883:"evolution as revolution" argument that helps explain why early US institutions were so conservative, modeled on the British example. The US had one of the most conservative revolutions in human history, especially compared to what happened in France only several years later. The fact that women's rights, Native American settlement, and slavery were not adequately addressed stems from this deliberately slow-paced evolution from the British monarchy and society. Second, some reviews have examined this book in comparison to
748:
707:
689:
636:
594:
549:
535:
321:
307:
293:
240:
206:
49:
895:. I am under the impression that free use of HighBeam is not widespread across the wiki. I burned a 7-day free trial in order to examine the references for this review. I don't know how long the free links will be accessible in comparison to the paid HighBeam service, so I think keeping both URLs makes sense, although it does double the sources. If
818:
I apologize to the aggregate that this review has taken as long as it has. It seemed to me that I should read the book upon which the article is written. Once I had started to read, it occurred to me that I may as well give as thorough an examination as I could rather than simply ensure GA criteria
415:
It's my impression that
Madison as a reluctant Federalist wanted a stronger central government only for purposes of strong emergency response. While Ellis makes the point about blurred sovereignty being the successful argument, I suspect that it was a compromise that no one really wanted as it was
882:
Sadly, the reviews of this book have been journalistic, not academic. I certainly hope there's some academic analysis of this book, as this article would benefit. There are two academic points that could also be discussed here when there's the necessary academic study. First, Ellis posits the
379:
The "Argument" section should explain that
Madison overcame Henry by pointing out how the Confederation government failed during the war. The current verbiage is confusing and implies that shared sovereignty and what we now call federalism was the winning play, when Madison never sought that
133:
129:
114:
452:
who advocated holding the countryside and forcing the
British to continue the occupation and attempt to strike the Continental Army. According to Ellis, Washington never made up his mind about the strategy and waited until the British attacked into the Carolinas.
106:
122:
99:
400:
Expanded to include both. Ellis does call the blurred sovereignty part "the clinching argument" (124), so it seems worth emphasizing here. Does this address your concern? Thanks for both of these suggestions. --
887:
academics that have raked the dead white guys over the coals as of late. Ellis's book does not pointedly reject the subaltern criticisms of the founders but he does differ with those academics about their
929:
54:
473:
I've attempted to rewrite this to address your concerns; let me know if you find it sufficient, or what wording you would prefer. Thanks again for the suggestions. --
87:
907:'s acceptance of me as a recruitee to perform this review. Certainly I need the training experience and without nominator consent, I would have been out of luck.
840:
No worries--I've been in plenty of 2- or 3-week GA reviews. There's no deadline, and I really appreciate both your thoroughness and the good suggestions above. --
77:
932:
also passed). I'm unlikely to try to take this up to A-class or FA myself, but with luck a future editor can make use of these good suggestions. Cheers, --
797:
Wow, you're going above and beyond! Well, hope you enjoy it--I really appreciate your doing that. There's no rush on this, obviously, so take your time. --
441:
872:
23:
59:
864:
855:
I approve this as a GA. I'd like to make some other comments for work to be performed concurrent with a review at the A-class or FA level:
163:
416:
too weak for the New
England merchant class and too strong for the Southern planter class. Regardless, your edits addressed my concerns.
440:
In the "Winter" section, Washington never changed strategy. Ellis makes plain that
Washington was unsure about how to proceed. It was
174:
868:
180:
82:
313:
884:
876:
445:
695:
212:
915:
827:
785:
720:
653:
607:
562:
495:
461:
424:
388:
351:
253:
157:
275:
232:
17:
909:
821:
779:
714:
647:
601:
556:
489:
455:
418:
382:
345:
247:
153:
860:
339:
was signed successfully, that
Georgian intransigence and McGillivray's double-dealing led to the
336:
599:
This article fairly depicts the book's contents and mentions journalistic reviews of the book.
937:
896:
892:
845:
802:
768:
478:
406:
368:
671:
541:
449:
220:
527:
928:
I appreciate your taking the time to review! It's turned into my first-ever two-GA day (
580:
285:
216:
184:
699:
681:
228:
224:
891:
I have twice added the free and direct URLs for references that had been linked via
777:
Yes, I've been reading this book over the past few days. I should be done shortly.
335:
The section about "Treaty" should be reworded to reflect the fact that although the
933:
904:
841:
798:
764:
642:
474:
402:
364:
299:
763:
Thanks for your comments so far. Just let me know what else is needed. Cheers, --
24:
Talk:American
Creation: Triumphs and Tragedies at the Founding of the Republic/GA1
941:
922:
849:
834:
806:
792:
772:
727:
660:
614:
569:
502:
482:
468:
431:
410:
395:
372:
358:
260:
167:
712:
The only applicable image is the cover, and the image is labeled for fair use.
819:
was met. I intend to finish this GA review on time as originally predicted.
554:
The article includes a short synopsis as well as some critical reaction.
332:
There are a couple points in the summary that will need to be changed:
899:
had an option for a second URL, this would be the time to use it.
645:'s improvements, activity on this article has been slow.
141:
110:
871:. You might also include interviews of the author by
930:
Fifteenth
Amendment to the United States Constitution
675:and other media, where possible and appropriate.
680:(images are tagged and non-free content have
8:
37:
245:The writing meets applicable guidelines.
68:
40:
7:
31:
746:
705:
687:
634:
592:
589:Fair representation without bias
547:
533:
319:
305:
291:
238:
204:
861:the Virginia Historical Society
859:You might include reviews from
183:for what the criteria are, and
1:
343:nullification of the treaty.
747:
706:
688:
635:
593:
548:
534:
320:
306:
292:
239:
205:
958:
869:the Pittsbugh Post-Gazette
487:Yes, that works. Thanks.
728:01:21, 29 June 2013 (UTC)
661:01:21, 29 June 2013 (UTC)
570:01:21, 29 June 2013 (UTC)
363:Expanded accordingly. --
168:18:30, 28 June 2013 (UTC)
942:21:22, 6 July 2013 (UTC)
923:20:58, 6 July 2013 (UTC)
850:12:52, 5 July 2013 (UTC)
835:04:43, 5 July 2013 (UTC)
807:17:39, 3 July 2013 (UTC)
793:17:35, 3 July 2013 (UTC)
773:13:47, 3 July 2013 (UTC)
615:20:58, 6 July 2013 (UTC)
503:20:58, 6 July 2013 (UTC)
483:19:22, 6 July 2013 (UTC)
469:18:58, 6 July 2013 (UTC)
432:18:58, 6 July 2013 (UTC)
411:12:52, 5 July 2013 (UTC)
396:04:43, 5 July 2013 (UTC)
373:12:52, 5 July 2013 (UTC)
359:04:43, 5 July 2013 (UTC)
261:18:58, 6 July 2013 (UTC)
194:reasonably well written
879:in the External links.
187:for what they are not)
18:Talk:American Creation
669:It is illustrated by
581:neutral point of view
519:broad in its coverage
877:Vermont Public Radio
682:fair use rationales
631:No edit wars, etc.
337:Treaty of New York
271:factually accurate
897:Template:Cite web
893:HighBeam Research
885:subaltern studies
700:suitable captions
448:, and ultimately
286:reference section
96:
95:
22:(Redirected from
949:
921:
918:
912:
833:
830:
824:
791:
788:
782:
750:
749:
726:
723:
717:
709:
708:
691:
690:
659:
656:
650:
638:
637:
613:
610:
604:
596:
595:
568:
565:
559:
551:
550:
537:
536:
501:
498:
492:
467:
464:
458:
430:
427:
421:
394:
391:
385:
357:
354:
348:
323:
322:
309:
308:
300:reliable sources
295:
294:
259:
256:
250:
242:
241:
208:
207:
146:
137:
118:
50:Copyvio detector
38:
27:
957:
956:
952:
951:
950:
948:
947:
946:
916:
910:
908:
828:
822:
820:
786:
780:
778:
721:
715:
713:
696:appropriate use
654:
648:
646:
608:
602:
600:
578:It follows the
563:
557:
555:
496:
490:
488:
462:
456:
454:
425:
419:
417:
389:
383:
381:
352:
346:
344:
254:
248:
246:
127:
104:
98:
92:
64:
36:
29:
28:
21:
20:
12:
11:
5:
955:
953:
945:
944:
911:Chris Troutman
901:
900:
889:
880:
853:
852:
823:Chris Troutman
816:
815:
814:
813:
812:
811:
810:
809:
781:Chris Troutman
758:
757:
756:
755:
754:
753:
734:
733:
732:
731:
730:
716:Chris Troutman
667:
666:
665:
664:
663:
649:Chris Troutman
621:
620:
619:
618:
617:
603:Chris Troutman
576:
575:
574:
573:
572:
558:Chris Troutman
514:
513:
512:
511:
510:
509:
508:
507:
506:
505:
491:Chris Troutman
457:Chris Troutman
438:
437:
436:
435:
434:
420:Chris Troutman
384:Chris Troutman
377:
376:
375:
347:Chris Troutman
327:
326:
325:
324:
298:(citations to
267:
266:
265:
264:
263:
249:Chris Troutman
189:
188:
154:Chris troutman
147:
94:
93:
91:
90:
85:
80:
74:
71:
70:
66:
65:
63:
62:
60:External links
57:
52:
46:
43:
42:
35:
32:
30:
15:
14:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
954:
943:
939:
935:
931:
927:
926:
925:
924:
919:
913:
906:
903:I appreciate
898:
894:
890:
886:
881:
878:
874:
870:
866:
862:
858:
857:
856:
851:
847:
843:
839:
838:
837:
836:
831:
825:
808:
804:
800:
796:
795:
794:
789:
783:
776:
775:
774:
770:
766:
762:
761:
760:
759:
752:
751:
744:
741:
740:
738:
735:
729:
724:
718:
711:
710:
703:
701:
697:
685:
683:
677:
676:
674:
673:
668:
662:
657:
651:
644:
640:
639:
632:
629:
628:
626:
622:
616:
611:
605:
598:
597:
590:
587:
586:
584:
582:
577:
571:
566:
560:
553:
552:
545:
543:
531:
529:
528:major aspects
523:
522:
520:
516:
515:
504:
499:
493:
486:
485:
484:
480:
476:
472:
471:
470:
465:
459:
451:
447:
443:
439:
433:
428:
422:
414:
413:
412:
408:
404:
399:
398:
397:
392:
386:
378:
374:
370:
366:
362:
361:
360:
355:
349:
342:
338:
334:
333:
331:
330:
329:
328:
317:
315:
303:
301:
289:
287:
281:
280:
278:
277:
272:
268:
262:
257:
251:
244:
243:
236:
234:
230:
226:
222:
218:
214:
202:
198:
197:
195:
191:
190:
186:
182:
178:
176:
172:
171:
170:
169:
165:
162:
159:
155:
152:
148:
145:
144:
140:
135:
131:
126:
125:
121:
116:
112:
108:
103:
102:
89:
86:
84:
81:
79:
76:
75:
73:
72:
67:
61:
58:
56:
53:
51:
48:
47:
45:
44:
39:
33:
25:
19:
905:User:Khazar2
902:
865:BookReporter
854:
817:
742:
736:
693:
679:
670:
643:User:Khazar2
630:
624:
588:
579:
539:
525:
518:
340:
311:
297:
283:
274:
270:
210:
200:
193:
173:
160:
150:
149:
142:
138:
124:Article talk
123:
119:
100:
97:
88:Instructions
641:Except for
225:word choice
111:visual edit
380:solution.
276:verifiable
55:Authorship
41:GA toolbox
888:approach.
743:Pass/Fail
446:Duportail
151:Reviewer:
78:Templates
69:Reviewing
34:GA Review
341:de facto
164:contribs
83:Criteria
934:Khazar2
842:Khazar2
799:Khazar2
765:Khazar2
737:Overall
542:focused
475:Khazar2
442:Maxwell
403:Khazar2
365:Khazar2
229:fiction
201:(prose)
134:history
115:history
101:Article
873:BookTV
867:, and
672:images
625:stable
623:It is
583:policy
517:It is
450:Greene
269:It is
231:, and
221:layout
192:It is
177:review
698:with
233:lists
179:(see
143:Watch
16:<
938:talk
917:talk
875:and
846:talk
829:talk
803:talk
787:talk
769:talk
722:talk
655:talk
609:talk
564:talk
497:talk
479:talk
463:talk
426:talk
407:talk
390:talk
369:talk
353:talk
273:and
255:talk
217:lead
215:for
185:here
181:here
158:talk
130:edit
107:edit
213:MoS
940:)
863:,
848:)
805:)
771:)
745::
739::
704::
692:b
686::
678:a
633::
627:.
591::
585:.
546::
538:b
532::
524:a
521:.
481:)
444:,
409:)
371:)
318::
314:OR
310:c
304::
296:b
290::
282:a
279:.
237::
227:,
223:,
219:,
209:b
203::
199:a
196:.
175:GA
166:)
132:|
113:|
109:|
936:(
920:)
914:(
844:(
832:)
826:(
801:(
790:)
784:(
767:(
725:)
719:(
702:)
694:(
684:)
658:)
652:(
612:)
606:(
567:)
561:(
544:)
540:(
530:)
526:(
500:)
494:(
477:(
466:)
460:(
429:)
423:(
405:(
393:)
387:(
367:(
356:)
350:(
316:)
312:(
302:)
288:)
284:(
258:)
252:(
235:)
211:(
161:·
156:(
139:·
136:)
128:(
120:·
117:)
105:(
26:)
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.