552:
409:
21:
229:
104:
754:
423:
382:
284:
257:
159:
433:
135:
530:
402:
169:
506:
75:
350:
571:
837:, has been going on for a little over a year now, and I am the only one to contribute to the discussion in that whole time. I don't wish to break policy, but since the article has vastly improved since its merge nomination, I feel it is a "Keeper" article, and the merge discussion should end. Agreements?
1047:
I take a bit of issue with using NCF as a defense in this case. I'm neutral in this argument, but I feel like NCF isn't clear as to works derived from short films. It's undeniable that the 2004 film is the primary topic, but its source material is the 2003 short. I feel like this area is muddily
985:, which is a different class of production from the full-length films that are generally title with "film" in our articles. I think that this is a principled distinction by which we can avoid the question of whether the widely released 2004 hit film is the primary topic of the term "Saw (film)".
803:
If there is other fair use media, consider checking that you have specified the fair use rationale on the other images used on this page. Note that any fair use images lacking such an explanation can be deleted one week after being tagged, as described on
1208:; and "(film)" should not redirect to the 2004 film either, as said above, the entire franchise would be a better target than the first film, so leave it as a disambiguation page link. A film franchise is a film topic. --
303:
and other media on
Knowledge (XXG). If you would like to participate, you can edit one of the articles mentioned below, or visit the project page, where you can join the project and contribute to the
800:
is an easy way to insure that your image is in compliance with
Knowledge (XXG) policy, but remember that you must complete the template. Do not simply insert a blank template on an image page.
515:
392:
238:
145:
1410:
1370:
520:
85:
733:
No, not a pun on anything. I believe the title came from the hacksaws
Lawrence and Adam had in the 2004 film, but I could be wrong. It's definitely not a pun though.
1375:
358:
267:
496:
305:
1405:
1400:
486:
781:, you must also write out on the image description page a specific explanation or rationale for why using this image in each article is consistent with
778:
340:
1009:
per nom. Readers searching for "Saw (film)" are most likely searching for the 2004 film, and the current titles imply a misleading level of parity. --
805:
797:
793:
770:
1415:
1390:
1385:
631:
I don't understand how you don't understand that sentence. It's a film that's nine in a half minutes long , and it was released in the year 2003.
330:
809:
363:
1365:
945:
1395:
908:
Subsequent comments should be made in a new section on the talk page. Editors desiring to contest the closing decision should consider a
1209:
1030:. The year qualifier is enough to diambig the two films. The 2004 film should not be moved to simply "film", as there is more than one.
876:
408:
1380:
462:
449:
387:
187:
291:
262:
115:
1139:
is more associated with the first feature film than any of the others or the short, I don't see what advantage it holds over
1107:
really ambiguous, though? Is a ten minute "short film" really a film, in the sense that anyone would normally think of it?
401:
199:
191:
195:
182:
140:
1316:
1240:
1227:. I agree with the nom. The 2004 film is the primary topic, and there's a difference between a short film and a film. —
899:
81:
596:
Is it right that this is called "2003 film" but included in the category 2004 films (together with Saw itself)Â ? --
47:
1263:, so the primary topic argument isn't really an effective discriminant for choosing between titles in this case.
941:
842:
819:
738:
665:
1347:
1204:
2004 move. The short film is still a film, so the 2004 film should not be located at ambiguous disambiguation
909:
121:
880:
1325:
1213:
103:
872:
789:
761:
1268:
1156:
1094:
20:
766:
31:
1264:
1152:
1090:
632:
934:
834:
1144:
765:
is being used on this article. I notice the image page specifies that the image is being used under
551:
74:
1312:
1294:
838:
815:
734:
661:
645:
1321:
1311:. We don't have a tiered naming system; there is no primary topic for a disambiguated title. See
458:
561:
228:
1234:
1183:
1173:, then? As of now, it points to a disambiguation page with lots of other meanings of "saw".
1117:
1085:
could apply to any of them or collectively in a general sense. It is better off directed to
1056:
995:
438:
1308:
1205:
1147:, disambiguated titles should ideally unambiguously define the topic of the article, which
1027:
1170:
1086:
971:
960:
657:
61:
1337:
782:
53:
1289:
1081:
isn't necessarily associated with just the first Saw film; there are loads of them and
853:
852:
I agree, the article is too big to merge into the Saw franchise article, IMO. KEEP. --
725:
622:
300:
42:
27:
753:
1359:
1073:
I don't agree with moving a clearly disambiguated title to an ambiguous title, which
1014:
1032:
660:
was already written. This short was made to promote it and make the full Saw film.
186:. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can
1228:
1174:
1108:
1050:
986:
597:
422:
381:
296:
295:, an attempt to build a comprehensive and detailed guide to fictional horror in
174:
1346:
Subsequent comments should be made in a new section on this talk page or in a
1285:
1166:
1104:
1074:
982:
975:
529:
428:
164:
158:
134:
37:
454:
283:
256:
618:
It was created from a scene that they chose from the script of Saw (2004).
1048:
defined. Perhaps this issue should be addressed on the NCF page, as well.
1010:
203:
1328:
1299:
1272:
1246:
1217:
1188:
1160:
1122:
1098:
1061:
1038:
1018:
1000:
950:
884:
858:
846:
823:
742:
727:
715:
707:
669:
648:
635:
625:
600:
349:
981:– The 2003 production was under ten minutes, and clearly constitutes a
696:
1288:
to the 2004 one. Helps readers without having an ambiguous qualifier.
542:
505:
692:
688:
777:
Knowledge (XXG) article constitutes fair use. In addition to the
700:
684:
644:
Right. Saw was made into a 2004 film after the short was made.--
676:
97:
69:
15:
752:
550:
528:
504:
348:
227:
1255:
Regardless of whether the article is the primary topic for
833:
This is a little ridiculous, but the discussion for merge,
927:
at its current title. No consensus on whether to rename
898:
The following discussion is an archived discussion of a
965:
929:
923:
453:, which aims to improve Knowledge (XXG)'s coverage of
1336:
The above discussion is preserved as an archive of a
912:. No further edits should be made to this section.
808:. If you have any questions please ask them at the
614:film, than how is the following sentence possible?
361:, a task force which is currently considered to be
1350:. No further edits should be made to this section.
202:. To improve this article, please refer to the
114:does not require a rating on Knowledge (XXG)'s
461:. If you would like to participate, visit the
869:the paralized victum was credited as "Body"
749:Fair use rationale for Image:Jigsawpuppet.JPG
8:
798:Knowledge (XXG):Fair use rationale guideline
1259:, it is indisputably the primary topic for
376:
251:
198:. To use this banner, please refer to the
129:
1411:Low-importance Australian cinema articles
1371:Redirect-Class Australian cinema articles
357:This redirect is within the scope of the
378:
309:to talk over new ideas and suggestions.
253:
131:
1376:Australian cinema task force articles
1165:How would you feel about redirecting
471:Knowledge (XXG):WikiProject Australia
289:This redirect is within the scope of
180:This redirect is within the scope of
101:
7:
1282:Support the first, oppose the second
917:The result of the move request was:
716:http://akas.imdb.com/title/tt0495241
708:http://akas.imdb.com/title/tt0387564
41:Because this page is not frequently
120:It is of interest to the following
1077:is. Also, as Lugnuts alludes, the
537:Need help improving this article?
315:Knowledge (XXG):WikiProject Horror
45:, present and future discussions,
14:
1406:Low-importance Australia articles
1401:Redirect-Class Australia articles
1229:
236:This article is supported by the
84:on 6 January 2023. The result of
1241:
796:. Using one of the templates at
569:
516:the Australian cinema task force
491:This redirect has been rated as
431:
421:
407:
400:
380:
335:This redirect has been rated as
282:
255:
212:Knowledge (XXG):WikiProject Film
196:regional and topical task forces
167:
157:
133:
102:
73:
19:
80:This article was nominated for
1416:WikiProject Australia articles
1391:Low-importance horror articles
1386:Redirect-Class horror articles
810:Media copyright questions page
565:can be contacted via email to
513:This redirect is supported by
474:Template:WikiProject Australia
1:
859:04:54, 30 November 2009 (UTC)
847:18:58, 14 November 2009 (UTC)
779:boilerplate fair use template
743:18:55, 14 November 2009 (UTC)
649:18:55, 4 September 2007 (UTC)
577:for non-editorial assistance.
543:National Library of Australia
1366:Redirect-Class film articles
1317:Independence Day (1996 film)
1235:
885:19:28, 2 November 2010 (UTC)
806:criteria for speedy deletion
728:02:55, 24 October 2007 (UTC)
239:Australian cinema task force
1396:WikiProject Horror articles
824:19:36, 2 January 2008 (UTC)
683:Are these titles a pun on:
562:Wikimedia Australia chapter
318:Template:WikiProject Horror
1432:
1329:13:58, 31 March 2014 (UTC)
1300:04:27, 30 March 2014 (UTC)
1273:08:36, 29 March 2014 (UTC)
1247:05:54, 29 March 2014 (UTC)
1218:05:49, 29 March 2014 (UTC)
1189:12:42, 28 March 2014 (UTC)
1161:12:09, 28 March 2014 (UTC)
1123:11:47, 28 March 2014 (UTC)
1099:10:05, 28 March 2014 (UTC)
1062:12:20, 28 March 2014 (UTC)
1039:09:41, 28 March 2014 (UTC)
1019:21:10, 27 March 2014 (UTC)
1001:15:14, 27 March 2014 (UTC)
790:the image description page
670:22:29, 27 April 2009 (UTC)
626:16:46, 23 April 2007 (UTC)
601:03:00, 23 April 2006 (UTC)
497:project's importance scale
341:project's importance scale
306:general Project discussion
1381:WikiProject Film articles
951:17:20, 4 April 2014 (UTC)
792:and edit it to include a
636:08:16, 29 June 2007 (UTC)
610:If this was a 9.5 minute
570:
558:
536:
512:
490:
416:
356:
334:
277:
235:
215:Template:WikiProject Film
152:
128:
1343:Please do not modify it.
905:Please do not modify it.
771:explanation or rationale
459:Australia-related topics
835:which can be found here
447:is within the scope of
34:that targets the page:
762:Image:Jigsawpuppet.JPG
757:
620:
555:
533:
509:
353:
232:
773:as to why its use in
756:
616:
554:
532:
508:
450:WikiProject Australia
352:
231:
57:should take place at:
921:. Consensus to keep
606:What Does This Mean?
1313:Titanic (1997 film)
1143:as a title. As per
675:Are these titles a
656:And the Script for
188:join the discussion
1151:doesn't fully do.
794:fair use rationale
758:
556:
534:
510:
477:Australia articles
354:
292:WikiProject Horror
233:
116:content assessment
56:
50:
1324:
949:
875:comment added by
589:
588:
585:
584:
581:
580:
375:
374:
371:
370:
250:
249:
246:
245:
190:and see lists of
96:
95:
68:
67:
52:
46:
1423:
1345:
1320:
1292:
1243:
1237:
1231:
1181:
1115:
1059:
1053:
1035:
993:
968:
966:Saw (short film)
940:
937:
932:
926:
907:
887:
865:Paralized Victum
856:
769:but there is no
576:
575:wikimedia.org.au
574:
573:
572:
479:
478:
475:
472:
469:
441:
439:Australia portal
436:
435:
434:
425:
418:
417:
412:
411:
410:
405:
404:
403:
398:
395:
384:
377:
323:
322:
319:
316:
313:
286:
279:
278:
273:
270:
259:
252:
220:
219:
216:
213:
210:
183:WikiProject Film
177:
172:
171:
170:
161:
154:
153:
148:
137:
130:
107:
106:
98:
77:
70:
23:
16:
1431:
1430:
1426:
1425:
1424:
1422:
1421:
1420:
1356:
1355:
1354:
1341:
1290:
1261:Saw (2004 film)
1175:
1171:Saw (2004 film)
1141:Saw (2004 film)
1109:
1087:Saw (franchise)
1057:
1051:
1033:
987:
972:Saw (2004 film)
964:
961:Saw (2003 film)
935:
930:Saw (2003 film)
928:
924:Saw (2004 film)
922:
903:
893:
870:
867:
854:
831:
751:
681:
658:Saw (2004 film)
608:
594:
568:
566:
539:Ask a Librarian
476:
473:
470:
467:
466:
445:Saw (2003 film)
437:
432:
430:
406:
399:
396:
390:
321:horror articles
320:
317:
314:
311:
310:
271:
265:
217:
214:
211:
208:
207:
173:
168:
166:
143:
62:Talk:Saw (film)
54:requested moves
12:
11:
5:
1429:
1427:
1419:
1418:
1413:
1408:
1403:
1398:
1393:
1388:
1383:
1378:
1373:
1368:
1358:
1357:
1353:
1352:
1338:requested move
1332:
1331:
1302:
1278:
1277:
1276:
1275:
1250:
1249:
1225:Strong support
1221:
1220:
1198:
1197:
1196:
1195:
1194:
1193:
1192:
1191:
1128:
1127:
1126:
1125:
1067:
1066:
1065:
1064:
1042:
1041:
1021:
979:
978:
969:
956:
954:
915:
914:
900:requested move
894:
892:
891:Requested move
889:
866:
863:
862:
861:
839:GroundZ3R0 002
830:
827:
816:BetacommandBot
750:
747:
746:
745:
735:GroundZ3R0 002
680:
673:
662:GroundZ3R0 002
654:
653:
652:
651:
646:CyberGhostface
639:
638:
607:
604:
593:
590:
587:
586:
583:
582:
579:
578:
557:
547:
546:
535:
525:
524:
521:Low-importance
511:
501:
500:
493:Low-importance
489:
483:
482:
480:
443:
442:
426:
414:
413:
397:Low‑importance
385:
373:
372:
369:
368:
359:Saw task force
355:
345:
344:
337:Low-importance
333:
327:
326:
324:
287:
275:
274:
272:Low‑importance
260:
248:
247:
244:
243:
234:
224:
223:
221:
179:
178:
162:
150:
149:
138:
126:
125:
119:
108:
94:
93:
86:the discussion
78:
66:
65:
58:
40:
35:
24:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
1428:
1417:
1414:
1412:
1409:
1407:
1404:
1402:
1399:
1397:
1394:
1392:
1389:
1387:
1384:
1382:
1379:
1377:
1374:
1372:
1369:
1367:
1364:
1363:
1361:
1351:
1349:
1344:
1339:
1334:
1333:
1330:
1327:
1323:
1318:
1314:
1310:
1306:
1303:
1301:
1298:
1297:
1293:
1287:
1284:but redirect
1283:
1280:
1279:
1274:
1270:
1266:
1262:
1258:
1254:
1253:
1252:
1251:
1248:
1244:
1238:
1232:
1226:
1223:
1222:
1219:
1215:
1211:
1210:70.24.250.235
1207:
1203:
1202:Strong oppose
1200:
1199:
1190:
1187:
1186:
1182:
1180:
1179:
1172:
1168:
1164:
1163:
1162:
1158:
1154:
1150:
1146:
1142:
1138:
1134:
1133:
1132:
1131:
1130:
1129:
1124:
1121:
1120:
1116:
1114:
1113:
1106:
1102:
1101:
1100:
1096:
1092:
1088:
1084:
1080:
1076:
1072:
1069:
1068:
1063:
1060:
1058:(speak to me)
1055:
1054:
1046:
1045:
1044:
1043:
1040:
1037:
1036:
1029:
1025:
1022:
1020:
1016:
1012:
1008:
1005:
1004:
1003:
1002:
999:
998:
994:
992:
991:
984:
977:
973:
970:
967:
962:
959:
958:
957:
953:
952:
947:
943:
939:
931:
925:
920:
913:
911:
906:
901:
896:
895:
890:
888:
886:
882:
878:
877:68.41.121.194
874:
864:
860:
857:
851:
850:
849:
848:
844:
840:
836:
828:
826:
825:
821:
817:
813:
812:. Thank you.
811:
807:
801:
799:
795:
791:
788:Please go to
786:
784:
780:
776:
772:
768:
764:
763:
755:
748:
744:
740:
736:
732:
731:
730:
729:
723:
720:
717:
712:
709:
704:
702:
698:
695:, as well as
694:
690:
686:
678:
674:
672:
671:
667:
663:
659:
650:
647:
643:
642:
641:
640:
637:
634:
630:
629:
628:
627:
624:
619:
615:
613:
605:
603:
602:
599:
591:
564:
563:
553:
549:
548:
544:
540:
531:
527:
526:
522:
519:(assessed as
518:
517:
507:
503:
502:
498:
494:
488:
485:
484:
481:
464:
460:
456:
452:
451:
446:
440:
429:
427:
424:
420:
419:
415:
394:
389:
386:
383:
379:
366:
365:
360:
351:
347:
346:
342:
338:
332:
329:
328:
325:
308:
307:
302:
298:
294:
293:
288:
285:
281:
280:
276:
269:
264:
261:
258:
254:
241:
240:
230:
226:
225:
222:
218:film articles
205:
201:
200:documentation
197:
193:
189:
185:
184:
176:
165:
163:
160:
156:
155:
151:
147:
142:
139:
136:
132:
127:
123:
117:
113:
109:
105:
100:
99:
91:
87:
83:
79:
76:
72:
71:
64:
63:
55:
49:
48:edit requests
44:
39:
33:
29:
25:
22:
18:
17:
1342:
1335:
1304:
1295:
1281:
1260:
1256:
1224:
1201:
1184:
1177:
1176:
1148:
1140:
1136:
1118:
1111:
1110:
1082:
1078:
1070:
1049:
1031:
1023:
1006:
996:
989:
988:
980:
955:
918:
916:
904:
897:
868:
832:
814:
802:
787:
774:
760:
759:
724:
721:
713:
705:
682:
655:
621:
617:
611:
609:
595:
559:
538:
514:
492:
463:project page
448:
444:
362:
336:
304:
290:
237:
181:
122:WikiProjects
111:
89:
60:
26:This is the
1348:move review
1265:Betty Logan
1153:Betty Logan
1091:Betty Logan
910:move review
871:—Preceding
722:Thank You,
633:ARBlackwood
175:Film portal
1360:Categories
1286:Saw (film)
1257:Saw (film)
1167:Saw (film)
1149:Saw (film)
1145:WP:PRECISE
1137:Saw (film)
1105:Saw (film)
1083:Saw (film)
1079:Saw (film)
1075:Saw (film)
983:short film
976:Saw (film)
938:HairedGirl
855:Mike Allen
623:The Dude 4
301:literature
204:guidelines
192:open tasks
146:Australian
38:Saw (film)
1322:BOVINEBOY
919:not moved
468:Australia
455:Australia
388:Australia
28:talk page
1242:contribs
1135:Even if
946:contribs
873:unsigned
783:fair use
767:fair use
592:Category
364:inactive
112:redirect
90:redirect
82:deletion
32:redirect
1034:Lugnuts
1007:Support
829:Merging
697:hacksaw
541:at the
495:on the
339:on the
43:watched
1309:WP:NCF
1305:Oppose
1230:Status
1206:WP:NCF
1178:bd2412
1112:bd2412
1071:Oppose
1052:Corvoe
1028:WP:NCF
1024:Oppose
990:bd2412
942:(talk)
693:seesaw
598:Beardo
393:Cinema
312:Horror
263:Horror
118:scale.
1296:Slash
936:Brown
933:. --
718:: -->
714:<
710:: -->
706:<
689:scene
110:This
30:of a
1326:2008
1307:per
1291:Red
1269:talk
1236:talk
1214:talk
1157:talk
1095:talk
1026:per
1015:talk
881:talk
843:talk
820:talk
775:this
739:talk
701:hack
685:seen
677:pun
666:talk
612:2003
567:help
560:The
457:and
297:film
209:Film
194:and
141:Film
88:was
51:and
1340:.
1169:to
1103:Is
1011:BDD
944:• (
703:??
679:on:
487:Low
331:Low
268:Saw
59:•
36:•
1362::
1315:,
1271:)
1245:)
1239:·
1216:)
1159:)
1097:)
1089:.
1017:)
974:→
963:→
902:.
883:)
845:)
822:)
785:.
741:)
726:]
719:.
711:;
699:,
691:,
687:,
668:)
523:).
391::
299:,
266::
144::
1319:.
1267:(
1233:(
1212:(
1185:T
1155:(
1119:T
1093:(
1013:(
997:T
948:)
879:(
841:(
818:(
737:(
664:(
545:.
499:.
465:.
367:.
343:.
242:.
206:.
124::
92:.
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
