499:. It heard evidence from all those involved in the case, including Horace Avory and Sir Forrest Fulton. In its report, it concluded that Adolph Beck should not have been convicted due to the errors made by the prosecution. The committee also chastised Judge Fulton in his conduct of the case, as he should have given consideration to the 1877 case, more so because of his involvement with it, which served to prejudice the proceedings against Beck. Furthermore, it criticised the Home Office for its indifference in acting on the case despite knowing since 1898 that Beck and Smith were not the same man. Instead, it sought to preserve the credibility of the judiciary rather than admit or correct its mistakes. It also stated that the omission of the prison authorities to state the fact of Smith's circumcision in the records of 1877 and 1881 was the primary cause of the miscarriage of justice.
175:. He insisted upon providing her with an elegant wardrobe for the voyage, wrote out a list of items for her and made out a cheque for £40 to cover her purchases. Then he examined her wristwatch and rings, and asked her to let him have them so that he could match their sizes and replace them with more valuable pieces. After he left, she discovered that a second watch was missing. Suspicious, she hurried to the bank to cash the cheque, only to find that it was worthless. She had been swindled and she swore that it was Adolf Beck who had done it. He was promptly arrested.
34:
140:
202:. The felony charges were based on presumed prior convictions in 1877, when a man named John Smith had been sentenced to five years for swindling unattached women by using the name Lord Willoughby, writing worthless cheques and taking their jewellery. He had disappeared after his release, and it was assumed that Beck and Smith were one and the same. Descriptions of John Smith from prison files were never compared with the current appearance of Adolph Beck.
379:, Scott ran up to him and accused him of defrauding her of her jewellery. Beck was horrified and denied the charge. Scott repeated her accusations and told him that someone was waiting to arrest him. He ran away in panic, but was caught immediately by the waiting police inspector, who arrested him at once. Beck's panicked flight reinforced the inspector's assumption regarding his guilt.
400:
151:(or 139, according to at least one account) when a woman blocked his way. She accused him of having tricked her out of two watches and several rings. Beck brushed her aside and crossed the road. When the woman followed him, he complained to a policeman that he was being followed by a prostitute who had accosted him. The woman in turn demanded his arrest, accusing him of having
119:. He returned to England in 1885 and engaged in various financial schemes, including an investment in a copper mine in Norway. Unfortunately the mine did not turn a profit, and he poured in more and more money until he had to put the mine up for sale. There were no takers and he was reduced to near-poverty. He was chronically short of money, in debt to the hotel in
156:
Lady
Everton. She said that she was not, but she was impressed by his gentlemanly manner and they struck up a conversation. According to her account, he introduced himself as "Lord Willoughby" and advised her that the flower show she was heading for was not worth visiting. He said that he knew horticulture because he had gardens on his
427:. Three of the five women who identified Beck in his second trial were brought in to confront Thomas and they quickly identified him as the swindler (the other two had gone abroad and thus were not present). Other swindled women were brought in who also admitted their error in identifying Beck. When the man who had been John Smith's
371:
On 22 March 1904, a servant by the name of
Paulina Scott filed a complaint that a grey-haired, distinguished looking man had accosted her on the street, paid compliments to her and then stolen her jewellery. The inspector who took the complaint was familiar with Beck's case and assumed he must be the
297:
Avory brought Beck's alleged victims into court and one after another they pointed to Beck as the swindler. There were, however, occasional moments of doubt. One mentioned that the swindler talked differently from Beck, peppering his speech with "Yankee" slang. Ottilie
Meissonier remembered that the
114:
Adolf (or Adolph) Beck was born in Norway in 1841, and educated as a chemist. However, he went to sea soon afterwards and moved to
England in 1865, working as a clerk to a shipping broker. In 1868 he moved to South America, where he made a living for a while as a singer, then became a shipbroker, and
155:
her three weeks earlier. The policeman took them both to the nearest police station, where the woman identified herself as
Ottilie Meissonier, unmarried, and a language teacher. She alleged that she had been walking down Victoria Street when Beck approached her, tipping his hat and asking if she was
355:
and had known Beck since his return to
England in 1885, wrote an article in the paper emphasising that Beck had been tried on the assumption that he and Smith were the same person, yet no evidence to support that assumption had been allowed by Judge Fulton. Public opinion was slowly swayed by Sims
386:
before Sir
William Grantham. Five women identified him and, based on this positive identification, he was found guilty by the jury. The judge, however, was dissatisfied about the case and expressed some doubts regarding it. Despite assurances from the Home Office and the police of Beck's guilt, he
470:
before moving to London. Apparently he fell upon hard times there, and turned to preying on women through fraud. When Beck was sent to prison in his place, Meyer had returned to the United States and did not come back until 1903, apparently when he thought Beck had served out his sentence. Thomas
422:
The inspector went to the new prisoner's cell. It held a grey-haired man, approximately of Beck's height, with certain features which made him resemble Beck. However, Beck was younger and frailer in build, and this man had a scar on the right side of his neck, as
Ottilie Meissoner remembered. The
285:
only about the later lists. Gurrin said that these had been written by Beck with a "disguised hand". Gill then asked
Justice Fulton's permission to question Gurrin about the lists from 1877, but he ruled, in line with procedure in the English courts, that any earlier convictions of the defendant
294:, Avory could still prosecute Beck for the misdemeanours, which did not require proof of prior conviction. He chose not to proceed with the felony charges, despite the fact that the prosecution case was based wholly on the unstated premise that Adolph Beck and John Smith were the same person.
321:
England did not yet have a court of criminal appeal, but between 1896 and 1901 Beck's solicitor presented ten petitions for re-examination of his case. His requests to see the prison's description of John Smith were repeatedly denied. However, in May 1898 an official at the
334:, while Beck was not. The Home Office asked Sir Forrest Fulton for his opinion of this new evidence. Fulton wrote a minute dated 13 May in which he acknowledged that Smith and Beck could not be the same person but he added that, even if Beck was not Smith, he was still the
623:
272:
named Thomas Gurrin compared the lists of clothing Smith had given his victims in 1877 to those written in 1894 and 1895, as well as to samples of Beck's handwriting. Gill thought that he would have his chance to prove mistaken identity when he
419:. The detective was familiar with the Beck case, having been present at Beck's two trials and asked for details. The details fitted the usual pattern but the alleged culprit, Adolph Beck, was already in jail, awaiting sentencing.
289:
Avory did not want to call Elless
Spurrell to give evidence because his testimony would have opened discussion of the past conviction, thereby allowing Gill the opportunity to cast doubt on Beck's guilt. Without Spurrell's
205:
At Beck's committal hearing, in late 1895, one of the policemen who had arrested Smith eighteen years before was called to testify. Eless Henry Spurrell (1847-1906), who had retired in 1892, gave his account as follows:
265:. If they could prove that Beck was in South America at the time when John Smith was committing his crimes and went to prison for them, they could undermine the allegation that Adolph Beck was John Smith.
178:
The inspector who was assigned to the case learned that in the previous two years twenty-two women had been defrauded by a grey-haired man who called himself "Lord Wilton de Willoughby" and used the same
487:
was awarded £2,000, later raised to £5,000 due to public clamour (about £600,000 as of May 2023), again due to George Robert Sims, but those who were responsible were the subject of public indignation.
277:
Gurrin. If Gurrin testified in court, as he had said previously, that the writing from 1877 was identical to that from 1894 and 1895, Gill could bring witnesses to show that Beck had been in
226:. I produce the certificate of that conviction. The prisoner is the man. ... There is no doubt whatever – I know quite well what is at stake on my answer and I say without doubt he is the man.
639:
A simple Purchasing Power Calculator would say the relative value is £573,100.00. This answer is obtained by multiplying £5,000.00 by the percentage increase in the RPI from 1904 to 2021.
372:
culprit, so he sent Scott to the restaurant where Beck took his lunch. She did not recognise him but the inspector was undeterred by the woman's uncertainty and set a trap for him.
115:
also engaged in buying and selling houses. He soon amassed a considerable amount of savings, at one time earning £8,000 as commission for a sale of a Spanish concession in the
510:
can be, and the extreme care with which juries must regard evidence of this kind. As for Adolf Beck, his exoneration brought him little consolation. He died a broken man of
471:
then resumed his swindling until he was finally arrested. When brought to trial on 15 September, Wilhelm Meyer pleaded guilty to those offences and was jailed for 5 years.
716:
706:
503:
103:
701:
415:
was told of the arrest of a man who had tried to swindle some rings from a pair of unemployed actresses that afternoon and had been apprehended at a
98:, brought about by unreliable methods of identification, erroneous eyewitness testimony, and a rush to convict the accused. As one of the best known
187:
that included Beck along with ten or fifteen men who had been selected randomly from the street. Because he was the only one with grey hair and a
438:
as "John Smith" had been, and he had two other aliases as well, "William Wyatt" and "William Weiss". His true identity was Wilhelm Meyer, born in
302:
on the right side of his neck, but was otherwise convinced that Beck was the man. Another testified that his mustache was longer and was waxed.
711:
55:
342:"with great suspicion." As a result, the letter W was removed from Beck's prison number, but nothing else was done regarding the case.
681:
662:
548:
412:
77:
611:
587:
269:
123:
where he lived and had borrowed money from his secretary. Nevertheless, he tried to keep up appearances by dressing in a
696:
331:
318:. In prison he was given John Smith's old prison number, D 523, with the letter W added, indicating a repeat convict.
48:
42:
218:
where the prisoner in the name of John Smith was convicted of feloniously stealing ear-rings and a ring and eleven
721:
507:
467:
230:
Beck protested and insisted that he could bring witnesses from South America to prove that he was there in 1877.
20:
59:
423:
prisoner had given his name as William Thomas but the inspector, convinced that he was John Smith, informed
310:
On 5 March 1896 Adolf Beck was found guilty of fraud and was sentenced to seven years of penal servitude at
139:
506:. The case is still cited by judges in Commonwealth countries as a glaring example of how inaccurate
496:
443:
408:
492:
211:
99:
519:
484:
357:
346:
311:
160:
estate which were extensive enough to require six gardeners. Meissonier mentioned that she grew
573:
677:
658:
544:
274:
262:
116:
95:
315:
148:
670:
edited by Eric R. Watson (William Hodge and company, Notable British Trials series, 1924).
502:
As a direct result of the case, important reforms resulted, including the creation of the
439:
223:
459:
388:
251:
180:
168:
164:; he asked her whether he might see them and she invited him to tea the following day.
161:
690:
463:
455:
424:
184:
120:
491:
Eventually, a Committee of Inquiry was established, headed by the noted jurist and
431:
in 1877 identified Thomas as his former tenant, the prisoner confessed his crimes.
278:
243:
195:
157:
323:
624:"Five Ways to Compute the Relative Value of a UK Pound Amount, 1270 to Present"
399:
515:
480:
383:
351:
255:
239:
215:
124:
246:, assisted by Guy Stephenson, while the defence was headed by an experienced
435:
376:
291:
286:
could not be mentioned in court until after the jury had given its verdict.
247:
188:
462:
and was engaged in growing coffee, and in various other businesses in the
191:
he was quickly identified by the women as the man who had defrauded them.
574:"Metropolitan Police: Records of Police Pensioners (MEPO 21/22/78/10532)"
511:
428:
416:
335:
219:
447:
282:
250:, Charles Gill, who was assisted by Percival Clarke. The judge was Sir
128:
451:
327:
199:
147:
On 16 December 1895 Beck was stepping out of the front door of 135
398:
339:
183:
as Beck's accuser had described. These women were asked to view a
172:
152:
138:
258:, had been responsible for sending John Smith to prison in 1877.
299:
592:
UNLAWFULLY ADOLF\BECK, Deception > fraud, 24th February 1896
131:
whenever he went out, even though they had become threadbare.
27:
261:
The defence's strategy was to argue that this was a case of
102:
of its time, the case led to the creation of the English
391:. Ten days later the case was solved once and for all.
19:"Adolf Beck" redirects here. For the physiologist, see
167:
At her home the next day, he invited her to go to the
411:
police station on 7 July, Inspector John Kane of the
563:
Criminal Appeal Act, 1907 (U.K.), 7 Edw. VII, c. 23.
222:of Louisa Leonard and was sentenced to five years'
94:was a notorious incident of wrongful conviction by
363:Beck was paroled in July 1901 for good behaviour.
281:in 1877. Avory, foreseeing this tactic, asked the
16:Notorious wrongful conviction by mistaken identity
360:, to the view that Beck's conviction was unjust.
238:On 3 March 1896 Beck was brought to trial at the
326:looked at the Smith file and saw that Smith was
657:by Tim Coates (Stationery Office Books, 2001).
338:of 1895, and that he viewed the South American
208:
466:, then setting up practice as a physician in
434:"William Thomas" turned out to be as much an
214:Reserve . On 7 May 1877 I was present at the
8:
483:on 29 July 1904 and in compensation for his
382:He was again put on trial on 27 June at the
543:. London: Stationery Office. p. 234.
479:Adolf Beck was given a free pardon by the
403:Police photographs of Beck (top) and Meyer
717:Norwegian emigrants to the United Kingdom
78:Learn how and when to remove this message
676:by Christopher Priest (Gollancz, 2022).
41:This article includes a list of general
531:
7:
707:Recipients of British royal pardons
375:On 15 April 1904, as Beck left his
349:, a journalist who worked for the
47:it lacks sufficient corresponding
14:
702:Overturned convictions in England
458:. He later became surgeon to the
413:Criminal Investigation Department
655:The Strange Story of Adolph Beck
541:The strange story of Adolph Beck
32:
588:"Proceedings of the Old Bailey"
345:While Beck remained in prison,
242:. The Crown was represented by
1:
367:Second arrest and conviction
712:High Court of Justice cases
738:
407:On a routine visit to the
194:Beck was charged with ten
18:
508:eyewitness identification
21:Adolf Beck (physiologist)
504:Court of Criminal Appeal
497:Sir Richard Henn Collins
104:Court of Criminal Appeal
668:The Trial of Adolf Beck
442:and graduated from the
312:Portland Convict Prison
110:Biographical background
62:more precise citations.
628:www.measuringworth.com
404:
395:Truth about John Smith
356:and others, including
228:
216:Central Criminal Court
210:In 1877 I was in the
144:
402:
306:Conviction and doubts
142:
576:. National Archives.
539:Coates, Tim (1999).
522:on 7 December 1909.
456:Father Joseph Damien
444:University of Vienna
409:Tottenham Court Road
387:decided to postpone
493:Master of the Rolls
244:Horace Edmund Avory
212:Metropolitan Police
697:Arthur Conan Doyle
674:Expect Me Tomorrow
520:Middlesex Hospital
485:false imprisonment
405:
358:Arthur Conan Doyle
347:George Robert Sims
330:and thus had been
270:handwriting expert
145:
263:mistaken identity
117:Galapagos Islands
96:mistaken identity
88:
87:
80:
729:
722:1877 in case law
642:
641:
636:
634:
620:
614:
609:
603:
602:
600:
598:
584:
578:
577:
570:
564:
561:
555:
554:
536:
452:Hawaiian Islands
316:Isle of Portland
83:
76:
72:
69:
63:
58:this article by
49:inline citations
36:
35:
28:
737:
736:
732:
731:
730:
728:
727:
726:
687:
686:
651:
649:Further reading
646:
645:
632:
630:
622:
621:
617:
610:
606:
596:
594:
586:
585:
581:
572:
571:
567:
562:
558:
551:
538:
537:
533:
528:
477:
397:
369:
308:
298:swindler had a
236:
224:penal servitude
149:Victoria Street
137:
112:
100:causes célèbres
92:Adolf Beck case
84:
73:
67:
64:
54:Please help to
53:
37:
33:
24:
17:
12:
11:
5:
735:
733:
725:
724:
719:
714:
709:
704:
699:
689:
688:
685:
684:
671:
665:
650:
647:
644:
643:
615:
612:William Thomas
604:
579:
565:
556:
549:
530:
529:
527:
524:
476:
473:
460:King of Hawaii
396:
393:
368:
365:
307:
304:
275:cross-examined
252:Forrest Fulton
235:
232:
181:modus operandi
169:French Riviera
162:chrysanthemums
136:
133:
111:
108:
86:
85:
40:
38:
31:
15:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
734:
723:
720:
718:
715:
713:
710:
708:
705:
703:
700:
698:
695:
694:
692:
683:
682:9781473235137
679:
675:
672:
669:
666:
664:
663:0-11-702414-7
660:
656:
653:
652:
648:
640:
629:
625:
619:
616:
613:
608:
605:
593:
589:
583:
580:
575:
569:
566:
560:
557:
552:
550:0-11-702414-7
546:
542:
535:
532:
525:
523:
521:
517:
513:
509:
505:
500:
498:
494:
489:
486:
482:
474:
472:
469:
465:
464:United States
461:
457:
453:
449:
446:. He studied
445:
441:
437:
432:
430:
426:
425:Scotland Yard
420:
418:
414:
410:
401:
394:
392:
390:
385:
380:
378:
373:
366:
364:
361:
359:
354:
353:
348:
343:
341:
337:
333:
329:
325:
319:
317:
313:
305:
303:
301:
295:
293:
287:
284:
280:
276:
271:
266:
264:
259:
257:
253:
249:
245:
241:
233:
231:
227:
225:
221:
217:
213:
207:
203:
201:
197:
196:misdemeanours
192:
190:
186:
182:
176:
174:
170:
165:
163:
159:
154:
150:
141:
134:
132:
130:
126:
122:
121:Covent Garden
118:
109:
107:
105:
101:
97:
93:
82:
79:
71:
61:
57:
51:
50:
44:
39:
30:
29:
26:
22:
673:
667:
654:
638:
631:. Retrieved
627:
618:
607:
595:. Retrieved
591:
582:
568:
559:
540:
534:
501:
490:
478:
433:
421:
406:
381:
374:
370:
362:
350:
344:
320:
309:
296:
288:
279:Buenos Aires
267:
260:
254:, who, as a
237:
229:
209:
204:
193:
177:
166:
158:Lincolnshire
146:
113:
91:
89:
74:
65:
46:
25:
332:circumcised
324:Home Office
68:August 2007
60:introducing
691:Categories
597:2 February
526:References
516:bronchitis
389:sentencing
384:Old Bailey
352:Daily Mail
256:prosecutor
240:Old Bailey
143:Adolf Beck
125:frock coat
43:references
475:Aftermath
292:testimony
248:barrister
220:shillings
198:and four
189:moustache
106:in 1907.
512:pleurisy
468:Adelaide
429:landlord
417:pawnshop
336:impostor
200:felonies
153:swindled
450:in the
448:leprosy
314:on the
283:witness
185:line-up
171:on his
129:top hat
56:improve
680:
661:
633:23 May
547:
454:under
440:Vienna
328:Jewish
135:Arrest
45:, but
436:alias
340:alibi
234:Trial
173:yacht
678:ISBN
659:ISBN
635:2023
599:2014
545:ISBN
514:and
481:King
377:flat
300:scar
127:and
90:The
518:in
693::
637:.
626:.
590:.
495:,
268:A
601:.
553:.
81:)
75:(
70:)
66:(
52:.
23:.
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
