Talk:Israel–Hamas war/Archive 37

2700:

higher because many casualties remain buried under rubble or in areas that medics cannot reach, Al-Qidra said. The Health Ministry does not differentiate between civilians and combatants in its figures but says about two-thirds of the people killed in Gaza were women and minors. The ministry is part of the Hamas-run government, but its casualty figures from previous wars were largely consistent with those of U.N. agencies and even the Israeli military. The Israeli military says it has killed around 9,000 militants, without providing evidence, and blames the high civilian death toll on Hamas because it positions fighters, tunnels and other militant infrastructure in dense neighborhoods, often near homes, schools or mosques.

3558:

trying to do it just needs more polish before it goes live. I do want to not per the exchange immediately above - I don't think motivations of the individual combatants is of encyclopedic interest to the lead in an article about the war. We care about the strategic reasonings, not the individual motivations of the people involved (which will vary by individual with a near-infinite number of permutations). Also, we generally should focus on the reasons for the war as evaluated by third-party sources,

31: 5470:"Iran has pushed its proxies to make trouble for the American military and to pressure Israel and the West" sounds like giving them authority to me in any case. In fact you have conceded that direct responsibility for ordering October 7 is a red herring, what matters is the overall relationship between the two actors. And of course, what can be verified in reliable sources irrespective of what any one of us considers the ultimate "truth". 5601:"Both Hamas and Iran have publicly acknowledged a strategic partnership. They hold separate goals in the decades-long conflict with Jerusalem, but those aims appear to have aligned during the early Saturday attack, which has left hundreds dead in Israel and fighting still flaring up in the south near Gaza. Iran has for years been fighting a shadow war against Israel through proxy groups, such as Hezbollah in Lebanon, Hamas and others." 2783:

the total number of deaths they've already registered. The estimate for the number of resdidential units which have been destroyed or made uninhabitable is 65000. plus 290,000 which are damaged. An extra 25000 under the rubble fom 65000 badly damaged or destroyed buildings doesn't sound unreasonable to me especially with snipers around the place though I'd have thought the ministy would be better at this by now.

1864:

do or don't also contain other terms like a year or range of years; and in test 2, whether they contain those words in any order, along with year or other terms. Neither test is designed to answer a question about the most common name; a separate investigation would be needed for that. But within that caveat, they appear to demonstrate support for the Move question.

169:– The war has now extended into 2024 for two weeks, so the current article title using only "2023" is contrary to standard naming practice on Knowledge: we would only use "2023" as the year disambiguation if the war had ended in 2023. The standard policy for disambiguation of multi-year wars is to include the years in parentheses after the war name. Compare with 5606:"Hamas's surprise attack on Israel on Oct. 7 has sparked numerous questions...But the latest war should not have been entirely unexpected. For years, Hamas has been one of the primary vehicles supported by the Islamic Republic of Iran in its strategy of confronting Israel on multiple fronts, with at least three fronts established since the 1980s." 2905: 3023:"Israel and the United States were internationally isolated amid global calls for a ceasefire"l; this sentence is supported by the four in-line citations, and in a previous talk page discussion, many more sources saying the exact same thing were provided. The continuous removal of half of this sentence is unacceptable. 5153:

Hamas incursion is verified as having nothing to do with Iran (that's in the Foreign Policy article above - "U.S. and Israeli officials have stated there is no evidence directly linking Iran to the attack, and some U.S. intelligence sources have suggested that Iranian leaders were caught off-guard.")

4325:

Given that we prefer secondary sources over primary sources, once we decided to include some aspect of the motives for the attack we shouldn't even be questioning whether we should include what analysts assess their motives to be - if we want to question some aspect of these, we should be questioning

3535:

You're making a good point when you say that the geopolitical reasons are unlikely to have motivated ordinary Hamas fighters. The motivations of the Hamas leadership are not necessarily the same as those of Hamas fighters and ideally the article should discuss both of them. Unfortunately, our sources

3305:

Currently the lede only mentions the stated reasons for the attack. The experts acknowledge some overlap between the stated and actual reasons (e.g., freeing Palestinian prisoners), however they also believe that there were other reasons, such as resisting the normalisation trend, re-established ties

2368:

I rather sadly did not find it an extraordinary story though it was shocking but yes I'd have agreed it should not go in without more support as there's a lot of propaganda about. However the above does seem to be an actual independent reliable source corroberating it rather than just duplicating the

2024:

story, but nothing will. It gives a selection of bits of the story that tend to have a pro middle east slant, but each story it does give is factual, as in the details match other reliable sources. We couldn't base a whole article on it, but we shouldn't do that with any source, it's useful as one of

1846:

The second test was similar, but uses three 'intitle' terms, to elicit titles that may have the same terms as in "Israel–Hamas War", but in any order, and conceivably with other terms mixed in. For example, if there are highly relevant published articles with the title "Hamas–Israel War" or "Gaza War

1801:

No. The Palestinian Authority in the West Bank neither invaded Israel nor deploys its police/army against Israel, and Israel is not attacking the PA (which is already in its pocket) but rather assisting settlers in the violence and expropriation of land which has been characteristic of that territory

1863:

These two tests do *not* address whether "Israel–Hamas War" is a more common title in reliable sources than "Israel–Gaza War", or any other wording. Both tests are aimed strictly at the move question, i.e., in test 1, whether titles in reliable sources that contain the expression "Israel–Hamas War"

502:- The "Israel-Hamas" designation is grossly inappropriate and we should not move the page without fixing that. People looking for sources to write the content are searching using "Israel-Hamas war" and finding a very biased subset of the resources available. e.g. see above re relevance of apartheid. 5269:

The proxy war could not have been "brought" by Hamas "to Israeli soil" or "spread further from the tiny Mediterranean enclave" if it was not in Gaza to begin with. This is approaching "didn't hear that" territory. Words in the English language do not cease to mean what they mean just because we may

4351:

The lede's purpose is to summarize the body. What you have inserted is not a summary of the body. Furthermore the context in question is Hamas' initial justification for the attack, and not analyses. There are many different analyses, including that Israel wants to make Gaza uninhabitable, reoccupy

3770:

The main goal of the change is to give equal weight to stated reasons and to reasons reported in secondary sources (although you're right that the latter should eventually have greater weight). The clause I've removed in order not to inflate the lede isn't crucial for the lede in my opinion. If the

3516:

The reverted bit removed some important bits of what Hamas said. Its quite likely the leaders did have the concerns the experts said but I hardly think that was primary or that three thousand militants went into what was essentially a possible suicide mission because of that! Russians and Americans

3441:

Just to add that stated reasons are often bollocks meant for non-expert domestic audience (i.e., the electorate). We don't write, for example, that Russia attacked Ukraine "in order to save its population from neo-Nazis", or that the US invaded Iraqi or Libyan oil fields "to combat terror". Hamas's

2782:

I've been trying to see if there's any way I can make the US figures sensible if they really are experts at estimating it. I think one would have to assume that the number of dead under rubble or deaths otherwise not registered is far far higher than the Gaza Health Mnistry says, perhaps as much as

2461:

in the Middle Eastern conflict, and likely not by own choice. I agree that we should not source anything to his opinions (we shouldn't use opinion pieces anyway). But we have no evidence that the organisations' reporting is unreliable. Does the fact that Boris Johnson lied to the UK parliament make

2408:

Wow. That's a horrific statement, especially from someone claiming to represent human rights. Definitely a partisan organization, so hopefully not reliable even when their claims are reported by RS. I wonder if there's some way to blacklist the organization's claims, not familiar with those aspects

181:

which ended up very complicated thanks to discussing three separate issues at once (whether to change "Israel–Hamas war" to something else, what to change the year disamguator to, and whether year disambiguation is needed at all). It was closed with the result being to retain the "Israel–Hamas war"

5418:

Iran supporting Hamas afterwards by definition turns it into a proxy...and of course it was supporting Hamas before. So for the umpteenth time, it's irrelevant whether Iran directly ordered Hamas to start the war. The most immediate cause of the Indochinese wars was French occupation but they were

2483:

Should be a fairly simple question, but I was curious why the former is used instead of the latter for a good 90% of citations in the article. Do the two not accomplish the same thing? If they do and nobody is opposed, I'd like to remove the #invoke part of the code to help further cut down on the

2275:

We can't include it as a fact, but we should include it AS a witness report "witnesses told Middle East Eye…" or just "witness reported that…" exactly as MEE have presented it. Other sources will probably trace to the same witnesses, the other sources would just be endorsing MEE. The discussion on

2028:

In terms of how much I personally trust it, compared to others with a similar stance, I'd rank it as less reliable than Al Jazeera (one of the world's most reliable news outlets on any topic other than the Qatari government) but more reliable than TRT or Electronic Intafada (I'm unsure how much to

3456:

While I agree that expert opinion should be emphasized over Hamas' view, I'm not sure your Russia comparison is quite accurate. Russia's justifications were simply lies ("Donbas genocide"). This is why we did not take them seriously. However, Hamas' justifications regarding settlements, West Bank

2988:

Now, I think it would be wrong if we started citing passages from the document that no reliable source has cited, and even more wrong if we started writing our own interpretations into the article. But in a situation where multiple sources are quoting selected passages from a document, it is good

2569:

The reason to use the #invoke version is to avoid having the article exceed template limits. Specifically, using the template doubles the amount of transcluded text which can cause the page to show errors instead of expanding templates. Previewing an edit of the current article shows "Post-expand

1824:

Current support level as I write seems strong enough that this discussion section might not be necessary, but nevertheless I prefer to have some data behind any decision I make in a formal discussion, so I went ahead with it. I did some search tests to see what they reveal about the proposed move

5812:

comes to mind, but not sure it really adds a whole lot. Let's go back to actual content. That's our job. Improving this patchy article. The place we're up to is this. There are many excellent reliable sources who have described the conflict as being a Proxy War. They are all listed above. I, and

5154:

then to argue that the subsequent incursion by Israel is part of a proxy war with Iran is ludicrous. The logic that Iran supports Hamas so it is part of proxy war is faulty, it requires at least active participation, that's why the situation is not part of an Iran US proxy war, at least not atm.

3856:

As to your second comment, it's true that only one source supports each claim ("reasserting its power" and "resolving internal tension"). Let's look at the reasons mentioned in the 3 articles I've listed above (Al-Jazeera, CBS and the NYT). Please feel free to add more sources dealing with this.

3557:

reverted, most immediately because of the weasel wording. Being the lead in a contentious area in which you've made similar bold edits twice, I think a full-text draft of the proposed change and then getting clear consensus is the best path forward. To be clear I agree in spirit with what you're

3487:

I said 'The stated reasons by Hamas were attributed to them'. The attributing is important. The attributed reason is more encyclopaediac than some american expert sitting halfway across the word spouting his expert opinion on what are the 'real' reasons are - which most definitely should also be

2699:

Since the war started, 25,105 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza, while another 62,681 have been wounded, the Health Ministry said. The toll included the 178 bodies brought to Gaza’s hospitals since Saturday, Health Ministry spokesperson Ashraf al-Qidra said. The overall toll is thought to be

2596:

that around 20% to 30% of all Hamas fighters in Gaza Strip have been killed, which is significant when compared to the overall death toll in Gaza, over 32,000 (counting the missing 7,000 who are presumed dead under rubble). The article further states that by Israeli estimates, around 9,000 Hamas

1315:

apply. Preceding the term with "2023" was already an unnecessary disambiguation, but it could have been passed off as part of the name. However, placing "2023–present" in parentheses would indicate that there is a need for disambiguation, when there is in fact no ambiguity. It is irrelevant that

4366:

I also support having Hamas reasons first and analysis afterwards. What's the point of analysing something without some basic facts first? And can I also say it just gives me a wrong feeling considering that America is such a strong supporter of Israel to see the analysis cited to two american

186:

about the title following on from that RM. This RM is intended specifically to fix the incorrect year disambiguation as soon as possible: a clearly incorrect title shouldn't be left in effect long-term on a heavily viewed page. It is intended without prejudice against any other discussions or

2976:

to the primary source but without further, specialized knowledge. For example, an article about a musician may cite discographies and track listings published by the record label, and an article about a novel may cite passages to describe the plot, but any interpretation needs a secondary

559:

I will say that this should not be taken as an endorsement of using the name Israel-Hamas, I do not believe the article should be titled that and believe Israel-Gaza is the only way to avoid a NPOV violation. However, when it comes to the date issue I'm fine with the change on principle.

4367:

newspapers and Al Jazeera - with an analysis from America, to see those views on why Hamas did it given prominence compared to Hamas itself. An anyway the reasons are in addition to what Hamas said so putting them there without the other reasons gives secondary reasons undue prominence.

1860:(even though it was updated on 18 Jan. 2024). The only other results for test 2 that included any type of year, included it only as part of a full date, such as CNN's "January 17, 2024 Israel-Hamas war" at result #4, and result #55: 'Daily Recap: Hamas - Israel War November 1st, 2023'. 5756:

On 25 June 1950, the KPA crossed the 38th parallel. Doesn't matter whether Beijing was across the details of that particular operation or not, let alone whether they ordered it. That is almost irrelevant. The Korean war was still a proxy war between the Communist bloc and the West.

3042:

that have primarily called for a ceasefire or the release of the hostages. Israel and the United States were internationally isolated amid global calls for a ceasefire..." is simply redundant and bad writing. The previous sentence already mentions the global calls for a ceasefire.

5356:

Again, this is a different issue from direct responsibility for ordering October 7, although even then there is disagreement. Either way Hamas can act - and according to sources is acting - as a proxy for Iran in the grand scheme of this war, which is what this article is about.

815:

What is the guarantee that this article (of course, if it is not changed to Gaza war or something like this) will not be the main topic in the long run? The article Russo-Ukrainian War may not be the main topic in the next decades, but there is no need to disambiguate it at this

3880:

So it looks like the reasserting power and resolving internal tensions should be removed and instead we should mention the ties with Iran. Here's a new version. Per u:VQuakr's comment I'm starting with the reasons from secondary sources and then mention the stated reasons.

871:(or "War in Gaza") with year. As attested by multiple reliable sources, Israel has attacked all of Gaza Strip, including civilian structures; their constant mention of Hamas is only war propaganda, whereas Knowledge article titles must be neutral much more than popular. — 5371:

I just pointed to foreign policy article, it says quite explicitly that Iran had nothing to do with starting this war and were even surprised by it. There are other sources saying the same. Iran then supporting Hamas afterwards does not suddenly turn Hamas into a proxy.

1828:

The tests purposely don't mention a year, in order to see whether titles that include the core title of "Israel–Hamas War" also mention a year (or some other term), or do not. Results from two searches appear to show that only a tiny number of results mention a year.

5138:

Likewise. "Neither say that the war is part of the proxy conflict, but that the war brought the proxy conflict to Israel" is a non-sentence. If the "war brought the proxy conflict to Israel" then by definition the war is or has become part of the proxy conflict.

3083:

Throughout the war, there have been popular protests around the world that have primarily called for a ceasefire or the release of the hostages. Israel and the United States were increasingly isolated amid calls from the international community for a ceasefire

2054:

For that particular story I would give it a brief mention prefaced "Eyewitnesses told Middle East Eye…" (exactly as they have) it's important to include as a thing that was observed / reported / claimed, but we can't say it's a thing that definitely happened.

2090:

An anonymously written article from "occupied Palestine" quoting people whose names were changed, produced by a news source believed to have ties to the Qatari government. No, I think that for a contentious subject we need much better sourcing than that.

5240:

That is neither the issue at hand, the definition of a proxy, or an argument grounded in any kind of Knowledge policy. Sources say Hamas brought the proxy conflict to Israeli soil, and it spread beyond Gaza. Your reason for excluding this information?

5092:: "The shape-shifting conflict in the Middle East saw Iran openly go on the offensive for the first time since the war in Gaza began, as Tehran’s latest round of existential brinkmanship with Israel spread further from the tiny Mediterranean enclave." 5436:

Nope, otherwise every time anyone supported anyone they are automatically prodiucing a proxy, which is nonsense. The ordinary meaning of proxy is the giving of authority to someone to act on their behalf, which Iran has plainly not done with Hamas.

2672:

It's complete baloney as a cursory inspection of the death toll will tell. But if the WSJ wants to write stupid things like that I suppose we have to copy it - it is a very reliable source. I'd attribute it to their sources. Verifiability not truth.

1142:

per what I have been saying for months (since the conflict started). Glad to see more users are finally thinking the same thing. "Israel–Hamas war" is the widely agreed-upon term used by the vast majority of publications and style guides, including:

5741:

Well, there may well be no consensus, in which it case it stays out. I still fail to see how one can reconcile proxy war for this conflict with top drawer sourcing confirming that Iran had no knowledge (or was even surprised) by the Hamas attack.

4252:

That is true. And I'm not against using primary sources at points. But has to be led by the secondary sources. To my mind, the common theme is that Hamas has always wanted to "obliterate" Israel. Has very little to do with responding to anything,

3358:

I would say that the opinion of neutral geopolitical experts is at least as relevant as the stated reasons from Hamas: the average reader will want to know why experts believe Hamas started the war, and not only why Hamas says it started the war.

3531:

I tried to keep the lede concise and so mentioned the key issues ("desecration" and settlements) while labelling everything else as "other actions in the West Bank and Gaza." If that was the issue, we can mention more of them. I'll give it a try

4907:

I wonder whether focusing on the (numeric) date instead of the (named) day could be something of a cultural bias. Both happened on the first Saturday of October. If your cultural frame is weeks, it's the same; if it's months, it's off by one

544:

I continue to believe that Israel-Hamas is an unacceptable name for the war and the discussion close was premature. However, I'm fine with deciding the date issue for now, and I also believe that either way there should be the date included.

5189:

And of course, saying this war forms part of the Iran-Israel proxy conflict is not the same thing as saying Hamas started it on direct orders from Iran. The bar certainly cannot be the "active participation" of Iranian armed forces, it's a

4174:

Analysts suggested that Palestinian frustration at Arab–Israeli normalization despite the ongoing blockade of Gaza and rising settler violence in the occupied West Bank—combined with deepening ties between Iran and Hamas—contributed to the

2724:

I agree with addition of this information, especially since we are using Gaza ministry numbers that do not differentiate between civilian and military casualties, as the WSJ coverage notes. It should be in the infobox and I see it is not.

5197:

The fact is we have multiple reliable sources contextualizing the war within the context of the proxy conflict. This is not mere "logic that Iran supports Hamas so it is part of proxy war" (i.e. SYNTH). This is literally what sources

5621:"The various militias and terrorist groups that Tehran nurtures have allowed it to indirectly evict America from Iraq, sustain the Assad family in Syria and, on Oct. 7, help inflict a deeply traumatizing attack on the Jewish state." 3442:

statements (of revenge, etc.) are also destined for its domestic audience. IMO, wider geopolitics should be given a prominent place in such articles, even if it means relying on sources not consumed en masse by the electorate. —

1838:

and looked at 87 results (Google claims 240 results for that page, but I see only 87). Other than daily reports (e.g, #7 CNN's "January 17, 2024 Israel-Hamas war") very few titles have a year in them; the only one I see is #57:

2616:: I agree this could be a very important bit of information to add to the lede, but I'm a little concerned about the last part: "which means that around 2/3rds of all deaths have been civilians", does the 'which means' violate 4911:

However, an online date converter tells me that the dates are 10 Tishrei 5734 and 22 Tishrei 5784 in the Hebrew calendar and 22 Rabi Al Awwal 1445 and 10 Ramadan 1393 in the Islamic calendar, so I prefer not saying "exactly".

5616:"Many observers, however, see Iran's primary goal more as waging a proxy war from afar by supporting Hamas, Hezbollah, and the Palestinian terrorist group Islamic Jihad, thereby forcing Israel into a de facto two-front war." 4180:

Hamas said it was responding to the blockade, occupation and settlements, as well as the "Judaization" of the Al-Aqsa Mosque and the plight of Palestinian refugees and prisoners, who it sought to free by taking an estimated

3471:

Yes, although I simply wanted to underscore that there are war rationales, and there are rationales for the masses, and both usually deserve to be mentioned. I didn't intend to compare the veracity of individual claims. —

5855:

The RFC option continues to be available, The one you said you did not want to waste time on, but you seem quite content to continue wasting time bludgeoning this discussion, where the consensus continues to be against.

4785: 2838: 5611:"Hamas, which controls the strip and is a rare Sunni Muslim organization among mostly Shiite militants, catapulted Iran and its allies back onto the global radar on Oct. 7 with a brutal cross-border attack on Israel." 2334:

Indeed. Is the source listed under any pages listing levels of source credibility ? If so, what is its stated level of reliability? (Can't remember what the page that lists sources and their reliability is called).

1518:. If there is no other article that shares this title, then it is by definition not "ambiguous", and no disambiguation is needed. "2023 Israel–Hamas war", and "Israel–Hamas war (2023–present)" should be tagged with 1375:

with disambiguation. Some of the contributors here seem to have incredibly short memories, but this isn't the first conflict in Gaza or even the first state of armed conflict to ever exist between Hamas and Israel.

2993:

so the interested reader can read the original document the media have quoted from. Any scholarly article, for example, would provide such a link, and that is the standard we here should be aspiring to as well.

5330:

The proxy argument refers to Iran's making use of proxies to stir the pot, but Hamas is not a proxy for Iran in this war. Houthis, Hezbollah, yes. So it is not applicable here. The material can be added to the

3800:

The lead summarizes the body. Where in the body do we talk about the expert opinions on the cause of the 10/7 attack? (I didn't immediately see it but the article is rather long and I may have just missed it).

5542:

Honestly at this point this is definitely original research by citing the definition of proxy war, rather than just giving one RS that says explicitly that the war with Hamas in part of of the proxy conflict.

3321:

This should be reflected in the lede per WP:DUE as otherwise only Hamas's stated reasons are mentioned. Also, WP:LEDE should summarise the article and now this part of article is not reflected in the lede.

3785:

The experts added renormalization as a reason rather than saying it was the reason. As far as I can see not all mentioned wanting to resolve internal tension or wanting to reassert themselves as a reason.

5594:

Your response to being given multiple RS that explicitly link this war to the proxy conflict was to engage in incomprehensible hair-splitting and goalpost-shifting. Here are some more for you to ignore:

2252:

needs more than one WP:RS for inclusion, it makes extraordinary claims based on "witnesses reported that" statements, there needs to be more substantial and independent sourcing than witness statements.

5065:

Thanks for providing the RS. They do not support the claim that the Israel-Hamas war is part of the Israel-Iran proxy war, but they make claims that these groups are proxies. That's not the same claim.

5827:

I have no objection to saying that Iran is in a proxy war with the US. And the sources do not describe this conflict as a proxy war. How could they if Iran had no idea about the attack to begin with?

1443:

In addition, I think it would be more accurate to call it the Israel-Hamas war since the war was officially declared by Israel against Hamas, not Gaza. Gaza is the name of a region and not a country.

2704:

Given that the ministry does not differentiate between civlians and combatants, and that the "women and minors" figure is most commonly quoted and easily sourced, I would suggest going with that.

5813:

other editors above, can see that, without this dimension being sketched out, the article will be the poorer for it. I believe it's time that we simply crack on and include the relevant content.

2754:

If we have any numbers on non-Hamas civilian mens were killed, we can put them in. Right now we do have a number in the WSJ on military casualties, and obviously in a war article we need that.

2069:

That is not the only consideration. Is the source reliable enough that we can say in wikivoice that eyewitness told them something? Either way, is it significant enough for this page, or is it

3423:

It even probably sort of covers what the actual plan was, in that it was somewhat calling for support from some of the groups they are in less cost contract with, like in the West Bank region.

2457:

Yep. Some people don't have that comfort of sitting safely in a comfy armchair thousands of miles away and analysing dispassionately kill numbers on another continent. Clearly, the guy is

5124:

The Palestinian death toll is due to the Israeli operation, just as much as the Israeli death toll is due to the Hamas operation. Please do not revert again reliably sourced material.

1774:

Wouldn’t “israel-Palestine war” be better here considering not only is the war in the Gaza Strip not just against Hamas and considering the deteriorating situation in the West Bank?

5022:

One state solution part isn't included in the initial declaration of war by Israel and to be honest sounds like original research as this isn't explicitly mentioned in the source.

1683:

redirects here. Thus unless the redirect is disambiguated, this page should logically be moved to that title, since there is already a consensus that this is the primary topic.

380:

but that is an Israeli propaganda slogan that is not used in most unbiased sources. (Though al Jazeera, who tend to have a pro Palestine stance, seem to be doing some targeted

2113:

And "occupied Palestine" is a fairly common term for Gaza and West Bank, the particularly slanted sources use that to refer to Israel, but I think MEE just calls it Israel.

5309:"The whole purpose of the Iranian proxies, they argue, is to find a way to punch at Israel and the United States without setting off the kind of war Tehran wants to avoid" 2181: 933:, you attack a state. Claiming that you only attack its ruling party is bollocks. Propaganda for idiots who have no faintest idea about the basics of international law. — 5051:

The number of Palestinian deaths is since the start of the war on October 7, as the source makes clear. If they're since the start of anyone's "operation", it's Hamas's.

3107:

Sounds good. But I am skeptical to put pro-Palestinian and pro-Israeli protests in the same weight, that they both have been "popular". What do the sources say on that?

2276:

the reliabile sources notice board (that someone linked above) says very reliable sources like the BBC already have a track record of quoting MEE as a reliable source.

469:- I am becoming more sympathetic to the argument for excluding the year entirely, but in any event we have to deal with the current title becoming factually incorrect. 4433:

McKernan, Bethan; Michaelson, Ruth; Graham-Harrison, Emma; Kierszenbaum, Quique; Balousha, Hazem; Taha, Sufian; Sherwood, Harriet; Beaumont, Peter (14 October 2023).

2017:

I read it quite a lot. Fairly reliable. It's cherry picked but it's factual. In my personal experience the stories it tells line up well with other reliable sources.

1161: 4711: 4542: 5089: 5043: 4411: 2811: 2032:

According to it's own Knowledge page it's a UK based spin off of Al Jazeera, I'm not sure if that's official or just some staff who left and did their own thing.

1606:

This discussion is only about disambiguation of the current base title, there will likely be another discussion about the base title in due course (see section

4758: 4666: 4615: 4589: 4497: 5788:

Victims of oppression and apartheid dared to lift a hand against the oppressor... It's totally unfathomable, sure there must be an evil actor behind it.

3771:

problem is with "according to experts," then could you suggest another way of introducing this (the CBS article does include several experts' opinions)?

3239: 2384: 1522: 5353:

Do you know of any sources which state that Hamas is not acting as a proxy for Iran in this war, in any way, contrary to the sources that do state that?

3057:

They are actually two separate things. One about protests, and the other about positions of states in the international community. It is not redundant.

286:(Without disambiguation): Only name. The article Siege of Mariupol is not called Siege of Mariupol (2022) because of the Battle of Mariupol (1919). Per 4692: 4523: 1551:

if disambiguation is required then I much prefer (2023-2024). I am more sympathetic to other users' arguments for no disambiguation and support simply

5041: 4434: 3088:

That would make it clearer that in the first sentence, we are talking about street demos and in the second about things like the UN General Assembly.

450:

Poland has been invaded several times, Russia has invaded Ukraine several times, and the Soviet Union has had other military conflicts in Afghanistan

239:

For the reasons stated above. I would also support simply naming the article as "Israel-Hamas war" with no year as a description as a second choice.

3344:

The experts can be left to give their opinions later. The stated reasons by Hamas were attributed to them and definitely are of lead type interest.

1758:

without the year. The majority of reliable sources use this name to describe the war. It is unambiguous so there is no confusion on other articles.

639: 142: 5669:

from afar by supporting Hamas, Hezbollah, and the Palestinian terrorist group Islamic Jihad, thereby forcing Israel into a de facto two-front war."

5387: 4968: 4470: 1230: 353: 2983:

analyze, evaluate, interpret, or synthesize material found in a primary source yourself; instead, refer to reliable secondary sources that do so.

2687:

There are countless sources reporting that according to the health ministry in Gaza, around two-thirds of all those killed are women and minors.

357: 5039: 4170:

I'd support something like this but the sources clearly also focus on Al-Aqsa among Hamas's stated reasons, so that warrants inclusion. Perhaps:

427:

Israel–Hamas war without disambiguation per the above comment, about the invasion of Poland, Russian invasion of Ukraine and Soviet-Afghan war.

4967:

Agreed. Most sources have not found an Iranian connection to the October 7 attacks. This connection has been explicitly denied by Israel itself

2424: 5038:

It's common knowledge, well attested to by reliable sources, that these events are linked to the Iran-Israel proxy conflict, see for example:

2593: 5641:

These are all sentences which you are using to synthesize that they mean that the war is a proxy war. There is no explicit mention anywhere.

1779: 723:

Yes there are the 2008-2009 and 2014 Israel-Hamas wars, but this is much better known than either one using this name; the others are Israel-

208: 2688: 94: 89: 84: 72: 67: 59: 5168:

Also the article clearly mentions that spillover fighting with supposed Iranian proxies is spillover fighting, and not the war in itself.

1592:

It seems pretty obvious that Hamas isn't the only Palestinian force involved in the conflict, as other parties in Gaza are also involved.

795:

that we want something to disambiguate from the 2014 conflict and that it will be better to keep this consistent with similar articles. —

174: 5255:"Hamas brought the proxy war to Israeli soil. Tehran's brinkmanship with Israel spread from Gaza." does not signify a proxy war in Gaza. 5086:: "Already, Hamas has succeeded in bringing the proxy war between Iran and Israel—typically fought in Lebanon and Syria—to Israeli soil." 4879:

I think the word "exactly" should be removed. It conveys the same point without the to-the-date precision implied by the word "exactly."

2768:

There's no Knowledge policy saying editors must put in stupid things if they're reliably sourced. In fact no one has to put anything in.

120:

Subsequent comments should be made in a new section on the talk page. Editors desiring to contest the closing decision should consider a

4821:

to 7 October 2023. Nearly all sources agree that the Yom Kippur War began on 6 October 1973, a date which most would not consider to be

2888:

Since Haaretz and Times of Israel have reported on it I believe this is notable enough to include in the article. I will be doing this.

349: 290:, disambiguation is only necessary when there is otherwise an actual conflict in article titles. No such conflict in titles exists. Per 5306:"For all the fears of an outbreak of fighting in the Middle East that could draw the United States, Israel and Iran into direct combat" 3039: 598: 3221: 2250: 1993: 5226:

There is no evidence that Iran asked Hamas to start or continue the conflict, therefore no evidence of their being a proxy for Iran.

5185: 5047: 2740:

I don't see how that how that would make any difference under the assumption that at least as many civilian men are killed as women.

602: 5526: 4731: 4562: 1299:

are deliberately ambiguous. But it is clear that the overwhelming majority of sources have settled on "Israel–Hamas war". Secondly,

3311: 2941:; I have just now re-added such a link as part of my edits. I think Core's edit was based on a misunderstanding or cursory read of 828: 1346: 1186: 5698:

I thought you weren't going to waste more time on this? Kindly start a RFC if you wish to argue against consensus at this point.

5501:

Now why would I waste any more of my time on that? Enjoy your "consensus" that sources don't say what they say in plain English.

1775: 827:

were not disambiguated because of the words "The" and "Theory". The title of this article is also different from other articles (

2298:

I was the one that posted RSN thread. Not every rumor or witness statement published on the internet needs to go in the article

1856:, and the results were very similar to the first test. Britannica at result #26 was the first to use any type of date, and uses 170: 5182:

The claims of unnamed US and Israeli officials now count as "verified" to you? We also have claims in the WSJ to the contrary.

4352:

it and build settlements there. Should we also include that in the lede, or are we going to cherrypick what analyses we like?

3853:

The text I'm proposing also doesn't say that preventing the normalisation was *the* reason. It's listed as one of the reasons.

183: 178: 3250: 3207: 3098: 3004: 2828: 2714: 779: 3135:

thankfully made the war progress map. But can you provide the source where you get the land control and war progress from ?

2110:

I think it would be appropriate to include as "witnesses reported that". This same story is also appearing in other sources.

1852: 1917:

Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

1260: 1244: 1217: 5522: 4857:

It's a good catch, but I also agree that the wording should stay the same as it is now as per Kashmiri's comment. Cheers!

3296:

Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

1979:

Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

1882:

Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

1684: 728: 968:

By your reasoning, unless you consider Gaza as a sovereign state, shouldn't you be insisting on calling it a war against

5617: 5607: 5602: 4137:

Hamas said its attack was in response to the continued ] of the ], the ], the expansion of ], and the plight of ] and ].

2383:

This other source is hardly better than Middle East Eye. The chairman of Euro-med Monitor was the assistant director of

791:

with disambiguation, oppose without it. The change is reasonable to reflect that it is now 2024, but I do think that in

706:, noting that the current title is subject of ongoing discussion and without prejudice to any other RM discussing that. 5712:

I've read the entire thread, and am content to accept that the Reliable Sources are clear the conflict is a Proxy War.

4224:

Interesting background, but we can't use the statement from a primary source to inform or shape encyclopaedic content.

3902:

Hamas said its attack was in response to the continued ] of the ], the ], the expansion of ], and the plight of ] and ]

3651:

Hamas said its attack was in response to the continued ] of the ], the ], the expansion of ], and the plight of ] and ]

3587:

Hamas said its attack was in response to the continued ] of the ], the ], the expansion of ], and the plight of ] and ]

2423:

Just saw that someone has already started a discussion at WP:RSN which is the appropriate venue for that, feel free to

1515: 1492:

Seems to me that there's been enough conflicts in the Gaza area that some form of disambiguation is required. See e.g.

642:

or to something else. There are no reasons to avoid discussing the larger issues with the article name in this thread.

4949:, which is false since the source explicitly says that these killings have occurred since the start of the operation. 4830: 1529: 1342: 1304: 311: 3562:

the stated purposes by the parties (even if attributed) to the conflict (which will be heavily politicized at best).

5404:

Actually looking more closely at the article, it is all over the place on this issue, needs sorting out in general.

5875: 5818: 5771: 5762: 5732: 5332: 5183: 4285:

Note that the lede reflects body. And the lede's sentence in question is related to Hamas' initial justifications.

4262: 4229: 3824: 3393: 2351: 1037:

I think retaining the disambiguation is helpful because it adds clarity to the timeline vs other wars between them.

977: 381: 38: 5808:

Not really moving the conversation along is it, randomly quoting articles, which I can do as well as any editor,

3834: 946:

Two things: avoid overly harsh language as this is a CTOP; and what basis does your argument have in policy, i.e.

160: 47: 17: 3315: 1763: 1631: 802: 771: 111: 1925:

Let´s face it´s going to go on for a while, we don´t have the crystal ball to know when it will come to an end.

1834: 1825:

question. The results appear to support "Israel–Hamas War" without any addtional qualifying terms such as year.

1629:

This conflict is continuing into 2024, so changing the article's title to include the current year makes sense.

1493: 5612: 5287: 5110:

Neither say that the war is part of the proxy conflict, but that the war brought the proxy conflict to Israel.

3140: 1200: 929:, not against governments, ruling parties, militaries, offices, or other non-state entities. When you attack a 488: 3414:

shared to announce the attacks, it's probably the closest thing to the definitive "why they said they did it".

137:. There's a clear consensus that moving is needed to fix the year in the title. I see a consensus in favor of 896:

Hamas built their terrorist infrastructure for the war in civilian areas to use Palestinians as human shields

5336: 4786:"Hamas Releases Memo Explaining Why It Waged War on Israel; Gazans Question Timing, Cite Criticism of Hamas" 3150: 2590: 2388: 2303: 1574: 1537: 1410: 1329: 1073: 1042: 611: 244: 5312:"Iran has pushed its proxies to make trouble for the American military and to pressure Israel and the West" 483:

Agreed. I don’t think including the year is necessary, but at a minimum it should not just be titled 2023.

4917: 4826: 4335: 2759: 2730: 2299: 2142: 2096: 1679:

If anyone considers this bludgeoning I will promptly redact this post, but I would like to point out that

1475: 1453: 1432: 1321: 1017: 678: 584: 532: 524: 339: 299: 226: 216: 3306:

with Iran and burnishing resistance credentials. These are some of the sources which discuss the reasons

307: 5871: 5861: 5832: 5814: 5779: 5758: 5747: 5728: 5703: 5646: 5548: 5492: 5442: 5409: 5395: 5377: 5344: 5294: 5260: 5231: 5173: 5159: 5129: 5115: 5071: 5027: 5011: 4972: 4957: 4644: 4357: 4290: 4258: 4254: 4225: 4215: 3820: 3389: 3307: 3282: 3112: 3062: 3028: 2877: 2845: 2446: 2358: 2318: 2261: 2232: 2200: 2130: 1945: 1930: 1615: 1569:

Disambiguation is not needed, because there is no other article with the base title "Israel—Hamas war".

1025: 995: 973: 915: 853: 775: 711: 689: 629: 457: 407: 365: 325: 121: 5622: 4346: 4331: 2157:"Northern Gaza, occupied-Palestine" I think most of the world would think it was a stretch to say that 1680: 1511: 1402: 1300: 1138: 1008: 528: 316: 138: 134: 3502:

I completely agree with this comment. In the version I suggested both sets of reasons are attributed.

2818:. None of the Western media reports I have seen so far provide a copy of the statement or link to it. 5899: 5846: 5689: 5632: 5506: 5478: 5424: 5362: 5321: 5275: 5246: 5217: 5144: 5101: 5083: 5056: 5045: 4865: 4276: 4243: 4197: 4189: 3375: 3048: 2661: 2628: 2555: 2492: 2210:

That editor is temporarily topic-banned from Israel-Palestine articles so you'll be waiting a while.

1759: 1731: 1727: 1711: 1597: 1316:

there may have been other Israel–Hamas wars as long as no other article is titled "Israel–Hamas war"

1308: 1239: 1013: 947: 842: 796: 670: 474: 445: 294:, concision is preferred over unnecessary precision. not only is there still no other article titled 2925:

We ended up having material about the document in two different places. I have now consolidated it.

2350:

It's a newsorg and presumed reliable (even if biased). Also not too difficult to find other sources

1840: 1587: 5903: 5879: 5865: 5850: 5836: 5822: 5803: 5783: 5766: 5751: 5736: 5707: 5693: 5650: 5636: 5552: 5537: 5510: 5496: 5482: 5446: 5428: 5413: 5399: 5381: 5366: 5348: 5325: 5298: 5279: 5264: 5250: 5235: 5221: 5177: 5163: 5148: 5133: 5119: 5105: 5075: 5060: 5031: 5015: 5001: 4983: 4961: 4921: 4902: 4898: 4888: 4872: 4852: 4834: 4475: 4376: 4361: 4339: 4294: 4280: 4266: 4247: 4233: 4219: 4201: 4165: 3846: 3828: 3810: 3795: 3780: 3571: 3545: 3526: 3511: 3497: 3480: 3466: 3450: 3435: 3397: 3379: 3365: 3353: 3338: 3286: 3271: 3254: 3232: 3222:

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/28/world/middleeast/oct-7-attacks-hamas-israel-sexual-violence.html

3211: 3162: 3158: 3144: 3136: 3116: 3102: 3066: 3052: 3032: 3008: 2920: 2897: 2881: 2867: 2849: 2832: 2792: 2777: 2763: 2749: 2734: 2718: 2682: 2665: 2649: 2645: 2635: 2606: 2602: 2579: 2562: 2538: 2518: 2512: 2499: 2470: 2450: 2436: 2418: 2403: 2378: 2362: 2344: 2323: 2285: 2266: 2237: 2219: 2205: 2170: 2146: 2124: 2100: 2082: 2064: 2043: 2005: 1969: 1949: 1934: 1905: 1873: 1811: 1807: 1794: 1767: 1747: 1715: 1692: 1671: 1654: 1650: 1637: 1619: 1601: 1578: 1564: 1541: 1505: 1480: 1458: 1437: 1414: 1396: 1393: 1367: 1350: 1333: 1166: 1129: 1125: 1096: 1092: 1077: 1063: 1046: 1029: 999: 981: 963: 941: 930: 920: 879: 857: 824: 808: 783: 753: 736: 715: 694: 651: 633: 615: 588: 569: 554: 536: 511: 492: 484: 478: 461: 436: 411: 393: 369: 343: 329: 274: 248: 230: 193: 154: 150: 3238:

What is your point? Besides, this NYT report has been accused of potential testimony manipulation.

1281: 124:

after discussing it on the closer's talk page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

5801: 5535: 4850: 4736: 4696: 4567: 4527: 4372: 3791: 3522: 3493: 3478: 3448: 3411: 3349: 3246: 3203: 3191: 3093: 2999: 2823: 2788: 2773: 2745: 2709: 2678: 2575: 2468: 2374: 1902: 1869: 1790: 1743: 1570: 1533: 1406: 1325: 1069: 1038: 939: 877: 749: 607: 565: 550: 303: 287: 256: 240: 261:

When I search for sources using "Israel-Hamas war" I get things like the pro Israel lobby group

3079:: Yeah, they are two different things, but it's true that the writing could be improved. Maybe: 1234: 4913: 4161: 3842: 3776: 3541: 3507: 3431: 3334: 3267: 3228: 2946: 2942: 2938: 2931: 2863: 2755: 2726: 2534: 2432: 2399: 2281: 2166: 2154: 2138: 2137:

One anonymous report in a biased publication citing anonymous people doesn't even come close.

2120: 2107: 2092: 2060: 2039: 1965: 1897:

Please refer to the existing requested move instead of starting a new conversation. Thanks. -

1847:

between Israel and Hamas", the second test would find those, whereas the first one wouldn't.

1667: 1560: 1510:

But the key point is, none of them are titled "Israel–Hamas war". That title actually already

1468: 1446: 1425: 1312: 1059: 674: 580: 520: 507: 389: 335: 291: 270: 222: 212: 5870:

You're mistaken to say the consensus is against anyone. There is no consensus here. Not yet.

2597:

fighters have been killed, which means that around 2/3rds of all deaths have been civilians.

5857: 5828: 5809: 5775: 5743: 5724: 5716: 5699: 5642: 5544: 5518: 5488: 5438: 5405: 5391: 5373: 5340: 5290: 5256: 5227: 5169: 5155: 5125: 5111: 5067: 5023: 5007: 4953: 4884: 4353: 4286: 4211: 3806: 3567: 3462: 3278: 3108: 3072: 3058: 3024: 2916: 2893: 2873: 2841: 2442: 2414: 2354: 2340: 2314: 2272: 2257: 2228: 2215: 2196: 2078: 2001: 1955: 1941: 1926: 1857: 1755: 1611: 1363: 1021: 991: 959: 911: 849: 792: 767: 707: 685: 647: 625: 453: 432: 422: 403: 377: 361: 321: 5895: 5842: 5685: 5628: 5502: 5474: 5463: 5420: 5358: 5317: 5271: 5242: 5213: 5140: 5097: 5052: 4997: 4938: 4858: 4272: 4239: 4193: 4185: 3371: 3076: 3044: 2657: 2621: 2548: 2526: 2485: 2394:

about the October 7 attack, calling the attackers "elite young men" and "heroic knights".

2070: 1989: 1707: 1593: 1501: 470: 2391: 4844:

would be anything between 49 and 51 years ago. So, I'm fine with the current wording. —

2965:

of primary source material requires a reliable secondary source for that interpretation.

766:- Being concise is important and upon further research I don't see a need for a date. ~ 5792: 4894: 4814: 3260: 3154: 3132: 2641: 2640:

Yes indeed, the 2/3rd parts is synthesis. That does not need to be added specifically.

2613: 2598: 2507: 1803: 1646: 1377: 1149: 1121: 1088: 146: 452:, yet those respective articles do not have a year in front of their article's title. 5796: 5720: 5530: 4978: 4845: 4368: 4327: 3787: 3518: 3489: 3473: 3443: 3420:

There must be a full transcript and translation SOMEWHERE but I've not had much luck.

3385: 3360: 3345: 3242: 3199: 3089: 2995: 2855: 2819: 2784: 2769: 2741: 2705: 2674: 2617: 2571: 2463: 2370: 2187: 1898: 1865: 1786: 1739: 1275: 951: 934: 872: 832: 745: 561: 546: 384:

aimed at it, because when I search using "Israel-Hamas war" I get 60% Al Jazeera. )

188: 5339:

except the latter doesn't exist, so Iran US relations or some other relevant place.

5006:

As editors we don't take anything, we reflect RS, and zero RS have made that claim.

2968:

A primary source may be used on Knowledge only to make straightforward, descriptive

1341:- I think disambiguation is unneccessary, as media covers with the name without it. 1222: 899:

Hamas planned the mass murder and sexual violence against Israeli civilians on Oct 7

4759:"Text of the speech by Ismail Haniyeh, on the first day of Operation Al-Aqsa Flood" 4667:"Text of the speech by Ismail Haniyeh, on the first day of Operation Al-Aqsa Flood" 4616:"Text of the speech by Ismail Haniyeh, on the first day of Operation Al-Aqsa Flood" 4590:"Text of the speech by Ismail Haniyeh, on the first day of Operation Al-Aqsa Flood" 4498:"Text of the speech by Ismail Haniyeh, on the first day of Operation Al-Aqsa Flood" 4471:"Hamas deputy chief anticipates hostages will be swapped for Palestinian prisoners" 4439: 4157: 3838: 3772: 3552: 3537: 3503: 3427: 3407: 3330: 3263: 3224: 3195: 2954: 2859: 2544: 2530: 2428: 2395: 2277: 2162: 2116: 2056: 2035: 1961: 1687: 1663: 1556: 1307:, there is no other article whose title contains the phrase "Israel–Hamas war", so 1269: 1055: 838: 731: 503: 399: 385: 266: 1255: 1144: 4992:

Nonsense, even if you take Iran's statements about revenge for Soleimani as BS.

3819:, I have, likewise, struggled to see it clearly in the main body of the article. 527:, but I would also support the proposed as more accurate than the current title. 5459: 4880: 4712:"Exclusive: Qatar seeking Israel-Hamas deal to free 50 hostages and 3-day truce" 4543:"Exclusive: Qatar seeking Israel-Hamas deal to free 50 hostages and 3-day truce" 3816: 3802: 3563: 3458: 2958:

may be used in Knowledge, but only with care, because it is easy to misuse them.

2912: 2889: 2815: 2410: 2336: 2211: 2182:

Knowledge:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 243#Hind Khoudary Middle East Eye

2074: 2049: 2012: 1997: 1359: 1296: 1175: 955: 643: 428: 182:

form of the title but with no consensus as to the other topics, and there is an

46:

If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the

5679:

between Iran and Israel—typically fought in Lebanon and Syria—to Israeli soil."

4943:

There are no sources saying that this war in Gaza is part of a proxy conflict.

2192:

to this conversation, they seem to have long term knowledge about this source.

1887:

Why isn´t the name changed to 2023-2024 (or even 2023-present) Israel-Hamas war

1264: 1054:

At this point, my perception is that the title still reflects the common name.

4993: 1497: 1286: 1170: 1155: 4693:"Hamas says it has enough Israeli captives to free all Palestinian prisoners" 4524:"Hamas says it has enough Israeli captives to free all Palestinian prisoners" 3457:

flare-ups, and Palestinian prisoners are true and independently attested to.

2224:

My mistake, I thought that had ended at AE, but still has a couple of weeks.

1211: 1196: 5454: 1249: 5841:

Except they do. Your novel personal opinion to the contrary is irrelevant.

187:

requested moves such as regarding changing the "Israel–Hamas war" wording.

1463:

Nevermind this previous statement I have now discovered that ] is called a

887:: re: "their constant mention of Hamas is only war propaganda" is absurd. 5212:

In response to this, all I see are frivolous attempts at hair-splitting.

2692: 1291: 1191: 820: 703: 262: 3417:

Al Jazerra and France 24 dubbed into English overlapping 1 minute grabs.

1205: 4716: 4547: 4435:"Seven days of terror that shook the world and changed the Middle East" 1226: 925:

Why writing all this nonsense? Just accept that international wars are

360:, but it did not disambiguate the three articles I gave as an example. 5487:

Well, consensus is against you right now, so suggest you open an RFC.

5390:"No evidence yet of Iran link to Hamas attack, says Israeli military" 1181: 1068:

The COMMONNAME is actually just "Israel–Hamas war", without the year.

5664:"Many observers, however, see Iran's primary goal more as waging a ' 5434:

Iran supporting Hamas afterwards by definition turns it into a proxy

2586:

Lede addition suggestion, 20-30% of all Hamas fighters killed so far

744:– It is concise and identifiable enough without the disambiguation. 2129:

It will be appropriate once the sourcing meets the requirements of

902:

Hamas initiated and is directing the terrorism and war they planned

579:, as it's factually no longer 2023, and the war is still going on. 3517:

didn't think of the Ukraine or Iraq as possible suicide missions.

3833:

These opinions are discussed in the 3rd and 4th paragraph of the

2872:

It's a post fact elaboration of their reasons for the incursion.

1734:, and Parham wiki; and per the results of some search tests; see 1016:. Links at the top of the page are sufficient. There is no other 298:, but even if there was, this article is unequivocally still the 4238:

Sure we can, if that statement is covered by secondary sources.

839:

it will be better to keep this consistent with similar articles.

4946:

You also claimed that your edit is reflecting the sources here

4271:

For sure, but good luck getting editors here to agree to that.

2570:

include size" is 1,346,349 bytes out of the 2,097,152 maximum.

2135:"Any exceptional claim requires multiple high-quality sources." 1645:

because to make things simple, the war is still going in 2024.

1532:, which dropped the year for the same reasons I have outlined. 950:? Are RS calling it "Israel-Hamas war" or "Gaza war"? Remember 265:, and only a bizarre little assortment of any other resources. 4970:. Also, not sure why the one-state solution part was removed. 1960:

Because we cannot agree on who or what Israel is at war with.

990:

The discussion is about disambiguation, not the generic name.

893:

Hamas built the terrorist infrastructure being used in the war

624:

The discussion is about disambiguation, not the generic name.

402:

The discussion is about disambiguation, not the generic name.

25: 2308:

Any exceptional claim requires multiple high-quality sources.

1401:

But none of them were called "Israel–Hamas war". There is no

702:, there is only one war with this title, unlike for example, 638:

No, the discussion is about whether to rename the article to

5797: 5531: 4846: 3474: 3444: 3329:, so I'd like to understand which policies it was based on. 2464: 1841:

2023/24 Israel-Hamas conflict: UK and international response

935: 873: 358:

Soviet Union has had other military conflicts in Afghanistan

334:

but there have been previous wars between Israel and Hamas.

5286:

We can say that this is part of Iran proxy war with US per

1263:, etc. For the record, there were also a few outliers: the 5727:

you have not achieved any kind of consensus here. At all.

2529:

it's used for debugging, so there may be a reason for it.

4710:

Mills, Andrew; Hassan, Ahmed Mohamed (15 November 2023).

4541:

Mills, Andrew; Hassan, Ahmed Mohamed (15 November 2023).

5080:

You have an interesting definition of "do not support".

4255:

as discussed in this short summary report from CBS News.

2161:

is not currently "occupied", it's full of IDF soldiers.

1358:

no brainer. The war is ongoing and it's no longer 2023.

1303:

is not ambiguous; it already redirects here. Similar to

4947: 3326: 2934: 2926: 2808: 1424:(Without disambiguation), per what Parham wiki said. – 165: 5419:

still a US-USSR proxy conflict. Drop the red herring.

2937:

all refs linking to the Hamas document itself, citing

2620:? If not, I feel all of this should be added. Cheers! 2180:: Whiteout comment on the source, I found this on RSN 5658:

Some explicit mentions in bold for your convenience:

1405:, so how can this title be described as "ambigious"? 4257:

I would expect the wiki article to make that clear.

3261:

https://www.hamas-massacre.net/categories/mass-rapes

3183:

Subsequent comments should be made in a new section.

2310:" This is especially important in a CTopics article. 448:, and particularly because of Parham's comment that 4207: 2989:practice to add a link to the primary source as an 2656:Don't see a need to get that granular in the lede. 2547:: By any chance, do you know if it's still needed? 1853:

intitle:Israel intitle:Hamas intitle:war -wikipedia

5473:You simply have zero arguments against inclusion. 3536:do not allow us to make this distinction for now. 207:A logical and reasonable proposal. Second choice: 4399: 4397: 4395: 4393: 2810:. A copy of the original statement can be viewed 4840:It was 50 years nearly to the day. In contrast, 4732:"What we know about the captives taken by Hamas" 4563:"What we know about the captives taken by Hamas" 4464: 4462: 4460: 4458: 4428: 4426: 4424: 4422: 1467:such. But I still support Parham's position. – 603:Spillover of the Israel–Gaza war (2023–present) 5673:"Already, Hamas has succeeded in bringing the 4326:whether their own claims of their motives are 2479:{{#invoke:cite news}} vs simply {{cite news}}? 1120:Are my preferred order of preferences... ~ 🦝 3488:attributed properly wherever it is stuck in. 3186:A summary of the conclusions reached follows. 1996:article as an example of Israeli war crimes. 8: 5795:is on the editor(s) wishing to add stuff. — 5458:is defined as an armed conflict between two 2441:Nothing wrong with Middle East Eye, either. 4645:"Why did Hamas attack Israel, and why now?" 2974:verified by any educated person with access 1785:moved here from Move header at the top, by 519:. I prefer without the disambiguation, per 2462:all UK government documents unreliable? — 2385:Council for European Palestinian Relations 110:The following is a closed discussion of a 4639: 4637: 700:Support this title without disambiguation 5684:Your removals are borderline vandalism. 4134: 4131: 4129: 4126: 4124: 4121: 4119: 4116: 4114: 4111: 4109: 4106: 4104: 4101: 4099: 4096: 4094: 4091: 4089: 4086: 4084: 4081: 4079: 4076: 4074: 4071: 4069: 4066: 4064: 4061: 4059: 4056: 4054: 4051: 4049: 4046: 4044: 4041: 4039: 4036: 4034: 4031: 4029: 4026: 4024: 4021: 4019: 4016: 4014: 4011: 4009: 4006: 4004: 4001: 3999: 3996: 3985: 3983: 3980: 3978: 3975: 3973: 3970: 3968: 3965: 3963: 3960: 3958: 3955: 3953: 3950: 3948: 3945: 3943: 3940: 3938: 3935: 3933: 3930: 3928: 3925: 3923: 3920: 3918: 3915: 3913: 3910: 3908: 3905: 3903: 3875:Drawing Israel into a quagmire 1/3 (CBS) 3759: 3757: 3754: 3752: 3749: 3747: 3744: 3742: 3739: 3737: 3734: 3731: 3728: 3725: 3722: 3719: 3717: 3714: 3712: 3709: 3707: 3704: 3700: 3697: 3694: 3691: 3688: 3685: 3682: 3679: 3676: 3673: 3669: 3666: 3663: 3660: 3658: 3655: 3652: 3640: 3637: 3634: 3631: 3628: 3625: 3622: 3619: 3616: 3613: 3609: 3606: 3603: 3600: 3598: 3595: 3593: 3590: 3588: 3325:My attempt to improve the lede has been 2249:: I think the above referenced incident 354:Russia has invaded Ukraine several times 4410:was invoked but never defined (see the 4389: 1992:a reliable source? I wanted to include 5433: 4841: 4822: 4818: 3866:Palestinian desperation: 2/3 (AJ, NYT) 1735: 449: 44:Do not edit the contents of this page. 5203:brought the proxy war to Israeli soil 4825:fifty years prior to 7 October 2023. 3872:Resolving internal tension: 1/3 (NYT) 3038:"Throughout the war, there have been 1843:" from the House of Commons Library. 350:Poland has been invaded several times 7: 5205:. Tehran's brinkmanship with Israel 4893:I agree and made the edit just now. 3177:The following discussion is closed. 1913:The following discussion is closed. 129:The result of the move request was: 4402: 1835:intitle:Israel–Hamas_war -wikipedia 1320:is demonstrably as notable as this 907:Hamas is central to this conflict. 4469:Pacchiani, Luca (7 October 2023). 4210:for elaboration on Hamas reasons. 3894: 3579: 2807:I have added a paragraph on this: 2390:. More recently he was positively 24: 5466:, supported by an external power. 5462:in which at least one party is a 3406:There was an 11 minute speech by 3153:, as stated on the file details. 1523:R from unnecessary disambiguation 1516:Israel–Hamas war (disambiguation) 4784:Khoury, Jack (21 January 2024). 3860:Derailing the normalisation: 3/3 3292:The discussion above is closed. 2903: 2387:, an organisation tied to Hamas 1975:The discussion above is closed. 1878:The discussion above is closed. 177:, etc. For context, there was a 29: 4208:#Hamas statement released today 4192:) 12:27, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 2952:Primary sources that have been 2369:source and it looks due to me. 1782:) 07:33, 19 January 2024 (UTC) 640:Israel–Hamas war (2023–present) 601:with a separate article titled 175:Yemeni civil war (2014–present) 166:Israel–Hamas war (2023–present) 143:Israel–Hamas war (2023–present) 4952:Waiting for your self-revert. 3301:Reasons for attack in the lede 2803:Hamas statement released today 1339:Support without disambiguation 764:Support without disambiguation 742:Support without disambiguation 721:Support without disambiguation 599:Israel–Gaza war (2023–present) 219:) 20:41, 12 January 2024 (UTC) 103:Requested move 12 January 2024 1: 3863:Mending fences with Iran: 3/3 3426:07:26, 25 January 2024 (UTC) 1726:(without disambiguation) per 669:(without disambiguation) per 184:ongoing unofficial discussion 5904:01:43, 2 February 2024 (UTC) 5880:03:43, 29 January 2024 (UTC) 5866:10:32, 27 January 2024 (UTC) 5851:09:16, 27 January 2024 (UTC) 5837:11:15, 26 January 2024 (UTC) 5823:04:59, 26 January 2024 (UTC) 5804:20:45, 25 January 2024 (UTC) 5784:14:22, 25 January 2024 (UTC) 5767:14:19, 25 January 2024 (UTC) 5752:12:01, 25 January 2024 (UTC) 5737:09:57, 25 January 2024 (UTC) 5708:13:12, 23 January 2024 (UTC) 5694:12:50, 23 January 2024 (UTC) 5651:09:34, 23 January 2024 (UTC) 5637:04:58, 23 January 2024 (UTC) 5553:20:03, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5538:17:12, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5511:16:42, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5497:16:17, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5483:16:15, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5447:16:06, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5429:15:53, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5414:15:48, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5400:15:47, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5382:15:42, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5367:15:34, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5349:15:26, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5326:15:14, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5299:15:08, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5280:15:12, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5265:15:02, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5251:14:52, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5236:13:59, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5222:13:54, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5178:12:29, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5164:12:12, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5149:11:59, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5134:10:04, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5120:09:46, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 5106:17:16, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 5076:13:43, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 5061:12:24, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 5032:08:15, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 5016:07:55, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 5002:23:28, 20 January 2024 (UTC) 4984:21:02, 20 January 2024 (UTC) 4962:11:05, 20 January 2024 (UTC) 4922:15:52, 31 January 2024 (UTC) 4903:09:29, 31 January 2024 (UTC) 4889:20:04, 25 January 2024 (UTC) 4873:17:08, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 4853:14:35, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 4835:14:26, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 4377:09:42, 25 January 2024 (UTC) 4362:10:59, 23 January 2024 (UTC) 4340:10:57, 23 January 2024 (UTC) 4295:10:53, 23 January 2024 (UTC) 4281:06:33, 23 January 2024 (UTC) 4267:06:18, 23 January 2024 (UTC) 4248:05:21, 23 January 2024 (UTC) 4234:02:26, 23 January 2024 (UTC) 4220:12:31, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 4202:12:27, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 4166:20:05, 19 January 2024 (UTC) 3869:Reasserting power: 1/3 (CBS) 3847:08:06, 18 January 2024 (UTC) 3829:02:32, 18 January 2024 (UTC) 3811:01:21, 18 January 2024 (UTC) 3796:23:30, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 3781:22:21, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 3572:22:09, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 3546:11:10, 16 January 2024 (UTC) 3527:10:03, 15 January 2024 (UTC) 3512:08:35, 15 January 2024 (UTC) 3498:08:07, 15 January 2024 (UTC) 3481:09:34, 15 January 2024 (UTC) 3467:02:54, 15 January 2024 (UTC) 3451:23:24, 14 January 2024 (UTC) 3436:07:26, 25 January 2024 (UTC) 3398:07:42, 15 January 2024 (UTC) 3380:22:07, 14 January 2024 (UTC) 3366:21:33, 14 January 2024 (UTC) 3354:21:24, 14 January 2024 (UTC) 3339:20:31, 14 January 2024 (UTC) 3287:17:29, 29 January 2024 (UTC) 3272:17:15, 29 January 2024 (UTC) 3255:09:52, 28 January 2024 (UTC) 3233:07:31, 28 January 2024 (UTC) 3212:23:46, 29 January 2024 (UTC) 3163:09:56, 23 January 2024 (UTC) 3145:07:21, 23 January 2024 (UTC) 3117:20:13, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 3103:20:11, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 3067:12:31, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 3053:12:03, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 3033:10:10, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 3009:20:00, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 2921:13:40, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 2898:13:05, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 2882:11:17, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 2868:22:55, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 2850:19:48, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 2833:17:53, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 2793:11:29, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 2778:22:32, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 2764:19:35, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 2750:19:25, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 2735:18:59, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 2719:18:54, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 2683:18:33, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 2666:17:19, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 2650:18:22, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 2636:17:06, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 2607:16:57, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 2580:02:46, 22 January 2024 (UTC) 2563:19:56, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 2539:19:40, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 2519:13:44, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 2500:03:06, 21 January 2024 (UTC) 2471:17:16, 20 January 2024 (UTC) 2451:22:02, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2437:21:52, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2419:21:47, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2404:21:26, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2379:16:14, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2363:14:16, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2345:08:41, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2324:09:29, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2286:04:48, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2267:04:26, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2238:09:20, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2220:08:39, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2206:04:13, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2171:04:04, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2147:14:02, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2125:03:58, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2101:00:06, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2083:08:45, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2065:04:19, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2044:03:54, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 2006:23:54, 16 January 2024 (UTC) 1984:Is Middle East Eye reliable? 1970:06:49, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 1950:18:45, 16 January 2024 (UTC) 1935:18:28, 16 January 2024 (UTC) 1906:06:11, 19 January 2024 (UTC) 1874:02:31, 19 January 2024 (UTC) 1812:08:04, 19 January 2024 (UTC) 1795:07:49, 19 January 2024 (UTC) 1768:02:16, 19 January 2024 (UTC) 1748:22:38, 18 January 2024 (UTC) 1716:21:48, 18 January 2024 (UTC) 1693:12:00, 18 January 2024 (UTC) 1672:07:54, 18 January 2024 (UTC) 1655:18:08, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 1638:15:16, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 1620:10:25, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 1602:09:46, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 1579:06:17, 18 January 2024 (UTC) 1565:16:04, 16 January 2024 (UTC) 1542:06:17, 18 January 2024 (UTC) 1506:13:43, 16 January 2024 (UTC) 1481:10:58, 16 January 2024 (UTC) 1459:10:48, 16 January 2024 (UTC) 1438:10:43, 16 January 2024 (UTC) 1415:06:17, 18 January 2024 (UTC) 1397:07:15, 16 January 2024 (UTC) 1368:02:52, 16 January 2024 (UTC) 1351:20:46, 15 January 2024 (UTC) 1334:05:26, 15 January 2024 (UTC) 1130:21:21, 14 January 2024 (UTC) 1097:12:51, 14 January 2024 (UTC) 1078:06:23, 18 January 2024 (UTC) 1064:09:16, 14 January 2024 (UTC) 1047:01:55, 14 January 2024 (UTC) 1030:01:10, 14 January 2024 (UTC) 1012:without disambiguation, per 1000:23:36, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 982:19:52, 19 January 2024 (UTC) 964:02:57, 16 January 2024 (UTC) 942:19:13, 15 January 2024 (UTC) 921:23:12, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 880:22:31, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 867:any form of "Israel–Hamas", 858:23:35, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 829:2021 Israel–Palestine crisis 809:22:19, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 784:20:15, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 754:14:07, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 737:12:46, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 716:10:39, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 695:10:13, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 652:06:27, 17 January 2024 (UTC) 634:10:10, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 616:09:54, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 589:07:00, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 570:22:23, 15 January 2024 (UTC) 555:05:33, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 537:04:47, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 512:04:44, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 493:20:02, 15 January 2024 (UTC) 479:22:20, 12 January 2024 (UTC) 462:21:43, 12 January 2024 (UTC) 437:21:20, 12 January 2024 (UTC) 412:09:52, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 394:04:52, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 370:21:11, 12 January 2024 (UTC) 344:21:01, 12 January 2024 (UTC) 330:20:46, 12 January 2024 (UTC) 275:04:48, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 249:02:01, 13 January 2024 (UTC) 231:15:54, 14 January 2024 (UTC) 209:Israel–Hamas war (2023–2024) 194:20:33, 12 January 2024 (UTC) 155:02:38, 20 January 2024 (UTC) 4647:. CBS News. 25 October 2023 3576:Okay, so here's the change. 3388:- absolutely support this. 2484:massive page size. Cheers! 1832:The first test I tried was 1776:The Great Mule of Eupatoria 1530:Russian invasion of Ukraine 1305:Russian invasion of Ukraine 1035:Support with disambiguation 819:The titles of the articles 444:without disambiguation per 320:redirects to this article. 312:Russian invasion of Ukraine 171:War in Sudan (2023–present) 5936: 5333:Iran-Israel proxy conflict 4842:approximately 50 years ago 3040:widespread global protests 1893:SEE CURRENT REQUESTED MOVE 1607: 1528:. This is very similar to 1285:calls it "War in Israel"; 382:Search engine optimisation 4819:exactly fifty years prior 4813:The lede states that the 4809:Call me pedantic, but... 3294:Please do not modify it. 3277:Another pointless edit. 3180:Please do not modify it. 2352:reporting the same thing 1977:Please do not modify it. 1940:Being dealt with above. 1915:Please do not modify it. 1880:Please do not modify it. 1858:Israel-Hamas War of 2023 1704:(without disambiguation) 442:Support Israel–Hamas war 117:Please do not modify it. 3019:International isolation 2025:the sources to include. 1279:use "Israel–Gaza war"; 5337:Iran-US proxy conflict 4763:Crescent International 4671:Crescent International 4620:Crescent International 4594:Crescent International 4502:Crescent International 1662:, the war is ongoing. 1107:Example (2023–present) 890:Hamas governs the area 5894:Try to remain civil. 2930:Note that yesterday, 1104:with disambiguation. 161:2023 Israel–Hamas war 42:of past discussions. 18:Talk:Israel–Hamas war 5774:is not an argument. 5303:...and with Israel. 4406:The named reference 1633:That Tired Tarantula 1494:Gaza War (2008–2009) 5772:WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS 4476:The Times of Israel 2991:ancillary reference 2970:statements of facts 2955:reputably published 1850:Test two was this: 931:sovereign territory 825:The Big Bang Theory 221:added second choice 5521:, also because of 3815:Very good point, @ 3412:Al-Qassam Brigades 2982: 2505:I agree with this 2020:It won't give the 1916: 1802:for some decades. 1514:, and there is no 1110:xample (2023-2024) 869:support "Gaza War" 304:Invasion of Poland 4827:SaintPaulOfTarsus 4699:. 7 October 2023. 4530:. 7 October 2023. 4142: 4141: 3835:Hamas motivations 3767: 3766: 3101: 3007: 2980: 2932:User:Coretheapple 2858:what did it say? 2831: 2717: 1914: 1798: 1797: 974:Shankar Sivarajan 308:Soviet–Afghan War 233: 100: 99: 54: 53: 48:current talk page 5927: 5872:MatthewDalhousie 5815:MatthewDalhousie 5799: 5759:MatthewDalhousie 5729:MatthewDalhousie 5533: 5335:article and the 5207:spread from Gaza 4942: 4869: 4862: 4848: 4801: 4800: 4798: 4796: 4781: 4775: 4774: 4772: 4770: 4765:. 9 October 2023 4755: 4749: 4748: 4746: 4744: 4728: 4722: 4721: 4707: 4701: 4700: 4689: 4683: 4682: 4680: 4678: 4673:. 9 October 2023 4663: 4657: 4656: 4654: 4652: 4641: 4632: 4631: 4629: 4627: 4622:. 9 October 2023 4612: 4606: 4605: 4603: 4601: 4596:. 9 October 2023 4586: 4580: 4579: 4577: 4575: 4559: 4553: 4552: 4538: 4532: 4531: 4520: 4514: 4513: 4511: 4509: 4504:. 9 October 2023 4494: 4488: 4487: 4485: 4483: 4466: 4453: 4452: 4450: 4448: 4443:. Anadolu Agency 4430: 4417: 4416: 4415: 4409: 4401: 4350: 4259:MatthewDalhousie 4226:MatthewDalhousie 3895: 3821:MatthewDalhousie 3580: 3556: 3476: 3446: 3390:MatthewDalhousie 3182: 3127:War map source ? 3096: 3092: 3002: 2998: 2911: 2907: 2906: 2826: 2822: 2712: 2708: 2632: 2625: 2559: 2552: 2515: 2510: 2496: 2489: 2466: 2322: 2304:WP:EXTRAORDINARY 2265: 2236: 2204: 2191: 1855: 1837: 1784: 1783: 1756:Israel-Hamas war 1723:Israel–Hamas war 1702:Israel–Hamas war 1681:Israel–Hamas war 1636: 1634: 1553:Israel-Hamas War 1527: 1521: 1478: 1473: 1456: 1451: 1435: 1430: 1422:Israel–Hamas war 1403:Israel–Hamas war 1391: 1384: 1301:Israel–Hamas war 1139:Israel–Hamas war 1009:Israel–Hamas war 1007:Support move to 937: 919: 875: 840: 805: 799: 693: 667:Israel–Hamas war 348:It is true, but 317:Israel–Hamas war 296:Israel–Hamas war 284:Israel–Hamas war 220: 168: 139:Israel–Hamas war 135:Israel–Hamas war 119: 81: 56: 55: 33: 32: 26: 5935: 5934: 5930: 5929: 5928: 5926: 5925: 5924: 5677: 5667: 5464:non-state actor 5084:Foreign Affairs 4982: 4936: 4934: 4867: 4860: 4811: 4806: 4805: 4804: 4794: 4792: 4783: 4782: 4778: 4768: 4766: 4757: 4756: 4752: 4742: 4740: 4730: 4729: 4725: 4709: 4708: 4704: 4691: 4690: 4686: 4676: 4674: 4665: 4664: 4660: 4650: 4648: 4643: 4642: 4635: 4625: 4623: 4614: 4613: 4609: 4599: 4597: 4588: 4587: 4583: 4573: 4571: 4561: 4560: 4556: 4540: 4539: 4535: 4522: 4521: 4517: 4507: 4505: 4496: 4495: 4491: 4481: 4479: 4468: 4467: 4456: 4446: 4444: 4432: 4431: 4420: 4408:aj7oct-invasion 4407: 4405: 4403: 4391: 4344: 4164: 4138: 4136: 4133: 4130: 4128: 4125: 4123: 4120: 4118: 4115: 4113: 4110: 4108: 4105: 4103: 4100: 4098: 4095: 4093: 4090: 4088: 4085: 4083: 4080: 4078: 4075: 4073: 4070: 4068: 4065: 4063: 4060: 4058: 4055: 4053: 4050: 4048: 4045: 4043: 4040: 4038: 4035: 4033: 4030: 4028: 4025: 4023: 4020: 4018: 4015: 4013: 4010: 4008: 4005: 4003: 4000: 3998: 3989: 3987: 3984: 3982: 3979: 3977: 3974: 3972: 3969: 3967: 3964: 3962: 3959: 3957: 3954: 3952: 3949: 3947: 3944: 3942: 3939: 3937: 3934: 3932: 3929: 3927: 3924: 3922: 3919: 3917: 3914: 3912: 3909: 3907: 3904: 3845: 3779: 3763: 3761: 3758: 3756: 3753: 3751: 3748: 3746: 3743: 3741: 3738: 3736: 3733: 3730: 3727: 3724: 3721: 3718: 3716: 3713: 3711: 3708: 3706: 3702: 3699: 3696: 3693: 3690: 3687: 3684: 3681: 3678: 3675: 3671: 3668: 3665: 3662: 3659: 3657: 3654: 3644: 3642: 3639: 3636: 3633: 3630: 3627: 3624: 3621: 3618: 3615: 3611: 3608: 3605: 3602: 3599: 3597: 3594: 3592: 3589: 3550: 3544: 3510: 3337: 3303: 3298: 3297: 3219: 3178: 3171: 3129: 3094: 3021: 3000: 2904: 2902: 2824: 2805: 2710: 2630: 2623: 2588: 2557: 2550: 2537: 2527:Template:Invoke 2513: 2508: 2494: 2487: 2481: 2435: 2402: 2311: 2300:WP:FALSEBALANCE 2254: 2225: 2193: 2185: 1990:Middle East Eye 1986: 1981: 1980: 1919: 1910: 1909: 1908: 1894: 1889: 1884: 1883: 1851: 1833: 1822: 1760:Interstellarity 1670: 1632: 1630: 1600: 1588:Israel–Gaza war 1525: 1519: 1476: 1469: 1466: 1454: 1447: 1444: 1433: 1426: 1385: 1378: 1322:WP:PRIMARYTOPIC 1218:The Independent 1018:WP:PRIMARYTOPIC 908: 807: 803: 798:Red-tailed hawk 797: 682: 679:WP:PRIMARYTOPIC 597:I would prefer 525:WP:PRIMARYTOPIC 300:WP:PRIMARYTOPIC 201: 164: 115: 105: 77: 30: 22: 21: 20: 12: 11: 5: 5933: 5931: 5923: 5922: 5921: 5920: 5919: 5918: 5917: 5916: 5915: 5914: 5913: 5912: 5911: 5910: 5909: 5908: 5907: 5906: 5892: 5891: 5890: 5889: 5888: 5887: 5886: 5885: 5884: 5883: 5882: 5682: 5681: 5680: 5675: 5671: 5665: 5656: 5655: 5654: 5653: 5626: 5625: 5624: 5619: 5614: 5609: 5604: 5592: 5591: 5590: 5589: 5588: 5587: 5586: 5585: 5584: 5583: 5582: 5581: 5580: 5579: 5578: 5577: 5576: 5575: 5574: 5573: 5572: 5571: 5570: 5569: 5568: 5567: 5566: 5565: 5564: 5563: 5562: 5561: 5560: 5559: 5558: 5557: 5556: 5555: 5540: 5515: 5514: 5513: 5471: 5468: 5416: 5402: 5354: 5315: 5314: 5313: 5310: 5307: 5284: 5283: 5282: 5270:want them to. 5210: 5199: 5195: 5187: 5180: 5095: 5094: 5093: 5087: 5049: 5036: 5035: 5034: 5020: 5019: 5018: 4987: 4986: 4976: 4933: 4930: 4929: 4928: 4927: 4926: 4925: 4924: 4909: 4877: 4876: 4875: 4815:Yom Kippur War 4810: 4807: 4803: 4802: 4776: 4750: 4723: 4702: 4684: 4658: 4633: 4607: 4581: 4554: 4533: 4515: 4489: 4454: 4418: 4388: 4387: 4383: 4382: 4381: 4380: 4379: 4364: 4330:for the lede. 4323: 4322: 4321: 4320: 4319: 4318: 4317: 4316: 4315: 4314: 4313: 4312: 4311: 4310: 4309: 4308: 4307: 4306: 4305: 4304: 4303: 4302: 4301: 4300: 4299: 4298: 4297: 4183: 4177: 4171: 4160: 4155: 4154: 4153: 4152: 4151: 4150: 4149: 4148: 4147: 4146: 4145: 4144: 4143: 4140: 4139: 3995: 3993: 3990: 3901: 3899: 3878: 3877: 3876: 3873: 3870: 3867: 3864: 3861: 3854: 3851: 3850: 3849: 3841: 3831: 3783: 3775: 3768: 3765: 3764: 3650: 3648: 3645: 3586: 3584: 3577: 3540: 3533: 3506: 3485: 3484: 3483: 3439: 3438: 3424: 3421: 3418: 3415: 3404: 3403: 3402: 3401: 3400: 3382: 3333: 3302: 3299: 3291: 3290: 3289: 3258: 3257: 3218: 3217: 3216: 3215: 3214: 3173: 3172: 3170: 3167: 3166: 3165: 3137:Stephan rostie 3128: 3125: 3124: 3123: 3122: 3121: 3120: 3119: 3086: 3080: 3055: 3020: 3017: 3016: 3015: 3014: 3013: 3012: 3011: 2986: 2985: 2984: 2978: 2966: 2963:interpretation 2959: 2928: 2886: 2885: 2884: 2852: 2804: 2801: 2800: 2799: 2798: 2797: 2796: 2795: 2780: 2722: 2721: 2702: 2696: 2685: 2669: 2668: 2654: 2653: 2652: 2587: 2584: 2583: 2582: 2567: 2566: 2565: 2533: 2522: 2521: 2480: 2477: 2476: 2475: 2474: 2473: 2455: 2454: 2453: 2439: 2431: 2409:of Knowledge. 2398: 2381: 2348: 2347: 2331: 2330: 2329: 2328: 2327: 2326: 2291: 2290: 2289: 2288: 2244: 2243: 2242: 2241: 2240: 2174: 2173: 2151: 2150: 2149: 2131:WP:EXCEPTIONAL 2114: 2111: 2088: 2087: 2086: 2085: 2052: 2046: 2033: 2030: 2026: 2018: 2015: 1985: 1982: 1974: 1973: 1972: 1958: 1952: 1922: 1920: 1911: 1896: 1895: 1892: 1891: 1890: 1888: 1885: 1877: 1821: 1818: 1817: 1816: 1815: 1814: 1771: 1770: 1750: 1718: 1695: 1674: 1666: 1657: 1640: 1624: 1623: 1622: 1596: 1583: 1582: 1581: 1546: 1545: 1544: 1512:redirects here 1487: 1486: 1485: 1484: 1483: 1464: 1442: 1419: 1418: 1417: 1370: 1353: 1336: 1319: 1133: 1132: 1117: 1116: 1115: 1114: 1111: 1108: 1099: 1082: 1081: 1080: 1049: 1032: 1004: 1003: 1002: 988: 987: 986: 985: 984: 966: 927:against states 905: 904: 903: 900: 897: 894: 891: 862: 861: 860: 847: 846: 845: 836: 817: 801: 786: 756: 739: 718: 697: 659: 658: 657: 656: 655: 654: 619: 618: 591: 574: 573: 572: 539: 514: 497: 496: 495: 485:Svenskbygderna 464: 439: 418: 417: 416: 415: 414: 374: 373: 372: 281: 280: 279: 278: 277: 259: 234: 200: 197: 158: 127: 126: 112:requested move 106: 104: 101: 98: 97: 92: 87: 82: 75: 70: 65: 62: 52: 51: 34: 23: 15: 14: 13: 10: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 5932: 5905: 5901: 5897: 5893: 5881: 5877: 5873: 5869: 5868: 5867: 5863: 5859: 5854: 5853: 5852: 5848: 5844: 5840: 5839: 5838: 5834: 5830: 5826: 5825: 5824: 5820: 5816: 5811: 5807: 5806: 5805: 5802: 5800: 5794: 5790: 5789: 5787: 5786: 5785: 5781: 5777: 5773: 5770: 5769: 5768: 5764: 5760: 5755: 5754: 5753: 5749: 5745: 5740: 5739: 5738: 5734: 5730: 5726: 5722: 5718: 5714: 5713: 5711: 5710: 5709: 5705: 5701: 5697: 5696: 5695: 5691: 5687: 5683: 5678: 5672: 5670: 5663: 5662: 5661: 5660: 5659: 5652: 5648: 5644: 5640: 5639: 5638: 5634: 5630: 5627: 5623: 5620: 5618: 5615: 5613: 5610: 5608: 5605: 5603: 5600: 5599: 5598: 5597: 5596: 5554: 5550: 5546: 5541: 5539: 5536: 5534: 5528: 5524: 5520: 5516: 5512: 5508: 5504: 5500: 5499: 5498: 5494: 5490: 5486: 5485: 5484: 5480: 5476: 5472: 5469: 5467: 5465: 5461: 5457: 5456: 5450: 5449: 5448: 5444: 5440: 5435: 5432: 5431: 5430: 5426: 5422: 5417: 5415: 5411: 5407: 5403: 5401: 5397: 5393: 5389: 5385: 5384: 5383: 5379: 5375: 5370: 5369: 5368: 5364: 5360: 5355: 5352: 5351: 5350: 5346: 5342: 5338: 5334: 5329: 5328: 5327: 5323: 5319: 5316: 5311: 5308: 5305: 5304: 5302: 5301: 5300: 5296: 5292: 5289: 5285: 5281: 5277: 5273: 5268: 5267: 5266: 5262: 5258: 5254: 5253: 5252: 5248: 5244: 5239: 5238: 5237: 5233: 5229: 5225: 5224: 5223: 5219: 5215: 5211: 5208: 5204: 5200: 5196: 5193: 5188: 5186: 5184: 5181: 5179: 5175: 5171: 5167: 5166: 5165: 5161: 5157: 5152: 5151: 5150: 5146: 5142: 5137: 5136: 5135: 5131: 5127: 5123: 5122: 5121: 5117: 5113: 5109: 5108: 5107: 5103: 5099: 5096: 5091: 5088: 5085: 5082: 5081: 5079: 5078: 5077: 5073: 5069: 5064: 5063: 5062: 5058: 5054: 5050: 5048: 5046: 5044: 5042: 5040: 5037: 5033: 5029: 5025: 5021: 5017: 5013: 5009: 5005: 5004: 5003: 4999: 4995: 4991: 4990: 4989: 4988: 4985: 4980: 4975: 4974: 4969: 4966: 4965: 4964: 4963: 4959: 4955: 4950: 4948: 4944: 4940: 4931: 4923: 4919: 4915: 4910: 4906: 4905: 4904: 4900: 4896: 4892: 4891: 4890: 4886: 4882: 4878: 4874: 4871: 4870: 4864: 4863: 4856: 4855: 4854: 4851: 4849: 4843: 4839: 4838: 4837: 4836: 4832: 4828: 4824: 4820: 4816: 4808: 4791: 4787: 4780: 4777: 4764: 4760: 4754: 4751: 4739: 4738: 4733: 4727: 4724: 4719: 4718: 4713: 4706: 4703: 4698: 4694: 4688: 4685: 4672: 4668: 4662: 4659: 4646: 4640: 4638: 4634: 4621: 4617: 4611: 4608: 4595: 4591: 4585: 4582: 4570: 4569: 4564: 4558: 4555: 4550: 4549: 4544: 4537: 4534: 4529: 4525: 4519: 4516: 4503: 4499: 4493: 4490: 4478: 4477: 4472: 4465: 4463: 4461: 4459: 4455: 4442: 4441: 4436: 4429: 4427: 4425: 4423: 4419: 4413: 4400: 4398: 4396: 4394: 4390: 4386: 4378: 4374: 4370: 4365: 4363: 4359: 4355: 4348: 4343: 4342: 4341: 4337: 4333: 4329: 4324: 4296: 4292: 4288: 4284: 4283: 4282: 4278: 4274: 4270: 4269: 4268: 4264: 4260: 4256: 4251: 4250: 4249: 4245: 4241: 4237: 4236: 4235: 4231: 4227: 4223: 4222: 4221: 4217: 4213: 4209: 4205: 4204: 4203: 4199: 4195: 4191: 4187: 4184: 4182: 4178: 4176: 4172: 4169: 4168: 4167: 4163: 4159: 4156: 3994: 3991: 3900: 3897: 3896: 3893: 3892: 3891: 3890: 3889: 3888: 3887: 3886: 3885: 3884: 3883: 3882: 3879: 3874: 3871: 3868: 3865: 3862: 3859: 3858: 3855: 3852: 3848: 3844: 3840: 3836: 3832: 3830: 3826: 3822: 3818: 3814: 3813: 3812: 3808: 3804: 3799: 3798: 3797: 3793: 3789: 3784: 3782: 3778: 3774: 3769: 3760:confrontation 3649: 3646: 3585: 3582: 3581: 3578: 3575: 3574: 3573: 3569: 3565: 3561: 3554: 3549: 3548: 3547: 3543: 3539: 3534: 3530: 3529: 3528: 3524: 3520: 3515: 3514: 3513: 3509: 3505: 3501: 3500: 3499: 3495: 3491: 3486: 3482: 3479: 3477: 3470: 3469: 3468: 3464: 3460: 3455: 3454: 3453: 3452: 3449: 3447: 3437: 3433: 3429: 3425: 3422: 3419: 3416: 3413: 3409: 3405: 3399: 3395: 3391: 3387: 3383: 3381: 3377: 3373: 3369: 3368: 3367: 3364: 3363: 3357: 3356: 3355: 3351: 3347: 3343: 3342: 3341: 3340: 3336: 3332: 3328: 3323: 3319: 3317: 3313: 3309: 3300: 3295: 3288: 3284: 3280: 3276: 3275: 3274: 3273: 3269: 3265: 3262: 3256: 3252: 3248: 3244: 3243:Sameboat - 同舟 3240: 3237: 3236: 3235: 3234: 3230: 3226: 3223: 3213: 3209: 3205: 3201: 3200:Sameboat - 同舟 3197: 3193: 3190:Violation of 3189: 3188: 3187: 3184: 3181: 3175: 3174: 3168: 3164: 3160: 3156: 3152: 3149: 3148: 3147: 3146: 3142: 3138: 3134: 3126: 3118: 3114: 3110: 3106: 3105: 3104: 3100: 3097: 3091: 3087: 3085: 3081: 3078: 3074: 3070: 3069: 3068: 3064: 3060: 3056: 3054: 3050: 3046: 3041: 3037: 3036: 3035: 3034: 3030: 3026: 3018: 3010: 3006: 3003: 2997: 2992: 2987: 2979: 2975: 2971: 2967: 2964: 2960: 2957: 2956: 2951: 2950: 2948: 2944: 2940: 2936: 2933: 2929: 2927: 2924: 2923: 2922: 2918: 2914: 2910: 2901: 2900: 2899: 2895: 2891: 2887: 2883: 2879: 2875: 2871: 2870: 2869: 2865: 2861: 2857: 2853: 2851: 2847: 2843: 2840: 2837: 2836: 2835: 2834: 2830: 2827: 2821: 2817: 2813: 2809: 2802: 2794: 2790: 2786: 2781: 2779: 2775: 2771: 2767: 2766: 2765: 2761: 2757: 2753: 2752: 2751: 2747: 2743: 2739: 2738: 2737: 2736: 2732: 2728: 2720: 2716: 2713: 2707: 2703: 2701: 2697: 2694: 2690: 2686: 2684: 2680: 2676: 2671: 2670: 2667: 2663: 2659: 2655: 2651: 2647: 2643: 2639: 2638: 2637: 2634: 2633: 2627: 2626: 2619: 2615: 2611: 2610: 2609: 2608: 2604: 2600: 2595: 2592: 2585: 2581: 2577: 2573: 2568: 2564: 2561: 2560: 2554: 2553: 2546: 2542: 2541: 2540: 2536: 2532: 2528: 2525:According to 2524: 2523: 2520: 2517: 2516: 2511: 2504: 2503: 2502: 2501: 2498: 2497: 2491: 2490: 2478: 2472: 2469: 2467: 2460: 2456: 2452: 2448: 2444: 2440: 2438: 2434: 2430: 2426: 2422: 2421: 2420: 2416: 2412: 2407: 2406: 2405: 2401: 2397: 2393: 2389: 2386: 2382: 2380: 2376: 2372: 2367: 2366: 2365: 2364: 2360: 2356: 2353: 2346: 2342: 2338: 2333: 2332: 2325: 2321: 2320: 2316: 2309: 2305: 2301: 2297: 2296: 2295: 2294: 2293: 2292: 2287: 2283: 2279: 2274: 2270: 2269: 2268: 2264: 2263: 2259: 2251: 2248: 2245: 2239: 2235: 2234: 2230: 2223: 2222: 2221: 2217: 2213: 2209: 2208: 2207: 2203: 2202: 2198: 2189: 2183: 2179: 2176: 2175: 2172: 2168: 2164: 2160: 2159:Northern Gaza 2156: 2152: 2148: 2144: 2140: 2136: 2132: 2128: 2127: 2126: 2122: 2118: 2115: 2112: 2109: 2105: 2104: 2103: 2102: 2098: 2094: 2084: 2080: 2076: 2072: 2068: 2067: 2066: 2062: 2058: 2053: 2051: 2047: 2045: 2041: 2037: 2034: 2031: 2027: 2023: 2019: 2016: 2014: 2010: 2009: 2008: 2007: 2003: 1999: 1995: 1991: 1983: 1978: 1971: 1967: 1963: 1959: 1957: 1953: 1951: 1947: 1943: 1939: 1938: 1937: 1936: 1932: 1928: 1923: 1918: 1907: 1904: 1900: 1886: 1881: 1876: 1875: 1871: 1867: 1861: 1859: 1854: 1848: 1844: 1842: 1836: 1830: 1826: 1819: 1813: 1809: 1805: 1800: 1799: 1796: 1792: 1788: 1781: 1777: 1773: 1772: 1769: 1765: 1761: 1757: 1754: 1751: 1749: 1745: 1741: 1737: 1733: 1732:WP:CONSISTENT 1729: 1728:WP:COMMONNAME 1725: 1724: 1719: 1717: 1713: 1709: 1705: 1703: 1699: 1696: 1694: 1691: 1689: 1686: 1682: 1678: 1675: 1673: 1669: 1665: 1661: 1658: 1656: 1652: 1648: 1644: 1641: 1639: 1635: 1628: 1625: 1621: 1617: 1613: 1609: 1605: 1604: 1603: 1599: 1595: 1591: 1589: 1584: 1580: 1576: 1572: 1571:InfiniteNexus 1568: 1567: 1566: 1562: 1558: 1554: 1550: 1547: 1543: 1539: 1535: 1534:InfiniteNexus 1531: 1524: 1517: 1513: 1509: 1508: 1507: 1503: 1499: 1495: 1491: 1488: 1482: 1479: 1474: 1472: 1462: 1461: 1460: 1457: 1452: 1450: 1441: 1440: 1439: 1436: 1431: 1429: 1423: 1420: 1416: 1412: 1408: 1407:InfiniteNexus 1404: 1400: 1399: 1398: 1395: 1392: 1390: 1389: 1383: 1382: 1374: 1371: 1369: 1365: 1361: 1357: 1354: 1352: 1348: 1344: 1340: 1337: 1335: 1331: 1327: 1326:InfiniteNexus 1323: 1317: 1314: 1310: 1309:WP:COMMONNAME 1306: 1302: 1298: 1294: 1293: 1292:The Economist 1288: 1284: 1283: 1278: 1277: 1272: 1271: 1266: 1262: 1258: 1257: 1252: 1251: 1246: 1242: 1241: 1236: 1232: 1228: 1224: 1220: 1219: 1214: 1213: 1208: 1207: 1202: 1198: 1194: 1193: 1188: 1184: 1183: 1178: 1177: 1176:The Telegraph 1172: 1168: 1164: 1163: 1158: 1157: 1152: 1151: 1146: 1141: 1140: 1135: 1134: 1131: 1127: 1123: 1119: 1118: 1112: 1109: 1106: 1105: 1103: 1100: 1098: 1094: 1090: 1086: 1083: 1079: 1075: 1071: 1070:InfiniteNexus 1067: 1066: 1065: 1061: 1057: 1053: 1050: 1048: 1044: 1040: 1039:DivineReality 1036: 1033: 1031: 1027: 1023: 1019: 1015: 1014:WP:COMMONNAME 1011: 1010: 1005: 1001: 997: 993: 989: 983: 979: 975: 971: 967: 965: 961: 957: 953: 949: 948:WP:COMMONNAME 945: 944: 943: 940: 938: 932: 928: 924: 923: 922: 918: 917: 913: 906: 901: 898: 895: 892: 889: 888: 886: 883: 882: 881: 878: 876: 870: 866: 863: 859: 855: 851: 848: 844: 843:WP:CONSISTENT 837: 834: 833:2014 Gaza War 830: 826: 822: 818: 814: 813: 812: 811: 810: 806: 800: 794: 790: 787: 785: 781: 777: 773: 769: 765: 762: 761: 757: 755: 751: 747: 743: 740: 738: 735: 733: 730: 726: 722: 719: 717: 713: 709: 705: 701: 698: 696: 692: 691: 687: 680: 676: 672: 671:WP:COMMONNAME 668: 664: 661: 660: 653: 649: 645: 641: 637: 636: 635: 631: 627: 623: 622: 621: 620: 617: 613: 609: 608:Prodrummer619 606: 604: 600: 596: 592: 590: 586: 582: 578: 575: 571: 567: 563: 558: 557: 556: 552: 548: 543: 540: 538: 534: 530: 526: 522: 518: 515: 513: 509: 505: 501: 498: 494: 490: 486: 482: 481: 480: 476: 472: 468: 465: 463: 459: 455: 451: 447: 446:WP:COMMONNAME 443: 440: 438: 434: 430: 426: 424: 419: 413: 409: 405: 401: 397: 396: 395: 391: 387: 383: 379: 375: 371: 367: 363: 359: 355: 351: 347: 346: 345: 341: 337: 333: 332: 331: 327: 323: 319: 318: 313: 309: 305: 301: 297: 293: 289: 285: 282: 276: 272: 268: 264: 260: 258: 257:JohnAdams1800 254: 253: 252: 251: 250: 246: 242: 241:JohnAdams1800 238: 235: 232: 228: 224: 218: 214: 210: 206: 203: 202: 198: 196: 195: 192: 191: 185: 180: 176: 172: 167: 162: 157: 156: 152: 148: 144: 140: 136: 132: 125: 123: 118: 113: 108: 107: 102: 96: 93: 91: 88: 86: 83: 80: 76: 74: 71: 69: 66: 63: 61: 58: 57: 49: 45: 41: 40: 35: 28: 27: 19: 5674: 5668: 5657: 5593: 5460:belligerents 5453: 5451: 5388:the Guardian 5206: 5202: 5191: 4971: 4951: 4945: 4935: 4932:Recent edits 4914:WhatamIdoing 4866: 4859: 4812: 4793:. Retrieved 4789: 4779: 4767:. Retrieved 4762: 4753: 4741:. Retrieved 4735: 4726: 4715: 4705: 4687: 4675:. Retrieved 4670: 4661: 4649:. Retrieved 4624:. Retrieved 4619: 4610: 4598:. Retrieved 4593: 4584: 4572:. Retrieved 4566: 4557: 4546: 4536: 4518: 4506:. Retrieved 4501: 4492: 4480:. Retrieved 4474: 4445:. Retrieved 4440:The Observer 4438: 4404:Cite error: 4384: 4347:BilledMammal 4332:BilledMammal 4179: 4173: 3559: 3440: 3408:Mohamad Deif 3361: 3324: 3320: 3304: 3293: 3259: 3220: 3196:user:Drsruli 3185: 3179: 3176: 3169:TNYT article 3130: 3082: 3022: 2990: 2973: 2972:that can be 2969: 2962: 2953: 2908: 2814:, hosted by 2806: 2756:Coretheapple 2727:Coretheapple 2723: 2698: 2629: 2622: 2589: 2556: 2549: 2506: 2493: 2486: 2482: 2458: 2349: 2312: 2307: 2255: 2246: 2226: 2194: 2177: 2158: 2155:Coretheapple 2139:Coretheapple 2134: 2108:Coretheapple 2093:Coretheapple 2089: 2021: 1987: 1976: 1924: 1921: 1912: 1879: 1862: 1849: 1845: 1831: 1827: 1823: 1752: 1722: 1720: 1701: 1700: 1697: 1690: 1676: 1659: 1642: 1626: 1585: 1552: 1548: 1489: 1470: 1448: 1427: 1421: 1387: 1386: 1380: 1379: 1372: 1355: 1338: 1290: 1282:The Atlantic 1280: 1276:The Guardian 1274: 1268: 1254: 1248: 1238: 1216: 1210: 1204: 1190: 1180: 1174: 1160: 1154: 1148: 1136: 1113:2023_Example 1101: 1084: 1051: 1034: 1006: 969: 926: 909: 884: 868: 864: 793:the long run 788: 763: 759: 758: 741: 734: 724: 720: 699: 683: 666: 662: 594: 593: 581:XTheBedrockX 576: 541: 529:BilledMammal 516: 499: 466: 441: 420: 336:Coretheapple 315: 295: 283: 236: 223:Coretheapple 213:Coretheapple 204: 189: 159: 130: 128: 116: 109: 78: 43: 37: 5858:Selfstudier 5829:Selfstudier 5776:Selfstudier 5744:Selfstudier 5725:Makeandtoss 5717:Selfstudier 5700:Selfstudier 5643:Makeandtoss 5545:Makeandtoss 5519:Selfstudier 5489:Selfstudier 5439:Selfstudier 5406:Selfstudier 5392:Selfstudier 5374:Selfstudier 5341:Selfstudier 5291:Selfstudier 5257:Selfstudier 5228:Selfstudier 5170:Makeandtoss 5156:Selfstudier 5126:Makeandtoss 5112:Makeandtoss 5068:Makeandtoss 5024:Makeandtoss 5008:Makeandtoss 4954:Makeandtoss 4743:15 December 4574:15 December 4354:Makeandtoss 4287:Makeandtoss 4212:Selfstudier 4082:frustration 4077:Palestinian 3698:significant 3279:Selfstudier 3192:WP:NOTFORUM 3109:Makeandtoss 3073:Makeandtoss 3059:Makeandtoss 3025:Makeandtoss 2874:Selfstudier 2842:Selfstudier 2839:Haaretz now 2816:lbcgroup.tv 2443:Selfstudier 2355:Selfstudier 2273:TimothyBlue 2029:trust TRT). 1956:StrongALPHA 1942:Selfstudier 1927:StrongALPHA 1612:Selfstudier 1022:Paul Vaurie 992:Parham wiki 850:Parham wiki 768:Politicdude 708:Selfstudier 626:Parham wiki 454:DecafPotato 404:Parham wiki 378:Parham wiki 362:Parham wiki 322:Parham wiki 288:WP:TITLEDAB 122:move review 36:This is an 5896:XeCyranium 5843:PrimaPrime 5686:PrimaPrime 5629:PrimaPrime 5517:I second @ 5503:PrimaPrime 5475:PrimaPrime 5421:PrimaPrime 5359:PrimaPrime 5318:PrimaPrime 5272:PrimaPrime 5243:PrimaPrime 5214:PrimaPrime 5141:PrimaPrime 5098:PrimaPrime 5053:PrimaPrime 4939:PrimaPrime 4795:22 January 4737:Al Jazeera 4697:Al-Jazeera 4651:12 January 4568:Al Jazeera 4528:Al-Jazeera 4482:25 October 4447:1 November 4385:References 4273:PrimaPrime 4240:PrimaPrime 4194:PrimaPrime 4186:PrimaPrime 4162:¿question? 3843:¿question? 3777:¿question? 3750:governance 3542:¿question? 3508:¿question? 3372:PrimaPrime 3335:¿question? 3312:Al Jazeera 3077:PrimaPrime 3045:PrimaPrime 2949:tells us: 2947:WP:PRIMARY 2943:WP:PRIMARY 2939:WP:PRIMARY 2658:PrimaPrime 2535:¿question? 2433:¿question? 2400:¿question? 1820:Discussion 1736:discussion 1708:Yorkporter 1668:¿question? 1594:NasssaNser 1313:WP:CONCISE 1124:(he/him • 675:WP:CONCISE 665:: move to 564:(he/him • 549:(he/him • 521:WP:CONCISE 471:PrimaPrime 356:, and the 292:WP:CONCISE 95:Archive 40 90:Archive 39 85:Archive 38 79:Archive 37 73:Archive 36 68:Archive 35 60:Archive 30 5810:WP:NOTARG 5676:proxy war 5666:proxy war 5455:proxy war 5194:conflict. 5090:Bloomberg 4981:on reply) 4895:Jikybebna 4769:1 January 4677:1 January 4626:1 January 4600:1 January 4508:1 January 4412:help page 4206:Also see 4107:deepening 3961:estimated 3837:section. 3705:political 3656:According 3626:estimated 3155:Ecrusized 3133:Ecrusized 2642:Ecrusized 2614:Ecrusized 2599:Ecrusized 2509:Abo Yemen 2306:states, " 2247:Comment 2 1804:Nishidani 1647:Quake1234 1343:Wendylove 1256:USA Today 1197:Bloomberg 1156:The Times 1122:Shushugah 1089:Ecrusized 1087:Per nom. 970:Palestine 835:and etc). 302:(Such as 179:recent RM 147:Galobtter 5798:kashmīrī 5721:Kashmiri 5532:kashmīrī 4977:(Please 4847:kashmīrī 4369:NadVolum 4097:violence 4022:included 3986:leverage 3788:NadVolum 3723:internal 3701:security 3689:presence 3641:leverage 3532:shortly. 3519:NadVolum 3490:NadVolum 3475:kashmīrī 3445:kashmīrī 3386:Chessrat 3370:Agreed. 3362:Chessrat 3346:NadVolum 3327:reverted 2856:Jayen466 2785:NadVolum 2770:NadVolum 2742:NadVolum 2695:, today: 2693:ABC News 2675:NadVolum 2572:Johnuniq 2465:kashmīrī 2459:involved 2392:ecstatic 2371:NadVolum 2188:Nableezy 2184:. ping 2071:WP:UNDUE 1899:Fuzheado 1866:Mathglot 1787:Mathglot 1740:Mathglot 1721:Support 1610:below). 1586:Move to 1297:CBS News 1250:The Hill 1240:Politico 1235:NBC News 1231:ABC News 1227:ABC News 1212:LA Times 1206:Sky News 1137:Move to 1020:either. 936:kashmīrī 874:kashmīrī 821:Big Bang 780:contribs 772:About me 746:FunLater 704:Gaza war 562:HadesTTW 547:HadesTTW 425:proposal 421:Support 314:). Also 263:UN Watch 190:Chessrat 5793:WP:ONUS 4861:Johnson 4823:exactly 4790:Haaretz 4717:Reuters 4548:Reuters 4175:attack. 4158:Alaexis 4117:between 4092:settler 4062:disrupt 4002:reasons 3839:Alaexis 3773:Alaexis 3745:between 3735:primary 3726:debates 3720:resolve 3674:disrupt 3664:experts 3553:Alaexis 3538:Alaexis 3504:Alaexis 3428:Irtapil 3331:Alaexis 3264:Drsruli 3251:contri. 3225:Drsruli 3208:contri. 3090:Andreas 2996:Andreas 2977:source. 2935:removed 2860:Irtapil 2820:Andreas 2706:Andreas 2689:Example 2624:Johnson 2594:reports 2551:Johnson 2545:Alaexis 2531:Alaexis 2488:Johnson 2429:Alaexis 2425:chip in 2396:Alaexis 2315:Timothy 2278:Irtapil 2258:Timothy 2229:Timothy 2197:Timothy 2178:Comment 2163:Irtapil 2117:Irtapil 2057:Irtapil 2036:Irtapil 1962:Irtapil 1753:Support 1738:below. 1698:Support 1688:Chicdat 1677:Comment 1664:Alaexis 1660:Support 1643:Support 1627:Support 1557:Yeoutie 1490:Support 1373:Support 1356:Support 1287:Reuters 1102:Support 1085:Support 1056:Drsruli 912:Timothy 885:Comment 789:Support 760:Support 732:Chicdat 686:Timothy 663:Support 595:Oppose: 577:Support 542:Support 517:Support 504:Irtapil 467:Support 400:Irtapil 386:Irtapil 267:Irtapil 237:Support 205:Support 39:archive 5201:Hamas 4881:JDiala 4817:began 4328:WP:DUE 4181:253... 4032:desire 4017:attack 3951:taking 3931:sought 3911:latter 3817:VQuakr 3803:VQuakr 3710:force, 3683:assert 3670:wanted 3620:taking 3610:sought 3596:latter 3564:VQuakr 3459:JDiala 3410:which 3131:User @ 2981:Do not 2913:JDiala 2890:JDiala 2618:WP:NOR 2050:JDiala 2013:JDiala 1998:JDiala 1608:#Title 1549:Oppose 1471:Howard 1449:Howard 1428:Howard 1394:(talk) 1295:, and 1273:, and 1052:Oppose 952:WP:VNT 865:Oppose 804:(nest) 727:wars. 644:MClay1 500:Oppose 429:Lukt64 423:Parham 199:Survey 5791:BTW, 5723:and @ 5192:proxy 4994:Arkon 4132:Hamas 4052:Hamas 3740:focus 3667:Hamas 3198:. -- 2691:from 2022:whole 1498:Nigej 1381:Katan 816:time. 141:over 131:Moved 16:< 5900:talk 5876:talk 5862:talk 5847:talk 5833:talk 5819:talk 5780:talk 5763:talk 5748:talk 5733:talk 5704:talk 5690:talk 5647:talk 5633:talk 5549:talk 5529:. — 5527:this 5523:this 5507:talk 5493:talk 5479:talk 5443:talk 5425:talk 5410:talk 5396:talk 5378:talk 5363:talk 5345:talk 5322:talk 5295:talk 5276:talk 5261:talk 5247:talk 5232:talk 5218:talk 5198:say: 5174:talk 5160:talk 5145:talk 5130:talk 5116:talk 5102:talk 5072:talk 5057:talk 5028:talk 5012:talk 4998:talk 4979:ping 4958:talk 4918:talk 4908:day. 4899:talk 4885:talk 4831:talk 4797:2024 4771:2024 4745:2023 4679:2024 4653:2024 4628:2024 4602:2024 4576:2023 4510:2024 4484:2023 4449:2023 4373:talk 4358:talk 4336:talk 4291:talk 4277:talk 4263:talk 4244:talk 4230:talk 4216:talk 4198:talk 4190:talk 4122:Iran 4112:ties 4087:with 4042:part 3976:Gaza 3971:into 3941:free 3921:whom 3825:talk 3807:talk 3792:talk 3729:over 3703:and 3635:Gaza 3632:into 3614:free 3604:whom 3568:talk 3523:talk 3494:talk 3463:talk 3432:talk 3394:talk 3376:talk 3350:talk 3283:talk 3268:talk 3247:talk 3229:talk 3204:talk 3159:talk 3141:talk 3113:talk 3063:talk 3049:talk 3029:talk 2961:Any 2917:talk 2909:Done 2894:talk 2878:talk 2864:talk 2846:talk 2812:here 2789:talk 2774:talk 2760:talk 2746:talk 2731:talk 2679:talk 2662:talk 2646:talk 2603:talk 2576:talk 2447:talk 2415:talk 2375:talk 2359:talk 2341:talk 2319:talk 2282:talk 2262:talk 2233:talk 2216:talk 2201:talk 2167:talk 2143:talk 2121:talk 2097:talk 2079:talk 2061:talk 2040:talk 2002:talk 1994:this 1966:talk 1946:talk 1931:talk 1903:Talk 1870:talk 1808:talk 1791:talk 1780:talk 1764:talk 1744:talk 1712:talk 1651:talk 1616:talk 1598:talk 1575:talk 1561:talk 1538:talk 1502:talk 1477:🌽33 1455:🌽33 1434:🌽33 1411:talk 1388:gais 1364:talk 1347:talk 1330:talk 1311:and 1270:WaPo 1245:CNBC 1192:Time 1126:talk 1093:talk 1074:talk 1060:talk 1043:talk 1026:talk 996:talk 978:talk 960:talk 916:talk 854:talk 841:See 823:and 776:talk 750:talk 725:Gaza 712:talk 690:talk 677:and 648:talk 630:talk 612:talk 585:talk 566:talk 551:talk 533:talk 523:and 508:talk 489:talk 475:talk 458:talk 433:talk 408:talk 390:talk 366:talk 340:talk 326:talk 310:and 271:talk 245:talk 227:talk 217:talk 211:. 151:talk 5719:, @ 5525:or 5386:Or 5288:NYT 4868:524 4127:and 4102:and 4067:the 4027:the 4012:the 4007:for 3997:The 3906:the 3755:and 3732:its 3715:and 3686:its 3677:the 3672:to 3612:to 3591:the 3560:not 3316:NYT 3308:CBS 3241:-- 3194:by 3151:ISW 3099:466 3084:... 3005:466 2829:466 2715:466 2631:524 2591:WSJ 2558:524 2495:524 2317::: 2313:// 2260::: 2256:// 2231::: 2227:// 2199::: 2195:// 1988:Is 1318:and 1265:BBC 1261:Pew 1223:PBS 1201:NPR 1187:CBC 1171:CNN 1167:AFP 1162:WSJ 1150:NYT 914::: 910:// 688::: 684:// 133:to 5902:) 5878:) 5864:) 5849:) 5835:) 5821:) 5782:) 5765:) 5750:) 5735:) 5706:) 5692:) 5649:) 5635:) 5551:) 5509:) 5495:) 5481:) 5452:A 5445:) 5427:) 5412:) 5398:) 5380:) 5365:) 5347:) 5324:) 5297:) 5278:) 5263:) 5249:) 5234:) 5220:) 5176:) 5162:) 5147:) 5132:) 5118:) 5104:) 5074:) 5059:) 5030:) 5014:) 5000:) 4973:VR 4960:) 4920:) 4901:) 4887:) 4833:) 4788:. 4761:. 4734:. 4714:. 4695:. 4669:. 4636:^ 4618:. 4592:. 4565:. 4545:. 4526:. 4500:. 4473:. 4457:^ 4437:. 4421:^ 4414:). 4392:^ 4375:) 4360:) 4338:) 4293:) 4279:) 4265:) 4246:) 4232:) 4218:) 4200:) 4135:. 4072:], 4057:to 4047:of 4037:on 3981:as 3956:an 3946:by 3936:to 3926:it 3916:of 3827:) 3809:) 3794:) 3692:as 3680:], 3661:to 3653:. 3638:as 3623:an 3617:by 3607:it 3601:of 3570:) 3525:) 3496:) 3465:) 3434:) 3396:) 3378:) 3352:) 3318:. 3314:, 3310:, 3285:) 3270:) 3253:) 3249:· 3231:) 3210:) 3206:· 3161:) 3143:) 3115:) 3095:JN 3075:, 3065:) 3051:) 3031:) 3001:JN 2945:. 2919:) 2896:) 2880:) 2866:) 2848:) 2825:JN 2791:) 2776:) 2762:) 2748:) 2733:) 2711:JN 2681:) 2664:) 2648:) 2605:) 2578:) 2449:) 2427:. 2417:) 2411:JM 2377:) 2361:) 2343:) 2337:JM 2302:. 2284:) 2218:) 2212:JM 2169:) 2145:) 2123:) 2099:) 2081:) 2075:JM 2073:? 2063:) 2042:) 2004:) 1968:) 1948:) 1933:) 1901:| 1872:) 1810:) 1793:) 1766:) 1746:) 1730:, 1714:) 1706:-- 1685:🐔 1653:) 1618:) 1577:) 1563:) 1555:. 1540:) 1526:}} 1520:{{ 1504:) 1496:. 1445:– 1413:) 1376:-- 1366:) 1360:JM 1349:) 1332:) 1324:. 1289:, 1267:, 1259:, 1253:, 1247:, 1243:, 1237:, 1233:, 1229:, 1225:, 1221:, 1215:, 1209:, 1203:, 1199:, 1195:, 1189:, 1185:, 1182:FT 1179:, 1173:, 1169:, 1165:, 1159:, 1153:, 1147:, 1145:AP 1128:) 1095:) 1076:) 1062:) 1045:) 1028:) 998:) 980:) 972:? 962:) 956:JM 954:. 856:) 831:, 782:) 778:, 774:, 752:) 729:🐔 714:) 681:. 673:, 650:) 632:) 614:) 587:) 568:) 553:) 535:) 510:) 491:) 477:) 460:) 435:) 410:) 392:) 368:) 352:, 342:) 328:) 306:, 273:) 247:) 229:) 173:, 163:→ 153:) 145:. 114:. 64:← 5898:( 5874:( 5860:( 5845:( 5831:( 5817:( 5778:( 5761:( 5746:( 5731:( 5715:@ 5702:( 5688:( 5645:( 5631:( 5547:( 5505:( 5491:( 5477:( 5441:( 5423:( 5408:( 5394:( 5376:( 5361:( 5343:( 5320:( 5293:( 5274:( 5259:( 5245:( 5230:( 5216:( 5209:. 5172:( 5158:( 5143:( 5128:( 5114:( 5100:( 5070:( 5055:( 5026:( 5010:( 4996:( 4956:( 4941:: 4937:@ 4916:( 4897:( 4883:( 4829:( 4799:. 4773:. 4747:. 4720:. 4681:. 4655:. 4630:. 4604:. 4578:. 4551:. 4512:. 4486:. 4451:. 4371:( 4356:( 4349:: 4345:@ 4334:( 4289:( 4275:( 4261:( 4242:( 4228:( 4214:( 4196:( 4188:( 3992:+ 3988:. 3966:] 3898:− 3823:( 3805:( 3790:( 3762:. 3695:a 3647:+ 3643:. 3629:] 3583:− 3566:( 3555:: 3551:@ 3521:( 3492:( 3461:( 3430:( 3392:( 3384:@ 3374:( 3348:( 3281:( 3266:( 3245:( 3227:( 3202:( 3157:( 3139:( 3111:( 3071:@ 3061:( 3047:( 3027:( 2915:( 2892:( 2876:( 2862:( 2854:@ 2844:( 2787:( 2772:( 2758:( 2744:( 2729:( 2677:( 2660:( 2644:( 2612:@ 2601:( 2574:( 2543:@ 2514:✉ 2445:( 2413:( 2373:( 2357:( 2339:( 2280:( 2271:@ 2214:( 2190:: 2186:@ 2165:( 2153:@ 2141:( 2133:. 2119:( 2106:@ 2095:( 2077:( 2059:( 2048:@ 2038:( 2011:@ 2000:( 1964:( 1954:@ 1944:( 1929:( 1868:( 1839:" 1806:( 1789:( 1778:( 1762:( 1742:( 1710:( 1649:( 1614:( 1590:. 1573:( 1559:( 1536:( 1500:( 1465:s 1409:( 1362:( 1345:( 1328:( 1091:( 1072:( 1058:( 1041:( 1024:( 994:( 976:( 958:( 852:( 770:( 748:( 710:( 646:( 628:( 610:( 605:. 583:( 531:( 506:( 487:( 473:( 456:( 431:( 406:( 398:@ 388:( 376:@ 364:( 338:( 324:( 269:( 255:@ 243:( 225:( 215:( 149:( 50:.

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.

Index