User talk:Paul_012 - Knowledge (XXG)

2354: 2158: 2229: 1791: 1541: 3202: 3709:, the first time was after it was manually orphaned) because of this. That doesn't mean there's absolutely no place for clarifications notes, but I would favour limiting them to names that are actually likely to be confused, such as people whose field of work makes them likely to be looked up by readers who've never read anything about Thai people. And as mentioned above, I think that footnotes, not hatnotes, are the appropriate format. -- 86: 3685:, where there was no consensus on the issue. More recently, some editors have preferred replacing them with footnotes, which I agree are more appropriate for their function—to provide information about the current article's subject. The reader shouldn't be distracted with information about which is a person's given name and surname (along with several minimally relevant links) before they even read a single word about said person. 3256: 4151: 3833: 3787: 2115: 819: 573: 466: 193: 2266: 2555: 1136: 3693:

not hatnotes, which are for the reader. But if it's for the reader, such explanation isn't really necessary as it's deducible from reading the article, provided they know which is the given name. So the only concern would be that a reader unfamiliar with the culture may come upon an article, see references to the first name, and become confused as to which is the given name and surname.

4405: 1473: 1404: 3572: 3400: 3310: 3107: 3011: 2915: 1675: 1586: 2764: 3986:เทศบาลตำบลเวียงฝาง (Wieng Fang Subdistrict Municipality) is a local administrative organization located within Wiang Subdistrict, Fang District, Chiang Mai Province, Thailand. It is not an administrative district (amphoe); rather, it is a local government entity operating within Wiang Subdistrict. For more detailed information, you can refer to their official website at 3273:. However, the image is currently not used in any articles on Knowledge (XXG). If the image was previously in an article, please go to the article and see why it was removed. You may add it back if you think that that will be useful. However, please note that images for which a replacement could be created are not acceptable for use on Knowledge (XXG) (see 1759: 4256: 4247:

Knowledge (XXG)'s naming convention is to stick to the usual Forename Surname format. Correct as you reason. But the previous name is correct in this article. There are reliable sources of information. There are sources that consistently refer to him. His name Patrick is not a nickname. His full name

3680:

This is a similar issue to surname-clarification hatnotes. Their use actually violates the guideline, though their long existence has led to them being tolerated for certain groups of articles, mostly East Asian biographies. I'm not updated on the community's position, the latest discussion I know of

263:

I'm not a regular AfC reviewer, so for that you might want to submit it through the usual process or ask someone else. I would comment, though, that unlike the EEC, which was the subject of a lot of sustained news coverage, these other economic corridor projects don't seem to be individually notable,

3692:

In given-name notices, the clarification is mixed in with an explanation on how to refer to people, which needs asking: who is this instruction meant for? If it's for editors (who might be unaware and incorrectly change the text), such messages should be given via in-source comments or edit notices,

356:

That's a good start. I think it could be developed either way (expanding to include the ECs, or having them as a separate article). Combining would allow for a single overview of their history, since their development is under the same government agency, but if/once they become more developed with a

3900:

Don't worry about it. Welcome to Knowledge (XXG), and thanks for contributing. Basically, Knowledge (XXG) articles generally only use parenthetical qualifiers when the title would be ambiguous without them. The practice is called "disambiguation" on Knowledge (XXG). Since the date already precisely

1311:

I appreciate your reply. It took more than a year for the article to be promoted on the Thai Knowledge (XXG). I do not know how long it will take on the English Knowledge (XXG). Most students are here for a relatively short term to learn some skills and experience. However, we are expected to be

917:

from July 2022 regarding notability of train stations? I see someone cited the 2019 discussion which the 2022 one supersedes, but not the 2022 one - I'm a little aghast that this happened. I'm not familiar with the details on this particular station, but you might have a case for DRV as most of the

775:

I'm rather familiar with the contributor. He's contributed to dozens of articles on luk thung singers over many years; this one is very much within his normal area of interest. And he's literally a school student. It's very unlikely that he's connected to the subject by employment. A false claim on

2720:

Hi Paul 012, thanks for letting me know. I will copy it over. In the future, if you are submitting a draft on behalf of someone else, the easiest way is to use {{subst:submit|XXXX}} where the XXXX is the user name that should get the notice. If you use the submit button, you can change the User

648:

when creating the page and included the name list as a section there as the surname is exclusive to the family. If the name list was a separate page, the template would be included as standard, but the documented guidance doesn't quite fit this specific case. I think it's most within the spirit of

2803:

Thanks you for your modification and yes I think that the death’s place aren’t Thailand 🇹🇭 but Vietnam 🇻🇳 because the source says « point d’appui de Bai Tho » and Bai Tho is a location point in Vietnam. But I am not sure at 100%. I find also this : Bang Son ตำบล บางซ่อน, Ban Pho, Province de

3546:

I should ask it on the page which contains the discussion "Discussion about new article on marine resources?" and clearly treats marine resources as within the scope of the project? Fish are marine resources. I also see a large number of fish and related topics in the linked articles category.

4337:

That's why I put the "BL" dab link on the hatnote, because of this rule, its relation to the article title, and so readers could "find the page they are looking for" more easily with a dab page. Again, I'm not looking to argue or be educated, please feel free to ignore this message. Cheers! —

404:

As noted in the edit summary, it appeared to be a single product by one company and not notable according to Knowledge (XXG)'s criteria. As for the second point, I am of the opinion that "inventions and discoveries" refers to scientific and technological advancements, not cultural heritage.

1876:. My attempts at translating it via Google have rendered it as either 'The Thai Money "Factory"' or a misspelling of "Royal Theater", but your translation help would greatly be appreciated; even if it's garbled (which I highly suspect), maybe you can suss out what was meant back then. 757:

I understand your point regarding the tik tok video, however, the editor claims to have taken the pic in November 2022, predating the tik tok upload. They've uploaded a number of other files, and have been selective in claiming authorship, or giving credit. Not sure about this one.

4251:

Please change the redirect back to his correct name. moved page Nattawat Finkler to Patrick Nattawat Finkler He currently lives and works in China. Known as Patrick Finkler, in China he goes only by the name Yin Haoyu, and Thai news agencies refer to him as Patrick Nattawat.

4257:

https://www.triamudom.ac.th/website/images/%E0%B8%9B%E0%B8%A3%E0%B8%B0%E0%B8%81%E0%B8%B2%E0%B8%A8%E0%B8%A3%E0%B8%B2%E0%B8%A2%E0%B8%8A%E0%B8%AD%E0%B8%9C%E0%B8%A1%E0%B8%AA%E0%B8%97%E0%B8%98%E0%B8%84%E0%B8%94%E0%B8%81%E0%B8%A3%E0%B8%AD%E0%B8%87%E0%B8%82%E0%B8%99%E0%B8%97_2.pdf

1045:

for details. NPP isn't supposed to be a stringent review by any means, but the queue is unfortunately often backlogged and pages may go unnoticed for some time. I'm not a new page reviewer so I can't help you there, but if you need further advice the place to ask would be

4306:

Hey, I just wanted to ask you if it is allowed for other people to edit your user page without your consent, because someone did that to me and it (please excuse my language), realy pissed me off. If you could reply on my talk page it would be greatly appreciated. Thanks

3676:

guideline, i.e. they should be reserved for letting readers know if they're in the wrong place and direct them to the article they're looking for. They're placed prominently at the top of articles so that readers will see them before they waste time reading the wrong

3696:

It's a valid concern, but one that isn't very significant, considering that it's a piece of information that only has to be learned once (unlike, say, with Japanese names, which are often ordered inconsistently). After that it just becomes a repetitive distraction.

933:

Thanks for the pointer. I knew of the 2019 RfC, but indeed not the 2022 one. I didn't think that that AfD singling out a single station was the best way to address the issue, so I didn't argue more strongly on the lack of source coverage. But the fact is also that

1977:

No worries, I was just hoping (possibly beyond hope) that you had any of the revisions of the deleted pages themselves (so, any content that was on the "Ç‹¬ç‰¹è§è§£" page), but I assume that Phase II and Phase III truly, permanently, "shredded" any deleted pages.

4239:

If the name of this article is changed, it should be the name that is commonly known in the profession, namely Patrick Finkler or Yin Haoyu. His full legal name is Patrick Nattawat Finkler, and the media in Thailand will refer to him in Thai as Patrick Nattawat.

4043:, which were created to propagate the concept and are inherently related to the main topic. Both titles redirect to the main article. If you think that the map categories shouldn't be on the main article, please move them to the redirect pages instead, per 1070:

This user is regularly deleting information from Bright Vachirawit Chivaaree work, without any justifications. Entire history this user is deleting artist achievements, which has reliable source. Requesting you to block this user from creating vandalism

3521:, given the often ill-defined boundaries between such bodies. However, should there develop other projects with overlapping scope, this project will deal primarily with those articles which do not fall within the scope of any of those other projects. 2067:

PS I'm not necessarily opposed to deletion or redirecting, especially if taking fancruft concerns into consideration, as there really doesn't seem to be much real content among these articles as they stand. My contesting of those PRODs was mainly on

3688:

For Thai names, there's usually no need for clarification as they follow the order most English readers would be familiar with, though there are uncommon cases where confusion has arisen. In such cases, I would favour using footnotes to clarify the

4248:

according to the law used to apply to study at a Thai high school. And the university in China is Patrick Nattawat Finkler. There is a certificate of his name in the reference source as confirmation. You can find truthful information about him.

938: 620:

because it doesn't seem applicable when I read the template documentation. Moreover, a quick browse through hundreds of articles transcluding the template couldn't find any articles with Family in its title. And Family articles, e.g. those in

2034:

and others in the series. I'm not OK with unreferenced articles standing. Do you have a proposal to go forward, perhaps you are taking on referencing the unreferenced (or equivalently, those that are only referenced to the pageant itself). ☆

667:

I agree that this case is can be argued either way and I won't try to remove it again. I find it strange, however, that if the surname template is used, any short description specified will be overridden by a standard "Surname list" text.

3657:, removing the given-name hatnote I had added, which you called "more distracting than helpful" and "generally unnecessary". Why is a footnote is a better solution? What's your criterion for given-name hatnotes? Would you ever use them? 4285:

Thanks for the correction. I had looked through news items and press releases and only found those that referred to him as นายณัฐวรรธ์ ฟิงค์เลอร์. Evidently, they're mistaken, as the documents you linked show. I've moved the page back.

1266:

The article is now a featured article on Thai Knowledge (XXG). We would like to improve it and nominate it as a featured article on the English Knowledge (XXG) too. Your kind participation in the process will be greatly appreciated.

1690: 152:

Paul - The movie is produced by GMMTV and copyright is with them. Please add back GMMTV link. Chronology - Taiwan's movie with same name. To be given credit & be mentioned in the movie details. For director - GMMTVs reference

1916:

From several encodings I tested from UTF-8, x-mac-thai was the only one without any "?"s or other faulty characters. Interesting to hear it still doesn't make any semantic sense, I'll let you know if anything else comes from it.

2052:

Sorry, my Knowledge (XXG) activity follows an I'm-feeling-like-it basis, so I can't make promises. If you believe the articles shouldn't be allowed to exist in this state without a concrete future road map, there's always AfD.

1901:

It's pure gibberish, and Google Translate's suggested "corrections" are also meaningless nonsensical character sequences that certainly don't translate to anything. Not sure why Thai was thought to be the intended encoding?

876:

Knowledge (XXG), like all sites using the MediaWiki software, uses wiki markup to format its pages. I don't know if you've been using the source editor, but if so, you're probably already familiar with it. Otherwise, see

3607: 2869:

Wikidata only allows statements to link to existing items, and there's no Bang Son in Vietnam listed on Wikidata (nor enough information to support creating a new item). I've changed the statement to Tonkin instead.

4243:

As there are reliable sources in Thai, English and Chinese, please check the information before making changes. He doesn't have a Thai name like other Thai people. which is normal for Thai people who are mixed race

2311: 1090:, but the specific cases you mention could also just be content disputes, as there's often disagreement on what awards are notable enough for inclusion, so please try to discuss the issues on the talk page first. -- 531:

You shouldn't have copied from the Samut Prakan radiation accident article, though, as the circumstances were very different and as such the copied content was wildly incorrect, short and abruptly ending as it was.

860:

Hi Paul, I need little guidance, I am trying to upskill myself in tech field, hence exploring Knowledge (XXG) opportunities. Could you please let me know apart from HTML what domain majorly used in article making?

1375: 310:

I still think all of them should have a separate page instead of being under SEZ. Alternatively, we could consider merging NEC, NEEC, SEC, and CEWC under a single page for Special Economic Corridors of Thailand.

944:

made me averse to trying to enforce policy on railway station notability through AfD, as they seem to always turn into a battle against people piling on with I-like-it !votes not based in policy, RfC or no.

3933:

When considering article titles (and also other matters) it's a good idea to look at the article talk page to see if there have been past discussions on the issue. In this case the page had been renamed to

3623: 3451: 3366: 3170: 3074: 2978: 1641: 2168: 941: 419:

I understand your point regarding cultural heritage. However, the Elide Fire Extinguishing Ball has won multiple awards and is recognized in multiple countries, which could demonstrate its notability.

3885:. I didn't think it would be contentious. To be honest, the title just seems bare without a locale indicated. But whatever. I don't think it's worth opening a discussion but if you disagree... Yours. 2295:. It has the authority to impose binding solutions to disputes between editors, primarily for serious conduct disputes the community has been unable to resolve. This includes the authority to impose 4122:

Please respond to issues regarding specific articles on that article's talk page, where the issue was raised. And you may NOT delete article talk page discussions. I'll continue the discussion at

2236: 325:

They shouldn't be at risk of speedy deletion for advertising, though they may not be accepted with the current references. I think they'd have better chance if combined under a single article. --

154: 513:

Which I don't agree with that propose. Because If there is no one make the Page then there will be none. For example in thai page. There's always other people who will ready to write after me.

935: 209: 3350: 420: 390: 343: 312: 297: 283: 249: 2280: 889:

programming language. All of these are only used by MediaWiki, though, so they might not be a very useful skillset elsewhere. Not sure if this answers your question; let me know if not. --

3706: 2129: 1087: 910: 4156:

A category or categories you have created have been nominated for possible deletion, merging, or renaming. A discussion is taking place to decide whether this proposal complies with the

1227: 589: 4162: 4143: 482: 1350:

is working on the article. If you have any comments/suggestions, please feel free to reach out. We are aiming for an FA nomination. It has been a long time since the GA promotion

3847: 3801: 3702: 833: 1225:! Having an article draft declined at Articles for Creation can be disappointing. If you are wondering why your article submission was declined, please post a question at the 4443: 4412: 4398: 1147:

More sources and content are needed. This definitely seems notable, but also very incomplete right now. Will decline for now, but more sources and content will go a long way.

3626:

after its run on the Main Page has completed. Finally, if you know of an interesting fact from another recently created article, then please feel free to suggest it on the

3454:

after its run on the Main Page has completed. Finally, if you know of an interesting fact from another recently created article, then please feel free to suggest it on the

3369:

after its run on the Main Page has completed. Finally, if you know of an interesting fact from another recently created article, then please feel free to suggest it on the

3173:

after its run on the Main Page has completed. Finally, if you know of an interesting fact from another recently created article, then please feel free to suggest it on the

3077:

after its run on the Main Page has completed. Finally, if you know of an interesting fact from another recently created article, then please feel free to suggest it on the

2981:

after its run on the Main Page has completed. Finally, if you know of an interesting fact from another recently created article, then please feel free to suggest it on the

1644:

after its run on the Main Page has completed. Finally, if you know of an interesting fact from another recently created article, then please feel free to suggest it on the

2628: 2524: 3208: 3201: 1625: 698:? I feel like the current article on Sbai places too much emphasis on its connection to Cambodia. I don't have experience with moving pages, can you help me request it? 4424: 4420: 2805: 1492: 1488: 1423: 1419: 3435: 2804:

Chachoengsoa, Thaïlande Yes it’s in French because I am French. The first reference can be Vietnam (Bai Tho) but the second one can be Thailand. In this source :

622: 2659: 2637:

Please check the submission for any additional comments left by the reviewer. You are encouraged to edit the submission to address the issues raised and resubmit

1171: 1149:

Please check the submission for any additional comments left by the reviewer. You are encouraged to edit the submission to address the issues raised and resubmit

1042: 713:

As this would be a potentially controversial move, raising the issue on the article talk page first, as you have done, is a good idea. I'll reply further there. --

3154: 3058: 2962: 2777: 1511: 1480: 1466: 3682: 1215: 3762:. This one's more readable so I think it should be rescuable without starting from scratch—most of the relevant info can probably be found in Thai sources. -- 3496: 2353:

I see that you wrote the article and its translation is being nominated for feature article on Thai Knowledge (XXG). Please see and comment if possible at

1951: 1047: 238: 3114: 3018: 2922: 1325:

composing/writing a comprehensive article from variety of online/printed sources rather than a mere translation of existing article from another language.

4066: 4040: 2461: 4394: 3285: 2652: 1819:

Reviewing/patrolling a page doesn't take much time, but it requires a strong understanding of Knowledge (XXG)’s CSD policy and notability guidelines.

1593: 1462: 1393: 1164: 4190: 1736: 4374:, not the other way round. (But also, BL is not an article about something else. It's a disambiguation page that already prominently links bank to 3579: 3407: 3317: 3241: 4335:

If a notable topic X is commonly referred to as "Foo", but the article "Foo" is not about X, there must be a hatnote linking to the article on X.

1813: 987: 1661: 4428: 4167: 3852: 3806: 2134: 1496: 1427: 838: 594: 487: 214: 4431:, or a project category that by its nature may become empty on occasion. If it remains empty for seven days or more, it may be deleted under 4214: 1809:

team is currently struggling to keep up with the influx of new articles and redirects needing review. We could use a few extra hands to help.

1499:, or a project category that by its nature may become empty on occasion. If it remains empty for seven days or more, it may be deleted under 1430:, or a project category that by its nature may become empty on occasion. If it remains empty for seven days or more, it may be deleted under 51:. Be aware that the page may be outdated and that the user whom this page is about may have no personal affiliation with any site other than 3751: 3600: 3591: 3525: 2334: 1987: 1926: 1891: 246: 3529: 1563:, which you nominated. If you know of another recently created or updated article suitable for inclusion in ITN, please suggest it on the 434: 918:

keep arguments are directly contradicting the RfC's close of "There clear is consensus that train stations have no inherent notability."

3215: 1564: 4416: 4236:

His legal Thai name is just Patrick Nattawat Finkler Patrick is not a nickname, but a real name. Nattawat is the middle name in Thai.

1484: 1415: 1293:

Thanks for reaching out. I don't currently have much on-wiki time, but I'll try to keep an eye on the article and see what I can do. —

824: 810: 737: 546:

Oh,I see. Sory for my bad. And also reason that I copied because I want it to being natural to reader but my bad for not checking it.

158: 2808:(by the French Government) It says that Jean was kill in Bang-Son in Tonkin and Tonkin is the north of Vietnam Have a nice weekend. 2561: 2542: 1142: 1123: 3870: 424: 394: 347: 316: 301: 287: 253: 2806:

https://www.memoiredeshommes.sga.defense.gouv.fr/fr/arkotheque/client/mdh/guerre_indochine/detail_fiche.php?ref=1633325&debut=0

2608: 31: 2376:(who doesn't seem to be currently active). I'm afraid I'm not familiar enough with the available sources to really help there. -- 2120: 2106: 1707: 242: 2679: 2620: 2615: 2498: 1191: 278:

Hmm I think CEWC is important enough, If we're talking about news coverage, there are even videos about CEWC, such as this one:

4005: 2330: 510: 37:

This is not an encyclopedia article or the talk page for an encyclopedia article. If you find this page on any site other than

3503: 2304: 1241:, a friendly space on Knowledge (XXG) where experienced editors lend a hand to help new editors like yourself! See you there! 3946:

discussions. For pages with such previous consensus, you should discuss further renaming proposals on the talk page first. --

2624: 2579: 923: 385:

Why did you remove the Elide Fire Extinguishing Ball from the list of Thai inventions? Was it not invented by a Thai person?

339: 3269:. The image description page currently specifies that the image is non-free and may only be used on Knowledge (XXG) under a 48: 4356: 3935: 3792: 3778: 2192: 1947: 4083:

That would be fine by me. Though I do think it's easier for navigation if the categories are kept on the main article. --

3274: 3270: 2602: 1038: 4062: 4036: 3187: 3091: 2995: 342:: I am unsure if this article will cover all of the economic zones in Thailand, including NEC, NEEC, SEC, CEWC, and EEC. 123: 119: 115: 111: 107: 103: 99: 1312:

long-term volunteers who can take over the task if needed. My support for the article is to set a good example for both

3733:--I haven't been able to find adequate sources for the title as-written, but my ability to work with Thai is limited. 3552: 3492: 3432:

compiled his authoritative English–Thai dictionary while in prison, with the manuscripts smuggled out for publication?

3237: 2645: 2546: 2316: 2031: 4157: 3943: 3902: 3842: 3796: 2583: 2124: 828: 584: 477: 204: 3556: 3627: 3613: 3467: 3455: 3441: 3370: 3356: 3174: 3160: 3078: 3064: 2982: 2968: 1657: 1645: 1631: 579: 564: 199: 184: 2575: 472: 457: 4312: 4208: 2485: 1851: 919: 4330: 2631:

when addressing this issue). If no additional references exist, the subject is not suitable for Knowledge (XXG).

1037:

That's probably the case. Newly created pages won't be indexed by search engines until they are reviewed by the

476:

has been nominated for renaming. A discussion is taking place to decide whether this proposal complies with the

203:

has been nominated for deletion. A discussion is taking place to decide whether this proposal complies with the

132: 4370:

is an article about something else, there will then need to be a hatnote at the top of the BL page pointing to

3339: 3329: 2394:

Thanks again for your reply. The article was promoted and it will soon be on the main page of Thai Wikpedia. --

2142: 2123:

has been nominated for merging. A discussion is taking place to decide whether this proposal complies with the

1983: 1922: 1887: 1109: 1076: 866: 827:

has been nominated for merging. A discussion is taking place to decide whether this proposal complies with the

583:

has been nominated for merging. A discussion is taking place to decide whether this proposal complies with the

4329:

Not trying to argue about policy because clearly you're a more experienced editor than I am, I'm just quoting

4044: 2292: 433:

I could be wrong about the fire-extinguishing ball. I won't revert if someone re-adds it. In cases like this,

3939: 3610:. You are welcome to check how many pageviews the nominated article or articles got while on the front page 3438:. You are welcome to check how many pageviews the nominated article or articles got while on the front page 3353:. You are welcome to check how many pageviews the nominated article or articles got while on the front page 3183: 3157:. You are welcome to check how many pageviews the nominated article or articles got while on the front page 3087: 3061:. You are welcome to check how many pageviews the nominated article or articles got while on the front page 2991: 2965:. You are welcome to check how many pageviews the nominated article or articles got while on the front page 2086:

Yes, I wanted to know what your plans were before I went that route, to avoid wasting effort for anybody. ☆

1943: 1628:. You are welcome to check how many pageviews the nominated article or articles got while on the front page 1442: 1411: 1397: 1027: 1011: 741: 4268: 3993: 2590: 1872:

Back in 2002, someone tried to make an article entitled ร์โ«นยฌรงโ«ฐยนรจยงรจยงยฃ on Knowledge (XXG), which

1374:

nominated it yesterday. It appears that we have two negative feedback that need to be addressed urgently.

4275: 4107:

Temperature 13.7°C on March 3, 1986 at Bangkok Metropolis station. Source taken from data on ogimet.com .

3860: 3838: 3824: 3814: 3548: 3488: 3222: 3147: 3051: 3030: 2955: 2249: 846: 602: 495: 222: 2564:

has been reviewed. Unfortunately, it has not been accepted at this time. The reasons left by S0091 were:

1827: 1145:

has been reviewed. Unfortunately, it has not been accepted at this time. The reason left by Losipov was:

988:

WT:WikiProject Hospitals#IP-hopping vandal changing hospital descriptions, esp. to add "district general"

703: 264:

and should probably be covered together under a single article, or as a section under an existing one. --

4262: 4160: