3009:
names, which would not be used around or known by non-dwarves. The name "Gimli" for example, cannot be a representation of his
Khuzdul name, since it used by Men, Elves and Hobbits. This is clear in LotR appendix F.I ("Gimli's own name, however, and the names of all his kin, are of Northern (Mannish) origin.") and in F.II ("The still more northernly language of Dale is in this book seen only in the names of the Dwarves that came from that region and so used the language of the Men there, taking their 'outer' names in that tongue.") The referenced essay "Of Dwarves and Men" in HOME XII, although not canonical in not being published by Tolkien himself, still agrees with this: "The case of the Dwarves of Moria was an example of adoption of names from Mannish languages of the North....", and even explicitly disclaims a connection between the inner and outer names: "Whether the adopted names that had meanings were selected because these meanings had some relation to their secret 'inner' names cannot be determined." (Actually I think this article should refer to the published LotR appendices rather the unpublished essay.)
1022:) the newer conception was well-established, continued in LOTR. I believe the "Diaspora" element and the Semitic-styled language is crucial to the "Jewish connection", but before those elements came to be... in short, I still think Norse and fairytale dwarves should probably be mentioned first. Perhaps we could mention those first but add "particularly" to "inspired by medieval Jewish...". Of course, the Norse dwarves are already bearded smiths/metalworkers and makers of treasures. OR, but the story of the
740:"It was said by Gimli that there are few dwarf-women, probably no more than a third of the whole people. They seldom walk abroad except at great need. They are in voice and appearance, and in garb if they must go on a journey, so like to dwarf-men that the eyes and ears of the other peoples cannot tell them apart. This has given rise to the foolish opinion among Men that there are no dwarf-women and that the Dwarves 'grow out of stone.'" ROTK Appendix A III Durin's folk.
962:
sources to confirm them. My rationale for putting the Jews first is that the sources I have (chiefly
Tolkiens Letters and the HoTH), put greater emphasis on the Jewish nature of the Dwarves rather than the Eddaic (to which I can only find references to the names being taken) or the Grimm. The aspects of being smaller along with mining and metal etc. are found firmly in Grimm, which is more likely to be Tolkiens first contact with dwarves. Although this is
1152:
same state as they were earlier in the diaspora, and that they no longer exist as only one or two minority groups in a uniform society as they did in
Medieval and parts of Early modern Eutrope (the other displaced group having been the Roma), but in a world teeeming with more and more refugees, immigrants and returnees from fallen empires, some of mixed race, makes us have to go back in time to understhand the way in which the swaves could be Jewish.
393:
375:
21:
1274:
2747:
2702:
2684:
2653:
2629:
2602:
2588:
2559:
2541:
2527:
2513:
2478:
2444:
76:
257:
230:
128:
107:
267:
347:
2076:
447:
923:
took their names from the people the live amongst, and kept their true names hidden and that the Dwarf names given would be
Mannish in origin (the long essay in HoME Vol 12 "Of Dwarves and Men"). Of course, Tolkien knew the Eddas and there are Dwarves in them, are there some sources that the Eddas Dwarves provided anything more than just the names? --
2913:
2876:
2839:
2802:
2765:
2032:
2368:
2343:
2322:
2277:
2253:
2225:
1790:
Middle-earth is not a continent. Middle-earth is the whole of the world, as opposed to
Valinor, which after the fall of Numenor was removed from Middle-earth. Numenor was part of Middle-earth before it sunk. True, this leaves us with no designation of the land-mass on which the whole of the action of
1151:
It seems like the
Dwarves of the Hobbit are clearly Jews, although their time of displacment means they are more early Medieval than contemporaries of Tolkien. The fact that the vast majority of Jews today live in either Israel in a state of return or in the US where they are not seen as quite in the
922:
It's clear from
Letters that JRR intended dwarves to 'represent' Jewish people, and based their language and characteristics largely upon medieval accounts of them. The fact they take their names from the Eddas does not mean they take any other influence from the Norse - indeed Tolkien says that they
1454:
Is there any evidence whatever that "Middle-Earth" is in
Tolkien restricted to a particular continent? Since the origin of the phrase is to refer to the entire Earth, the world among the 9 where Men dwell, I would be surprised. But I've turned out to be ignorant before, and I don't want to change an
1429:
Before the
Dwarves of Nogrod and Belegost came west over the mountains the Elves of Beleriand knew not what these others were, and hunted them, and slew them; but afterwards they let them alone, and they were called the Noegyth Nibin, the Petty-dwarves, in the Sindarin tongue. (p. 242, HarperCollins
1047:
reprints the draft text of The Hobbit, but the extensive notes and commentary encompases its relationship to the rest of
Tolkiens work, including it's thematic and textual links to the earlier and later Silmarillion etc. I highly recommend it. The order should, of course, reflect the history of the
938:
I would guess the basic concepts of dwarves as creatures of the earth, treasure-hoarders, skilled in metalworking, mining and smithing, at least - though their shorter size seems not to derive from the Eddas but from later versions, if the Wiki article on Norse dwarves is accurate. I'd say JRR used
3041:
Ok, I have edited the section appropriately. For now I have commented out the linguistic map, both because I don't know exactly how to change it, and because I'm not sure it's actually useful. It seems more confusing than helpful, especially with the compass rose in it that seems to imply there is
1416:
No more than a shallow grot it looked, with a low broken arch; but further in it had been deepened and bored far under the hill by the slow hands of the Petty-dwarves, in the long years that they had dwelt there, untroubled by the Grey-elves of the woods. (p. 130, HarperCollins paperback edition,
1762:
Within Arda, Dwarves are limited to the continent of Middle-earth (with the sole exception of Gimli). I propose to slightly rewrite the article to change Arda to Middle-earth; this would be more precise, and won't mislead those who imagine that the whole fictional universe is called Middle-earth.
696:
Ok, in that same section, there is stated a belief among men that dwarves spring from stone, or such. That appears to come from the movie, and thus is non-canonical. I doubt any Tolkein book mentions that (unless perhaps an appendix?), but encourage someone to similarly name a Tolkein source if
1724:
The above link does not work. It may be true but I would be slow to rush. Tolkien was a Catholic, not a Protestant. As such we cannot assume he ever read the Bible. Also is not the Temple Mount most often in English rendered Moriah? How would it have been rendered in the Bible Tolkien would have
3008:
I don't believe this is correct, or at least is not expressed clearly. A dwarf had a secret "inner" name in Khuzdul, and a public "outer" name, in a "northern Mannish" form. The Norse names used in The Hobbit and LotR are feigned to be translations of the outer Mannish names, not of the Khuzdul
1052:
not the weight of influences, unless we change the title of the section to "influences". Incidently Rateliffs only other Dwarf/Jewish comment mentions that the traditional Jewish calendar and the Dwarven calendar begin at approximately the same time (late autumn), in opposition to the medieval
961:
What is clear is that Tolkien drew a triangle between Fairytale - Medieval Jewish - Eddas and called that triangle "dwarves". Which influences came to him first - I don't know, and the sources I have to hand don't say. Your guesses, though reasonable, are unfortunately just guesses without the
533:
Tolkien's own opinion on the matter is now in the article. The letter was to the person in charge of the Lord of the Rings radio dramatization, and the forn of the reply, especially the part about accents, does make me think that the question was about similarities between Khuzdul and Hebrew.
3003:
When he came to The Lord of the Rings, where he had a proper language for the Dwarves, he was obliged to pretend, in the essay Of Dwarves and Men, that the Old Norse names were translations from Khuzdul, just as the English spoken by the Dwarves to Men and Hobbits was a translation from
1434:
I found these quotations using the indexes in these books, but I would be interested in a quotation (which would be from some unindexed page) showing specifically that they were hunted "for food and sport". Until then, I've changed the text and citation to fit the sources I've found.
1667:
The only direct statement that I'm aware of is in the Prologue to LOTR, where he says that hobbits are "smaller than Dwarves ... ranging between two and four feet of our measure." Which would imply that dwarves were taller than about four feet, but how much taller is unclear.
2363:
Thank you. John Rateliff, Marjorie Burns, and Bradford Lee Eden are all major Tolkien scholars with many respected publications between them, so the claims in the paragraph are robust. It is supported, too, by the quotations from Tolkien's letters in the second paragraph.
1194:). I suppose he referred to the inappropriate image of Narsil which was indeed useless here, and so reinstasted "Adaptations" section, adding some more commentary (any further input would be appreciated). I have also removed CJRT's map of Beleriand – its inclusion into
1166:
Tolkien as a Catholic would accept Maccabees as cannon in a way that Protestants would not, so this may lead to his understanding Jewish militarism differently. Tolkien was a mass and confession going Catholic among other things, so this is a factor that should not be
1323:
If there is other fair use media, consider checking that you have specified the fair use rationale on the other images used on this page. Note that any fair use images lacking such an explanation can be deleted one week after being tagged, as described on
1130:
Good edits anon. I'm not sure what the comment relates to, many things are bearded and warlike, and if reliable sources relate them to Tolkiens dwarves then the article should mention them. Incidentally i don't recall any dwarf wars in the Eddas.
1579:
was first published in 1937. There is no possible way that the "representation of Dwarves as evil changed dramatically with The Hobbit," because the "representation" being referred to in that sentence would not exist until 46 years after
759:, Bilbo reflects that he couldn't be mistaken for a dwarf, even in a dwarven cloak, because he had no beard. If female dwarves in male dwarf clothes cannot easily be distinguished from males, but the beardlessness of hobbits means they
891:
I'm fairly sure seven magical hammers were never mentioned in the Silmarillion, much less hammers which could summon Aule(!), and as far as I can tell this is the only page on the net that mentions such items. Looks a bit bogus to me.
982:(Iceland being the home of the Eddas) on the other hand, has a significantly smaller range of instruments, neither of which appear in the book. Although I think this puts even more weight on the Jewish nature of the dwarves, it is
490:
I am curious as to how Dwarvish is like Hebrew...as far as I recall there is very little Dwarvish in the books, and Tolkien just didn't create a full language for them. And what other similaritiess are there with "the Jews"?
1005:
I agree with the verifiability concerns (the more sources the better) and the singing and instruments - interesting. I've been thinking about the development/evolution of the dwarves, and how it might relate to this. By
1109:, and it is my opinion is that it would have been a strong influence on the medieval christians opinion of the Jews. Hopefully the rewording clarifies this, and disentangles my opinion from what the source actually says.
1694:
1. You do agree with the current analysis that compares the dwarves to the Jews? So do you really believe that the most spiritually and 'blood line' related place to both (Jews and dwarves) has the same name by chance?
1470:
No, Middle-earth specifically refers to the great continent lying east of Belegaer the western ocean upon which most of his tales and histories take place, as distinct from the Undying Lands in the West, and Numenor in
3056:
I've tweaked it temporarily, will tidy it up when I'm with a decent graphics editor. The compass just tells that Dale is off to the east, not a very contentious point really. Of course the map is also used elsewhere.
1246:
I have heard of a nation, or house of Dwarves called Dourhands. It says in the book there are only seven nations, all of which are mentioned. Is Dourhand another name for a dwarf house, like Durin's Folk/Longbeards?
986:
and feel free to discount it. On another note, I find the first thread on this talk page very concerning in the editorial precedent it is trying to set, and I may be over-compensating for the "don't mention the Jews"
834:
However does anything in the Hobbit or even LotR prove female dwarves have beards. Was this an idea present in the Hobbit (where Thorin refers to his sister so female dwarves clearly exist) or was it merged in later
1198:
article is debatable, and here it is surely prohibited - and the image of a "generic" dwarf – the author of the latter intended no connection with Tolkien's works, and its usage here would be just "unencyclopedic".
1202:
I have also rearranged sections, grouping together all in-universe material and moving "Concept and creation" to follow it. The reasons I have already described in a similar discussion that I raised at the
1549:? Perhaps dwarf houses in the mountains, with thatched roofs, timber and mortor, for instance? Alpine longhouses? They were miners and the Nordic people claim to see them in modern times. Perhaps they are
2008:
is one more go at it. For what it is worth, all these link Jerusalem to the lonely mountain, not to Moria. Thus making that above mentioned link of the Temple Mount to Moria not really workable.
1320:
is an easy way to ensure that your image is in compliance with Knowledge (XXG) policy, but remember that you must complete the template. Do not simply insert a blank template on an image page.
1191:"Adaptations" section, and then by Davémon, with a claim that they "fall out of scope of a limited number of web-resolution screenshots for identification and critical commentary on the film" (
2921:
2884:
2847:
2810:
2773:
947:
and making them smaller, giving them axes, etc. That's what I meant with one influence "predating" another - poorly worded. So that's why I would mention mythical/traditional dwarves first.
2043:
2081:
1226:. There is precedent in FA's on fictional subjects to put this type of content before describing the fiction. P.S. Very happy with the new low-res dwarves image from the movies. --
3120:
2422:
1882:
is an unnecessary content fork of this page. We can easily merge the relevant content from that page into the sections on this page about the history of the Dwarvish race.
676:"For the Naugrim have beards from the beginning of their lives, male and female alike." - The War of the Jewels, The Later Quenta Silmarillion: Of the Naugrim and the Edain
3135:
2466:
2297:
Attributed the claim directly to Rateliff: he is a reliable source and this is his stated opinion. The matter is however not in doubt; among dozens of possible examples,
2114:
1014:
aren't dispossessed exiles (no Erebor or Moria to be displaced from). No Semitic dwarf-language at this point either. One major source for the Jewish connection concerns
409:
356:
240:
32:
1353:
has anyone a copy of the 'Rune to letter' translations of the runes pictured? it might be useful/interesting to some. i have a copy in a book, but no means to upload...
991:. Either way I think I've put my case forward as well as I can, and will leave it to you or others to represent the various weights of the influences as they see fit. --
487:"he Dwarvish language, called Khuzdûl and created by Aulë, sounds much like Hebrew, and one may draw the similarities between the Dwarves and the Jews even farther."
182:
2104:
211:
3130:
3090:
2950:
1809:
No, Middle-earth is the central continent, distinct from Valinor and Numenor and the Eastern continent. In Tolkien it was never a word for the entire world. --
2676:
400:
380:
195:
2086:
2470:
2462:
1691:, I don't agree with your statement that "here's no evidence that Tolkien formed the two syllables of Sindarin "Mor-ia" after the hebrew template mount".
626:
is never used to refer to Tolkien's Dwarves, so I removed it from the opening of the article and did not put it in bold text. --] 21:22, 4 Sep 2004 (UTC)
3115:
905:
I have taken the liberty of removing the section entitled "Seven Hammers", but I encourage the original contributor to submit a reference, if it exists.
2356:
Ending with Brackmann's excerpts from Mythlore is fair and balanced. However, I am concerned about the first paragraph in this section and its validity.
1301:, you must also write out on the image description page a specific explanation or rationale for why using this image in each article is consistent with
1298:
655:
337:
148:
3100:
898:
VERY Bogus. I can't even recall such a reference in HoME (History of Middle Earth) by Christopher Tolkien. Without verification, this needs to go.
172:
2519:
2454:
1325:
1317:
1313:
1290:
3110:
327:
198:
that generally fictional articles should be written in present tense, all Tolkien legendarium-related articles that cover in-universe material
1329:
895:(I guess it might fit with some of the weird stuff in earlier drafts of Tolkien's tales, but in that case I don't think it would be canon...)
650:
Just what Book and comment states that female Dwarves have beards? I've read they're so alike in appearance does not mean they do have them.
46:
1776:
1764:
1222:
Concept and creation really must come first, it's the only section with any real world context which is what the article should be about re:
668:
2905:
2868:
2831:
2794:
2757:
2694:
2412:
2025:
135:
112:
3125:
1585:
302:
300:
on Knowledge (XXG). If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the project and contribute to the
1706:
1698:
2. The dwarves dispersed after losing Moria much like how the Jews dispersed after losing their Temple, located at Mount Moria (aka the
1527:
713:
3085:
2690:
2505:
2458:
3095:
1254:
1187:
With several recent revisions, all screenshots from Peter Jackson's movies were removed from the article, first by CharlesMartel, who
2615:
2418:
2109:
38:
971:
2533:
1989:
Interestingly the most pertinent detail to Tolkien I have learned from that article is that he would go to confession before mass.
499:
The Dwarvish language is (IIRC) based on three-letter roots, like Hebrew and Arabic. Also, some folks think "Khazad" sounds like "
3105:
53:
2153:
642:
Moved back to the plural, for consistency with other articles. (And for the vast majority of links) ] 22:02, 7 Sep 2004 (UTC)
280:
235:
87:
2132:
1946:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.
1655:
859:. Its the same issue as with the article about Elves so lets have the discussion there to keep it in a centralized place
560:. Speculation on how Dwarves resemble Jews is not wanted here I believe, as it was mainly a philological musing by JRRT.
518:, not here. And we don't want any comparisons between Dwarves and Jews: gem hoarding, beards, etc.—could get nasty fast.
813:
3027:
Yes, feel free to change the ref to the appdx, and to tweak the diagram. I can do the latter when I'm back at my desk.
2450:
880:
Subsequent comments should be made in a new section on this talk page. No further edits should be made to this section.
798:
Subsequent comments should be made in a new section on the talk page. No further edits should be made to this section.
473:
2318:
As you make it clear it is his stated opinion, and we are not getting into Biblical exegesis here, I'll leave this.
2006:
1105:
as potentially being Tolkiens source for the Dwarves warlike behaviour. The books of Joshua and Judges appear in the
2495:
1639:
I was wondering if Talkien ever described the statue of his /or the nordic/ dwarfs. How high were they actually?
2013:
1994:
1980:
1962:
1932:
1796:
1747:
1730:
1172:
1157:
1044:
860:
840:
664:
2594:
2580:
2128:
1956:
1780:
1768:
1589:
1339:
1906:: no evidence "Fathers of the Dwarves" is notable, and (properly cited) the material would be well at home in
1400:, not acquainted with Dwarves yet, saw the Petty-dwarves as little more than bothersome animals, calling them
93:
1973:
709:
3062:
3032:
2986:
2393:
2290:
Rateliff is claiming the Hebrew Bible portrays Jews as warlike? How is this citation presented and defended?
2191:
1915:
1864:
1791:
the Hobbit and LotR take place, but hey, we have no adequate descriptions for the Euro-Asia-Africa landmass.
1725:
read? How often? What other sources would cause this connection? Did Tolkien ever say the Dwarves were Jews?
1531:
1309:
1281:
1258:
823:
463:
3012:
The diagram "Linguistic Map of Middle-Earth.svg" in the article near this text seems to repeat this error.
2551:
2547:
2266:
You mention three of the clans and the Petty Dwarves. Is it appropriate to mention the clans from the East?
1643:
1250:
701:
1879:
1828:
943:
and defined them with "Jewish" traits and a "Semitic-ish" language, instead of taking stereotypes of Jews
660:
144:
1360:
20:
705:
686:
408:
on Knowledge (XXG). If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join
1286:
1204:
503:". The obvious antisemitic stereotypes get in there, too. *shrug* It's overanalyzing, is what it is. --
1707:
http://contemporaryreligiousrationalism.blogspot.co.il/2013/01/non-fiction-tolkien-friend-of-jews.html
1127:
Tried to bring some balance. Am I to believe Norse dwarves weren't bearded and warlike (when roused)?
3047:
3043:
3017:
3013:
2924:
until a consensus is reached, and readers of this page are welcome to contribute to the discussion.
2887:
until a consensus is reached, and readers of this page are welcome to contribute to the discussion.
2850:
until a consensus is reached, and readers of this page are welcome to contribute to the discussion.
2813:
until a consensus is reached, and readers of this page are welcome to contribute to the discussion.
2776:
until a consensus is reached, and readers of this page are welcome to contribute to the discussion.
2339:
Added citation for parallel with Rosh Hashanah. We now have two reliable sources for this parallel.
2009:
1990:
1976:
1958:
1928:
1907:
1832:
1792:
1743:
1726:
1460:
1456:
1440:
1168:
1153:
856:
836:
466:
on 23 January 2020. For the contribution history and old versions of the redirected page, please see
2298:
1714:
1669:
1356:
1285:
is being used on this article. I notice the image page specifies that the image is being used under
459:
42:
2769:
2727:
2171:
2147:
1705:
3. Please refer to this book analysis agreeing that the dwarves Moria derives from the Jews Moria:
1673:
1335:
909:
2969:
2917:
2666:
1647:
1623:
Is it worth mentioning that Peter Jackson's interpretation of Dwarves draws some inspiration from
561:
519:
3058:
3028:
2982:
2954:
2930:
2893:
2856:
2819:
2782:
2389:
2187:
2051:
1911:
1887:
1860:
1476:
979:
818:
808:
504:
2949:
Suprisingly, some sources were found in a related Polish Knowledge (XXG) deletion discussion at
2806:
1710:
1023:
2963:
2039:
1814:
1651:
1608:
1519:
1515:
1378:
1231:
1136:
1114:
1058:
996:
928:
777:
733:
1523:
1223:
988:
1558:
1498:
1035:
974:- along with the number of singers / musicians (plus one for bad luck!), as is the habit of
952:
744:
723:
681:
492:
405:
514:
I've removed it from the article. Notes on how Khuzdul resembles Hebrew may be at place in
2880:
2843:
1436:
1079:
140:
1302:
983:
963:
2723:
2167:
2143:
1603:
was written in 1920s, but not published till much later. Hope that clarifies things. --
1212:
1102:
1098:
1027:
764:
583:
538:
1273:
3079:
2925:
2888:
2851:
2814:
2777:
2047:
1883:
1688:
1472:
1018:
only, if I'm correct. By the time Tolkien wrote about the Jewish connection himself (
272:
2332:
Please supply further evidence of the Dwarf Calendar resembling the Jewish Calendar.
3066:
3051:
3036:
3021:
2990:
2959:
2942:
2935:
2898:
2861:
2824:
2787:
2746:
2731:
2397:
2195:
2175:
2157:
2055:
2017:
1998:
1984:
1966:
1936:
1919:
1891:
1868:
1818:
1810:
1800:
1784:
1751:
1734:
1718:
1699:
1677:
1659:
1612:
1604:
1593:
1562:
1535:
1502:
1480:
1464:
1444:
1382:
1374:
1364:
1343:
1262:
1235:
1227:
1216:
1176:
1161:
1140:
1132:
1118:
1110:
1083:
1062:
1054:
1039:
1000:
992:
956:
932:
924:
912:
867:
864:
844:
828:
781:
773:
767:
747:
726:
691:
1425:, on the other hand, does, but makes no reference to food or sport specifically:
1554:
1494:
1094:
1090:
1053:
calendar that begins in spring - and again this first occurs with The Hobbit. --
1031:
948:
603:
392:
374:
297:
1075:
1010:, they're already "semi-Jewish" but what about earlier stages? The dwarves in
755:
266:
262:
256:
229:
2774:
Knowledge (XXG):Redirects for discussion/Log/2021 September 10#Noegyth Nibin
2210:
My sense is that one of the important contributions (skills) of Dwarves was
1208:
1195:
634:
used in proper names, such as "Dwarrowdelf" as an alternate name for Moria.
580:
535:
2922:
Knowledge (XXG):Redirects for discussion/Log/2021 September 10#Nibin-Nogrim
2135:. The edit link for this section can be used to add comments to the review.
1927:
There is not enough on the earliest drarves to justify a seperate article.
1771:) 05:36, 1 October 2016 (UTC) Sorry, that should be 'slightly rewrite the
1740:
127:
106:
2811:
Knowledge (XXG):Redirects for discussion/Log/2021 September 10#Nibin-Noeg
1545:
Do Middle-earth dwarves ever inhabit other than halls, and caves, or the
975:
151:
for suggestions and ideas on how you can improve this and other articles.
2912:
2875:
2838:
2801:
2764:
2031:
3042:
some geographical information being imparted which I don't really see.
1421:
which gives no indication that they were hunted by Elves at any point.
1106:
557:
515:
346:
293:
289:
1631:, and the line "Never trust an elf!" is a direct pull from that game.
2306:
2302:
1397:
500:
1584:
was published. I think more fanboys are spinning creative OR here.
1392:
Under the section on Petty-dwarves, there is the following comment:
2885:
Knowledge (XXG):Redirects for discussion/Log/2021 September 10#Ibun
2848:
Knowledge (XXG):Redirects for discussion/Log/2021 September 10#Ibûn
1742:
quotes multiple cases in which Tolkien connects the dwaves to Jews.
614:
and Appendix F, I've updated the article with information the term
1370:
285:
1297:
Knowledge (XXG) article constitutes fair use. In addition to the
1490:
874:
The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate.
792:
The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposal.
1627:
as well as Middle-earth itself? He's been noted as a player of
2166:; the review will follow the same sections of the Article. --
1412:. I guess this is in the section entitled "Of Mîm the Dwarf":
441:
69:
15:
2381:
The resources/research on Philology and Letters is good work.
2242:
at the age of 32. Why not include his great feat at that age?
2038:
An editor has asked for a discussion to address the redirect
2030:
1272:
345:
284:, an attempt to build a comprehensive and detailed guide to
214:
for more information about this and other article standards.
1955:
Here is an article from the Times of Israel on the subject
1404:'two-legged (animals)', and hunted them for food and sport.
2951:
pl:Knowledge (XXG):Poczekalnia/artykuły/2023:08:03:Durin
1192:
1188:
468:
454:
59:
763:, it seems pretty clear the females must have beards.
2916:
A discussion is taking place to address the redirect
2879:
A discussion is taking place to address the redirect
2842:
A discussion is taking place to address the redirect
2805:
A discussion is taking place to address the redirect
2768:
A discussion is taking place to address the redirect
1848:
Subsequent comments should be made in a new section.
404:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of
1541:...and many small dwellings in the Misty Mountains?
1328:. If you have any questions please ask them at the
1026:in BOLT seems loosely inspired by the story of the
1373:page, which could be improved but does the job. --
212:Knowledge (XXG):WikiProject Middle-earth/Standards
2670:and other media, where possible and appropriate.
2186:Many thanks, I look forward to working with you.
1455:accurate reference merely because of ignorance!
1074:Were medieval Jews really considered warlike? --
418:Knowledge (XXG):WikiProject Fictional characters
45:. If it no longer meets these criteria, you can
2722:May we consider the reflections above?
1269:Fair use rationale for Image:Gimli With Axe.jpg
772:Or else Bilbo subscribed to the stone theory. —
139:, which aims to build an encyclopedic guide to
1855:The result of this discussion was a unanimous
722:I remember reading it in Lord of the Rings. -
2675:(images are tagged and non-free content have
1851:A summary of the conclusions reached follows.
8:
1318:Knowledge (XXG):Fair use rationale guideline
1207:; if you disagree, please discuss it there.
1205:WikiProject Middle-earth Standards talk page
939:the dwarves of myth/fairytales as templates
3121:Unknown-importance Fantasy fiction articles
2309:and his people with the edge of the sword."
970:are entirely consistent with those used in
472:; for the discussion at that location, see
2739:Issues resolved, article passes GA Review.
2064:
369:
224:
101:
3136:WikiProject Fictional characters articles
421:Template:WikiProject Fictional characters
1684:Moria as a reference to the Temple Mount
157:Knowledge (XXG):WikiProject Middle-earth
2095:
2067:
371:
306:to talk over new ideas and suggestions.
226:
147:, and related topics. Please visit the
103:
3002:
2315:
204:the current action must be written in
3131:GA-Class fictional character articles
3091:Language and literature good articles
2960:Piotr Konieczny aka Prokonsul Piotrus
33:Language and literature good articles
7:
1842:The following discussion is closed.
855:I propose that we move this page to
732:The relevant quote LOTR quote (from
398:This article is within the scope of
278:This article is within the scope of
133:This article is within the scope of
75:
73:
92:It is of interest to the following
2212:the making of mail of linked rings
1975:is another article on the subject.
1408:This is followed by a citation in
312:Knowledge (XXG):WikiProject Novels
14:
3116:GA-Class Fantasy fiction articles
2957:for a potential fun to-do DYK :)
753:And you can add to this that, in
160:Template:WikiProject Middle-earth
41:. If you can improve it further,
3101:High-importance Tolkien articles
2911:
2874:
2837:
2800:
2763:
2745:
2700:
2682:
2651:
2627:
2624:Fair representation without bias
2600:
2586:
2557:
2539:
2525:
2511:
2476:
2442:
2366:
2341:
2320:
2275:
2251:
2223:
1942:The discussion above is closed.
1316:. Using one of the templates at
445:
401:WikiProject Fictional characters
391:
373:
265:
255:
228:
196:Guide to writing better articles
126:
105:
74:
19:
2920:. The discussion will occur at
2883:. The discussion will occur at
2846:. The discussion will occur at
2809:. The discussion will occur at
2772:. The discussion will occur at
2421:for what the criteria are, and
1908:Dwarf (Middle-earth) § Creation
332:This article has been rated as
177:This article has been rated as
2936:03:36, 10 September 2021 (UTC)
2899:03:35, 10 September 2021 (UTC)
2862:03:34, 10 September 2021 (UTC)
2825:03:33, 10 September 2021 (UTC)
2788:03:33, 10 September 2021 (UTC)
2439:(prose, spelling, and grammar)
1330:Media copyright questions page
901:02:58, 28 February 2007 (UTC)
29:has been listed as one of the
1:
3111:Mid-importance novel articles
3086:Knowledge (XXG) good articles
2133:Talk:Dwarf (Middle-earth)/GA1
1660:15:08, 24 November 2013 (UTC)
1613:12:41, 15 February 2012 (UTC)
1594:22:15, 14 February 2012 (UTC)
1575:was first published in 1983;
1536:05:37, 17 February 2011 (UTC)
1481:21:35, 14 November 2010 (UTC)
1344:23:42, 13 February 2008 (UTC)
1299:boilerplate fair use template
803:The result of the debate was
748:10:25, 28 February 2007 (UTC)
727:12:54, 27 February 2007 (UTC)
412:and see a list of open tasks.
354:This article is supported by
2940:
2701:
2683:
2652:
2628:
2601:
2587:
2558:
2540:
2526:
2512:
2477:
2443:
2056:00:41, 1 February 2020 (UTC)
2018:22:02, 15 January 2020 (UTC)
1999:21:49, 15 January 2020 (UTC)
1985:21:43, 15 January 2020 (UTC)
1967:21:36, 15 January 2020 (UTC)
1937:21:21, 15 January 2020 (UTC)
1920:16:31, 14 January 2020 (UTC)
1892:15:57, 12 January 2020 (UTC)
1869:03:37, 24 January 2020 (UTC)
1819:06:56, 16 January 2020 (UTC)
1801:21:29, 15 January 2020 (UTC)
1752:21:28, 15 January 2020 (UTC)
1735:21:25, 15 January 2020 (UTC)
1719:17:14, 20 January 2014 (UTC)
1489:Read the first paragraph to
1450:"The continent Middle-Earth"
1445:19:43, 15 October 2009 (UTC)
1326:criteria for speedy deletion
1263:20:59, 14 January 2008 (UTC)
1236:14:30, 14 January 2008 (UTC)
1217:16:44, 13 January 2008 (UTC)
1177:22:40, 20 January 2020 (UTC)
1162:22:37, 20 January 2020 (UTC)
1141:23:30, 8 November 2008 (UTC)
1119:16:09, 12 January 2008 (UTC)
1084:01:06, 12 January 2008 (UTC)
1063:16:09, 12 January 2008 (UTC)
1040:15:17, 11 January 2008 (UTC)
845:22:28, 20 January 2020 (UTC)
692:15:59, 28 January 2006 (UTC)
424:fictional character articles
3126:WikiProject Novels articles
1878:In my opinion, the article
1785:05:38, 1 October 2016 (UTC)
1563:22:47, 7 January 2012 (UTC)
1503:14:34, 8 January 2012 (UTC)
1001:14:06, 9 January 2008 (UTC)
980:Traditional Icelandic music
966:: the dwarf instruments in
957:12:07, 9 January 2008 (UTC)
933:19:22, 7 January 2008 (UTC)
918:Nordic-Jewish-Grimm dwarves
618:and the origin of the term
315:Template:WikiProject Novels
3152:
3067:09:38, 7 August 2023 (UTC)
3052:18:16, 5 August 2023 (UTC)
3037:07:13, 5 August 2023 (UTC)
3022:20:25, 4 August 2023 (UTC)
2991:06:57, 4 August 2023 (UTC)
2970:02:14, 4 August 2023 (UTC)
2756:"Noegyth Nibin" listed at
2732:06:34, 10 March 2021 (UTC)
2398:09:08, 10 March 2021 (UTC)
2316:this is his stated opinion
1369:There is a version on the
1310:the image description page
768:19:40, 23 April 2007 (UTC)
338:project's importance scale
303:general Project discussion
183:project's importance scale
3096:GA-Class Tolkien articles
2904:"Nibin-Nogrim" listed at
2196:09:04, 6 March 2021 (UTC)
2176:06:34, 6 March 2021 (UTC)
2158:06:34, 6 March 2021 (UTC)
1678:15:08, 10 July 2015 (UTC)
1465:20:50, 8 April 2010 (UTC)
1383:09:18, 9 April 2008 (UTC)
1365:21:10, 8 April 2008 (UTC)
1312:and edit it to include a
1045:The History of the Hobbit
976:singing through the night
913:08:08, 7 March 2007 (UTC)
868:09:43, 4 March 2006 (UTC)
861:Talk:Elves (Middle-earth)
829:09:56, 9 March 2006 (UTC)
782:20:20, 21 June 2012 (UTC)
606:01:39, 27 Aug 2004 (UTC)
495:05:48, 14 Aug 2003 (UTC)
386:
353:
331:
250:
189:
176:
121:
100:
2906:Redirects for discussion
2869:Redirects for discussion
2832:Redirects for discussion
2795:Redirects for discussion
2758:Redirects for discussion
2042:. Please participate in
2026:Redirects for discussion
1944:Please do not modify it.
1845:Please do not modify it.
1430:paperback edition, 1999)
1388:Hunting of Petty-dwarves
1291:explanation or rationale
1282:Image:Gimli With Axe.jpg
972:traditional Jewish music
877:Please do not modify it.
795:Please do not modify it.
586:15:20, 20 Jan 2004 (UTC)
564:15:19, 20 Jan 2004 (UTC)
541:15:18, 20 Jan 2004 (UTC)
522:15:13, 20 Jan 2004 (UTC)
507:15:02, 20 Jan 2004 (UTC)
194:Though it states in the
136:WikiProject Middle-earth
3106:GA-Class novel articles
2793:"Nibin-Noeg" listed at
2432:reasonably well written
2046:if you wish to do so.
2044:the redirect discussion
1758:Homeland of the Dwarves
1619:Peter Jackson's Dwarves
1618:
1024:Necklace of the Dwarves
610:After looking it up in
464:Dwarves in Middle-earth
27:Dwarves in Middle-earth
2425:for what they are not)
2035:
1880:Fathers of the Dwarves
1829:Fathers of the Dwarves
1601:The Book of Lost Tales
1573:The Book of Lost Tales
1526:should redirect here.
1277:
1012:The Book of Lost Tales
678:
579:No quarrel with that.
455:Fathers of the Dwarves
350:
82:This article is rated
2664:It is illustrated by
2616:neutral point of view
2572:broad in its coverage
2034:
2024:"Durin II" listed at
1293:as to why its use in
1276:
674:
646:Female Dwarves beards
452:The contents of the
349:
86:on Knowledge (XXG)'s
39:good article criteria
1833:Dwarf (Middle-earth)
857:Dwarf (Middle-earth)
658:comment was added by
415:Fictional characters
406:fictional characters
381:Fictional characters
2677:fair use rationales
2221:Good point, added.
1089:No. Rateliff cites
1050:textual development
483:Untitled discussion
57:: March 10, 2021. (
2648:No edit wars, etc.
2491:factually accurate
2036:
1314:fair use rationale
1278:
1189:completely deleted
1183:Copyrighted images
357:Fantasy task force
351:
281:WikiProject Novels
88:content assessment
3001:The article says
2867:"Ibun" listed at
2830:"Ibûn" listed at
2695:suitable captions
2506:reference section
2123:
2122:
2010:John Pack Lambert
1991:John Pack Lambert
1977:John Pack Lambert
1959:John Pack Lambert
1929:John Pack Lambert
1793:John Pack Lambert
1744:John Pack Lambert
1727:John Pack Lambert
1663:
1646:comment added by
1402:(Levain) Tad-dail
1349:Runic Translation
1265:
1253:comment added by
1169:John Pack Lambert
1154:John Pack Lambert
837:John Pack Lambert
734:Talk:Bearded lady
718:
704:comment added by
672:
594:Did Tolkien ever
480:
479:
440:
439:
436:
435:
432:
431:
368:
367:
364:
363:
223:
222:
219:
218:
215:
149:project talk page
68:
67:
64:
3143:
2966:
2915:
2878:
2841:
2804:
2767:
2749:
2704:
2703:
2686:
2685:
2655:
2654:
2631:
2630:
2604:
2603:
2590:
2589:
2561:
2560:
2543:
2542:
2529:
2528:
2520:reliable sources
2515:
2514:
2480:
2479:
2446:
2445:
2374:
2370:
2369:
2349:
2345:
2344:
2328:
2324:
2323:
2283:
2279:
2278:
2259:
2255:
2254:
2231:
2227:
2226:
2164:Starts GA Review
2077:Copyvio detector
2065:
1847:
1827:Propose merging
1662:
1640:
1599:The material in
1568:Chronology error
1423:The Silmarillion
1410:Unfinished Tales
1289:but there is no
1248:
879:
821:
816:
811:
797:
717:
698:
651:
471:
449:
448:
442:
426:
425:
422:
419:
416:
395:
388:
387:
377:
370:
320:
319:
316:
313:
310:
275:
270:
269:
259:
252:
251:
246:
243:
232:
225:
190:
165:
164:
163:Tolkien articles
161:
158:
155:
141:J. R. R. Tolkien
130:
123:
122:
117:
109:
102:
85:
79:
78:
77:
70:
62:
60:Reviewed version
51:
23:
16:
3151:
3150:
3146:
3145:
3144:
3142:
3141:
3140:
3076:
3075:
2999:
2968:
2964:
2947:
2934:
2909:
2897:
2872:
2860:
2835:
2823:
2798:
2786:
2761:
2691:appropriate use
2613:It follows the
2408:
2367:
2365:
2342:
2340:
2321:
2319:
2276:
2274:
2252:
2250:
2224:
2222:
2207:
2127:This review is
2119:
2091:
2063:
2029:
1953:
1948:
1947:
1876:
1843:
1836:
1777:111.220.227.146
1765:111.220.227.146
1760:
1686:
1641:
1637:
1635:About the high?
1621:
1570:
1543:
1513:
1452:
1390:
1354:
1351:
1271:
1244:
1185:
920:
889:
884:
875:
853:
819:
814:
809:
793:
699:
690:
689:
661:143.200.225.101
648:
640:
485:
467:
446:
423:
420:
417:
414:
413:
317:
314:
311:
308:
307:
271:
264:
244:
238:
179:High-importance
162:
159:
156:
153:
152:
116:High‑importance
115:
83:
58:
12:
11:
5:
3149:
3147:
3139:
3138:
3133:
3128:
3123:
3118:
3113:
3108:
3103:
3098:
3093:
3088:
3078:
3077:
3074:
3073:
3072:
3071:
3070:
3069:
2998:
2995:
2994:
2993:
2980:
2979:
2978:
2958:
2946:
2939:
2928:
2908:
2902:
2891:
2871:
2865:
2854:
2834:
2828:
2817:
2797:
2791:
2780:
2760:
2754:
2743:
2742:
2741:
2740:
2720:
2719:
2713:
2712:
2711:
2710:
2709:
2707:
2662:
2661:
2660:
2659:
2658:
2638:
2637:
2636:
2635:
2634:
2611:
2610:
2609:
2608:
2607:
2568:
2567:
2566:
2565:
2564:
2518:(citations to
2487:
2486:
2485:
2484:
2483:
2427:
2426:
2407:
2404:
2403:
2402:
2401:
2400:
2383:
2382:
2378:
2377:
2376:
2375:
2358:
2357:
2353:
2352:
2351:
2350:
2334:
2333:
2313:
2312:
2311:
2310:
2292:
2291:
2287:
2286:
2285:
2284:
2268:
2267:
2263:
2262:
2261:
2260:
2244:
2243:
2235:
2234:
2233:
2232:
2216:
2215:
2206:
2203:
2202:
2201:
2200:
2199:
2198:
2181:
2162:
2138:
2137:
2121:
2120:
2118:
2117:
2112:
2107:
2101:
2098:
2097:
2093:
2092:
2090:
2089:
2087:External links
2084:
2079:
2073:
2070:
2069:
2062:
2059:
2028:
2022:
2021:
2020:
2003:
2002:
2001:
1952:
1951:dwaves as Jews
1949:
1941:
1940:
1939:
1922:
1901:
1875:
1874:
1873:
1872:
1871:
1838:
1837:
1835:
1825:
1824:
1823:
1822:
1821:
1804:
1803:
1759:
1756:
1755:
1754:
1737:
1685:
1682:
1681:
1680:
1636:
1633:
1620:
1617:
1616:
1615:
1586:12.233.146.130
1569:
1566:
1542:
1539:
1512:
1509:
1508:
1507:
1506:
1505:
1484:
1483:
1451:
1448:
1432:
1431:
1419:
1418:
1406:
1405:
1389:
1386:
1352:
1350:
1347:
1336:BetacommandBot
1270:
1267:
1243:
1240:
1239:
1238:
1184:
1181:
1180:
1179:
1164:
1148:
1147:
1146:
1145:
1144:
1143:
1122:
1121:
1103:Book of Judges
1099:Book of Joshua
1072:
1071:
1070:
1069:
1068:
1067:
1066:
1065:
919:
916:
904:
888:
887:Seven Hammers?
885:
883:
882:
852:
849:
848:
847:
801:
800:
788:
787:
786:
785:
784:
742:
741:
730:
729:
685:
684:
654:The preceding
647:
644:
639:
636:
628:
627:
592:
591:
590:
589:
588:
587:
581:— No-One Jones
572:
571:
570:
569:
568:
567:
566:
565:
547:
546:
545:
544:
543:
542:
536:— No-One Jones
526:
525:
524:
523:
509:
508:
484:
481:
478:
477:
450:
438:
437:
434:
433:
430:
429:
427:
410:the discussion
396:
384:
383:
378:
366:
365:
362:
361:
352:
342:
341:
334:Mid-importance
330:
324:
323:
321:
318:novel articles
277:
276:
260:
248:
247:
245:Mid‑importance
233:
221:
220:
217:
216:
187:
186:
175:
169:
168:
166:
131:
119:
118:
110:
98:
97:
91:
80:
66:
65:
50:
24:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
3148:
3137:
3134:
3132:
3129:
3127:
3124:
3122:
3119:
3117:
3114:
3112:
3109:
3107:
3104:
3102:
3099:
3097:
3094:
3092:
3089:
3087:
3084:
3083:
3081:
3068:
3064:
3060:
3059:Chiswick Chap
3055:
3054:
3053:
3049:
3045:
3040:
3039:
3038:
3034:
3030:
3029:Chiswick Chap
3026:
3025:
3024:
3023:
3019:
3015:
3010:
3006:
3005:
2996:
2992:
2988:
2984:
2983:Chiswick Chap
2981:
2976:
2975:
2974:
2973:
2972:
2971:
2967:
2961:
2956:
2955:Chiswick Chap
2952:
2944:
2938:
2937:
2933:
2932:
2927:
2923:
2919:
2914:
2907:
2903:
2901:
2900:
2896:
2895:
2890:
2886:
2882:
2877:
2870:
2866:
2864:
2863:
2859:
2858:
2853:
2849:
2845:
2840:
2833:
2829:
2827:
2826:
2822:
2821:
2816:
2812:
2808:
2803:
2796:
2792:
2790:
2789:
2785:
2784:
2779:
2775:
2771:
2770:Noegyth Nibin
2766:
2759:
2755:
2753:
2752:
2748:
2738:
2737:
2736:
2735:
2734:
2733:
2729:
2725:
2717:
2714:
2708:
2706:
2705:
2698:
2696:
2692:
2680:
2678:
2672:
2671:
2669:
2668:
2663:
2657:
2656:
2649:
2646:
2645:
2643:
2639:
2633:
2632:
2625:
2622:
2621:
2619:
2617:
2612:
2606:
2605:
2598:
2596:
2584:
2582:
2581:major aspects
2576:
2575:
2573:
2569:
2563:
2562:
2555:
2553:
2549:
2537:
2535:
2523:
2521:
2509:
2507:
2501:
2500:
2498:
2497:
2492:
2488:
2482:
2481:
2474:
2472:
2468:
2464:
2460:
2456:
2452:
2440:
2436:
2435:
2433:
2429:
2428:
2424:
2420:
2416:
2414:
2410:
2409:
2405:
2399:
2395:
2391:
2390:Chiswick Chap
2387:
2386:
2385:
2384:
2380:
2379:
2373:
2362:
2361:
2360:
2359:
2355:
2354:
2348:
2338:
2337:
2336:
2335:
2331:
2330:
2329:
2327:
2317:
2308:
2304:
2300:
2296:
2295:
2294:
2293:
2289:
2288:
2282:
2272:
2271:
2270:
2269:
2265:
2264:
2258:
2248:
2247:
2246:
2245:
2241:
2240:Dain Ironfoot
2237:
2236:
2230:
2220:
2219:
2218:
2217:
2213:
2209:
2208:
2204:
2197:
2193:
2189:
2188:Chiswick Chap
2185:
2184:
2183:
2182:
2180:
2178:
2177:
2173:
2169:
2165:
2160:
2159:
2155:
2152:
2149:
2145:
2142:
2136:
2134:
2130:
2125:
2124:
2116:
2113:
2111:
2108:
2106:
2103:
2102:
2100:
2099:
2094:
2088:
2085:
2083:
2080:
2078:
2075:
2074:
2072:
2071:
2066:
2060:
2058:
2057:
2053:
2049:
2045:
2041:
2033:
2027:
2023:
2019:
2015:
2011:
2007:
2004:
2000:
1996:
1992:
1988:
1987:
1986:
1982:
1978:
1974:
1971:
1970:
1969:
1968:
1964:
1960:
1957:
1950:
1945:
1938:
1934:
1930:
1926:
1923:
1921:
1917:
1913:
1912:BenKuykendall
1909:
1905:
1902:
1899:
1896:
1895:
1894:
1893:
1889:
1885:
1881:
1870:
1866:
1862:
1861:BenKuykendall
1859:for merging.
1858:
1854:
1853:
1852:
1849:
1846:
1840:
1839:
1834:
1830:
1826:
1820:
1816:
1812:
1808:
1807:
1806:
1805:
1802:
1798:
1794:
1789:
1788:
1787:
1786:
1782:
1778:
1774:
1770:
1766:
1757:
1753:
1749:
1745:
1741:
1738:
1736:
1732:
1728:
1723:
1722:
1721:
1720:
1716:
1712:
1708:
1703:
1701:
1696:
1692:
1690:
1683:
1679:
1675:
1671:
1666:
1665:
1664:
1661:
1657:
1653:
1649:
1645:
1634:
1632:
1630:
1626:
1614:
1610:
1606:
1602:
1598:
1597:
1596:
1595:
1591:
1587:
1583:
1578:
1574:
1567:
1565:
1564:
1560:
1556:
1552:
1548:
1540:
1538:
1537:
1533:
1529:
1528:64.229.100.61
1525:
1521:
1517:
1510:
1504:
1500:
1496:
1492:
1488:
1487:
1486:
1485:
1482:
1478:
1474:
1469:
1468:
1467:
1466:
1462:
1458:
1449:
1447:
1446:
1442:
1438:
1428:
1427:
1426:
1424:
1415:
1414:
1413:
1411:
1403:
1399:
1395:
1394:
1393:
1387:
1385:
1384:
1380:
1376:
1372:
1367:
1366:
1362:
1358:
1348:
1346:
1345:
1341:
1337:
1333:
1332:. Thank you.
1331:
1327:
1321:
1319:
1315:
1311:
1308:Please go to
1306:
1304:
1300:
1296:
1292:
1288:
1284:
1283:
1275:
1268:
1266:
1264:
1260:
1256:
1252:
1241:
1237:
1233:
1229:
1225:
1221:
1220:
1219:
1218:
1214:
1210:
1206:
1200:
1197:
1193:
1190:
1182:
1178:
1174:
1170:
1165:
1163:
1159:
1155:
1150:
1149:
1142:
1138:
1134:
1129:
1128:
1126:
1125:
1124:
1123:
1120:
1116:
1112:
1108:
1104:
1100:
1096:
1092:
1088:
1087:
1086:
1085:
1081:
1077:
1064:
1060:
1056:
1051:
1046:
1043:
1042:
1041:
1037:
1033:
1029:
1025:
1021:
1017:
1013:
1009:
1004:
1003:
1002:
998:
994:
990:
985:
981:
977:
973:
969:
965:
960:
959:
958:
954:
950:
946:
942:
937:
936:
935:
934:
930:
926:
917:
915:
914:
911:
908:Sincerely, --
906:
902:
899:
896:
893:
886:
881:
878:
872:
871:
870:
869:
866:
862:
858:
850:
846:
842:
838:
833:
832:
831:
830:
827:
826:
822:
817:
812:
806:
799:
796:
790:
789:
783:
779:
775:
771:
770:
769:
766:
762:
758:
757:
752:
751:
750:
749:
746:
739:
738:
737:
735:
728:
725:
721:
720:
719:
715:
711:
707:
706:75.19.179.224
703:
694:
693:
688:
683:
677:
673:
670:
666:
662:
659:
657:
645:
643:
637:
635:
633:
625:
621:
617:
613:
609:
608:
607:
605:
601:
597:
585:
582:
578:
577:
576:
575:
574:
573:
563:
559:
555:
554:
553:
552:
551:
550:
549:
548:
540:
537:
532:
531:
530:
529:
528:
527:
521:
517:
513:
512:
511:
510:
506:
502:
498:
497:
496:
494:
488:
482:
475:
474:its talk page
470:
465:
461:
457:
456:
451:
444:
443:
428:
411:
407:
403:
402:
397:
394:
390:
389:
385:
382:
379:
376:
372:
359:
358:
348:
344:
343:
339:
335:
329:
326:
325:
322:
305:
304:
299:
298:short stories
295:
291:
287:
283:
282:
274:
273:Novels portal
268:
263:
261:
258:
254:
253:
249:
242:
237:
234:
231:
227:
213:
210:. Please see
209:
208:
203:
202:
197:
193:
188:
184:
180:
174:
171:
170:
167:
150:
146:
142:
138:
137:
132:
129:
125:
124:
120:
114:
111:
108:
104:
99:
95:
89:
81:
72:
71:
61:
56:
55:
48:
44:
40:
36:
35:
34:
28:
25:
22:
18:
17:
3011:
3007:
3000:
2948:
2929:
2918:Nibin-Nogrim
2910:
2892:
2873:
2855:
2836:
2818:
2799:
2781:
2762:
2750:
2744:
2721:
2715:
2688:
2674:
2665:
2647:
2641:
2623:
2614:
2592:
2578:
2571:
2545:
2531:
2517:
2503:
2494:
2490:
2448:
2438:
2431:
2411:
2371:
2346:
2325:
2314:
2305:discomfited
2299:Exodus 17:13
2280:
2256:
2239:
2238:You mention
2228:
2211:
2205:Observations
2179:
2163:
2161:
2150:
2140:
2139:
2126:
2115:Instructions
2037:
1954:
1943:
1924:
1903:
1897:
1877:
1856:
1850:
1844:
1841:
1773:introduction
1772:
1761:
1704:
1700:Temple Mount
1697:
1693:
1687:
1642:— Preceding
1638:
1628:
1624:
1622:
1600:
1581:
1576:
1572:
1571:
1550:
1546:
1544:
1514:
1453:
1433:
1422:
1420:
1409:
1407:
1401:
1391:
1368:
1355:
1334:
1322:
1307:
1294:
1280:
1279:
1255:24.90.98.214
1245:
1201:
1186:
1073:
1049:
1019:
1015:
1011:
1007:
967:
944:
940:
921:
907:
903:
900:
897:
894:
890:
876:
873:
854:
824:
804:
802:
794:
791:
760:
754:
743:
731:
695:
679:
675:
653:
649:
641:
631:
629:
623:
619:
615:
611:
599:
595:
593:
489:
486:
453:
399:
355:
333:
301:
279:
206:
205:
200:
199:
191:
178:
154:Middle-earth
134:
113:Middle-earth
94:WikiProjects
52:
43:please do so
31:
30:
26:
2997:Dwarf names
2943:Durin's Day
2463:word choice
2388:Thank you.
2129:transcluded
1547:underground
1249:—Preceding
1095:2 Maccabees
1091:1 Maccabees
1028:Brísingamen
745:Mike Rosoft
724:Mike Rosoft
700:—Preceding
556:Removed to
493:Adam Bishop
469:its history
145:legendarium
3080:Categories
3044:CodeTalker
3014:CodeTalker
2977:Good work!
2965:reply here
2807:Nibin-Noeg
2552:plagiarism
2496:verifiable
2082:Authorship
2068:GA toolbox
1739:This link
1582:The Hobbit
1577:The Hobbit
1457:GeorgeTSLC
1437:Hairy Dude
1016:The Hobbit
1008:The Hobbit
968:The Hobbit
756:The Hobbit
638:Moved back
598:call them
458:page were
294:novelettes
207:past tense
37:under the
2724:Whiteguru
2168:Whiteguru
2144:Whiteguru
2141:Reviewer:
2105:Templates
2096:Reviewing
2061:GA Review
1670:Mnudelman
1629:Warhammer
1625:Warhammer
1551:"shadowy"
1357:Ashspirit
1242:Dourhands
1196:Beleriand
765:Daibhid C
697:they can.
3004:Westron.
2945:notable?
2926:Hog Farm
2889:Hog Farm
2852:Hog Farm
2815:Hog Farm
2778:Hog Farm
2154:contribs
2110:Criteria
2048:Hog Farm
2040:Durin II
1900:per nom.
1884:Hog Farm
1689:De728631
1656:contribs
1644:unsigned
1520:dwerrows
1516:Dwarrows
1473:Solicitr
1471:between.
1303:fair use
1287:fair use
1251:unsigned
1209:Súrendil
1167:ignored.
910:Thrombur
714:contribs
702:unsigned
669:contribs
656:unsigned
624:Dwarrows
616:dwarrows
600:dwarrows
290:novellas
84:GA-class
47:reassess
2716:Overall
2595:focused
2548:copyvio
2467:fiction
2273:Added.
2249:Added.
1904:Support
1898:Support
1857:support
1811:Elphion
1763:Cheers
1648:Nix1129
1605:Davémon
1524:dwerrow
1511:Dwarrow
1375:Davémon
1228:Davémon
1224:wp:fict
1133:Davémon
1111:Davémon
1107:Vulgate
1055:Davémon
1020:Letters
993:Davémon
989:wp:bias
925:Davémon
865:savidan
810:Nightst
774:Tamfang
620:dwarves
612:Letters
558:Khuzdul
516:Khuzdul
336:on the
241:Fantasy
181:on the
2751:Passed
2667:images
2642:stable
2640:It is
2618:policy
2570:It is
2489:It is
2469:, and
2459:layout
2430:It is
2415:review
2307:Amalek
2303:Joshua
1555:Ncsr11
1495:Ncsr11
1398:Sindar
1032:Uthanc
949:Uthanc
604:Aranel
596:really
584:(talk)
539:(talk)
501:Khazar
460:merged
309:Novels
286:novels
236:Novels
201:before
143:, his
90:scale.
54:Review
2693:with
2471:lists
2417:(see
2406:Final
2301:"And
2131:from
2005:Here
1972:Here
1925:Merge
1831:into
1417:1998)
1371:Cirth
1076:Error
984:WP:OR
964:WP:OR
945:first
941:first
820:llion
562:— Jor
520:— Jor
462:into
192:Note:
3063:talk
3048:talk
3033:talk
3018:talk
2987:talk
2931:Talk
2894:Talk
2881:Ibun
2857:Talk
2844:Ibûn
2820:Talk
2783:Talk
2728:talk
2550:and
2493:and
2455:lead
2453:for
2423:here
2419:here
2394:talk
2372:Done
2347:Done
2326:Done
2281:Done
2257:Done
2229:Done
2192:talk
2172:talk
2148:talk
2052:talk
2014:talk
1995:talk
1981:talk
1963:talk
1933:talk
1916:talk
1888:talk
1865:talk
1815:talk
1797:talk
1781:talk
1769:talk
1748:talk
1731:talk
1715:talk
1711:Bgme
1674:talk
1652:talk
1609:talk
1590:talk
1559:talk
1532:talk
1522:and
1499:talk
1491:Arda
1477:talk
1461:talk
1441:talk
1396:The
1379:talk
1361:talk
1340:talk
1295:this
1259:talk
1232:talk
1213:talk
1173:talk
1158:talk
1137:talk
1115:talk
1080:talk
1059:talk
1036:talk
997:talk
953:talk
929:talk
851:Move
841:talk
805:move
778:talk
710:talk
665:talk
602:? --
296:and
173:High
2953:. @
2941:Is
2451:MoS
1775:'.
835:on?
825:(?)
807:. —
761:can
736:):
682:CBD
671:) .
630:It
505:FOo
328:Mid
49:it.
3082::
3065:)
3050:)
3035:)
3020:)
2989:)
2730:)
2699::
2687:b
2681::
2673:a
2650::
2644:.
2626::
2620:.
2599::
2591:b
2585::
2577:a
2574:.
2556::
2544:d
2538::
2534:OR
2530:c
2524::
2516:b
2510::
2502:a
2499:.
2475::
2465:,
2461:,
2457:,
2447:b
2441::
2437:a
2434:.
2413:GA
2396:)
2194:)
2174:)
2156:)
2054:)
2016:)
1997:)
1983:)
1965:)
1935:)
1918:)
1910:.
1890:)
1867:)
1817:)
1799:)
1783:)
1750:)
1733:)
1717:)
1709:--
1702:)
1676:)
1658:)
1654:•
1611:)
1592:)
1561:)
1553:?
1534:)
1518:,
1501:)
1493:.
1479:)
1463:)
1443:)
1381:)
1363:)
1342:)
1305:.
1261:)
1234:)
1215:)
1175:)
1160:)
1139:)
1131:--
1117:)
1101:,
1097:,
1093:,
1082:)
1061:)
1038:)
1030:.
999:)
978:.
955:)
931:)
863:.
843:)
780:)
716:)
712:•
680:--
667:•
632:is
622:.
292:,
288:,
239::
63:).
3061:(
3046:(
3031:(
3016:(
2985:(
2962:|
2726:(
2718::
2697:)
2689:(
2679:)
2597:)
2593:(
2583:)
2579:(
2554:)
2546:(
2536:)
2532:(
2522:)
2508:)
2504:(
2473:)
2449:(
2392:(
2214:.
2190:(
2170:(
2151:·
2146:(
2050:(
2012:(
1993:(
1979:(
1961:(
1931:(
1914:(
1886:(
1863:(
1813:(
1795:(
1779:(
1767:(
1746:(
1729:(
1713:(
1672:(
1650:(
1607:(
1588:(
1557:(
1530:(
1497:(
1475:(
1459:(
1439:(
1377:(
1359:(
1338:(
1257:(
1230:(
1211:(
1171:(
1156:(
1135:(
1113:(
1078:(
1057:(
1034:(
995:(
951:(
927:(
839:(
815:a
776:(
708:(
687:☎
663:(
652:—
476:.
360:.
340:.
185:.
96::
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.