734:. When I realised that the "editorial tug of war that...caused the state of Taiwan to constantly blink in and out of existence over the course of a single day" was really a minor 11-minute affair, I was quite disappointed in the BBC. At the same time, they claim to have identified almost 1,600 contentious edits to 22 "politically sensitive" articles (though sadly they did not identify to which articles or language Knowledge (XXG) they belonged). The journal articles, the comments from the academics, and the statements from the Taiwanese community are all a cause for concern about a growing political trend in China and the desire for the government to tell its side of things. I think it's something we should be on the lookout for. -
344:. They write that "due to the influence by foreign media, Knowledge (XXG) entries have a large number of prejudiced words against the Chinese government". To rectify this, they say the Chinese "must develop a targeted external communication strategy, which includes cultivating influential editors on the wiki platform." They conclude with "China urgently needs to encourage and train Chinese netizens to become Knowledge (XXG) platform opinion leaders and administrators… can adhere to socialist values and form some core editorial teams."
249:, Wikimedia Taiwan board member Jamie Lin said that many incidents are not merely good faith differences of opinion, but instead "control by the Government". According to Lin, editors — not just content — are under pressure, "some have told us that their personal information has been sprayed , because they have different thoughts." On a Wikimedia Telegram channel, according to Lin, a person told a Taiwanese editor that "the policemen will enjoy your mother's forensic report".
110:
130:
186:
573:
90:
120:
36:
140:
439:" against the free flow of information has created a direct and effective blocking of voices from inside the wall. I cannot say for sure that the pro-China voices coming from inside China are cherry-picked. However, the firewall is so effective that most, other than those who are considered 'top dissidents', already have their voices shut out of the outside world."
100:
333:. Ding posits that "there is a lack of systematic ordering and maintenance of contents about China's major political discourse on Knowledge (XXG)" and says that it needs to "reflect our voices and opinions in the entry, so as to objectively and truly reflect the influence of Chinese path and Chinese thoughts on other countries and history".
701:
pro-China editing and most China-related disputes do not end in China's favour. Pro-China POV pushers certainly exist, just as from any major country, but they're usually quickly reverted and do not return. If China were truly serious about manipulating
Knowledge (XXG), I'd expect to see tons of new editors on top articles such as
150:
263:
ineffective in dealing with off-site harassment – the WMF really can't do anything. The working group manipulates on-site rules to silence whistleblowers and completely ruin how the project runs. This method is so effective that some working group editors practice it without even knowing that it violates civility at its root."
748:
I'd add that the concerns raised by BBC are not limited to the
English Knowledge (XXG). While the Chinese government may not have been so successful at POV pushing on enwiki, it doesn't mean their efforts are necessarily futile in other language versions, most notably the Chinese Knowledge (XXG). And
442:
Some
Knowledge (XXG) language versions have been blocked in China starting as early as 2004, but the Chinese Knowledge (XXG) was most affected. By April 2019, all Knowledge (XXG) versions were reported to be blocked. Mainland Chinese editors who wish to edit any version of Knowledge (XXG) can try to
385:
mention of "Republic of China" from the sentence, without an edit summary. Kusma reverted this, and the exchange happened once more before the article's lead was left in its original form, 11 minutes after the edit war started. The BBC characterized this as an "an editorial tug of war that – as far
306:
that the battle over
Knowledge (XXG) content comes at a time when China is showing an increasing desire to fix perceived misconceptions about it abroad, "'Telling China's story' is a concept that has gained huge traction over the past couple of years They think that a lot of the perceptions people
457:
s coverage according to the unnamed mainland editor. It "seems to target the
Chinese government, but anyone who reads it would apply these false statements to ordinary mainland Chinese Wikimedians in general and conclude that all mainland Chinese contributors are sent by the Chinese government."
262:
that Hong Kong editors have had similar experiences. "Direct attacks on well-known editors who do not align with a single point of view and shutting down resistance through off-site harassment. This is what some members of the
Mainland Chinese working group are doing. The Wikimedia Foundation is
700:
As probably the most active editor in
English Knowledge (XXG) on China-related topics, I have to say this TV program seems like yet another clueless media report about Knowledge (XXG). Throughout my decade of editing career on English Knowledge (XXG), I've yet to see any evidence of concerted
347:
The unnamed mainland editor quoted above says that "just two academic papers can't represent what China's propaganda department wants. Countless academic papers in China are aimed at foreign media, including the newswires, Twitter, and
Knowledge (XXG), with over 20 so far in October."
270:
that "the BBC's coverage is biased and was backed by
Wikimedia Taiwan, the anti-China chapter. The coverage just makes accusations, instead of trying to help solve the problem." The opinions of this editor are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of
831:
I do not understand how this the state's actions. I have many
Chinese friends in real life and online. This is a real position that they hold. So to sum it up to state-led action by the propaganda department is ridiculous.
652:
622:
647:
637:
627:
617:
602:
540:
76:
678:
314:"The idea of a unique "Chinese view" or "Chinese story" on Knowledge (XXG) would be as disastrous as making the Foundation a for-profit entity. It would ruin the reputation of the project."
597:
590:
612:
534:
231:
584:
560:
551:
55:
44:
632:
642:
321:
show that the Chinese government might be interested in altering content on Knowledge (XXG) to show itself in a more favorable light. In 2016, Jie Ding, an official at the
404:
to say that they are "China's inherent territory". The territorial status of the islands is currently disputed by Taiwan, the People's Republic of China, and Japan. The
237:"We cannot be sure who were behind the edits that we found, or why they were done ... there was nothing that directly tied these edits back to the Chinese government."
907:
773:
personal information other than an email address (optional) for an editor, it's not obvious how numerous editors would have their real-life identities exposed. --
21:
883:
855:
878:
873:
93:
868:
420:
identified "almost 1,600 tendentious edits across 22 politically sensitive articles" without specifying the Knowledge (XXG) language versions.
750:
386:
as the encyclopedia was concerned – caused the state of Taiwan to constantly blink in and out of existence over the course of a single day."
329:, published the paper "Analysis of the Feasibility of Using Knowledge (XXG) to Carry out the Dissemination of Chinese Political Discourse" in
769:
I found this puzzling: "some have told us that their personal information has been sprayed ...". Given that Knowledge (XXG) doesn't keep
322:
833:
412:
was altered to describe the event as "the June 4th incident" to "quell the counter-revolutionary riots". Meanwhile, the article for the
863:
572:
49:
35:
17:
205:
299:
431:
skipped very quickly over two of the fundamental conditions that the Chinese Knowledge (XXG) operates under. Editor 1233 told
409:
805:
Doxxing, especially when you realize those are previous event organizers, where their identity can be easily identified.--
287:
393:, this single-day event is part of a larger conflict over the politicization of Chinese content across both English and
290:, said, "I'm surprised it's taken this long actually is a prioritised source of facts and knowledge about the world."
374:
275:
He continued "Carl Miller interviewed Wikimedia Taiwan, anti-China scholars, but not Chinese Wikimedians themselves."
381:
reverted the change five minutes later. Xiaolifeidaohank quickly implemented the change again, and then subsequently
336:
This line of thought is shared by at least two Chinese academics. This year, Li-hao Gan and Bin-Ting Weng published "
817:
889:
779:
326:
841:
822:
800:
782:
762:
743:
718:
222:
strongly suggests that the Communist government of China is directly editing Knowledge (XXG) and perhaps even
837:
413:
739:
359:
793:
482:
215:
210:
775:
365:
the lead sentence of the Taiwan article from "Taiwan, officially the Republic of China (ROC), is a
758:
416:
has seen intense debate over whether to characterize the participants as protesters or rioters.
103:
674:
123:
735:
163:
133:
788:
714:
401:
398:
167:
189:
153:
337:
811:
436:
366:
30:
The BBC looks at Chinese government editing: But they aren't entirely sure they see it
901:
754:
338:
Opportunities And Challenges Of China's Foreign Communication in the Knowledge (XXG)
444:
283:
143:
405:
706:
478:
113:
725:
710:
702:
378:
806:
370:
230:. Widespread edit warring was also reported. However, as Miller notes in an
730:
I think there's an element of sensationalism to the story as reported by
266:
An editor from mainland China, who did not wish to be identified, told
227:
223:
54:
486:
282:
about possible Chinese government editing of Knowledge (XXG),
195:
571:
34:
254:
690:
683:
663:
382:
362:
208:
dropped a bombshell on mainland China in its October 5
377:." No explanation was provided in the edit summary.
307:
have of China abroad are really misunderstandings."
688:If your comment has not appeared here, you can try
479:"China and Taiwan clash over Knowledge (XXG) edits"
178:
325:, a global media corporation overseen by the
8:
787:I believe they just mean outing or doxxing.
394:
214:television program. The segment reported by
709:, etc., which is definitely not the case. -
71:The BBC looks at Chinese government editing
908:Knowledge (XXG) Signpost archives 2019-10
397:. This conflict includes a change to the
450:The use of proxies has had an effect on
354:checked a case of edit warring cited by
298:Lokman Tsui, Assistant Professor at the
18:Knowledge (XXG):Knowledge (XXG) Signpost
691:
667:
467:
70:
473:
471:
175:
516:
514:
512:
510:
508:
506:
504:
29:
7:
323:China International Publishing Group
753:, but that doesn't make it right.
524:were conducted during October 2019
402:article on Chinese Knowledge (XXG)
286:, Senior Lecturer in Media at the
56:
28:
673:These comments are automatically
749:yes, state-sponsored editing is
206:British Broadcasting Corporation
184:
148:
138:
128:
118:
108:
98:
88:
373:" to "Taiwan is a province in
300:Chinese University of Hong Kong
684:add the page to your watchlist
410:1989 Tiananmen Square protests
1:
842:04:31, 17 November 2019 (UTC)
288:University of New South Wales
823:10:16, 6 November 2019 (UTC)
801:05:25, 2 November 2019 (UTC)
783:04:28, 2 November 2019 (UTC)
763:12:18, 1 November 2019 (UTC)
744:00:39, 1 November 2019 (UTC)
719:23:49, 31 October 2019 (UTC)
331:International Communications
856:delivered to your talk page
358:. At 14:20 on September 11
924:
532:For related coverage, see:
375:People's Republic of China
342:Journal of Social Sciences
241:Incidents and accusations
183:
327:Communist Party of China
226:or harassing editors in
414:2019 Hong Kong protests
681:. To follow comments,
576:
424:Fundamental conditions
39:
575:
360:User:Xiaolifeidaohank
220:Knowledge (XXG) Wars?
191:Knowledge (XXG) Wars?
38:
751:not limited to China
677:from this article's
483:Click (TV programme)
435:that a "systematic "
317:Two papers cited by
278:When questioned by
252:Hong Kong resident
668:Discuss this story
653:On the bright side
623:Arbitration report
577:
520:All interviews by
395:Chinese Wikipedias
45:← Back to Contents
40:
821:
814:
692:purging the cache
648:News from the WMF
310:Editor 1233 told
294:The Chinese story
202:
201:
50:View Latest Issue
915:
892:
851:Want the latest
816:
809:
796:
778:
729:
695:
693:
687:
666:
595:
587:
580:
563:
555:
525:
518:
499:
498:
496:
494:
489:. 5 October 2019
475:
456:
257:
188:
187:
176:
170:
152:
151:
142:
141:
132:
131:
122:
121:
112:
111:
102:
101:
92:
91:
62:
60:
58:
923:
922:
918:
917:
916:
914:
913:
912:
898:
897:
896:
895:
894:
893:
888:
886:
881:
876:
871:
866:
859:
848:
847:
799:
794:
774:
723:
697:
689:
682:
671:
670:
664:+ Add a comment
662:
658:
657:
656:
638:Recent research
588:
585:31 October 2019
583:
581:
578:
567:
566:
561:
558:
553:
547:
546:
529:
528:
519:
502:
492:
490:
477:
476:
469:
454:
426:
406:Chinese article
399:Senkaku Islands
296:
253:
245:As reported by
243:
185:
179:External videos
172:
171:
161:
160:
159:
158:
149:
139:
129:
119:
109:
99:
89:
83:
80:
69:
65:
63:
57:31 October 2019
53:
52:
47:
41:
31:
26:
25:
24:
12:
11:
5:
921:
919:
911:
910:
900:
899:
887:
882:
877:
872:
867:
862:
861:
860:
850:
849:
846:
845:
844:
829:
828:
827:
826:
825:
791:
776:John Broughton
767:
766:
765:
746:
672:
669:
661:
660:
659:
655:
650:
645:
640:
635:
630:
628:Traffic report
625:
620:
618:Community view
615:
610:
605:
603:Special report
600:
594:
582:
570:
569:
568:
559:
550:
549:
548:
542:Community view
527:
526:
500:
466:
465:
425:
422:
295:
292:
242:
239:
200:
199:
181:
180:
174:
173:
157:
156:
146:
136:
126:
116:
106:
96:
85:
84:
81:
75:
74:
73:
72:
67:
66:
64:
61:
48:
43:
42:
33:
32:
27:
15:
14:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
920:
909:
906:
905:
903:
891:
885:
880:
875:
870:
865:
857:
854:
843:
839:
835:
834:50.126.105.22
830:
824:
819:
813:
808:
804:
803:
802:
797:
790:
786:
785:
784:
781:
777:
772:
768:
764:
760:
756:
752:
747:
745:
741:
737:
733:
727:
722:
721:
720:
716:
712:
708:
704:
699:
698:
694:
685:
680:
676:
665:
654:
651:
649:
646:
644:
641:
639:
636:
634:
631:
629:
626:
624:
621:
619:
616:
614:
611:
609:
606:
604:
601:
599:
596:
592:
586:
579:In this issue
574:
565:
557:
545:
544:
543:
538:
537:
533:
523:
517:
515:
513:
511:
509:
507:
505:
501:
488:
484:
480:
474:
472:
468:
464:
463:
459:
453:
448:
446:
443:edit through
440:
438:
434:
430:
423:
421:
419:
415:
411:
407:
403:
400:
396:
392:
389:According to
387:
384:
380:
376:
372:
368:
364:
361:
357:
353:
349:
345:
343:
339:
334:
332:
328:
324:
320:
315:
313:
308:
305:
301:
293:
291:
289:
285:
281:
276:
274:
273:The Signpost.
269:
264:
261:
258:confirmed to
256:
250:
248:
240:
238:
236:
235:
232:interview in
229:
225:
221:
217:
213:
212:
207:
197:
193:
192:
182:
177:
169:
165:
155:
147:
145:
137:
135:
127:
125:
117:
115:
107:
105:
97:
95:
87:
86:
78:
59:
51:
46:
37:
23:
19:
852:
770:
731:
607:
598:In the media
591:all comments
564:"In focus" →
541:
535:
531:
530:
522:The Signpost
521:
491:. Retrieved
461:
460:
451:
449:
441:
433:The Signpost
432:
428:
427:
417:
390:
388:
355:
352:The Signpost
351:
350:
346:
341:
335:
330:
318:
316:
312:The Signpost
311:
309:
303:
297:
284:Heather Ford
279:
277:
272:
268:The Signpost
267:
265:
260:The Signpost
259:
251:
246:
244:
234:The Signpost
233:
219:
209:
203:
190:
94:PDF download
890:Suggestions
858:each month?
736:Indy beetle
707:Jiang Zemin
675:transcluded
216:Carl Miller
164:Indy beetle
144:X (Twitter)
789:Smallbones
703:Xi Jinping
556:"In focus"
493:26 October
462:References
379:User:Kusma
168:Smallbones
82:Share this
77:Contribute
22:2019-10-31
884:Subscribe
795:smalltalk
679:talk page
613:Interview
536:Interview
371:East Asia
340:" in the
902:Category
879:Newsroom
874:Archives
853:Signpost
755:feminist
608:In focus
554:Previous
437:firewall
134:Facebook
124:LinkedIn
114:Mastodon
68:In focus
20: |
633:Gallery
445:proxies
383:removed
363:changed
302:, told
218:called
198:, 24:30
228:Taiwan
224:doxing
154:Reddit
104:E-mail
869:About
732:Click
726:Zanhe
711:Zanhe
643:Essay
452:Click
429:Click
418:Click
391:Click
367:state
356:Click
319:Click
304:Click
280:Click
247:Click
211:Click
16:<
864:Home
838:talk
807:1233
780:(♫♫)
759:talk
740:talk
715:talk
562:Next
539:and
495:2019
408:for
255:1233
204:The
166:and
771:any
487:BBC
485:at
369:in
196:BBC
162:By
79:—
904::
840:)
815:/
810:(
761:)
742:)
717:)
705:,
552:←
503:^
481:.
470:^
447:.
194:,
836:(
820:）
818:C
812:T
798:)
792:(
757:(
738:(
728::
724:@
713:(
696:.
686:.
593:)
589:(
497:.
455:'
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
