236:, Ruzan Hakobyan praises the book for being "one of the best and most comprehensive works not only on the Karabagh conflict but also on the region as a whole". However, in the same review she also explains that "an informed eye can detect certain drawbacks". Hakobyan lists two drawbacks, the first one being, according to her, the repeated assertion that the start of the conflict was unexpected for both Armenians and Azeris of Karabakh who lived peacefully and in good relations side-by-side, labeling this as "at the very least optimistic" . Within the context of providing an example, Hakobyan states: "For 70 years Armenians in Karabagh have been systematically subjected to a deliberate policy of discrimination and removal from their homeland and have made repeated attempts to rectify the situation". She then proceeds to list the gradual decrease and increase of the Karabakhi Armenia and Azerbaijani population, respectively, during Soviet rule by using Soviet censuses. Another drawback mentioned by Hakobyan: "one cannot help detecting is that in trying to be impartial the author sometimes slips into flatly equalizing the behaviours of the Armenians and the Azeris during the years of the conflict, thus undermining the historical reality. For instance, he repeatedly claims that the Azeri population that left Armenia in the first year of the conflict has undergone the same inhuman treatment from Armenians as the Armenian population in Sumgait and Baku. But he has no data on which to base this assertion. All he manages to produce are the unfounded assertions of the Azeri population itself, while the atrocities that Azeris had performed towards the Armenian population in Sumgait and Baku are thoroughly documented and widely known". She concludes the review by mentioning that
704:
29:
248:
A number of
Armenian academics and analysts were critical of the book, arguing that it presents a false balance between Armenia and Azerbaijan and contains inaccuracies. Professor Alexander Manasyan of
261:" and "carries out Azerbaijani position by distorting the essence of the problem, masterfully going around all the unfavorable to Azerbaijani position facts and events [
227:
praised de Waal for providing "a deeper and more compelling account of the conflict than anyone before ... one likely to exercise give-no-quarters partisans on both sides."
546:
809:
637:"Studies on Strategy and Security", compiled and edited, with an introduction and commentary by Dr Armen Ayvazyan, Yerevan, Lusakn, 2007, 684 pp. , p. 657
616:
804:
210:, Samuel Andoh wrote that "most articles on the conflict tend to partial towards one side or the other, putting the blame on Armenia or Azerbaijan ...
779:
745:
653:
271:
784:
313:
764:
114:
789:
516:"Book review: Armenia and Azerbaijan through Peace and War: Black Garden: 10 Year Anniversary Edition, written by Thomas de Waal"
794:
774:
193:
502:
magisterial histories are an essential part of a comprehensible explanation of the intractable problems that beset the region.
799:
171:
738:
274:, as "a banal propaganda but not an objective research on Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict." Vrtanesyan concludes that "
144:
60:
206:
148:
250:
711:
731:
680:
451:
612:"Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict: on the Frontlines of the Information War, or the Last "Accord" of the Year"
611:
423:
232:
181:
395:
321:
592:
515:
493:
201:
257:, wrote that de Waal "supports the point of view which is steered by the propaganda machine of
769:
571:
Hakobyan, R. (2004). "Thomas de Waal, (New York and London: New York
University Press, 2003),
485:
109:
715:
418:
703:
584:
527:
293:
219:
187:
151:
since 1988 combined with interviews conducted on the ground in the aftermath of the war.
676:
285:
281:
224:
166:
155:
128:
42:
758:
596:
648:
344:"Thomas de Waal presents supplemented version of his "Black Garden" book in Yerevan"
681:"Խոջալուի մասին Սերժ Սարգսյանի խոսքերը Թոմաս դե Վաալը ենթատեքստից դուրս է մեջբերել"
278:
is not an unbiased work, neither can its author be considered a neutral observer."
369:"Awards & Grants: Black garden: Armenia and Azerbaijan through peace and war"
284:, an independent Armenian analyst and journalist, wrote that de Waal had quoted
343:
588:
531:
185:
called it "a lucid, evenhanded analysis of the intricacies of this conflict".
136:
489:
368:
270:
The book was also criticized by Karen
Vrtanesyan, an Armenian expert for the
28:
497:
132:
240:, even with such drawbacks, remains of high quality and significance.
200:
The book was particularly praised for its balanced approach given the
140:
258:
263:
547:"Black Garden: Armenia and Azerbaijan Through Peace and War"
154:
The book won the
Outstanding Academic Title 2003 award from
191:
magazine reviewer Paul Quinn-Judge and Robert
Chenciner in
22:
Black Garden: Armenia and
Azerbaijan Through Peace and War
573:
Black Garden: Armenia and
Azerbaijan through Peace and War
124:
Black Garden: Armenia and
Azerbaijan Through Peace and War
719:
267:], skillfully offering lie as believable truth".
649:""The Black Garden": In Search of Imagined Balance"
108:
100:
92:
84:
74:
66:
56:
48:
38:
179:as "admirable and rigorous" and Amer Latif in
739:
8:
214:... is probably one of the few exceptions."
21:
746:
732:
617:International Center for Human Development
292:regarding the latter's comments about the
27:
20:
320:. Belgrade Security Forum. Archived from
610:Manasyan, Alexander (19 February 2007).
305:
450:Quinn-Judge, Paul (2 February 2004).
197:also gave the book positive reviews.
7:
700:
698:
654:Ararat Center for Strategic Research
476:Chenciner, Robert (2011). "Review".
394:Ascherson, Neal (20 November 2003).
272:Ararat Center for Strategic Research
810:International relations book stubs
718:. You can help Knowledge (XXG) by
147:. It consists of a history of the
14:
545:Legvold, Robert (November 2003).
702:
575:, 337 pp. maps, illustrations".
514:Andoh, Samuel K. (9 May 2014).
780:Books about petroleum politics
375:. American Library Association
1:
710:This article about a book on
805:Armenia–Azerbaijan relations
685:ANI Armenian Research Center
452:"Two Peoples, One Nightmare"
172:The New York Review of Books
204:nature of the conflict. In
16:2003 book by Thomas de Waal
826:
785:First Nagorno-Karabakh War
697:
145:First Nagorno-Karabakh War
61:First Nagorno-Karabakh War
589:10.1017/S0090599200016317
532:10.1163/15692108-12341295
520:African and Asian Studies
207:African and Asian Studies
149:Nagorno-Karabakh conflict
26:
765:Foreign policy doctrines
417:Dr. Latif, Amer (2005).
251:Yerevan State University
790:Books about geopolitics
712:international relations
526:(1–2). Brill: 241–244.
795:2003 non-fiction books
775:Books about Azerbaijan
288:out of context in the
143:republics, during the
131:, based on a study of
478:International Affairs
398:. The New York Review
396:"In the Black Garden"
194:International Affairs
679:(26 February 2018).
577:Nationalities Papers
233:Nationalities Papers
800:Books about Armenia
647:Vrtanesyan, Karen.
23:
127:is a 2003 book by
727:
726:
318:belgradeforum.org
202:ethno-nationalist
120:
119:
85:Publication place
817:
748:
741:
734:
706:
699:
689:
688:
673:
667:
665:
663:
661:
644:
638:
635:
629:
628:
626:
624:
607:
601:
600:
568:
562:
561:
559:
557:
542:
536:
535:
511:
505:
504:
473:
467:
466:
464:
462:
447:
441:
440:
438:
436:
414:
408:
407:
405:
403:
391:
385:
384:
382:
380:
365:
359:
358:
356:
354:
340:
334:
333:
331:
329:
314:"Thomas de Waal"
310:
294:Khojaly Massacre
76:Publication date
31:
24:
825:
824:
820:
819:
818:
816:
815:
814:
755:
754:
753:
752:
695:
693:
692:
677:Hakobyan, Tatul
675:
674:
670:
659:
657:
646:
645:
641:
636:
632:
622:
620:
609:
608:
604:
570:
569:
565:
555:
553:
551:Foreign Affairs
544:
543:
539:
513:
512:
508:
475:
474:
470:
460:
458:
449:
448:
444:
434:
432:
416:
415:
411:
401:
399:
393:
392:
388:
378:
376:
367:
366:
362:
352:
350:
342:
341:
337:
327:
325:
312:
311:
307:
302:
253:, in reviewing
246:
220:Foreign Affairs
164:
93:Media type
77:
34:
17:
12:
11:
5:
823:
821:
813:
812:
807:
802:
797:
792:
787:
782:
777:
772:
767:
757:
756:
751:
750:
743:
736:
728:
725:
724:
707:
691:
690:
687:(in Armenian).
668:
639:
630:
602:
583:(3): 699–701.
563:
537:
506:
468:
442:
419:"Book Reviews"
409:
386:
373:Choice Reviews
360:
335:
324:on 7 July 2013
304:
303:
301:
298:
286:Serzh Sargsyan
282:Tatul Hakobyan
245:
242:
225:Robert Legvold
167:Neal Ascherson
163:
160:
156:Choice Reviews
129:Thomas de Waal
118:
117:
112:
106:
105:
102:
98:
97:
94:
90:
89:
88:United Kingdom
86:
82:
81:
78:
75:
72:
71:
68:
64:
63:
58:
54:
53:
50:
46:
45:
43:Thomas de Waal
40:
36:
35:
32:
15:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
822:
811:
808:
806:
803:
801:
798:
796:
793:
791:
788:
786:
783:
781:
778:
776:
773:
771:
768:
766:
763:
762:
760:
749:
744:
742:
737:
735:
730:
729:
723:
721:
717:
713:
708:
705:
701:
696:
686:
682:
678:
672:
669:
656:
655:
650:
643:
640:
634:
631:
619:
618:
613:
606:
603:
598:
594:
590:
586:
582:
578:
574:
567:
564:
552:
548:
541:
538:
533:
529:
525:
521:
517:
510:
507:
503:
499:
495:
491:
487:
483:
479:
472:
469:
457:
453:
446:
443:
430:
426:
425:
420:
413:
410:
397:
390:
387:
374:
370:
364:
361:
349:
345:
339:
336:
323:
319:
315:
309:
306:
299:
297:
295:
291:
287:
283:
279:
277:
273:
268:
266:
265:
260:
256:
252:
243:
241:
239:
235:
234:
228:
226:
222:
221:
215:
213:
209:
208:
203:
198:
196:
195:
190:
189:
184:
183:
178:
174:
173:
168:
161:
159:
157:
152:
150:
146:
142:
139:, two former
138:
134:
130:
126:
125:
116:
115:0-8147-6032-5
113:
111:
107:
103:
99:
95:
91:
87:
83:
79:
73:
69:
65:
62:
59:
55:
51:
47:
44:
41:
37:
33:First edition
30:
25:
19:
720:expanding it
709:
694:
684:
671:
660:29 September
658:. Retrieved
652:
642:
633:
623:30 September
621:. Retrieved
615:
605:
580:
576:
572:
566:
554:. Retrieved
550:
540:
523:
519:
509:
501:
481:
477:
471:
459:. Retrieved
455:
445:
433:. Retrieved
431:(1): 141–143
428:
422:
412:
400:. Retrieved
389:
377:. Retrieved
372:
363:
351:. Retrieved
347:
338:
326:. Retrieved
322:the original
317:
308:
290:Black Garden
289:
280:
276:Black Garden
275:
269:
262:
255:Black Garden
254:
247:
238:Black Garden
237:
231:
229:
218:
216:
212:Black Garden
211:
205:
199:
192:
186:
180:
177:Black Garden
176:
170:
165:
153:
123:
122:
121:
18:
348:mediamax.am
230:Writing in
217:Writing in
759:Categories
484:(3): 742.
424:Parameters
300:References
182:Parameters
175:described
137:Azerbaijan
597:186477839
490:0020-5850
244:Criticism
104:360 pages
70:NYU Press
67:Publisher
770:Caucasus
498:20869740
49:Language
162:Reviews
133:Armenia
57:Subject
52:English
595:
556:17 May
496:
488:
461:17 May
435:17 May
402:17 May
379:16 May
353:7 July
328:7 July
141:Soviet
39:Author
714:is a
593:S2CID
494:JSTOR
101:Pages
96:Print
716:stub
662:2007
625:2007
558:2021
486:ISSN
463:2021
456:Time
437:2021
404:2021
381:2021
355:2013
330:2013
259:Baku
188:Time
135:and
110:ISBN
80:2003
585:doi
528:doi
264:sic
169:in
761::
683:.
651:.
614:.
591:.
581:32
579:.
549:.
524:13
522:.
518:.
500:.
492:.
482:87
480:.
454:.
429:35
427:.
421:.
371:.
346:.
316:.
296:.
223:,
158:.
747:e
740:t
733:v
722:.
666:.
664:.
627:.
599:.
587::
560:.
534:.
530::
465:.
439:.
406:.
383:.
357:.
332:.
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
