Talk:Arab world/Archive 2 - Knowledge (XXG)

1583:, which clearly stipulates that viewpoints must be cited in proportion to their prominence in reliable sources. So unless you can somehow prove that the language-based definition of the Arab world is at least as prominent in reliable sources (which will take some doing), it cannot be cited on par with the mainstream definition of the Arab world. The only conceivable workaround that is to include two additional section headings: the first titled "Standard territorial definition" (where the standard territorial definition of the Arab world is cited), and the second titled "Ancillary linguistic definition" under which the ancillary linguistic definition can be cited. But here too, WP:WEIGHT must still be respected in terms of not attempting to relegate certain League of Arab States members to the same level as territories which are not commonly associated with the Arab world (i.e. the layout in the Language section must be preserved). I have therefore adjusted the areas in question to accommodate your concerns. 1493:

correctly changed to "Territory"). In the second place, the alternative linguistic basis is considered (under the heading "Language"). There is a substantial body of literature that supports an (ethno-)linguistic basis for the definition of the Arab world, although it is certainly less common than the standard territorial definition. However, it is certainly not fringe. A general point on language in the Arab world is made in the first paragraph of the Demographics section. The paragraph reflecting Fishkopf (inter alia) should be moved back to the beginning of the Language section, as an introduction to that section: "As an alternative to, or in combination with, this standard territorial definition , the Arab world may be defined" on various ethno-linguistic bases. I am happy for an additional sentence indicating that this is subsidiary to (insofar as it is less common than) the standard territorial definition to be inserted. This should address your concern about

1389:). In fact, the source states that the Arab world is traditionally coextensive with the territories in the Arab League i.e. the standard definition of the Arab world: "No universally accepted definition of 'the Arab world' exists, but it is generally assumed to include the twenty-two countries belonging to the Arab League that have a combined population of about 280 million". It just adds that, for the purposes of the book, it extends that standard definition to include Arab-speaking populations in the diaspora or places where use of Arabic is at least considered to be critical to identity: "For the purposes of this introduction, this territorial definition is combined with a linguistic one (use of the Arabic language, or its recognition as critical to identity), and thereby extended into multiple diasporas, especially the Americas, Europe, Southeast Asia, West Africa, and Australia". I have adjusted the text and layout to reflect this. In future, per 3135:

it's repeatedly referred to as an "Arab state". Chad has far more speakers of Arabic than Somalia, but is not considered an Arab country because it's not a member of the Arab League - the article begins to look like it's about the Arab League rather than about the Arab World. By the same logic that Somalia is considered an Arab state, one would argue that Iran should then have more of a case - given the prevalence of Arabic in Iran and the existence of an actual ethnic Arab population that's actually native to Iran, as compared to Somalia's tiny population of non-native Arab traders. Indeed, Eritrea likely has a larger fraction of Arabic speakers than Somalia. Knowledge (XXG) should be informative and neutral, but a quick look at the pages dealing with the Horn of Africa leaves one with the distinct impression that these pages are being used to spread some sort of pan-ethnic propaganda rather than actual knowledge.

1520:

include the twenty-two countries belonging to the Arab League that have a combined population of about 280 million". Strictly for the purposes of the introduction of his book, the author just extends that standard definition to include Arab-speaking populations in the diaspora or places where use of Arabic is at least considered to be critical to identity: "For the purposes of this introduction, this territorial definition is combined with a linguistic one (use of the Arabic language, or its recognition as critical to identity), and thereby extended into multiple diasporas, especially the Americas, Europe, Southeast Asia, West Africa, and Australia". And this is what the page now does -- cites the standard definition of the Arab world in proportion to its prominence, with the ancillary language-based definition in an appropriately subordinate position in the Definition section.

4230:

the Arab World, i.e. a country where the majority language or at least one major language is Arabic. To me, this seems to be the case of Somalia - it is of course a member of the League, but up to which point it is an "Arab country" or would have been considered such before the League was founded? The text says that "Although Arabic is widely spoken by many people in the north and urban areas in the south, Somali is the most widely used language, and contains many Arabic loan words.". As the source is a print source, I can't check what it says exactly, but the loanword issue is irrelevant, as Somali is a very different language from Arabic and the loanwords are not enough as to suggest any similarity (probably Turkish and Farsi have more). Now, how much "widely spoken" is Arabic in Somalia? Knowledge (XXG)'s

1533: 1454:

themselves lineal descendants of the Phoenicians). The Arab League was conceived in the colonial period as a way of uniting and thus saving the so-called 'Arab Nation' from what was at the time perceived as an existential threat on the part of the Western colonial powers. I think the situation has been reversed somewhat nowadays. Many contemporary Occidental societies now, in turn, seem to feel under threat from what they perceive to be a neo-colonial Muslim expansion, the latter of which they believe is attempting to impose fundamentally different and alien customs and values on European communities. It's a tense period, to be sure.

1133:). South Sudan is not a part of the Arab League, so there's no question as to whether or not it is a part of the Arab world on that basis; it isn't. When Sudan was still unified, it was generally understood that it was the northern half that was "Arab" Sudan, whereas the southern half was "Nilotic" Sudan. In fact, this is what the Sudan Wiki article used to say in its intro before the referendum, I believe. Now that the two areas are no longer united as one country, the confusion has been cleared up. This is also why another user updated the Arab world map recently to remove South Sudan from the list of territories in the Arab world. 1646:

territorial definition is the standard definition (so no dispute there), but isn't it rather a question of whether a state or territory is "Arab", as defined by the AL. If so, the Arab world would not be by default coextensive with the AL, although it may well be (and indeed is so currently). Shouldn't the first sentence of the Standard territorial definition section read: " all countries that the Arab League deems "Arab" are generally considered part of the Arab world. At present, all such countries are members of the Arab League." This is then followed neatly by the AL's definition of "Arab" -- agree?

5075: 4950: 4530: 3619: 1615:. It consists of 21 countries and territories ". I understand that, as standard, the Arab world is generally defined as including 21 countries and territories (i.e., the Arab League member-states), but it also may include other elements, not least the Arab citizens of Israel. In light of the changes to the Definition section, would it not be better to say "The Arab world may refer to Arabic-speaking states, territories and populations . The standard definition of the Arab world consists of the 21 states and territories of the Arab League". 618:

example, a country where 2% of the population speaks Arabic is a country where Arabic is "more widely" spoken than a country with 1% Arabic speakers. This is patently misleading. On the other hand, "widely" and "not widely" are more distinctive and would help the reader draw a meaningful conclusion. To use the same example, Arabic spoken by only 2% of the population could not reasonably be held to be "widely spoken", although 30% might, and 50% or above would almost certainly. I have reverted the text accordingly.

1079:

official / national language, is sufficient for a country to be deemed part of the Arab world. South Sudan is (I think) unique in being eligible for Arab League membership but not actually a member. If the general rule I set out above strictly requires a country to be an Arab League member (and not merely eligible for membership) in order to be deemed part of the Arab world, then South Sudan would fail the test; but considering this unusual state of affairs, it is surely worth considering in the article.

1289:

be placed in the right section. As a non-Arab League state, one where Arabic is neither an official/national language nor widely spoken, the logical place to mention the territory it seems would be alongside areas such as Senegal, which have somewhat similar circumstances. Incidentally, although Arab League representatives have not opposed the idea of South Sudan joining the organization (the AL has a clause that if an Arab country splits in two, the splinter states have the right to join the League

1489:

cannot therefore be included in the definition of the Arab world as a consequence ("thus") of the inclusion in that definition of "states or territories in which the majority of the population speaks Arabic". Secondly, the "Arab diaspora" is not a homogeneous entity -- it is more correct to say "populations of the Arab diaspora", rather than the entire Arab diaspora as a blanket term, since a community of twenty Arabs living in, say, Samoa, would not typically be considered part of the Arab world.

1608:

inter alia, Fishkopf is referring to states and territories that have declared Arabic an official or national language, even though not widely spoken, since it is deemed "critical to their identity"; although perhaps he includes other groups too. I'm curious to learn what you think this phrase means. Notwithstanding that Fishkopf certainly uses the expression, might this be a fringe definition of "Arab" that would be better omitted from the article? Or is it common elsewhere in the literature?

4243:

would be in Morocco or Algeria or English in many African countries. Shouldn't the specific character of Somalia be explained in the article? If I'm not mistaken, it is the only country in the Arabic League (probably together with Comoros Islands) where Arabic is very little spoken, if any. In all other countries of the League, a local Arabic variant is the mother tongue of at least 50% of the population (Morocco), and normally closer to 80-90%, if not 99%. This seems to me worth mentioning.

2561:. That is, it is referring to the relative degree of Arabization rather than genealogical traditions or ancestry. Most Maghrebis and Egyptians are of related Hamitic ancestral stock, and many Near Easterners are descended from various local Semitic speaking populations rather than from the peninsular Arabs. All speak languages from the Afro-Asiatic (Hamitic-Semitic) family. Anyway, the table is on the population of the various Arab states, not on peninsular Arabs only. 2032:

odd. Perhaps a mention of why Malta, although speaking arabic and having some historic and cultural ties to the rest of the arab world, is not generally seen as part of the Arab world. I suspect that it is primarily on religious/cultural grounds, that is, it is hard to be a 'real' Arab unless you are also muslim. I might be wrong, but thats what I came looking for in this article: a good explanation of why certain countries are in and others are out.

4917: 31: 1536:. That includes the author's additional assertion that "For the purposes of this introduction, this territorial definition is combined with a linguistic one", a linguistic definition which he defines as "use of the Arabic language, or its recognition as critical to identity" (that's why the "critical to identity" aspect was cited; it's part and parcel of Frishkopf's language-based ancillary definition of the Arab world). 137:

some Arab countries. There is enough heat already. Mentioning that Israel is not a member of the Arab league and is not considered an Arab state would suffice. An article about the Arab world does not have to coincide with the opinions of some media of the Arab world, it should state unbiased facts, it should not be hostile towards any country. Please reply when you have a chance. This statement should change.

3920: 3868: 152:

would have a point. But the wording in no way implies (to someone reasonably fluent in English) any such thing. Your desired phrasing is non-nonsensical, insofar as the fact noted is the non-recognition of Israel as such, although it has a significant Arab identifying population, NOT non-recognition as an Arab state. To repeat, there is nothing biased or prejudicial in the mere noting of an objective fact. (

687:). As such, it's actually the earlier layout that was unsatisfactory because it relegated certain AL states to a similar status as countries like Chad, which are not, by contrast, acknowledged as being a part of the Arab world by most mainstream definitions. That said, I have added a reference for the statement that the Arab League states are generally acknowledged as being part of the Arab world. 5018: 4819: 4679: 4596: 4461: 4303: 4133: 4036: 3572: 3494: 2789:

included in the Arab World, of course it should--it's in the Arab League after all, which is what we've accepted as the definition. What I'm saying is some of the blanket statements, like this one, about Arab League member states are not true. You're right that my concerns are in some ways similar to the ones in section 2--I could have posted under that section, my apologies.

1350:

widely held (often in conjunction with the political definition). In any event, I think we need additional references to support this broad statement. In particular, rather than maps, I think that academic literature is required to give weight to this assertion. This is because maps reflect an inherent political bias, at the expense of other (e.g., ethno-linguistic) approaches.

4727: 593:). As you may have read from the preceding Talk section, there is consensus that language should be the basis of inclusion within the scope of the definition of the Arab world. However, it is unclear whether this should be (a) "widely spoken" (which, I would suggest, should mean "spoken by the majority or a significant minority") or (b) "national / official language". 2724:

Classical Arabic (symptomatic of Arabic diglossia). This contrasts with the situation in the wider Islamic world, where in contiguous Iran, Pakistan and Afghanistan, Arabic maintains its use in a similar script and retains its cultural prestige primarily as the language of religion and theological scholarship, but where Arabic is not spoken as a vernacular."

2212: 1922:

like the westerners have done for the past 500 years. This article is absolutely a racist and fascist article against the North Africans who ever never ever asked to be called Arabs. 6.why don't know why you Amazigh hate the arab, i am algerian and i love you amazigh but when i read comments like that i feel very sad for the gap that between us.

4648: 4355: 4202: 4084: 3542: 2425: 2267: 1238:

prerequisite for inclusion in the Arab world, South Sudan would fail. But this is not the point -- the question is whether, for the purposes of this article, it is worth considering South Sudan's (I think) unique circumstance in the context of a possible broader definition of the Arab world (i.e., broader than the Arab League's definition).

1689:

be considered fringe. I also don't have an issue with the redaction in the lede that: "The Arab world may refer to Arabic-speaking states, territories and populations . The standard definition of the Arab world includes the 21 states and territories of the Arab League". I have therefore adjusted the text to reflect this.

3134:

This article is so misleading as to be essentially useless. It keeps on harping about the Arab World being the countries of the Arab League, a circular sort of logic that's obviously nonsensical. Somalia has a small fraction of people that actually do speak Arabic, but on this and several other pages

1688:

belonging to the Arab League that have a combined population of about 280 million". That said, I have reviewed your other proposal and it seems more palatable. I interpret that Frishkopf reference to the recognition of Arabic as being "critical to identity" much as you have. As such, it could perhaps

1523:

The assertion in the article that "the Arab world may be defined as consisting of those states or territories in which the majority of the population speaks Arabic or regard it as critical to identity, and thus may also include the Arab diaspora" cannot be amended to "the Arab world may be defined as

1497:. An entire section on Language is not in keeping with the brief addressing of the subject in the opening paragraph of the Demographics section. In any event, the Language section is clearly addressing various states', territories' and populations' possible inclusion in definitions of the Arab world. 1349:

As you will have seen, I have updated the article to consider alternative definitions of the Arab world. As regards your statement that the Arab League definition is "standard", I would say that it was the "standard" political definition, but that alternative ethno-linguistic definitions are equally

1188:

South Sudan in the context of this article, even if only to point out that (a) the territory of South Sudan used to be included in the Arab League's definition of the Arab world, (b) South Sudan is eligible for Arab League membership (and, if it became a member, would be included in the Arab League's

410:

Possibly French in Lebanon. From Article 11 of the Lebanese constitution (my own translation of the French): "Arabic is the official national language. A law shall determine the cases in which the French language is to be used." French is a conditionally language - that is, laws determine when it can

151:

Eh? It is a political fact that Saudi Arabia and several other states do not recognise Israel. Merely noting that is not indicating that Israel is not a state, only that these states do not recognise it. An unbaised fact. If the article indicated in some fashion the position is/was "correct" then you

136:

This turns the linguistic (Arabic speaking countries) or demographic (countries/territories with Arab population) section into a political, hostile towards Israel statement. Despite Saudi non-recognition, Israel is a sovereign state, member of UN and recognised by the majority of countries, including

3424:

As for as Chad is concerned, it is not an Arab country nor it is counted as an Arab country. Somalia, Eritria, Comoros and Djibouti have some Arab and mostly mixed population (Arab+indigenous). Though most of the population there don't speak Arabic as its first language. But they understand Arabic

1921:

5. Arabic as language is only used by the government and the press and is used in schools. This is and was NOT the choice of the nation but of Tyrannical dictators like Khaddafi and Hosni Mubarak etc etc. There is NO freedom of speech or organisation in North Africa. People can’t choose their leader

1761:

to the map on this page. Israel is highlighted in green along with the other arab states. Given that the map itself separates Israel from Gaza and the West Bank, it is more appropriate and correct to leave Israel blank, and only to highlight in green those territories. I do believe the author of the

1645:

On a separate point, and at risk of re-opening an old wound, surely the standard territorial definition is fundamentally flawed in the event that an AL member is expelled from the AL. If Libya were expelled from the AL, would Libya suddenly cease to be part of the Arab world? I understand that the

1481:

I'm afraid that my assertion is precisely supported by the reference, as you yourself have shown. The definition used by Fishkopf for the purposes of his introduction is "an alternative to, or in combination with," (in your quotation you seem to have omitted the first few words of the sentence) the

1288:

As shown below, it is not merely my iteration that the Arab world is generally coextensive with the territories in the League of Arab States; it's the standard definition of the area. That said, I am not in principle opposed to the inclusion of South Sudan somewhere in this article. It just needs to

4237:

and The entry there lists strangely enough only two varieties of Arab: "Taizzi-Adenite", which is listed as a Yemeni variant (perhaps there is a small group of Yemeni population in Somalia?) and "Standard Arabic", which is, as we know, an official language in Somalia, but of course no mother tongue

3649:

How can I request removal of protection from this article? I want to add content about medieval Arab history and I was able to find out the article is locked because Israel and Palestine are in a dispute. I think this is not a good reason to prohibit editing of an article that spans over a thousand

3408:

Why is the definition of arab world all the "Arab-speaking" countries ? It gives a false idea of countries like Somalia, Djibouti, Eirtrea, Chad, etc. because they are not ethnically Arabs. Let's just focus on the definition, how can language be the definition for something so ethnical ? Sure Saudi

3158:

In English, the "Arab world" usually means the countries and territories populated mainly by Arabs, i.e. essentially native speakers of Arabic. The "League of Arab States" is the name of a supranational organization whose member states all have Standard Arabic as one of their official languages. As

2788:

Exactly, but that wasn't my concern. What I said was the distinction above (i.e. that the Arab World contrasts with the wider Islamic world by use of Arabic as vernacular) is NOT true for some of the countries, including Somalia. You've misunderstood me, I'm not debating whether Somalia should be

1607:

My query about the "critical to identity" wording is not a criticism of your edit (you have only accurately quoted Fishkopf) -- rather, I wonder whether this is in keeping with the definition of "Arab" that is generally used in the article (i.e., the Arab League definition). I presume that, perhaps

1600:

I said that my assertion was "precisely" supported by the reference, that is "entirely", since I had hoped it was clear that, under my earlier layout, the Language definition was subsidiary / ancillary to the standard territorial definition. Evidently you disagreed, but we seem to have found common

1528:

extended into multiple diasporas", Frishkopf himself includes the various Arab diasporas in his language-based definition of the Arab world specifically based on the fact that they make "use of the Arabic language" and acknowledge "its recognition as critical to identity". The text, however, can be

1488:

I disagree with your wording "and thus may include the Arab diaspora". Could we replace with "and may include populations of the Arab diaspora"? First, the Arab diaspora does not refer to particular states or territories (i.e., it encompasses populations within certain states and territories), and

4229:

This article takes as basis of the Arab World the political block of the Arab League, which is not necesssarily the same thing - should a State leave the League, it would still be part of the Arab world. And the other way round, a State could be part of the Arab League without being really part of

2731:

I'm focusing on Somalia here as I know more of it than of the other nations, but I'm sure it's not the only nation where the blanket statements don't all ring true. I don't know what can be done and I suppose it would be madness to individually describe every member state on such a precise level,

2031:

Maltese is an Arabic idiom, and unlike other Arabics uses the latin script. Standard Arabic is not used, unlike many other Arabic speaking countries. Malta is predominately Catholic. There is very little mention of Malta in the article, and no mention of Maltese language. It strikes me as a little

1683:

themselves in the Arab League, not the Arab League itself (the latter of which was just formed to unite the pre-existing idea of an "Arab Nation"), that are generally coextensive with the Arab world. As your Frishkopf source explains: "No universally accepted definition of 'the Arab world' exists,

4242:

lists several media broadcasting in Arabic, besides Somali and English, if you visit the websites of these media, you'll see that there is no Arabic version nor any news in Arabic. All this gives the impression that Arabic is to a very great extent a foreign language in Somalia, just like French

2887:

Quote from the article "Arab world, also known as the Arab nation (الأمة العربية al-ʾummah al-ʿarabīah), consists of the 22 Arabic-speaking countries of the Arab League." This makes it seem like Arab world and Arab league are essentially the same thing so why two different articles the article on

2723:

In the 'Demographics' section, the article states: "Arab League countries are defined by an Arab majority; the Arabic language forms the unifying feature of the Arab world. Though different areas use local varieties of Arabic, all share in the use of the modern standardized language, derived from

1717:

This seems mainly vanity. What do areas mean? At least comparing Tunisia and Algeria with Alaska have meaning. There's nothing but empty uninhabitable space any of them! But it seems to make them all non-notable, rather than notable. So what that the Gobi desert is "bigger than" Death Valley? Not

1519:

supported by the Frishkopf source since the author clearly states that the Arab world is traditionally coextensive with the territories in the Arab League i.e. the standard definition of the Arab world: "No universally accepted definition of 'the Arab world' exists, but it is generally assumed to

1385:

I do not ipso facto have anything against mentioning that there are alternative definitions of the Arab world to the standard one cited above and below. However, your addition to the article the assertion that "in combination with, the Arab League definition discussed above, the Arab world may be

617:

One other point: I notice that you have amended "not widely spoken" to "less widely spoken". While I agree that "widely spoken" is inherently relativist (what is "widely"?), it is not particularly informative to distinguish between "widely" (or, implicitly, "more widely") and "less widely". For

1492:

Re layout -- The layout was structured to reflect the alternative bases for definitions of the Arab world (i.e., as subsections of the Definition section). In the first place, the standard territorial definition is considered (under the current heading "Arab League", although this could be more

1179:

I do not dispute your re-iteration of the Arab League's definition of the Arab world (although I would stress that this is only one possible definition of the Arab world). However, for the purposes of this article, a strict approach in line with this "rule" would fail to consider the (I think)

1078:

The question is whether (eligibility for) membership of the Arab League determines whether a country is part of the Arab world. It seems to be a general rule (see the debate in the following section) that being a member of the Arab League, regardless of whether Arabic is widely spoken or is an

598:

The earlier layout was, I would argue, more explanatory insofar as it differentiated equally between these three variables: (1) membership of the Arab League, (2) Arabic being widely spoken, and (3) Arabic as an official language. The current edit prioritises membership of the Arab League, and

2558:). That they aren't ethnically Arab is not particularly meaningful, though, since the Arab world is chiefly comprised of Arabized populations. This is why the CIA also indicates that "although almost all Algerians are Berber in origin (not Arab), only a minority identify themselves as Berber" 2727:

This contrast between Arab League countries and the wider Islamic world is extremely muddy--Somalia is exactly as Iran, Pakistan, and Afghanistan are described here, and yet is a member state. Arabic is an official language for religious reasons and is used liturgically, but not spoken as a

1237:

One other point: I would point out that I did not suggest that eligibility for membership was the test for inclusion in the Arab League's definition of the Arab world -- indeed, I expressly stated that, on the basis of the "rule" that Arab League membership (i.e., not mere eligibility) was a

4011:

In its current version as of 2021-May-05, this article defines the Arab World as being exactly the same thing as the Arab League. If this is accurate, this article should be merged with the Arab League article. If not accurate, this article needs to be re-written in a way that clarifies the

1453:

Arabic is indeed the liturgical language of Islam. However, it must be remembered that not all self-identified 'Arabs' are Muslim (like many Lebanese Christians or Yemeni Jews, for example; though, admittedly, many Maronite Christians do not identify in this way at all, but instead consider

1422:

It's my impression that Arabic is the preferred language for the Islamic religion. The Qur'an is more lyrical in Arabic. Is it possible that the "Arab World"/"Arab League" was intended to be some sort of religious precursor to resurrecting the Caliphate? At the core is the Arabic language.

2728:

vernacular. Given that Somalia, for the most part, consists of neither ethnic Arabs nor Arabic speakers, many of the blanket statements about the League states are glaringly false in relation to Somalia. It seems that Somalia joined the league for political purposes more than anything.

1529:

amended to "the Arab world may be defined as consisting of those states or territories in which the majority of the population speaks Arabic or regard it as critical to identity, and thus may also include populations of the Arab diaspora" since he does talk about multiple Arab diasporas.

3707:

Hello! I take issue with the map of the Arab World. Syria is in light green as to symbolize its suspension from the Arab League. But the Arab world is different from the Arab League. It is a scholarly and political entity, not a political organization; it cannot be defined by what some

112:

This does not seem to be a discussion of Israel's legitimacy as such, it is a factual observation, your edit implies a degree of recognition that would be false in the cse of the Saudis and other non-recognizers. I am reverting. There is nothing wrong with a bland factual note as such.

807:(an Arabic-cognate) as an official language and are mentioned accordingly in this section. In my opinion, South Sudan should fit in here. Notwithstanding its history (with Arabic as an official language and so constituting a member of the Arab world), the continued widespread use of 1846:

This can only be removed if Lewis was quoted incorrectly, which must be somehow demonstrated. If he was quoted correctly, then it must be left and material inserted that refutes this. We can assess whether material is generally reliable or not. This has been done for Lewis and he is

985:) -- as you point out, Roentgenium111, the first category chiefly consists of Arab League member-states, so South Sudan's eligibility is an important consideration (although not a requirement for inclusion in the "Arab world", as I have previously discussed). More importantly, the 422:

As Article 11 of Lebanon's Constitution states, "Arabic is the official national language. A law determines the cases in which the French language may be used", then French explicitly hasn't been given official or national language status and therefore isn't applicable to the map.

446:

Why "Algeria" in particular? Morocco has more Berber speakers than Algeria , overal 80% have Algerian Arabic as a native language . There are also linguistical minorities in Lebanon and Iraq , as well as Lybia and Egypt. I don't understand why you put only Algeria in blue...

909:

could then be strictly defined (for the purposes of this article) as states and territories falling into the first category, but the article would still cover the other categories (for completeness' sake). Absent any contention to the contrary, I will implement that change.

2850:

Considering there's already an article on the Arab League, this article appears superfluous. If membership in the Arab League is the criteria, then the article should be covered in the article about the Arab League. If the criteria is the extent of spoken Arabic, then

1838:

Apart from being propagandistic, the statement is simply untrue. According to the CIA data for 1999, Spain's GDP was US&645 billion while the total GDP of only five Arab countries - Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Algeria, Morocco and Tunisia - amounted to US$ 670,2 billion.

1386:

defined as consisting of those states or territories in which the majority of the population is Arab and/or speaks Arabic, and may even include Arab or Arabic-speaking populations outside the traditional Arab world" is not entirely supported by the cited source (c.f.

4982:

as cited source and that said 45% not 75%, I updated that article to reflect what the source it's citing says. Leaving it 75% here as M.Bitton has provided multiple sources to support that, there probably needs to be some discussion on what to use in both places.

711:

The maps we have on this page will very soon be inaccurate starting July 9, 2011 when the South Sudan Republic is declared. South Sudan has practically no Arabic language (except for a negligible tiny tiny minority perhaps) and it is certainly not part of the

1027:

It doesn't seem so clear to me from what you write: The article you linked specifically says that South Sudan is eligible for the Arab League because it was part of an Arab state previously, not because it is an Arab country itself. And the language claim in

1539:

The old layout was unsatisfactory because it literally put the language-based definition of the Arab world -- which your own Frishkopf source describes as ancillary, a fact which can also readily be seen in most standard maps of the Arab world (e.g.

2762:). Somalia is indeed not mostly inhabited by "ethnic Arabs", nor are most other nations in the Arab world (the ancient Egyptians, Berbers, Phoenicians, Himyarites, Sabaeans, etc. didn't speak Arabic either, though they too spoke languages from the 853:

minority. But this ought to be in a separate subsection IMO. Somalia, for example, lists Arab as an "official" language, but this seems to be more for Islamic (religious) purposes than because the people actually speak or use Arabic in their daily

1121:

Slight correction there: it's not eligibility for the Arab League that determines whether or not a country is a member of the Arab world. It's that, as a rule, the Arab world is generally coextensive with the territories that are already in the

3946:

until a consensus is reached, and anyone is welcome to contribute to the discussion. The nomination will explain the policies and guidelines which are of concern. The discussion focuses on high-quality evidence and our policies and guidelines.

3894:

1524:

consisting of those states or territories in which the majority of the population speaks Arabic or regard it as critical to identity, and may include populations of the Arab diaspora" because, as can be seen in the quote above and its use of "

819:, while requiring Anglicization, does not need amending beyond the insertion of the new boundary-line between Sudan and South Sudan. This is an ethnographic map and South Sudan will continue to have an Arab population (see also this 1579:) -- on equal footing with the standard territorial definition of the Arab world since it juxtaposed that linguistic definition right beside the the mainstream territorial one in the Definition section. This too is inconsistent with 3420:

An Arab is person whose first language or mother tongue is Arabic, an he belongs to the specific geographical region called the Arab World. This region's people also share same culture, traditions and customs to the most extent.

2891:

This whole article reads like a disaster, like a mish-mash of different ideas and completely without any course of direction. There's really no point in editing or improving this article when we have a perfectly good article on

1292:), a member of the South Sudanese administration told the press recently that his nation would not be joining the League since the government believes that the territory does not meet the pre-conditions necessary for inclusion 3234:

There isn't any evidence of a Dubai being anywhere close to 9000 years old. Don't know what the source is but that would make it one of the oldest continuously inhabited settlements in the world, which it definitely is not.

2924:

The Arab League article is about a political organization founded in the 40s. This article is about an area and its people and history going back much further than that. Its similar to the difference between the article

3966:

There is nothing about Sabaeans written here, an ancient people of South Arabia, who founded a Kingdom of Saba. They arę mentioned in the Bible. They spoke the Sabaean language, one of the Old South Arabian languages.

2011:

So I personally don't know how to edit maps and even if I did I'd still need permission but 2 things. 1 shouldn't the West Bank and Gaza Strip be added on the map ? 2 is it possible to get the map in higher pixels ?

3767:

I agree with you. It is even mentioned at the top of the article that not to be confused with Arab League. I have found a photo that I think is more related to the subject. Other editors might have another opinion.

3385:

The GDP of Arab world mentioned on this page is actually GDP (nominal), not GDP (PPP). The given reference of World Bank too proves that. Therefore, I request that this error should be fixed as soon as possible.

297:, these Arab states switched sides and fought for the Axis. And later on, when North Africa and France were taken from the Axis, these states switched sides again, fighting for the Allies once more. However, 790:

section (I would argue that the list of states at the top of that section is arbitrary and incomplete). But that section also (and quite rightly) excludes Eritrea and Chad from membership of the Arab world

2102:. This information is wrong. I would just point out that there's 280 Arabs living in the Arab League, but that's not the total population. In total, there live about 350 million people in the Arab League. 3433: 3394: 2046:

One of the other reasons are that Maltese are genetically distinct from the Arab world, they plot in the gap between Europe and the near east, alongside Sicilians, south Italians and Ashkenazi Jews.

1854:. That is, you, a non-expert, have added it up and found an expert wrong. Unfortunately, this process cannot be used in Knowledge (XXG) for the reasons cited. Needs reliable disproof at this point. 5059: 4068: 2959:

1) Comoros, Djibouti, and Somalia are members of the Arab League, but are not considered part of the Arab world, i.e. they are not mainly populated by Arab settlers or Arabized local populations

4437: 3950:

Users may edit the page during the discussion, including to improve the page to address concerns raised in the discussion. However, do not remove the deletion notice from the top of the page.

3898:

Users may edit the page during the discussion, including to improve the page to address concerns raised in the discussion. However, do not remove the deletion notice from the top of the page.

3742: 3665: 1189:

definition of the Arab world), (c) it is however "Nilotic", rather than "Arab", and (d) (subject to referencing) Arabic is not widely spoken (although an Arabic pidgin, Juba Arabic, is).

1912:

2. Arab/Arabic is a name for a NATION, and nation that lives and exist only in the Middle east according to all none facist and racist historians and scientist around the whole world.

1482:

standard territorial definition. In other words, Fishkopf acknowledges the standard territorial definition and then uses an alternative definition for the purposes of his introduction.

1679:) for political reasons as an incentive for it to get its act together, so-to-speak. So that hypothetical scenario does not apply in this case. It also does not apply because it's the 640:

The map you linked to above is not consistent with the areas traditionally held to be the Arab world. As a rule, the Arab world is generally coextensive with the territories in the

3943: 3891: 2818:

Ok, I see what you're referring to there about Somalia's main reasons for joining the Arab League. Political expediency was indeed one primary motivation, as was the then popular

977:. However, it is becoming increasingly clear (following independence) that South Sudan should fall in the first category. South Sudan is eligible to apply for membership to the 1393:, please discuss any augmentations you wish to make to the standard definition of the Arab world, so that they may be evaluated in terms of seeing if they pass Knowledge (XXG)'s 721: 1733:

These made no sense and no one tried to defend them. Would need "English world" or "Aryan World" or some such abstraction. None seemed to relate to "Arab World" particularly.

3847: 3792: 3773: 3708:

intergovernmental council decides to do with its membership. I suggest it be changed to a map from a respected scholarly source defining the geographical Arab World. Best

3692: 586:

I'm not sure this is necessarily helpful. Membership to the Arab League (and please note that this is the translated form commonly used on Knowledge (XXG), rather than

3468:

I was going to fix some of the citations, but I don't have access to this level of protected articles. Could someone with the appropriate access level please fix them?

3327: 3323: 3309: 3076: 3072: 3058: 2665: 2661: 2647: 333:

I plan on making a change to the map, wherein Algeria's native Tamazight (Berber) language should be recognized as a national language as it has been since 2002 (see

4012:

difference. My personal understanding is the latter (i.e. the Arab World and the Arab League are not the same and therefore this article needs to be re-written). --

2100:"The standard definition of the Arab world comprises the 22 states and territories of the Arab League (...), with a combined population of around 280 million people" 3738: 3661: 3932: 3880: 936:

That sounds good, also since all Arab League countries seem to fall in the first category (and few others do). So which category would South Sudan be in? --

1184:

become an Arab League member-state and so be included in the Arab League's definition of the Arab world. Because of this, I think that it would be worth

3687:

500 edits you would be able to edit these articles. Also you should sign your comments by typing this ~~~~ at the end of your comment. Have a nice day.--

479:

The population of native Arabic speakers is more than 350 which puts Arabic in the second place after Chinese in terms of the number of native speaker.

4234:

entry says "2 million Somalis speak it", but not clarifying if they speak it as their mother tongue or as a foreign language; the source is Ethnologue,

599:

consigns variables (2) and (3) as less significant. I would advocate reverting to the earlier layout as a fairer appraisal of the different positions.

4262:

The largest cities section seems to be inconsistent in its measurements (for example Kuwait making the list on this page vs not being in the top 10 of

3762: 3734: 3678: 3657: 3010: 3626: 213:, and still others were neutral. As nearly all of the Arab states were controlled by European powers, they fought alongside that power. For example, 4263: 3787:

Hi, what is the problem with the map there? Could you explain your POV here please? Before you start and edit war and get yourself blocked. Thanks--

3428:

Note :- Eriteria is commonly not considered an Arab nation, most probably because it has also a large number of non-muslim non-Arabized population.

4407:“Arab” is defined as “a member of an Arabic-speaking people”, Somalians speak Somali as their first language, not Arabic which is only spoken by 816: 725: 1918:

4. In the Maghreb we speak 4 different Tamazight(Berbers) languages and an Arabic_Berber language which we call Darija. NO ONE SPEAKS ARABIC.

1801:) are therefore part of the Arab world under the standard territorial definition and should therefore remain coloured green (as you suggest). 4901: 4883: 2860: 2766:

family). It is nonetheless a part of the Arab world since the standard territorial definition of the Arab world is the 22 territories in the

568:

from other non-AL countries, as the former are all traditionally considered part of the Arab world whereas the latter typically aren't (c.f.

186: 3603: 2033: 4270:

that make the top 10 outside of this page aren't included. I feel like this list needs to be cleaned up or at least consistently sourced.

2859:

should not be in the article - Arabic is almost certainly spoken more widely on a day-to-day basis in South Sudan than it is in Somalia.

1676:

I don't fully agree. For one thing, Libya has not been expelled from the Arab League; it has just been temporarily suspended (reprimanded

3215:

Our Arab World infobox map singles out Syria with a separate colour. But yet there is no explanation why Syria is in a different colour?

4573: 3723:

Yes, the meaning of this has changed over time and as Jacob Lassner has written from the perspective of religious Muslims there is only

3195: 3020: 2971: 2796: 2739: 1929: 5063: 4334:

Please change total population of Arab World from 423,000,000 to 436,080,728 (2020). This is based on recent data from the World Bank:

4072: 2912: 2150: 2116:

As there seem to be no interest for this article, I will remove this mis-calculated information and replace it with the right number.

2080: 520: 4441: 3447:"...Portuguese rule has, been self-governing since..." should be corrected to "...Portuguese rule, has been self-governing since..." 2963:

3) Arguably, Palestine and Western Sahara are not "states" in the normal understanding of that word, due to their lack of sovereignty

4281: 3974: 3305:

When you have finished reviewing my changes, you may follow the instructions on the template below to fix any issues with the URLs.

3054:

When you have finished reviewing my changes, you may follow the instructions on the template below to fix any issues with the URLs.

2494: 2066: 1887: 1835:"The total GDP of all Arab countries in 1999 was US$ 531.2 billion. By contrast, the GDP of Spain that year was US$ 595.5 billion." 648:). Given that, the current layout does not actually prioritize Arab League states alone, but rather the Arab world as a whole (e.g. 486: 5094: 4990: 4969: 4785:

My bad, I misread the caption; I thought this was referring to the second instance of "in", i.e., "the premiere in Cairo" --: -->

3250: 3164: 3136: 966:

I had originally intended South Sudan to be included in the third category, on the basis that an Arabic cognate language (here,

4366: 3727:. The conflict in Sudan is also missing from the article and needs to be added. It is unfortunate that the article is locked. 3625:

it's not clear what changes you want to be made. Please mention the specific changes in a "change X to Y" format and provide a

2482:

Somali people are not ethnic Arabs, but they identify more with Arabs than Africans due to religious and trade ties with Arabs.

2200: 179:

it say in article "after world war II". What did the Arab states do during world war II? Were they alias of the axis powers?

2550: 1790: 1758: 717: 463: 3552: 506: 411:

be used in an official capacity. It's used mainly in schools, and acceptable for many government forms and applications. ←

4776: 4416: 1915:

3. Morocco or the Maghreb, which is ethnically and genetically Amazigh(Berber) according to all historians and scientist.

993:

page states that colloquial Arabic is "widely spoken" -- this would satisfy the test for inclusion in the first category.

4627:

Broken sentence in the first paragraph: "Arabic language, which is used as the lingua franca throughout the Arab world."

1387: 3370: 3119: 2708: 3936: 3884: 3809:

not necessarily a problem, I just replaced it with one that's identical to the previous map, except it included Syria.

2541: 2432:

An editor has determined that the edit contains an error somewhere. Please follow the instructions below and mark the

2274:

An editor has determined that the edit contains an error somewhere. Please follow the instructions below and mark the

1677: 4754: 4715: 1987:

So while there may be dissidents, as there are everywhere, I think the article is fine the way it is and according to

4511: 541:

Can we discuss the population rather than continue to edit war over it? One of the last reverters mentioned that the

3285: 4630:

Suggested edit: "The Arabic language is used as the lingua franca throughout the Arab world." or something similar

4362: 4189: 3011:

https://web.archive.org/web/20120203093100/https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/ir.html

2348: 2344: 2121: 2107: 38: 5087: 5024: 4962: 4825: 4685: 4602: 4467: 4309: 4139: 4042: 3578: 3500: 3179:

2) Arguably, Palestine and Western Sahara are not "states" in the normal understanding of that word, due to their

2559: 1559: 667: 4635: 3409:

Arabia is an Arab country, but Chad... I think the "Arab World" should be redefined, and the map is misleading. (

2864: 2244: 1485:

I note that you have quoted Fishkopf's "critical to identity" wording -- what does this mean? How is it provable?

190: 59: 3548: 3326:

to delete these "External links modified" talk page sections if they want to de-clutter talk pages, but see the

3075:

to delete these "External links modified" talk page sections if they want to de-clutter talk pages, but see the

2664:

to delete these "External links modified" talk page sections if they want to de-clutter talk pages, but see the

1574: 682: 4905: 4887: 4772: 4412: 4114: 2037: 1568: 1562: 1045: 941: 891:

section be further broken down (i.e., new sub-headings) to differentiate between states and territories where:

676: 670: 502: 293:, and thus, fought alongside the French. However, after the fall of France to Germany and the establishment of 3607: 2402: 2343:

I think there should be a separate article for the history of the Arab world and the Arabic-speaking peoples.

1611:

One further query: The opening sentence of the article states that: "The Arab world refers to Arabic-speaking

1129:). This is also how the Arab League itself defines the Arab world, or what it refers to as the "Arab Nation" ( 894:

Arabic is "widely spoken" (this could be defined as "being spoken by the majority or a substantial minority");

4181:, apart from brief intermittent Persian and Portuguese rule, has been self-governing since the 8th century." 4171:, apart from brief intermittent Persian and Portuguese rule has, been self-governing since the 8th century." 3295: 2975: 2800: 2743: 2613: 1933: 644:. This is also how the Arab League itself defines the Arab world, or what it refers to as the "Arab Nation" ( 4577: 4017: 3361: 3277: 3199: 3110: 3002: 2827: 2775: 2699: 2593: 2356: 2154: 2139: 2084: 1820: 1694: 1588: 1459: 1406: 1300: 1293: 1138: 692: 576: 524: 318: 4433: 4185: 3978: 3970: 3730: 3653: 3238: 3191: 3014: 2967: 2900: 2792: 2735: 2511: 2117: 2103: 1925: 1891: 1883: 1550: 658: 482: 451: 182: 4750: 4711: 4110: 3475: 3429: 3390: 3273: 3140: 2908: 2763: 2732:

but I wonder if someone reading this article won't get the wrong impression about some of these nations.

1565: 820: 673: 206: 157: 118: 5082: 4957: 3175:. And conversely, Western Sahara is indeed a part of the Arab world, but not a member of the Arab League. 2888:

Arab league details many of the same things in this article ie demographics, history, culture, etc etc.

2543:

A Pastoral Democracy: A Study of Pastoralism and Politics Among the Northern Somali of the Horn of Africa

5104: 4791: 4738: 4502:

Grey-green orthographic maps are the tradition for use in intercontinental regions, such as the similar

4278: 4239: 3952: 3900: 3832: 3814: 3345: