529:, Reagle observed that today the question was not so much "about the quality of Knowledge (XXG) - because I think it has improved, - but the significance of Knowledge (XXG)". Weinberger added: "You show any living person any biography written in any medium - newspaper story about them or whatever: That person will feel embarrassed and ashamed, and denounce it because they got it wrong, and they didn't mention this, or they spent too much time on that, or they maybe look fat ... There is no possibility of pleasing people with any biography short of their obituary."
626:: Craigslist and Knowledge (XXG) are both being sued by Russell Dan Smith of South Carolina for "openly promot child prostitution and the distribution of child pornography" by allowing it to be viewable on their sites within his home state. Smith is demanding $ 500 million from each; should he win, half the proceeds would go to Smith and half to the state of South Carolina. Smith says that he discovered such things on both sites unintentionally while searching the defendant sites for "valid non-pornographic purposes". (
1006:
rights are then outlined in the standard copyright law". The author of the novel chose to ignore CC BY-SA, and chose not to apply it to the work. In that case, it is then up to the authors of the
Knowledge (XXG) passages and the author in question to find an agreement that satisfies both parties (for example, relicensing the book), or the author has to remove those passages and cease distributing them in a manner that violates CC BY-SA. Copyleft licenses are "viral" because people
1035:...and an addition: Since this issue also touches fair-use and excerpting, that's actually a good example of people ignoring the license and letting the thing revert to standard copyright law. If you're just taking a small quote of text out of Knowledge (XXG), you're usually ignoring the CC license and exercising the fair-use power granted by the copyright law. Nobody is crying bloody murder over short, attributed Knowledge (XXG) quotes - and nobody should. --
760:
515:). Exley explained his role at the Foundation, insisting it was not that of a usual "community organizer" (which would imply a hierarchy between organizer and "organizees" and ignore the largely self-organizing nature of Knowledge (XXG)), but rather "to create an environment where community members can work full-time in a concerted way, in a way they are not able to as volunteers, on solving and researching community problems."
117:
107:
33:
127:
588:". Quoted by Rue89, Adrienne Alix, the president of the French Wikimedia chapter, commented that Houellebecq's use of Knowledge (XXG) articles did not present a clear legal issue (pointing to the brevity of the used passages, and questioning their originality), and doubting the conclusion that it would make the entire book pass into a Creative Commons license.
87:
137:
97:
461:
changes don't even make sense". The plagiarism appears to have extended to a subsequent paper by Said and others, where Deep
Climate sarcastically described a passage matching the Knowledge (XXG) article as a "return to the safe ground of Knowledge (XXG)" after criticizing the preceding paragraph for "rampant confusion" and bad English.
259:(XXG) users by surprise. Wales has never really been a shy spokesperson by any means, but 99% of the visitors to Knowledge (XXG) were probably like "Who the heck is this guy popping up on my screen, and why does he want my money?" It turns out that the appeal for funds was actually the result of a collaborative process of volunteers ...
258:
The
Wikimedia Foundation ... took a dramatic approach to their annual fundraising campaign. Just head over to any article on Knowledge (XXG) and you'll see a banner ad featuring the face of Jimmy Wales, the founder of Knowledge (XXG), and an appeal for funds. The banner ads have taken many Knowledge
731:
for having "the same lack of tolerance for corporate blather. 'At
Knowledge (XXG), the usability group has done focus studies,' Wales says. 'Most of what they came up with, I thought, was blindingly obvious.'" In what the magazine described as a "knock at one of Knowledge (XXG)'s biggest critics",
476:
that the report was never "intended to take intellectual credit for any aspect of paleoclimate reconstruction science or for any original research aspect of social network analysis", but that the authors had felt "some pressure" from the House committee to complete the report "faster than we might
1005:
I don't think the novel is automatically CC BY-SA, even when it would have included bits of
Knowledge (XXG). I can't remember the exact phrasing CC BY-SA uses, but GNU GPL (another copyleft license) basically has the statement "if you don't agree with the license, then you can ignore it, but your
460:
version. (The report had examined the social network of authors that had collaborated with one particular climate scientist, alleging the possibility of an old boy network.) Deep
Climate noted that while Wegman et al. appeared to have changed a few words from the Knowledge (XXG) original, "the
732:
Wales said: "When I go to speak at a university or high school, it's completely insane how excited the kids are about
Knowledge (XXG). I remember when I was in school, if they told us that the editor-in-chief of Encyclopaedia Britannica was coming, we would've probably just killed ourselves."
189:
In the second week after the fundraiser's official launch on
November 15, the graphic banners featuring Jimmy Wales (which had been proved to be most effective in testing) were still used in most of the ads, and continued to provoke amused and annoyed reactions in news and social media (cf.
335:
that
Knowledge (XXG) "needs a decent amount of cash to stay free", and called the appeal "a very genuine and valid call to action for donations", but commented that "Jimmy Wales really offered himself up for the internet’s endless humor with this latest marketing move", offering a few more
208:") asked: "Wales may be a founding father, but does he really deserve the Caribbean-island-dictator treatment? Apparently, his face has been scientifically proven to be an appealing fundraising icon, albeit against somewhat unimpressive competition." Pointing to
701:, the Myanmar Computer Professionals Association asked Burmese people to contribute 15 minutes to creating articles in that language, with the target of achieving 15,000 articles by next July. According to news reports, Knowledge (XXG)'s insistence on using
679:: Qwiki, a Californian start-up company, hopes to revolutionise the web experience by creating "information you can watch". The experience is the result of machine-generated one-minute videos derived from Knowledge (XXG) pages as well as other sources. (
389:
An academic investigation has found that some uncredited passages in an influential report for the U.S. Congress that questioned the validity of climate change research appear to have been plagiarised from
Knowledge (XXG) (including the articles
931:
Fetchy, there's a nice little blog article where it shows that the statistics for the Jimmy banner are a bit skewed. I'm currently looking for it, but I remember sending a link to James about it (I believe James put together the stats).
665:, which has recruited American universities including George Washington University, UC Berkeley, and Harvard, to offer courses that involve students in the process of improving Knowledge (XXG) articles on public policy. It cited
1062:
Regarding the Houellebecq controversy: that's certainly a bold claim! I'm not too wise on copyright law, but does Gallaire have anything even close to a valid claim on the licensig of teh book because it ripped Knowledge (XXG)?
688:
709:) may be just one reason for the low participation rate among the 20 million Burmese; other reasons cited were a dislike of Knowledge (XXG)'s open participation model and the lack of financial incentives to contribute. (
380:
against the mockery: "Make fun of Jimmy Wales' ubiquitous puss all you want ... but that doesn't diminish the effectiveness of the Knowledge (XXG) co-founder's ever-so-slightly narcissistic fundraising campaign."
804:
814:
799:
967:
However, it does not appear to contain all the testing results (only mentions tests conducted before the fundraiser started, and none testing personal appeals from community members). According to the
964:...and that page was already linked in the article (see "the Foundation's banner testing results" in the paragraph about AOL Urlesque), as well as in the Signpost background article linked at the top.
819:
845:
347:, and asked "is Jimmy Wales staring at you just creepy, or does it actually make people want to give more money to Knowledge (XXG)? Turns out the Staring Jimmy ads work", linking the Foundation's
809:
784:
73:
777:
747:
738:
552:
509:
232:
191:
175:
1096:
794:
269:
276:"why they need so much cash", rather inaccurately claiming that "only a slim 23 are actually on books" and that "travel expenses make up a large part of the operating expenses".
771:
52:
41:
411:
627:
559:(the book's publisher) announced it was "undertaking legal steps" against lawyer and blogger Florent Gallaire, who has linked to an unauthorized PDF version of the book on
673:) out of the 150+ articles actively being worked on by students in 14 courses at these universities. WMF hopes the number of courses will double for the spring semester.
279:
Numerous parodies of the banners continued to appear. Several media outlets reported a spoof of "the whole unintentionally hilarious Knowledge (XXG) donation thing" (
1148:
968:
307:
the "trolling": "if there ever was a self-serious banner that needed spoofing, it was Wales's". "Spreeblick" (one of the most widely read German blogs) posted a
21:
431:
1123:
887:
I'd just like to find out who came up with the idea of being able turn those banners off in preferences. I'd pat them on the back for a job well done. :)
1118:
1113:
585:
578:
358:) displays a Knowledge (XXG) fundraising banner featuring Jimmy Wales on every webpage accessed. It received further media coverage last week, with
308:
1108:
684:
194:). (The banners can be removed temporarily by clicking the "X" on the top right corner, and permanently, for logged-in users, via a gadget in the
182:
The annual Wikimedia fundraiser reached slightly more than $ 5.5 million in donations to the Foundation on November 28, according to the official
332:
724:
435:
980:
533:, Reagle highlighted that part of the conversation, and noted the apparent absence of comparative studies of biographies of living people.
439:
445:
224:
205:
1103:
1075:
759:
46:
32:
17:
427:
448:
in April on the Deep Climate blog, which called Knowledge (XXG) "the favourite source of scholars in a hurry", and has provided a
292:
919:
575:
567:-licensed text from Knowledge (XXG), it was legal to make the entire work available under the same license, by virtue of its
473:
238:), on historical predecessors of Knowledge (XXG), and issues such as notability and consensus decisions on Knowledge (XXG).
902:
1046:
1025:
304:
261:
363:
254:
979:
was tested several times on US readers, and performed well, although I can't find a page giving actual testing results (
637:
525:
might approve of Knowledge (XXG), were he alive today. Talking about Wikipedians' concerns about defamatory material in
374:
348:
273:
231:
drive!", and featuring a short interview with Joseph Reagle, author of the recent book "Good Faith Collaboration" (see
666:
370:
took a converse approach, promising to replace Jimmy Wales' photo with that of a kitten on each Knowledge (XXG) page.
216:
613:
469:
227:"), commenting that it is "expected to last two months. Think about that the next time you're sore about a two week
975:(as well as earlier comments by Philippe in the media, see last week's Signpost), a banner featuring the appeal by
1082:
1050:
1029:
995:
959:
941:
926:
896:
881:
611:
312:
607:
544:
377:
497:
449:
1129:
395:
367:
355:
209:
983:
seems to be intended to provide that kind of information, but it appears to be malfunctioning at the moment).
720:
419:
340:
972:
680:
1073:
955:
937:
220:
68:
Fundraising banners continue to provoke; plagiarism charges against congressional climate change report
914:
876:
530:
328:
698:
618:
616:
518:
268:
A posting on the blog of the "Critical Point of View" Knowledge (XXG) research initiative (see also
599:
359:
195:
603:
892:
581:
540:
423:
658:
311:, a sentence-by-sentence parody of the German translation of Jimmy Wales' appeal, complete with
867:"graphic banners featuring Jimmy Wales (which had been proved to be most effective in testing)"
183:
90:
1042:
1021:
1014:
by the license terms, to apply them in the derivative works. It doesn't work automatically. --
841:
556:
296:
120:
1065:
951:
933:
494:
385:
Report on climate change for the U.S. Congress plagiarised Knowledge (XXG) and other sources
201:
158:
526:
212:, Slate added that "now Wales has some more formidable competition from his own subjects."
100:
909:
870:
426:, a climate scientist, and to entries on Knowledge (XXG), that it constitutes plagiarism.
354:
As reported in the last "In the news", an unofficial browser extension for Google Chrome (
344:
130:
991:
976:
947:
490:
453:
391:
319:
has appeared on YouTube, with the artist questioning the need for donations: "Just get
246:
710:
1142:
888:
595:
415:
399:
1037:
1016:
655:
407:
324:
228:
110:
444:
At least in one case, the Knowledge (XXG) plagiarism allegations had already been
705:(as opposed to the preference of Myanmar internet users for the non-Unicode font
140:
150:
291:(Christopher Poole), linking to a picture of a kitten instead of an appeal (as
728:
560:
501:
403:
316:
280:
468:, Wegman, who is currently under investigation from George Mason University,
176:
November 15 launch, emphasis on banner optimization and community involvement
987:
641:
572:
154:
662:
725:
Knowledge (XXG) Founder's Advice to Brands: 'Make Stuff That Doesn't Suck'
645:
568:
564:
553:
Houellebecq defends himself against charges of Knowledge (XXG) plagiarism
300:
702:
563:, arguing in a legal analysis that because of the incorporation of the
522:
320:
697:: Responding to calls from WMF to boost the number of articles on the
723:
last week asked Jimbo Wales for insights on managing brands online ("
706:
505:
323:, Jimmy, you know? Like the rest of the Internet!" And every page on
452:
of a passage in the Wegman report with the Knowledge (XXG) article
594:: Last month, the Wikimedia Foundation's Chief Technology Officer
284:
241:
In the introduction to another, longer interview with Reagle (see
422:. It was found to have passages so similar to work by Professor
288:
366:
it might be added to public computers, like a college lab PC.
51:
251:
644:
undertook a very detailed analysis of the readership for the
758:
31:
517:
Reagle was asked various questions related to his book and
210:
other proposed banners featuring Knowledge (XXG) volunteers
586:
The latest Houellebecq pirated because of Knowledge (XXG)!
521:
from a recent talk at Berkman, such as if he thought that
506:
Good Faith Collaboration - The Culture of Knowledge (XXG)
412:
US House of Representatives energy and commerce committee
309:"personal appeal from Spreeblick founder Johnny Haeusler"
857:
850:
830:
670:
547:
that were adapted from three Knowledge (XXG) articles (
457:
313:
Haeusler photoshopped into one of the Wikimedia banners
638:'L.A. Law' Knowledge (XXG) page viewed 874 times today
336:
photoshopped images and sarcastic tweets as examples.
855:If your comment has not appeared here, you can try
500:the Wikimedia Foundation's Chief Community Officer
539:: The controversy about passages in French writer
174:full background report on the annual fundraiser: "
610:about Knowledge (XXG) and other topics. Video
504:and Joseph Reagle, author of the recent book "
331:featuring Jimmy Wales. The "Techerator" blog
8:
186:– about a third of the $ 16 million target.
981:wmf:Special:ContributionTrackingStatistics
1149:Knowledge (XXG) Signpost archives 2010-11
489:: On the podcast of Harvard University's
165:Fundraiser coverage and parodies continue
620:recordings have recently been published.
223:covered the fundraiser on November 25 ("
18:Knowledge (XXG):Knowledge (XXG) Signpost
858:
834:
606:" event, talking with Stuart Candy and
67:
225:The unpaid army behind Knowledge (XXG)
7:
903:meta:Fundraising 2010/Banner testing
555:) was reignited earlier this month.
343:one of the banners with the article
414:, and was written by statisticians
973:updates from the fundraising staff
946:Meh, can't seem to find it. Maybe
317:dance/rap version of Wales' appeal
53:
28:
1095:is written by editors like you –
840:These comments are automatically
418:, David Scott and Yasmin Said of
402:had been commissioned in 2006 by
905:. It was the definitive winner.
580:). A headline on the website of
537:Houellebecq copyleft controversy
450:detailed side-by-side comparison
206:His Wikiness requests your money
135:
125:
115:
105:
95:
85:
727:"), comparing him to Apple CEO
368:Another Google Chrome extension
327:is currently displaying one of
851:add the page to your watchlist
661:on the Wikimedia Foundation's
1:
996:11:50, 30 November 2010 (UTC)
960:08:11, 30 November 2010 (UTC)
942:05:56, 30 November 2010 (UTC)
927:01:43, 30 November 2010 (UTC)
897:00:31, 30 November 2010 (UTC)
882:21:07, 29 November 2010 (UTC)
1083:19:43, 5 December 2010 (UTC)
1051:21:33, 2 December 2010 (UTC)
1030:21:25, 2 December 2010 (UTC)
634:The Onion on page view stats
487:Exley and Reagle interviewed
410:, Republican members of the
375:Colorado Springs Independent
242:
669:as one active example (see
667:Food Quality Protection Act
1165:
184:Fundraiser Statistics page
545:La Carte et le territoire
472:against the allegations,
192:last week's "In the news"
663:Public Policy Initiative
652:Public policy initiative
636:: In an article titled "
624:Internet carrier lawsuit
396:Dansgaard-Oeschger event
287:by that site's founder,
245:), Harvard University's
1010:make note that they're
950:has logs or something.
699:Burmese Knowledge (XXG)
695:Burmese Knowledge (XXG)
689:San Francisco Chronicle
571:clause (as reported by
420:George Mason University
848:. To follow comments,
763:
677:WP pages in video form
349:banner testing results
339:AOL's "Urlesque" blog
329:several parody banners
36:
762:
640:", US satire website
598:was a speaker at the
458:12:21, 2 January 2006
398:) and textbooks. The
270:this week's interview
221:American Public Media
35:
844:from this article's
592:Danese Cooper speaks
378:defended the banners
969:banner history page
805:Features and admins
600:Long Now Foundation
373:A blogger from the
219:" radio program on
835:Discuss this story
815:Arbitration report
800:WikiProject report
764:
541:Michel Houellebecq
424:Raymond S. Bradley
42:← Back to Contents
37:
1080:
859:purging the cache
820:Technology report
604:Long Conversation
266:
265:
47:View Latest Issue
1156:
1132:
1081:
1072:
1068:
925:
922:
917:
912:
879:
873:
862:
860:
854:
833:
782:
774:
772:29 November 2010
767:
750:
742:
685:Business Insider
495:David Weinberger
470:defended himself
252:
161:
139:
138:
129:
128:
119:
118:
109:
108:
99:
98:
89:
88:
59:
57:
55:
54:29 November 2010
1164:
1163:
1159:
1158:
1157:
1155:
1154:
1153:
1139:
1138:
1137:
1136:
1135:
1134:
1133:
1128:
1126:
1121:
1116:
1111:
1106:
1099:
1089:
1088:
1078:
1071:
1066:
1059:
920:
915:
910:
906:
877:
871:
864:
856:
849:
838:
837:
831:+ Add a comment
829:
825:
824:
823:
810:Election report
775:
770:
768:
765:
754:
753:
751:"In the news" →
748:
745:
740:
483:
432:Daily Telegraph
387:
345:staring contest
167:
162:
148:
147:
146:
145:
136:
126:
116:
106:
96:
86:
80:
77:
66:
62:
60:
50:
49:
44:
38:
26:
25:
24:
12:
11:
5:
1162:
1160:
1152:
1151:
1141:
1140:
1127:
1122:
1117:
1112:
1107:
1102:
1101:
1100:
1091:
1090:
1087:
1086:
1085:
1076:
1058:
1055:
1054:
1053:
1003:
1002:
1001:
1000:
999:
998:
984:
965:
962:
944:
839:
836:
828:
827:
826:
822:
817:
812:
807:
802:
797:
792:
787:
785:News and notes
781:
769:
757:
756:
755:
746:
737:
736:
735:
734:
733:
714:
692:
674:
649:
631:
621:
608:Peter Schwartz
589:
534:
516:
491:Berkman Center
482:
479:
454:Social network
392:social network
386:
383:
356:available here
264:
263:
260:
256:
249:observed that
247:Berkman Center
172:The Signpost's
166:
163:
144:
143:
133:
123:
113:
103:
93:
82:
81:
78:
72:
71:
70:
69:
64:
63:
61:
58:
45:
40:
39:
30:
29:
27:
15:
14:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
1161:
1150:
1147:
1146:
1144:
1131:
1125:
1120:
1115:
1110:
1105:
1098:
1094:
1084:
1079:
1074:
1070:
1069:
1061:
1060:
1056:
1052:
1048:
1044:
1040:
1039:
1034:
1033:
1032:
1031:
1027:
1023:
1019:
1018:
1013:
1009:
997:
993:
989:
985:
982:
978:
974:
970:
966:
963:
961:
957:
953:
949:
945:
943:
939:
935:
930:
929:
928:
924:
923:
918:
913:
904:
900:
899:
898:
894:
890:
886:
885:
884:
883:
880:
874:
868:
861:
852:
847:
843:
832:
821:
818:
816:
813:
811:
808:
806:
803:
801:
798:
796:
793:
791:
788:
786:
783:
779:
773:
766:In this issue
761:
752:
744:
743:"In the news"
730:
726:
722:
718:
715:
712:
711:Myanmar Times
708:
704:
700:
696:
693:
690:
686:
682:
678:
675:
672:
668:
664:
660:
657:
653:
650:
647:
643:
639:
635:
632:
629:
625:
622:
619:
617:
614:
612:
609:
605:
601:
597:
596:Danese Cooper
593:
590:
587:
583:
579:
576:
574:
570:
566:
562:
558:
554:
550:
546:
543:'s new novel
542:
538:
535:
532:
528:
524:
520:
514:
512:
507:
503:
499:
496:
492:
488:
485:
484:
480:
478:
475:
471:
467:
462:
459:
455:
451:
447:
442:
441:
437:
433:
429:
425:
421:
417:
416:Edward Wegman
413:
409:
405:
401:
400:Wegman report
397:
393:
384:
382:
379:
376:
371:
369:
365:
361:
357:
352:
350:
346:
342:
337:
334:
330:
326:
322:
318:
314:
310:
306:
302:
298:
294:
290:
286:
282:
277:
275:
271:
257:
253:
250:
248:
244:
239:
237:
235:
230:
226:
222:
218:
213:
211:
207:
203:
199:
197:
193:
187:
185:
180:
179:
177:
171:
164:
160:
156:
152:
142:
134:
132:
124:
122:
114:
112:
104:
102:
94:
92:
84:
83:
75:
56:
48:
43:
34:
23:
19:
1093:The Signpost
1092:
1064:
1036:
1015:
1011:
1007:
1004:
907:
866:
865:
789:
778:all comments
721:Fast Company
717:Brand advice
716:
694:
676:
656:ReadWriteWeb
651:
633:
623:
591:
577:and Numerama
548:
536:
510:
486:
465:
463:
443:
408:Ed Whitfield
388:
372:
353:
338:
325:Uncyclopedia
278:
267:
240:
233:
229:public radio
214:
200:
188:
181:
173:
169:
168:
155:Tilman Bayer
1130:Suggestions
1067:bahamut0013
1008:consciously
971:and recent
952:Killiondude
934:Killiondude
872:Orange Mike
842:transcluded
790:In the news
681:Shiny Shiny
584:exclaimed "
531:On his blog
498:interviewed
217:Marketplace
196:preferences
159:Ohconfucius
65:In the news
1012:obligated,
901:Mike, see
729:Steve Jobs
615:and audio
561:RapidShare
557:Flammarion
551:coverage:
502:Zack Exley
436:Daily Mail
404:Joe Barton
364:suggesting
341:juxtaposed
281:TechCrunch
79:Share this
74:Contribute
22:2010-11-29
1124:Subscribe
986:Regards,
846:talk page
795:Interview
642:The Onion
628:Tech Dirt
573:Rue89.com
466:USA Today
456:, in its
428:USA Today
333:explained
305:applauded
170:See also
1143:Category
1119:Newsroom
1114:Archives
1097:join in!
1057:Copyleft
889:Rockfang
741:Previous
659:reported
648:article.
646:L.A. Law
569:copyleft
565:CC-BY-SA
549:Signpost
511:Signpost
360:PC World
303:blogger
301:Westword
297:Erictric
293:reported
234:Signpost
121:LinkedIn
101:Facebook
20: |
1038:wwwwolf
1017:wwwwolf
977:Kartika
703:Unicode
523:Diderot
481:Briefly
477:like".
474:stating
321:AdSense
111:Twitter
1047:growls
1026:growls
707:Zawgyi
519:slides
513:review
362:India
236:review
151:Lumos3
131:Reddit
91:E-mail
1109:About
1077:deeds
1043:barks
1022:barks
948:James
916:COMMS
911:ƒETCH
440:Salon
299:). A
285:4chan
283:) on
274:asked
243:below
215:The "
202:Slate
16:<
1104:Home
992:talk
988:HaeB
956:talk
938:talk
893:talk
878:Talk
749:Next
671:diff
602:'s "
527:BLPs
446:made
406:and
394:and
315:. A
289:m00t
157:and
141:Digg
875:|
582:RTL
508:" (
464:In
295:by
198:.)
149:By
76:—
1145::
1049:)
1028:)
994:)
958:)
940:)
895:)
869:--
739:←
719::
687:,
683:,
654::
493:,
438:,
434:,
430:,
351:.
272:)
262:”
255:“
204:("
153:,
1045:/
1041:(
1024:/
1020:(
990:(
954:(
936:(
921:/
908:/
891:(
863:.
853:.
780:)
776:(
713:)
691:)
630:)
178:"
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
