Talk:Gaza genocide/Archive 5

968:

charge — including the recent report that, since October, Israel has facilitated the entry of more than 870 metric tons of food and other humanitarian aid to Gaza’s two million inhabitants. Meanwhile, Hamas attacks or plunders food shipments, and it has denied Gazan civilians access to vast storehouses of food and medicines that it secreted in its tunnels before Oct. 7...Israel has, in fact, done more than any other military has ever done to minimize civilian casualties during large-scale urban warfare, even sacrificing the lives of many of its own soldiers in the process. For example, Israeli forces drop warning leaflets, distribute maps, and place automated phone calls to civilians in Gaza to identify areas in which combat is planned, in order to enable civilians to evacuate in advance...Yet Hamas intentionally impedes efforts of Palestinian civilians to flee to safer areas, and then it uses the military plans provided by Israel to attack its troops, employing Palestinian civilians and hostages seized in Israel as human shields — undeniably a war crime..the deaths of thousands of people during a war is not alone indicative of genocidal intent...Israel too is waging a defensive war against ongoing aggression, war crimes and genocide, but it is taking far greater steps to protect civilian lives than Allied forces did

134: 154: 143: 163: 2108:- Procedurally, two weeks after the last Move Review closed, with no new sources brought to the discussion, and no new arguments, is too soon to have another RM. It's a ridiculous waste of time to have a whole second RM simply because somebody on the internet disagrees with the first one. (Disclosure: I tried removing this RM when it was first posted and reported InterpidContributor to AE for restoring it twice.) We're going to end up having the same people make the same votes for the same reasons as last time. Substantively, I oppose this for the same reasons as last time. 1186:- even if we completely ignore that there was an established consensus for this title and that consensus was reviewed and upheld at a review, the proposed title is terrible. Just independent of any process concern, "Accusations of Gazan genocide in the Israel–Hamas war" is a terrible title. It is overly long and confusing, is it genocide against Gazans or by Gazans? It is limited in scope, ignoring the sources that say this process started well before last year. It fails basically every criteria for article titles. And that’s ignoring the process here. 174: 3348:- there are two questions here, one procedural (whether it's too early for another RM) and one substantive (which title is most appropriate). It might be too late now, but it would have been cleaner if procedural objections had been made in a separate section. If this ends up not being closed for procedural reasons, then it goes to substance, where the closer may have a hard time discerning whether each procedural oppose is also a substantive oppose, and if so, how much weight to assign such !votes which don't get into substantive arguments. — 766:, et al: "Despite all the concern for the fate of the Palestinian population, however, the standards of judgement slip completely when genocidal intentions are attributed to Israel's actions." These distortions fuel misinformation. For example, misinterpretation of the ICJ and ICC rulings which did not find a "plausible" genocide. They will have to show Israeli intent. While the death of any innocent person is a tragedy, the killing of 2% of the Gazan population during a tough urban war isn't equivalent to such historical events like the 442:, as examples of articles titled "genocide" without a consensus/a legal ruling. However, these articles are about terms that are used to characterize systemic oppression and don't refer to a single historical event, like the Holocaust. We should be honest that "Gaza genocide" as a title evokes a historical event, not a characterization of an event. In any case, I think the titling of such an important article as "Gaza genocide" should be based on reasoning rather than on a precedent by two articles with relatively low readership. 1301:- At some point, obvious truths need to be recognized for what they are. There are prominent figures who continue to deny the Holocaust and the Armenian genocide, but their positions are rightly ignored by Knowledge for the same reason that the positions of flat-earthers and climate change deniers, some quite prominent, are ignored here. Because the truth is obvious, and no amount of argument is going to change that. At some point, you have to stop wasting time entertaining those who are willfully ignorant of reality. 3042:. The UN framework is considered generally lacking and not fit for determining what is or is not genocide among genocide scholars (even among the few genocide scholars who are currently choosing to use the framework to argue that Gaza is not a genocide). While we should include their opinions in the article, the UN framework is not the metric we use, we use what reliable sources use, so we privilege academic literature first-and-foremost, balanced with the other published opinions of relevant specialists and experts. 427:

that a lof of these sources, on both sides of the argument, are not actually specialized in the topic of genocide. If we really want to know if there's an academic/expert consensus, a useful exercise could be to improve the table and prioritize genocide/Holocaust scholars and international law experts, as well as separate them based on their stance and their level of confidence in said stance. While I would be happy to be proven wrong, I doubt such an exercise would show a consensus yet.

4950:. My conjecture is that this Russian request about a case with a very similar name and some sloppy journalism led to a conclusion that South Africa sought an extension. This example also shows that requests and rulings on them are public and published even when it is the president of the court rather than the full court which makes the decision. If no such ruling regarding South Africa appears on the ICJ web site soon, we can reasonably conclude that there was no request. 183: 1323:, I am forced to consider any new vote an attempt, perhaps unintentional, to manufacture a weak or biased enough turnout to force a change, and then argue for retention at the new title based on the new precedent. I am also very unswayed by the notion we may offend people or cause a lack of trust. Knowledge has gone against a dozen governments before, I scarcely think we should back down because this one wields scarier accusations of "isms" than the previous lot. 335: 31: 946:

leading multiple international observers to report that Israel had failed to meet the requirements of the ICJ's ruling, further leading South Africa to request additional measures, and for various reliable sources to report on deaths due to starvation within Gaza. This is just one exemplary aspect show the stark difference in conditions in just 4–5 months, let alone the further 6 months since the ICJ rulings. --

1732:, but they are not genocide. But even the war crimes are debatable because the Israeli forces did care to move civilians out of the areas of most intense operations and created some presumably safe zones in Gaza. Yes, a couple of Israeli officials (I would call them far-right idiots) did say on several occasions "let's kill them all". Nevertheless, this is not at all an official policy of the Jewish state, 97: 2422:

was made with basically no majority, it now takes a supermajority to say the close was bad since the 50% that liked the move can simply claim "the move was good" and secure a "no consensus". I agree with the concerns that this makes Knowledge look very biased and overall hurts the credibility of Knowledge via the bad look. I didn't participate in any of the previous topic discussions.

3956: 1389:

title "Accusations of Gaza genocide in the Israel-Hamas war" is more appropriate. The use of "accusations" clarifies that the term genocide is a subject of debate and (extreme) controversy, not a settled fact, while maintaining neutrality. The suggested title makes it clear that these are accusations, not a definitive statement in Knowledge's voice.

2512:. Almost nothing has been said in this discussion that wasn't said in the last two. If the consensus (or lack thereof) ends up any different, it'd be because everyone is exhausted and may not argue as effectively as they did before. We should propose a moratorium after this to avoid yet another rehash and save everyone's time and energy. 2062:

the Palestinian refugees to enter, even when they want to go, and do not facilitate their immigration and transportation (I assume that the Israel would be only happy to help them out?). I am not trying to make any moral judgements, but simply thinking about the historical precedents of resolving such conflicts, only the recent

3541:

current POV name. If editors are arguing against one or more of these alternative names (rather than just expressing a slight preference for one but acceptability of them all), it would be prudent to be extremely clear in your reasoning to avoid your opinion being seen as a !vote for the current title. -bɜ:ʳkənhɪmez |

4852:. I can only see the headline "No delay in Israel ICJ case, says SA after Israeli 'not enough evidence' report" and one sentence "South Africa says it will file evidence of genocide in Gaza in October as scheduled, despite claims out of Israel it is seeking a delay.", but that seems clear enough. Note that this is a 2244:, which clearly hasn't happened. There's no need to quantify how many genocide scholars subscribe to each view - the fact that there's a (non-fringe) controversy means that it's a POV name. We should take a cue from the mainstream media here, since they tend to have similar asperations of neutrality. Literally 1573:. The current title claims that there actually is a genocide, namely that people are being killed intentionally because of their ancestry or other aspects correlated with ancestry (e.g skin color, culture). This is not the case. The target title makes zero claim on any actual genocide, only accusations of it. 4194:, I can't find much in Google either. Erdoğan is well-known for being an international leader who has harshly protested against the Israeli actions in Gaza; he said nothing about any of this when he met some months ago with Romanian PM Marcel Ciolacu, whose cabinet was supposedly complicit in genocide 3540:

is fine, I have a slight preference for name 2 for consistency as XDanielx points out. I will caution those commenting on this topic however that the last RM was derailed by the splitting of editors between these alternative names, and that is the reason the closer claimed to find a consensus for the

2465:

per the previous discussion. As for "The title doesn't match the article", we should bring the article in line with the emerging consensus and the reality of the situation. Also it seems there is no title you can pick that won't be seen as POV. Take "Gaza genocide accusations" for example. This would

1388:

I opposed the move to Gaza Genocide from the very beginning because I think it does not reflect the uncertainty and ongoing investigation by experts in various fields regarding whether the events in Gaza truly constitute genocide. In the context of the current discussion, I believe that the suggested

945:

aid agencies can simply request for more aid to be allowed in. This is a perfect point to show the outdatedness of these bullet points, as has been shown from the ICJ's ruling in January, the IDF controlling the blockade (alongside a small section of civilians), restricted aid into Gaza even further,

4847:

Circles are not square, the moon is not made of strawberry jam, and nations bringing cases to the ICJ don't admit they can't find enough evidence. Yet it's amazing how many "news" sites have uncritically repeated Kan's claim. Searching again today, I found no independent confirmation, but I did find

4698:

Although it is not impossible that the inability to find evidence could be the reason for South Africa to request a deadline extension, it is totally impossible that South Africa would cite that as the reason. We are not required to believe in fairies. I am not even convinced yet that such a request

4428:

Sorry, I can't find a permalink to a KAN report itself right now. It may have been part of a radio or TV report that hasn't been transcribed or a live article that isn't categorized under the same place as their other news pieces about the ICJ stuff. I found a 3rd source from Arutz Sheva but I don't

4272:

I agree it should be removed if proper sourcing can't be found. Proper sourcing should be scholars saying "Romania," "complicit," "Gaza genocide." (I did a quick Google Scholar search and was unable to find anything.) Simply saying Romania supplies arms to Israel shouldn't be enough for Knowledge to

4203:

I have just seen that this section was first added by an editor who was known in the Romanian topic area for his sloppy edits. He was indefinitely blocked last month. I really don't see much weight for keeping this section in the article. I really find it ashaming that this section has been kept for

2421:

The current title is a clear POV title. The previous close illustrates one of the flaws of our close review process. We have what can very reasonably be seen as a bad close (clear consensus for some move but no obvious consensus between the choices with a near 50/50 split). However, once the move

2148:

relitigation of the last RM. Let's put a moratorium on it and discuss it in 1-2 years when the dust settles. Incidentally, the support arguments often rest on a misconception of the concept of genocide—for example one supporter arguing that Gazans are not "being killed intentionally because of their

967:

Bruce J. Einhorn, Kathleen N. Coleman, Clarice R. Feldman, Joel K. Greenberg, Jeffrey N. Mausner, and Philip L. Sunshine — worked as U.S. federal prosecutors of perpetrators of Nazi genocide ...we have seen no evidence of Israeli commission of genocide, and there is much evidence that disproves that

540:

I don't know why editors keep on insisting on a procedural close when there are more than enough editors here supporting the motion. Shutting down discussion is a hallmark of POV pushing or stonewalling, and neither of those are legitimate means for conducting a a discussion according to Knowledge's

4140:

section only features claims from three pro-Palestine groups that Romania is somehow involved. Only the reasoning of one of the three is explained and it is uniquely that Romanian weapon sales to Israel have continued after the war started. I am not an expert by any means but I seriously doubt this

2494:

This is getting absurd at this point. The topic was closed just recently after having gone through several rounds already, and it was decided convincingly. No new arguments have been presented to restart it, nothing has changed in terms of the underlying facts. This is an abuse of the system and we

2061:

Yes, it does appear that nowhere in Gaza is safe. As an outsider to this conflict, I would assume that all civilians should simply be allowed to evacuate from the war zone (as would be in any other war), which can be only to Egypt or other countries. But apparently that other countries do not allow

1083:

870,000 tons does bring a more reasonable number of 1.3 kg/(person*day). Indeed not everyone needs aid, so perhaps the amount per person in need is closer to double that. Raw mass isn't super useful however, since much of this could for example be water or cement. But this would enter the territory

1063:

That isn't the only aid though, as other countries and NGOs have provided aid as well, not to mention charitable donations and aid provided by the private sector. Also, not literally every person needs the aid, though it may be more than half and as much as 80%. There's some statistical information

752:

director of the genocide studies program at Yale University, says that Israel has only explicitly said they want to exterminate Hamas, and has not directly stated intent to “destroy a religious, ethnic or racial group.” Ben Kiernan, the director of the Cambodian Genocide Program at Yale University,

555:

Because this isn’t some game where if you try try again and just get the numbers to turn out then you win. We had a discussion that resulted in consensus. That discussion was reviewed and the finding of consensus endorsed. If there had been no consensus then fine discussion further makes sense. But

452:

The title I'm suggesting, "Accusations of Gazan genocide in the Israel-Hamas war", is the one I think is best. The "in the Israel–Hamas war" goes along with my call for unambiguity, as there have been multiple other accusations of a Gazan genocide in the past. However, I think it would be pertinent

4144:

I think many of you need to reconsider what are you writing over here. This is just biased propaganda at this point. Pointing fingers at random countries online is a ridiculous thing to do. I think the section should be removed. Or, if there's actual academic and expert debate on this, the section

2361:

the data is how respondents felt about selected quotes, taken from the context of their articles that Charny presented to them. How the respondents felt had they been presented the papers the small quotes were taken from could be very different, and must be considered when assessing Charny's paper

1981:

I would point out the Vox article is almost ten years old, and in that time there has been an explicit move in the Knesset to the right, with Bibi agree to work with far-right parties who have explicit expulsionary and irredentist ideologies. This fact has been brought up multiple times in popular

760:

determine whether Israel’s government is committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza. I think the charge is invalid; there is no systematic effort to exterminate Gaza’s population. (If there were, given the vast disparity in power, Israel would surely have killed many more than 23,000 people,

749:

useful to understand how the distortion of terminology serves to inflame and imply that a war or policy of extermination is the official policy of Israel when it isn't. This article is a good overview of the legal basics of Hamas' war crimes and why the war is one of self-defense and an attempt to

591:

People, especially people who don't edit the articles in question, starting snap-RMs (and RFCs) with no "before" discussion, and doing this multiple times in rapid succession, is a huge problem in this topic area. It's very disruptive, it makes talk pages almost unusable and causes widespread burn

426:

that has been compiled on the talk page. It's huge, I read all of it, and I have to say I didn't come out of it with any impression of a consensus. Opinions range widely, from "It is one" to "It could be one" to "It isn't one", and no position is clearly dominant. One thing to take into account is

414:

committing a genocide. I mention this not because my non-expert opinion should have any sort of weight in this debate, but as an assurance to you that this RM is being done in good faith. After reading the previous discussion, as well as the whole scholarly/expert opinion table on the talk page, I

4793:

Having read the article, it appears that the claim there isn't enough evidence is the assessment by article authors deducing this must be the reason due to South Africa requesting an extension on the evidence deadline. The article does not say the South Africa team stated they did not have enough

4679:

from this article because you want this article (the primary article in summary style, which is appropriate, obviously) because it would not fit your POV to contain more information about the veracity of the claims here.The title has not been dealt with and still violates NPOV. After the upcoming

448:

Until there is an academic/expert consensus on the genocide, this article is about a debate and we don't lose anything by titling it as such, except a bit of concision. Neutrality should be our priority when it comes to a crucial article like this one. As a reminder, readers won't read an article

818:

A genocide need not reach the level of the Holocaust to be a genocide, and pointing to the arguments of someone a believes a certain threshold of number dead be met to constitute genocide, is not just at odds with any of the frameworks employed by genocide scholars, but is also counter to the UN

4102:

I know. They are also not for people to waste volunteer time by engaging them in a death spiral of RM requests until the 'correct' outcome is obtained. That would quite a foolish thing to do, the kind of foolishness I see a lot in the PIA topic area. It is so easy to have patience in this life.

2448:

that this is a genocide, even if there is consensus that there have been significant civilian casualties. Those claiming there is some academic consensus have repeatedly cherrypicked sources to support their view. This entire topic has been the subject of POV pushing and it damages Knowledge's

2317:

Ah, that article by Charny, where Charny considers any comparative analysis in genocide studies between any event and the Holocaust to be at least Holocaust minimisation if not denial. Oh, except for when Charny does the comparative analysis. And may we not forget Charny has had it out for the

1693:

for not bringing anything new to the table and only relitigating the previous, well-attended and confirmed move, but with an even worse and more convoluted title alternative than the original + with no substance or merit to the RM. A lack of a moratorium is not an invitation to raise fresh RMs

433:

When I wrote that this title could erode confidence in the neutrality of Knowledge, I was referring to this point. Someone who clicks on "Gaza genocide" will immediately be met with multiple clear contradictions, and a general appearance of dishonesty. First, the short description refers to an

421:

A lot of the argumentation in favor of the "Gaza genocide" title centers around the fact that, while the mainstream opinion and media may be split on the genocide accusation, a wide majority of scholars and experts consider the massacre a genocide. Before anyone contributes to this discussion,

4007:

Please do not remove a RM just because you don't agree on the timing. We can use this post to discuss whatever needs to be discussed for a new RM discussion and close. You could well have replied in the move request section above instead of deleting it and creating this new discussion.

4135:

I already know well this topic area is eager to emotional and exaggerated claims. But I was actually baffled to see the claim in the infobox that Romania is allegedly complicit in a genocide in the Gaza Strip. Is there any academic consensus or discussion regarding this? Currently this

521:

While I happen to agree with you that the current name is in need of improvement and I do like your suggestions, unless you can find something significant that changed since the endorsed RM closure a weeks ago, I don't how this isn't just a waste of everyone's time. I would recommend a

3991:

We don't just open an RM for no obvious reason, out of the blue, just after a recent RM that also went through MR and was endorsed, without a prior discussion. Specifically, one should elaborate on what has changed since the previous discussion, that would warrant opening a new RM?

778:

that Israel is not intentionally killing civilians and shows restraint. I recognize these are unpopular opinions. While I note that the previous close addressed the potential counterfactual aspect of the title, I believe editors should nonetheless find a consensus to rename it.

836:

where the article is by an IDF colonel who's repertoire of research is all in support of Israel's military actions. Firstly, I would comment that a retaliatory war does not preclude then possibility of genocide in the UN convention. Secondly, I would highlight how this list of

3032:

If we look at specifically genocide scholars, there is a clear majority of those who have expressed their opinion, or provided their analysis that this is a genocide. It is also (so far) only genocide scholars who have published their analysis in peer-reviewed academic

2036:"Safe zones" have been a tool of genocide before... it does not prove anything about the supposedly benign intentions of the Israeli state—and they are specifically argued to be tools of ethnic cleansing and genocide by multiple sources that have been cited here. Also 269:

Thank you for your effort. I support updating the infobox, and I have no objections agains these images except for the assurances, if at all possible, that the childrens' families don't object to these photographs being posted on Knowledge. Copyright is one thing, and

4594:

Well, you'd think from some of the discussions that the ICJ is not nuanced and is unequivocal, but as that article shows, the case is ongoing and South Africa is asking for a delay, possibly due to being unable to prove their allegations to the legal standard needed.

853:" (published by Cambridge University Press). Then specifically to Gaza currently, we have the following academic articles which discuss the argument of a "defensive war" as justification why this does not constitute genocide, and why such an argument doesn't work: 4643:

I'm sorry, but this absolutely has to do with this article. If claims of genocide cannot be substantiated by evidence, this article needs to be evaluated (not just the title but its content). Trying to shoehorn discussion into a separate article is an example of

1728:. This is complicated. There is a war, and a lot of civilians are always killed in every war. Actually, the ratio of civilian:militant killed during this war is pretty low (1:1 according to Israeli sources). It was much higher in wars by US. Then, there could be 592:

out. It's caused a giant mess at the main war page, and we need to figure out a way to not let this disruption continue. I tried to address this here and at AE (unsuccessfully), and when the AE closes I'm planning to bring it up at AN for a community discussion.

985:

That's a tabloid press opinion piece by a prosecutor bigging up other prosecutors and repeating tired Israeli talking points, not a serious anything, and certainly no answer to the peer-reviewed academic papers in the Journal of Genocide Research noted above.

1711:, the topic is widely controversial and there are ferocious arguments about it in the real world. It is best for Knowledge to be neutral and reflect an objective outlook on the issue. The title nominated better serves in protecting Knowledge's neutrality. 799:

Nearly all these sources date back to the early months of the war, when the casualties and damage were, though high, risible compared to the situation from March onwards, where the scale of the devastation multiplied to a level of qualitative difference.

3554:

The purpose of this discussion is to decide on the right alternative name. I so happen to believe that the closer of the last discussion should have been able to count the !votes and group them by names, and decide on one of them, or as a noconsensus.

434:"alleged genocide", while the hatnote informs the reader that "his article is about genocide accusations". Then, the first sentence describes accusations of genocide, just like the rest of the article. Some have pointed to other articles, such as 1740:. What we have are only allegations. They should be described as such, and indeed, they are described as such in the lead of this page (I did not read anything below the lead). The title of the page should simply be consistent with its content. 849:" (which was actually published in a peer-reviewed journal by an expert in genocide studies), about how arguments of "security" and "defense" are used and wielded to justify and perpetrate genocide. Moses then expands this greatly in his book " 960:

I'm aware of the existence of such essays, and certainly the article should discuss in a balanced and NPOV way, the various opinions with due weight, but there also many more sources which are not convinced, even recent ones. For example this

1138:

that's less reputable may take on the reputation of the author. In this case, there's nothing wrong with the publication's reliability, but I'm mainly offering the author as an expert on the topic of war crimes and the prosecution thereof.

1823:'Israeli military rules of engagement reportedly allow the killing of up to 20 civilians to take out a single junior Hamas fighter, 100 for a senior leader. By comparison, the United States put the ratio at 30-to-one for Saddam Hussein.( 2404:; was pinged here since I participated in the previous RM, and my position remains the same. Mainstream media and news outlets don't refer to what's happening in Gaza as a "genocide" in their own 'voice', so neither should Knowledge. 383:

The result of the move request was: This is currently running 2 to 1 against, with most citing procedural issues so in the interest of not wasting everyone's time more than it has already been wasted, I'm closing this. While there is

238:

I'm not insisting on using the exact same pictures with the exact same captions in the example I provided, I'm just saying that such a subject needs definitely more than one picture to illustrate it while taking into consideration

3047:

So I would argue, since there hasn't been any massive change in such sources (though it could be argued a slight move in support of labelling this a genocide), there is not currently grounds to reargue the move of the article. --

4945:

I have a conjecture about this. On essentially the same day that SA was alleged to have sought an extension, Russia sought an extension to a deadline for submitting a counter-memorial regarding Ukraine. The request and ruling is

234:

I think this single image undermines the reality of what's going on in Gaza considering that we got in Commons many precious pictures that illustrate the situation well and I think it would be a shame if they remained unused.

4354:

South Africa is attempting to extend the deadline for presenting evidence against Israel at the International Court of Justice in The Hague because it is unable to prove its allegations of genocide, Kan News reported on

4757:

to consider this until there is something more official. But I do believe bringing up the reports in at this point multiple sources (at least some of which are reliable) that the request is forthcoming. -bɜ:ʳkənhɪmez |

4360:

should protect specific allegations of guilt of the crime of genocide for specific Israelis or other living individuals from being unequivocally stated, as the case is ongoing. I'm not sure that the current text does.

2321:

And this is before we get into the laughable notion of "journalistic objectivity", where broadly sich a notion is ripped to shreds in research, and is even highlighted as an issue in regards to Israel-Palestine. --

2014:"the increasing genocidal rhetoric in the Knesset". Yes, this seems to be true. Somehow I am not surprised given the ferocity and the endless nature of the conflict. I have no idea how they are going to resolve it. 4226:

Those included here use the logic of legal cases brought against them for complicity. As there is a legal case brought against Romania by citizens of Romania, using my 1 revert in this 24 hour period to add it

2443:

based on a fractured discussion that intentionally split editors up between two different "qualifier" words in order to make it seem like the current title had the most support. There is no academic consensus

1067:

That chart also isn't just food because it also shows the other types of humanitarian aid broken out such as shelter and medical supplies. Also, looking at that site, the number was supposed to be 870,000.

1839:

Given that oppose positions are grounded in prior discussion of a mass of first class RS, supporting a change requires serious new sourcing, not trumped up propaganda claims, duly dismissed, like the ToL

1454:

You are probably right. Also, it takes some time for people to organize their Reddit, Discord etc. calls to arms/off-site canvassing efforts. There is normally a sizable delay between call and response.

761:

though that number is, of course, still staggeringly high. The death toll figure comes from the Hamas-run Health Ministry in Gaza.) Genocide is an incendiary accusation that should not be used loosely

415:

wholeheartedly believe that "Gaza genocide" is a premature title and does more harm than good, risking the erosion of public confidence in Knowledge for a wide swath of the population. My reasoning :

2336:

That's not a fair summary of Charny's critique, and anyway the important part of the paper is the data, where a majority of respondents felt the journal involved Holocaust minimization and so forth.

1926:

I did not say the conflict is too complex to possibly understand, and I agree with the author of the linked article about the "myths". This is an interesting "fact checking" article. Please check

2295:

Individual scholars have no such commitment to neutrality. Certain journals might impose some standard of neutrality, but not so much the Journal of Genocide Research, which has been accused of

937:

Further to this, beyond all the issues with bullet points 1–7, which are all contentious claims in the scholarship of each point, I would like to focus on number 8. Bullet point 8 in Baruch's 8

2466:

seem to suggest that these are mere accusations without any substance to them. Such a suggestion would require completely ignoring the words and actions of Israeli officials and IDF soldiers.

4229:

there's nothing about this in the article, and I'd be surprised to find out that such a legal case wouldn't be considered undue when acussing a country of complicity in genocide in Knowledge.

2969: 2177:

To be honest this RM seems like the continuation of the usual toxic battleground behaviour that dominates this topic area. A matter of weeks ago the previous RM closure was endorsed at

316:

Thank you. I'm sure more suitable photographs will gradually become available. I'd be grateful if you could keep an eye on the Commons and come up with an updated collage in a while. —

2040:

found that "these measures, far from protecting Palestinian civilians, serve rather to support Israel’s genocidal campaign by systematically forcing civilians into unliveable areas". (

2941: 3129:, HaOfa's and Oleg Y's usernames are different to their signatures. I already included them. I can't see that Rockstone35, Thisasia, Guise or mountainhead participated in the RM at 3013:

As time has gone on we have seen more people come to the conclusion that this is genocide, a couple of prominent opinions of note that have come out since the last move request are

4720:

is the official statement. Of course the matter won't be definitively put to bed until there is either an official denial or a request for an extension appears on the ICJ website.

2153:

is not required for genocide, nor is "ancestry" and its correlates the only grounds on which genocide can be committed—even according to more restrictive definitions of genocide. (

3897: 4744:

RS does not constrain discussion, it only constrains what is allowed in articles. If you know of an actual confirmation (more than just a repeat) of Kan's claim, please tell us.

3433:

Why u wanna change the name if it's confirmed most victims are civilians 50% women and children. Says it's confirmed in article, change name and it's all of a sudden biased bruh

1982:

press, as well as explicitly in the work of genocide scholars, in published academic articles assessing the current situation as genocidal. Particularly Yoav Di-Capua's article "

1116:

Academic articles by experts in the field, in the leading journal for the field in question, should be considered of more weight than articles published in the popular press. --

3005: 2288:, making it a useful signal for assessing the neutrality of names. Of course this is an ideal; in reality no source is perfectly neutral. But when MSM sources are completely 2439:. Current title is clearly POV, there may not be any new arguments but hopefully there will be an actual assessment of consensus in this discussion. The last RM ended in a 2933: 704:

and that there have been three RMs on this article this year, the filling of another RM so soon after the last one was endorsed by a move review is entirely disruptive.

4611:

It's not unusual for there to be delays in court proceedings, the case is expected to last for years. Anyway, those issues are for the specific article about the case.

3018: 2267: 4713: 4700: 1406:- Someone lit a fire. This will attract attention. Perhaps the talk page should be extended confirmed protected to reduce the cost of enforcing ARBECR compliance. 2965: 1828: 4849: 1831: 4462: 2195:

A few relevant experts have changed from "warning of potential genocide" to "this is genocidal", is the main difference in RS since the last move request. --

477:

I think it is worth distilling all possible new names into to two choices. We need to make sure we end up with something representative of consensus. I think

1009: 745:. First of all, I think it's not at all clear that there's an overwhelming consensus that such a name as the current one is accurate. I find this article by 4174:

not unique, as that is the argument that has lead to the accusations of complicity and legal actions around such in all countries listed as "complicit". --

1643:. As a side note, English Knowledge's reputation remains strong throughout, despite efforts by Israeli lobby groups to cast doubt. Perhaps if we renamed to 4512:

This article contains extensive text accusing various individuals such as Israeli cabinet members or even U.S. President Biden of complicity with crimes.

3036:

Most of the experts who argue this is not genocide are legal scholars, applying the UN framework, that is, they argue there is not currently evidence of

1252:

noted, nothing has changed since the last requested move, and the claim that "unambiguity is more important than concision" is completely unsupported by

504: 292:

Sadly I don't think it is possible to verify whether those children's families accept using the photographs in Knowledge or not (I'd assume they don't).

4772: 4562:

which affords some leeway. However, I think some of the stuff about complicity, for example mentioning several German politicians, goes a bit too far.

4326: 4235: 4210: 4155: 2937: 2125:– As I said on the talk page I believe the current title is an NPOV violation and I do not feel a consensus was reached in the previous move request. 834:

This article is a good overview of the legal basics of Hamas' war crimes and why the war is one of self-defense and an attempt to rescue the hostages.

2957: 1130:

Strictly pertaining to the Eli Rosenbaum op-ed, it's a question of the author's expertise and not simply the publication. An expert article that is

556:

here, when there was consensus, it is tendentious, making people go through the same shit because some people are upset they didn’t get their way.

2945: 1787: 4191:, is there any source other than pro-Palestinian protestors that Romania is complicit in genocide in the Gaza Strip? Nothing in Google Scholar 2529:

Such a move would further the article from a neutral point of view, and as mentioned above this issue has been handily and repeatedly settled.

1347:. Nothing has changed from earlier, and all of the massive amount of evidence in this page still remains. This is just battleground behaviour. 804:

like the early commentators cited here (several with no credentials) was initially sceptical but changed his opinion in August for this reason.

734: 2365:

And to clarify, my previous comment is a summary of how Charny has conducted himself across multiple critiques, not this specific paper. --

2961: 2063: 1478:: While I still think it was inappropriate to change this article's title, the arguments I point to for a procedural close are the same as 407: 3506: 3262:. I suggest you rectify that by pinging ALL editors who were involved in those discussions excluding ones that I've already pinged above. 2908:

as editors involved in the prior RM. Part 4 of 4. Appologies if I've missed anyone or doubled up pinging anyone. It was a lot of editors.

1798: 1012:, with an op-ed by a legendary former director of the US DOJ and an expert in prosecuting war crimes, so absolutely reliable and germane. 374:

Subsequent comments should be made in a new section on the talk page. Editors desiring to contest the closing decision should consider a

4198: 1669: 1368: 701: 668: 439: 133: 4074:

Perhaps if the article were renamed 'Not the Capital' it might help reduce the number of people trying to storm it to Stop the Steal.

1289: 153: 142: 1588:

per Selfstudier and TarnishedPath who echoed what I wanted to say. How many times are we going to do this? Sixth time's the charm? -

388:, respondents there noted that discussions that didn't bring anything new to the table should be handled through existing processes. 4885: 4680:

Arbitration Committee intervention, people will be able to actually decide on a NPOV title without being disrupted. -bɜ:ʳkənhɪmez |

3759: 2949: 2558: 2481: 4926: 4022:

I created this discussion before you disruptively (re)posted the above RM and you improperly moved it, causing further disruption.

3871: 4197:. Several other EU countries sell weapons to Israel, and they do not have their own sections acussing them of genocide complicity 4195: 2214:

moving this article to something that is less POV pushing - but I'm not a fan of this particular proposed title. It's unwieldy. --

4812: 2953: 2598: 1636: 1364:, per u:Andre's arguments. The two discussions (move discussion and closure review) were quite close (per the move review closer 697: 664: 3284:

I suggest you AGF. If you notice any editors missing from my post, who you didn't ping already in your post, you may do so now.

3170:

I ping those two users from the list of names in the move review. The other three are from page move related discussions above.

883:

Expert Commentary, the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, and the Question of Genocide: Prosemitic Bias within a Scholarly Community?

3512: 3322: 2905: 2339:

Sure no news agency is perfectly neutral; that doesn't really matter given that they're completely unanimous on this matter. —

2296: 1674:

a moratorium (for 3/6 months, not any longer), but that vote is already over, extremely convincingly choosing for no moratorium

775: 742: 393: 4141:

condition meets the criteria for genocide anyhow. Is there even a definition for complicity in genocide in international law?

3931: 4965: 4947: 3527: 3475: 3356: 2743: 2347: 2307: 2256: 1556:

this move would be an initial and crucial step in restoring Knowledge's credibility and neutrality regarding ARBPIA topics.

274:

is quite another, and here I'd really would like to make sure that Knowledge respects it and doesn't add to parents' trauma.

4353: 1995:

Gaza as Twilight of Israel Exceptionalism: Holocaust and Genocide Studies from Unprecedented Crisis to Unprecedented Change

1064:

released by the Israeli government that suggests that while most of the aid was public early on, more of it is private now.

4820: 4331: 4240: 4215: 4160: 4093: 4051: 4013: 3982:

Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

3631: 3613: 3560: 3422: 3289: 3245: 3175: 3116: 2071: 2019: 1970: 1938: 1745: 1676:. But, I mean this debate is not going to go away. A month or two maximum after this is closed, there will be another RM. 1334: 1308: 1232: 582: 546: 494: 162: 2449:

reputation to allow a title like this that states as a fact what is still in active, significant debate. -bɜ:ʳkənhɪmez |

4735: 4661:

We just report what reliable sources say. The title has been dealt with. Don't really understand the shoehorning point?

4452: 4419: 4383: 4192: 3438: 3130: 2158: 2045: 1904:... thankfully there are genocide scholars for this topic, as reiterated quite redundantly at the last RM – so covered! 1673: 1201: 916: 651: 385: 72: 67: 59: 1319:

We've had two votes on this now. Unless there is some groundbreaking evidence that miraculously exonerates Israel from

3898:"Warum Deutschland vor dem IGH dem von Südafrika gegen Israel erhobenen Vorwurf des Völkermords entgegentreten sollte" 3072: 1639:

was nominated no less than 10x for deletion (different situation here) and currently is moved to its current target

4204:

three months and nobody has said anything about this propaganda despite the many views that this article receives.

3318: 1862: 1577: 531: 389: 303: 255: 173: 38: 1768:

Actually, the ratio of civilian:militant killed during this war is pretty low (1:1 according to Israeli sources).

4775:, not sure if "the "Kalman Lieberman" program here on Network B" is some sort of attribution. Might be a part of 4675:

Your claim was that discussion shouldn't go here because there's a subarticle. That is attempting to shoehorn it

2536: 2500: 1808: 1644: 365: 3463:

The relationship between genocide status and casualty ratios is a matter for genocide scholars to discuss; this

2037: 708:, but filing an RM less than a month after the previous one was endorsed by a move review is taking the mickey. 4699:

exists. I can't find anything on the ICJ site and I can't find anything in South African sources. For example,

4321: 4251: 4230: 4205: 4150: 4089: 4047: 4009: 3627: 3609: 3556: 3418: 3285: 3255: 3241: 3187: 3171: 3126: 3112: 2691: 2646: 2285: 2067: 2015: 1966: 1934: 1741: 1668:

means this is already over, especially considering the last move review was concluded less than 3 weeks ago on

1228: 578: 542: 490: 2318:

journal ever since it retracted a comment by him accusing another Jewish genocide scholar of Holocaust denial.

1275:– Nothing has changed since the previous RM, no need to open yet another one for essentially the same thing. 4731: 4448: 4415: 4379: 3581: 3434: 2735: 1998:". These three scholars highlight the increasing genocidal rhetoric in the Knesset over the past decade. -- 1606: 1518:. Unless there's any new information that would justify moving this page to the long title mentioned above, 1263: 1049:

For the record in a population of 2 million over 11 months this amounts to 1.3 grams(!) per person per day.

647: 228: 103: 4763: 4685: 4653: 4559: 4108: 4079: 3957:"The big lie of genocide & Gaza: Seven experts on Nazi genocide expose the canard of Israeli 'crimes'" 3546: 3068: 2852: 2454: 2186: 2134: 1460: 1411: 1285: 643: 4149:. Currently the only sources in the section are three newspapers reporting about pro-Palestine protests. 1901: 4916: 4889: 4784: 4666: 4616: 4585: 4533: 4503: 4470: 4411: 4146: 4065: 4027: 3997: 3820: 3234: 3163: 2840: 2836: 2820: 2703: 2554: 2477: 2275: 2222: 1909: 1858: 1699: 1574: 1256:, which treats precision and concision as equally important characteristics in selecting article titles 1103: 1089: 1054: 1033: 991: 746: 680: 672: 527: 375: 313: 297: 266: 249: 240: 2711: 2392:

it's been a few weeks since we closed the last RM, i don't see any new evidence presented etc etc ... —

1801:

that it was acceptable to kill 30 civilians in exchange for taking out one lower-order Hamas commander.

1028:

Still opinion. Still non-academic. And from a hardened political insider with a political perspective.

733:

I will note a precedent for repeated move requests despite nothing really changing due to a POV title,

2248:

MSM sources describe accusations of genocide, rather than calling it a genocide in their own voice. —

449:

which they perceive as dishonest, and Knowledge's great potential for de-polarization is then wasted.

295:

Thank you for reminding me of this, I retract my request til at least better pictures are available —

4953: 4911:

says the ICJ has refused the request for a delay, treating it as fact that there was such a request.

4717: 4555: 4547: 3734: 3516: 3453: 3259: 2707: 2586: 2530: 2496: 2469: 1394: 1227:

there is a discussion below on proposed names if you would like to help select a better alternative.

903: 891: 882: 870: 858: 846: 435: 244: 1366:

Overall, there's nothing in here to suggest one side is emphatically right or wrong on that question

3790: 3502: 3401: 2731: 2650: 2440: 1876: 1845: 1805: 1773:

MVBW. You are citing one Israeli source, that ignored the evidence of Israeli officials themselves.

1681: 1652: 1209: 1001: 809: 3008:

aimed to gather all opinions, and there are a couple of trends of note that should be pointed out:

1424:

if you want, but I don't think you have much chance unless there is quite a bit of IP disruption.

378:

after discussing it on the closer's talk page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

4961: 4875: 4602: 4569: 4543: 4519: 4489: 4479: 4436: 4401: 4368: 4357: 4297: 4278: 3701: 3650: 3577: 3464: 3300: 3264: 3224: 3213: 3192: 3135: 3088: 3026: 2974: 2910: 2857: 2776: 2756: 2747: 2715: 2655: 2427: 2113: 2085: 2080: 1956: 1716: 1622: 1610: 1561: 1527: 1494: 1479: 1426: 1257: 1188: 1157: 1146: 1074: 1019: 976: 786: 738: 710: 626: 597: 558: 512: 462: 346: 322: 285: 47: 17: 3084: 1593: 182: 4776: 2638: 2513: 2066:

comes to my mind. Was it genocide of Armenians? That did not happen in Gaza, at least not yet.

4759: 4754: 4681: 4649: 4645: 4551: 4104: 4075: 3913: 3767: 3694: 3542: 3308: 3108: 3104: 2780: 2739: 2683: 2610: 2590: 2450: 2237: 2182: 2128: 1640: 1544: 1456: 1407: 1376: 1352: 1329: 1305: 1276: 1131: 767: 3704: 3674: 4912: 4867: 4853: 4816: 4780: 4716:

from yesterday the SA president is cited as saying that SA will file a memorial next month.

4662: 4612: 4581: 4529: 4499: 4466: 4061: 4023: 3993: 3905: 3686: 3156: 3092: 2808: 2796: 2618: 2574: 2550: 2473: 2271: 2215: 2154: 2041: 1905: 1695: 1626: 1099: 1085: 1050: 1029: 1005: 987: 676: 271: 4824: 4703:

published only 7 hours ago doesn't mention it even though it mentions the Oct 28 deadline.

4546:

warns about contentious labels ("Genocide Joe") and a slanted POV tone that lacks balance (

4827:) is a radio station that operated under that name 1952-2017, afterwhich it became KAN B ( 4799: 4311: 4288: 4259: 4179: 3833: 3449: 3053: 2848: 2800: 2784: 2687: 2409: 2370: 2327: 2200: 2003: 1502: 1421: 1390: 1253: 1121: 951: 928: 908: 841:

was published 16 October 2023, almost 11 months ago. Thirdly, I would point in counter to

824: 763: 4831:), but the old name is still used often. (Sorry, couldn't be bothered to ill the links.) 4429:

suppose we need that one for anything. If I find the actual KAN link, I'll let you know.

3155:

I participated in the move review, but I did not participate in the May 3rd proposal. --

206:

Bags filled with body parts of Palestinians killed by rocket strikes in Al-Tabaeen school

3498: 3021:

where he has moved from warning of a potential for genocide to this being genocide, and

2885: 4828: 3396: 2901: 2889: 2881: 2824: 2816: 2792: 2788: 2727: 2719: 2642: 2630: 2606: 2578: 2517: 2393: 1872: 1855: 1841: 1677: 1665: 1648: 1224: 1204: 863: 805: 755: 3258:, it's apparent to me that you didn't ping all editors from those discussions. That's 2270:

in the Journal of Genocide Research et al. ... instead of, erm, the local newspapers.

892:

A Threshold Crossed: On Genocidal Intent and the Duty to Prevent Genocide in Palestine

4957: 4930: 4908: 4899: 4871: 4857: 4745: 4721: 4704: 4597: 4564: 4514: 4484: 4431: 4396: 4393: 4363: 4292: 4274: 4137: 4043: 3645: 3605: 3520: 3468: 3445: 3349: 3304: 3219: 3096: 3022: 2812: 2804: 2751: 2695: 2675: 2634: 2626: 2614: 2594: 2582: 2423: 2358: 2340: 2300: 2249: 2233: 2178: 2109: 1952: 1948: 1712: 1589: 1557: 1523: 1515: 1249: 1220: 1141: 1069: 1014: 971: 962: 896: 842: 781: 705: 696:. Absolutely nothing has changed since the last RM. Given that the last RM closed on 622: 593: 508: 458: 403: 342: 317: 280: 107: 4866:

Given the lack of global MSM coverage, I don't think these events are a significant

4779:(updated to include the SA government confirmation that they will file as planned). 4410:

Google Translate exists. Please post Kan News link, I can't find it in the article.

2549:

per logic of the RFC which brought the article to Gaza Genocide in the first place.

774:

and shouldn't be compared to them, and it's at least argued by some experts such as

574: 410:– Let me preface this by saying that, in my mind, there is little doubt that Israel 4933: 4920: 4902: 4893: 4879: 4860: 4835: 4803: 4788: 4766: 4748: 4739: 4724: 4707: 4688: 4670: 4656: 4620: 4606: 4589: 4573: 4537: 4523: 4507: 4493: 4474: 4456: 4440: 4423: 4405: 4387: 4372: 4336: 4315: 4301: 4282: 4263: 4245: 4220: 4183: 4165: 4112: 4097: 4083: 4069: 4055: 4031: 4017: 4001: 3654: 3635: 3617: 3585: 3564: 3549: 3532: 3480: 3457: 3426: 3406: 3361: 3326: 3293: 3279: 3249: 3238: 3236: 3228: 3207: 3179: 3165: 3150: 3120: 3076: 3057: 2989: 2925: 2893: 2872: 2828: 2771: 2723: 2699: 2670: 2622: 2562: 2541: 2521: 2504: 2485: 2457: 2431: 2413: 2396: 2374: 2352: 2331: 2312: 2279: 2261: 2224: 2204: 2190: 2169: 2150: 2140: 2117: 2092: 2075: 2056: 2023: 2007: 1974: 1960: 1942: 1913: 1880: 1866: 1849: 1824: 1749: 1720: 1703: 1685: 1656: 1614: 1597: 1580: 1565: 1548: 1540: 1531: 1506: 1464: 1441: 1415: 1398: 1380: 1372: 1356: 1348: 1339: 1324: 1311: 1302: 1293: 1267: 1236: 1214: 1195: 1164: 1150: 1135: 1125: 1107: 1093: 1078: 1058: 1037: 1023: 995: 980: 955: 932: 828: 813: 790: 725: 684: 655: 630: 601: 586: 565: 550: 535: 516: 498: 466: 397: 350: 324: 307: 287: 259: 4172:

uniquely that Romanian weapon sales to Israel have continued after the war started

3690: 1994: 1984: 1065: 671:, nothing new has been presented and this appears as nothing more than disruptive 424:

I strongly encourage that you first read the "Scholarly and expert opinions" table

3847: 446:

Unambiguity is more important than concision, especially in a polarizing article.

3813:"Holocaust Distortions on Social Media After 10/7. The Antisemitic Mobilization" 3312: 3014: 2897: 2844: 2832: 2602: 2163: 2050: 801: 46:

If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the

4730:

technically aa isn't reliable, and we shouldn't use government press releases.

3812: 3394:

propoped above, inserting here. The others still concatenate Gaza and genocide.

4795: 4307: 4255: 4188: 4175: 3932:"Opinion: I'm an expert in urban warfare. Israel is upholding the laws of war" 3909: 3100: 3049: 2877: 2679: 2405: 2366: 2323: 2196: 2149:

ancestry or other aspects correlated with ancestry (e.g skin color, culture)"—

1999: 1729: 1618: 1498: 1117: 1098:

Oh and the sending of aid in no way absolves Israel of the crime of genocide.

947: 924: 851:

The Problems of Genocide: Permanent Security and the Language of Transgression

820: 3916: 3770: 3697: 1818:

But serious strategic analysts stated shortly afterwards the contrary that:

1790:, where it cites a December 2023 estimation by the IDF that Israel was doing 1493:

above, with further details on the current sources, explained by myself in a

4832: 1989: 771: 750:

rescue the hostages. I also think what David Simon has written is relevant;

3719: 4929:

is another South African source saying that SA doesn't want an extension.

3675:"Word Crimes: Reclaiming The Language of The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict" 1084:

of quibbling, as compared to a difference of three orders of magnitude...

859:"We are Fighting Nazis": Genocidal Fashionings of Gaza(ns) After 7 October 419:

The scholarly/expert opinion is more polarized that what has been claimed.

3760:"Opinion | Israel's war in Gaza isn't genocide, but is it proportionate?" 2181:. Fundamentally what has changed since the last time this was assessed? 4042:. Please do not delete other editors contributions to talk page as per 2240:, and our policy is to use POV names only when they're so common as to 1200:

Agreed that the proposed title is awkward. A better proposal is simply

4200:. From what I can see, this claim is non-existent in reliable sources. 4145:

needs some heavy working and sourcing so that the claim does not look

3387:

is a second favourite often proposed in some form, like the one above.

571:

if you try try again and just get the numbers to turn out then you win

4088:

That kind of conjecture is really not what these talk pages are for.

3002:

scholarly/expert opinion is more polarized that what has been claimed

919:, and having been much more recently published than Baruch's list of 200:

A man carries the body of a Palestinian child killed by the shelling

4254:

apologies I seem to have misremembered the sources for Romania. --

3791:"Grundsätze der Solidarität. Eine Stellungnahme - Normative Orders" 3596:

Based on the discussion immediately above, I would like to propose

3067:

I’d like to see evidence of academic polarization before I decide.

279:

I'll also wait for other editors to opine on the matter. Cheers, —

3133:. Can you please advise where you are getting those editors from? 3519:

is a minor consideration; any of the proposed names seem okay. —

1854:

I don't trust any estimations made over 5 years in the future...@

4392:

The KAN article is in Hebrew. Here's another source from JPost.

1829:

A War They Both Are Losing: Israel, Hamas and the Plight of Gaza

4447:

JPost seems fine actually. i think its a fair bit less biased.

2292:

about a certain naming decision, that should be a wake-up call.

875: 3417:

and some of the longer names proposed in earlier discussions.

1811:, that the combatant vs civilian kill ratio was close to I:!, 941:

focusses on the legality of a blockade, and how if there is a

505:

Knowledge:Arbitration/Requests/Enforcement#IntrepidContributor

457:, and, in the case of a negative, adjust the title afterward. 91: 25: 4884:

Isn't the 'Moon made of green cheese' is more popular phrase?

2855:

as editors involved in the prior RM discussion. Part 3 of 4.

2754:

as editors involved in the prior RM discussion. Part 2 of 4.

4498:

What is it in this article that is specifically of concern?

2297:

Holocaust Minimization, Anti-Israel Themes, and Antisemitism

1931:

Israel is explicitly seeking Palestinians’ total destruction

847:

Replacing 'Genocide' with 'Permanent Security' via Genealogy

318: 281: 455:

whether or not the article should be titled "Gaza genocide"

88:

Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 16 August 2024

3735:"Is What's Happening in Gaza a Genocide? Experts Weigh In" 573:

This topic area as a whole seems ripe with this ideology (

4039:, and then a full seven minutes later you made this post 3380:

is more in line with the current content of the article.

4580:

Still don't see what it has to do with the JP article.

4040: 4037: 3413:

Both these names are shorter and more concise than the

3190:

have you pinged selected editors from the move review?

904:

Genocide and Resistance in Palestine under Law's Shadow

3131:

Talk:Gaza_genocide/Archive_2#Requested_move_3_May_2024

3004:, it is very dependent on how we draw the boundaries. 1539:

per above. Nothing has changed since the previous RM.

3415:

Accusations of Gazan genocide in the Israel–Hamas war

3216:

i do participated in the move from the achieved talk

1900:

The conflict is too complex to possibly understand –

408:

Accusations of Gazan genocide in the Israel–Hamas war

3006:

Template:Expert opinions in the Gaza genocide debate

1809:

which trumpeted the claim you repeat almost verbatim

915:All of these being full articles, published in the 3848:"Israel-Gaza: What did the ICJ ruling really say?" 3722:(Report). Institute for National Security Studies. 2653:as editors involved in the prior RM. Part 1 of 4. 1794:in killing only two civilians for every combatant. 1514:– Nothing has changed since the page was moved to 1047:870 metric tons of food and other humanitarian aid 485:are the best possible names on the NPOV side, and 1694:without demonstrating a change of circumstances. 489:as the current name on the contentious POV side. 4273:characterize it as complicity in Gaza genocide. 1004:and one of the major newspapers in the NY area, 3576:, with a slight preference for 2 per xDanielx. 3392:Allegations of genocide in the Israel-Hamas war 1813:an historic achievement in protecting civilians 4036:No, first you removed the above editor's post 3317:you were missing from overly-long ping lists. 2492:Strong oppose/bad RM/WP:SNOW/Procedural close 1832:International Institute for Strategic Studies 1647:people would stop trying to 'evict' it. ~ 🦝 8: 4898:Yes, but that one's true so it didn't suit. 4701:this South African news story about the case 4550:). Arguably, many of these sources are also 2569:Discussion (Requested move 7 September 2024) 642:- Exactly nothing has changed. This is just 4463:South Africa's genocide case against Israel 3037: 2284:Mainstream media has the unique feature of 1902:The 11 biggest myths about Israel-Palestine 4951: 2970:WikiProject Israel Palestine Collaboration 2467: 2266:Or maybe look to ask the scholarly papers 1345:Strongest possible oppose and speedy close 364:The following is a closed discussion of a 472:Polling (Requested move 7 September 2024) 4378:Why are you linking JNS instead of KAN? 4131:Supposed Romanian complicity in genocide 3872:"Genocide in Gaza is difficult to prove" 2942:WikiProject Crime and Criminal Biography 4856:, not the Indian one of the same name. 3987:Restoring my improperly removed comment 3665: 2972:have been notified of this discussion. 1985:Genocidal Mirroring in Israel/Palestine 1947:That was written in 2015, years before 621:nothing has changed since the last RM. 4225: 4171: 3829: 3818: 3602:Gazan genocide in the Israel–Hamas war 3001: 2241: 1365: 1046: 966: 942: 833: 759: 751: 570: 212:Palestinian body parts in plastic bags 44:Do not edit the contents of this page. 4349:ICJ case delay sought by South Africa 735:1948 Palestinian expulsion and flight 341:The edit request has been retracted. 7: 4287:absolutely agree, that'd be classic 2129: 2064:Flight of Nagorno-Karabakh Armenians 737:. I support some similar rename per 431:The title doesn't match the article. 2934:WikiProject International relations 1369:Knowledge:Move_review/Log/2024_July 440:Black genocide in the United States 203:Dead infant in Kamal Adwan Hospital 3233:From talk page discussions above: 1788:Casualties of the Israel–Hamas war 1586:Strong oppose and procedural close 1202:Accusations of genocide in the ... 1002:Pulitzer Prize winning publication 965:Daily News piece, from last month 197:Bombing campaign of the Gaza Strip 24: 4753:I tend to agree with this. It is 4414:is apparently fairly right-wing. 4138:Gaza genocide#Romanian complicity 3978:The discussion above is closed. 3955:Rosenbaum, Eli M. (2024-08-11). 3896:Walter, Christian (2024-01-11). 3720:The War with Hamas: Legal Basics 2242:effectively become a proper name 1637:Allegations of Israeli apartheid 1520:this discussion should be closed 700:, was endorsed at a move review 386:a consensus against a moratorium 333: 181: 172: 161: 152: 141: 132: 95: 29: 3673:Divine, Donna Robinson (2019). 3600:as the new RM name in place of 3513:Palestinian genocide accusation 3441:) 22:28, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2966:WikiProject Disaster management 743:Palestinian genocide accusation 357:Requested move 7 September 2024 223:the single image in the infobox 4934:22:45, 12 September 2024 (UTC) 4921:13:14, 12 September 2024 (UTC) 4903:07:35, 12 September 2024 (UTC) 4894:05:27, 12 September 2024 (UTC) 4880:04:05, 12 September 2024 (UTC) 4870:of the topic of this article. 4861:02:23, 12 September 2024 (UTC) 4836:16:54, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4804:09:59, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4789:09:34, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4767:05:53, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4749:05:01, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4740:04:28, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4725:04:18, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4714:this South African news report 4708:04:04, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4689:05:46, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4671:03:49, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4657:03:44, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4621:03:39, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4607:03:34, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4590:03:24, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4574:03:33, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4538:03:23, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4524:03:17, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4508:03:10, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4494:02:56, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4475:02:51, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4457:02:45, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4441:02:59, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4424:02:43, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4406:02:41, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4388:02:38, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4373:02:23, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 4337:10:28, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 4316:09:41, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 4302:00:17, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 4264:08:29, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 4060:That can be dealt with at AE. 3811:Jikeli, Gunther (2023-11-27). 3758:Zakaria, Fareed (2024-01-12). 3718:Baruch, Pnina Sharvit (2023). 3655:08:57, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3636:08:55, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3618:08:54, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3586:07:19, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3565:07:13, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3550:03:29, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3533:02:58, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3507:00:13, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3458:05:38, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3407:15:11, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3327:13:49, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3294:11:06, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3280:09:23, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3250:08:19, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3229:08:00, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3208:04:05, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3180:07:11, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3166:03:42, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 3151:02:36, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 2563:17:38, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 2542:17:30, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 2522:17:12, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 2505:08:56, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 2486:07:56, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 2458:03:27, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 2375:15:48, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 2353:15:03, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 2332:09:03, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 2313:04:16, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 1635:per Tarnishedpath. Similarly, 1237:11:16, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 1165:12:14, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 1151:09:12, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 1126:08:54, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 1108:07:52, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 1094:07:43, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 1079:07:25, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 1059:07:16, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 1038:10:40, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 1024:05:42, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 996:05:35, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 981:04:02, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 602:15:42, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 587:15:35, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 566:11:16, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 551:08:01, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 398:17:52, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 1: 4283:23:21, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 4246:23:07, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 4221:22:56, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 4184:22:43, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 4166:22:36, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 4113:07:28, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 4098:17:44, 8 September 2024 (UTC) 4084:10:35, 8 September 2024 (UTC) 4070:18:35, 7 September 2024 (UTC) 4056:18:03, 7 September 2024 (UTC) 4032:18:00, 7 September 2024 (UTC) 4018:17:41, 7 September 2024 (UTC) 4002:17:32, 7 September 2024 (UTC) 3733:Burga, Solcyré (2023-11-13). 3705:10.2979/israelstudies.24.2.01 3691:10.2979/israelstudies.24.2.01 3481:22:45, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 3427:18:07, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 3362:16:32, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 3121:14:08, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 3077:10:59, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 3058:08:53, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2990:04:04, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2926:04:03, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2873:04:01, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2772:03:58, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2671:03:56, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2432:22:48, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2414:22:26, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2397:22:00, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2280:23:49, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2262:21:25, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2225:21:00, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2205:22:31, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2191:19:07, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2170:17:35, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2141:17:27, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2118:17:05, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2093:19:41, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2076:18:48, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2057:17:35, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2024:17:23, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 2008:17:10, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1992:and Luigi Daniele's article " 1975:17:06, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1961:17:01, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1943:16:50, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1914:16:33, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1881:22:44, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1867:22:39, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1850:22:35, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1750:16:04, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1721:15:10, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1704:15:04, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1686:14:04, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1657:13:47, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1605:for the reasons mentioned by 1598:13:04, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1581:12:44, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1566:12:07, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1549:11:08, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1532:10:43, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1507:10:02, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1465:10:55, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1442:10:11, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1416:09:32, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1399:09:12, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1381:07:09, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1357:05:46, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1340:05:44, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1312:05:10, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1294:04:56, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1268:04:44, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1215:10:39, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 1196:03:36, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 956:13:41, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 933:10:27, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 829:09:55, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 819:Convention on the matter. -- 814:08:52, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 791:03:30, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 726:03:09, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 685:03:03, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 656:02:58, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 631:02:55, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 536:20:45, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 517:18:45, 7 September 2024 (UTC) 499:17:06, 7 September 2024 (UTC) 467:15:23, 7 September 2024 (UTC) 4815:) is a radio show hosted by 3930:Spencer, John (2023-11-07). 2135: 2106:Strong oppose/bad RM/WP:SNOW 1933:. That is what I am saying. 943:severe humanitarian shortage 917:Journal of Genocide Research 575:see the 5th banner down here 209:Child dead due to starvation 2599:The Great Mule of Eupatoria 1645:Settlement of Gaza genocide 886:" by Omar Shahabudin McDoom 351:23:37, 16 August 2024 (UTC) 325:20:50, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 308:18:50, 16 August 2024 (UTC) 288:18:40, 16 August 2024 (UTC) 260:02:43, 16 August 2024 (UTC) 122:to reactivate your request. 110:has been answered. Set the 4983: 4306:I've removed Romania. -- 3371:Proposed alternative names 2938:WikiProject Discrimination 2906:DaZyzzogetonsGotDaLastWord 741:and similar article title 663:There was an RM closed on 4773:a google translation here 4482:applies on all articles. 4461:This is a matter for the 3910:10.59704/f0aacf09b66eda04 3604:as proposed above by OP @ 2958:WikiProject Ethnic groups 2744:CommunityNotesContributor 1672:. I would have supported 871:A World Without Civilians 541:policies and guidelines. 483:Gaza genocide allegations 479:Gaza genocide accusations 4646:trying to make a POVFORK 3980:Please do not modify it. 3643:this or the other name. 3598:Gaza genocide accusation 3385:Gaza genocide accusation 3378:Gaza genocide allegation 2946:WikiProject Human rights 2286:journalistic objectivity 1495:discussion comment below 371:Please do not modify it. 192:Clockwise from top left: 4854:South African news site 4823:); whereas Reshet Bet ( 2495:shouldn't entertain it. 229:Template:Multiple image 3828:Cite journal requires 3038: 1836: 1770: 1420:You can request it at 3497:works in my opinion. 3319:ScottishFinnishRadish 2962:WikiProject Palestine 2038:Forensic Architecture 1821: 1766: 747:Donna Robinson Divine 390:ScottishFinnishRadish 42:of past discussions. 4819:and Asaf Lieberman ( 706:Consensus can change 436:Transgender genocide 4252:Super Dromaeosaurus 4090:IntrepidContributor 4048:IntrepidContributor 4010:IntrepidContributor 3961:New York Daily News 3628:IntrepidContributor 3610:IntrepidContributor 3557:IntrepidContributor 3511:Name 2 would match 3419:IntrepidContributor 3286:IntrepidContributor 3256:IntrepidContributor 3242:IntrepidContributor 3188:IntrepidContributor 3172:IntrepidContributor 3127:IntrepidContributor 3113:IntrepidContributor 2647:My very best wishes 2068:My very best wishes 2016:My very best wishes 1967:My very best wishes 1935:My very best wishes 1806:The Times of Israel 1742:My very best wishes 1229:IntrepidContributor 579:PhotogenicScientist 543:IntrepidContributor 491:IntrepidContributor 4732:Bluethricecreamman 4648:. -bɜ:ʳkənhɪmez | 4449:Bluethricecreamman 4416:Bluethricecreamman 4380:Bluethricecreamman 3574:Either one is fine 3435:HumansRightsIsCool 3083:Let's not forget @ 2950:WikiProject Israel 2736:Dreameditsbrooklyn 1607:Bluethricecreamman 648:Bluethricecreamman 646:and relitigation. 18:Talk:Gaza genocide 4969: 4956:comment added by 4558:). Yes, they are 4542:Not as such, but 3876:Leiden University 3460: 3069:Personisinsterest 3000:: In response to 2992: 2954:WikiProject Death 2853:Personisinsterest 2488: 2472:comment added by 1797:Official sources 1641:Israeli apartheid 768:Armenian genocide 126: 125: 85: 84: 54: 53: 48:current talk page 4974: 4817:Kalman Liebskind 4809:Kalman-Lieberman 4771:The Kan report, 4605: 4572: 4560:WP:PUBLICFIGUREs 4522: 4492: 4439: 4404: 4371: 4334: 4329: 4324: 4300: 4243: 4238: 4233: 4218: 4213: 4208: 4163: 4158: 4153: 3971: 3970: 3968: 3967: 3952: 3946: 3945: 3943: 3942: 3927: 3921: 3920: 3893: 3887: 3886: 3884: 3883: 3868: 3862: 3861: 3859: 3858: 3844: 3838: 3837: 3831: 3826: 3824: 3816: 3808: 3802: 3801: 3799: 3798: 3787: 3781: 3780: 3778: 3777: 3755: 3749: 3748: 3746: 3745: 3730: 3724: 3723: 3715: 3709: 3708: 3670: 3653: 3523: 3471: 3443: 3409: 3352: 3316: 3161: 3041: 2931: 2841:Animal lover 666 2837:Me Da Wikipedian 2821:Brusquedandelion 2704:Smallangryplanet 2539: 2533: 2390:Procedural close 2343: 2303: 2252: 2220: 2166: 2139: 2137: 2131: 2088: 2053: 1965:Yes, of course. 1859:Me Da Wikipedian 1476:Procedural close 1337: 1332: 1327: 1282: 1281: 1260: 1259:BluePenguin18 🐧 1191: 1160: 1149: 1077: 1022: 979: 876:Elyse Semerdjian 789: 690:Procedural close 561: 528:Me Da Wikipedian 524:procedural close 453:to first debate 373: 337: 336: 320: 314:The Cheesedealer 300: 283: 272:right to privacy 267:The Cheesedealer 252: 185: 176: 165: 156: 145: 136: 117: 113: 99: 98: 92: 81: 56: 55: 33: 32: 26: 4982: 4981: 4977: 4976: 4975: 4973: 4972: 4971: 4601: 4568: 4518: 4488: 4435: 4400: 4367: 4351: 4332: 4327: 4322: 4296: 4241: 4236: 4231: 4216: 4211: 4206: 4161: 4156: 4151: 4133: 3989: 3984: 3983: 3976: 3975: 3974: 3965: 3963: 3954: 3953: 3949: 3940: 3938: 3929: 3928: 3924: 3902:Verfassungsblog 3895: 3894: 3890: 3881: 3879: 3870: 3869: 3865: 3856: 3854: 3846: 3845: 3841: 3827: 3817: 3810: 3809: 3805: 3796: 3794: 3789: 3788: 3784: 3775: 3773: 3764:Washington Post 3757: 3756: 3752: 3743: 3741: 3732: 3731: 3727: 3717: 3716: 3712: 3672: 3671: 3667: 3649: 3594: 3592:New name for RM 3530: 3521: 3515:nicely, though 3478: 3469: 3465:isn't the place 3395: 3373: 3359: 3350: 3298: 3157: 3039:dolus specialis 2708:Vinegarymass911 2587:Entropyandvodka 2571: 2551:🌸wasianpower🌸 2537: 2532:entropyandvodka 2531: 2497:Raskolnikov.Rev 2350: 2341: 2310: 2301: 2259: 2250: 2216: 2164: 2126: 2086: 2051: 1951:began in 2023. 1799:stated by April 1792:remarkably well 1379: 1335: 1330: 1325: 1279: 1277: 1258: 1189: 1158: 1155:He isn’t that. 1145: 1073: 1018: 975: 909:Maryam Jamshidi 785: 644:WP:BATTLEGROUND 559: 474: 369: 359: 334: 298: 250: 221:Please replace 219: 218: 217: 216: 215: 188: 187: 186: 178: 177: 168: 167: 166: 158: 157: 148: 147: 146: 138: 137: 115: 111: 96: 90: 77: 30: 22: 21: 20: 12: 11: 5: 4980: 4978: 4943: 4942: 4941: 4940: 4939: 4938: 4937: 4936: 4882: 4845: 4844: 4843: 4842: 4841: 4840: 4839: 4838: 4806: 4769: 4696: 4695: 4694: 4693: 4692: 4691: 4641: 4640: 4639: 4638: 4637: 4636: 4635: 4634: 4633: 4632: 4631: 4630: 4629: 4628: 4627: 4626: 4625: 4624: 4623: 4578: 4577: 4576: 4528:In Wikivoice? 4445: 4444: 4443: 4350: 4347: 4346: 4345: 4344: 4343: 4342: 4341: 4340: 4339: 4270: 4269: 4268: 4267: 4266: 4223: 4201: 4147:WP:EXCEPTIONAL 4132: 4129: 4128: 4127: 4126: 4125: 4124: 4123: 4122: 4121: 4120: 4119: 4118: 4117: 4116: 4115: 3988: 3985: 3977: 3973: 3972: 3947: 3922: 3888: 3863: 3839: 3803: 3782: 3750: 3725: 3710: 3679:Israel Studies 3664: 3663: 3659: 3658: 3657: 3638: 3626:as nominator. 3593: 3590: 3589: 3588: 3570: 3569: 3568: 3567: 3535: 3526: 3509: 3486: 3485: 3484: 3483: 3474: 3411: 3410: 3388: 3381: 3372: 3369: 3367: 3365: 3364: 3355: 3342: 3341: 3340: 3339: 3338: 3337: 3336: 3335: 3334: 3333: 3332: 3331: 3330: 3329: 3231: 3184: 3183: 3182: 3080: 3079: 3061: 3060: 3044: 3043: 3034: 3030: 3010: 3009: 2994: 2993: 2875: 2774: 2732:Metropolitan90 2673: 2651:Stephan rostie 2570: 2567: 2566: 2565: 2544: 2524: 2507: 2489: 2460: 2434: 2416: 2399: 2387: 2386: 2385: 2384: 2383: 2382: 2381: 2380: 2379: 2378: 2377: 2363: 2346: 2337: 2319: 2306: 2293: 2255: 2227: 2209: 2208: 2207: 2172: 2143: 2123:Strong support 2120: 2102: 2101: 2100: 2099: 2098: 2097: 2096: 2095: 2034: 2033: 2032: 2031: 2030: 2029: 2028: 2027: 2026: 1979: 1978: 1977: 1919: 1918: 1917: 1916: 1892: 1891: 1890: 1889: 1888: 1887: 1886: 1885: 1884: 1883: 1837: 1819: 1816: 1802: 1795: 1779: 1778: 1777: 1776: 1775: 1774: 1771: 1764: 1753: 1752: 1723: 1706: 1688: 1670:22 August 2024 1659: 1630: 1600: 1583: 1571:Strong support 1568: 1551: 1534: 1509: 1472: 1471: 1470: 1469: 1468: 1467: 1447: 1446: 1445: 1444: 1401: 1386:Strong Support 1383: 1375: 1359: 1342: 1314: 1296: 1270: 1243: 1242: 1241: 1240: 1239: 1180: 1179: 1178: 1177: 1176: 1175: 1174: 1173: 1172: 1171: 1170: 1169: 1168: 1167: 1114: 1113: 1112: 1111: 1110: 1096: 1044: 1043: 1042: 1041: 1040: 913: 912: 911: 899: 887: 878: 866: 831: 816: 794: 793: 756:Fareed Zakaria 728: 702:22 August 2024 687: 673:WP:IDONTLIKEIT 669:22 August 2024 667:, endorsed on 658: 633: 615: 614: 613: 612: 611: 610: 609: 608: 607: 606: 605: 604: 519: 473: 470: 401: 381: 380: 366:requested move 360: 358: 355: 354: 353: 331: 330: 329: 328: 327: 299:🧀Cheesedealer 293: 276: 275: 251:🧀Cheesedealer 241:WP:NOTCENSORED 214: 213: 210: 207: 204: 201: 198: 194: 190: 189: 180: 179: 171: 170: 169: 160: 159: 151: 150: 149: 140: 139: 131: 130: 129: 128: 127: 124: 123: 100: 89: 86: 83: 82: 75: 70: 65: 62: 52: 51: 34: 23: 15: 14: 13: 10: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 4979: 4970: 4967: 4963: 4959: 4955: 4949: 4935: 4932: 4928: 4924: 4923: 4922: 4918: 4914: 4910: 4906: 4905: 4904: 4901: 4897: 4896: 4895: 4891: 4887: 4883: 4881: 4877: 4873: 4869: 4865: 4864: 4863: 4862: 4859: 4855: 4851: 4837: 4834: 4830: 4826: 4822: 4818: 4814: 4810: 4807: 4805: 4801: 4797: 4794:evidence. -- 4792: 4791: 4790: 4786: 4782: 4778: 4774: 4770: 4768: 4765: 4761: 4756: 4752: 4751: 4750: 4747: 4743: 4742: 4741: 4737: 4733: 4729: 4728: 4727: 4726: 4723: 4719: 4715: 4710: 4709: 4706: 4702: 4690: 4687: 4683: 4678: 4674: 4673: 4672: 4668: 4664: 4660: 4659: 4658: 4655: 4651: 4647: 4642: 4622: 4618: 4614: 4610: 4609: 4608: 4604: 4600: 4599: 4593: 4592: 4591: 4587: 4583: 4579: 4575: 4571: 4567: 4566: 4561: 4557: 4556:WP:BLPPRIMARY 4554:sources (see 4553: 4549: 4548:WP:BLPBALANCE 4545: 4541: 4540: 4539: 4535: 4531: 4527: 4526: 4525: 4521: 4517: 4516: 4511: 4510: 4509: 4505: 4501: 4497: 4496: 4495: 4491: 4487: 4486: 4481: 4478: 4477: 4476: 4472: 4468: 4464: 4460: 4459: 4458: 4454: 4450: 4446: 4442: 4438: 4434: 4433: 4427: 4426: 4425: 4421: 4417: 4413: 4409: 4408: 4407: 4403: 4399: 4398: 4394: 4391: 4390: 4389: 4385: 4381: 4377: 4376: 4375: 4374: 4370: 4366: 4365: 4359: 4356: 4348: 4338: 4335: 4330: 4325: 4319: 4318: 4317: 4313: 4309: 4305: 4304: 4303: 4299: 4295: 4294: 4290: 4286: 4285: 4284: 4280: 4276: 4271: 4265: 4261: 4257: 4253: 4249: 4248: 4247: 4244: 4239: 4234: 4228: 4224: 4222: 4219: 4214: 4209: 4202: 4199: 4196: 4193: 4190: 4187: 4186: 4185: 4181: 4177: 4173: 4170: 4169: 4168: 4167: 4164: 4159: 4154: 4148: 4142: 4139: 4130: 4114: 4110: 4106: 4101: 4100: 4099: 4095: 4091: 4087: 4086: 4085: 4081: 4077: 4073: 4072: 4071: 4067: 4063: 4059: 4058: 4057: 4053: 4049: 4045: 4041: 4038: 4035: 4034: 4033: 4029: 4025: 4021: 4020: 4019: 4015: 4011: 4006: 4005: 4004: 4003: 3999: 3995: 3986: 3981: 3962: 3958: 3951: 3948: 3937: 3933: 3926: 3923: 3918: 3915: 3911: 3907: 3903: 3899: 3892: 3889: 3877: 3873: 3867: 3864: 3853: 3849: 3843: 3840: 3835: 3822: 3814: 3807: 3804: 3792: 3786: 3783: 3772: 3769: 3765: 3761: 3754: 3751: 3740: 3736: 3729: 3726: 3721: 3714: 3711: 3706: 3703: 3699: 3696: 3692: 3688: 3684: 3680: 3676: 3669: 3666: 3662: 3656: 3652: 3648: 3647: 3642: 3639: 3637: 3633: 3629: 3625: 3622: 3621: 3620: 3619: 3615: 3611: 3607: 3603: 3599: 3591: 3587: 3583: 3579: 3578:FortunateSons 3575: 3572: 3571: 3566: 3562: 3558: 3553: 3552: 3551: 3548: 3544: 3539: 3538:Either 1 or 2 3536: 3534: 3529: 3524: 3518: 3517:WP:CONSISTENT 3514: 3510: 3508: 3504: 3500: 3496: 3492: 3488: 3487: 3482: 3477: 3472: 3466: 3462: 3461: 3459: 3455: 3451: 3447: 3442: 3440: 3436: 3431: 3430: 3429: 3428: 3424: 3420: 3416: 3408: 3405: 3404: 3400: 3399: 3393: 3389: 3386: 3382: 3379: 3375: 3374: 3370: 3368: 3363: 3358: 3353: 3347: 3344: 3343: 3328: 3324: 3320: 3314: 3310: 3306: 3302: 3301:Chuckstablers 3297: 3296: 3295: 3291: 3287: 3283: 3282: 3281: 3278: 3277: 3276: 3273: 3270: 3267: 3261: 3260:WP:CANVASSING 3257: 3253: 3252: 3251: 3247: 3243: 3239: 3237: 3235: 3232: 3230: 3227: 3226: 3225: 3223: 3222: 3215: 3214:TarnishedPath 3211: 3210: 3209: 3206: 3205: 3204: 3201: 3198: 3195: 3189: 3185: 3181: 3177: 3173: 3169: 3168: 3167: 3164: 3162: 3160: 3154: 3153: 3152: 3149: 3148: 3147: 3144: 3141: 3138: 3132: 3128: 3124: 3123: 3122: 3118: 3114: 3110: 3106: 3102: 3098: 3094: 3090: 3086: 3082: 3081: 3078: 3074: 3070: 3066: 3063: 3062: 3059: 3055: 3051: 3046: 3045: 3040: 3035: 3031: 3028: 3024: 3023:Amos Goldberg 3020: 3016: 3012: 3011: 3007: 3003: 2999: 2996: 2995: 2991: 2988: 2987: 2986: 2983: 2980: 2977: 2971: 2967: 2963: 2959: 2955: 2951: 2947: 2943: 2939: 2935: 2930: 2929: 2928: 2927: 2924: 2923: 2922: 2919: 2916: 2913: 2907: 2903: 2899: 2895: 2891: 2887: 2883: 2879: 2874: 2871: 2870: 2869: 2866: 2863: 2860: 2854: 2850: 2846: 2842: 2838: 2834: 2830: 2826: 2822: 2818: 2814: 2810: 2806: 2802: 2798: 2794: 2790: 2786: 2782: 2778: 2777:Trilletrollet 2773: 2770: 2769: 2768: 2765: 2762: 2759: 2753: 2749: 2748:BluePenguin18 2745: 2741: 2737: 2733: 2729: 2725: 2721: 2717: 2716:FortunateSons 2713: 2709: 2705: 2701: 2697: 2693: 2689: 2685: 2681: 2677: 2672: 2669: 2668: 2667: 2664: 2661: 2658: 2652: 2648: 2644: 2640: 2636: 2632: 2628: 2624: 2620: 2616: 2612: 2608: 2604: 2600: 2596: 2592: 2588: 2584: 2580: 2576: 2568: 2564: 2560: 2556: 2552: 2548: 2547:Strong oppose 2545: 2543: 2540: 2534: 2528: 2525: 2523: 2519: 2515: 2511: 2508: 2506: 2502: 2498: 2493: 2490: 2487: 2483: 2479: 2475: 2471: 2464: 2461: 2459: 2456: 2452: 2447: 2442: 2438: 2435: 2433: 2429: 2425: 2420: 2417: 2415: 2411: 2407: 2403: 2400: 2398: 2395: 2391: 2388: 2376: 2372: 2368: 2364: 2360: 2356: 2355: 2354: 2349: 2344: 2338: 2335: 2334: 2333: 2329: 2325: 2320: 2316: 2315: 2314: 2309: 2304: 2298: 2294: 2291: 2287: 2283: 2282: 2281: 2277: 2273: 2269: 2265: 2264: 2263: 2258: 2253: 2247: 2243: 2239: 2235: 2234:Gaza genocide 2231: 2228: 2226: 2223: 2221: 2219: 2213: 2210: 2206: 2202: 2198: 2194: 2193: 2192: 2188: 2184: 2180: 2176: 2175:Strong oppose 2173: 2171: 2168: 2167: 2160: 2156: 2152: 2147: 2144: 2142: 2138: 2132: 2124: 2121: 2119: 2115: 2111: 2107: 2104: 2103: 2094: 2090: 2089: 2082: 2079: 2078: 2077: 2073: 2069: 2065: 2060: 2059: 2058: 2055: 2054: 2047: 2043: 2039: 2035: 2025: 2021: 2017: 2013: 2012: 2011: 2010: 2009: 2005: 2001: 1997: 1996: 1991: 1987: 1986: 1980: 1976: 1972: 1968: 1964: 1963: 1962: 1958: 1954: 1950: 1949:Gaza genocide 1946: 1945: 1944: 1940: 1936: 1932: 1929: 1925: 1924: 1923: 1922: 1921: 1920: 1915: 1911: 1907: 1903: 1899: 1896: 1895: 1894: 1893: 1882: 1878: 1874: 1870: 1869: 1868: 1864: 1860: 1857: 1853: 1852: 1851: 1847: 1843: 1838: 1835: 1833: 1830: 1826: 1820: 1817: 1814: 1810: 1807: 1803: 1800: 1796: 1793: 1789: 1785: 1784: 1783: 1782: 1781: 1780: 1772: 1769: 1765: 1763: 1759: 1758: 1757: 1756: 1755: 1754: 1751: 1747: 1743: 1739: 1735: 1731: 1727: 1724: 1722: 1718: 1714: 1710: 1707: 1705: 1701: 1697: 1692: 1691:Strong oppose 1689: 1687: 1683: 1679: 1675: 1671: 1667: 1663: 1660: 1658: 1654: 1650: 1646: 1642: 1638: 1634: 1633:Strong oppose 1631: 1628: 1624: 1623:BluePenguin18 1620: 1616: 1612: 1611:TarnishedPath 1608: 1604: 1603:Strong oppose 1601: 1599: 1595: 1591: 1587: 1584: 1582: 1579: 1576: 1572: 1569: 1567: 1563: 1559: 1555: 1552: 1550: 1546: 1542: 1538: 1537:Strong oppose 1535: 1533: 1529: 1525: 1521: 1517: 1516:Gaza genocide 1513: 1512:Strong oppose 1510: 1508: 1504: 1500: 1496: 1492: 1491: 1488: 1485: 1482: 1477: 1474: 1473: 1466: 1462: 1458: 1453: 1452: 1451: 1450: 1449: 1448: 1443: 1440: 1439: 1438: 1435: 1432: 1429: 1423: 1419: 1418: 1417: 1413: 1409: 1405: 1402: 1400: 1396: 1392: 1387: 1384: 1382: 1378: 1374: 1370: 1367: 1363: 1360: 1358: 1354: 1350: 1346: 1343: 1341: 1338: 1333: 1328: 1322: 1318: 1317:Strong Oppose 1315: 1313: 1310: 1307: 1304: 1300: 1297: 1295: 1291: 1287: 1283: 1274: 1273:Strong oppose 1271: 1269: 1265: 1261: 1255: 1251: 1247: 1246:Strong oppose 1244: 1238: 1234: 1230: 1226: 1222: 1218: 1217: 1216: 1213: 1212: 1208: 1207: 1203: 1199: 1198: 1197: 1193: 1192: 1185: 1182: 1181: 1166: 1162: 1161: 1154: 1153: 1152: 1148: 1144: 1143: 1137: 1133: 1129: 1128: 1127: 1123: 1119: 1115: 1109: 1105: 1101: 1097: 1095: 1091: 1087: 1082: 1081: 1080: 1076: 1072: 1071: 1066: 1062: 1061: 1060: 1056: 1052: 1048: 1045: 1039: 1035: 1031: 1027: 1026: 1025: 1021: 1017: 1016: 1011: 1007: 1003: 999: 998: 997: 993: 989: 984: 983: 982: 978: 974: 973: 969: 964: 963:Eli Rosenbaum 959: 958: 957: 953: 949: 944: 940: 939:bullet points 936: 935: 934: 930: 926: 922: 921:bullet points 918: 914: 910: 906: 905: 900: 898: 897:Nimer Sultany 894: 893: 888: 885: 884: 879: 877: 873: 872: 867: 865: 861: 860: 855: 854: 852: 848: 844: 843:A. Dirk Moses 840: 839:bullet points 835: 832: 830: 826: 822: 817: 815: 811: 807: 803: 798: 797: 796: 795: 792: 788: 784: 783: 777: 773: 769: 765: 762: 757: 754: 748: 744: 740: 736: 732: 729: 727: 724: 723: 722: 719: 716: 713: 707: 703: 699: 695: 691: 688: 686: 682: 678: 674: 670: 666: 662: 661:Strong oppose 659: 657: 653: 649: 645: 641: 637: 636:Strong oppose 634: 632: 628: 624: 620: 619:Strong oppose 617: 616: 603: 599: 595: 590: 589: 588: 584: 580: 576: 572: 569: 568: 567: 563: 562: 554: 553: 552: 548: 544: 539: 538: 537: 533: 529: 525: 520: 518: 514: 510: 506: 502: 501: 500: 496: 492: 488: 487:Gaza genocide 484: 480: 476: 475: 471: 469: 468: 464: 460: 456: 450: 447: 443: 441: 437: 432: 428: 425: 420: 416: 413: 409: 405: 404:Gaza genocide 400: 399: 395: 391: 387: 379: 377: 372: 367: 362: 361: 356: 352: 348: 344: 340: 332: 326: 323: 321: 315: 311: 310: 309: 306: 305: 304: 301: 294: 291: 290: 289: 286: 284: 278: 277: 273: 268: 264: 263: 262: 261: 258: 257: 256: 253: 246: 245:WP:GRATUITOUS 242: 236: 232: 231: 230: 224: 211: 208: 205: 202: 199: 196: 195: 193: 184: 175: 164: 155: 144: 135: 121: 118:parameter to 109: 108:Gaza genocide 105: 101: 94: 93: 87: 80: 76: 74: 71: 69: 66: 63: 61: 58: 57: 49: 45: 41: 40: 35: 28: 27: 19: 4952:— Preceding 4944: 4846: 4808: 4711: 4697: 4676: 4596: 4563: 4513: 4483: 4430: 4395: 4362: 4352: 4291: 4143: 4134: 4105:Sean.hoyland 4076:Sean.hoyland 3990: 3979: 3964:. Retrieved 3960: 3950: 3939:. Retrieved 3935: 3925: 3901: 3891: 3880:. Retrieved 3878:. 2024-01-11 3875: 3866: 3855:. Retrieved 3851: 3842: 3821:cite journal 3806: 3795:. Retrieved 3785: 3774:. Retrieved 3763: 3753: 3742:. Retrieved 3738: 3728: 3713: 3682: 3678: 3668: 3660: 3644: 3640: 3623: 3601: 3597: 3595: 3573: 3537: 3494: 3490: 3432: 3414: 3412: 3402: 3397: 3391: 3384: 3377: 3366: 3345: 3309:Hemiauchenia 3274: 3271: 3268: 3265: 3263: 3220: 3218: 3217: 3202: 3199: 3196: 3193: 3191: 3158: 3145: 3142: 3139: 3136: 3134: 3109:mountainhead 3105:Zohariko1234 3064: 2997: 2984: 2981: 2978: 2975: 2973: 2920: 2917: 2914: 2911: 2909: 2867: 2864: 2861: 2858: 2856: 2781:TimeEngineer 2766: 2763: 2760: 2757: 2755: 2740:CoffeeCrumbs 2712:BilledMammal 2684:Oleg Yunakov 2665: 2662: 2659: 2656: 2654: 2611:Howardcorn33 2591:Chaotic Enby 2572: 2546: 2526: 2509: 2491: 2468:— Preceding 2462: 2445: 2437:Support move 2436: 2419:Support move 2418: 2401: 2389: 2289: 2245: 2229: 2217: 2211: 2183:AusLondonder 2174: 2162: 2151:mass killing 2145: 2130:mountainhead 2122: 2105: 2084: 2049: 1993: 1983: 1930: 1927: 1897: 1834:4 June 2024. 1825:Daniel Byman 1822: 1812: 1791: 1767: 1761: 1737: 1733: 1725: 1708: 1690: 1661: 1632: 1602: 1585: 1575:Animal lover 1570: 1554:Support move 1553: 1536: 1519: 1511: 1489: 1486: 1483: 1480: 1475: 1457:Sean.hoyland 1436: 1433: 1430: 1427: 1425: 1408:Sean.hoyland 1403: 1385: 1361: 1344: 1320: 1316: 1298: 1272: 1245: 1210: 1205: 1187: 1183: 1156: 1140: 1068: 1013: 970: 938: 920: 902: 890: 881: 869: 857: 850: 838: 780: 776:John Spencer 753:also agrees. 731:Support move 730: 720: 717: 714: 711: 709: 693: 689: 660: 639: 635: 618: 557: 523: 486: 482: 478: 454: 451: 445: 444: 430: 429: 423: 418: 417: 411: 402: 382: 370: 363: 338: 302: 296: 254: 248: 237: 233: 226: 222: 220: 191: 119: 104:edit request 78: 43: 37: 4913:Selfstudier 4886:84.54.73.17 4813:קלמן ליברמן 4781:Selfstudier 4764:talk to me! 4686:talk to me! 4663:Selfstudier 4654:talk to me! 4613:Selfstudier 4582:Selfstudier 4544:WP:BLPSTYLE 4530:Selfstudier 4500:Selfstudier 4480:WP:BLPCRIME 4467:Selfstudier 4358:WP:BLPCRIME 4320:Thank you. 4062:Selfstudier 4024:Selfstudier 3994:Selfstudier 3852:www.bbc.com 3793:(in German) 3685:(2): 1–16. 3547:talk to me! 3093:Rockstone35 3019:August 2024 3015:Omer Bartov 2809:KetchupSalt 2797:Vice regent 2619:Iskandar323 2575:Paul Vaurie 2474:KetchupSalt 2455:talk to me! 2272:Iskandar323 2268:already out 2081:WP:NOTFORUM 1906:Iskandar323 1696:Iskandar323 1664:. Firstly, 1627:Selfstudier 1331:Consermonor 1100:KetchupSalt 1086:KetchupSalt 1051:KetchupSalt 1030:Iskandar323 988:Iskandar323 864:Zoé Samudzi 845:' article " 802:Omer Bartov 739:WP:POVTITLE 698:3 July 2024 677:Selfstudier 665:3 July 2024 376:move review 36:This is an 4821:אסף ליברמן 4552:WP:PRIMARY 3966:2024-09-10 3941:2024-09-09 3882:2024-09-09 3857:2024-09-09 3797:2024-09-09 3776:2024-09-09 3744:2024-09-09 3661:References 3467:for it. — 3450:Left guide 3448:violation 2849:NoonIcarus 2801:Crossroads 2785:Bondegezou 2688:Eladkarmel 2238:WP:POVNAME 1730:war crimes 1651:(he/him • 1391:Eladkarmel 1377:¿question? 1321:everything 1132:WP:SELFPUB 112:|answered= 4868:WP:ASPECT 4465:article. 3917:2366-7044 3830:|journal= 3771:0190-8286 3698:1084-9513 3398:SPECIFICO 3390:Name #3: 3383:Name #2: 3376:Name #1: 3159:Rockstone 3033:journals. 3027:July 2024 2902:SPECIFICO 2890:Alalch E. 2882:Kowal2701 2876:Pinging @ 2825:AndyBloch 2817:Cremastra 2793:Blindlynx 2789:Cremastra 2775:Pinging @ 2728:MarkiPoli 2720:Nishidani 2674:Pinging @ 2643:Hogo-2020 2631:Unbandito 2607:Esolo5002 2579:Simonm223 2573:Pinging @ 2441:supervote 2394:blindlynx 2290:unanimous 2218:Rockstone 1990:Raz Segal 1928:Myth #10: 1873:Nishidani 1871:Corrected 1856:Nishidani 1842:Nishidani 1678:MarkiPoli 1649:Shushugah 1336:Opus meum 1303:Ferocious 1225:SPECIFICO 1206:SPECIFICO 1006:WP:GENREL 806:Nishidani 772:Holocaust 79:Archive 5 73:Archive 4 68:Archive 3 60:Archive 1 4966:contribs 4958:Zero0000 4954:unsigned 4907:Now the 4872:Levivich 4850:a denial 4755:too soon 4355:Tuesday. 4289:WP:SYNTH 4275:Levivich 3606:WikiFouf 3522:xDanielx 3499:Let'srun 3470:xDanielx 3351:xDanielx 3305:Sameboat 3221:Thisasia 3097:Thisasia 2886:Let'srun 2813:Vegan416 2805:FunLater 2752:XDanielx 2696:FunLater 2676:Rainsage 2627:Levivich 2615:CybJubal 2595:Zanahary 2583:Kashmiri 2559:contribs 2482:contribs 2470:unsigned 2424:Springee 2359:XDanielx 2342:xDanielx 2302:xDanielx 2251:xDanielx 2110:Levivich 2087:nableezy 1953:Levivich 1898:Myth #1: 1760:'Comment 1738:de facto 1713:Galamore 1558:ABHammad 1524:FunLater 1422:WP:RPP/I 1290:contribs 1278:Chaotic 1254:WP:TITLE 1250:M.Bitton 1221:Nableezy 1190:nableezy 1159:nableezy 1134:or in a 764:Habermas 758:agrees: 623:M.Bitton 594:Levivich 560:nableezy 509:Levivich 459:WikiFouf 343:M.Bitton 319:kashmīrī 282:kashmīrī 3641:Support 3624:Support 3489:Either 3444:struck 3346:Comment 3311:, and 3065:Comment 2998:Comment 2894:Iazyges 2829:Alaexis 2724:SKAG123 2700:Skitash 2623:David A 2402:Support 2230:Support 2212:Support 1988:", and 1804:It was 1734:de juro 1726:Support 1709:Support 1666:WP:SNOW 1615:Iazyges 1541:Skitash 1404:Comment 1373:Alaexis 1362:Support 1349:David A 1326:Iazyges 1309:Ferrets 1000:It's a 770:or the 640:Bad RFC 481:and/or 39:archive 4825:רשת ב' 4044:WP:TPO 3495:Name 2 3491:Name 1 3446:WP:ECR 3313:Redxiv 3089:Oleg Y 2968:, and 2932:Note: 2898:Huldra 2845:Kinsio 2833:Czello 2603:Jerdle 2527:Oppose 2510:Oppose 2463:Oppose 2446:at all 2179:WP:MRV 2165:buidhe 2146:Oppose 2052:buidhe 1840:piece. 1662:Oppose 1306:Flying 1299:Oppose 1184:Oppose 1010:WP:RSP 694:Oppose 4829:כאן ב 4796:Cdjp1 4598:Andre 4565:Andre 4515:Andre 4485:Andre 4432:Andre 4397:Andre 4364:Andre 4323:Super 4308:Cdjp1 4293:Andre 4256:Cdjp1 4232:Super 4207:Super 4189:Cdjp1 4176:Cdjp1 4152:Super 3702:JSTOR 3646:Andre 3107:and @ 3101:Guise 3085:HaOfa 3050:Cdjp1 2904:and @ 2878:Some1 2851:and @ 2750:and @ 2692:האופה 2680:Cdjp1 2649:and @ 2635:Ïvana 2406:Some1 2367:Cdjp1 2362:here. 2324:Cdjp1 2236:is a 2197:Cdjp1 2000:Cdjp1 1619:Cdjp1 1590:Ïvana 1578:|666| 1499:Cdjp1 1223:and @ 1142:Andre 1136:WP:RS 1118:Cdjp1 1070:Andre 1015:Andre 972:Andre 948:Cdjp1 925:Cdjp1 923:. -- 907:" by 895:" by 874:" by 862:" by 821:Cdjp1 782:Andre 503:FYI, 339:Note: 116:|ans= 102:This 16:< 4962:talk 4948:here 4931:Zero 4927:here 4925:And 4917:talk 4900:Zero 4890:talk 4876:talk 4858:Zero 4833:El_C 4800:talk 4785:talk 4777:this 4746:Zero 4736:talk 4722:Zero 4718:Here 4705:Zero 4677:away 4667:talk 4617:talk 4586:talk 4534:talk 4504:talk 4471:talk 4453:talk 4420:talk 4384:talk 4312:talk 4279:talk 4260:talk 4227:back 4180:talk 4109:talk 4094:talk 4080:talk 4066:talk 4052:talk 4028:talk 4014:talk 3998:talk 3914:ISSN 3834:help 3768:ISSN 3739:TIME 3695:ISSN 3632:talk 3614:talk 3582:talk 3561:talk 3503:talk 3454:talk 3439:talk 3423:talk 3403:talk 3323:talk 3290:talk 3275:Path 3246:talk 3203:Path 3176:talk 3146:Path 3117:talk 3073:talk 3054:talk 2985:Path 2921:Path 2868:Path 2767:Path 2666:Path 2639:PBZE 2555:talk 2538:talk 2518:talk 2514:PBZE 2501:talk 2478:talk 2428:talk 2410:talk 2371:talk 2328:talk 2299:. — 2276:talk 2201:talk 2187:talk 2114:talk 2072:talk 2020:talk 2004:talk 1971:talk 1957:talk 1939:talk 1910:talk 1877:talk 1863:talk 1846:talk 1786:See 1746:talk 1717:talk 1700:talk 1682:talk 1653:talk 1625:and 1594:talk 1562:talk 1545:talk 1528:talk 1503:talk 1497:. -- 1490:Path 1461:talk 1437:Path 1412:talk 1395:talk 1353:talk 1286:talk 1280:Enby 1233:talk 1211:talk 1122:talk 1104:talk 1090:talk 1055:talk 1034:talk 992:talk 952:talk 929:talk 825:talk 810:talk 721:Path 681:talk 652:talk 638:and 627:talk 598:talk 583:talk 547:talk 532:talk 513:talk 495:talk 463:talk 438:and 394:talk 347:talk 243:and 4712:In 4412:JNS 4333:Dro 4242:Dro 4217:Dro 4162:Dro 3936:CNN 3906:doi 3687:doi 3493:or 3272:hed 3269:nis 3266:Tar 3200:hed 3197:nis 3194:Tar 3143:hed 3140:nis 3137:Tar 3103:, @ 3099:, @ 3095:, @ 3091:, @ 3087:, @ 3025:in 3017:in 2982:hed 2979:nis 2976:Tar 2918:hed 2915:nis 2912:Tar 2900:, @ 2896:, @ 2892:, @ 2888:, @ 2884:, @ 2880:, @ 2865:hed 2862:nis 2859:Tar 2847:, @ 2843:, @ 2839:, @ 2835:, @ 2831:, @ 2827:, @ 2823:, @ 2819:, @ 2815:, @ 2811:, @ 2807:, @ 2803:, @ 2799:, @ 2795:, @ 2791:, @ 2787:, @ 2783:, @ 2779:, @ 2764:hed 2761:nis 2758:Tar 2746:, @ 2742:, @ 2738:, @ 2734:, @ 2730:, @ 2726:, @ 2722:, @ 2718:, @ 2714:, @ 2710:, @ 2706:, @ 2702:, @ 2698:, @ 2694:, @ 2690:, @ 2686:, @ 2682:, @ 2678:, @ 2663:hed 2660:nis 2657:Tar 2645:, @ 2641:, @ 2637:, @ 2633:, @ 2629:, @ 2625:, @ 2621:, @ 2617:, @ 2613:, @ 2609:, @ 2605:, @ 2601:, @ 2597:, @ 2593:, @ 2589:, @ 2585:, @ 2581:, @ 2577:, @ 2246:all 2091:- 1736:or 1487:hed 1484:nis 1481:Tar 1434:hed 1431:nis 1428:Tar 1371:). 1248:As 1194:- 1163:- 1008:on 718:hed 715:nis 712:Tar 577:). 564:- 225:by 114:or 106:to 4968:) 4964:• 4919:) 4909:JP 4892:) 4878:) 4802:) 4787:) 4762:| 4760:me 4738:) 4684:| 4682:me 4669:) 4652:| 4650:me 4619:) 4603:🚐 4588:) 4570:🚐 4536:) 4520:🚐 4506:) 4490:🚐 4473:) 4455:) 4437:🚐 4422:) 4402:🚐 4386:) 4369:🚐 4314:) 4298:🚐 4281:) 4262:) 4182:) 4111:) 4096:) 4082:) 4068:) 4054:) 4046:. 4030:) 4016:) 4000:) 3959:. 3934:. 3912:. 3904:. 3900:. 3874:. 3850:. 3825:: 3823:}} 3819:{{ 3766:. 3762:. 3737:. 3700:. 3693:. 3683:24 3681:. 3677:. 3651:🚐 3634:) 3616:) 3608:. 3584:) 3563:) 3545:| 3543:me 3531:\ 3505:) 3479:\ 3456:) 3425:) 3360:\ 3325:) 3307:, 3303:, 3292:) 3248:) 3240:. 3178:) 3119:) 3111:. 3075:) 3056:) 2964:, 2960:, 2956:, 2952:, 2948:, 2944:, 2940:, 2936:, 2561:) 2557:• 2535:| 2520:) 2503:) 2484:) 2480:• 2453:| 2451:me 2430:) 2412:) 2373:) 2351:\ 2330:) 2311:\ 2278:) 2260:\ 2232:- 2203:) 2189:) 2161:) 2157:· 2133:/ 2116:) 2083:. 2074:) 2048:) 2044:· 2022:) 2006:) 1973:) 1959:) 1941:) 1912:) 1879:) 1865:) 1848:) 1827:, 1748:) 1719:) 1702:) 1684:) 1655:) 1621:, 1617:, 1613:, 1609:, 1596:) 1564:) 1547:) 1530:) 1522:. 1505:) 1463:) 1414:) 1397:) 1355:) 1292:) 1288:· 1266:) 1264:💬 1262:( 1235:) 1147:🚐 1124:) 1106:) 1092:) 1075:🚐 1057:) 1036:) 1020:🚐 994:) 977:🚐 954:) 931:) 827:) 812:) 787:🚐 683:) 675:. 654:) 629:) 600:) 585:) 549:) 534:) 526:. 515:) 507:. 497:) 465:) 412:is 406:→ 396:) 368:. 349:) 247:— 227:a 120:no 64:← 4960:( 4915:( 4888:( 4874:( 4811:( 4798:( 4783:( 4734:( 4665:( 4615:( 4584:( 4532:( 4502:( 4469:( 4451:( 4418:( 4382:( 4328:Ψ 4310:( 4277:( 4258:( 4250:@ 4237:Ψ 4212:Ψ 4178:( 4157:Ψ 4107:( 4092:( 4078:( 4064:( 4050:( 4026:( 4012:( 3996:( 3969:. 3944:. 3919:. 3908:: 3885:. 3860:. 3836:) 3832:( 3815:. 3800:. 3779:. 3747:. 3707:. 3689:: 3630:( 3612:( 3580:( 3559:( 3528:C 3525:/ 3501:( 3476:C 3473:/ 3452:( 3437:( 3421:( 3357:C 3354:/ 3321:( 3315:: 3299:@ 3288:( 3254:@ 3244:( 3212:@ 3186:@ 3174:( 3125:@ 3115:( 3071:( 3052:( 3029:. 2553:( 2516:( 2499:( 2476:( 2426:( 2408:( 2369:( 2357:@ 2348:C 2345:/ 2326:( 2308:C 2305:/ 2274:( 2257:C 2254:/ 2199:( 2185:( 2159:c 2155:t 2136:? 2127:— 2112:( 2070:( 2046:c 2042:t 2018:( 2002:( 1969:( 1955:( 1937:( 1908:( 1875:( 1861:( 1844:( 1815:. 1762:. 1744:( 1715:( 1698:( 1680:( 1629:. 1592:( 1560:( 1543:( 1526:( 1501:( 1459:( 1410:( 1393:( 1351:( 1284:( 1231:( 1219:@ 1120:( 1102:( 1088:( 1053:( 1032:( 990:( 950:( 927:( 901:" 889:" 880:" 868:" 856:" 823:( 808:( 692:/ 679:( 650:( 625:( 596:( 581:( 545:( 530:( 511:( 493:( 461:( 392:( 345:( 312:@ 265:@ 50:.

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.

Index