95:
the non-Fairtrade farmers may be harmed by
Fairtrade. These problems arise with both case studies and more general surveys, and are particularly intractable when the appropriate control group is in another country. There have been virtually no base period studies, to determine the position before a cooperative joined Fairtrade, so it is seldom possible to claim that the farmers in a cooperative are better off or have more self-esteem because of Fairtrade, rather than because Fairtrade selects efficient cooperatives with educated, efficient, well-off farmers.
127:
Fairtrade product in a country - valuable but different research. Even if twenty or thirty studies which met the impact evaluation criteria could be identified, it would not be possible to generalize from them because it is not claimed that they are typical. The studies are not of randomly selected cooperatives. They are concentrated on better known, more successful and well established ones, and there are few which examine the problems of cooperatives which have recently joined
Fairtrade or of the least successful quartile of Fairtrade cooperatives.
677:
70:, start with the premise that any intervention in an economic system has various impacts throughout that system: some significant, many small; some costs, some benefits; some people benefit, others are harmed. Impact evaluations aim to identify costs and benefits throughout the system, then quantify them, so that people do not make unwarranted claims of impact and so that informed decisions can be made.
22:
119:
that this is typical. The conclusion is rather that secretiveness prevents impact analysis of the full
Fairtrade system. Few studies analyse how much extra money is received by the cooperatives, what it is spent on, how much is taken by managers of cooperatives and how much reaches the farmers. Few studies discuss the costs identified in the
104:
and even more difficult to measure any effects on non-Fairtrade farmers in other, poorer, countries. The decision on which such measures to include introduces a bias: it may be asked whether there are other non-money costs or benefits that might be included in the studies which would give answers less favourable to
Fairtrade.
98:
The possibility that all groups of farmers have increased incomes because of higher world prices, changed exchange rates etc. is difficult to tackle. As most of the extra money paid by consumers is taken by firms in rich countries or is spent on added costs incurred in meeting
Fairtrade standards, it
103:
projects. These are difficult to measure, and it is particularly difficult to measure these non-monetary benefits in control groups of local non-Fairtrade farmers, the extent to which non-Fairtrade farmers lose self-esteem, etc. because they are excluded from Fair trade impact studies, for instance,
94:
to ensure that an impact is the result of the intervention being studied, which is often impossible and always difficult with
Fairtrade because of the way that Fairtrade is organized, notably because the Fairtrade farmers and cooperatives are selected from the richer and more efficient, and because
118:
One impact, the amount of money going to businesses in rich countries rather than to Third World producers, is addressed in only a handful of studies. These show that in some cases 90% to 99.5% of the extra money paid by consumers is kept as extra profit by firms in rich countries but cannot show
107:
An unpublished consultancy report prepared for
Fairtrade found only 33 studies that met their own criteria (not those of the World Bank or Inter-American Bank) for impact studies. These 33 included unpublished undergraduate and mastersâ dissertations, unpublished theses, articles by employees or
126:
There are, however, case studies of
Fairtrade cooperatives which do not attempt to be impact studies, identifying and quantifying all positive and negative impacts, but are, rather, examinations of how subsections of the system operate, usually single Fairtrade cooperatives and sometimes one
81:
in
America have developed guidelines, but analysis is considered particularly difficult with developing country agriculture. Peter Griffiths has examined the additional problems that arise when analysing the impact of Fairtrade interventions, arising from the way it is organized.
115:, and fewer still that attempt to quantify them. There are few mentions in the literature of the biggest financial costs and benefits, the extra price paid by consumers and the extra profit made by companies in rich countries, and fewer attempts to quantify these.
152:
Winters, P., Salazar, L. and
Maffioli, A. âDesigning impact evaluations for agricultural projectsâ, Impact Evaluation Guidelines, Strategy Development Division, Technical Notes No. IDB-TN-198. (Washington, DC: Inter-American Development Bank, 2010). Accessed at
165:
Angelucci, M. and Di Maro, V. Project Evaluation and Spillover Effects. Impact Evaluation Guidelines, Strategy Development Division, Technical Notes No. IDB-TN-136 (Washington, DC: Inter-American Development Bank, 2010). Accessed at
142:
Winters, P., Alessandro Maffioli and Lina Salazar, âIntroduction to the Special Feature: Evaluating the Impact of Agricultural Projects in Developing Countriesâ Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 62, No. 2, 2011, 393â402 doi:
234:
Kilian, B., Jones, C., Pratt, L., & Villalobos, A. (2006). âIs Sustainable Agriculture a Viable Strategy to Improve Farm Income in Central America? A Case Study on Coffeeâ. Journal of Business Research, 59(3),
657:
225:
Valkila, J., Haaparanta, P., & Niemi, N. (2010). âEmpowering Coffee Traders? The Coffee Value Chain from Nicaraguan Fair Trade Farmers to Finnish Consumers.â Journal of Business Ethics, 97:257-270
178:
Michael A. Clemens and Gabriel Demombynes, âWhen Does Rigorous Impact Evaluation Make a Difference? The Case of the Millennium Villagesâ, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 5477, 2010
194:
Griffiths, P., âEthical objections to Fairtradeâ Journal of Business Ethics: Volume 105, Issue 3 (2012), Page 357-373 (DOI) 10.1007/s10551-011-0972-0 www.springerlink.com Accessed at
465:
470:
99:
is seldom possible to identify direct financial benefit to farmers, and the studies concentrate on non-monetary benefits, like improvement in self-esteem or the creation of
413:
383:
444:
210:
111:
Griffiths suggests that even this is optimistic: there are very few studies that examine any of the costs identified by critics of Fairtrade in the
294:
206:
Nelson, V., & Pound, B.: 2009, The Last Ten Years: A Comprehensive Review of the Literature on the Impact of Fairtrade. Retrieved from
262:
342:
495:
485:
398:
257:
108:
members of Fairtrade cooperatives, several reports on the same cooperatives, and one report cited under two different titles.
393:
611:
388:
565:
706:
449:
480:
429:
287:
626:
434:
322:
647:
555:
490:
475:
352:
207:
590:
408:
317:
100:
67:
32:
631:
570:
701:
680:
616:
575:
560:
280:
195:
78:
530:
337:
120:
112:
59:
36:
545:
540:
500:
268:
The Center for Fair and Alternative Trade: Scholarly Research on Fair Trade and its Impacts
621:
214:
40:
606:
550:
505:
49:
695:
535:
362:
347:
91:
585:
247:
154:
580:
327:
303:
74:
63:
525:
367:
357:
439:
208:
http://www.fairtrade.org.uk/resources/natural_resources_institute.aspx
167:
403:
252:
196:
http://www.griffithsspeaker.com/Fairtrade/why_fair_trade_isn.htm
276:
258:
World Fair Trade Organization-Europe: Fair trade impact studies
15:
272:
267:
263:
Fair Trade Institute: Collection of fair trade publications
90:
Impact studies require study of the counterfactual, using
45:
471:
Fair Trade Association of Australia & New Zealand
253:
European Fair Trade Association: Impact of fair trade
640:
599:
514:
466:
AsociaciĂłn del Sello de Productos de Comercio Justo
458:
422:
376:
310:
414:International Resources for Fairer Trade (IRFT)
384:Fairtrade Labelling Organizations International
288:
8:
248:Fairtrade International: Impact and research
155:http://www.iadb.org/document.cfm?id=35529432
190:
188:
186:
184:
445:International Fairtrade Certification Mark
295:
281:
273:
440:FLO-CERT (inspection & certification)
506:Fair Trade USA (formerly TransFair USA)
135:
7:
14:
496:Max Havelaar-Stiftung Switzerland
676:
675:
343:Alternative trading organization
143:10.1111/j.1477-9552.2011.00296.x
20:
486:Association Max Havelaar France
399:European Fair Trade Association
394:Network of European Worldshops
168:http://www-personal.umich.edu/
1:
612:List of Fairtrade settlements
389:World Fair Trade Organization
46:help to improve this article
566:Gepa The Fair Trade Company
723:
671:
450:Fair Trade Certified Mark
333:Fair trade impact studies
481:The Fairtrade Foundation
430:Fair trade certification
435:Fairtrade International
328:Fair trade and politics
323:Fairtrade certification
556:Equal Exchange Trading
491:Stichting Max Havelaar
476:Fairtrade Mark Ireland
353:Trade Justice Movement
591:Ten Thousand Villages
409:Fair Trade Federation
318:History of fair trade
101:community development
68:cost-benefit analysis
632:World Fair Trade Day
571:Handcrafting Justice
459:Labeling initiatives
39:to meet Knowledge's
681:Category:Fair trade
617:Fairtrade fortnight
576:SERRV International
561:Rainforest Alliance
516:Alternative trading
213:2012-01-26 at the
707:Impact assessment
689:
688:
531:Artisans du Monde
338:Fair trade debate
121:Fair trade debate
113:Fair trade debate
60:Impact evaluation
57:
56:
41:quality standards
714:
679:
678:
663:
653:
546:Divine Chocolate
541:Ctm altromercato
501:Fairtrade Canada
297:
290:
283:
274:
236:
232:
226:
223:
217:
204:
198:
192:
179:
176:
170:
163:
157:
150:
144:
140:
35:and may require
24:
23:
16:
722:
721:
717:
716:
715:
713:
712:
711:
692:
691:
690:
685:
667:
661:
659:Brewing Justice
651:
636:
622:Make Trade Fair
595:
519:
517:
510:
454:
418:
372:
306:
301:
244:
239:
233:
229:
224:
220:
215:Wayback Machine
205:
201:
193:
182:
177:
173:
164:
160:
151:
147:
141:
137:
133:
88:
53:
25:
21:
12:
11:
5:
720:
718:
710:
709:
704:
694:
693:
687:
686:
684:
683:
672:
669:
668:
666:
665:
655:
644:
642:
638:
637:
635:
634:
629:
624:
619:
614:
609:
607:Fairtrade Town
603:
601:
597:
596:
594:
593:
588:
583:
578:
573:
568:
563:
558:
553:
551:Equal Exchange
548:
543:
538:
533:
528:
522:
520:
515:
512:
511:
509:
508:
503:
498:
493:
488:
483:
478:
473:
468:
462:
460:
456:
455:
453:
452:
447:
442:
437:
432:
426:
424:
420:
419:
417:
416:
411:
406:
401:
396:
391:
386:
380:
378:
374:
373:
371:
370:
365:
360:
355:
350:
345:
340:
335:
330:
325:
320:
314:
312:
308:
307:
302:
300:
299:
292:
285:
277:
271:
270:
265:
260:
255:
250:
243:
242:External links
240:
238:
237:
227:
218:
199:
180:
171:
158:
145:
134:
132:
129:
92:control groups
87:
84:
66:systems, like
55:
54:
28:
26:
19:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
719:
708:
705:
703:
700:
699:
697:
682:
674:
673:
670:
664:
660:
656:
654:
650:
646:
645:
643:
639:
633:
630:
628:
625:
623:
620:
618:
615:
613:
610:
608:
605:
604:
602:
598:
592:
589:
587:
584:
582:
579:
577:
574:
572:
569:
567:
564:
562:
559:
557:
554:
552:
549:
547:
544:
542:
539:
537:
534:
532:
529:
527:
524:
523:
521:
518:organizations
513:
507:
504:
502:
499:
497:
494:
492:
489:
487:
484:
482:
479:
477:
474:
472:
469:
467:
464:
463:
461:
457:
451:
448:
446:
443:
441:
438:
436:
433:
431:
428:
427:
425:
423:Certification
421:
415:
412:
410:
407:
405:
402:
400:
397:
395:
392:
390:
387:
385:
382:
381:
379:
375:
369:
366:
364:
363:Body shopping
361:
359:
356:
354:
351:
349:
348:Trade justice
346:
344:
341:
339:
336:
334:
331:
329:
326:
324:
321:
319:
316:
315:
313:
309:
305:
298:
293:
291:
286:
284:
279:
278:
275:
269:
266:
264:
261:
259:
256:
254:
251:
249:
246:
245:
241:
231:
228:
222:
219:
216:
212:
209:
203:
200:
197:
191:
189:
187:
185:
181:
175:
172:
169:
162:
159:
156:
149:
146:
139:
136:
130:
128:
124:
122:
116:
114:
109:
105:
102:
96:
93:
85:
83:
80:
76:
71:
69:
65:
61:
51:
48:by making it
47:
43:
42:
38:
34:
31:reads like a
29:This article
27:
18:
17:
658:
648:
586:Twin Trading
332:
230:
221:
202:
174:
161:
148:
138:
125:
117:
110:
106:
97:
89:
72:
58:
30:
652:(2006 film)
377:Federations
311:Core topics
702:Fair trade
696:Categories
649:Black Gold
581:Traidcraft
536:Cafédirect
358:Sweatshops
304:Fair trade
131:References
79:Inter Bank
75:World Bank
64:fair trade
33:term paper
600:Campaigns
526:Alter Eco
368:Worldshop
44:. Please
627:No Sweat
235:322â330.
211:Archived
52:in tone.
86:Studies
50:neutral
37:cleanup
662:(book)
641:Media
404:FINE
77:and
73:The
62:of
698::
183:^
123:.
296:e
289:t
282:v
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.