User talk:Demt1298 - Knowledge (XXG)

3062:

concerns for you response in the fact you present it as if you own the articles in question and would resist their update with cited material. Reviewing the pages, some seems to provide large amounts of non-cited information (i.e. color of uniforms under the participant section of the 1888 American Cup article), and if references are found that counter this information, they should be updated with cited references. I believe when you are referring to the 'This Year in American Soccer' you might be talking about what can be found online at The Society of American Soccer History, but am not sure if that is what you are referring to. I understand a common belief that anything can be placed on the internet without reference, which is why what is written on Knowledge (XXG) is best when cited from a secondary source. But attempting to negate a contemporary reference when no historic reference is sourced in the article seems short-sighted. If historic references exist, articles would be improved with those references being notated with in-line citations. Hope this recommendations helps improve these articles that seem to lack appropriate citations.

3046:

possible. You are not the first person that has pointed modern sources to me. I'm seeing sources that I spent a lot of time to remove and replace with contemporary ones only to have them reintroduced. In particular 'This Year In American Soccer'. While I have used Spalding a few times it was only as a last resort. If you want to throw in here and there, I happy to dig through my notes and other parchment. I am not trying to kick you in the teeth but I have had a number of non researchers challenge my info. It seems that I am the only one that has challenged the modern authors. They have all written outstanding books but they are not error free. Kind regards.

1410:

recommends. That allows two things. One people will have a visual reference of how it would look on MLS articles and allow them to comment on likes and dislikes based on that visual reference. Secondly, it would allow the editors to use the 2024 Austin FC season pages formatting to make the adjustment to the other MLS articles. I think if we just revert because other MLS articles aren't in line with WP Football and MOS:ACESS recommendation, it won't lead to progress in getting other editors to adjust those articles to be in line with current recommendations. I know that other leagues also have this issue, because in the Premier League, the

2943:

encountered errors in modern sources . I noticed you were adding link to references. I have seen other people do that though I have mixed feelings about that because some go to a pay wall or some go to nothing. Either way none of mine have links because when I did the research over twenty years ago it all came from painstakingly pouring through agonizingly small or blurry print on microfilm. I still haven't got around to completing all the American Cup pages because took on too many projects though I promise to get to them soon. Anyway any improvements you see fit are extremely appreciated.

1359:, which discusses formatting that gives readers and editors with visual impairment the ability to use screen readers to read articles on Knowledge (XXG). I understand your concern for MLS articles, but I think WP Football should be the standard for football pages regardless of league. There are thousands of pages that use the older format and I wouldn't go back and correct those personally, but moving forward I think editors should use the most up to date recommendations on Knowledge (XXG) to provide the best access to most people. I would appreciate hearing your input on this. 2856: 2003: 2671: 3142: 3342: 3555: 1237: 814: 22: 370: 1751: 137: 3511: 3291: 2809: 2297: 1900: 1582: 1176: 942: 620: 3641: 461: 1278: 689: 468: 3669:! All experience levels welcome. Never worked on a GA project before? We'll teach you how to get started. Or maybe you're an old hand at GAs – we'd love to have you involved! Participants are invited to work on nominating and/or reviewing GA submissions related to women and women's works (e.g., books, films) during the event period. We hope to collectively cover article subjects from at least 1038: 1452: 2142: 2343: 598: 2495:

Good Article status. Consequently, I'm going to remove your assessment request for Sörenstam, but I encourage you to choose another article (one that hasn't yet reached GA or above) and request a 20-minute assessment for that instead. There are definitely many other biographies about women in sports that would benefit from some concentrated improvements. Best,

3522: 3302: 2820: 2308: 1911: 1593: 1187: 953: 631: 3500: 3280: 2798: 2286: 1889: 1571: 1165: 931: 609: 2994:

I have concern about this, because I also have another reference that states 13 teams entered and the original page didn't have any reference that directly said six teams entered, even your reversion is unreferenced. I don't think we should be removing something referenced without replacing it with a

2592:

However, he struggled to hold his place, as Bangladesh already had two other left arm seamers, Gholam Nousher and Jahangir Alam Talukdar. Anisur's career was also hampered by injuries and No-Ball problem. Still, he briefly emerged in 1994, following the retirement of Prince and Dulu, as the country's

753:

Welcome to the drive! Thank you for joining the effort – one person cannot do much, but together we can do so much more. There's a ton, and i mean a TON of soccer-related articles that are not cited at all. Although the drive hasn't officially began yet, you can test out your citation skills on these

2942:

Those scores came from a multitude of sources. I only put scores on main space that had multiple sources that matched. One of the most frustrating things about that period is conflicting data which happens more than you think clear through the 1980's. I am a stickler for accuracy and unfortunately I

1624:

Hello, I'm Logan Z Man 2022! I wanted to talk about the boxscores for the 2024 Chattanooga FC season page. I kinda prefer the collapsible Box scores as it allows you to see the opponent's goal scorers and the penalty kicks as well. Is it okay if I put collapsible Boxscores in underneath the schedule

3076:

I certainly don’t claim ownership. I’m just trying to prevent errors because I’ve seen it explode. If it is in the article then I have read it in print. Nothing is made up. I put a reference for every game and elsewhere within reason. I spent an unreal amount of time cleaning up soccer history here

2436:

That's a good question about undoing your changes and completing the page move the correct way but that is not possible anymore. You have the user permission to move pages but only if the target page (new title) does not exist. Since “CFU Club Shield” exists, you would not be able to move “CONCACAF

3027:

So I added the reference. Yes I have reviewed those items. I greatly admire the amount of work done by all these historians and researchers however what I saw in a number of these is compounded errors. People kept referencing the same thing. I went all the way back and scoured the libraries of all

2419:

Thank you for the feedback, I appreciate being able to learn more about WikiPedia and want to say thank you for treating this situation as a learning experience for me rather then a negative experience. I do have a question. I see you used a process to merge histories. I know it seems like that is

3045:

I reviewed a few more pages and while I encourage people to contribute to this era because I have been working alone here, I want to caution about sources as above. I worked for a long time to bring information that was not on the internet out in the open with as much accuracy and completeness as

2596:

Yet, Anisur Rahman would find it difficult to get himself in to the main national team. Of course, two other left armers, Prince and Dulu were in the team already. Also, no ball problems combined with injuries hampered Anisur’s progress. Still, following the retirement of Prince and Dulu in 1994,

2494:

as part of the June Women in Green "Good Article" editathon, but it appears that this article has already met and passed a formal GA review & reassessment (it is currently rated "A-Class", which is actually one level higher than GA!), so this article is not the best choice for working towards

1351:- "Concerns have been raised about the football box collapsible and its compliance with MOS:ACCESS. For further information and the most recent discussions, see Knowledge (XXG):Dispute resolution noticeboard/Archive 238#Football Season articles and football results articles." It can be found here 2977:

Ok so I did review some of the edits to 1885 and I am going to have to revert at least one. One of the references is incorrect. I spent many years working on just that tournament and with 150% definitive proof there were only six teams entered and participated in that tournament not thirteen. No

1418:

articles uses current format. I oppose the idea of regressing editing recommendations for standardization. We need to encourage other editors to bring their articles up to current standards and in turn provide a better product for those who use electronic adjuncts for their wikipedia experience.

1661:

about the concerns with this template. I know the new template loses thing like cards and opponents whom score, but do those stats matter to the club the article is about? I would discourage the idea of putting the collapsible boxscore underneath the new template and instead start or add to the

3061:

I appreciate your work on finding sources that reference this time period of soccer. You in no way are kicking anyone in the teeth, even if you are attempting to suggest there is some form a research you have performed that is in some way better then other editors on Knowledge (XXG). I do have

1967:

The Universal Code of Conduct Coordinating Committee (U4C) is a global group dedicated to providing an equitable and consistent implementation of the UCoC. Community members were invited to submit their applications for the U4C. For more information and the responsibilities of the U4C, please

1409:

I appreciate that feedback, but why would we want all of the MLS pages to not be in line with WP Football. I agree with starting the conversation with whatever group of editors you think control MLS articles, but I would use the 2024 Austin FC season page as the example of what WP Football

1944: 2957:

I appreciate what you are saying. I am finding much of the same info the early history of soccer. I agree with avoiding the pay sites as much as possible, which is why I linked the newspapers.com link the way I did, it allows them to be linked and reviewed without being a pay member.

3077:

because of all the indiscriminate copy pasting from rsssf and the archive from past editors. I have seen some people go overboard on the references and it starts to look hideous. But I get it, it’s not wrong. Give time to dig up the old notes. I’m working rugby right now.

77:

Under the reward board I choose September 1 and looked under ineligible. I found Ferenc Gyulay and there was not a reference for his death date. I have provided a reference for the death date on that article. Hope this is what you were looking for.

1947: 1656:

suggests that season pages should not just become a listing of stats related to the subject. I personally don't think this second concern is a great concern in the collapsible box scores, but it is still a concern. There is more discussion on

242:

Thank you for writing the article on Knowledge (XXG)! I genuinely appreciate your efforts in creating the article on Knowledge (XXG) and expanding the sum of human knowledge in Knowledge (XXG). Wishing you and your family a great

985: 719: 681: 784:

For soccer match articles, I often find news sources or official webpage of the matches to source the point stats, as these are more reliable than a random score database. Don't hesitate to ask me anything! I am here to help :)

2350:

to Knowledge (XXG). It appears that you tried to give a page a different title by copying its content and pasting either the same content, or an edited version of it, into another page with a different name. This is known as a

3673:(or broader international articles) by month's end. GA resources and one-on-one support will be provided by experienced GA editors, and participants will have the opportunity to earn a special WiG barnstar for their efforts. 2441:(uncontroversial technical requests). Since we need an administrator to fix this up either way, I say we stick with the history merge approach. Let me know if you have any other questions about moving pages. 3607: 1530: 2550:. Our article about it says some material is written by experts and some by fans. Their website emphasizes that "anyone can contribute" and have their work featured alongside that of sports journalists. 1391:

I agree it may be better but I think all MLS pages should use same format, would be best to revert back to the old way until all pages changed. Maybe we can start a discussion on it with other editors.

699:

There is a substantial backlog of unsourced articles on Knowledge (XXG), and we need your help! The purpose of this drive is to add sources to these unsourced articles and make a meaningful impact.

1106: 731: 1302:

backlog drive. Your contributions played a crucial role in sourcing 14,300 unsourced articles during the drive. Thank you so much for participating and helping to reduce the backlog! – –

2386:

from the old title to the new. If you cannot perform a particular page move yourself this way (e.g. because a page already exists at the target title), please follow the instructions at

401:, whether it be someone you have had disagreements with in the past, a good friend, or just some random person. Sending you heartfelt and warm greetings for Christmas and New Year 2024. 3574: 1961: 1658: 1644:

Thank you for reaching out. I am aware alot of editors are more comfortable with the collapsible box scores because they have been using them for an extended period of time. But,

992: 1698:

Good day! Thank you for contributing to Knowledge (XXG) by writing this article. I have marked the article as reviewed. Have a wonderful and blessed day for you and your family!

2909:

Yes I threw some items on the talk pages however I placed everything that I thought was relevant on the main space with references. Is there something specific you identified?

3476: 3256: 2774: 2262: 1865: 1547: 1141: 907: 574: 2103: 1969: 3701: 3472: 3252: 2770: 2258: 1861: 1543: 1137: 903: 570: 3658: 3406: 3397: 3391: 3380: 3374: 3211: 3202: 3192: 3186: 3178: 3172: 2724: 2718: 2710: 2704: 2698: 2210: 2195: 2189: 2181: 2175: 2169: 1804: 1798: 1790: 1784: 1778: 1515: 1499: 1495: 1487: 1483: 1479: 1085: 1081: 1073: 1069: 1065: 873: 857: 853: 845: 841: 537: 524: 518: 510: 504: 495: 3013:

Soccer in a football world : the story of America's forgotten game by David Wangerin also reference thirteen teams entering the 1885 American Cup, for your review.

2602:

He used the reverse swing of the old ball with great effect. In fact, Anisur Rahman was one of the first Bangladeshi bowler to successfully use the reverse swing.

2239: 3727:

It is so belated, hahaha, but yeah, I saw on your user page and just decided to drop a note. It's 17 days late, but please accept my well wishes. Happy editing,

1645: 1352: 1348: 1295: 675: 2390:

to have it moved by someone else. Also, if there are any other pages that you moved by copying and pasting, even if it was a long time ago, please list them at

2044: 2031: 3589: 2052: 3488: 3268: 2786: 2274: 1960:

This is a reminder that the voting period for the Universal Code of Conduct Coordinating Committee (U4C) ends on May 9, 2024. Read the information on the

1877: 1559: 1153: 919: 586: 3100: 1328:

Hi. I was wondering why the format you use is better? the other 28 pages use the format I used. seems we should be consistent on all 29 teams. Thank you

3482: 3262: 2780: 2466:

Darn! Ok, I will learn from this and do it correctly next time. Thank you for doing the behind the scenes work to fix my mistake and merge the history.

2268: 1871: 1553: 1415: 1147: 913: 580: 3028:

the contemporary sources I could to verify these claims. I have also had discussions with some of these historians and clarified some of these issues.

2097: 2978:

paper at that time says any different. There is a reason I do not use American Soccer Archives, RSSSF, or Melvin Smith's "Evolvements" book --: -->

2420:

the right answer, but would it be bad if I undid my editing and went through the move process instead, so I can see how that process is completed?

1411: 2360: 3697: 3651: 3614: 3562: 2391: 2092: 2064: 757: 2605:

The reverse swing with the old ball was Anisur’s big weapon. In fact, he was the first Bangladeshi bowler to use this technique successfully.

2514:

Thank you, I should have reread the content assessment prior to asking. I though A was below GA, awaiting the final GA assessment. Thank you!

2086: 3717: 3349: 3149: 2678: 2149: 1758: 1459: 1045: 821: 556: 475: 3713: 2568:

Examining closely what Tigerbill44 wrote, parts of it are strikingly similar to what was already in our Anisur Rahman article at the time:

743: 3457: 3617:. If you are ever unsure what to do, ask your fellow patrollers or just leave the page for someone else to review – you're not alone! 2379: 3665:

Running from October 1 to 31, 2024, WikiProject Women in Green (WiG) is hosting a Good Article (GA) edit-a-thon event with the theme

730:

You're receiving this message because you have subscribed to the mailing list. To opt-out of future mailings, please remove yourself

2010: 310:

Hey, I've noticed you edit quite a few USL pages and so I wanted to mention that I started an unofficial USL editor project/group

1652:

issues for Knowledge (XXG) users whom utilize screen readers and fails to meet compliance with Knowledge (XXG) guidelines. Also,

311: 3600: 3238: 2756: 3709: 739: 1713: 314:

Letting it be a collective place to chart out goals that folks interested in USL can work on individually or collaboratively.

258: 2347: 2216: 1826: 317:

Feel free to edit the page(s) with your own goals or just use it as a reference point for anything you may want to work on.

3581: 2056: 1004: 790: 386: 38: 2387: 2352: 1630: 1236: 422: 652:. If you have any further suggestions, don´t hesitate to edit or contact me on my talk page. Thank you in advance. 3732: 2500: 1008: 3566: 2371: 339:

Wow! Strong work you have there. I have only glanced at it, but think it looks good and would like to participate.

3451: 2562: 1659:

Knowledge (XXG):Dispute resolution noticeboard/Archive 238#Football Season articles and football results articles

325: 345:

If you have any constructive criticism for me, let me know. I love to learn more about editing. Happy Holidays!

50: 2874: 2538: 2048: 777: 157: 2855: 2437:

Caribbean Shield” on top of it, even if you blanked the page. In that situation, you would have to go through

2073: 1819: 1641: 1626: 1000: 786: 657: 210: 3728: 3690: 3687: 3624: 2511: 2496: 2040: 1310: 2620: 2383: 1653: 390: 2670: 2002: 3570: 2628: 2557:

content undergo the same fact checking as the professional? Is Tigerbill44, the author of the source

1256: 1223: 336: 321: 227: 203:

in citations; otherwise, they are inaccessible to readers without access and are liable to link rot.

3596: 3539: 3319: 2995:

reference that says six teams entered. I will have to mark it with a reference needed due to this.

2837: 2491: 2325: 1928: 1610: 1204: 970: 767: 649: 173: 151: 101: 95: 72: 3141: 3683: 2895: 2546: 2375: 1017: 653: 56: 3577:, please check back there to see if your access is time-limited or if there are other comments. 2586: 1299: 2615:

are based on some third source, but unless it can be identified I think we have to assume that

813: 3554: 3445: 3341: 3119: 2356: 1725: 1294:

This award is given in recognition to Demt1298 for collecting more than 100 points during the

772: 270: 205: 3423: 2867: 2438: 1662:

discussion on WikiProject Football about the fact these stats don't fit into the new format.

3618: 3082: 3051: 3033: 2984: 2948: 2914: 2442: 2395: 1981: 1683: 1396: 1382: 1333: 1303: 438: 410: 52: 21: 2554: 1691: 235: 2639: 2624: 2335: 1975:

Please share this message with members of your community so they can participate as well.

1252: 1219: 369: 109: 1124:

When creating a new article, check various spellings, including birth name, married names

1957:

You are receiving this message because you previously participated in the UCoC process.

1750: 1100: 136: 3535: 3315: 3104: 2833: 2753:

A foreign language biography does not guarantee notability for English Knowledge (XXG).

2363:. Instead, the software used by Knowledge (XXG) has a feature that allows pages to be 2321: 1924: 1606: 1200: 966: 200: 105: 3743: 3679: 3063: 3014: 2996: 2959: 2929: 2891: 2643: 2515: 2467: 2421: 1663: 1420: 1360: 1013: 762: 346: 291: 177: 113: 79: 3510: 3290: 2808: 2296: 1899: 1581: 1175: 941: 619: 3640: 3634: 3514: 3294: 3115: 3111: 2812: 2490:

Hi Demt1298 -- I see that you have requested a 20-minute assessment of the article

2300: 2230: 1903: 1720: 1687: 1585: 1179: 945: 623: 460: 285: 265: 231: 2382:

for you). This both preserves the page history intact and automatically creates a

467: 1103:– All content gender gap events, in every language Knowledge (XXG), in March 2024 3078: 3047: 3029: 3010: 2980: 2944: 2925: 2910: 2463: 2416: 1841: 1406: 1392: 1378: 1344: 1329: 1037: 434: 406: 3442:

when searching for sources, and remember to add her to any of these that apply:

2880:

backlog drive, earning you this Order of the Lesser Scribe of Knowledge (XXG) (

1277: 688: 2122: 1649: 1451: 1356: 385:

Hello Demt1298, may you be surrounded by peace, success and happiness on this

2141: 1945:

You can find this message translated into additional languages on Meta-wiki.

1648:

has the concerns for the collapsible box scores template having significant

888: 394: 597: 3635:

Women in Green's "Around the World in 31 Days" GA Editathon – October 2024

3521: 3301: 2819: 2307: 1910: 1592: 1186: 952: 630: 601: 3439: 2551: 1111: 398: 54: 2928:

No I was just wondering if there was a reference I hadn't found to use.

2342: 3503: 3283: 2801: 2289: 1892: 1845: 1574: 1168: 934: 612: 3751: 3736: 3629: 3613:

You can find a list of other useful links and tools for patrollers at

3606:

If you can read any languages other than English, add yourself to the

3543: 3499: 3322: 3279: 3123: 3086: 3071: 3055: 3037: 3022: 3004: 2988: 2967: 2952: 2937: 2918: 2899: 2840: 2797: 2651: 2632: 2523: 2504: 2475: 2456: 2429: 2409: 2328: 2285: 2211:

Women in Green Good Article Edit-a-thon June 2024 - Going Back in Time

1984: 1931: 1888: 1732: 1671: 1634: 1613: 1570: 1514:

The second round of "One biography a week" begins in April as part of

1428: 1400: 1386: 1368: 1337: 1315: 1260: 1227: 1207: 1164: 984:

Welcome, welcome, welcome Demt1298! I'm glad that you are joining the

973: 930: 794: 747: 661: 608: 459: 442: 414: 354: 329: 299: 277: 216: 185: 163: 121: 87: 3525: 3305: 3158:

August 2024, Volume 10, Issue 8, Numbers 293, 294, 311, 313, 314, 315

2823: 2311: 1914: 1596: 1269:

February 2024 WikiProject Unreferenced articles backlog drive – award

1190: 956: 634: 342:

Thanks for the invite. I will take a closer look when I have a chance

2739: 320:

If nothing else, I appreciate all the edits you do! Happy holidays!

3358:

September 2024, Volume 10, Issue 9, Numbers 293, 294, 311, 316, 317

1850:

is better than none, particularly for biographies of living people.

3580:

This is a good time to re-acquaint yourself with the guidance at

3561:

Hi Demt1298, I just wanted to let you know that I have added the

2866:

You scored 1011 points while adding citations to articles during

484:

January 2024, Volume 10, Issue 1, Numbers 291, 293, 294, 295, 296

3099:

An automated process has detected that when you recently edited

703:

Barnstars will be awarded based on the number of articles cited.

1529:

If you run into technical problems, you might find help on our

1468:

April 2024, Volume 10, Issue 4, Numbers 293, 294, 302, 303, 304

1054:

March 2024, Volume 10, Issue 3, Numbers 293, 294, 299, 300, 301

710:, both to advertise the event and tally the points later using 2687:

July 2024, Volume 10, Issue 7, Numbers 293, 294, 311, 312, 313

2158:

June 2024, Volume 10, Issue 6, Numbers 293, 294, 308, 309, 310

57: 15: 1767:

May 2024, Volume 10, Issue 5, Numbers 293, 294, 305, 306, 307

830:

February 2024, Volume 10, Issue 2, Numbers 293, 294, 297, 298

3639: 3553: 3340: 3140: 2669: 2140: 2001: 1749: 1450: 1126:

and pseudonyms, to be sure an article doesn't already exist.

1036: 988:! Please, have a cup of WikiTea, and go cite some articles. 812: 687: 466: 2434:

You are welcome! Thank you for being receptive to feedback.

2374:, you should be able to move an article yourself using the 290:

Thank you for the for the feedback, I truly appreciate it.

2071:

Looking for a new project? perhaps authoring an article on

892:

can now be searched on the ProQuest tab at the WP Library.

711: 2370:

In most cases for registered users, once your account is

2862:

Thanks for participating in the June 2024 backlog drive!

2530:

Reliability and Citogenesis at Anisur Rahman (cricketer)

3700:. You can remove yourself from receiving notifications 3565:

to your account. This means you now have access to the

3103:, you added a link pointing to the disambiguation page 2578: 2558: 2110: 1938:

Reminder to vote now to select members of the first U4C

1822:- contest with certificates of participation and prizes 1625:

page? That is just how I do the schedules and scores.

872:

Please let other wikiprojects know about our February

3491: