Knowledge

Talk:Al Hirschfeld Theatre/GA1

Source 📝

286:"The southern end of the lounge contains a seating area, with a niche enclosing a marble water fountain. The northern end contains a staircase descending directly into the orchestra seating, with a wrought-iron railing and ceiling lantern." Recommend replacing one instance of the word "contains". There are also other instances (for example, "The second-westernmost arch contains a double metal door at the ground story, while the westernmost (right) arch contains a window at the ground story." 721: 700: 684: 659: 642: 623: 607: 587: 575: 559: 547: 539: 512: 488: 42: 223:
Earwig's Copyvio Detector identifies a 36.3% chance of copyright violation with the Landmarks Preservation Commission, 27.0% with an article on the theatre in Playbill and 23.7% with the item on the theatre in IMDB. It seems that the overlap with the latter two are mainly the list of productions so
230:
I have fixed some instances. However, there are many places in the text where it is difficult to use active voice, such as part of the design section. In other cases, active and passive voice are used together so the sentences don't all have the same grammatical pattern; that can lead to a similar
343:"the latter of which ran at the Beck for six months." Is it necessary to repeat "at the Beck"? Also please take a look at the previous paragraph where "the Beck" features frequently. 324:"The balcony level (also known as the mezzanine)" The term messanine was used previously. Does this describe the same feature? If so, I suggest explaining this at the first mention. 47: 80: 126: 70: 122: 678: 52: 107: 227:
My grammar checker highlights that there is a high usage of the passive voice in the article. I suggest reducing these to make it more approachable.
506: 498: 99: 694: 156: 204:
The article is of substantial length, 5,108 words of readable prose, plus a referenced list of notable productions and an infobox.
690: 533: 502: 632: 75: 553: 409:
that this is a "wonderful article" with "phenomenal research". Please ping me when you would like me to take another look.
485:
the prose is clear, concise, and understandable to an appropriately broad audience; spelling and grammar are correct;
115: 17: 494: 208: 617: 525: 170: 713: 639:
it represents viewpoints fairly and without editorial bias, giving due weight to different points of view.
613: 601: 581: 731: 727: 457: 453: 414: 410: 384: 380: 254: 250: 192:
This is a stable and well-written article. 96.7% of authorship is by Epicgenius. It is currently ranked
178: 174: 150: 92: 569: 565: 436: 406: 370: 351: 332: 313: 294: 275: 240: 656:
it does not change significantly from day to day because of any ongoing edit war or content dispute.
232: 267:
Should "the center section includes a stair" read "a flight of stairs" or is it a single stair.
671: 426: 146: 709: 447: 432: 400: 366: 347: 328: 309: 290: 271: 236: 166: 305:"In addition, the seats were upholstered". I suggest that "in addition" is superfluous. 365:
This isn't quoted from the reference. However, I'm not sure what to replace this with.
735: 461: 440: 418: 388: 374: 355: 336: 317: 298: 279: 258: 244: 182: 160: 270:
It is a single staircase (technically, the staircase has a landing in the middle).
379:
Fair enough. I am not sure it is strictly encyclopaedic but I think that is OK.
169:. If my experience is anything to go by, it is likely to be close to being a 431:
Thanks for your review. I have addressed the comments you mentioned above.
362:"epicenter" is an interesting word choice. Is this a contemporary quote? 220:
Images have appropriate licensing and public domain or CC tags.
677:
images are tagged with their copyright statuses, and valid
207:
It is written in a summary style, consistent with relevant
536:, presented in accordance with the layout style guideline; 165:
This looks like another well written article nominated by
134: 103: 249:
That is fair. It is a fine balancing act sometimes.
584:
on the topic without going into unnecessary detail.
674:and other media, where possible and appropriate. 544:all inline citations are from reliable sources; 217:References appear to be from reputable sources. 452:Excellent work. I will start my review now. 8: 616:without going into unnecessary detail (see 712:. This article meets the criteria to be a 30: 61: 33: 224:this does not constitute a violation. 7: 405:I concur with the statement made by 231:situation as described in the essay 681:are provided for non-free content; 24: 719: 698: 682: 657: 640: 621: 605: 585: 573: 557: 545: 537: 510: 486: 346:I have removed the repetitions. 474:The six good article criteria: 173:. I will start my review soon. 214:Citations seem to be thorough. 1: 736:08:07, 23 January 2022 (UTC) 720: 699: 683: 658: 641: 622: 606: 586: 574: 558: 546: 538: 511: 487: 462:08:04, 23 January 2022 (UTC) 441:20:37, 22 January 2022 (UTC) 419:19:33, 22 January 2022 (UTC) 389:08:04, 23 January 2022 (UTC) 375:20:37, 22 January 2022 (UTC) 356:20:37, 22 January 2022 (UTC) 337:20:37, 22 January 2022 (UTC) 327:Yes, I have clarified this. 318:20:37, 22 January 2022 (UTC) 299:20:37, 22 January 2022 (UTC) 280:20:37, 22 January 2022 (UTC) 259:08:04, 23 January 2022 (UTC) 245:20:37, 22 January 2022 (UTC) 183:10:58, 19 January 2022 (UTC) 161:10:58, 19 January 2022 (UTC) 751: 18:Talk:Al Hirschfeld Theatre 289:I have rephrased these. 691:relevant to the topic 633:neutral point of view 596:broad in its coverage 493:it complies with the 614:focused on the topic 566:copyright violations 554:no original research 679:fair use rationales 233:Knowledge:Proseline 521:factually accurate 708:Congratulations, 695:suitable captions 600:it addresses the 534:reference section 478:It is reasonable 89: 88: 742: 723: 722: 702: 701: 686: 685: 661: 660: 644: 643: 625: 624: 609: 608: 589: 588: 577: 576: 561: 560: 549: 548: 541: 540: 514: 513: 490: 489: 451: 430: 404: 209:Manuals of Style 139: 130: 111: 43:Copyvio detector 31: 750: 749: 745: 744: 743: 741: 740: 739: 564:it contains no 497:guidelines for 495:Manual of Style 472: 445: 424: 407:No Swan So Fine 398: 190: 120: 97: 91: 85: 57: 29: 22: 21: 20: 12: 11: 5: 748: 746: 706: 705: 704: 703: 687: 664: 663: 662: 647: 646: 645: 628: 627: 626: 610: 592: 591: 590: 578: 562: 550: 542: 532:it contains a 517: 516: 515: 491: 471: 468: 467: 466: 465: 464: 396: 395: 394: 393: 392: 391: 360: 359: 358: 341: 340: 339: 322: 321: 320: 303: 302: 301: 284: 283: 282: 265: 264: 263: 262: 261: 225: 221: 218: 215: 212: 205: 189: 186: 140: 87: 86: 84: 83: 78: 73: 67: 64: 63: 59: 58: 56: 55: 53:External links 50: 45: 39: 36: 35: 28: 25: 23: 15: 14: 13: 10: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 747: 738: 737: 733: 729: 726: 717: 715: 711: 696: 692: 688: 680: 676: 675: 673: 669: 665: 655: 654: 652: 648: 638: 637: 635: 634: 629: 619: 618:summary style 615: 611: 604:of the topic. 603: 599: 598: 597: 593: 583: 579: 571: 567: 563: 555: 551: 543: 535: 531: 530: 528: 527: 522: 518: 508: 504: 500: 496: 492: 484: 483: 481: 477: 476: 475: 469: 463: 459: 455: 449: 444: 443: 442: 438: 434: 428: 423: 422: 421: 420: 416: 412: 408: 402: 390: 386: 382: 378: 377: 376: 372: 368: 364: 363: 361: 357: 353: 349: 345: 344: 342: 338: 334: 330: 326: 325: 323: 319: 315: 311: 307: 306: 304: 300: 296: 292: 288: 287: 285: 281: 277: 273: 269: 268: 266: 260: 256: 252: 248: 247: 246: 242: 238: 234: 229: 228: 226: 222: 219: 216: 213: 210: 206: 203: 202: 201: 199: 195: 187: 185: 184: 180: 176: 172: 168: 163: 162: 158: 155: 152: 148: 145: 141: 138: 137: 133: 128: 124: 119: 118: 114: 109: 105: 101: 96: 95: 82: 79: 77: 74: 72: 69: 68: 66: 65: 60: 54: 51: 49: 46: 44: 41: 40: 38: 37: 32: 26: 19: 724: 718: 714:Good Article 707: 667: 650: 631: 602:main aspects 595: 552:it contains 524: 520: 480:well written 479: 473: 397: 197: 196:class and a 193: 191: 171:Good Article 164: 153: 143: 142: 135: 131: 117:Article talk 116: 112: 93: 90: 81:Instructions 728:simongraham 693:, and have 689:images are 668:illustrated 507:word choice 454:simongraham 427:Simongraham 411:simongraham 381:simongraham 251:simongraham 175:simongraham 147:Simongraham 104:visual edit 710:Epicgenius 570:plagiarism 526:verifiable 470:Assessment 448:Epicgenius 433:Epicgenius 401:Epicgenius 367:Epicgenius 348:Epicgenius 329:Epicgenius 310:Epicgenius 291:Epicgenius 272:Epicgenius 237:Epicgenius 167:Epicgenius 48:Authorship 34:GA toolbox 630:It has a 612:it stays 580:it stays 308:Removed. 200:nominee. 144:Reviewer: 71:Templates 62:Reviewing 27:GA Review 188:Comments 157:contribs 76:Criteria 582:focused 127:history 108:history 94:Article 672:images 666:It is 651:stable 649:It is 594:It is 519:It is 503:layout 194:Start 136:Watch 16:< 732:talk 725:Pass 568:nor 523:and 505:and 499:lead 458:talk 437:talk 415:talk 385:talk 371:talk 352:talk 333:talk 314:talk 295:talk 276:talk 255:talk 241:talk 179:talk 151:talk 123:edit 100:edit 670:by 198:DYK 734:) 716:. 653:. 636:. 620:). 529:. 501:, 482:. 460:) 439:) 417:) 387:) 373:) 354:) 335:) 316:) 297:) 278:) 257:) 243:) 235:. 181:) 159:) 125:| 106:| 102:| 730:( 697:. 572:; 556:; 509:. 456:( 450:: 446:@ 435:( 429:: 425:@ 413:( 403:: 399:@ 383:( 369:( 350:( 331:( 312:( 293:( 274:( 253:( 239:( 211:. 177:( 154:· 149:( 132:· 129:) 121:( 113:· 110:) 98:(

Index

Talk:Al Hirschfeld Theatre
Copyvio detector
Authorship
External links
Templates
Criteria
Instructions
Article
edit
visual edit
history
Article talk
edit
history
Watch
Simongraham
talk
contribs
10:58, 19 January 2022 (UTC)
Epicgenius
Good Article
simongraham
talk
10:58, 19 January 2022 (UTC)
Manuals of Style
Knowledge:Proseline
Epicgenius
talk
20:37, 22 January 2022 (UTC)
simongraham

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.