Knowledge (XXG)

:Overcategorization - Knowledge (XXG)

Source đź“ť

68: 140: 1268:
It is not necessary to completely empty every parent category into sub-categories. So do not categorize articles into "miscellaneous", "other", "not otherwise specified" or "remainder", categories. Such articles will have little in common. If there are some articles that don't fit appropriately into
1122:
However, avoid sub-categorizing subjects by location if that location does not have any relevant bearing on the subjects' other characteristics. For example, quarterbacks' careers are not defined merely by the specific state that they once lived in (unless they played for a team within that state).
420:
Categorization by non-defining characteristics should be avoided. It is sometimes difficult to know whether or not a particular characteristic is "defining" for any given topic, and there is no one definition that can apply to all situations. However, the following suggestions or rules-of-thumb may
1142:
if this relates to a specific place or event. If it is relevant to identify the place of burial (either from the perspective of the person or the burial place), then someone buried in a less notable cemetery, or in a place with just a few notable burials, should be recorded in a list within the
507:
is the test that is used to determine whether a category should be created for a particular attribute of a topic. In general, it is much easier to verifiably demonstrate that a particular characteristic is notable than to prove that it is a defining characteristic of the topic. In cases where a
1826:
Avoid categorizing locations by the events or event types that have been held there, such as arenas that have hosted specific sports events or concerts, convention centers that have hosted specific conventions or meetings, or cities featured in specific television shows that film at multiple
2359:
Avoid categorizing characters or specific works by the performers who have portrayed them or appeared in them. A typical film or television series has many actors in various roles, so categorizing by actor results in needless clutter. Similarly, some roles, particularly animated ones like
173:) in an article requires creating an associated category. For some article topics, this could potentially result in hundreds of categories, most of which aren't particularly relevant. This may also make it more difficult to find any particular category for a specific article. Such 515:
It is recommended to name or rename categories to have as little vagueness as possible, discouraging non-defining articles from being added. If you have just invented a subcategory on the spot that lacks a main article, it may not be a defining attribute. Examples include:
624:
For biographical articles, it is usual to categorize by such aspects as their career, origins, and major accomplishments. In contrast, someone's tastes in food, their favorite holiday destination, or the number of tattoos they have would be considered
2260:
Avoid categorizing performers by an appearance at an event or other performance venue. This also includes categorization by performance—even for permanent or recurring roles—in any specific radio, television, film, or theatrical production (such as
629:. Such an item which may be appropriate information to include in an article, may still be inappropriate for categorization. In general, if something could be easily left out of a biography, it is likely that it is a trivial characteristic. 502:
is the test that is used to determine whether a topic should have its own article. This test, combined with the test of verifiability, is used to determine whether particular information should be included in an article about a topic.
1485:
and vague determination. Determining what degree or nature of "association" with a particular subject is necessary to qualify for inclusion in such a category can also be subjective and vague, and any threshold set may fail
1203:
to be an option, and when similar intersections can be made for related categories. A common way to address such narrow categorization is to selectively "Up-Merge" the contents of the category to its parent categories.
2631: 1391:" would be inappropriate. However, categorization may be appropriate if the categorized subjects are directly-related. For example, a category grouping articles directly-related to a specific Jackson family, such as 1549:
Avoid categorizing people by their personal opinions, even if a reliable source can be found for the opinions. This includes supporters or critics of an issue, personal preferences (such as liking or disliking
1198:
Categories which intersect two (or more) topics or characteristics can result in very narrow categories with few members. Such categories should only be created when both parent categories are large enough for
1913:
by performers' performances. For example, just as we shouldn't categorize a performer by action or appearance, we shouldn't categorize a production by a performer's action or appearance in that production.
2641: 2595: 2447: 615: 2621: 2293: 1463: 1451: 1307: 824: 632:
Also avoid categorizing people by information associated with a person's death, such as the age at which the person died, the place of the person's death, or by whether the person still had
2335: 2323: 2246: 2001: 1928: 1820: 1814: 1808: 1657: 1651: 1455: 1445: 1439: 1329:"), it is generally better to merge the subjects to a single category, and re-categorize any articles or categories which might no longer meet the criteria of the unified target category. 1311: 1303: 1299: 1262: 1256: 1250: 1180: 2025: 1663: 1603: 1537: 1374: 1370: 1097: 1091: 904: 900: 892: 816: 692: 680: 674: 607: 1138:
may seem significant from the perspective of local studies, is rarely defining from the perspective of the individual. The place of death is not normally categorized – consider using a
2478: 2319: 2021: 2017: 2013: 2009: 1936: 1932: 1681: 1467: 1085: 820: 686: 611: 603: 599: 259: 2339: 2331: 2242: 2238: 2234: 2029: 2005: 1192: 1188: 896: 559: 212: 2327: 2226: 1997: 1924: 1531: 908: 2315: 2230: 1993: 1743: 1543: 1459: 1366: 1184: 670: 666: 227: 222: 1143:
article about the burial place. However, if the burial place is notable in its own right and has too many other notable people to list, then such burials may be categorized.
2626: 2611: 1215:
Similarly, while an article in categories A, B, and C could potentially be placed in categories "A and B", "B and C", and "A and C" – creating a "triple intersection" of
217: 1036:
While people may be categorized by the year of their birth and year of death, do not categorize people by day or month of birth or death. (See also list of CFD examples
2440: 1677:
recipients. And a recipient of an award should be added to a category of award recipients only if receiving the award is a defining characteristic of the recipient.
1838: 2513: 2488: 380: 237: 2662: 2564: 2559: 1000:
does not usually change from year to year), it is generally better to (up)merge to the (non-year) parent category of the topic, and then diffuse as appropriate.
2590: 277: 2667: 2433: 1037: 703: 2288:
Note also that performers should not be categorized into a general category which groups topics about a particular performance venue or production (e.g.
182:
To address these concerns, this page lists types of categories that should generally be avoided. Based on existing guidelines and previous precedent at
1613:
A candidate not yet nominated for public office, the possible next CEO of a certain corporation, a potential member of a sports team, an actor on the
838:
with 3,800 students is not meaningfully different from one with 4,100 students. A better way of representing this kind of information is to make it a
2498: 2112:
Portraying a "type" of character (such as dead, female, gay, homeless, queen, old, president, religious, Scottish, wealthy, etc.) This also includes
464: 282: 2726: 425:
a defining characteristic is one that reliable, secondary sources commonly and consistently define, in prose, the subject as having. For example: "
75: 2281: 1498: 1392: 148:
Do not create categories for every single verifiable fact in articles. This only makes the category system more crowded and less easy to navigate.
1696:). If both a category and a list are viable on the same topic, such a list may make a suitable main article for the category, indicated with the 1493:
However, it may be appropriate to have categories whose title clearly conveys a specific and defined relationship to a specific subject, such as
165:
Categorization is a Knowledge (XXG) feature used to group pages for ease of navigation, and correlating similar information. However, not every
2682: 1837:
However, categories that indicate how a specific facility is regularly used in a specific and notable way for some or all of the year (such as
1111:
can be a way to divide subjects into regions that are directly related to the subjects' characteristics. Location may also be used as a way to
2585: 183: 1692:
is determined by separate criteria. So regardless of whether a category is created, a list of the recipients may be created (presuming that
2150: 326: 159: 2731: 2695: 2616: 291: 91: 2677: 1029: 2705: 2503: 247: 2657: 1116: 2415: 170: 2554: 268: 300: 31: 2368:, have been performed by multiple actors, and being performed by a particular actor is seldom a defining trait for such roles. 2549: 2544: 1775: 1834:) have hosted so many sports events and conventions over time that categories listing all such events would not be readable. 1321:" and "crime history"), or if two categories' names are similar enough to have nearly identical inclusion criteria (such as " 1384:
when it is a non-defining characteristic of the subject, or by characteristics of the name rather than the subject itself.
562:
that places should not be categorized as established in the year of the earliest surviving historical record of the place.
2200:
Similarly, avoid categorizing artists based on producers, film directors or other artists they have worked with (such as "
2091: 1023: 1015: 543: 83: 2508: 199: 2365: 2539: 2493: 2473: 2468: 1399: 1044: 884: 405:
characteristics of an article's topic are central to categorizing the article. A defining characteristic is one that
372: 155: 38: 2216:
is distinguished by his performances as an actor, not by the fact that he has appeared in Steven Spielberg's films.
508:
particular attribute about a topic is verifiable and notable but not defining, or where doubt exists, creation of a
2636: 1621:
may sometimes be appropriate for such groupings, especially after the passage of the events to which they relate.
2672: 633: 474:
if the characteristic falls within any of the forms of overcategorization mentioned on this page, it is probably
1764:, regularly publish lists of the "top 10" (or some other number) in any particular field. Such lists tend to be 621:
Avoid categorizing topics by characteristics that are unrelated or wholly peripheral to the topic's notability.
1878:
Avoid categorizing performers by their performances. Examples of "performers" include (but are not limited to)
981:
only when necessary. This applies to any time period, like months to years; or years or decades, to centuries.
319: 416:
refer to in describing the topic, such as the nationality of a person or the geographic location of a place.
2103: 1674: 1128: 1028:
an English soldier born in 1590 and notable for military service in the 1620s should not be categorized in
2392: 2263: 2190: 1831: 1494: 1861: 1789: 1717: 1632: 1584: 1512: 1413: 1347: 1280: 1231: 1154: 1066: 861: 797: 647: 573: 558:
process may be used to determine whether a particular characteristic is defining or not. For example,
401: 384: 347: 100: 87: 961:). In that situation, consider grouping them by the next tier up. So for example, instead of grouping 2410: 2174: 1770: 1617:
to play a role, or an award nominee (just to name a few examples) should not be grouped by category.
997: 938: 532: 2569: 1200: 1112: 970: 57: 1317:
If a category is mostly duplicative or overlapping with another category (such as the coverage of "
1014:
a writer who lived from 1850 to 1910 and wrote their only work in 1908 should be categorized under
1003:
In addition, people are categorized by time period only if their activity in that time period is a
521: 312: 392: 53: 49: 42: 2289: 2140: 2056: 1883: 1570: 175: 1693: 2700: 1700: 1830:
Likewise, avoid categorizing events by their hosting locations. Many notable locations (e.g.
1685: 1618: 1333: 1139: 842:, either in an existing article, or as a separate list, such as "List of school districts in 839: 699: 509: 2361: 2205: 2064: 2052: 1032:, since their defining characteristic relates to years after the Tudor period ended in 1603. 2419: 1689: 1610: 950: 555: 2529: 2121: 2080: 2047:
Avoid categories which categorize performers by their portrayal of a role. This includes:
835: 1768:
and may be somewhat arbitrary. Some particularly well-known and unique lists such as the
406: 1895: 1388: 1135: 702:
inclusion criterion should not be used in naming/defining a category. Examples include
490: 484: 166: 17: 2720: 2534: 2201: 2194: 2129: 993: 2208:
actors"). Performers are defined by their body of work, not by the people they have
160:
Knowledge (XXG):What Knowledge (XXG) is not § Non-encyclopedic cross-categorizations
2158: 2106: 2087: 1950: 1468:
Hospitals and medical institutions associated with the 2019–20 coronavirus pandemic
831: 2406: 847: 1942:
Avoid categorizing performers by some action they may have performed (such as a "
817:
School districts at the top 7% in Pennsylvania on Pennsylvania standardized tests
2186: 2170: 2166: 2068: 1970: 1958: 1761: 391:
One of the central goals of the categorization system is to categorize articles
2182: 2117: 2099: 2072: 1910: 1614: 1565:
Please note, however, the distinction between holding an opinion and being an
1551: 1326: 467:(regardless of whether it is currently mentioned in the lead), it is probably 1669:
A category of award recipients should exist only if receiving the award is a
2275: 2213: 2178: 2135: 2113: 2095: 1966: 1954: 1943: 1269:
any of the sub-categories, then leave the articles in the parent category.
433: 2425: 1664:
Category:People who have received honorary degrees from Harvard University
1043:
When categorizing by time period, clearly state the inclusion criteria at
1962: 1887: 1753: 1566: 1774:
charts may constitute exceptions, although creating categories for them
2269: 2162: 1947: 1757: 1559: 931: 626: 427: 1208:
For example, if an article is in category "A" and in category "B" – a
2145: 2076: 2060: 1903: 1899: 1891: 1387:
For example, a category for unrelated people who happen to be named "
1322: 1108: 1104: 924: 1049:
This category is for politicians who were active in the 19th century
830:
There is no particular reason for choosing "7%", "$ 30,000", or the
2422:
which seek to be an alternative way to address overcategorization.
1879: 1846: 1318: 1053:
This category is for politicians who were born in the 19th century
2292:), when the specific performance category would be deleted (e.g. 463:
if the characteristic would not be appropriate to mention in the
1978: 1974: 1749: 917: 436: 37:
For the diffusion of categories (the equivalent of the Commons'
2429: 992:, (for example, because many athletes participate in multiple 134: 62: 1018:. They did no notable writing in the 19th century, so should 2243:
Entertainers who performed for troops during the Vietnam War
1682:
Knowledge (XXG):Categories, lists, and navigation templates
381:
Knowledge (XXG):Categorizing articles about people#Defining
48:
For other guidelines which concern overcategorization, see
2632:
Overcategorization/Intersection of location and occupation
2040:
Performers who have portrayed <a type of character: -->
482:
Often, users can become confused between the standards of
2383:
in declarative statements, rather than table or list form
2026:
Actors who have played the President of the United States
1776:
may risk violating the publisher's copyright or trademark
1212:
does not necessarily need to be created for this article.
1123:
The place of residence of parents and relatives is never
186:, such categories, if created, are likely to be deleted. 86:
may apply. Substantive edits to this page should reflect
1973:, etc.); or how they may have chosen to appear (such as 1398:
When considering grouping subjects that share a name, a
1336:
to provide clarity and detail to each of the instances.
1869: 1797: 1732: 1725: 1640: 1592: 1520: 1428: 1421: 1355: 1288: 1239: 1169: 1162: 1074: 869: 805: 655: 588: 581: 362: 355: 122: 115: 108: 2043:
Performers who have performed <a specific work: -->
1604:
Potential 2008 Republican U.S. Presidential Candidates
1569:, as the latter may be a defining characteristic (see 2037:
Performers who have portrayed <character name: -->
2256:
Performers who have performed on <production: -->
1965:", etc.); some method of performance (such as while 2650: 2604: 2578: 2522: 2461: 2253:Performers who have performed at <location: --> 1937:Saxophonists who are capable of circular breathing 1193:American people of Hungarian descent by occupation 1115:a large category into subcategories, for example, 2642:WikiProject Plants/Description in year categories 2596:Categories for discussion/All current discussions 2355:which have been portrayed by a specific performer 2351:which have been portrayed by a specific performer 2332:Fictional characters portrayed by Christopher Lee 2328:Fictional characters portrayed by Peter Dinklage 2347:who have been portrayed by a specific performer 1839:Category:National Basketball Association venues 821:Locations with per capita incomes over $ 30,000 698:Adjectives which imply a subjective, vague, or 397: 74:This page documents an English Knowledge (XXG) 2622:Categorising fictional characters by attribute 1847:#Performers by production or performance venue 2441: 2220:Performers by production or performance venue 1673:characteristic for the large majority of its 1507:By opinion or preference of an issue or topic 846:by size". Note that Knowledge (XXG) allows a 834:as cutoff points in these cases. Likewise, a 448:, ...". If such examples are common, each of 320: 8: 30:"WP:OC" redirects here. For other uses, see 2479:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 1251:People of the Moravian Church miscellaneous 957:categories with very few members (see also 82:Editors should generally follow it, though 2448: 2434: 2426: 2075:), and also non-human characters (such as 1456:People associated with the hippie movement 1402:might be a possible alternative solution. 327: 313: 188: 2663:DexDor/Categorization of award recipients 2364:and historical/mythological figures like 2022:Actors who played HIV-positive characters 373:Knowledge (XXG):Categorization § Defining 184:Knowledge (XXG):Categories for discussion 1998:Actors that portrayed heroes or villains 154:For broader coverage of this topic, see 2696:Category:Knowledge (XXG) categorization 2376: 1499:Category:Obama administration personnel 1393:Category:Jackson family (show business) 1332:It might also be appropriate to create 290: 267: 245: 198: 191: 2627:Do not write articles using categories 2612:Categories are different from articles 2324:Characters Portrayed by Leslie Nielsen 2189:), even if the "voice" in question is 1694:the list meets the notability criteria 1611:Knowledge (XXG) is not a crystal ball. 171:intersection of two or more such facts 2416:Knowledge (XXG):Category intersection 2018:Actors who have played gay characters 2014:Actors who have played serial killers 1821:Democratic National Convention venues 1815:Republican National Convention venues 179:is also known as "category clutter". 7: 2301: 2127:Performing a specific work (such as 1658:Category:Honorary citizens of Berlin 1342:Unrelated subjects with shared names 512:is often the preferred alternative. 2320:Characters portrayed by Johnny Depp 2151:Why did the chicken cross the road? 2102:. (This does not currently include 1744:Rolling Stone's 500 Greatest Albums 1446:People associated with Pope Pius XI 1030:Category:People of the Tudor period 909:Films set in the 10th millennium BC 856:Intersection by year or time period 726:), any reference to relative size ( 456:may be deemed to be "defining" for 2727:Knowledge (XXG) editing guidelines 2514:Overcategorization/User categories 2489:Categorizing articles about people 2231:Saturday Night Live musical guests 2212:with professionally. For example, 1925:Actresses who have appeared veiled 1918:Performers by action or appearance 1558:the person by other people (e.g. " 1464:Places associated with The Beatles 1460:Films associated with Generation X 1440:People associated with John McCain 1380:Avoid categorizing by a subject's 1117:Category:American writers by state 90:. When in doubt, discuss first on 25: 2683:Kbdank71/Wikiproject notification 2565:Template index/Category namespace 2560:Category classification templates 2294:Category:Star Trek script writers 2065:characters based upon real people 2030:Actors who have played Doctor Who 2006:Actresses who portrayed Lois Lane 1987:Performers by role or composition 1579:Potential candidates and nominees 1275:Mostly overlapping or duplicative 942:) is not generally considered an 893:20th-century American politicians 393:by their defining characteristics 27:Knowledge (XXG) editing guideline 2591:Categories for discussion/Speedy 2309:Role or composition by performer 2239:Celebrity Poker Showdown players 2067:from history or legend (such as 1841:) may sometimes be appropriate. 1652:Category:MTV Movie Award winners 138: 66: 2668:Alan Liefting/On categorisation 2209: 1765: 1554:), and opinions or allegations 1482: 2732:Knowledge (XXG) categorization 2456:Knowledge (XXG) categorization 1933:Musicians who play left-handed 1487: 1452:People associated with Madonna 1371:Churches named for St. Dunstan 1308:German expatriates in Tanzania 1257:Brass bands of other countries 1219:, should generally be avoided. 1098:Male models from Dallas, Texas 1086:Roman Catholic bishops of Ohio 943: 901:1971 National League All-Stars 885:Knowledge (XXG):People by year 634:unreleased or unpublished work 156:Knowledge (XXG):Categorization 1: 2678:gracefool/What is a category? 2658:DexDor/Terminology categories 2316:Fictional characters by actor 1909:This includes categorizing a 1670: 1473:The problem with saying that 1124: 1024:Category:19th-century writers 1016:Category:20th-century writers 1004: 946:division for categorization. 642:Subjective inclusion criteria 636:at the time of their death. 2499:Categorization/Sorting names 2350:<Types of characters: --> 2227:Artists who played Coachella 2133:, "Waltz of the swans" from 989: 921:(or group of years, such as 792:Arbitrary inclusion criteria 342:Non-defining characteristics 1092:Quarterbacks from Louisiana 958: 2748: 1859: 1787: 1715: 1630: 1607:(deleted in November 2006) 1582: 1538:Iraq liberation opposition 1510: 1411: 1345: 1278: 1229: 1185:Roads in Ukraine by Oblast 1152: 1064: 984:Similarly, If two or more 949:However, avoid creating a 882: 859: 795: 645: 571: 465:lead section of an article 370: 345: 153: 98: 92:this guideline's talk page 47: 36: 29: 2691: 2586:Categories for discussion 2340:Films starring Jim Carrey 1856:Performers by performance 1312:Crime history nominations 1136:place of a person's birth 848:table to be made sortable 556:categories for discussion 238:Perennial deletion review 2282:The Phantom of the Opera 1994:American dramatic actors 1408:By being associated with 1226:Miscellaneous categories 1061:Intersection by location 988:categories have a large 527:Medically-skilled people 385:Knowledge (XXG):Defining 146:This page in a nutshell: 2617:Categories versus lists 1181:Sportsmen from Brisbane 1045:the top of the category 825:Category:100th episodes 704:subjective descriptions 568:Trivial characteristics 554:In disputed cases, the 2706:WikiProject Categories 2535:Basic help for editors 2530:Basic help for readers 2504:Categorizing redirects 2418:– one of several open 2264:The Jack Benny Program 2051:Portraying a specific 1967:standing on their head 1481:, is that it can be a 1189:Triathletes from Leeds 905:1852 religious leaders 750:), or personal trait ( 742:), relative distance ( 700:inherently non-neutral 418: 32:WP:OC (disambiguation) 18:Knowledge (XXG):NONDEF 1832:Madison Square Garden 1495:Category:Obama family 1477:is "associated" with 1304:Climate change denial 681:Outstanding Canadians 228:Common outcomes (TfD) 223:Common outcomes (RfD) 218:Common outcomes (AfD) 2673:Coder Dan/Categories 2555:Categorizing portals 2550:Container categories 2411:Help:Sortable tables 2165:characters, both in 2002:Jim Steinman artists 1217:category A, B, and C 1103:Categorizing by the 998:religious leadership 675:Mysterious musicians 544:Fiction about robots 292:Proposals and policy 278:Guide to arbitration 269:Arbitration (Arbcom) 250:Bureaucratship (RfB) 2605:Projectspace essays 2346:<Characters: --> 2157:This also includes 1884:pornographic actors 1809:WrestleMania venues 1684:, the existence of 1400:disambiguation page 1263:Uncategorised songs 1149:Narrow intersection 1105:geographic boundary 1051:is not the same as 301:Perennial proposals 248:Adminship (RfA) and 2484:Overcategorization 2290:Category:Star Trek 2235:Ozzfest performers 2193:or other specific 2153:" (a joke), etc.). 2141:To be or not to be 1571:Category:Activists 897:November 11 births 560:there is consensus 538:Fast-moving drones 260:Arguments to avoid 233:Overcategorisation 213:Arguments to avoid 176:overcategorization 2714: 2713: 2701:Category:Contents 1929:Anal porn actress 1760:, and other such 1429:WP:ASSOCIATEDWITH 1375:Fictional Misters 1367:Ice-named rappers 549:Robots in fiction 337: 336: 152: 151: 133: 132: 76:editing guideline 16:(Redirected from 2739: 2651:Userspace essays 2450: 2443: 2436: 2427: 2420:feature requests 2395: 2390: 2384: 2381: 2362:Woody Woodpecker 2302:#Venues by event 2247:Actors by series 2206:Steven Spielberg 2122:stock characters 1880:actors/actresses 1872: 1800: 1735: 1728: 1705: 1699: 1643: 1627:Award recipients 1595: 1523: 1431: 1424: 1358: 1291: 1242: 1210:category A and B 1172: 1165: 1077: 1007:characteristic. 872: 808: 687:Wars France lost 658: 656:WP:SUBJECTIVECAT 604:Red haired kings 600:Celebrity Gamers 591: 584: 407:reliable sources 365: 358: 329: 322: 315: 192:Common decisions 189: 142: 141: 135: 125: 118: 111: 70: 69: 63: 21: 2747: 2746: 2742: 2741: 2740: 2738: 2737: 2736: 2717: 2716: 2715: 2710: 2687: 2646: 2600: 2574: 2545:FAQ for editors 2540:FAQ for readers 2518: 2509:User categories 2457: 2454: 2403: 2398: 2391: 2387: 2382: 2378: 2374: 2343: 2311: 2306: 2250: 2222: 2204:musicians" or " 2090:, or doing an " 2081:Kermit the Frog 2034: 1989: 1940: 1920: 1876: 1875: 1868: 1864: 1858: 1851: 1824: 1804: 1803: 1796: 1792: 1786: 1784:Venues by event 1747: 1739: 1738: 1731: 1724: 1720: 1714: 1703: 1697: 1667: 1647: 1646: 1639: 1635: 1629: 1608: 1599: 1598: 1591: 1587: 1581: 1547: 1527: 1526: 1519: 1515: 1509: 1471: 1435: 1434: 1427: 1420: 1416: 1410: 1378: 1362: 1361: 1354: 1350: 1344: 1315: 1295: 1294: 1287: 1283: 1277: 1266: 1246: 1245: 1238: 1234: 1228: 1196: 1176: 1175: 1168: 1161: 1157: 1151: 1101: 1081: 1080: 1073: 1069: 1063: 1047:. For example, 1022:be included in 912: 887: 876: 875: 868: 864: 858: 850:by any column. 836:school district 828: 812: 811: 806:WP:ARBITRARYCAT 804: 800: 794: 696: 662: 661: 654: 650: 644: 619: 612:Famous redheads 595: 594: 587: 580: 576: 570: 375: 369: 368: 361: 354: 350: 344: 333: 252: 163: 139: 129: 128: 121: 114: 107: 103: 95: 67: 61: 46: 35: 28: 23: 22: 15: 12: 11: 5: 2745: 2743: 2735: 2734: 2729: 2719: 2718: 2712: 2711: 2709: 2708: 2703: 2698: 2692: 2689: 2688: 2686: 2685: 2680: 2675: 2670: 2665: 2660: 2654: 2652: 2648: 2647: 2645: 2644: 2639: 2634: 2629: 2624: 2619: 2614: 2608: 2606: 2602: 2601: 2599: 2598: 2593: 2588: 2582: 2580: 2576: 2575: 2573: 2572: 2567: 2562: 2557: 2552: 2547: 2542: 2537: 2532: 2526: 2524: 2520: 2519: 2517: 2516: 2511: 2506: 2501: 2496: 2494:People by year 2491: 2486: 2481: 2476: 2474:Category names 2471: 2469:Categorization 2465: 2463: 2459: 2458: 2455: 2453: 2452: 2445: 2438: 2430: 2424: 2423: 2413: 2407:m:Help:Sorting 2402: 2399: 2397: 2396: 2385: 2375: 2373: 2370: 2357: 2356: 2354:<Works: --> 2352: 2348: 2312: 2310: 2307: 2298: 2258: 2257: 2254: 2223: 2221: 2218: 2155: 2154: 2125: 2110: 2084: 2045: 2044: 2041: 2038: 1990: 1988: 1985: 1921: 1919: 1916: 1874: 1873: 1865: 1860: 1857: 1854: 1843: 1805: 1802: 1801: 1793: 1788: 1785: 1782: 1740: 1737: 1736: 1729: 1721: 1716: 1713: 1712:Published list 1710: 1648: 1645: 1644: 1636: 1631: 1628: 1625: 1600: 1597: 1596: 1588: 1583: 1580: 1577: 1562:criminals"). 1544:Star Trek fans 1528: 1525: 1524: 1516: 1511: 1508: 1505: 1479:something else 1436: 1433: 1432: 1425: 1417: 1412: 1409: 1406: 1363: 1360: 1359: 1351: 1346: 1343: 1340: 1300:Church History 1296: 1293: 1292: 1284: 1279: 1276: 1273: 1247: 1244: 1243: 1235: 1230: 1227: 1224: 1221: 1220: 1213: 1177: 1174: 1173: 1166: 1158: 1153: 1150: 1147: 1134:And while the 1082: 1079: 1078: 1070: 1065: 1062: 1059: 1034: 1033: 1026: 994:all-star games 953:of individual 939:historical era 889: 874: 873: 865: 860: 857: 854: 813: 810: 809: 801: 796: 793: 790: 663: 660: 659: 651: 646: 643: 640: 596: 593: 592: 585: 577: 572: 569: 566: 552: 551: 540: 529: 496:"definingness" 480: 479: 472: 461: 446:adjective noun 389: 388: 367: 366: 359: 356:WP:NONDEFINING 351: 346: 343: 340: 335: 334: 332: 331: 324: 317: 309: 306: 305: 304: 303: 295: 294: 288: 287: 286: 285: 280: 272: 271: 265: 264: 263: 262: 254: 253: 249: 246: 243: 242: 241: 240: 235: 230: 225: 220: 215: 207: 206: 196: 195: 193: 150: 149: 143: 131: 130: 127: 126: 119: 112: 104: 99: 96: 81: 80: 71: 26: 24: 14: 13: 10: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 2744: 2733: 2730: 2728: 2725: 2724: 2722: 2707: 2704: 2702: 2699: 2697: 2694: 2693: 2690: 2684: 2681: 2679: 2676: 2674: 2671: 2669: 2666: 2664: 2661: 2659: 2656: 2655: 2653: 2649: 2643: 2640: 2638: 2637:Wiki workflow 2635: 2633: 2630: 2628: 2625: 2623: 2620: 2618: 2615: 2613: 2610: 2609: 2607: 2603: 2597: 2594: 2592: 2589: 2587: 2584: 2583: 2581: 2577: 2571: 2568: 2566: 2563: 2561: 2558: 2556: 2553: 2551: 2548: 2546: 2543: 2541: 2538: 2536: 2533: 2531: 2528: 2527: 2525: 2521: 2515: 2512: 2510: 2507: 2505: 2502: 2500: 2497: 2495: 2492: 2490: 2487: 2485: 2482: 2480: 2477: 2475: 2472: 2470: 2467: 2466: 2464: 2460: 2451: 2446: 2444: 2439: 2437: 2432: 2431: 2428: 2421: 2417: 2414: 2412: 2408: 2405: 2404: 2400: 2394: 2389: 2386: 2380: 2377: 2371: 2369: 2367: 2363: 2353: 2349: 2345: 2344: 2342: 2341: 2337: 2336:Films by star 2333: 2329: 2325: 2321: 2317: 2308: 2305: 2303: 2297: 2295: 2291: 2286: 2284: 2283: 2278: 2277: 2272: 2271: 2266: 2265: 2255: 2252: 2251: 2249: 2248: 2244: 2240: 2236: 2232: 2228: 2219: 2217: 2215: 2211: 2207: 2203: 2202:George Martin 2198: 2196: 2195:sound effects 2192: 2191:animal sounds 2188: 2184: 2180: 2176: 2172: 2168: 2164: 2160: 2152: 2149:(the play), " 2148: 2147: 2142: 2138: 2137: 2132: 2131: 2130:Amazing Grace 2126: 2123: 2119: 2115: 2111: 2108: 2105: 2101: 2097: 2093: 2089: 2088:impersonating 2085: 2082: 2078: 2074: 2070: 2066: 2063:), including 2062: 2058: 2054: 2050: 2049: 2048: 2042: 2039: 2036: 2035: 2033: 2031: 2027: 2023: 2019: 2015: 2011: 2010:Batman actors 2007: 2003: 1999: 1995: 1986: 1984: 1982: 1980: 1976: 1972: 1968: 1964: 1960: 1956: 1952: 1949: 1945: 1939: 1938: 1934: 1930: 1926: 1917: 1915: 1912: 1907: 1905: 1901: 1897: 1893: 1889: 1885: 1881: 1871: 1867: 1866: 1863: 1855: 1853: 1850: 1848: 1842: 1840: 1835: 1833: 1828: 1823: 1822: 1817: 1816: 1811: 1810: 1799: 1795: 1794: 1791: 1783: 1781: 1779: 1777: 1773: 1772: 1767: 1763: 1759: 1755: 1751: 1746: 1745: 1734: 1730: 1727: 1723: 1722: 1719: 1711: 1709: 1707: 1702: 1695: 1691: 1687: 1683: 1678: 1676: 1672: 1666: 1665: 1660: 1659: 1654: 1653: 1642: 1638: 1637: 1634: 1626: 1624: 1622: 1620: 1616: 1612: 1606: 1605: 1594: 1590: 1589: 1586: 1578: 1576: 1574: 1572: 1568: 1563: 1561: 1557: 1553: 1546: 1545: 1540: 1539: 1534: 1533: 1522: 1521:WP:OPINIONCAT 1518: 1517: 1514: 1506: 1504: 1502: 1500: 1496: 1491: 1489: 1484: 1480: 1476: 1470: 1469: 1465: 1461: 1457: 1453: 1448: 1447: 1442: 1441: 1430: 1426: 1423: 1419: 1418: 1415: 1407: 1405: 1403: 1401: 1396: 1394: 1390: 1385: 1383: 1377: 1376: 1372: 1368: 1357: 1356:WP:SHAREDNAME 1353: 1352: 1349: 1341: 1339: 1337: 1335: 1330: 1328: 1324: 1320: 1314: 1313: 1309: 1305: 1301: 1290: 1289:WP:OVERLAPCAT 1286: 1285: 1282: 1274: 1272: 1270: 1265: 1264: 1259: 1258: 1253: 1252: 1241: 1237: 1236: 1233: 1225: 1223: 1218: 1214: 1211: 1207: 1206: 1205: 1202: 1195: 1194: 1190: 1186: 1182: 1171: 1167: 1164: 1160: 1159: 1156: 1148: 1146: 1144: 1141: 1137: 1132: 1130: 1126: 1120: 1118: 1114: 1110: 1106: 1100: 1099: 1094: 1093: 1088: 1087: 1076: 1075:WP:OCLOCATION 1072: 1071: 1068: 1060: 1058: 1056: 1054: 1050: 1046: 1041: 1039: 1031: 1027: 1025: 1021: 1017: 1013: 1012: 1011: 1010:For example: 1008: 1006: 1001: 999: 996:, or because 995: 991: 987: 982: 980: 976: 972: 968: 964: 960: 956: 952: 951:category tree 947: 945: 941: 940: 934: 933: 927: 926: 920: 919: 914:Categorizing 911: 910: 906: 902: 898: 894: 888: 886: 880: 879: 871: 867: 866: 863: 855: 853: 851: 849: 845: 841: 837: 833: 832:100th episode 827: 826: 822: 818: 807: 803: 802: 799: 791: 789: 787: 785: 781: 777: 773: 769: 765: 761: 757: 753: 749: 745: 741: 737: 733: 729: 725: 721: 717: 713: 709: 705: 701: 695: 694: 693:Racist people 689: 688: 683: 682: 677: 676: 672: 668: 657: 653: 652: 649: 641: 639: 637: 635: 630: 628: 622: 618: 617: 616:Deaths by age 613: 609: 605: 601: 590: 586: 583: 582:WP:TRIVIALCAT 579: 578: 575: 567: 565: 563: 561: 557: 550: 546: 545: 541: 539: 535: 534: 530: 528: 524: 523: 519: 518: 517: 513: 511: 506: 501: 497: 493: 492: 491:verifiability 487: 486: 477: 473: 470: 466: 462: 459: 455: 451: 447: 443: 439: 438: 435: 430: 429: 424: 423: 422: 417: 415: 411: 408: 404: 403: 396: 394: 387: 386: 382: 377: 376: 374: 364: 360: 357: 353: 352: 349: 341: 339: 330: 325: 323: 318: 316: 311: 310: 308: 307: 302: 299: 298: 297: 296: 293: 289: 284: 281: 279: 276: 275: 274: 273: 270: 266: 261: 258: 257: 256: 255: 251: 244: 239: 236: 234: 231: 229: 226: 224: 221: 219: 216: 214: 211: 210: 209: 208: 205: 203: 197: 194:and arguments 190: 187: 185: 180: 178: 177: 172: 169:fact (or the 168: 161: 157: 147: 144: 137: 136: 124: 120: 117: 113: 110: 106: 105: 102: 97: 93: 89: 85: 79: 77: 72: 65: 64: 59: 55: 51: 44: 40: 33: 19: 2483: 2393:Per this RfC 2388: 2379: 2358: 2314: 2299: 2287: 2280: 2274: 2268: 2262: 2259: 2225: 2199: 2156: 2144: 2134: 2128: 2107:tribute acts 2086:Portraying, 2046: 1992: 1983: 1941: 1923: 1908: 1877: 1852: 1844: 1836: 1829: 1825: 1819: 1813: 1807: 1780: 1769: 1762:publications 1748: 1742: 1708: 1679: 1668: 1662: 1656: 1650: 1623: 1609: 1602: 1575: 1564: 1555: 1548: 1542: 1536: 1530: 1503: 1492: 1478: 1474: 1472: 1450: 1444: 1438: 1404: 1397: 1386: 1381: 1379: 1365: 1338: 1331: 1316: 1298: 1271: 1267: 1261: 1255: 1249: 1222: 1216: 1209: 1197: 1179: 1163:WP:NARROWCAT 1145: 1133: 1121: 1102: 1096: 1090: 1084: 1057: 1052: 1048: 1042: 1035: 1019: 1009: 1002: 985: 983: 978: 974: 966: 962: 954: 948: 936: 929: 922: 915: 913: 891: 881: 878: 877: 852: 843: 829: 815: 788: 783: 779: 775: 771: 767: 763: 759: 755: 751: 747: 743: 739: 735: 731: 727: 723: 719: 715: 711: 707: 697: 691: 685: 679: 667:Obese people 665: 638: 631: 623: 620: 598: 589:WP:OCTRIVIAL 564: 553: 548: 542: 537: 531: 526: 520: 514: 505:Definingness 504: 499: 495: 489: 483: 481: 475: 468: 457: 453: 449: 445: 441: 432: 426: 421:be helpful: 419: 414:consistently 413: 409: 400: 398: 390: 378: 338: 232: 201: 181: 174: 164: 145: 73: 2579:Discussions 2210:#ASSOCIATED 2187:Donald Duck 2171:Darth Vader 2167:live-action 2118:stereotypes 2069:King Arthur 1971:left-handed 1959:sword fight 1882:(including 1827:locations. 1766:#SUBJECTIVE 1552:green beans 1483:#SUBJECTIVE 1297:Examples: 1170:WP:OCNARROW 1127:and rarely 977:categories 969:. And then 772:intelligent 671:Cult actors 608:Bald People 547:instead of 536:instead of 533:Quadcopters 525:instead of 371:Main page: 39:COM:OVERCAT 2721:Categories 2523:Help pages 2462:Guidelines 2313:Examples: 2224:Examples: 2183:Bugs Bunny 2114:archetypes 2100:politician 2092:impression 2073:Steve Jobs 1991:Examples: 1922:Examples: 1911:production 1870:WP:PERFCAT 1798:WP:OCVENUE 1706:template. 1690:categories 1641:WP:OCAWARD 1615:short list 1532:Cat lovers 1488:#ARBITRARY 1437:Examples: 1422:WP:OCASSOC 1364:Examples: 1327:skepticism 1248:Examples: 1083:Examples: 944:#ARBITRARY 935:, or even 890:Examples: 883:See also: 814:Examples: 664:Examples: 597:Examples: 522:Physicians 500:Notability 485:notability 379:See also: 283:Principles 200:Deletion ( 167:verifiable 109:WP:OVERCAT 84:exceptions 58:WP:USERCAT 2300:See also 2276:Star Wars 2214:Tom Hanks 2181:(such as 2179:animation 2169:(such as 2136:Swan Lake 2096:celebrity 2055:(such as 2053:character 1955:spit take 1944:pirouette 1888:comedians 1845:See also 1806:Example: 1771:Billboard 1754:magazines 1741:Example: 1733:WP:OCLIST 1726:WP:TOPTEN 1718:Shortcuts 1671:#DEFINING 1649:Example: 1601:Example: 1593:WP:CANCAT 1529:Example: 1475:something 1414:Shortcuts 1240:WP:OCMISC 1201:diffusion 1178:Example: 1155:Shortcuts 1005:#DEFINING 975:by decade 967:by decade 870:WP:OCYEAR 752:beautiful 724:important 574:Shortcuts 478:defining. 471:defining; 450:adjective 440:..." or " 434:adjective 363:WP:NONDEF 348:Shortcuts 101:Shortcuts 88:consensus 54:WP:OCEPON 50:WP:OCEGRS 43:WP:SUBCAT 2401:See also 2366:Hercules 2177:) or in 2175:Ultraman 2094:" of, a 1981:, etc.) 1963:anal sex 1906:, etc. 1862:Shortcut 1790:Shortcut 1758:websites 1701:Cat main 1633:Shortcut 1585:Shortcut 1567:activist 1513:Shortcut 1348:Shortcut 1325:", and " 1281:Shortcut 1232:Shortcut 1125:defining 1067:Shortcut 990:#OVERLAP 965:, group 862:Shortcut 844:(region) 798:Shortcut 760:friendly 648:Shortcut 410:commonly 402:defining 2570:PetScan 2270:M*A*S*H 2163:dubbing 2159:voicing 2143:" from 2104:notable 1904:singers 1900:orators 1892:dancers 1675:notable 1560:alleged 1389:Jackson 1129:notable 1113:diffuse 986:by year 979:by year 971:diffuse 963:by year 959:#NARROW 955:by year 932:century 716:notable 712:popular 627:trivial 458:subject 442:Subject 428:Subject 116:WP:OCAT 41:), see 2245:, and 2146:Hamlet 2120:, and 2077:Lassie 2061:Batman 2057:Hamlet 2028:, and 1979:veiled 1957:", a " 1953:", a " 1948:runway 1946:", a " 1896:models 1323:denial 1109:polity 925:decade 768:honest 764:greedy 708:famous 494:, and 431:is an 56:, and 2372:Notes 2279:, or 1750:Books 1686:lists 1619:Lists 1556:about 1334:lists 1319:crime 1107:of a 784:young 740:short 732:small 728:large 720:great 444:, an 123:WP:OC 2409:and 1975:bald 1961:", " 1951:walk 1688:and 1680:Per 1382:name 1140:list 1038:here 973:the 918:year 840:list 780:ugly 756:evil 744:near 736:tall 510:list 454:noun 452:and 437:noun 412:and 399:The 383:and 158:and 2296:). 2285:). 2233:, 2185:or 2173:or 2161:or 2139:, " 2098:or 2079:or 2071:or 2059:or 1886:), 1573:). 1497:or 1490:. 1131:. 1040:.) 1020:not 937:by 930:by 923:by 916:by 786:). 776:old 748:far 476:not 469:not 204:fD) 2723:: 2338:, 2334:, 2330:, 2326:, 2322:, 2318:, 2273:, 2267:, 2241:, 2237:, 2229:, 2197:. 2116:, 2109:.) 2024:, 2020:, 2016:, 2012:, 2008:, 2004:, 2000:, 1996:, 1977:, 1969:, 1935:, 1931:, 1927:, 1902:, 1898:, 1894:, 1890:, 1818:, 1812:, 1778:. 1756:, 1752:, 1704:}} 1698:{{ 1661:, 1655:, 1541:, 1535:, 1501:. 1466:, 1462:, 1458:, 1454:, 1449:, 1443:, 1395:. 1373:, 1369:, 1310:, 1306:, 1302:, 1260:, 1254:, 1191:, 1187:, 1183:, 1119:. 1095:, 1089:, 1055:. 928:, 907:, 903:, 899:, 895:, 823:, 819:, 782:, 778:, 774:, 770:, 766:, 762:, 758:, 754:, 746:, 738:, 734:, 730:, 722:, 718:, 714:, 710:, 690:, 684:, 678:, 673:, 669:, 614:, 610:, 606:, 602:, 498:. 488:, 52:, 2449:e 2442:t 2435:v 2304:. 2124:. 2083:) 2032:. 1849:. 706:( 460:. 395:: 328:e 321:t 314:v 202:X 162:. 94:. 78:. 60:. 45:. 34:. 20:)

Index

Knowledge (XXG):NONDEF
WP:OC (disambiguation)
COM:OVERCAT
WP:SUBCAT
WP:OCEGRS
WP:OCEPON
WP:USERCAT
editing guideline
exceptions
consensus
this guideline's talk page
Shortcuts
WP:OVERCAT
WP:OCAT
WP:OC
Knowledge (XXG):Categorization
Knowledge (XXG):What Knowledge (XXG) is not § Non-encyclopedic cross-categorizations
verifiable
intersection of two or more such facts
overcategorization
Knowledge (XXG):Categories for discussion
Deletion (XfD)
Arguments to avoid
Common outcomes (AfD)
Common outcomes (RfD)
Common outcomes (TfD)
Overcategorisation
Perennial deletion review
Adminship (RfA) and
Bureaucratship (RfB)

Arguments to avoid

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.

↑