1091:, the 'Nazi/Soviet similarities' are insufficient to make denunciation a specifically 'totalitarian' phenomenon." He criticizes this argument by stating that "the difference between Nazi/Communist systems and Western ones is 'not qualitative but quantitative.' By implication, therefore, singling out Communist and Nazi terror in order to equate them becomes Cold War slanderâthe ideological subtext, as it happens, of twenty-five years of 'revisionist,' social-reductionist Sovietology." He further criticizes it by making the point that "this fact-for-fact's sake approach suggests that there is nothing specifically Communist about Communist terrorâand, it would seem, nothing particularly Nazi about Nazi terror either." He states that "the bloody Soviet experiment is banalized in one great gray anthropological blur; and the Soviet Union is transmogrified into just another country in just another age, neither more nor less evil than any other regime going", and dismisses this as "obviously nonsense." For Malia, "the problem of moral judgment" is "inseparable from any real understanding of the past" and "from being human."
1123:, Courtois further says: "This book is one of the first attempts to study Communism with a focus on its criminal dimensions, in both the central regions of Communist rule and the farthest reaches of the globe. Some will say that most of these crimes were actions conducted in accordance with a system of law that was enforced by the regimes' official institutions, which were recognized internationally and whose heads of state continued to be welcomed with open arms. But was this not the case with Nazism as well? The crimes we shall expose are to be judged not by the standards of Communist regimes, but by the unwritten code of natural laws of humanity." Courtois states that "he legal ramification of crimes committed by a specific country were first confronted in 1945 at the Nuremberg Tribunal, which was organized by the Allies to consider the atrocities committed by the Nazis." Courtois writes that "n examination of all the crimes committed by the Leninist/Stalinist regime, and in the Communist world as a whole, reveals crimes that fit into each of these three categories", namely
745:, to include 'every possible death just to run up the score.' To an extent, the charge is valid. Courtois and other contributors to the volume equate the people shot, hanged, or killed in prisons or the camps with those who were victims of calculated political famines (in the Chinese and Soviet cases), or who otherwise starved for lack of food or died for lack of drugs." Based on the results of their studies, Courtois estimated the total number of the victims at between 65 and 93 million, an unjustified and unclear sum according to Margolin and Werth. In particular, Margolin, who authored the book's chapter on Vietnam, stated that "he has never mentioned a million deaths in Vietnam"; Margolin likened Courtois's effort to "militant political activity, indeed, that of a prosecutor amassing charges in the service of a cause, that of a global condemnation of the Communist phenomenon as an essentially criminal phenomenon." Historians
1100:
always encounter a double standard as long as there exist a left and a right", which he "roughly define as the priority of compassionate egalitarianism for the one, and as the primacy of prudential order for the other." Malia states that "ince neither principle can be applied absolutely without destroying society, the modern world lives in perpetual tension between the irresistible pressure for equality and the functional necessity of hierarchy." For Malia, it is "this syndrome" which "gives the permanent qualitative advantage to
Communism over Nazism in any evaluation of their quantitative atrocities. For the Communist projects, in origin, claimed commitment to universalistic and egalitarian goals, whereas the Nazi projects offered only unabashed national egoism", causing their practices to be "comparable" and their "moral auras" to be "antithetical."
539:
there never was a "benign, initial phase of
Communism before some mytical 'wrong turn' threw it off track", claiming that Lenin expected and wanted from the start a civil war "to crush all 'class enemies'; and this war, principally against the peasants, continued with only short pauses until 1953." Malia further says that the Red Terror "cannot be explained as the prolongation of prerevolutionary political cultures", but rather as "a deliberate policy of the new revolutionary order; and its scope and inhumanity far exceeded anything in the national past." Malia laments that "'Positivist' social scientists ... have averred that moral questions are irrelevant to understanding the past" and criticizes this perspective by arguing that it "reduces politics and ideology everywhere to anthropology."
543:
product of social process", faulting that "researches have endlessly insisted that the
October Revolution was a workers' revolt and not a Party coup d'Ă©tat, when it was obviously the latter riding piggyback on the former." According to Malia, "the central issue in Communist history is not the Party's ephemeral worker 'base'; it is what the intelligentsia victors of October later did with their permanent coup d'etat, and so far this has scarcely been explored." Malia then goes on to describe "two fantasies holding out the promise of a better Soviet socialism than the one the Bolsheviks actually built." The first one is "the 'Bukharin alternative' to Stalin" which Malia describes as "a thesis that purports to offer a nonviolent, market road to socialismâthat is, Marx's
885:, only Courtois made the comparison between Communism and Nazism, while the other sections of the book "are, in effect, narrowly focused monographs, which do not pretend to offer overarching explanations." Paczkowski wonders whether it can be applied "the same standard of judgment to, on the one hand, an ideology that was destructive at its core, that openly planned genocide, and that had an agenda of aggression against all neighboring (and not just neighboring) states, and, on the other hand, an ideology that seemed clearly the opposite, that was based on the secular desire of humanity to achieve equality and social justice, and that promised a great leap of forward into freedom", and states that while a good question, it is hardly new and inappropriate because
1192:, "his gigantic volume, the sum of works of 11 historians, social scientists, and journalists, is less important for the content, but for the social storm it has provoked in France. ... What Werth and some of his colleagues object to is 'the manipulation of the figures of the numbers of people killed' (Courtois talks of almost 100 million, including 65 million in China); 'the use of shock formulas, the juxtaposition of histories aimed at asserting the comparability and, next, the identities of fascism, and Nazism, and communism.' Indeed, Courtois would have been far more effective if he had shown more restraint."
919:. In 2012, TismÄneanu wrote that "in the case of communism one can identify an inner dynamic that could and did in fact contrast the original promises to the sordidly criminal practices. In other words, there was a possible search for reforms, and even for socialism with a human face, within the communist world, but such a thing would have been unthinkable under Nazism. The chasm between theory and practice, or at least between the moral-humanist Marxian (or socialist) creed, and the Leninist, Stalinist (or Maoist, or Khmer Rouge) experiments was more than an intellectual fantasy."
38:
1112:"inopportune because equating Communism with Nazism removed the 'last barriers to legitimating the extreme right,' that is, Le Pen." While stating it is true that "Le Pen's party and similar hate-mongering, xenophobic movements elsewhere in Europe represents an alarming new phenomenon that properly concerns all liberal democrats", Malia writes that in no way does it follow that "Communism's criminal past should be ignored or minimized." Malia writes that "the persistence of such sophistry is precisely why
534:
those who saw it as the socialist end of history and those who considered it history's most vital tyranny." According to Malia, "more than eighty years after 1917, probing examination of the Big
Questions raised by the Marxist-Leninist phenomenon has hardly begun" and that "a serious historiography was precluded in Soviet Russia by the regime's mandatory ideology", further stating that "scholarly investigation of Communism has until recently fallen disproportionately to Westerns." Malia writes that "
2006:: the figure of 100 million deaths and the parallel with Nazism. They became central in the debate that followed. ... In articles and interviews Werth and Margolin pointed out how, in the service of this goal, Courtois distorted and exaggerated: Werth's total, including the Civil War and the famine of 1932â1933 had been five million less than Courtois's 'mythical number,' while Margolin denied having spoken of the Vietnamese Communists being responsible for one million deaths. Interviewed in
1471:
not astonish their readers, "dramatize the sufferings of the victims of
Communism", or focus on quarrels over exact numbers of victims, affirming that there is no serious moral difference between the lower and higher estimated numbers. Speaking of the relative immorality of Communism and Nazism, Ryan said that the "body count tips the scales against Communism", but that if the "intrinsic evil of the entire project" is considered, Nazism is still worse because it was exterminationist.
953:, writing: "The Reich Security Head Office issued to the commandants a full collection of reports concerning the Russian concentration camps. These described in great detail the conditions in, and organization of, the Russian camps, as supplied by former prisoners who had managed to escape. Great emphasis was placed on the fact that the Russians, by their massive employment of forced labor, had destroyed whole peoples." His remarks and comparisons were deemed by critics to be
1084:, summarizing its response as "spurning reductionist sociology as a device to exculpate Communism", that "Marxist-Leninist regimes are cast in the same ideological and organizational mold throughout the world", and that "this pertinent point also had its admonitory subtext: that socialists of whatever stripe cannot be trusted to resist their ever-present demons on the far left (those popular fronts were no accident after all)."
505:
whether the ideology itself is "blameless", stating that "here will always be some nitpickers who maintain that actual
Communism has nothing in common with theoretical communism" and that "it would be absurd to claim that doctrines expounded prior to Jesus Christ, during the Renaissance, or even in the nineteenth century were responsible for the events that took place in the twentieth century." Quoting
548:
dear to
Bukharin, a revolution ultimately leading to massive upward mobility from the factory bench." Malia writes that "perhaps a moral, rather than a social, approach to the Communist phenomenon can yield a truer understanding for the much-investigated Soviet social process claimed victims on a scale that has never aroused a scholarly curiosity at all proportionate to the magnitude of the disaster."
1268:
David-Fox criticized the idea to connect the deaths with some "generic
Communism" concept, defined down to the common denominator of party movements founded by intellectuals. David-Fox also described "Malia's comparison and rhetorical equation of erstwhile social-history revisionists in the Soviet field with David Irving and other Holocaust deniers" as "a quintessentially ideological move."
1209:) publicly disassociated themselves from Courtois' statements in the introduction and criticized his editorial conduct. Margolin and Werth felt that Courtois was "obsessed" with arriving at a total of 100 million killed, which resulted in "sloppy and biased scholarship", faulted him for exaggerating death tolls in specific countries, and rejected the comparison between Communism and Nazism.
774:(think of North Korea, China, Cuba, Vietnam, where it is still alive, if not well). lasted between 1933 and 1945. Second, we simply do not know what the price in terms of victims of Nazism would have been had Hitler won the war. The logical hypothesis is that not only Jews and Gypsies but also millions of Slavs and other 'racially unfit' individuals would have been destined to death."
881:; rather than "indistinguishable evils", they emphasized a marked distinction in ideology. Courtois responded in the same newspaper with an essay in 1997. Werth compared the idea to ascribe all crimes committed by Communist states to communism with the idea to "throw in the face of a liberal the crimes committed in all the countries that claimed to be liberal." According to historian
820:: "The more you compare Communism and Nazism, the more the differences are obvious." Weiner wrote that "hen Stalin's successors opened the gates of the Gulag, they allowed 3 million inmates to return home. When the Allies liberated the Nazi death camps, they found thousands of human skeletons barely alive awaiting what they knew to be inevitable execution." Historian
996:. For Courtois, both Communist and Nazi systems deemed "a part of humanity unworthy of existence. The difference is that the Communist model is based on the class system, the Nazi model on race and territory." Courtois writes: "Here, the genocide of a 'class' may well be tantamount to the genocide of a "race"âthe deliberate starvation of a child of a Ukrainian
1019:
unavoidable comparison of this sum with that for Nazism, which at an estimated 25 million turns out to be distinctly less murderous than
Communism." According to Malia, "he shocking dimensions of the Communist tragedy" are "hardly news to any serious student of twentieth-century history, at least when the different Leninist regimes are taken individually."
4868:
1482:'s research on hunger. While India's democratic institutions prevented famines, its excess of mortality over Chinaâpotentially attributable to the latter's more equal distribution of medical and other resourcesâwas nonetheless close to 4 million per year for non-famine years. Chomsky wrote that "supposing we now apply the methodology of the
4679:
732:
mostly focused on three aspects, namely that the estimates were based on sparse and incomplete data when significant errors are inevitable, that the figures were skewed to higher possible values, and that those dying at war and victims of civil wars, Holodomor, and other famines under
Communist regimes should not be counted.
1030:. He states that Courtois raised the point of how Western intellectuals, Communist sympathizers and apologists for Communist leaders were complicit in Communist crimes, and that they only rejected them "discreetly and in silence." According to Malia, the French right has been tainted by its association with the Nazi
4799:
2010:, Margolin likened Courtois's effort to 'militant political activity, indeed, that of a prosecutor amassing charges in the service of a cause, that of a global condemnation of the Communist phenomenon as an essentially criminal phenomenon.' Both rejected the comparison between Communism and Nazism: ... ."
854:
academic journal, Marxist philosopher Robert Steigerwald wrote: "The book's main thesis reads thus: our century's fundamental crime was not the Holocaust, but rather the existence of Communism. Through the manipulation of numbersâonly twenty-five million human lives fell victim to Hitler, one hundred
794:
that "the Revolution of 1917 was one of the great events of the century. ... And if the had taken so long to denounce Stalinism, it had done so anyway." Jospin added that "the PCF had learned the lessons from its history. It is represented in my government and I'm proud of it." In a 21 November 1997
731:
This and other communist death tolls have been criticized by various historians and scholars. Any attempt to estimate a total number of killings under communist regimes depends greatly on definitions, ranging from a low of 10â20 million to as high as 110 million. Criticism of some of the estimates is
2438:
Dallin, Alexander (Winter 2000). "The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression. By Stéphane Courtois, Nicolas Werth, Jean-Louis Panné, Andrzej Paczkowski, Karel Bartoƥek, and Jean-Louis Margolin. Trans. Jonathan Murphy and Mark Kramer. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1999. xx,
1325:
summarized the authors as charging that Communism was a criminal system, while others such as Werth gave more nuanced views, and stated that "despite Courtois' brave attempt in the conclusion, however, the authors fail to answer their own central question: Why did communism, when in power, start and
1222:
and gives the date as 17 October 1917; the letter could hardly have originated at that time, since in it Lenin talks about the need to defeat the Tsarist government, and turn the war into a civil conflict. He gives credit to the Austro-Hungarian rather than the German army for the conquest of Poland
542:
According to Malia, there is a "basic problem" in Western historiography of Communism which he describes as "the conceptual poverty of the Western empirical effort." Malia states that "his poverty flows from the premise that Communism can be understood, in an aseptic and value-free mode, as the pure
533:
In his foreword to the English-language and American edition, Malia states that "Communism has been the great story of the twentieth century" and "it had come to rule a third of mankind and seemed poised to advance indefinitely. For seven decades it haunted world politics, polarizing opinion between
504:
Courtois writes that "egardless of the role that theoretical communist doctrines may have played in the practice of real Communism before 1917", it was what he terms "flesh-and-blood Communism" which "imposed wholesale repression, culminating in a state-sponsored reign of terror." Courtois then asks
1551:
states that the book has played a major role in what she terms the criminalization of Communism in the European political space in the post Cold War-era. According to Neumayer, "by making criminality the very essence of communism, by explicitly equating the 'race genocide' of Nazism with the 'class
1542:
has played a dual role, both chronicling the crimes of various Communist regimes and also serving as a text that reveals the shifting status of Marxism in the aftermath of the Cold War. Much of the controversy that has surrounded the book has focused on Stephane Courtois's introduction, in which he
1004:
as a result of the famine caused by the Nazi regime. According to Courtois, "the intransigent facts demonstrate that Communist regimes have victimized approximately 100 million people in contrast to the approximately 25 million of the Nazis." Courtois further says that "the Jewish genocide became a
769:
wrote: "Speaking of the number of victims under communist regimes (between 85 and 100 million) and comparing this horrible figure to number of people who perished under or because of Nazism (25 million), Courtois decided to downplay a few crucial facts. In this respect, some of his critics were not
547:
socialism, which necessitates the full suppression of private property, profit, and the market." The second one "purports to find the impetus behind Stalin's 'revolution from above' of 1929â1933 in a 'cultural revolution' from below by Party activists and workers against the 'bourgeois' specialists
538:
offers us the first attempt to determine, overall, the actual magnitude of what occurred, by systematically detailing Leninism's 'crimes, terror, and repression' from Russia in 1917 to Afghanistan in 1989." Malia also argues against what he terms "the fable of 'good Lenin/bad Stalin'", stating that
1470:
wrote that "o the extent that the book has a literary style, it is that of the recording angel; this is the body count of a colossal, wholly failed social, economic, political and psychological experiment. It is a criminal indictment, and it rightly reads like one." Ryan stated that the authors do
1330:
cited the numerous critiques, including it being called "a crudely anticommunist, anti-Semitic work", and agreed that "excessive moralizing makes objective analysis of the past difficultâand perhaps impossible", and the book has weaknesses but wrote that it has had two positive effects, among them
1099:
Malia asks "What of the moral equivalence of Communism and Nazism?" Malia writes that "fter fifty years of debate, it is clear that no matter what the hard facts are, degrees of totalitarian evil will be measured as much in terms of present politics as in terms of past realities" and that "we will
902:
stated that while "nalytical distinctions between them are certainly important, and sometimes Courtois does not emphasize them sufficiently", their "commonality in terms of complete contempt for the bourgeois state of law, human rights, and the universality of humankind regardless of spurious race
1254:
questioned "hether all these cases, from Hungary to Afghanistan, have a single essence and thus deserve to be lumped togetherâjust because they are labeled Marxist or communistâis a question the authors scarcely discuss." Historians Jens Mecklenburg and Wolfgang Wippermann wrote that a connection
1018:
Malia strongly agrees with Courtois, describing it as "a 'tragedy of planetary dimensions' ..., with a grand total of victims variously estimated by contributors to the volume at between 85 million and 100 million" and stating that what he terms the "full power of the shock" was "delivered by the
1009:
as a unique atrocity has also prevented the assessment of other episodes of comparable magnitude in the Communist world. After all, it seems scarcely plausible that the victors who had helped bring about the destruction of a genocidal apparatus might themselves have put the very same methods into
1212:
Several reviewers have singled out Werth's "State against Its People" as being the most notable and best researched contribution in the book. Historian Ronald Aronson stated that " is concerned, fortunately, neither to minimize nor to maximize numbers, but to accurately determine what happened."
1267:
criticized the figures as well as the idea to combine loosely connected events under a single category of Communist death toll, blaming Courtois for their manipulation and deliberate inflation which are presented to advocate the idea that Communism was a greater evil than Nazism. In particular,
1073:
as arguing that "it is illegitimate to speak of a single Communist movement from Phnom Penh to Paris. Rather, the rampage of the Khmer Rouge is like the ethnic massacres of third-world Rwanda, or the 'rural' Communism of Asia is radically different from the 'urban' Communism of Europe; or Asian
813:
Many observers have rejected Courtois' numerical and moral comparison of communism to Nazism in the introduction, the claim made in the book that "a lot of what they describe 'crimes, terror, and repression' has somehow been kept from the general public", According to Werth, there was still a
805:
wrote: "The comparison with Nazism is inevitable. It is merited on the grounds of the mutual commitment to social engineering through violent means; the ensuing demographic, psychological, and ethical implications; and, not least, the fact that both systems constantly scrutinized one another.
556:
According to the introduction, the number of people killed by the Communist governments amounts to more than 94 million. The statistics of victims include deaths through executions, man-made hunger, famine, war, deportations, and forced labor. The breakdown of the number of deaths is given as
1531:
may be seen as an effort to legitimize the claims to memorialization and reparations of those who suffered under Communism. Such claims have become high stakes in an era that frequently rewards those who can demonstrate that they, too, have been victimized in the past." In a 2001 article for
353:
regimes. The work was praised by a broad range of popular-press publications and historians, while academic press and specialist reviews were more critical or mixed for some historical inaccuracies. The introduction by Courtois was especially criticized, including by three of the book's main
1313:
stands out as a significant work that should be required reading for all modern historians. Each essay stands alone as an important scholarly contribution. At the same time, the essays hang together well. It is interesting also that all of the writers have political roots in European left."
1200:
Whereas chapters of the book that describe the events in separate Communist states were praised for the most part, some generalizations made by Courtois in the introduction to the book became a subject of criticism both on scholarly and political grounds. Moreover, three of the book's main
1053:
Malia writes that the "ultimate distinguishing characteristic" of Nazism is the Holocaust which, according to Malia, is considered as historically unique. He laments that "Hitler and Nazism are now a constant presence in Western print and on Western television", while "Stalin and Communism
4644:
1578:, their intense relationship with the Communist project could have similar consequences for the national psyche", and that Courtois, Lazar's former collaborator, believes French intellectuals have never "done their mourning of revolutionary ideology and of Leninism." A 2019 review for
1556:
contributed to legitimising the equivalence of Nazi and Communist crimes. The book figures prominently in the 'spaces of the anti-communist cause' comparably structured in the former satellite countries, which are a major source of the discourse criminalising the Socialist period."
2001:
s authors. ... Courtois's figures for the Soviet Union, Vietnam, and Latin America go far beyond the estimates of the authors themselves, as does Courtois's final body count. ... But two other theses created considerable consternation and have come to be associated with
824:
remarked that Courtois' comparison of 100 million victims of Communism to 25 million victims of Nazism leaves out "most of the 40â60,000,000 lives lost in the Second World War, for which arguably Hitler and not Stalin was principally responsible." Alongside philosopher
4650:
1604:
wrote that "the book was a turning point in the emergence of a consensual historical narrative across the former East-West divide as it enabled the formation of a revamped pan-European anti-communist movement." In a 2021 editorial in the eco-socialist journal
1103:
According to this argument, " moral man can have 'no enemies to the left,' a perspective in which undue insistence on Communist crime only 'plays into the hands of the right'âif, indeed, any anticommunism is not simply a mask for antiliberalism." Malia cites
473:, Courtois states that "the Communism that concerns us does not exist in the transcendent sphere of ideas. This Communism is altogether real; it has existed at key moments of history and in particular countries, brought to life by its famous leaders", citing
3740:
Wynot, Jennifer (Fall 2003). "Reviewed Work: The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression by Stéphane Courtois, Nicolas Werth, Jean-Louis Panné, Andrzej Paczkowski, Karel Bartoƥek, Jean-Louis Margolin, Jonathan Murphy, Mark Kramer, Martin Malia".
1298:
succeeds in demonstrating ... that Communism in its Leninist version (and, one must recognize, this has been the only successful application of the original dogma) was from the very outset inimical to the values of individual rights and human freedom." In
1074:
Communism is really only anticolonial nationalism", further stating that "conflating sociologically diverse movements" is "merely a stratagem to obtain a higher body count against Communism, and thus against all the left." He criticizes this as "
1275:
wrote that "he myth of the well-intentioned foundersâthe good czar Lenin betrayed by his evil heirsâhas been laid to rest for good. No one will any longer be able to claim ignorance or uncertainty about the criminal nature of Communism." In
1217:
criticized the chapter written by Werth, arguing that "Werth can also be an extremely careless historian. He gives the number of Bolsheviks in October 1917 as 2,000, which is a ridiculous underestimate. He quotes from a letter of Lenin to
4789:
1486:" to India, "the democratic capitalist 'experiment' has caused more deaths than in the entire history of ... Communism everywhere since 1917: over 100 million deaths by 1979, and tens of millions more since, in India alone." Historian
4749:
1965:
1679:
has not said everything." Like the first effort, this second work was edited by Courtois. The book focused on the history of Communism in Eastern Europe. Several translations of the book were marketed as the second volume of
1180:
has been especially influential in Eastern Europe, where it was uncritically embraced by prominent politicians and intellectualsâmany of these intellectuals popularized it using terminology and concepts popular with the
4706:
1331:
stirring a debate about the implementation of totalitarian ideologies and "an exhaustive balance sheet about one aspect of the worldwide phenomenon of communism." According to honorary professor David J. Galloway, "
4546:
4627:
1147:
titled "Die Aufarbeitung des Sozialismus in der DDR" ("The Processing of Socialism in the GDR"). It consists of two subchapters, namely "Politische Verbrechen in der DDR" ("Political Crimes in the GDR") by
757:
wrote that moral, legal, or political judgments hardly depend on the number of victims. Getty criticized Malia as a "specialist on the 19th century who has never done original research on the Soviet era."
454:
in the book. According to Courtois, "e must make a distinction between the doctrine of communism and its practice. As a political philosophy, communism has existed for centuries, even millennia." Citing
4804:
2475:
1592:(1997), these essays are both nuanced and balanced, presenting Lenin and Stalin as human leaders driven as much by realpolitik and personal histories and events as by Communist ideology." In a 2019
4578:
1600:"is still up for debate by historians, political scientists and economists. It's not an easy claim to fact-check, and is ultimately a matter of opinion." In 2020, political scientist Valentin Behr
1066:, who "was ostracized worldwide once his Nazi past was uncovered", while the same treatment was not applied to Communists, with Communist monuments still standing in the former Communist states.
1116:
is so opportune", much like Courtois' reasoning for writing the book that "the crimes of Communism have yet to receive a fair and just assessment from both historical and moral viewpoints."
1994:
Aronson wrote: "But most of these problems pale in significance compared with the book's opening and closing chapters, which caused enormous controversy and even occasioned a break among
358:
and giving a definitive number of "victims of communism", which critics have described as inflated. Werth's chapter, however, stood out as a positive. The book's title was chosen to echo
3613:
2860:
810:
reduce the comparison to body counting, charging communists with killing nearly 100 million people and the Nazis, 25 million. At best, this approach is ahistorical and demeaning."
1259:'s Cambodia and Joseph Stalin's Soviet Union are far from evident and that Pol Pot's study of Marxism in Paris is insufficient for connecting radical Soviet industrialism and the
1176:
for crimes against humanity for his role in the deportation of Jews from Bordeaux to Hitler's death camps. Papon's lawyers introduced the book as evidence for the defense." The
4794:
4764:
3536:
4809:
931:
systems, stating that Communist regimes have killed "approximately 100 million people in contrast to the approximately 25 million victims of the Nazis." Courtois claims that
438:
in his foreword. Courtois writes that "Communist regimes turned mass crime into a full-blown system of government" and are responsible for a greater number of deaths than
4571:
1005:
byword for modern barbarism, the epitome of twentieth-century mass terror. ... More recently, a single-minded focus on the Jewish genocide in an attempt to characterize
4298:[Renaud Escande (ed.), The Black Book of the French Revolution, 2008] (in French). Institut d'Histoire de la Révolution française. February 2008. Archived from
1639:
regimes, which are to be rigorously critiqued but should nonetheless be considered part of it, rather than denying any family resemblances with communism, like some on
753:
criticized Courtois for failing to draw a distinction between victims of neglect and famine and victims of "intentional murder." Regarding these questions, historian
4754:
1788:
1722:
prompted the publication of several other "black books" which argued that similar chronicles of violence and death tolls can be constructed from an examination of
341:
has been translated into numerous languages, has sold millions of copies, and is considered one of the most influential and controversial books written about the
1235:"is formulated in an extremely conservative way, since the actual number of victims was much larger", with 1,000,000â1,500,000 excess deaths. Historians such as
1574:, quoting fellow historian Marc Lazar as saying that "just as the intense relationship of the French with their national history created the conditions for the
1034:, whereas "'knowing the truth about the U.S.S.R.' has never been an academic matter" until the time the book was published. Malia then cites the example of the
855:
million to Communism worldwideâthe impression is created that Communism is four times worse than fascism and that the Holocaust was not a uniquely evil crime."
2182:
4564:
1929:
1172:"received both praise and criticism. ... The book was especially controversial in France because it was published during the 1997 trial of Nazi collaborator
525:
and Thomas More. Courtois claims that "the crimes of Communism have yet to receive a fair and just assessment from both historical and moral viewpoints."
4784:
1498:, the book ignores the effect of international factors, including military interventions, invasions, sanctions, and coups, on the Communist experience.
814:
qualitative difference between communism and Nazism, stating: "Death camps did not exist in the Soviet Union." On 21 September 2000, Werth further told
739:
wrote that "ome critics complained that Courtois was 'hunting' for the highest possible number of victims, which led him, as J. Arch Getty wrote in the
4919:
1951:
1335:
provides an excellent survey of scholarship on the Soviet system and the systems of other communist states", and said that this emphasis is valuable.
1227:
as 'elected'. He incorrectly writes that the peasant rebels during the civil war did more harm to the Reds than to the Whites, and so on." Historian
414:" of the 20th century; they distinguish it from small-c communism, which has existed for millennia, while capital-c Communism began in 1917 with the
4914:
3508:
4929:
4701:
4503:
4043:
3001:
by Stephane Courtois, Nicolas Werth, Jean-Louis Panne, Andrzej Paczkowski, Karel Bartosek, Jean-Louis Margolin, Jonathan Murphy and Mark Kramer"
4909:
4904:
2572:
by Stéphane Courtois, Nicolas Werth, Jean-Louis Panné, Andrzej Paczkowski, Karel Bartoƥek, Jean-Louis Margolin, Jonathan Murphy, Mark Kramer".
514:
4527:
4276:
4251:
4226:
4197:
3628:
3382:
3127:
3103:
2941:
2819:
2379:
2224:
2040:
1845:
246:
1321:
collapse the myth of a benign, initial phase of communism before it was diverted from the right path by circumstances." Political scientist
1026:) is incorporated into French law, the "class genocide" of Communism can be equated with the "race genocide" of Nazism and categorized as a
873:, they contributed to "the debates on comparisons between Nazism and communism", with SĂ©melin describing this as a theory also developed in
4899:
1915:
Karel BartoĆĄek (1930â2004), a historian from the Czech Republic and researcher at the Institut d'Histoire du Temps PrĂ©sent (IHTP) in Paris.
3634:
2870:
2771:
David-Fox, Michael (Winter 2004). "On the Primacy of Ideology: Soviet Revisionists and Holocaust Deniers (In Response to Martin Malia)".
2709:
4934:
4779:
2681:
518:
4661:
4600:
4435:
4175:
4154:
4133:
4112:
3416:
2067:
1783:
150:
3098:. Translated by Schoch, Cynthia. CERI Series in Comparative Politics and International Studies. New York: Columbia University Press.
4924:
4894:
4759:
4621:
4409:
4376:
4358:
4340:
3999:
3662:
3443:
3283:
3262:
2663:
2484:
1793:
710:
4218:
1054:
materialize only sporadically", with the status of former Communists carrying no stigma. Malia also laments a double standard in
699:
4889:
4869:
Presidential Commission of the Russian Federation to Counter Attempts to Falsify History to the Detriment of Russia's Interests
1919:
1534:
4066:
1232:
4427:
4295:
3146:
Reid, Donald (June 2005). "In Search of the Communist Syndrome: Opening the Black Book of the New Anti-Communism in France".
1753:
and received mostly negative reviews from both the press and historians. Courtois went back to its proposed link between the
1580:
1450:
1396:
1224:
973:. Courtois defended himself from the charges by citing the Russian-Jewish writer Vasily Grossman, who compared the deaths of
446:' that began in Sarajevo in 1914 and ended in Moscow in 1991, finds itself at center states in the story. Communism predated
360:
3924:
3561:
2718:
903:
and class distinctions is in my view beyond doubt." TismÄneanu said that in making this comparison, Courtois was drawing on
3463:
509:("Revolutions, like trees, are recognized by the fruit they bear"), Courtois says that "t was not without reason" that the
3854:
1839:
1543:
argues that communism represents a greater evil than Nazism, largely based on Marxism-Leninism's heftier death tally." In
1432:
1301:
562:
377:
4390:
1832:
1562:
950:
450:
and Nazism, outlived both, and left its mark on four continents." Courtois goes on to explain what is meant by the term
365:
4451:. Harvard University. 15 October 1999. Retrieved 18 August 2021. Extracts by the publisher from many different reviews.
2738:
1974:
Pierre Rigoulet, a political historian, human rights activist and researcher at the Institut d'Histoire Sociale (IHTP).
1527:
s relatively scanty scholarly contribution, it is hard to read the book in other than political terms. In this regard,
3192:
TismÄneanu, Vladimir (January 2001). "Communism and the Human Condition: Reflections on the Black Book of Communism".
1607:
1306:
1244:
720:
346:
801:, Courtois stated: "In my opinion, there is nothing exceptional about the Nazi genocide against the Jews." Historian
770:
wrong. First, as an expansionist global phenomenon, Communism lasted between 1917 and the time of the completion of
4716:
1961:
870:
791:
312:
186:
37:
1851:
4834:
4711:
4696:
4415:
1426:
615:
10,000 deaths "resulting from actions of the international Communist movement and Communist parties not in power"
4800:
International Commission for the Evaluation of the Crimes of the Nazi and Soviet Occupation Regimes in Lithuania
4459:
4333:
From the Gulag to the Killing Fields: Personal Accounts of Political Violence and Repression in Communist States
2152:
4944:
4386:
2371:
1875:
970:
783:
316:
218:
3066:
3061:
1652:
1620:
1588:
said: "Unlike the cardboard cutouts of Communist leadership presented in ideologically charged studies like
1444:
1124:
443:
288:
3676:
2639:
4939:
1863:
1746:
1491:
1291:
1281:
1182:
1039:
1035:
1027:
1000:
as a result of the famine caused by Stalin's regime 'is equal to' the starvation of a Jewish child in the
935:'s methods of mass extermination were adopted from Soviet methods. As an example, Courtois cites the Nazi
899:
766:
630:
168:
4448:
3972:
3408:
3028:
1811:
1286:
1219:
4500:
3945:Ć kof, Lenart (2012). "Two Recurrences of an Idea: On Political and Ethical Vicissitudes of Democracy".
2896:
403:
3231:
2345:
1236:
91:
4774:
4726:
3087:
2361:
1925:
1818:
1798:
1734:
1456:
1128:
419:
415:
342:
300:
276:
260:
145:
51:
1087:
Malia writes that by reducing politics and ideology to anthropology, it "assure us that contrary to
4667:
4655:
4645:
European Public Hearing on European Conscience and Crimes of Totalitarian Communism: 20 Years After
3709:
Lauber, Jack M. (2000). "Feature Review: The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression".
3464:"A Tale of 'Two Totalitarianisms': The Crisis of Capitalism and the Historical Memory of Communism"
2597:
DuliÄ, Tomislav (2004). "Tito's Slaughterhouse: A Critical Analysis of Rummel's Work on Democide".
2357:
1947:
1771:
1632:
1512:
1462:
1366:
1348:
1202:
894:
746:
434:
The introduction, written by Courtois, was the main source of controversy, and was acknowledged by
272:
75:
4523:
4065:
Behr, Valentin; Blaive, Muriel; Constantin, Anenoma; Neumayer, Laure; Zombory, Måté (April 2020).
1152:
and "Vom schwierigen Umgang mit der Wahrnehmung" ("On the Difficulty of Handling Perceptions") by
1042:
votes to gain a parliamentary majority. While the non-Gaullist right cited the book to attack the
442:
or any other political system. Courtois says that "Communism, the defining characteristic of the '
4680:
European Parliament resolution on the importance of European remembrance for the future of Europe
4673:
4633:
4397:
4086:
3836:
3807:
3750:
3722:
3530:
3486:
3351:
3311:
3209:
3171:
3163:
3020:
2974:
2825:
2622:
2614:
2581:
2545:
2513:
2456:
2416:
2349:
1957:
1857:
1758:
1640:
1390:
1327:
1240:
1010:
practice. When faced with this paradox, people generally preferred to bury their heads in sand."
946:
882:
821:
736:
522:
264:
86:
3579:
3091:
1938:
RĂ©mi Kauffer, a specialist in the history of intelligence, terrorism and clandestine operations.
1346:
received praise in many publications in the United Kingdom and the United States, including the
889:
is not "about communism as an ideology or even about communism as a state-building phenomenon."
858:
833:
commented that Courtois' death toll estimate for Nazism "conveniently" excludes those killed in
4478:
3490:
4431:
4423:
4405:
4372:
4354:
4346:
4336:
4272:
4247:
4222:
4193:
4171:
4150:
4129:
4108:
3995:
3684:
3658:
3624:
3439:
3412:
3378:
3279:
3258:
3123:
3099:
2937:
2815:
2659:
2480:
2375:
2220:
2190:
2063:
2036:
1754:
1703:
1414:
1264:
966:
958:
332:
241:
96:
64:
4842:
4744:
4639:
4489:
4078:
4024:
3895:
3777:
3714:
3594:
3513:
3504:
3478:
3343:
3201:
3155:
3012:
2966:
2807:
2780:
2651:
2606:
2505:
2448:
2131:
2101:
1882:
1825:
1804:
1487:
1408:
1384:
1354:
1251:
1189:
1059:
1023:
850:, and other critics also denounced it as antisemitic, a charge Malia disagreed with. In the
754:
741:
637:
486:
461:
407:
3768:
Pekacz, Jolanta T. (2001). "Twentieth-Century CommunismâThe Rise and Fall of an Illusion".
2532:
Kuromiya, Hiroaki (January 2001). "Review Article: Communism and Terror. Reviewed Work(s):
1143:
The German edition contains an additional chapter on the Soviet-backed Communist regime in
984:
Courtois states that the Soviet crimes against peoples living in the Caucasus and of large
17:
4769:
4531:
4507:
4463:
3963:
3565:
3459:
3398:
3053:
1636:
1495:
1420:
1402:
1378:
1360:
1149:
1055:
915:
904:
830:
373:
350:
280:
173:
140:
127:
80:
4244:
Le livre noir du colonialisme: XVIe-XXIe siĂšcle : de l'extermination Ă la repentance
3967:
3011:(3). Oxford University Press on behalf of the Organization of American Historians: 1156.
2934:
French Writers and the Politics of Complicity: Crises of Democracy in the 1940s and 1990s
1538:, professor of history Shane J. Maddock wrote: "Since its publication in France in 1997,
335:
was originally slated to write the introduction, but he died before being able to do so.
1619:
as "a 1997 propaganda volume that suits a more recent China-bashing campaign, where the
626:
The murder of hundreds of thousands of rebellious workers and peasants from 1918 to 1922
4587:
4382:
4328:
4324:
3987:
2353:
2153:"Reviews: The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression by Stéphane Courtois"
1575:
1571:
1552:
genocide' of Communism in connection with the Ukrainian Great Famine of 1932â1933, the
1548:
1372:
1322:
1228:
942:
714:
662:
506:
498:
482:
478:
411:
369:
4556:
4553:. Institute on Religion and Public Life (2): 56. Retrieved 14 January 2022 â via Gale.
4067:"An Anti-Communist Consensus: The Black Book of Communism in Pan-European Perspective"
4883:
4512:
4090:
3726:
3371:
3355:
3213:
3175:
2978:
2957:
Bartov, Omer (Spring 2002). "Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History".
2829:
2677:
2626:
2341:
2135:
1980:
1206:
1173:
1153:
1088:
1063:
1006:
1001:
909:
787:
750:
724:
703:
692:
680:
610:
494:
328:
268:
103:
69:
3482:
3992:
The Criminalisation of Communism in the European Political Space after the Cold War
2803:
The Devil in History: Communism, Fascism, and Some Lessons of the Twentieth Century
1941:
1593:
1545:
The Criminalisation of Communism in the European Political Space after the Cold War
1475:
1144:
1031:
985:
932:
928:
834:
641:
598:
568:
474:
435:
381:
324:
320:
4299:
3900:
3883:
3334:(2001). "What Future for the Future? Reflections on the Black Book of Communism".
3159:
1718:
down into series of discrete movements, with mixed positive and negative results.
4369:
The Burden of Responsibility: Blum, Camus, Aron, and the French Twentieth Century
3916:
3553:
3433:
3117:
2801:
2655:
2365:
2122:
Suny, Ronald Grigor (2007). "Russian Terror/ism and Revisionist Historiography".
2057:
877:. Margolin, along with Werth, addressed this comparison in a response printed in
3331:
3057:
3032:
1727:
1517:
1479:
1438:
1260:
1214:
1075:
1043:
978:
954:
847:
826:
802:
655:
592:
580:
490:
466:
292:
619:
According to Courtois, the crimes by the Soviet Union included the following:
4850:
4790:
Estonian International Commission for Investigation of Crimes Against Humanity
4721:
3718:
3347:
3205:
2811:
1777:
1723:
1165:
1132:
993:
862:
684:
510:
296:
4750:
Office for the Documentation and the Investigation of the Crimes of Communism
3688:
2996:
2610:
2194:
4496:. Harvard University Press. Retrieved 18 August 2021 â via Internet Archive.
4364:
4082:
4015:
Burds, Jeffrey (April 2019). "The Cambridge History of Communism (Review)".
3233:
Distortion, negationism and minimization of the Holocaust in postwar Romania
2865:
2536:
by Stephane Courtois; Reflections on a Ravaged Century by Robert Conquest".
2105:
1869:
1715:
1656:
1628:
1624:
1467:
1272:
1080:
1047:
688:
673:
394:
162:
3598:
4351:
The Passing of an Illusion: The Idea of Communism in the Twentieth Century
4044:"Did Over 100 Million People Die under Communism during the 20th Century?"
3831:. American Association of Teachers of Slavic and East European Languages.
3402:
2970:
2784:
1478:
criticized the book and its reception as one-sided by outlining economist
4028:
3781:
2686:
866:
842:
816:
797:
586:
574:
399:
284:
154:
4105:
Du passé faisons table rase! Histoire et mémoire du communisme en Europe
3811:
3754:
3239:. International Commission on the Holocaust in Romania. pp. 47, 59.
3230:
Friling, Tuvia; Ioanid, Radu; Ionescu, Mihail E.; Benjamin, Lya (2004).
3167:
2420:
1935:
Pascal Fontaine, a journalist with a special knowledge of Latin America.
1673:
Du passé faisons table rase! Histoire et mémoire du communisme en Europe
1231:
stated that the book's estimate of "at least 500,000" deaths during the
4296:"Renaud Escande (dir.), Le Livre Noir de la Révolution française, 2008"
3840:
3614:"War die Hungersnot in der Ukraine intendiert? (Submission in English)"
3315:
3024:
2618:
2585:
2460:
1971:
Jean-Louis Panné, a specialist on the international Communist movement.
1256:
604:
447:
4707:
Act on Illegality of the Communist Regime and on Resistance Against It
3884:"Anti-Communism and the Hundreds of Millions of Victims of Capitalism"
2800:
TismÄneanu, Vladimir (2012). "Utopian Radicalism and Dehumanization".
2549:
2517:
2059:
The Haunting Past: History, Memory, and Justice in Contemporary France
1022:
Malia mentions Courtois' argument that since Nuremberg jurisprudence (
927:
Courtois considers Communism and Nazism to be distinct yet comparable
4455:
3255:
Das Schwarzbuch des Kommunismus. UnterdrĂŒckung, Verbrechen und Terror
439:
355:
304:
158:
3016:
2452:
2407:
Paczkowski, Andrzej (Spring 2001). "The Storm over the Black Book".
1960:, the deputy director of the Institute for Political Studies of the
1944:, a historian and the author of the foreword to the English edition.
4628:
European Public Hearing on Crimes Committed by Totalitarian Regimes
3877:
3875:
2806:(E-book ed.). University of California Press. pp. 18â52.
2650:. SpringerBriefs on Pioneers in Science and Practice. pp. 111â129.
2509:
1243:
challenged the authors' thesis that the famine of 1933 was largely
4402:
Red Flag Unfurled: History, Historians, and the Russian Revolution
1596:
article, Naphtali Khumalo said that the 100 million estimate from
997:
974:
962:
666:
648:
456:
4126:
Das Schwarzbuch des Kommunismus 2. Das schwere Erbe der Ideologie
2918:(2). Marxist Educational Press, University of Minnesota: 241â251.
521:, called themselves "Communists", and erected monuments to honor
3580:"The 1947 Soviet Famine and the Entitlement Approach to Famines"
3373:
Aversion and Erasure: The Fate of the Victim After the Holocaust
1702:, a collective work of twenty academics, was a response to both
1686:
Das Schwarzbuch of Kommunismus 2. Das schwere Erbe der Ideologie
1675:
with the same imprint. The first edition included the subtitle "
1317:
Historian Jolanta Pekacz said that the "archival revelations of
423:
275:, and several other European academics documenting a history of
4560:
3621:
Roter Holocaust? : Kritik des Schwarzbuchs des Kommunismus
3096:
Purify and Destroy: The Political Uses of Massacre and Genocide
2439:
858 pp. Notes. Index. Photographs. Maps. $ 37.50, hard bound".
2185:[Divisions among the team of historians of Communism].
1046:"for harboring allies with an unrepented 'criminal past'", the
846:
denounced the introduction, the main source of controversy, as
4805:
Institute for the Investigation of Communist Crimes in Romania
4335:(hardcover ed.). Intercollegiate Studies Institute hardcover.
4269:
Schwarzbuch Kapitalismus: ein Abgesang auf die Marktwirtschaft
2496:
Harff, Barbara (1996). "Death by Government by R. J. Rummel".
2476:
Final Solutions: Mass Killing and Genocide in the 20th Century
1876:
The Black Book of Capitalism: A farewell to the market economy
1263:'s murderous anti-urbanism under the same category. Historian
992:
and were not very much different from similar policies by the
4547:"The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, and Repression"
1954:
and a researcher at the Research Institute on Southeast Asia.
1671:
was followed by the publication in 2002 of a series entitled
4353:. Translated by Deborah Furet. University of Chicago Press.
623:
The execution of tens of thousands of hostages and prisoners
4551:
First Things: A Monthly Journal of Religion and Public Life
4371:(illustrated, reprinted ed.). University of Chicago Press.
3970:[Communism: The Falsifuication of a "Black Book"].
3304:
The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, and Repression
2899:
The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, and Repression
2534:
The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, and Repression
977:' children to those of Jewish children who were put in the
937:
2640:"The Comparative Analysis of Mass Atrocities and Genocide"
829:, anthropologist and postsocialist gender studies scholar
3655:
Roter Holocaust'? Kritik des Schwarzbuchs des Kommunismus
3310:(110, Special Edition: Frontiers of Knowledge): 166â169.
2897:"Review Article: Communism and Terror. Reviewed Work(s):
1294:, whose work focuses on Eastern Europe, stated that "the
676:) and 2 million others during the famine of 1932 and 1933
4213:
Bordier, Roger; Frémion, Yves; Perrault, Gilles (2001).
3827:
by Stephane Courtois, Jonathan Murphy and Mark Kramer".
3300:
Le Livre noir du communisme: Crimes, terreur, répression
2092:
Aronson, Ronald (2003). "Communism's posthumous trial".
1139:
German edition: "The Processing of Socialism in the GDR"
309:
Le Livre noir du communisme: Crimes, terreur, répression
4634:
Prague Declaration on European Conscience and Communism
4542:(3) Retrieved 18 August 2021 â via History Cooperative.
4519:. Retrieved 18 August 2021 â via Faits & Documents.
3825:
The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression
3796:
The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression
2999:
The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression
2570:
The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression
2367:
The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression
2336:
2334:
2332:
2330:
2328:
2326:
2324:
2322:
2320:
2318:
2316:
2314:
2312:
2310:
2308:
2306:
2304:
2302:
2300:
2298:
2296:
2294:
2292:
2290:
2288:
2286:
2284:
2282:
2280:
2278:
2276:
2274:
2272:
2270:
2268:
2266:
2264:
2262:
2260:
2258:
2256:
2183:"Les divisions d'une Ă©quipe d'historiens du communisme"
1590:
The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression
256:
The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression
3650:
Mecklenburg, Jens; Wippermann, Wolfgang, eds. (1998).
2254:
2252:
2250:
2248:
2246:
2244:
2242:
2240:
2238:
2236:
665:, resulting in the deportation of 2 million so-called
331:. The introduction was written by Courtois. Historian
3882:
Engel-Di Mauro, Salvatore; et al. (4 May 2021).
3404:
Red Hangover: Legacies of Twentieth-Century Communism
2773:
Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History
2176:
2174:
2172:
2170:
4795:
Genocide and Resistance Research Centre of Lithuania
4765:
Institute for Information on the Crimes of Communism
3619:. In Mecklenburg, Jens; Wolfgang Wippermann (eds.).
2644:
R.J. Rummel: An Assessment of His Many Contributions
1623:
is purposefully conflated with communism. Just like
4861:
4818:
4810:
Hannah Arendt Institute for Totalitarianism Studies
4737:
4689:
4610:
3435:
The Strange Death of Soviet Communism: A Postscript
3249:Stéphane Courtois, Joachim Gauck, Ehrhart Neubert,
2890:
2888:
2033:
Representing the Shoah for the Twenty-first Century
790:responded to the book's claims and declared to the
240:
232:
224:
210:
202:
192:
182:
133:
123:
113:
57:
47:
3968:"Communisme, les falsifications d'un 'livre noir'"
3370:
3187:
3185:
2795:
2793:
2403:
2401:
2399:
2397:
2395:
2393:
2391:
1918:Sylvain Boulouque, a research associate at GEODE,
1651:is used as an anti-communist trope to dismiss any
4640:European Parliament declaration of 23 August 2008
3657:. Hamburg: Konkret Verlag Literatur (in German).
3119:Stalinism and Nazism: History and Memory Compared
2854:
2852:
2850:
2848:
2846:
2767:
2765:
2763:
2217:Stalinism and Nazism: History and Memory Compared
2147:
2145:
1627:should not be confused with chaos and terrorism,
1305:, the journal of the Institute of History of the
1038:prime minister Lionel Jospin, who was in need of
364:, a documentary record of Nazi atrocities in the
307:. The book was originally published in France as
3535:: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (
3517:. Archived from the original on 13 February 2002
2748:. Vol. 285, no. 3. Boston. p. 113
2528:
2526:
2031:Ronit Lenáčin; Mike Dennis; Eva Kolinsky (2003).
1964:and a member of the archival commission for the
1741:. In 2008, Courtois took part to the writing of
1280:, Jack M. Lauber compared its impact to that of
640:, a policy of systematic repression against the
4755:Institute for the Study of Totalitarian Regimes
3294:
3292:
2990:
2988:
1789:Crimes against humanity under communist regimes
4651:European Parliament resolution of 2 April 2009
4420:Tombstone: The Great Chinese Famine, 1958â1962
3326:
3324:
3116:Golsan, Richard Joseph; Rousso, Henry (2004).
2927:
2925:
2564:
2562:
2560:
2558:
2433:
2431:
2429:
2087:
2085:
2083:
2081:
2079:
4572:
4290:
4288:
3548:
3546:
2732:
2730:
2728:
1078:condescension." Malia cites the conservative
907:'s earlier explorations of the same theme in
8:
4422:(hardcover ed.). Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
3141:
3139:
2708:Becker, Jean-Jacques (JulyâSeptember 1998).
2684:[Communism: Return to the History].
2124:Australian Journal of Politics & History
1930:Centre national de la recherche scientifique
315:. In the United States, it was published by
30:
3794:Legvold, Robert (NovemberâDecember 1999). "
2714: : de la polémique à la compréhension"
2117:
2115:
1932:and the main author and editor of the book.
1566:article, historian Donald Reid states that
1494:defended the book. According to journalist
4785:Reconciliation of European Histories Group
4775:Federal Commissioner for the Stasi Records
4579:
4565:
4557:
2447:(4). Cambridge University Press: 882â883.
1647:, the 100 million estimate popularized by
633:which caused the death of 5 million people
36:
29:
3899:
3798:by Stéphane Courtois and Nicolas Werth".
1983:, a historian and researcher at the IHTP.
1903:The book was published in English in 1999
354:contributors, for comparing communism to
27:1997 book by Stéphane Courtois and others
4492:ЧŃŃĐœĐ°Ń ĐșĐœĐžĐłĐ° ĐșĐŸĐŒĐŒŃĐœĐžĐ·ĐŒĐ° (Russian ed.).
3225:
3223:
2498:The Journal of Interdisciplinary History
861:writes that Courtois and Margolin "view
4023:(2). Oxford University Press: 595â599.
2863:[The Black Book of Communism].
2682:"Communisme : retour Ă l'histoire"
2023:
1912:The full list of contributors include:
1896:
1743:The Black Book of the French Revolution
695:from 1939 to 1941 and from 1944 to 1945
651:during the period between 1918 and 1930
647:The murder of tens of thousands in the
469:as communist examples of what he terms
430:Introduction: "The Crimes of Communism"
406:communism, i.e., the actually existing
345:in the 20th century, in particular the
4242:Beaufils, Thomas; Ferro, Marc (2003).
4042:Khumalo, Naphtali (5 September 2019).
3528:
1749:which proved to be controversial like
1631:should not be confused, like those on
515:Russian Social Democratic Labour Party
4499:Joffrin, Laurent (17 December 1997).
4387:"Hitler vs. Stalin: Who Killed More?"
4071:Revue d'Ă©tudes comparatives Est-Ouest
3623:. Hamburg: Konkret Literatur Verlag.
2859:Paolo, Paul-François (24 July 2012).
1846:Mass killings under communist regimes
7:
4454:Bourrinet, Philippe (18 March 2002)
4147:Chernata kniga na komunizma 2. chast
3829:The Slavic and East European Journal
3257:(in German). MĂŒnchen: Piper Verlag.
3154:(2). Taylor & Francis: 295â318.
2574:Journal of Interdisciplinary History
2062:. University of Pennsylvania Press.
1690:Chernata kniga na komunizma 2. chast
988:in the Soviet Union could be called
4522:Maddock, Shane J. (December 2001).
4168:Il libro del nero comunismo europeo
4107:(in French). Paris: Robert Laffon.
3823:Galloway, David J. (Autumn 2001). "
2995:Maddock, Shane J. (December 2001).
1966:Polish Ministry of Internal Affairs
1694:Il libro nero del comunismo europeo
1062:, citing former Austrian president
672:The death of 4 million Ukrainians (
323:. The German edition, published by
4662:Declaration on Crimes of Communism
4601:Comparison of Nazism and Stalinism
4484:Courtois, Stéphane; Kramer, Mark;
4149:(in Bulgarian). Sofia: Prosoretz.
3927:from the original on 27 March 2018
3278:. University of California Press.
2719:VingtiĂšme siĂšcle. Revue d'histoire
2181:Chemin, Ariane (30 October 1997).
1928:, the director of research at the
1784:Comparison of Nazism and Stalinism
1586:The Cambridge History of Communism
806:Unfortunately, the authors of the
778:Comparison of communism and Nazism
658:which killed almost 690,000 people
151:Comparison of Nazism and Communism
25:
4760:Institute of National Remembrance
4622:Council of Europe resolution 1481
4473:. Retrieved 18 August 2021 â via
3552:Kenez, Peter (30 November 1999).
3298:Hoffman, Stanley (Spring 1998). "
1794:Criticism of communist party rule
1643:do." According to Engel-Di Mauro
1188:According to political scientist
4780:Berlin-Hohenschönhausen Memorial
4545:Radosh, Ronald (February 2000).
4170:(in Italian). Milan: Mondadori.
4166:Courtois, Stéphane, ed. (2006).
4145:Courtois, Stéphane, ed. (2004).
4124:Courtois, Stéphane, ed. (2004).
4103:Courtois, Stéphane, ed. (2002).
4077:(2â3). Ăditions NecPlus: 55â88.
3802:. Council on Foreign Relations.
3148:The International History Review
3122:. University of Nebraska Press.
2136:10.1111/j.1467-8497.2007.00439.x
2056:Rousso, Henry (7 January 2002).
529:Foreword: "The Uses of Atrocity"
327:, includes a chapter written by
4915:Collaborative non-fiction books
4656:Vilnius Declaration of the OSCE
4456:"Du bon usage des livres noirs"
3675:Judt, Tony (22 December 1997).
3491:10.5406/historypresent.4.2.0115
3483:10.5406/historypresent.4.2.0115
3005:The Journal of American History
2538:Journal of Contemporary History
2035:. Berghahn Books. p. 217.
1535:The Journal of American History
1050:"remained awkwardly in place."
4930:Harvard University Press books
4404:(hardcover ed.). Verso Books.
4017:The American Historical Review
3587:Cambridge Journal of Economics
1581:The American Historical Review
1451:The Washington Post Book World
1397:The New York Times Book Review
1326:stay so murderous?" Historian
1201:contributors (Karel Bartosek,
782:On 12 November 1997, the then-
361:The Black Book of Soviet Jewry
1:
4920:Ăditions Robert Laffont books
4905:Books about Soviet repression
4668:Stockholm Programme of the EU
4449:"The Black Book of Communism"
3901:10.1080/10455752.2021.1875603
3853:Ryan, Alan (2 January 2000).
3711:History: Reviews of New Books
3369:Dean, Carolyn Janice (2010).
3160:10.1080/07075332.2005.9641061
2861:"Le Livre noir du communisme"
2568:Weiner, Amir (Winter 2002). "
1977:Yves Santamaria, a historian.
1840:Le Livre noir du colonialisme
1433:The Times Literary Supplement
1278:History: Reviews of New Books
961:criticized the comparison of
513:, whose party was called the
378:Jewish Anti-Fascist Committee
4674:Warsaw Declaration of the EU
4391:The New York Review of Books
4215:Le livre noir du capitalisme
4128:(in German). Munich: Piper.
3432:Gvosdev, Nikolas K. (2008).
3377:. Cornell University Press.
2912:Nature, Society, and Thought
2901:edited by Stéphane Courtois
2895:Robert, Steigerwald (1999).
2737:Getty, J Arch (March 2000).
2656:10.1007/978-3-319-54463-2_12
2479:. Cornell University Press.
2473:Valentino, Benjamin (2005).
1833:Le Livre noir du capitalisme
1563:International History Review
1547:(2018), political scientist
951:Auschwitz concentration camp
865:as the equivalent to racial
852:Nature, Society, and Thought
42:Cover of the English edition
31:The Black Book of Communism
4900:Books critical of communism
4827:The Black Book of Communism
4536:Journal of American History
4490:"Chornaya kniga kommunizma"
4394:. Retrieved 18 August 2021.
3888:Capitalism Nature Socialism
3770:Canadian Journal of History
2932:Golsan, Richard J. (2006).
2869:(in French). Archived from
2712:Le Livre noir du communisme
2642:. In Gleditsch, N. P., ed.
2215:Rousso, Henry, ed. (2004).
1751:The Black Book of Communism
1720:The Black Book of Communism
1712:The Black Book of Communism
1682:The Black Book of Communism
1677:The Black Book of Communism
1649:The Black Book of Communism
1617:The Black Book of Communism
1611:, Salvatore Engel-Di Mauro
1608:Capitalism Nature Socialism
1598:The Black Book of Communism
1568:The Black Book of Communism
1540:The Black Book of Communism
1508:The Black Book of Communism
1344:The Black Book of Communism
1311:The Black Book of Communism
1307:Russian Academy of Sciences
1170:The Black Book of Communism
1121:The Black Book of Communism
1110:The Black Book of Communism
945:who organized the infamous
887:The Black Book of Communism
875:The Black Book of Communism
552:Estimated number of victims
501:as examples of the latter.
347:history of the Soviet Union
339:The Black Book of Communism
118:Le Livre noir du communisme
18:The black book of communism
4961:
4935:History books about famine
4910:Books by Stéphane Courtois
4717:Decommunization in Ukraine
3677:"The Longest Road to Hell"
3438:. Transaction Publishers.
3276:How We Forgot the Cold War
2722:(59). JulyâSeptember 1998.
2155:. Harvard University Press
1962:Polish Academy of Sciences
1739:Dictionnaire du communisme
1233:Soviet famine of 1946â1947
1223:in 1915. He describes the
563:People's Republic of China
4835:Between Hitler and Stalin
4712:Decommunization in Russia
4697:Bans on communist symbols
4595:
4192:. Ăditions de l'Atelier.
4190:Le SiĂšcle des communismes
3719:10.1080/03612750009604252
3568:. Retrieved 1 March 2000.
3348:10.1007/s12142-001-1028-0
3306:) by Stéphane Courtois".
3206:10.1007/s12142-001-1027-1
2812:10.1525/9780520954175-003
2739:"The Future Did Not Work"
2599:Journal of Peace Research
1733:In 2007, Courtois edited
1700:Le SiĂšcle des communismes
1427:The Saturday Evening Post
1309:, Jennifer Wynot wrote: "
392:The authors use the term
212:Published in English
35:
4925:French non-fiction books
4895:Anti-communism in France
4530:20 February 2008 at the
4188:Dreyfus, Michel (2000).
3578:Ellman, Michael (2000).
2611:10.1177/0022343304040051
2372:Harvard University Press
1621:Communist Party of China
1570:opened the way to a new
1245:artificial and genocidal
1069:Malia cites the liberal
971:Holocaust trivialization
840:At least one scholar in
784:Prime Minister of France
317:Harvard University Press
289:extrajudicial executions
219:Harvard University Press
4506:8 December 2002 at the
4327:(2006). "Foreword". In
4271:. Frankfurt: Eichborn.
4083:10.3917/receo1.512.0055
2638:Harff, Barbara (2017),
2106:10.1111/1468-2303.00240
1852:Le Passé d'une illusion
1708:Le passé d'une Illusion
1669:Black Book of Communism
1653:criticism of capitalism
1554:Black Book of Communism
1445:The Wall Street Journal
1296:Black Book of Communism
1178:Black Book of Communism
1164:According to historian
1125:crimes against humanity
723:and deportation of the
519:Russian Communist Party
444:short twentieth century
313:Ăditions Robert Laffont
187:Ăditions Robert Laffont
4890:1997 non-fiction books
4770:House of Terror Museum
3947:Synthesis philosophica
3894:(1). Routledge: 1â17.
3509:"The Price of an Idea"
3471:History of the Present
2676:Margolin, Jean-Louis;
1952:Université de Provence
1864:Mao: The Unknown Story
1747:historical revisionism
1290:. Political scientist
1282:Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
1255:between the events in
1225:Provisional Government
1028:crime against humanity
892:In a 2001 article for
765:, political scientist
691:, and people from the
631:Russian famine of 1921
169:Double genocide theory
4462:11 March 2008 at the
4267:Kurz, Robert (2009).
4246:. Paris: R. Laffont.
3973:Le Monde diplomatique
3917:"Counting the Bodies"
3612:Tauger, Mark (1998).
3409:Duke University Press
3088:Jaffrelot, Christophe
3062:"Anti-anti-communism"
3042:– via ProQuest.
2971:10.1353/kri.2002.0016
2785:10.1353/kri.2004.0007
1812:The Gulag Archipelago
1287:The Gulag Archipelago
1220:Alexander Shliapnikov
644:between 1917 and 1933
319:, with a foreword by
4590:in Europe since 1989
4468:Aujourd'hui le Maroc
4219:Le Temps des cerises
3782:10.3138/cjh.36.2.311
3640:on 4 September 2006.
3599:10.1093/cje/24.5.603
3564:1 March 2000 at the
3507:(20 December 1999).
3274:Wiener, Jon (2012).
2680:(14 November 1997).
2409:The Wilson Quarterly
2358:Margolin, Jean-Louis
1950:, a lecturer at the
1819:The Stalinist Legacy
1799:Criticism of Marxism
1745:, a similar work of
1457:The Washington Times
1129:crimes against peace
965:victims with Jewish
763:The Devil in History
679:The deportations of
517:, renamed it as the
416:Bolshevik Revolution
343:history of communism
277:political repression
146:History of communism
4475:Left-Wing Communism
4398:Suny, Ronald Grigor
4302:on 25 February 2008
3554:"Little Black Book"
3336:Human Rights Review
3194:Human Rights Review
2350:Paczkowski, Andrzej
1948:Jean-Louis Margolin
1772:Anti-Stalinist Left
1520:wrote: "In view of
1513:Human Rights Review
1492:Jean-François Revel
1463:The Weekly Standard
1367:Insight on the News
1349:East Valley Tribune
1292:Vladimir TismÄneanu
1203:Jean-Louis Margolin
900:Vladimir TismÄneanu
895:Human Rights Review
767:Vladimir TismÄneanu
747:Jean-Jacques Becker
273:Jean-Louis Margolin
114:Original title
76:Jean-Louis Margolin
32:
4611:European hearings,
4029:10.1093/ahr/rhz214
3859:The New York Times
3681:The New York Times
2362:Courtois, Stéphane
2094:History and Theory
1958:Andrzej Paczkowski
1920:Université Paris X
1858:Prague Declaration
1759:October Revolution
1391:The New York Times
1328:Andrzej Paczkowski
957:. A report by the
947:extermination camp
883:Andrzej Paczkowski
822:Ronald Grigor Suny
737:Andrzej Paczkowski
567:20 million in the
561:65 million in the
523:Tommaso Campanella
471:utopian philosophy
265:Andrzej Paczkowski
259:is a 1997 book by
87:Andrzej Paczkowski
4877:
4876:
4385:(10 March 2011).
4278:978-3-8218-7316-9
4253:978-2-221-09254-5
4228:978-2-84109-325-0
4199:978-2-7082-3516-8
3966:(December 1997).
3855:"The Evil Empire"
3630:978-3-89458-169-5
3505:Scammell, Michael
3384:978-0-8014-4944-4
3129:978-0-8032-9000-6
3104:978-0-231-14283-0
3060:(22 March 2018).
2943:978-0-8018-8258-6
2821:978-0-520-95417-5
2381:978-0-674-07608-2
2346:Panné, Jean-Louis
2226:978-0-8032-3945-6
2042:978-1-57181-802-7
1926:Stéphane Courtois
1755:French Revolution
1735:Ăditions Larousse
1415:Publishers Weekly
1265:Michael David-Fox
1095:Moral equivalence
1044:Jospin government
969:as an attempt at
967:Holocaust victims
959:Wiesel Commission
923:Stéphane Courtois
792:National Assembly
669:from 1930 to 1932
597:1 million in the
420:Stéphane Courtois
408:communist regimes
261:Stéphane Courtois
252:
251:
247:978-0-674-07608-2
203:Publication place
109:(*German edition)
52:Stéphane Courtois
16:(Redirected from
4952:
4843:The Soviet Story
4745:Black Ribbon Day
4702:Communist crimes
4581:
4574:
4567:
4558:
4518:
4501:"Sauver LĂ©nine?"
4495:
4472:
4312:
4311:
4309:
4307:
4292:
4283:
4282:
4264:
4258:
4257:
4239:
4233:
4232:
4210:
4204:
4203:
4185:
4179:
4164:
4158:
4143:
4137:
4122:
4116:
4101:
4095:
4094:
4062:
4056:
4055:
4053:
4051:
4039:
4033:
4032:
4012:
4006:
4005:
3984:
3978:
3977:
3964:Perrault, Gilles
3960:
3954:
3943:
3937:
3936:
3934:
3932:
3912:
3906:
3905:
3903:
3879:
3870:
3869:
3867:
3865:
3850:
3844:
3821:
3815:
3792:
3786:
3785:
3765:
3759:
3758:
3737:
3731:
3730:
3706:
3700:
3699:
3697:
3695:
3672:
3666:
3654:
3648:
3642:
3641:
3639:
3633:. Archived from
3618:
3609:
3603:
3602:
3584:
3575:
3569:
3550:
3541:
3540:
3534:
3526:
3524:
3522:
3514:The New Republic
3501:
3495:
3494:
3468:
3460:Ghodsee, Kristen
3456:
3450:
3449:
3429:
3423:
3422:
3399:Ghodsee, Kristen
3395:
3389:
3388:
3376:
3366:
3360:
3359:
3328:
3319:
3296:
3287:
3272:
3266:
3247:
3241:
3240:
3238:
3227:
3218:
3217:
3189:
3180:
3179:
3143:
3134:
3133:
3113:
3107:
3092:SĂ©melin, Jacques
3085:
3079:
3078:
3076:
3074:
3054:Ghodsee, Kristen
3050:
3044:
3043:
3041:
3039:
2992:
2983:
2982:
2954:
2948:
2947:
2929:
2920:
2919:
2909:
2892:
2883:
2882:
2880:
2878:
2856:
2841:
2840:
2838:
2836:
2797:
2788:
2769:
2758:
2757:
2755:
2753:
2743:
2734:
2723:
2706:
2700:
2699:
2697:
2695:
2673:
2667:
2636:
2630:
2595:
2589:
2566:
2553:
2530:
2521:
2494:
2488:
2471:
2465:
2464:
2435:
2424:
2405:
2386:
2385:
2360:(October 1999).
2338:
2231:
2230:
2212:
2206:
2205:
2203:
2201:
2178:
2165:
2164:
2162:
2160:
2149:
2140:
2139:
2119:
2110:
2109:
2089:
2074:
2073:
2053:
2047:
2046:
2028:
2011:
2000:
1992:
1986:
1910:
1904:
1901:
1883:The Soviet Story
1826:Historikerstreit
1805:The Great Terror
1655:and support for
1526:
1490:and philosopher
1488:Jacques Julliard
1409:Orlando Sentinel
1385:The New Republic
1355:Evening Standard
1252:Alexander Dallin
1237:Hiroaki Kuromiya
1190:Stanley Hoffmann
1060:de-Stalinization
1024:Nuremberg Trials
755:Alexander Dallin
742:Atlantic Monthly
721:Operation Lentil
638:decossackization
487:Georges Marchais
404:MarxistâLeninist
295:, and deaths in
281:communist states
194:Publication date
100:
92:Jean-Louis Panné
40:
33:
21:
4960:
4959:
4955:
4954:
4953:
4951:
4950:
4949:
4945:Political books
4880:
4879:
4878:
4873:
4857:
4814:
4733:
4685:
4614:
4613:resolutions and
4612:
4606:
4605:
4591:
4585:
4532:Wayback Machine
4516:
4508:Wayback Machine
4493:
4470:
4464:Wayback Machine
4445:
4383:Snyder, Timothy
4347:Furet, François
4329:Hollander, Paul
4325:Applebaum, Anne
4321:
4319:Further reading
4316:
4315:
4305:
4303:
4294:
4293:
4286:
4279:
4266:
4265:
4261:
4254:
4241:
4240:
4236:
4229:
4212:
4211:
4207:
4200:
4187:
4186:
4182:
4165:
4161:
4144:
4140:
4123:
4119:
4102:
4098:
4064:
4063:
4059:
4049:
4047:
4041:
4040:
4036:
4014:
4013:
4009:
4002:
3988:Neumayer, Laure
3986:
3985:
3981:
3962:
3961:
3957:
3953:. (2): 225â236.
3944:
3940:
3930:
3928:
3915:Chomsky, Noam.
3914:
3913:
3909:
3881:
3880:
3873:
3863:
3861:
3852:
3851:
3847:
3822:
3818:
3800:Foreign Affairs
3793:
3789:
3767:
3766:
3762:
3743:Russian History
3739:
3738:
3734:
3708:
3707:
3703:
3693:
3691:
3674:
3673:
3669:
3652:
3649:
3645:
3637:
3631:
3616:
3611:
3610:
3606:
3582:
3577:
3576:
3572:
3566:Wayback Machine
3551:
3544:
3527:
3520:
3518:
3503:
3502:
3498:
3466:
3458:
3457:
3453:
3446:
3431:
3430:
3426:
3419:
3411:. p. 140.
3397:
3396:
3392:
3385:
3368:
3367:
3363:
3330:
3329:
3322:
3297:
3290:
3273:
3269:
3248:
3244:
3236:
3229:
3228:
3221:
3191:
3190:
3183:
3145:
3144:
3137:
3130:
3115:
3114:
3110:
3086:
3082:
3072:
3070:
3052:
3051:
3047:
3037:
3035:
3017:10.2307/2700532
2994:
2993:
2986:
2956:
2955:
2951:
2944:
2931:
2930:
2923:
2907:
2894:
2893:
2886:
2876:
2874:
2873:on 25 July 2012
2858:
2857:
2844:
2834:
2832:
2822:
2799:
2798:
2791:
2770:
2761:
2751:
2749:
2741:
2736:
2735:
2726:
2707:
2703:
2693:
2691:
2675:
2674:
2670:
2637:
2633:
2596:
2592:
2567:
2556:
2531:
2524:
2495:
2491:
2472:
2468:
2453:10.2307/2697429
2437:
2436:
2427:
2406:
2389:
2382:
2354:Bartosek, Karel
2340:
2339:
2234:
2227:
2214:
2213:
2209:
2199:
2197:
2180:
2179:
2168:
2158:
2156:
2151:
2150:
2143:
2121:
2120:
2113:
2091:
2090:
2077:
2070:
2055:
2054:
2050:
2043:
2030:
2029:
2025:
2020:
2015:
2014:
1998:
1993:
1989:
1911:
1907:
1902:
1898:
1893:
1888:
1767:
1665:
1637:state socialist
1524:
1504:
1496:Gilles Perrault
1403:National Review
1379:Library Journal
1361:Foreign Affairs
1341:
1302:Russian History
1198:
1162:
1150:Ehrhart Neubert
1141:
1097:
1056:de-Nazification
1016:
925:
916:Forever Flowing
905:Vasily Grossman
859:Jacques SĂ©melin
831:Kristen Ghodsee
795:interview with
780:
591:1.5 million in
585:1.7 million in
554:
531:
432:
422:describes as a
390:
374:Vasily Grossman
351:state socialist
225:Media type
217:
213:
198:6 November 1997
195:
178:
174:Totalitarianism
141:Communist state
108:
94:
81:Ehrhart Neubert
43:
28:
23:
22:
15:
12:
11:
5:
4958:
4956:
4948:
4947:
4942:
4937:
4932:
4927:
4922:
4917:
4912:
4907:
4902:
4897:
4892:
4882:
4881:
4875:
4874:
4872:
4871:
4865:
4863:
4859:
4858:
4856:
4855:
4847:
4839:
4831:
4822:
4820:
4816:
4815:
4813:
4812:
4807:
4802:
4797:
4792:
4787:
4782:
4777:
4772:
4767:
4762:
4757:
4752:
4747:
4741:
4739:
4735:
4734:
4732:
4731:
4730:
4729:
4719:
4714:
4709:
4704:
4699:
4693:
4691:
4687:
4686:
4684:
4683:
4677:
4671:
4665:
4659:
4653:
4648:
4642:
4637:
4631:
4625:
4618:
4616:
4608:
4607:
4604:
4603:
4597:
4596:
4593:
4592:
4588:Anti-communism
4586:
4584:
4583:
4576:
4569:
4561:
4555:
4554:
4543:
4520:
4497:
4482:
4452:
4444:
4443:External links
4441:
4440:
4439:
4436:978-0374277932
4413:
4395:
4380:
4362:
4344:
4320:
4317:
4314:
4313:
4284:
4277:
4259:
4252:
4234:
4227:
4205:
4198:
4180:
4176:978-8804517955
4159:
4155:978-9547333987
4138:
4134:978-3492045520
4117:
4113:978-2221095003
4096:
4057:
4046:. Africa Check
4034:
4007:
4000:
3979:
3955:
3938:
3907:
3871:
3845:
3835:(3): 587â589.
3816:
3787:
3776:(2): 311â316.
3760:
3732:
3701:
3667:
3643:
3629:
3604:
3593:(5): 603â630.
3570:
3542:
3496:
3477:(2): 115â142.
3451:
3444:
3424:
3418:978-0822369493
3417:
3390:
3383:
3361:
3342:(2): 135â143.
3320:
3308:Foreign Policy
3288:
3267:
3242:
3219:
3200:(2): 125â134.
3181:
3135:
3128:
3108:
3094:, eds. (2009)
3080:
3045:
2984:
2965:(2): 281â302.
2949:
2942:
2921:
2884:
2842:
2820:
2789:
2759:
2724:
2701:
2678:Werth, Nicolas
2668:
2631:
2590:
2580:(3): 450â452.
2554:
2544:(1): 191â201.
2522:
2510:10.2307/206491
2504:(1): 117â119.
2489:
2466:
2425:
2387:
2380:
2342:Werth, Nicolas
2232:
2225:
2207:
2166:
2141:
2111:
2100:(2): 222â245.
2075:
2069:978-0812236453
2068:
2048:
2041:
2022:
2021:
2019:
2016:
2013:
2012:
2004:The Black Book
1996:The Black Book
1987:
1985:
1984:
1978:
1975:
1972:
1969:
1955:
1945:
1939:
1936:
1933:
1923:
1916:
1905:
1895:
1894:
1892:
1889:
1887:
1886:
1879:
1872:
1867:
1860:
1855:
1848:
1843:
1836:
1829:
1822:
1815:
1808:
1801:
1796:
1791:
1786:
1781:
1774:
1768:
1766:
1763:
1704:François Furet
1664:
1661:
1576:Vichy syndrome
1572:anti-communism
1549:Laure Neumayer
1529:The Black Book
1522:The Black Book
1516:, sociologist
1506:Reflecting on
1503:
1500:
1466:. Philosopher
1373:Kirkus Reviews
1340:
1337:
1333:The Black Book
1323:Robert Legvold
1319:The Black Book
1229:Michael Ellman
1197:
1196:Academic press
1194:
1161:
1158:
1140:
1137:
1114:The Black Book
1096:
1093:
1015:
1012:
924:
921:
863:class genocide
786:and Socialist
779:
776:
772:The Black Book
729:
728:
718:
715:Crimean Tatars
707:
696:
677:
670:
663:dekulakization
659:
652:
645:
634:
627:
624:
617:
616:
613:
607:
601:
595:
589:
583:
577:
571:
565:
553:
550:
536:The Black Book
530:
527:
507:Ignazio Silone
499:Maurice Thorez
483:Vladimir Lenin
479:Jacques Duclos
431:
428:
412:real socialism
389:
386:
370:Ilya Ehrenburg
333:François Furet
299:and allegedly
250:
249:
244:
238:
237:
234:
230:
229:
226:
222:
221:
216:8 October 1999
214:
211:
208:
207:
204:
200:
199:
196:
193:
190:
189:
184:
180:
179:
177:
176:
171:
166:
148:
143:
137:
135:
131:
130:
125:
121:
120:
115:
111:
110:
107:
106:
101:
89:
84:
78:
73:
67:
65:Karel BartoĆĄek
61:
59:
55:
54:
49:
45:
44:
41:
26:
24:
14:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
4957:
4946:
4943:
4941:
4940:Joachim Gauck
4938:
4936:
4933:
4931:
4928:
4926:
4923:
4921:
4918:
4916:
4913:
4911:
4908:
4906:
4903:
4901:
4898:
4896:
4893:
4891:
4888:
4887:
4885:
4870:
4867:
4866:
4864:
4860:
4853:
4852:
4848:
4845:
4844:
4840:
4837:
4836:
4832:
4829:
4828:
4824:
4823:
4821:
4817:
4811:
4808:
4806:
4803:
4801:
4798:
4796:
4793:
4791:
4788:
4786:
4783:
4781:
4778:
4776:
4773:
4771:
4768:
4766:
4763:
4761:
4758:
4756:
4753:
4751:
4748:
4746:
4743:
4742:
4740:
4736:
4728:
4725:
4724:
4723:
4720:
4718:
4715:
4713:
4710:
4708:
4705:
4703:
4700:
4698:
4695:
4694:
4692:
4688:
4681:
4678:
4675:
4672:
4669:
4666:
4663:
4660:
4657:
4654:
4652:
4649:
4646:
4643:
4641:
4638:
4635:
4632:
4629:
4626:
4623:
4620:
4619:
4617:
4609:
4602:
4599:
4598:
4594:
4589:
4582:
4577:
4575:
4570:
4568:
4563:
4562:
4559:
4552:
4548:
4544:
4541:
4537:
4533:
4529:
4525:
4521:
4515:
4514:
4509:
4505:
4502:
4498:
4491:
4487:
4483:
4480:
4476:
4469:
4465:
4461:
4457:
4453:
4450:
4447:
4446:
4442:
4437:
4433:
4429:
4425:
4421:
4417:
4416:Yang, Jisheng
4414:
4411:
4410:9781784785642
4407:
4403:
4399:
4396:
4393:
4392:
4388:
4384:
4381:
4378:
4377:9780226414195
4374:
4370:
4366:
4363:
4360:
4359:9780226273402
4356:
4352:
4348:
4345:
4342:
4341:1-932236-78-3
4338:
4334:
4330:
4326:
4323:
4322:
4318:
4301:
4297:
4291:
4289:
4285:
4280:
4274:
4270:
4263:
4260:
4255:
4249:
4245:
4238:
4235:
4230:
4224:
4220:
4217:. Montreuil:
4216:
4209:
4206:
4201:
4195:
4191:
4184:
4181:
4177:
4173:
4169:
4163:
4160:
4156:
4152:
4148:
4142:
4139:
4135:
4131:
4127:
4121:
4118:
4114:
4110:
4106:
4100:
4097:
4092:
4088:
4084:
4080:
4076:
4072:
4068:
4061:
4058:
4045:
4038:
4035:
4030:
4026:
4022:
4018:
4011:
4008:
4003:
4001:9781351141741
3997:
3994:. Routledge.
3993:
3989:
3983:
3980:
3975:
3974:
3969:
3965:
3959:
3956:
3952:
3948:
3942:
3939:
3926:
3922:
3918:
3911:
3908:
3902:
3897:
3893:
3889:
3885:
3878:
3876:
3872:
3860:
3856:
3849:
3846:
3842:
3838:
3834:
3830:
3826:
3820:
3817:
3813:
3809:
3805:
3801:
3797:
3791:
3788:
3783:
3779:
3775:
3771:
3764:
3761:
3756:
3752:
3748:
3744:
3736:
3733:
3728:
3724:
3720:
3716:
3712:
3705:
3702:
3690:
3686:
3682:
3678:
3671:
3668:
3664:
3663:3-89458-169-7
3660:
3656:
3647:
3644:
3636:
3632:
3626:
3622:
3615:
3608:
3605:
3600:
3596:
3592:
3588:
3581:
3574:
3571:
3567:
3563:
3559:
3558:Feed Magazine
3555:
3549:
3547:
3543:
3538:
3532:
3516:
3515:
3510:
3506:
3500:
3497:
3492:
3488:
3484:
3480:
3476:
3472:
3465:
3461:
3455:
3452:
3447:
3445:9781412835176
3441:
3437:
3436:
3428:
3425:
3420:
3414:
3410:
3406:
3405:
3400:
3394:
3391:
3386:
3380:
3375:
3374:
3365:
3362:
3357:
3353:
3349:
3345:
3341:
3337:
3333:
3327:
3325:
3321:
3317:
3313:
3309:
3305:
3301:
3295:
3293:
3289:
3285:
3284:9780520954250
3281:
3277:
3271:
3268:
3264:
3263:3-492-04053-5
3260:
3256:
3252:
3246:
3243:
3235:
3234:
3226:
3224:
3220:
3215:
3211:
3207:
3203:
3199:
3195:
3188:
3186:
3182:
3177:
3173:
3169:
3165:
3161:
3157:
3153:
3149:
3142:
3140:
3136:
3131:
3125:
3121:
3120:
3112:
3109:
3105:
3101:
3097:
3093:
3089:
3084:
3081:
3069:
3068:
3063:
3059:
3055:
3049:
3046:
3034:
3030:
3026:
3022:
3018:
3014:
3010:
3006:
3002:
3000:
2991:
2989:
2985:
2980:
2976:
2972:
2968:
2964:
2960:
2953:
2950:
2945:
2939:
2936:. JHU Press.
2935:
2928:
2926:
2922:
2917:
2913:
2906:
2904:
2900:
2891:
2889:
2885:
2872:
2868:
2867:
2862:
2855:
2853:
2851:
2849:
2847:
2843:
2831:
2827:
2823:
2817:
2813:
2809:
2805:
2804:
2796:
2794:
2790:
2786:
2782:
2779:(1): 81â105.
2778:
2774:
2768:
2766:
2764:
2760:
2747:
2740:
2733:
2731:
2729:
2725:
2721:
2720:
2716:(in French).
2715:
2713:
2705:
2702:
2689:
2688:
2683:
2679:
2672:
2669:
2665:
2664:9783319544632
2661:
2657:
2653:
2649:
2645:
2641:
2635:
2632:
2628:
2624:
2620:
2616:
2612:
2608:
2605:(1): 85â102.
2604:
2600:
2594:
2591:
2587:
2583:
2579:
2575:
2571:
2565:
2563:
2561:
2559:
2555:
2551:
2547:
2543:
2539:
2535:
2529:
2527:
2523:
2519:
2515:
2511:
2507:
2503:
2499:
2493:
2490:
2486:
2485:9780801472732
2482:
2478:
2477:
2470:
2467:
2462:
2458:
2454:
2450:
2446:
2442:
2441:Slavic Review
2434:
2432:
2430:
2426:
2422:
2418:
2414:
2410:
2404:
2402:
2400:
2398:
2396:
2394:
2392:
2388:
2383:
2377:
2373:
2369:
2368:
2363:
2359:
2355:
2351:
2347:
2343:
2337:
2335:
2333:
2331:
2329:
2327:
2325:
2323:
2321:
2319:
2317:
2315:
2313:
2311:
2309:
2307:
2305:
2303:
2301:
2299:
2297:
2295:
2293:
2291:
2289:
2287:
2285:
2283:
2281:
2279:
2277:
2275:
2273:
2271:
2269:
2267:
2265:
2263:
2261:
2259:
2257:
2255:
2253:
2251:
2249:
2247:
2245:
2243:
2241:
2239:
2237:
2233:
2228:
2222:
2218:
2211:
2208:
2196:
2192:
2189:(in French).
2188:
2184:
2177:
2175:
2173:
2171:
2167:
2154:
2148:
2146:
2142:
2137:
2133:
2129:
2125:
2118:
2116:
2112:
2107:
2103:
2099:
2095:
2088:
2086:
2084:
2082:
2080:
2076:
2071:
2065:
2061:
2060:
2052:
2049:
2044:
2038:
2034:
2027:
2024:
2017:
2009:
2005:
1997:
1991:
1988:
1982:
1981:Nicolas Werth
1979:
1976:
1973:
1970:
1967:
1963:
1959:
1956:
1953:
1949:
1946:
1943:
1940:
1937:
1934:
1931:
1927:
1924:
1921:
1917:
1914:
1913:
1909:
1906:
1900:
1897:
1890:
1885:
1884:
1880:
1878:
1877:
1873:
1871:
1868:
1866:
1865:
1861:
1859:
1856:
1854:
1853:
1849:
1847:
1844:
1842:
1841:
1837:
1835:
1834:
1830:
1828:
1827:
1823:
1821:
1820:
1816:
1814:
1813:
1809:
1807:
1806:
1802:
1800:
1797:
1795:
1792:
1790:
1787:
1785:
1782:
1780:
1779:
1775:
1773:
1770:
1769:
1764:
1762:
1760:
1756:
1752:
1748:
1744:
1740:
1736:
1731:
1729:
1725:
1721:
1717:
1713:
1709:
1705:
1701:
1697:
1695:
1691:
1687:
1683:
1678:
1674:
1670:
1662:
1660:
1658:
1654:
1650:
1646:
1642:
1638:
1635:do, with the
1634:
1630:
1626:
1622:
1618:
1614:
1610:
1609:
1603:
1599:
1595:
1591:
1587:
1583:
1582:
1577:
1573:
1569:
1565:
1564:
1558:
1555:
1550:
1546:
1541:
1537:
1536:
1530:
1523:
1519:
1515:
1514:
1509:
1501:
1499:
1497:
1493:
1489:
1485:
1481:
1477:
1472:
1469:
1465:
1464:
1459:
1458:
1453:
1452:
1447:
1446:
1441:
1440:
1435:
1434:
1429:
1428:
1423:
1422:
1417:
1416:
1411:
1410:
1405:
1404:
1399:
1398:
1393:
1392:
1387:
1386:
1381:
1380:
1375:
1374:
1369:
1368:
1363:
1362:
1357:
1356:
1351:
1350:
1345:
1339:Popular press
1338:
1336:
1334:
1329:
1324:
1320:
1315:
1312:
1308:
1304:
1303:
1297:
1293:
1289:
1288:
1283:
1279:
1274:
1269:
1266:
1262:
1258:
1253:
1248:
1246:
1242:
1238:
1234:
1230:
1226:
1221:
1216:
1210:
1208:
1207:Nicolas Werth
1204:
1195:
1193:
1191:
1186:
1184:
1183:radical right
1179:
1175:
1174:Maurice Papon
1171:
1167:
1159:
1157:
1155:
1154:Joachim Gauck
1151:
1146:
1138:
1136:
1134:
1130:
1126:
1122:
1117:
1115:
1111:
1107:
1101:
1094:
1092:
1090:
1089:Hannah Arendt
1085:
1083:
1082:
1077:
1072:
1067:
1065:
1064:Kurt Waldheim
1061:
1057:
1051:
1049:
1045:
1041:
1037:
1033:
1029:
1025:
1020:
1013:
1011:
1008:
1007:the Holocaust
1003:
1002:Warsaw ghetto
999:
995:
991:
987:
986:social groups
982:
980:
976:
972:
968:
964:
960:
956:
952:
948:
944:
940:
939:
934:
930:
922:
920:
918:
917:
912:
911:
910:Life and Fate
906:
901:
897:
896:
890:
888:
884:
880:
876:
872:
869:." Alongside
868:
864:
860:
856:
853:
849:
845:
844:
838:
836:
832:
828:
823:
819:
818:
811:
809:
804:
800:
799:
793:
789:
788:Lionel Jospin
785:
777:
775:
773:
768:
764:
759:
756:
752:
751:J. Arch Getty
748:
744:
743:
738:
733:
726:
722:
719:
716:
712:
708:
705:
704:Volga Germans
701:
697:
694:
693:Baltic states
690:
686:
682:
678:
675:
671:
668:
664:
660:
657:
653:
650:
646:
643:
639:
635:
632:
628:
625:
622:
621:
620:
614:
612:
611:Latin America
608:
606:
603:1 million in
602:
600:
596:
594:
590:
588:
584:
582:
579:2 million in
578:
576:
573:2 million in
572:
570:
566:
564:
560:
559:
558:
551:
549:
546:
540:
537:
528:
526:
524:
520:
516:
512:
508:
502:
500:
496:
495:Joseph Stalin
492:
488:
484:
480:
476:
472:
468:
464:
463:
458:
453:
449:
445:
441:
437:
429:
427:
425:
421:
417:
413:
409:
405:
401:
397:
396:
387:
385:
383:
379:
375:
371:
368:, written by
367:
366:Eastern Front
363:
362:
357:
352:
348:
344:
340:
336:
334:
330:
329:Joachim Gauck
326:
322:
318:
314:
310:
306:
302:
298:
294:
290:
286:
282:
278:
274:
270:
269:Nicolas Werth
266:
262:
258:
257:
248:
245:
243:
239:
235:
231:
227:
223:
220:
215:
209:
205:
201:
197:
191:
188:
185:
181:
175:
172:
170:
167:
164:
160:
156:
152:
149:
147:
144:
142:
139:
138:
136:
132:
129:
126:
122:
119:
116:
112:
105:
104:Nicolas Werth
102:
98:
93:
90:
88:
85:
82:
79:
77:
74:
71:
70:Joachim Gauck
68:
66:
63:
62:
60:
56:
53:
50:
46:
39:
34:
19:
4849:
4841:
4833:
4826:
4825:
4738:Institutions
4615:declarations
4550:
4539:
4535:
4511:
4494:(in Russian)
4485:
4474:
4467:
4419:
4401:
4389:
4368:
4350:
4332:
4304:. Retrieved
4300:the original
4268:
4262:
4243:
4237:
4214:
4208:
4189:
4183:
4167:
4162:
4146:
4141:
4125:
4120:
4104:
4099:
4074:
4070:
4060:
4048:. Retrieved
4037:
4020:
4016:
4010:
3991:
3982:
3976:(in French).
3971:
3958:
3950:
3946:
3941:
3929:. Retrieved
3920:
3910:
3891:
3887:
3862:. Retrieved
3858:
3848:
3832:
3828:
3824:
3819:
3803:
3799:
3795:
3790:
3773:
3769:
3763:
3749:(3). Brill.
3746:
3742:
3735:
3710:
3704:
3692:. Retrieved
3680:
3670:
3651:
3646:
3635:the original
3620:
3607:
3590:
3586:
3573:
3557:
3521:18 September
3519:. Retrieved
3512:
3499:
3474:
3470:
3454:
3434:
3427:
3403:
3393:
3372:
3364:
3339:
3335:
3332:Torpey, John
3307:
3303:
3299:
3275:
3270:
3254:
3250:
3245:
3232:
3197:
3193:
3151:
3147:
3118:
3111:
3095:
3083:
3071:. Retrieved
3065:
3058:Sehon, Scott
3048:
3036:. Retrieved
3008:
3004:
2998:
2962:
2958:
2952:
2933:
2915:
2911:
2902:
2898:
2875:. Retrieved
2871:the original
2864:
2833:. Retrieved
2802:
2776:
2772:
2750:. Retrieved
2746:The Atlantic
2745:
2717:
2711:
2704:
2692:. Retrieved
2685:
2671:
2647:
2643:
2634:
2602:
2598:
2593:
2577:
2573:
2569:
2541:
2537:
2533:
2501:
2497:
2492:
2474:
2469:
2444:
2440:
2415:(2): 28â34.
2412:
2408:
2366:
2216:
2210:
2198:. Retrieved
2186:
2157:. Retrieved
2127:
2123:
2097:
2093:
2058:
2051:
2032:
2026:
2007:
2003:
1995:
1990:
1942:Martin Malia
1908:
1899:
1881:
1874:
1862:
1850:
1838:
1831:
1824:
1817:
1810:
1803:
1776:
1750:
1742:
1738:
1732:
1719:
1711:
1707:
1699:
1698:
1693:
1689:
1685:
1681:
1676:
1672:
1668:
1666:
1648:
1644:
1616:
1612:
1606:
1601:
1597:
1594:Africa Check
1589:
1585:
1579:
1567:
1561:
1559:
1553:
1544:
1539:
1533:
1528:
1521:
1511:
1507:
1505:
1483:
1476:Noam Chomsky
1473:
1461:
1455:
1449:
1443:
1437:
1431:
1425:
1419:
1413:
1407:
1401:
1395:
1389:
1383:
1377:
1371:
1365:
1359:
1353:
1347:
1343:
1342:
1332:
1318:
1316:
1310:
1300:
1295:
1285:
1277:
1270:
1249:
1211:
1199:
1187:
1177:
1169:
1163:
1145:East Germany
1142:
1120:
1118:
1113:
1109:
1105:
1102:
1098:
1086:
1079:
1070:
1068:
1052:
1032:Vichy regime
1021:
1017:
1014:Martin Malia
989:
983:
979:gas chambers
936:
933:Nazi Germany
929:totalitarian
926:
914:
908:
893:
891:
886:
878:
874:
871:Michael Mann
857:
851:
841:
839:
835:World War II
815:
812:
807:
796:
781:
771:
762:
760:
740:
734:
730:
642:Don Cossacks
618:
599:Eastern Bloc
569:Soviet Union
555:
544:
541:
535:
532:
503:
475:Fidel Castro
470:
460:
451:
436:Martin Malia
433:
393:
391:
382:World War II
359:
338:
337:
325:Piper Verlag
321:Martin Malia
308:
301:artificially
293:deportations
283:, including
255:
254:
253:
117:
4690:Legislation
4670:(2010â2015)
4517:(in French)
4471:(in French)
3921:Spectrezine
3694:31 December
3253:. (2004) .
2690:(in French)
2159:24 February
2130:(1): 5â19.
1728:colonialism
1714:. It broke
1615:. describe
1518:John Torpey
1480:Amartya Sen
1439:The Tribune
1261:Khmer Rouge
1241:Mark Tauger
1215:Peter Kenez
1108:as deeming
1076:Eurocentric
955:antisemitic
943:Rudolf Höss
848:antisemitic
827:Scott Sehon
803:Amir Weiner
711:deportation
700:deportation
656:Great Purge
609:150,000 in
593:Afghanistan
581:North Korea
491:Ho Chi Minh
467:Thomas More
297:labor camps
95: [
4884:Categories
4862:Opposition
4851:Bloodlands
4722:Lustration
4549:(review).
4513:Libération
4428:0374277931
4365:Judt, Tony
4050:2 December
3806:(6): 155.
3038:14 January
2835:14 January
2018:References
1778:Bloodlands
1724:capitalism
1560:In a 2005
1484:Black Book
1474:Historian
1271:Historian
1250:Historian
1213:Historian
1166:Jon Wiener
1133:war crimes
994:Nazi Party
808:Black Book
735:Historian
685:Ukrainians
511:Bolsheviks
349:and other
4727:in Poland
4349:(1999) .
4306:10 August
4091:229212026
3931:27 August
3864:27 August
3727:143188977
3689:0362-4331
3531:cite news
3356:144552416
3214:143741542
3176:159911023
3073:24 August
3033:224901571
2979:201790241
2877:10 August
2866:Le Figaro
2830:226725531
2752:30 August
2627:145120734
2195:1950-6244
1870:Stalinism
1716:communism
1684:, titled
1657:socialism
1633:the Right
1629:communism
1625:anarchism
1468:Alan Ryan
1273:Tony Judt
1160:Reception
1081:Le Figaro
1048:Gaullists
1040:Communist
1036:Socialist
941:official
689:Moldovans
674:Holodomor
557:follows:
452:Communism
395:communism
285:genocides
183:Publisher
163:Stalinism
4528:Archived
4524:"Review"
4504:Archived
4488:(2001).
4460:Archived
4418:(2012).
4400:(2017).
4367:(1998).
3990:(2018).
3925:Archived
3812:20049582
3755:24660822
3562:Archived
3462:(2014).
3401:(2017).
3168:40109537
3029:ProQuest
2687:Le Monde
2421:40260182
2200:3 August
2187:Le Monde
2008:Le Monde
1765:See also
1757:and the
1641:the Left
1106:Le Monde
1071:Le Monde
990:genocide
879:Le Monde
867:genocide
843:Le Monde
817:Le Monde
798:Die Zeit
587:Ethiopia
575:Cambodia
545:integral
462:Republic
418:, which
400:Leninist
398:to mean
388:Overview
376:for the
303:created
155:Leninism
134:Subjects
124:Language
3841:3086399
3316:1149284
3025:2700532
2959:Kritika
2694:14 June
2619:4149657
2586:3656222
2461:2697429
2364:(ed.).
1663:Sequels
1510:in the
1257:Pol Pot
727:in 1944
717:in 1944
713:of the
706:in 1941
702:of the
605:Vietnam
448:fascism
380:during
305:famines
165:, etc.)
58:Authors
4854:(2010)
4846:(2008)
4838:(2004)
4830:(1997)
4682:(2019)
4676:(2011)
4664:(2010)
4658:(2009)
4647:(2009)
4636:(2008)
4630:(2008)
4624:(2006)
4486:et al.
4479:Online
4434:
4426:
4408:
4375:
4357:
4339:
4331:, ed.
4275:
4250:
4225:
4196:
4174:
4153:
4132:
4111:
4089:
3998:
3839:
3810:
3753:
3725:
3687:
3661:
3627:
3489:
3442:
3415:
3381:
3354:
3314:
3282:
3261:
3212:
3174:
3166:
3126:
3102:
3031:
3023:
2977:
2940:
2903:et al.
2828:
2818:
2742:(text)
2662:
2625:
2617:
2584:
2550:261138
2548:
2518:206491
2516:
2483:
2459:
2419:
2378:
2223:
2193:
2066:
2039:
1692:, and
1645:et al.
1602:et al.
1584:about
1502:Legacy
1460:, and
1205:, and
1131:, and
1119:About
975:kulaks
725:Ingush
667:kulaks
497:, and
440:Nazism
356:Nazism
206:France
159:Maoism
128:French
48:Editor
4819:Media
4087:S2CID
3837:JSTOR
3808:JSTOR
3751:JSTOR
3723:S2CID
3713:(3).
3653:'
3638:(PDF)
3617:(PDF)
3583:(PDF)
3487:JSTOR
3467:(PDF)
3352:S2CID
3312:JSTOR
3251:et al
3237:(PDF)
3210:S2CID
3172:S2CID
3164:JSTOR
3021:JSTOR
2975:S2CID
2908:(PDF)
2826:S2CID
2623:S2CID
2615:JSTOR
2582:JSTOR
2546:JSTOR
2514:JSTOR
2457:JSTOR
2417:JSTOR
1999:'
1891:Notes
1613:et al
1525:'
1421:Salon
998:kulak
963:Gulag
681:Poles
649:Gulag
457:Plato
410:and "
233:Pages
228:Print
99:]
4432:ISBN
4424:ISBN
4406:ISBN
4373:ISBN
4355:ISBN
4337:ISBN
4308:2021
4273:ISBN
4248:ISBN
4223:ISBN
4194:ISBN
4172:ISBN
4151:ISBN
4130:ISBN
4109:ISBN
4052:2021
3996:ISBN
3933:2020
3866:2020
3696:2021
3685:ISSN
3659:ISBN
3625:ISBN
3537:link
3523:2016
3440:ISBN
3413:ISBN
3379:ISBN
3280:ISBN
3259:ISBN
3124:ISBN
3100:ISBN
3075:2020
3067:Aeon
3040:2022
2938:ISBN
2879:2021
2837:2022
2816:ISBN
2754:2020
2696:2015
2660:ISBN
2481:ISBN
2376:ISBN
2221:ISBN
2202:2016
2191:ISSN
2161:2008
2064:ISBN
2037:ISBN
1726:and
1710:and
1667:The
1239:and
1058:and
913:and
749:and
709:The
698:The
661:The
654:The
636:The
629:The
465:and
424:coup
402:and
372:and
242:ISBN
4079:doi
4075:2â3
4025:doi
4021:124
3896:doi
3778:doi
3715:doi
3595:doi
3479:doi
3344:doi
3202:doi
3156:doi
3013:doi
2967:doi
2808:doi
2781:doi
2652:doi
2607:doi
2506:doi
2449:doi
2132:doi
2102:doi
1737:'s
1706:'s
1284:'s
761:In
459:'s
311:by
279:by
236:912
4886::
4540:88
4538:.
4534:.
4526:.
4510:.
4477:.
4466:.
4458:.
4430:.
4287:^
4221:.
4085:.
4073:.
4069:.
4019:.
3951:27
3949:.
3923:.
3919:.
3892:32
3890:.
3886:.
3874:^
3857:.
3833:45
3804:78
3774:36
3772:.
3747:30
3745:.
3721:.
3683:.
3679:.
3591:24
3589:.
3585:.
3560:.
3556:.
3545:^
3533:}}
3529:{{
3511:.
3485:.
3473:.
3469:.
3407:.
3350:.
3338:.
3323:^
3291:^
3222:^
3208:.
3196:.
3184:^
3170:.
3162:.
3152:27
3150:.
3138:^
3090:;
3064:.
3056:;
3027:.
3019:.
3009:88
3007:.
3003:.
2987:^
2973:.
2961:.
2924:^
2916:12
2914:.
2910:.
2887:^
2845:^
2824:.
2814:.
2792:^
2775:.
2762:^
2744:.
2727:^
2658:.
2648:37
2646:.
2621:.
2613:.
2603:41
2601:.
2578:32
2576:.
2557:^
2542:36
2540:.
2525:^
2512:.
2502:27
2500:.
2455:.
2445:59
2443:.
2428:^
2413:25
2411:.
2390:^
2374:.
2370:.
2356:;
2352:;
2348:;
2344:;
2235:^
2219:.
2169:^
2144:^
2128:53
2126:.
2114:^
2098:42
2096:.
2078:^
1761:.
1730:.
1696:.
1688:,
1659:.
1454:,
1448:,
1442:,
1436:,
1430:,
1424:,
1418:,
1412:,
1406:,
1400:,
1394:,
1388:,
1382:,
1376:,
1370:,
1364:,
1358:,
1352:,
1247:.
1185:.
1168:,
1156:.
1135:.
1127:,
981:.
949:,
938:SS
898:,
837:.
687:,
683:,
493:,
489:,
485:,
481:,
477:,
426:.
384:.
291:,
287:,
271:,
267:,
263:,
161:,
157:,
97:fr
4580:e
4573:t
4566:v
4481:.
4438:.
4412:.
4379:.
4361:.
4343:.
4310:.
4281:.
4256:.
4231:.
4202:.
4178:.
4157:.
4136:.
4115:.
4093:.
4081::
4054:.
4031:.
4027::
4004:.
3935:.
3904:.
3898::
3868:.
3843:.
3814:.
3784:.
3780::
3757:.
3729:.
3717::
3698:.
3665:.
3601:.
3597::
3539:)
3525:.
3493:.
3481::
3475:4
3448:.
3421:.
3387:.
3358:.
3346::
3340:2
3318:.
3302:(
3286:.
3265:.
3216:.
3204::
3198:2
3178:.
3158::
3132:.
3106:.
3077:.
3015::
2997:"
2981:.
2969::
2963:3
2946:.
2905:"
2881:.
2839:.
2810::
2787:.
2783::
2777:5
2756:.
2710:"
2698:.
2666:.
2654::
2629:.
2609::
2588:.
2552:.
2520:.
2508::
2487:.
2463:.
2451::
2423:.
2384:.
2229:.
2204:.
2163:.
2138:.
2134::
2108:.
2104::
2072:.
2045:.
1968:.
1922:.
153:(
83:*
72:*
20:)
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.