compassionate727 1796: 1784: 1782:Compassionate727 1757: 1754:Compassionate727 1750: 1734: 1732:Compassionate727 1727: 1713: 1711: 1694: 1693: 1691: 1689: 1678: 1672: 1671: 1669: 1667: 1661: 1653: 1599: 1592: 1587:FleishmanHillard 1565: 1564: 1562: 1560: 1549: 1543: 1542: 1540: 1538: 1532: 1524: 1480: 1396: 1395: 1393: 1392: 1377: 1371: 1370: 1368: 1366: 1355: 1349: 1348: 1346: 1344: 1338: 1330: 1191: 1113:RfC relisted by 1112: 1109:FleishmanHillard 1097: 1095:Compassionate727 1074: 1050: 1049: 1047: 1045: 1034: 1028: 1027: 1025: 1023: 1017: 1009: 971: 952: 950: 949: 948: 947: 946: 936: 922: 921: 919: 917: 912:. Bank of Canada 911: 903: 897: 896: 894: 892: 887:. Bank of Canada 886: 878: 847:FleishmanHillard 828: 821: 760: 713:digital currency 648: 556: 555: 549: 515: 514: 511: 508: 505: 484: 479: 478: 468: 461: 460: 455: 447: 440: 428:importance scale 410: 409: 406: 403: 400: 379: 372: 371: 366: 358: 351: 321: 320: 317: 314: 311: 290: 285: 284: 274: 267: 266: 261: 253: 246: 216: 215: 212: 209: 206: 181: 174: 173: 168: 160: 153: 128: 107: 106: 103: 100: 97: 80: 73: 72: 67: 66: 65: 55: 48: 31: 25: 24: 16: 2386: 2385: 2381: 2380: 2379: 2377: 2376: 2375: 2281: 2280: 2244: 2234: 2216: 2196: 2188: 2168: 2162: 2158: 2138: 2116: 2097: 2080:8 December 2022 2067: 2030: 1989: 1843: 1823: 1802: 1790: 1779: 1751: 1744: 1729: 1721: 1709: 1707: 1699: 1698: 1697: 1687: 1685: 1680: 1679: 1675: 1665: 1663: 1659: 1655: 1654: 1650: 1583: 1578: 1577: 1570: 1569: 1568: 1558: 1556: 1551: 1550: 1546: 1536: 1534: 1530: 1526: 1525: 1521: 1474: 1401: 1400: 1399: 1390: 1388: 1379: 1378: 1374: 1364: 1362: 1357: 1356: 1352: 1342: 1340: 1336: 1332: 1331: 1327: 1181: 1101: 1092: 1070: 1060: 1055: 1054: 1053: 1043: 1041: 1036: 1035: 1031: 1021: 1019: 1015: 1011: 1010: 1006: 965: 963: 944: 943: 942: 941: 940: 938: 932: 927: 926: 925: 915: 913: 909: 905: 904: 900: 890: 888: 884: 880: 879: 875: 819: 754: 642: 606: 553: 512: 509: 506: 503: 502: 482:Politics portal 480: 473: 453: 407: 404: 401: 398: 397: 364: 318: 315: 312: 309: 308: 286: 279: 259: 213: 210: 207: 204: 203: 166: 124: 104: 101: 98: 95: 94: 61: 32:on Knowledge's 29: 12: 11: 5: 2384: 2382: 2374: 2373: 2368: 2363: 2358: 2353: 2348: 2343: 2338: 2333: 2328: 2323: 2318: 2313: 2308: 2303: 2298: 2293: 2283: 2282: 2257:unified ledger 2247: 2243: 2240: 2220: 2187: 2177: 2157: 2154: 2137: 2134: 2115: 2112: 2066: 2063: 2029: 2026: 2025: 2024: 1988: 1985: 1842: 1839: 1822: 1819: 1818: 1817: 1816: 1815: 1814: 1813: 1812: 1811: 1739: 1738: 1696: 1695: 1684:. Coindesk.com 1673: 1647: 1646: 1642: 1612: 1611: 1600: 1582: 1579: 1571: 1567: 1566: 1555:. Coindesk.com 1544: 1518: 1517: 1513: 1512: 1511: 1510: 1509: 1492: 1491: 1490: 1489: 1486: 1468: 1467: 1449: 1448: 1430: 1429: 1421: 1420: 1398: 1397: 1372: 1361:. Coindesk.com 1350: 1324: 1323: 1319: 1318: 1317: 1277:RfC relisted. 1271: 1270: 1224: 1223: 1222: 1221: 1205: 1204: 1203: 1202: 1201: 1200: 1197: 1173: 1172: 1153: 1102: 1082: 1081: 1080: 1061: 1059: 1056: 1052: 1051: 1040:. Coindesk.com 1029: 1003: 1002: 998: 962: 959: 931: 928: 924: 923: 898: 872: 871: 867: 841: 840: 829: 818: 817:"edit request" 815: 766: 765: 764: 763: 735: 734: 731: 727: 702: 701: 700: 699: 698: 697: 689: 688: 687: 686: 668: 667: 666: 665: 658: 657: 656: 655: 637: 636: 605: 602: 599: 598: 597: 596: 573:WP:COIRESPONSE 557: 545: 544: 541: 540: 537: 536: 529:Mid-importance 525: 519: 518: 516: 499:the discussion 486: 485: 469: 457: 456: 454:Mid‑importance 448: 436: 435: 432: 431: 424:Mid-importance 420: 414: 413: 411: 399:Cryptocurrency 394:the discussion 390:cryptocurrency 380: 368: 367: 365:Mid‑importance 362:Cryptocurrency 359: 347: 346: 343: 342: 335:Mid-importance 331: 325: 324: 322: 305:the discussion 292: 291: 275: 263: 262: 260:Mid‑importance 254: 242: 241: 238: 237: 230:Mid-importance 226: 220: 219: 217: 200:the discussion 182: 170: 169: 167:Mid‑importance 161: 149: 148: 145: 144: 121: 111: 110: 108: 81: 69: 68: 56: 44: 43: 37: 26: 13: 10: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 2383: 2372: 2369: 2367: 2364: 2362: 2359: 2357: 2354: 2352: 2349: 2347: 2344: 2342: 2339: 2337: 2334: 2332: 2329: 2327: 2324: 2322: 2319: 2317: 2314: 2312: 2309: 2307: 2304: 2302: 2299: 2297: 2294: 2292: 2289: 2288: 2286: 2279: 2278: 2274: 2270: 2266: 2262: 2258: 2254: 2250: 2241: 2239: 2238: 2232: 2231: 2226: 2225: 2219: 2214: 2213: 2208: 2204: 2199: 2195:The redirect 2193: 2186: 2182: 2178: 2176: 2175: 2171: 2165: 2155: 2153: 2152: 2148: 2144: 2135: 2133: 2132: 2128: 2124: 2121: 2113: 2111: 2109: 2105: 2101: 2095: 2093: 2089: 2085: 2072: 2064: 2062: 2061: 2057: 2053: 2052:217.87.181.52 2050: 2045: 2041: 2040:217.87.181.52 2037: 2027: 2023: 2019: 2015: 2011: 2010: 2009: 2008: 2004: 2000: 1996: 1995: 1986: 1984: 1983: 1979: 1976: 1975: 1971: 1968: 1964: 1961: 1958: 1955: 1952: 1949: 1946: 1945: 1941: 1938: 1937: 1933: 1930: 1926: 1923: 1920: 1917: 1916: 1910: 1907: 1904: 1901: 1898: 1895: 1892: 1889: 1886: 1883: 1880: 1879: 1874: 1871: 1870: 1865: 1862: 1859: 1856: 1852: 1849: 1846: 1840: 1838: 1837: 1833: 1829: 1820: 1810: 1806: 1800: 1794: 1789: 1788: 1787: 1783: 1777: 1772: 1771: 1770: 1766: 1762: 1755: 1748: 1743: 1742: 1741: 1740: 1737: 1733: 1725: 1720: 1719: 1718: 1717: 1714: 1712: 1704: 1683: 1677: 1674: 1658: 1652: 1649: 1645: 1641: 1640: 1636: 1632: 1628: 1625: 1622: 1618: 1609: 1605: 1601: 1598: 1594: 1593: 1590: 1588: 1580: 1575: 1554: 1548: 1545: 1529: 1523: 1520: 1516: 1508: 1504: 1500: 1496: 1495: 1494: 1493: 1487: 1484: 1483: 1478: 1473: 1470: 1469: 1466: 1462: 1458: 1454: 1451: 1450: 1447: 1443: 1439: 1438: 1432: 1431: 1426: 1423: 1422: 1419: 1416: 1414: 1412: 1411: 1406: 1403: 1402: 1386: 1382: 1376: 1373: 1360: 1354: 1351: 1335: 1329: 1326: 1322: 1316: 1312: 1308: 1304: 1301: 1298: 1294: 1290: 1287: 1284: 1280: 1276: 1273: 1272: 1268: 1264: 1260: 1256: 1252: 1246: 1242: 1238: 1235:)." could be 1234: 1233:outside money 1229: 1226: 1225: 1220: 1216: 1212: 1209: 1208: 1207: 1206: 1198: 1195: 1194: 1189: 1185: 1180: 1177: 1176: 1175: 1174: 1171: 1167: 1163: 1162: 1157: 1154: 1152: 1149: 1147: 1145: 1144: 1139: 1136: 1135: 1134: 1133: 1129: 1125: 1120: 1116: 1110: 1105: 1100: 1096: 1090: 1086: 1079: 1076: 1073: 1068: 1063: 1062: 1057: 1039: 1033: 1030: 1014: 1008: 1005: 1001: 997: 996: 992: 988: 984: 981: 978: 975: 969: 960: 958: 957: 953: 951: 929: 908: 902: 899: 883: 877: 874: 870: 866: 865: 861: 857: 851: 848: 838: 834: 830: 827: 823: 822: 816: 814: 813: 809: 805: 800: 799: 795: 791: 785: 784: 780: 776: 770: 758: 753: 752: 751: 750: 749: 748: 744: 740: 732: 728: 725: 724: 723: 720: 716: 714: 709: 706: 695: 694: 693: 692: 691: 690: 685: 681: 677: 672: 671: 670: 669: 662: 661: 660: 659: 653: 646: 641: 640: 639: 638: 635: 631: 627: 623: 622: 621: 620: 616: 612: 603: 594: 590: 587: 584: 580: 577: 576: 574: 570: 566: 562: 558: 551: 550: 534: 530: 524: 521: 520: 517: 500: 496: 492: 491: 483: 477: 472: 470: 467: 463: 462: 458: 452: 449: 446: 442: 429: 425: 419: 416: 415: 412: 395: 391: 387: 386: 381: 378: 374: 373: 369: 363: 360: 357: 353: 340: 336: 330: 327: 326: 323: 306: 302: 298: 297: 289: 283: 278: 276: 273: 269: 268: 264: 258: 255: 252: 248: 235: 231: 225: 222: 221: 218: 201: 197: 193: 189: 188: 183: 180: 176: 175: 171: 165: 162: 159: 155: 142: 139: 136: 132: 127: 117: 113: 112: 109: 92: 88: 87: 82: 79: 75: 74: 70: 60: 57: 54: 50: 45: 41: 35: 27: 23: 18: 17: 2265:Mr. Carstens 2256: 2248: 2245: 2228: 2222: 2210: 2189: 2183:" listed at 2159: 2139: 2117: 2096: 2068: 2034:— Preceding 2031: 1997: 1990: 1980: 1977: 1972: 1969: 1965: 1962: 1959: 1956: 1953: 1950: 1947: 1942: 1939: 1934: 1931: 1927: 1924: 1921: 1918: 1911: 1908: 1905: 1902: 1899: 1896: 1893: 1890: 1887: 1884: 1881: 1875: 1872: 1866: 1863: 1860: 1857: 1853: 1850: 1847: 1844: 1824: 1706: 1700: 1686:. Retrieved 1676: 1664:. Retrieved 1651: 1643: 1629: 1626: 1623: 1619: 1615: 1604:edit request 1584: 1581:Edit request 1573: 1557:. Retrieved 1547: 1535:. Retrieved 1522: 1514: 1471: 1452: 1436: 1435: 1424: 1410:TimTempleton 1409: 1404: 1389:. Retrieved 1387:. 2017-09-17 1384: 1375: 1363:. Retrieved 1353: 1341:. Retrieved 1328: 1320: 1299: 1285: 1279:Timtempleton 1274: 1249:— Preceding 1227: 1184:TimTempleton 1178: 1160: 1159: 1155: 1143:TimTempleton 1142: 1137: 1106: 1103: 1084: 1077: 1071: 1064: 1042:. Retrieved 1032: 1020:. Retrieved 1007: 999: 985: 982: 979: 964: 937: 933: 914:. Retrieved 901: 889:. Retrieved 876: 868: 852: 844: 833:edit request 801: 786: 771: 767: 736: 721: 717: 710: 707: 703: 607: 585: 565:Terms of Use 528: 488: 423: 383: 334: 294: 229: 185: 137: 105:AfC articles 91:project page 84: 40:WikiProjects 1828:Gabrielabed 1385:www.bis.org 804:Gabrielabed 790:Gabrielabed 757:Stanjourdan 739:Stanjourdan 645:Stanjourdan 626:Stanjourdan 611:Stanjourdan 2285:Categories 2269:41.66.99.0 1999:Metaxolotl 1710:spintendo 1644:References 1515:References 1391:2017-11-09 1321:References 1255:Jtbobwaysf 1000:References 945:Spintendo 869:References 196:Investment 126:this draft 2261:Finternet 1861:Sources. 1799:Spintendo 1776:Spintendo 1747:Spintendo 1724:Spintendo 1688:April 13, 1666:April 13, 1477:Spintendo 1437:North8000 1293:North8000 1243:(a clear 1188:North8000 1161:North8000 1044:April 13, 1022:April 13, 968:Spintendo 593:eCurrency 310:Economics 301:Economics 257:Economics 131:Sulfurboy 2036:unsigned 1303:contribs 1289:contribs 1275:Comment: 1263:contribs 1251:unsigned 916:March 2, 589:contribs 504:Politics 495:politics 451:Politics 141:contribs 2100:Kaisery 2088:BL33701 2014:MrOllie 1472:Comment 1453:Support 1405:Comment 1228:Support 1179:Comment 1156:Comment 1138:Comment 1089:be bold 891:Jan 31, 569:WP:PAID 531:on the 426:on the 337:on the 232:on the 192:Finance 30:C-class 2249:mCBDCs 2218:Utopes 2136:Mining 1559:May 8, 1537:May 8, 1457:Dryfee 1365:May 8, 1343:May 8, 1307:Cunard 1291:) and 1115:Cunard 36:scale. 2170:A. B. 2164:A. B. 1660:(PDF) 1602:This 1531:(PDF) 1337:(PDF) 1245:WP:RS 1237:WP:OR 1016:(PDF) 910:(PDF) 885:(PDF) 831:This 730:term. 2273:talk 2230:cont 2224:talk 2198:Cdbc 2181:Cdbc 2147:talk 2127:talk 2104:talk 2078:and 2056:talk 2044:talk 2018:talk 2003:talk 1832:talk 1765:talk 1690:2018 1668:2018 1635:talk 1561:2018 1539:2018 1503:talk 1461:talk 1442:talk 1367:2018 1345:2018 1311:talk 1297:talk 1283:talk 1259:talk 1215:talk 1186:and 1166:talk 1128:talk 1119:talk 1046:2018 1024:2018 991:talk 918:2018 893:2018 860:talk 808:talk 794:talk 779:talk 743:talk 680:talk 630:talk 615:talk 583:talk 559:The 194:and 135:talk 2263:by 2246:Hi, 2094:). 575:. 563:'s 523:Mid 418:Mid 329:Mid 224:Mid 2287:: 2275:) 2227:/ 2149:) 2129:) 2106:) 2058:) 2020:) 2005:) 1834:) 1767:) 1637:) 1505:) 1463:) 1444:) 1383:. 1313:) 1265:) 1261:• 1217:) 1168:) 1130:) 1085:is 1069:. 993:) 862:) 810:) 796:) 781:) 745:) 682:) 632:) 617:) 143:). 2271:( 2233:) 2221:( 2179:" 2145:( 2125:( 2102:( 2090:( 2054:( 2042:( 2016:( 2001:( 1830:( 1803:— 1795:: 1791:@ 1780:— 1763:( 1756:: 1752:@ 1749:: 1745:@ 1730:— 1726:: 1722:@ 1692:. 1670:. 1633:( 1563:. 1541:. 1501:( 1479:: 1475:@ 1459:( 1440:( 1394:. 1369:. 1347:. 1309:( 1300:· 1295:( 1286:· 1281:( 1257:( 1213:( 1190:: 1182:@ 1164:( 1126:( 1117:( 1093:— 1048:. 1026:. 989:( 970:: 966:@ 920:. 895:. 858:( 806:( 792:( 777:( 759:: 755:@ 741:( 678:( 650:( 647:: 643:@ 628:( 613:( 595:. 586:· 581:( 535:. 430:. 341:. 236:. 138:· 133:( 42::

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.

Index