73:
93:
787:
137:
53:
83:
683:
ArbCom members (i.e., those at the beginning of the queue) would take on the next case. Arbitrators would be able to move themselves to the back of the queue at any time. This would lower the workload of each individual
Arbitrator, and also lower burnout, supporters say. The different ArbComs that hear each case, though, open the system up for inconsistency, critics counter.
103:
722:(RfC) avenues more heavily in dispute resolution. In fact, some have suggested simply emphasizing the MedCom as more of a lower-tier body, but without binding powers. In addition, calls have been made to the AMA to provide more effective advocates that would help streamline the process and thus reduce the workload for the ArbCom. In addition, the idea of having
63:
652:
change argue that this would significantly lower the workload and stress for the ArbCom, as the lower body would resolve trivial disputes and rule on some matters that would not be appealed. In addition, supporters argue that the magistrates could be more easily replaced, as they would not occupy a seat as important as that on the ArbCom.
113:
655:
However, critics contend that having a lower-tier would indubitably introduce bias and unregularity into the dispute resolution system. They claim that nothing prevents disputants from appealing every case to the ArbCom; as a result, not only would the ArbCom have an increased workload from having to
651:
One of these proposals involves creating a lower branch in the "judicial system" — in other words, have a body under the ArbCom that would screen cases, with the ArbCom hearing all appeals. Various names for this lower body have been suggested, the most recent being "magistrates". Proponents of this
682:
Enlarging the number of
Arbitrators is also included in proposals that would change how cases are assigned. Supporters of these changes say that all the Arbitrators should be ranked in a queue. When an Arbitrator goes on break or becomes inactive, s/he goes to the back of the queue. The most active
686:
Yet another proposal also involves an enlarged ArbCom, but with a structure more similar to the two-tiered proposal involving magistrates and arbitrators. This proposal lets the ArbCom be divided into several pools randomly; one pool would initially hear a case. If the disputants wished to appeal,
678:
Another proposed reform requires increasing the number of
Arbitrators. The theory behind this proposal is that the larger the ArbCom, the less work each individual member has to do. In addition, proponents say that this would effectively lower burnout and also make resignations and departures less
679:
likely to significantly affect the current operations of the ArbCom. Critics, though, say that an enlarged pool of
Arbitrators will do nothing but increase bureaucracy, red tape, and inefficiency, while all Arbitrators will still have to review the same amount of material.
702:
votes for
Arbitrators, and each person succeeding would serve on the ArbCom. Critics, though, argue that this change would make ArbCom too much of a "popularity contest", and that there may be too large a pool of Arbitrators to effectively accomplish anything.
671:, while the Arbitrators would be elected by the community. Because magistrates could be appointed at any time, the number of people serving in the lower-tier "court" could be expanded according to the needs of the community at the current time. However,
687:
then the case would be heard by the full ArbCom. Though supporters maintain that this change would also reduce workload and lower burnout, the random assignment of a case to one pool also introduces inconsistencies in the system, critics say.
691:
729:
Throughout ArbCom's existence, there have been many calls for reform. As
Knowledge (XXG) approaches the December 2005 elections, additional proposals to make the system more effective will undoubtably be presented.
831:
753:
882:
851:
769:
856:
773:
660:
444:
204:
836:
757:
645:
600:
587:
574:
561:
548:
535:
509:
496:
483:
470:
457:
431:
405:
360:
347:
334:
321:
308:
295:
269:
256:
243:
230:
217:
191:
165:
841:
761:
39:
826:
821:
749:
745:
625:
418:
392:
178:
152:
846:
811:
765:
737:
798:
967:
56:
21:
943:
938:
933:
804:
928:
694:
involves a theoretically limitless number of
Arbitrators. Instead of having elections or appointments for a set number of Arbitrators,
923:
786:
17:
706:
Despite the majority of calls for reform centering on the ArbCom, there have also been proposals for involving the rest of the
707:
641:
675:
commented, "To be honest, this looks like an attempt to force a role for Jimbo into an area where he isn't really needed."
906:
949:
640:, there have been calls for reform and many proposed changes not only to the ArbCom, but to the entire
637:
66:
878:
664:
86:
668:
723:
719:
715:
699:
96:
126:
711:
116:
601:
Introduction to a special series: A look at the upcoming
Arbitration Committee elections
361:
Introduction to a special series: A look at the upcoming
Arbitration Committee elections
648:, various proposals and reforms have been suggested since the ArbCom began operation.
961:
667:
builds on those ideas. However, Snow proposes that magistrates would be appointed by
656:
review the lower court's ruling, but the process would be extended out ever further.
903:
695:
106:
726:
for content-related disputes and conduct-related disputes has also been proposed.
76:
672:
624:
Note: Due to the changes announced regarding the election procedure (see
419:
Arbitration
Committee elections continue; ArbCom member resigns
179:
Arbitration Committee elections continue; ArbCom member resigns
406:
Jimbo Wales appoints 11 arbitrators, increases committee size
166:
Jimbo Wales appoints 11 arbitrators, increases committee size
785:
135:
894:
887:
867:
632:
will examine the many proposed reforms for the ArbCom.
892:If your comment has not appeared here, you can try
902:I'm mentioned in the Signpost! I'm famous! Yay! –
523:A closer look: the calls for reform of the ArbCom
283:A closer look: the calls for reform of the ArbCom
34:A closer look: the calls for reform of the ArbCom
710:. Changes have been suggested to involve the
8:
968:Knowledge (XXG) Signpost archives 2005-10
588:The history of the Arbitration Committee
471:Jimbo starts new poll regarding election
348:The history of the Arbitration Committee
231:Jimbo starts new poll regarding election
18:Knowledge (XXG):Knowledge (XXG) Signpost
895:
871:
33:
536:A look back: the 2004 ArbCom elections
296:A look back: the 2004 ArbCom elections
638:Knowledge (XXG) Arbitration Committee
7:
393:A chat with the elected Arbitrators
153:A chat with the elected Arbitrators
606:
593:
580:
567:
554:
541:
528:
515:
502:
489:
476:
463:
450:
437:
424:
411:
398:
366:
353:
340:
327:
314:
301:
288:
275:
262:
249:
236:
223:
210:
197:
184:
171:
158:
28:
877:These comments are automatically
636:Ever since the beginnings of the
111:
101:
91:
81:
71:
61:
51:
918:: doing it for free since 2005.
716:Association of Member Advocates
522:
282:
888:add the page to your watchlist
510:ArbCom duties and requirements
270:ArbCom duties and requirements
1:
575:About the Arbitration process
484:Last chance to run for ArbCom
335:About the Arbitration process
244:Last chance to run for ArbCom
907:20:58, 2 November 2005 (UTC)
432:ArbCom candidates (part two)
192:ArbCom candidates (part two)
700:Requests for Adminship-like
984:
708:dispute resolution process
646:criticism of the committee
642:dispute resolution process
630:Knowledge (XXG) Signpost
832:Guardian rates articles
562:Criticism of the ArbCom
322:Criticism of the ArbCom
885:. To follow comments,
790:
549:Current ArbCom members
309:Current ArbCom members
140:
789:
497:ArbCom voting process
257:ArbCom voting process
139:
881:from this article's
720:Requests for Comment
852:Features and admins
770:Features and admins
712:Mediation Committee
872:Discuss this story
857:Arbitration report
791:
141:
896:purging the cache
777:
736:Also this week:
724:separate branches
644:. Along with the
628:), this week the
617:
616:
607:19 September 2005
594:26 September 2005
458:Straw poll closes
445:ArbCom candidates
367:19 September 2005
354:26 September 2005
218:Straw poll closes
205:ArbCom candidates
975:
952:
899:
897:
891:
870:
837:Tim Starling Day
809:
801:
794:
734:
698:proposed having
692:radical proposal
608:
595:
582:
569:
556:
543:
530:
517:
504:
503:14 November 2005
491:
490:28 November 2005
478:
465:
464:19 December 2005
452:
439:
426:
413:
400:
374:
373:
368:
355:
342:
329:
316:
303:
290:
277:
264:
263:14 November 2005
251:
250:28 November 2005
238:
225:
224:19 December 2005
212:
199:
186:
173:
160:
144:
143:Related articles
138:
129:
115:
114:
105:
104:
95:
94:
85:
84:
75:
74:
65:
64:
55:
54:
983:
982:
978:
977:
976:
974:
973:
972:
958:
957:
956:
955:
954:
953:
948:
946:
941:
936:
931:
926:
919:
911:
910:
901:
893:
886:
875:
874:
868:+ Add a comment
866:
862:
861:
860:
817:ArbCom election
802:
799:31 October 2005
797:
795:
792:
780:
779:
778:
742:ArbCom election
718:(AMA), and the
661:recent proposal
620:
619:
618:
613:
568:10 October 2005
555:17 October 2005
542:24 October 2005
529:31 October 2005
516:7 November 2005
477:5 December 2005
425:16 January 2006
412:23 January 2006
399:6 February 2006
328:10 October 2005
315:17 October 2005
302:24 October 2005
289:31 October 2005
276:7 November 2005
237:5 December 2005
185:16 January 2006
172:23 January 2006
159:6 February 2006
148:
147:
146:ArbCom election
142:
136:
131:
130:
124:
123:
122:
121:
112:
102:
92:
82:
72:
62:
52:
46:
43:
32:
31:ArbCom election
26:
25:
24:
12:
11:
5:
981:
979:
971:
970:
960:
959:
947:
942:
937:
932:
927:
922:
921:
920:
913:
912:
909:
876:
873:
865:
864:
863:
859:
854:
849:
844:
842:News and notes
839:
834:
829:
824:
819:
814:
808:
796:
784:
783:
782:
781:
766:Press coverage
762:News and notes
754:Expert ratings
733:
732:
626:previous story
621:
615:
614:
611:
610:
604:
598:
597:
591:
585:
584:
581:3 October 2005
578:
572:
571:
565:
559:
558:
552:
546:
545:
539:
533:
532:
526:
520:
519:
513:
507:
506:
500:
494:
493:
487:
481:
480:
474:
468:
467:
461:
455:
454:
451:2 January 2006
448:
442:
441:
438:9 January 2006
435:
429:
428:
422:
416:
415:
409:
403:
402:
396:
389:
386:
385:
377:
371:
370:
364:
358:
357:
351:
345:
344:
341:3 October 2005
338:
332:
331:
325:
319:
318:
312:
306:
305:
299:
293:
292:
286:
280:
279:
273:
267:
266:
260:
254:
253:
247:
241:
240:
234:
228:
227:
221:
215:
214:
211:2 January 2006
208:
202:
201:
198:9 January 2006
195:
189:
188:
182:
176:
175:
169:
163:
162:
156:
149:
145:
134:
133:
132:
120:
119:
109:
99:
89:
79:
69:
59:
48:
47:
44:
38:
37:
36:
35:
30:
29:
27:
15:
14:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
980:
969:
966:
965:
963:
951:
945:
940:
935:
930:
925:
917:
908:
905:
898:
889:
884:
880:
869:
858:
855:
853:
850:
848:
845:
843:
840:
838:
835:
833:
830:
828:
827:Image storage
825:
823:
822:ArbCom update
820:
818:
815:
813:
810:
806:
800:
793:In this issue
788:
776:
775:
771:
767:
763:
759:
755:
751:
747:
746:ArbCom update
743:
739:
731:
727:
725:
721:
717:
713:
709:
704:
701:
697:
693:
690:Finally, one
688:
684:
680:
676:
674:
670:
666:
662:
657:
653:
649:
647:
643:
639:
634:
633:
631:
627:
612:
609:
603:
602:
596:
590:
589:
583:
577:
576:
570:
564:
563:
557:
551:
550:
544:
538:
537:
531:
525:
524:
518:
512:
511:
505:
499:
498:
492:
486:
485:
479:
473:
472:
466:
460:
459:
453:
447:
446:
440:
434:
433:
427:
421:
420:
414:
408:
407:
401:
395:
394:
388:
387:
384:
383:
382:
381:More articles
376:
375:
372:
369:
363:
362:
356:
350:
349:
343:
337:
336:
330:
324:
323:
317:
311:
310:
304:
298:
297:
291:
285:
284:
278:
272:
271:
265:
259:
258:
252:
246:
245:
239:
233:
232:
226:
220:
219:
213:
207:
206:
200:
194:
193:
187:
181:
180:
174:
168:
167:
161:
155:
154:
128:
118:
110:
108:
100:
98:
90:
88:
80:
78:
70:
68:
60:
58:
50:
49:
41:
23:
19:
915:
816:
805:all comments
758:Starling Day
741:
735:
728:
705:
689:
685:
681:
677:
665:Michael Snow
658:
654:
650:
635:
629:
623:
622:
605:
599:
592:
586:
579:
573:
566:
560:
553:
547:
540:
534:
527:
521:
514:
508:
501:
495:
488:
482:
475:
469:
462:
456:
449:
443:
436:
430:
423:
417:
410:
404:
397:
391:
390:
380:
379:
378:
365:
359:
352:
346:
339:
333:
326:
320:
313:
307:
300:
294:
287:
281:
274:
268:
261:
255:
248:
242:
235:
229:
222:
216:
209:
203:
196:
190:
183:
177:
170:
164:
157:
151:
150:
57:PDF download
950:Suggestions
879:transcluded
847:In the news
812:China block
738:China block
669:Jimbo Wales
107:X (Twitter)
774:T.R.O.L.L.
714:(MedCom),
127:Flcelloguy
45:Share this
40:Contribute
22:2005-10-31
944:Subscribe
883:talk page
962:Category
939:Newsroom
934:Archives
916:Signpost
97:Facebook
87:LinkedIn
77:Mastodon
20: |
904:Quadell
696:Quadell
750:Images
117:Reddit
67:E-mail
929:About
16:<
924:Home
914:The
673:Geni
663:by
125:By
42:—
964::
772:—
768:—
764:—
760:—
756:—
752:—
748:—
744:—
740:—
659:A
900:.
890:.
807:)
803:(
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.