657:, namely that multiple sources are needed "so that we can write a reasonably balanced article that complies with Knowledge (XXG):Neutral point of view". Otherwise, editors will just cherry-pick facts from routine coverage in recaps of individual games, as opposed to independent sources that look at the rivalry as a whole. "Local coverage" is not as issue for me; its the limited number of independent sources. A rivalry from say California or Texas would likely generate more in-state, independent coverage than a series from Idaho.—
685:(Idaho Falls, ID), September 11, 1997 ("There will be no bonfires, no mayoral bets, no side of ham that might be Fed-Exed from the Gate City to Moscow, or vice versa. Ask Idaho State coach Tom Walsh about the Idaho/Idaho State football rivalry, which plays for the 35th time at 4:05 p.m. Saturday, and he's too busy thumping the tub for a win, any win, to worry only about the black and yellow Vandals.");
477:
The first four items are from those independent sources. The fifth may or may not be independent, but is significant for its discussion of the renewal of the rivalry with a conscious effort to brand and market it under the name "Battle of the Domes". Even if the fifth is not independent, we still
183:
839:). Sources from the 1980s and 1990s have been hard to find, as the key Idaho newspapers do not appear on Newspapers.com for those decades, but we now have at least six independent sources dealing with the series as a traditional rivalry.
387:); history dating back to 1916; and frequency of play (played regularly from 1962-1998, less frequently before and after, but set to be renewed starting in 2018). Also, there is some coverage of the series as a rivalry, including
522:- if the rivalry was notable beyond a local level, there would be coverage outside of Idaho. My rule of thumb is that without broader coverage, the case can't be made that this rivalry is anything more than of local interest.
214:
Another creation of same editor. No independent citations to establish a rivalry, just marketing from official sites and game results. Establishment of games results alone from a series is not sufficient for
177:
505:
in-state rivalries of state schools are almost always notable. This is somewhat unique that Idaho State is FCS and Idaho is FBS... but the history still holds up. Notability cannot be lost.--
236:
109:
104:
113:
250:
96:
412:
308:
136:
379:. Several objective indicia of a rivalry are present, including geographic proximity (this is an intra-state rivalry); an official name for the series ("Battle of the Domes", see
143:
356:
336:
724:, Nov. 11, 1963 ("The moment of truth comes next Saturday for fans of Idaho and Idaho State when the two football powers clash at Pocatello in what is fast becoming
264:
713:
Digging through
Newspaperarchive.com, there are actually dozens more articles discussing this series as a traditional rivalry. Here are a few more examples:
628:
how we judge the notability of articles. Here, there appear to be multiple RS third-party newspapers within the state of Idaho that have covered this series
100:
198:
165:
805:, Oct. 7, 1977 ("Ah, rivals. There's nothing quite like them. Take the Idaho State Bengals and their annual donnybrook with the Idaho Vandals ...");
422:
from 2017 ("Bengals and
Vandals Unveil New Rivalry Series, 'Battle of the Domes'"). Not a slam dunk but overall, I think there's enough to pass the
56:
defers to GNG. There's no requirement that there be coverage from sources outside the state of Idaho, which is the main delete argument presented.
92:
84:
848:
708:
666:
641:
610:
580:
561:
532:
514:
491:
464:
435:
368:
348:
327:
297:
270:
256:
242:
228:
78:
159:
693:, April 4, 1997 ("It took some finagling, but Idaho State Athletic Director Irv Cross and Idaho Athletic Director Oval Jaynes have rebuilt
155:
530:
72:
17:
205:
293:
571:- I can't see this being of interest to anyone outside of Idaho. Coverage doesn't appear to make this a significant rivalry.--
589:
541:
171:
871:
40:
653:
with lack of significant coverage in multiple, independent sources. The biggest issue is that it fails the guideline
380:
734:
798:
419:
624:
pass, per Cbl62's sources. Whether it has attracted coverage outside of the local area is irrelevant - that's
809:
781:
751:
405:
281:
528:
510:
66:
675:
In addition to the sources listed above, additional sources are found at
Newslibrary.com. These include:
867:
318:
that are independent of the subject, it is presumed to be suitable for a stand-alone article or list.).
36:
53:
764:
699:."). We now have significant coverage of the rivalry in at least three independent, reliable sources.
289:
391:
637:
445:
191:
398:
717:
323:
224:
662:
554:
523:
506:
460:
364:
344:
62:
29:
The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.
866:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's
826:
654:
455:
as independent sources that mention the rivalry. The others you listed are non-independent.—
58:
35:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's
576:
451:
650:
621:
479:
423:
311:
216:
844:
704:
487:
431:
285:
633:
601:
415:
from 2017 ("Bengals, Vandals to begin Battle of the Domes yearly rivalry series"); and
681:
319:
220:
52:. Cbl62 has presented multiple independent sources that discuss the rivalry; the SNG
658:
551:
456:
360:
340:
394:
from 1967 ("renewing for the seventh time a rivalry that was born back in 1916");
130:
572:
840:
700:
483:
427:
478:
have significant coverage in multiple, reliable sources, thus enough to pass
760:, played before a capacity crowd at the ISU Minidome in Pocatello ...");
408:
from 1976 ("Vandals, Bengals Stoke Fires in Time-Tested
Rivalry");
860:
The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate.
747:
in football
Saturday, the Idaho Vandals ... grudge match ...");
401:
from 1975 ("the ISU-Idaho rivalry has an emotional history");
592:
to generate a more thorough discussion and clearer consensus.
544:
to generate a more thorough discussion and clearer consensus.
735:
Bengals Seek to Break
Vandals Hex in Big Sky Football Opener
632:
over a 50-year period. And, that's enough to meet GNG.
384:
126:
122:
118:
237:
list of
American football-related deletion discussions
190:
819:
oldest intra-state college football rivalry in Idaho
251:
list of
Popular culture-related deletion discussions
816:, Sept. 25, 1975 ("Idaho and Idaho State renew the
598:Please add new comments below this notice. Thanks,
550:Please add new comments below this notice. Thanks,
307:Byline is "By ISU Sports Information Sep 6, 2017"
204:
754:, The Ogden Standard-Examiner, Oct. 4, 1970 ("The
43:). No further edits should be made to this page.
874:). No further edits should be made to this page.
788:, Oct. 26, 1985 ("There's no question it's the
741:, Sep. 26, 1969 ("Idaho State will be meeting
718:Bengals Host Vandals In Big 'Game of the Year'
679:"The Rivalry? New players, coaches and a 1",
8:
799:Idaho-ISU Grid Rivalry Fails to Stir Bengals
357:list of Schools-related deletion discussions
355:Note: This debate has been included in the
335:Note: This debate has been included in the
263:Note: This debate has been included in the
249:Note: This debate has been included in the
235:Note: This debate has been included in the
337:list of Events-related deletion discussions
696:one of the state's best football rivalries
354:
334:
279:
265:list of Idaho-related deletion discussions
262:
248:
234:
833:, Nov 7, 1965 (referring to ISU-Idaho as
316:significant coverage in reliable sources
310:; So is not independent and still fails
794:." ... It's an in-state rivalry ...");
482:. Clearly not a slam dunk but enough.
18:Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion
7:
278:Independent source added 12/30/17.
93:Idaho–Idaho State football rivalry
85:Idaho–Idaho State football rivalry
24:
810:Emotions high in Idaho-ISU battle
782:Idaho-ISU game is Big Sky feature
752:Idaho State Too Much for Vandals
1:
515:22:33, 31 December 2017 (UTC)
436:06:18, 31 December 2017 (UTC)
369:21:02, 30 December 2017 (UTC)
349:21:02, 30 December 2017 (UTC)
328:02:31, 31 December 2017 (UTC)
298:20:37, 30 December 2017 (UTC)
271:05:53, 30 December 2017 (UTC)
257:05:53, 30 December 2017 (UTC)
243:05:52, 30 December 2017 (UTC)
229:05:49, 30 December 2017 (UTC)
849:22:09, 17 January 2018 (UTC)
709:16:53, 17 January 2018 (UTC)
667:12:53, 17 January 2018 (UTC)
642:02:28, 17 January 2018 (UTC)
611:21:27, 14 January 2018 (UTC)
581:03:24, 14 January 2018 (UTC)
492:16:37, 17 January 2018 (UTC)
465:12:40, 17 January 2018 (UTC)
79:21:04, 20 January 2018 (UTC)
562:03:18, 7 January 2018 (UTC)
533:21:14, 6 January 2018 (UTC)
383:); a traveling trophy (see
891:
765:ISU-Idaho is old home week
689:"Return of the Vandals",
314:(If a topic has received
863:Please do not modify it.
791:biggest game of the year
727:a major in-state rivalry
32:Please do not modify it.
771:, Oct. 4, 1974 ("It's
774:a traditional rivalry
814:The Idaho Free Press
267:. Happy New Year!!!
253:. Happy New Year!!!
239:. Happy New Year!!!
831:Idaho State Journal
803:Idaho State Journal
786:Great Falls Tribune
757:traditional rivalry
739:Idaho State Journal
722:Idaho State Journal
446:Idaho State Journal
59:(non-admin closure)
836:"the arch-rivalry"
744:its biggest rival
613:
609:
564:
371:
351:
300:
284:comment added by
273:
259:
245:
61:
882:
865:
827:On the Sidelines
769:Idaho Free Press
608:
606:
599:
597:
595:
593:
559:
549:
547:
545:
452:Idaho Free Press
209:
208:
194:
146:
134:
116:
75:
69:
57:
34:
890:
889:
885:
884:
883:
881:
880:
879:
878:
872:deletion review
861:
614:
602:
600:
588:
586:
565:
555:
540:
538:
151:
142:
107:
91:
88:
73:
67:
48:The result was
41:deletion review
30:
22:
21:
20:
12:
11:
5:
888:
886:
877:
876:
856:
855:
854:
853:
852:
851:
670:
669:
644:
596:
585:
584:
583:
548:
537:
536:
535:
517:
499:
498:
497:
496:
495:
494:
470:
469:
468:
467:
373:
372:
352:
332:
331:
330:
302:
301:
275:
274:
260:
246:
212:
211:
148:
87:
82:
46:
45:
25:
23:
15:
14:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
887:
875:
873:
869:
864:
858:
857:
850:
846:
842:
838:
837:
832:
828:
825:
821:
820:
815:
811:
808:
804:
800:
797:
793:
792:
787:
783:
780:
776:
775:
770:
766:
763:
759:
758:
753:
750:
746:
745:
740:
736:
733:
729:
728:
723:
719:
716:
712:
711:
710:
706:
702:
698:
697:
692:
691:Post Register
688:
684:
683:
682:Post Register
678:
674:
673:
672:
671:
668:
664:
660:
656:
652:
648:
645:
643:
639:
635:
631:
627:
623:
619:
616:
615:
612:
607:
605:
594:
591:
582:
578:
574:
570:
567:
566:
563:
560:
558:
553:
546:
543:
534:
531:
529:
527:
526:
521:
518:
516:
512:
508:
507:Paul McDonald
504:
501:
500:
493:
489:
485:
481:
476:
475:
474:
473:
472:
471:
466:
462:
458:
454:
453:
448:
447:
442:
439:
438:
437:
433:
429:
425:
421:
418:
414:
411:
407:
404:
400:
397:
393:
390:
386:
382:
378:
375:
374:
370:
366:
362:
358:
353:
350:
346:
342:
338:
333:
329:
325:
321:
317:
313:
309:
306:
305:
304:
303:
299:
295:
291:
287:
283:
277:
276:
272:
269:
266:
261:
258:
255:
252:
247:
244:
241:
238:
233:
232:
231:
230:
226:
222:
218:
207:
203:
200:
197:
193:
189:
185:
182:
179:
176:
173:
170:
167:
164:
161:
157:
154:
153:Find sources:
149:
145:
141:
138:
132:
128:
124:
120:
115:
111:
106:
102:
98:
94:
90:
89:
86:
83:
81:
80:
76:
70:
64:
60:
55:
51:
44:
42:
38:
33:
27:
26:
19:
862:
859:
835:
834:
830:
823:
818:
817:
813:
806:
802:
795:
790:
789:
785:
778:
773:
772:
768:
761:
756:
755:
748:
743:
742:
738:
731:
726:
725:
721:
714:
695:
694:
690:
686:
680:
676:
646:
630:as a rivalry
629:
625:
617:
603:
587:
568:
556:
539:
525:TimTempleton
524:
519:
502:
450:
444:
440:
416:
409:
402:
395:
388:
376:
315:
280:— Preceding
268:
254:
240:
213:
201:
195:
187:
180:
174:
168:
162:
152:
139:
63:power~enwiki
49:
47:
31:
28:
178:free images
54:WP:NRIVALRY
604:Sandstein
286:Rick lay95
868:talk page
634:Ejgreen77
361:• Gene93k
341:• Gene93k
37:talk page
870:or in a
590:Relisted
542:Relisted
320:UW Dawgs
294:contribs
282:unsigned
221:UW Dawgs
137:View log
39:or in a
822:...");
777:...");
659:Bagumba
655:WP:WHYN
457:Bagumba
441:Comment
184:WP refs
172:scholar
110:protect
105:history
651:WP:GNG
649:Fails
647:Delete
622:WP:GNG
573:Rusf10
569:Delete
520:Delete
480:WP:GNG
443:I see
424:WP:GNG
312:WP:GNG
217:WP:GNG
156:Google
114:delete
841:Cbl62
730:.");
701:Cbl62
620:as a
484:Cbl62
428:Cbl62
426:bar.
199:JSTOR
160:books
144:Stats
131:views
123:watch
119:links
16:<
845:talk
824:(15)
807:(14)
796:(13)
779:(12)
762:(11)
749:(10)
705:talk
663:talk
638:talk
618:Keep
577:talk
552:ansh
511:talk
503:Keep
488:talk
461:talk
449:and
432:talk
420:this
413:this
406:this
399:this
392:this
385:here
381:here
377:Keep
365:talk
345:talk
324:talk
290:talk
225:talk
192:FENS
166:news
127:logs
101:talk
97:edit
50:keep
732:(9)
715:(8)
687:(7)
677:(6)
626:not
557:666
417:(5)
410:(4)
403:(3)
396:(2)
389:(1)
206:TWL
135:– (
847:)
829:,
812:,
801:,
784:,
767:,
737:,
720:,
707:)
665:)
640:)
579:)
513:)
490:)
463:)
434:)
367:)
359:.
347:)
339:.
326:)
296:)
292:•
227:)
219:.
186:)
129:|
125:|
121:|
117:|
112:|
108:|
103:|
99:|
77:)
71:,
843:(
703:(
661:(
636:(
575:(
509:(
486:(
459:(
430:(
363:(
343:(
322:(
288:(
223:(
210:)
202:·
196:·
188:·
181:·
175:·
169:·
163:·
158:(
150:(
147:)
140:·
133:)
95:(
74:ν
68:π
65:(
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.