245:
1483:"evolution as revolution" argument that helps explain why early US institutions were so conservative, modeled on the British example. The US had one of the most conservative revolutions in human history, especially compared to what happened in France only several years later. The fact that women's rights, Native American settlement, and slavery were not adequately addressed stems from this deliberately slow-paced evolution from the British monarchy and society. Second, some reviews have examined this book in comparison to
142:
313:
107:
285:
344:
152:
585:
265:
447:
21:
1348:
1307:
1289:
1236:
1194:
1149:
1135:
921:
907:
893:
840:
806:
76:
575:
557:
686:
1495:. I am under the impression that free use of HighBeam is not widespread across the wiki. I burned a 7-day free trial in order to examine the references for this review. I don't know how long the free links will be accessible in comparison to the paid HighBeam service, so I think keeping both URLs makes sense, although it does double the sources. If
334:
1418:
I apologize to the aggregate that this review has taken as long as it has. It seemed to me that I should read the book upon which the article is written. Once I had started to read, it occurred to me that I may as well give as thorough an examination as I could rather than simply ensure GA criteria
1015:
It's my impression that
Madison as a reluctant Federalist wanted a stronger central government only for purposes of strong emergency response. While Ellis makes the point about blurred sovereignty being the successful argument, I suspect that it was a compromise that no one really wanted as it was
655:
Just wanted to post a courtesy note here that I'll probably be trying to bring this up to GA status in the coming week or two; if anyone's still active here, I'd welcome your input. My plan is to expand the content section a bit more, to add a few of the book's major themes as elaborated by critics
1482:
Sadly, the reviews of this book have been journalistic, not academic. I certainly hope there's some academic analysis of this book, as this article would benefit. There are two academic points that could also be discussed here when there's the necessary academic study. First, Ellis posits the
979:
The "Argument" section should explain that
Madison overcame Henry by pointing out how the Confederation government failed during the war. The current verbiage is confusing and implies that shared sovereignty and what we now call federalism was the winning play, when Madison never sought that
1052:
who advocated holding the countryside and forcing the
British to continue the occupation and attempt to strike the Continental Army. According to Ellis, Washington never made up his mind about the strategy and waited until the British attacked into the Carolinas.
742:
274:
121:
254:
117:
1000:
Expanded to include both. Ellis does call the blurred sovereignty part "the clinching argument" (124), so it seems worth emphasizing here. Does this address your concern? Thanks for both of these suggestions. --
1487:
academics that have raked the dead white guys over the coals as of late. Ellis's book does not pointedly reject the subaltern criticisms of the founders but he does differ with those academics about their
1596:
1606:
1576:
1591:
478:
465:
1586:
1621:
400:
390:
182:
1581:
1529:
1611:
491:
199:
691:
1601:
1073:
I've attempted to rewrite this to address your concerns; let me know if you find it sufficient, or what wording you would prefer. Thanks again for the suggestions. --
656:
and Ellis himself, a bit more background on the book's writing, and its critical reception. Thanks to everybody who worked on this before me for getting it started --
366:
724:
1507:'s acceptance of me as a recruitee to perform this review. Certainly I need the training experience and without nominator consent, I would have been out of luck.
1440:
No worries--I've been in plenty of 2- or 3-week GA reviews. There's no deadline, and I really appreciate both your thoroughness and the good suggestions above. --
1571:
235:
225:
714:
1532:
also passed). I'm unlikely to try to take this up to A-class or FA myself, but with luck a future editor can make use of these good suggestions. Cheers, --
1397:
Wow, you're going above and beyond! Well, hope you enjoy it--I really appreciate your doing that. There's no rush on this, obviously, so take your time. --
1616:
357:
318:
294:
189:
125:
1041:
514:
1566:
194:
1472:
696:
244:
1464:
1455:
I approve this as a GA. I'd like to make some other comments for work to be performed concurrent with a review at the A-class or FA level:
763:
495:
1016:
too weak for the New
England merchant class and too strong for the Southern planter class. Regardless, your edits addressed my concerns.
1631:
1040:
In the "Winter" section, Washington never changed strategy. Ellis makes plain that
Washington was unsure about how to proceed. It was
605:
472:
165:
112:
46:
774:
523:
177:
1556:
609:
1468:
1626:
780:
719:
38:
32:
1561:
913:
173:
on
Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the ongoing discussions.
362:
87:
1484:
1476:
599:
562:
1045:
53:
1295:
812:
1515:
1427:
1385:
1320:
1253:
1207:
1162:
1095:
1061:
1024:
988:
951:
853:
757:
875:
832:
738:
20:
509:
Place either of the following WikiProject banners on United States
History-related articles and assess:
93:
613:
349:
157:
1509:
1421:
1379:
1314:
1247:
1201:
1156:
1089:
1055:
1018:
982:
945:
847:
753:
333:
312:
284:
365:
on
Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join
1460:
939:
was signed successfully, that
Georgian intransigence and McGillivray's double-dealing led to the
936:
141:
106:
1199:
This article fairly depicts the book's contents and mentions journalistic reviews of the book.
1537:
1496:
1492:
1445:
1402:
1368:
1078:
1006:
968:
661:
459:
42:
1271:
1141:
1049:
820:
1127:
617:
1528:
I appreciate your taking the time to review! It's turned into my first-ever two-GA day (
1180:
885:
816:
784:
485:
446:
1550:
1299:
1281:
828:
824:
170:
1491:
I have twice added the free and direct URLs for references that had been linked via
1377:
Yes, I've been reading this book over the past few days. I should be done shortly.
935:
The section about "Treaty" should be reworded to reflect the fact that although the
584:
1533:
1504:
1441:
1398:
1364:
1242:
1074:
1002:
964:
899:
657:
590:
1363:
Thanks for your comments so far. Just let me know what else is needed. Cheers, --
743:
Talk:American
Creation: Triumphs and Tragedies at the Founding of the Republic/GA1
264:
1312:
The only applicable image is the cover, and the image is labeled for fair use.
580:
339:
147:
1419:
was met. I intend to finish this GA review on time as originally predicted.
1541:
1522:
1449:
1434:
1406:
1392:
1372:
1327:
1260:
1214:
1169:
1102:
1082:
1068:
1031:
1010:
995:
972:
958:
860:
767:
745:. The edit link for this section can be used to add comments to the review.
665:
169:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of topics relating to the
574:
556:
1154:
The article includes a short synopsis as well as some critical reaction.
932:
There are a couple points in the summary that will need to be changed:
604:. To participate in the project, please visit its page, where you can
255:
WikiProject Military history - American Revolutionary War task force
1499:
had an option for a second URL, this would be the time to use it.
275:
WikiProject Military history - U.S. military history task force
69:
15:
283:
263:
243:
1245:'s improvements, activity on this article has been slow.
526:|class=|importance=|UShistory=Yes|UShistory-importance=}}
361:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of the
435:
430:
425:
420:
59:
1471:. You might also include interviews of the author by
1530:
Fifteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution
1597:United States military history task force articles
1607:Unknown-importance United States History articles
1577:GA-Class United States articles of Low-importance
1275:and other media, where possible and appropriate.
1592:GA-Class United States military history articles
479:United States History articles needing infoboxes
466:United States History articles needing attention
45:. If it no longer meets these criteria, you can
616:. To improve this article, please refer to the
1587:American Revolutionary War task force articles
1622:Mid-importance United States History articles
1280:(images are tagged and non-free content have
8:
1582:GA-Class American Revolutionary War articles
375:Knowledge:WikiProject United States History
1612:WikiProject United States History articles
674:
612:. To use this banner, please refer to the
551:
454:Here are some tasks awaiting attention:
408:
378:Template:WikiProject United States History
307:
101:
845:The writing meets applicable guidelines.
492:Stub-Class United States History articles
610:discuss matters related to book articles
412:WikiProject United States History To-do:
1602:GA-Class United States History articles
705:
677:
618:relevant guideline for the type of work
553:
309:
103:
1572:Low-importance United States articles
7:
596:This article is within the scope of
496:Category:United States history stubs
355:This article is within the scope of
163:This article is within the scope of
75:
73:
210:Knowledge:WikiProject United States
92:It is of interest to the following
1617:WikiProject United States articles
213:Template:WikiProject United States
14:
515:WikiProject United States History
358:WikiProject United States History
41:. If you can improve it further,
1346:
1305:
1287:
1234:
1192:
1189:Fair representation without bias
1147:
1133:
919:
905:
891:
838:
804:
583:
573:
555:
445:
342:
332:
311:
150:
140:
105:
74:
19:
1567:GA-Class United States articles
1461:the Virginia Historical Society
1459:You might include reviews from
783:for what the criteria are, and
395:This article has been rated as
230:This article has been rated as
381:United States History articles
29:has been listed as one of the
1:
943:nullification of the treaty.
651:Going for Good Article status
369:and see a list of open tasks.
292:This article is supported by
272:This article is supported by
252:This article is supported by
1347:
1306:
1288:
1235:
1193:
1148:
1134:
920:
906:
892:
839:
805:
363:history of the United States
626:Knowledge:WikiProject Books
1648:
1632:WikiProject Books articles
1469:the Pittsbugh Post-Gazette
1087:Yes, that works. Thanks.
629:Template:WikiProject Books
401:project's importance scale
236:project's importance scale
1328:01:21, 29 June 2013 (UTC)
1261:01:21, 29 June 2013 (UTC)
1170:01:21, 29 June 2013 (UTC)
963:Expanded accordingly. --
768:18:30, 28 June 2013 (UTC)
666:18:55, 14 June 2013 (UTC)
568:
524:WikiProject United States
407:
394:
327:
291:
271:
251:
229:
166:WikiProject United States
135:
100:
1542:21:22, 6 July 2013 (UTC)
1523:20:58, 6 July 2013 (UTC)
1450:12:52, 5 July 2013 (UTC)
1435:04:43, 5 July 2013 (UTC)
1407:17:39, 3 July 2013 (UTC)
1393:17:35, 3 July 2013 (UTC)
1373:13:47, 3 July 2013 (UTC)
1215:20:58, 6 July 2013 (UTC)
1103:20:58, 6 July 2013 (UTC)
1083:19:22, 6 July 2013 (UTC)
1069:18:58, 6 July 2013 (UTC)
1032:18:58, 6 July 2013 (UTC)
1011:12:52, 5 July 2013 (UTC)
996:04:43, 5 July 2013 (UTC)
973:12:52, 5 July 2013 (UTC)
959:04:43, 5 July 2013 (UTC)
861:18:58, 6 July 2013 (UTC)
295:WikiProject U.S. history
171:United States of America
1557:Knowledge good articles
794:reasonably well written
1627:GA-Class Book articles
1479:in the External links.
787:for what they are not)
288:
268:
248:
216:United States articles
82:This article is rated
1562:History good articles
1269:It is illustrated by
1181:neutral point of view
1119:broad in its coverage
517:|class=|importance=}}
372:United States History
319:United States History
287:
267:
247:
39:good article criteria
33:History good articles
1477:Vermont Public Radio
350:United States portal
158:United States portal
1282:fair use rationales
184:Articles Requested!
1231:No edit wars, etc.
937:Treaty of New York
871:factually accurate
289:
269:
249:
88:content assessment
1497:Template:Cite web
1493:HighBeam Research
1485:subaltern studies
1300:suitable captions
1048:, and ultimately
886:reference section
733:
732:
648:
647:
644:
643:
640:
639:
600:WikiProject Books
550:
549:
546:
545:
542:
541:
538:
537:
306:
305:
302:
301:
118:Revolutionary War
68:
67:
64:
57:: July 6, 2013. (
27:American Creation
1639:
1521:
1518:
1512:
1433:
1430:
1424:
1391:
1388:
1382:
1350:
1349:
1326:
1323:
1317:
1309:
1308:
1291:
1290:
1259:
1256:
1250:
1238:
1237:
1213:
1210:
1204:
1196:
1195:
1168:
1165:
1159:
1151:
1150:
1137:
1136:
1101:
1098:
1092:
1067:
1064:
1058:
1030:
1027:
1021:
994:
991:
985:
957:
954:
948:
923:
922:
909:
908:
900:reliable sources
895:
894:
859:
856:
850:
842:
841:
808:
807:
687:Copyvio detector
675:
634:
633:
630:
627:
624:
606:join the project
593:
588:
587:
577:
570:
569:
559:
552:
527:
518:
449:
442:
441:
409:
383:
382:
379:
376:
373:
352:
347:
346:
345:
336:
329:
328:
323:
315:
308:
218:
217:
214:
211:
208:
160:
155:
154:
153:
144:
137:
136:
131:
128:
122:Military history
109:
102:
85:
79:
78:
77:
70:
62:
60:Reviewed version
51:
23:
16:
1647:
1646:
1642:
1641:
1640:
1638:
1637:
1636:
1547:
1546:
1516:
1510:
1508:
1428:
1422:
1420:
1386:
1380:
1378:
1321:
1315:
1313:
1296:appropriate use
1254:
1248:
1246:
1208:
1202:
1200:
1178:It follows the
1163:
1157:
1155:
1096:
1090:
1088:
1062:
1056:
1054:
1025:
1019:
1017:
989:
983:
981:
952:
946:
944:
854:
848:
846:
737:This review is
729:
701:
673:
653:
631:
628:
625:
622:
621:
589:
582:
534:
521:
512:
440:
380:
377:
374:
371:
370:
348:
343:
341:
321:
215:
212:
209:
206:
205:
204:
190:Become a Member
156:
151:
149:
129:
115:
86:on Knowledge's
83:
58:
12:
11:
5:
1645:
1643:
1635:
1634:
1629:
1624:
1619:
1614:
1609:
1604:
1599:
1594:
1589:
1584:
1579:
1574:
1569:
1564:
1559:
1549:
1548:
1545:
1544:
1511:Chris Troutman
1501:
1500:
1489:
1480:
1453:
1452:
1423:Chris Troutman
1416:
1415:
1414:
1413:
1412:
1411:
1410:
1409:
1381:Chris Troutman
1358:
1357:
1356:
1355:
1354:
1353:
1334:
1333:
1332:
1331:
1330:
1316:Chris Troutman
1267:
1266:
1265:
1264:
1263:
1249:Chris Troutman
1221:
1220:
1219:
1218:
1217:
1203:Chris Troutman
1176:
1175:
1174:
1173:
1172:
1158:Chris Troutman
1114:
1113:
1112:
1111:
1110:
1109:
1108:
1107:
1106:
1105:
1091:Chris Troutman
1057:Chris Troutman
1038:
1037:
1036:
1035:
1034:
1020:Chris Troutman
984:Chris Troutman
977:
976:
975:
947:Chris Troutman
927:
926:
925:
924:
898:(citations to
867:
866:
865:
864:
863:
849:Chris Troutman
789:
788:
754:Chris troutman
748:
747:
731:
730:
728:
727:
722:
717:
711:
708:
707:
703:
702:
700:
699:
697:External links
694:
689:
683:
680:
679:
672:
669:
652:
649:
646:
645:
642:
641:
638:
637:
635:
595:
594:
578:
566:
565:
560:
548:
547:
544:
543:
540:
539:
536:
535:
533:
532:
531:
530:
529:
528:
519:
506:
498:
481:
468:
453:
451:
450:
439:
438:
433:
428:
423:
417:
414:
413:
405:
404:
397:Mid-importance
393:
387:
386:
384:
367:the discussion
354:
353:
337:
325:
324:
322:Mid‑importance
316:
304:
303:
300:
299:
290:
280:
279:
270:
260:
259:
250:
240:
239:
232:Low-importance
228:
222:
221:
219:
203:
202:
197:
192:
187:
180:
178:Template Usage
174:
162:
161:
145:
133:
132:
130:Low‑importance
110:
98:
97:
91:
80:
66:
65:
50:
24:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
1644:
1633:
1630:
1628:
1625:
1623:
1620:
1618:
1615:
1613:
1610:
1608:
1605:
1603:
1600:
1598:
1595:
1593:
1590:
1588:
1585:
1583:
1580:
1578:
1575:
1573:
1570:
1568:
1565:
1563:
1560:
1558:
1555:
1554:
1552:
1543:
1539:
1535:
1531:
1527:
1526:
1525:
1524:
1519:
1513:
1506:
1503:I appreciate
1498:
1494:
1490:
1486:
1481:
1478:
1474:
1470:
1466:
1462:
1458:
1457:
1456:
1451:
1447:
1443:
1439:
1438:
1437:
1436:
1431:
1425:
1408:
1404:
1400:
1396:
1395:
1394:
1389:
1383:
1376:
1375:
1374:
1370:
1366:
1362:
1361:
1360:
1359:
1352:
1351:
1344:
1341:
1340:
1338:
1335:
1329:
1324:
1318:
1311:
1310:
1303:
1301:
1297:
1285:
1283:
1277:
1276:
1274:
1273:
1268:
1262:
1257:
1251:
1244:
1240:
1239:
1232:
1229:
1228:
1226:
1222:
1216:
1211:
1205:
1198:
1197:
1190:
1187:
1186:
1184:
1182:
1177:
1171:
1166:
1160:
1153:
1152:
1145:
1143:
1131:
1129:
1128:major aspects
1123:
1122:
1120:
1116:
1115:
1104:
1099:
1093:
1086:
1085:
1084:
1080:
1076:
1072:
1071:
1070:
1065:
1059:
1051:
1047:
1043:
1039:
1033:
1028:
1022:
1014:
1013:
1012:
1008:
1004:
999:
998:
997:
992:
986:
978:
974:
970:
966:
962:
961:
960:
955:
949:
942:
938:
934:
933:
931:
930:
929:
928:
917:
915:
903:
901:
889:
887:
881:
880:
878:
877:
872:
868:
862:
857:
851:
844:
843:
836:
834:
830:
826:
822:
818:
814:
802:
798:
797:
795:
791:
790:
786:
782:
778:
776:
772:
771:
770:
769:
765:
762:
759:
755:
752:
746:
744:
740:
735:
734:
726:
723:
721:
718:
716:
713:
712:
710:
709:
704:
698:
695:
693:
690:
688:
685:
684:
682:
681:
676:
670:
668:
667:
663:
659:
650:
636:
632:Book articles
619:
615:
614:documentation
611:
607:
603:
602:
601:
592:
586:
581:
579:
576:
572:
571:
567:
564:
561:
558:
554:
525:
520:
516:
511:
510:
508:
507:
505:
503:
499:
497:
493:
490:
488:
487:
482:
480:
477:
475:
474:
469:
467:
464:
462:
461:
456:
455:
452:
448:
444:
443:
437:
434:
432:
429:
427:
424:
422:
419:
418:
416:
415:
411:
410:
406:
402:
398:
392:
389:
388:
385:
368:
364:
360:
359:
351:
340:
338:
335:
331:
330:
326:
320:
317:
314:
310:
297:
296:
286:
282:
281:
277:
276:
266:
262:
261:
257:
256:
246:
242:
241:
237:
233:
227:
224:
223:
220:
207:United States
201:
198:
196:
193:
191:
188:
186:
185:
181:
179:
176:
175:
172:
168:
167:
159:
148:
146:
143:
139:
138:
134:
127:
123:
119:
114:
113:United States
111:
108:
104:
99:
95:
89:
81:
72:
71:
61:
56:
55:
48:
44:
40:
36:
35:
34:
28:
25:
22:
18:
17:
1505:User:Khazar2
1502:
1465:BookReporter
1454:
1417:
1342:
1336:
1293:
1279:
1270:
1243:User:Khazar2
1230:
1224:
1188:
1179:
1139:
1125:
1118:
940:
911:
897:
883:
874:
870:
810:
800:
793:
773:
760:
750:
749:
736:
725:Instructions
654:
598:
597:
591:Books portal
501:
500:
484:
483:
471:
470:
458:
457:
396:
356:
293:
273:
253:
231:
195:Project Talk
183:
164:
94:WikiProjects
52:
43:please do so
31:
30:
26:
1241:Except for
825:word choice
739:transcluded
1551:Categories
980:solution.
876:verifiable
692:Authorship
678:GA toolbox
37:under the
1488:approach.
1343:Pass/Fail
1046:Duportail
751:Reviewer:
715:Templates
706:Reviewing
671:GA Review
941:de facto
764:contribs
720:Criteria
84:GA-class
47:reassess
1534:Khazar2
1442:Khazar2
1399:Khazar2
1365:Khazar2
1337:Overall
1142:focused
1075:Khazar2
1042:Maxwell
1003:Khazar2
965:Khazar2
829:fiction
801:(prose)
658:Khazar2
473:Infobox
460:Cleanup
426:history
399:on the
234:on the
126:History
1473:BookTV
1467:, and
1272:images
1225:stable
1223:It is
1183:policy
1117:It is
1050:Greene
869:It is
831:, and
821:layout
792:It is
777:review
200:Alerts
90:scale.
54:Review
1298:with
833:lists
779:(see
741:from
623:Books
563:Books
502:Other
486:Stubs
436:purge
431:watch
1538:talk
1517:talk
1475:and
1446:talk
1429:talk
1403:talk
1387:talk
1369:talk
1322:talk
1255:talk
1209:talk
1164:talk
1097:talk
1079:talk
1063:talk
1026:talk
1007:talk
990:talk
969:talk
953:talk
873:and
855:talk
817:lead
815:for
785:here
781:here
758:talk
662:talk
608:and
421:edit
813:MoS
391:Mid
226:Low
49:it.
1553::
1540:)
1463:,
1448:)
1405:)
1371:)
1345::
1339::
1304::
1292:b
1286::
1278:a
1233::
1227:.
1191::
1185:.
1146::
1138:b
1132::
1124:a
1121:.
1081:)
1044:,
1009:)
971:)
918::
914:OR
910:c
904::
896:b
890::
882:a
879:.
837::
827:,
823:,
819:,
809:b
803::
799:a
796:.
775:GA
766:)
664:)
522:{{
513:{{
494:,
124:/
120:/
116::
63:).
1536:(
1520:)
1514:(
1444:(
1432:)
1426:(
1401:(
1390:)
1384:(
1367:(
1325:)
1319:(
1302:)
1294:(
1284:)
1258:)
1252:(
1212:)
1206:(
1167:)
1161:(
1144:)
1140:(
1130:)
1126:(
1100:)
1094:(
1077:(
1066:)
1060:(
1029:)
1023:(
1005:(
993:)
987:(
967:(
956:)
950:(
916:)
912:(
902:)
888:)
884:(
858:)
852:(
835:)
811:(
761:·
756:(
660:(
620:.
504::
489::
476::
463::
403:.
298:.
278:.
258:.
238:.
96::
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
