501:, which is also mostly a Hadith quote farm at present. The Hadith in praise of Umar and Hadith of Umar... articles which we are debating appear to exist merely because the creator couldn't fit all of his hadith quotes into his main article Sunni view of Umar. Commentary and encyclopedic content seem to have been a secondary consideration.
537:
The traffic stats to the article are nothing more than the background noise that you would expect for a long standing linked up article like this. No google news, scholar or book hits whatsoever but an odd amount of search hits which I suspect somehow originate from the wikipedia article (have a look
632:. It's quite probable that an article exists for this subject, as DGG correctly notes that it is a key element in the dispute between Shi'a and Sunni traditions. But this isn't that article, and a clean start (at a clearer title) would be best for such an important topic.
552:
It is also not clear what the copyright status might be on the particular translation quoted. In fact if the link in the citations is correct (which I am not sure it is for every quote) this all appears to come from a 1995 translation
457:- if this was expanded to include a commentary I would change my vote to keep. It could be a great look at a very important work. As it stands though it isn't an article, just a series of quotes with a few sentences to give a context.
173:
279:
and expand. There is surely going to be both classical and modern commentary, especially on a hadith which appears to be central in the dispute between Shi'a and Sunni. Those qualified to find it should look.
355:
515:
Content forks, created in good faith, should, in my opinion, by default be merged and redirected. That somebody made the article is strong evidence that it is a reasonable search term. Changing to
538:
through them). I think the titles of all of the articles are likely the article creator's own classifications. This editor created many many 'Hadith...' articles to fit these quotes into.
167:
128:
332:. Any commentary can easily go into the main article and the quotes reduced down to a few examples in that article. So delete the sub articles and clean up the main one.
589:
101:
96:
105:
133:
88:
390:
399:
248:
219:
188:
638:
615:- this is a quote farm and not an article. Any actual content makes sense at the parent article so there is no need for this one. --
155:
557:
17:
394:
471:. Needs style editing. "Could be expanded but this is not yet done" is not a good reason to delete. That is ultra extreme
230:
Page is basically just a collection of quotes. They can go to
Wikiquotes. The little non-quote content is a minute subset of
386:
149:
642:
624:
604:
569:
547:
532:
510:
484:
461:
446:
412:
367:
341:
291:
271:
253:
224:
70:
145:
442:
329:
206:
92:
657:
351:
63:
36:
195:
656:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's talk page or in a
35:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's talk page or in a
325:
84:
76:
244:
215:
309:
438:
161:
528:
480:
301:
181:
600:
565:
543:
520:
506:
498:
408:
363:
337:
321:
317:
267:
239:
231:
210:
633:
554:
382:
29:
The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.
429:
620:
524:
494:
476:
596:
561:
539:
502:
404:
359:
333:
313:
287:
263:
58:
378:
305:
376:
Might be fun looking for quotes in the other 1000+ articles created by this user.
122:
262:
no significant content without the quotes which should be in wikiquote not here.
472:
358:. It appears a couple of the articles unfortunately escaped this mass deletion.
497:. Any expantion or commentary on this is far better in the more sensibly named
458:
616:
282:
49:
493:
Please read my comments. I also think this article is a fairly useless
312:, wikipedia is being used to repeat this classic text, this is a big
560:
so extensive lifting of text is very likely to be a copright issue.
432:
to generate a more thorough discussion so consensus may be reached.
354:
by prod in 2007, and many more after the following deletion debate
650:
The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate.
356:
Knowledge:Articles for deletion/Hadith of the demise of
Muhammad
235:
324:. The two sub articles being considered for deletion have 32
523:. Keeping the quotes in the history is not a bad thing. --
308:
all of the quotes, in all three articles come from one book
118:
114:
110:
180:
350:
Some of the other articles have already been deleted
437:Please add new comments below this notice. Thanks,
39:). No further edits should be made to this page.
660:). No further edits should be made to this page.
304:. All of these articles were created in 2006 by
194:
8:
590:list of Islam-related deletion discussions
584:
300:Yes a commentary would be good but not a
588:: This debate has been included in the
330:Hadith of Umar and the Qur'an#References
7:
326:Hadith in praise of Umar#References
24:
240:Raziman T V's Alternate account
211:Raziman T V's Alternate account
18:Knowledge:Articles for deletion
1:
322:Sunni view of Umar#References
320:has 103 of these quotes, see
207:Hadith of Umar and the Qur'an
643:16:23, 18 January 2010 (UTC)
625:17:16, 14 January 2010 (UTC)
605:15:06, 14 January 2010 (UTC)
570:08:43, 19 January 2010 (UTC)
548:06:54, 19 January 2010 (UTC)
533:00:11, 19 January 2010 (UTC)
511:11:40, 14 January 2010 (UTC)
485:00:31, 14 January 2010 (UTC)
462:14:02, 13 January 2010 (UTC)
447:02:19, 13 January 2010 (UTC)
71:11:03, 20 January 2010 (UTC)
413:07:33, 7 January 2010 (UTC)
368:07:00, 7 January 2010 (UTC)
352:Hadith of Umar and prophecy
342:05:56, 7 January 2010 (UTC)
292:04:12, 7 January 2010 (UTC)
272:22:11, 6 January 2010 (UTC)
254:19:48, 6 January 2010 (UTC)
225:19:52, 6 January 2010 (UTC)
677:
653:Please do not modify it.
85:Hadith in praise of Umar
77:Hadith in praise of Umar
32:Please do not modify it.
310:History of the Caliphs
316:. The main article
209:. Same concerns --
521:Sunni view of Umar
499:Sunni view of Umar
318:Sunni view of Umar
232:Sunni view of Umar
44:The result was
641:
607:
593:
449:
252:
223:
69:
668:
655:
637:
594:
519:to (I guess) to
439:Timotheus Canens
436:
434:
415:
402:
242:
213:
205:Also nominating
199:
198:
184:
136:
126:
108:
56:
34:
676:
675:
671:
670:
669:
667:
666:
665:
664:
658:deletion review
651:
427:
398:
377:
141:
132:
99:
83:
80:
37:deletion review
30:
22:
21:
20:
12:
11:
5:
674:
672:
663:
662:
646:
645:
627:
609:
608:
581:
580:
579:
578:
577:
576:
575:
574:
573:
572:
488:
487:
464:
451:
450:
435:
424:
423:
422:
421:
420:
419:
418:
417:
416:
371:
370:
345:
344:
295:
294:
274:
228:
227:
202:
201:
138:
134:AfD statistics
79:
74:
66:
61:
54:
42:
41:
25:
23:
15:
14:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
673:
661:
659:
654:
648:
647:
644:
640:
635:
631:
628:
626:
622:
618:
614:
611:
610:
606:
602:
598:
591:
587:
583:
582:
571:
567:
563:
559:
558:9781897940259
556:
551:
550:
549:
545:
541:
536:
535:
534:
530:
526:
522:
518:
514:
513:
512:
508:
504:
500:
496:
492:
491:
490:
489:
486:
482:
478:
474:
470:
469:
465:
463:
460:
456:
453:
452:
448:
444:
440:
433:
431:
426:
425:
414:
410:
406:
401:
400:pages created
396:
392:
388:
384:
380:
375:
374:
373:
372:
369:
365:
361:
357:
353:
349:
348:
347:
346:
343:
339:
335:
331:
327:
323:
319:
315:
311:
307:
303:
299:
298:
297:
296:
293:
289:
285:
284:
278:
275:
273:
269:
265:
261:
258:
257:
256:
255:
250:
246:
241:
237:
233:
226:
221:
217:
212:
208:
204:
203:
197:
193:
190:
187:
183:
179:
175:
172:
169:
166:
163:
160:
157:
154:
151:
147:
144:
143:Find sources:
139:
135:
130:
124:
120:
116:
112:
107:
103:
98:
94:
90:
86:
82:
81:
78:
75:
73:
72:
68:
67:
64:
62:
59:
55:
53:
50:
47:
40:
38:
33:
27:
26:
19:
652:
649:
634:UltraExactZZ
629:
612:
585:
516:
495:content fork
467:
466:
454:
428:
306:User:Striver
281:
276:
259:
229:
191:
185:
177:
170:
164:
158:
152:
142:
57:
51:
45:
43:
31:
28:
473:Immediatism
168:free images
302:quote farm
525:SmokeyJoe
477:SmokeyJoe
597:Polargeo
562:Polargeo
540:Polargeo
517:redirect
503:Polargeo
430:Relisted
405:Polargeo
387:contribs
360:Polargeo
334:Polargeo
264:Polargeo
249:Contribs
220:Contribs
129:View log
391:deleted
379:Striver
328:and 10
174:WP refs
162:scholar
102:protect
97:history
630:Delete
613:Delete
455:Delete
314:WP:NOT
260:Delete
146:Google
106:delete
46:delete
475:. --
459:Panyd
395:count
288:talk
189:JSTOR
150:books
123:views
115:watch
111:links
16:<
621:talk
617:Whpq
601:talk
586:Note
566:talk
555:ISBN
544:talk
529:talk
507:talk
481:talk
468:Keep
443:talk
409:talk
383:talk
364:talk
338:talk
277:Keep
268:talk
245:Talk
236:Umar
234:and
216:Talk
182:FENS
156:news
119:logs
93:talk
89:edit
639:Did
283:DGG
238:--
196:TWL
131:•
127:– (
60:(t/
52:NJA
623:)
603:)
592:.
568:)
546:)
531:)
509:)
483:)
445:)
411:)
403:)
397:·
393:·
389:·
385:·
366:)
340:)
290:)
270:)
251:)
247:-
222:)
218:-
176:)
121:|
117:|
113:|
109:|
104:|
100:|
95:|
91:|
65:c)
48:.
636:~
619:(
599:(
595:—
564:(
542:(
527:(
505:(
479:(
441:(
407:(
381:(
362:(
336:(
286:(
266:(
243:(
214:(
200:)
192:·
186:·
178:·
171:·
165:·
159:·
153:·
148:(
140:(
137:)
125:)
87:(
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.