Knowledge

:Articles for deletion/Cincinnati Reds minor league players - Knowledge

Source 📝

216:. Nominators rationale makes no sense and is his trying to make a point after he tried to add minor players to these pages and was reverted. A list page has different notability requirements than an article. These articles are about the farm system, a notable subject and contain the entire rosters. The article is well sourced and "unnecessary and redundant" is not a proper rationale for deletion. 167: 310:
The Knowledge community, WP:BASEBALL, and/or the participants in this AfD may "conclude that the topic actually should not have a stand-alone article," and that the subject matter may be better covered as part of another
353: 161: 93: 88: 97: 393: 80: 373: 120: 255: 127: 198:
To qualify for this page, a player must pass GNG. If they pass GNG, then they qualify for a standalone article. That makes this page unnecessary and redundant.
303:- The listed minor league baseball players are those who have been determined to be of some measure of notability under the general notability guidelines per 286:
him. We have a long standing consensus on how to do this that he doesn't seem to comprehend, and now he's wasting our time and resources on this farce. –
84: 182: 149: 76: 68: 307:, but WP:BASEBALL and the larger community believe would be better served by inclusion in an "incubator" list article such as this one. 429: 405: 385: 365: 344: 327: 295: 267: 246: 225: 207: 62: 143: 139: 17: 189: 155: 448: 203: 40: 444: 323: 36: 263: 242: 221: 199: 425: 175: 291: 401: 381: 361: 340: 29:
The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.
443:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's
35:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's
319: 234: 417: 283: 279: 259: 238: 217: 421: 53: 304: 287: 397: 377: 357: 336: 114: 437:
The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate.
354:
list of United States of America-related deletion discussions
110: 106: 102: 174: 394:
list of Lists of people-related deletion discussions
374:list of Sportspeople-related deletion discussions 335:and trout per Dirtlawyer, Spanneraol and others. 43:). No further edits should be made to this page. 451:). No further edits should be made to this page. 256:list of Baseball-related deletion discussions 188: 8: 392:Note: This debate has been included in the 372:Note: This debate has been included in the 352:Note: This debate has been included in the 254:Note: This debate has been included in the 391: 371: 351: 253: 7: 314:per GNG. This is just such a case: 77:Cincinnati Reds minor league players 69:Cincinnati Reds minor league players 24: 18:Knowledge:Articles for deletion 1: 420:nomination, per Dirtlawyer1. 430:03:22, 6 November 2014 (UTC) 406:02:28, 6 November 2014 (UTC) 386:02:28, 6 November 2014 (UTC) 366:02:27, 6 November 2014 (UTC) 345:23:39, 5 November 2014 (UTC) 328:19:52, 5 November 2014 (UTC) 296:15:05, 5 November 2014 (UTC) 268:14:42, 5 November 2014 (UTC) 247:14:23, 5 November 2014 (UTC) 226:06:21, 5 November 2014 (UTC) 208:06:14, 5 November 2014 (UTC) 63:15:08, 8 November 2014 (UTC) 468: 440:Please do not modify it. 32:Please do not modify it. 48:The result was 408: 388: 368: 282:and I've already 270: 459: 442: 193: 192: 178: 130: 118: 100: 60: 34: 467: 466: 462: 461: 460: 458: 457: 456: 455: 449:deletion review 438: 231:Procedural keep 135: 126: 91: 75: 72: 54: 41:deletion review 30: 22: 21: 20: 12: 11: 5: 465: 463: 454: 453: 433: 432: 410: 409: 389: 369: 348: 347: 330: 298: 278:Alex is being 272: 271: 250: 249: 228: 196: 195: 132: 71: 66: 46: 45: 25: 23: 15: 14: 13: 10: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 464: 452: 450: 446: 441: 435: 434: 431: 427: 423: 419: 415: 412: 411: 407: 403: 399: 395: 390: 387: 383: 379: 375: 370: 367: 363: 359: 355: 350: 349: 346: 342: 338: 334: 331: 329: 325: 321: 317: 313: 312: 306: 302: 299: 297: 293: 289: 285: 281: 277: 274: 273: 269: 265: 261: 257: 252: 251: 248: 244: 240: 236: 232: 229: 227: 223: 219: 215: 212: 211: 210: 209: 205: 201: 191: 187: 184: 181: 177: 173: 169: 166: 163: 160: 157: 154: 151: 148: 145: 141: 138: 137:Find sources: 133: 129: 125: 122: 116: 112: 108: 104: 99: 95: 90: 86: 82: 78: 74: 73: 70: 67: 65: 64: 61: 59: 58: 51: 44: 42: 38: 33: 27: 26: 19: 439: 436: 413: 332: 315: 309: 308: 300: 275: 230: 213: 197: 185: 179: 171: 164: 158: 152: 146: 136: 123: 56: 55: 49: 47: 31: 28: 320:Dirtlawyer1 276:Speedy keep 214:Speedy Keep 162:free images 284:WP:TROUTed 260:Spanneraol 239:VMS Mosaic 218:Spanneraol 445:talk page 422:Ejgreen77 418:WP:POINTy 398:• Gene93k 378:• Gene93k 358:• Gene93k 280:WP:POINTy 235:WP:POINTy 57:Wizardman 37:talk page 447:or in a 288:Muboshgu 121:View log 39:or in a 337:Rlendog 311:article 168:WP refs 156:scholar 94:protect 89:history 305:WP:GNG 140:Google 98:delete 416:on a 183:JSTOR 144:books 128:Stats 115:views 107:watch 103:links 16:< 426:talk 414:Keep 402:talk 382:talk 362:talk 341:talk 333:Keep 324:talk 316:KEEP 301:Keep 292:talk 264:talk 243:talk 233:per 222:talk 204:talk 200:Alex 176:FENS 150:news 111:logs 85:talk 81:edit 50:keep 318:. 190:TWL 119:– ( 428:) 404:) 396:. 384:) 376:. 364:) 356:. 343:) 326:) 294:) 266:) 258:. 245:) 237:. 224:) 206:) 170:) 113:| 109:| 105:| 101:| 96:| 92:| 87:| 83:| 52:. 424:( 400:( 380:( 360:( 339:( 322:( 290:( 262:( 241:( 220:( 202:( 194:) 186:· 180:· 172:· 165:· 159:· 153:· 147:· 142:( 134:( 131:) 124:· 117:) 79:(

Index

Knowledge:Articles for deletion
talk page
deletion review
Wizardman
15:08, 8 November 2014 (UTC)
Cincinnati Reds minor league players
Cincinnati Reds minor league players
edit
talk
history
protect
delete
links
watch
logs
views
View log
Stats
Google
books
news
scholar
free images
WP refs
FENS
JSTOR
TWL
Alex
talk
06:14, 5 November 2014 (UTC)

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.