262:, none of which seem to have made much of an impact to the series. Also, a lack of reliable sources, as well as about half of the list including real-world locations which had little impact on the series are the final nails in the coffin. If locations need to be mentioned, they can instead be mentioned in the Atlas Shrugged article, but only those locations that really had an impact, not an unnamed bar on top of a skyscraper.
204:―I do confess that I do not know much about it. However, I have found that whereas other articles about lists of fictional locations do have some reasonable secondary sources that establish its notability, there are no such secondary sources here―well, there is are the primary sources, but that, of course, does not establish its "real-world notability" that is
508:. This may be interesting or useful for some fans or scholars, but that doesn't mean it meets our criteria for inclusion. There is simply nothing to indicate that locations in this particular novel are a notable subject covered in secondary sources. There are other sites where this type of trivia can be documented. --
495:
Half the article is made up of real-world places coupled with plot, and the other half is made up of minor sites or building-like places of which any real-world town/region has non-notable thousands. And this is just one novel instead of a franchise where places show up repeatedly and might need a
240:
The most expensive barroom in New York, built on the top of a skyscraper, while reproducing the feel of being in a cellar. It has uncomfortable tiny tables, awful drinks and miserable service......" It's fair enough to have entries on fictional places like Narnia or the bar in Cheers, but such
528:
is one of the greatest books ever written, but this list is pointless and does not belong in
Knowledge (XXG). It is not particularly notable and consists mostly of a list cobbled together of a combination of real places and fictional places, along with odd snippets of the plot of the novel.
216:. In any case, while I myself do not know of the merits of Juhachi's reasoning, given that his opinion was backed up by two other long-established editors in the other discussion, I have reason to believe that his reasoning is probably sound.
161:
554:
Atlas
Shrugged is too long), parts of it can be split off. However, this list is also much too long, even in the context of an "Atlas Shrugged" wiki, so I would vote "trim and merge", if I cared that much about it. —
411:
306:
155:
310:
371:??? Is there a single source anywhere on the planet dealing with this topic in depth, let alone the multiple sources that we would need to see the topic clear notability requirements?
89:
84:
93:
76:
389:
289:
book? If it was a series it would have been understandable. It could instead be merged to the main article if such locations are determined to be integral to the book's plot.
116:
121:
433:
196:
about the notability of fictional places, an editor
Juhachi came to me with a concern that fictional locations with no "real-world" notability probably fail the
330:. Articles such as this are generally linked with notable people, places, and things; as such, should be kept. They are very useful for fans of said topic.
193:
476:
Attempts have been made to relocate the page to other wikis, but no one seems to be interested. See the discussions I linked above for more on that. --
176:
143:
538:
562:
542:
517:
500:
485:
471:
447:
425:
403:
380:
355:
339:
322:
293:
280:
266:
250:
223:
58:
137:
17:
133:
276:
80:
183:
241:
places should feature in multiple works or be really important to the work. Falls in the category of excessive detail. --
72:
64:
581:
40:
258:
As much as I think that this was probably nominated to prove a point, I have to agree with New questions on this one.
272:
149:
335:
534:
467:
246:
220:
559:
352:
290:
263:
209:
577:
36:
348:
56:
331:
169:
530:
463:
242:
217:
311:
Knowledge (XXG):WikiProject
Objectivism/Cross talk/Archive 5#List of locations in Atlas Shrugged
259:
556:
443:
421:
399:
376:
29:
The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.
576:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's
35:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's
513:
481:
318:
271:
How is this an indiscriminate list of locations when it only lists locations of one book?
197:
53:
233:
208:. I know that Atlas Struggled is particularly notable, but noting that notability is not
201:
497:
439:
417:
395:
372:
110:
509:
477:
314:
305:: Participants may be interested in previous discussions about this page at
459:
351:
Things that will only be of importance to a small group of people?
570:
The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate.
550:. When an article becomes too long (and no one doubts that the
307:
Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Places in Atlas
Shrugged
260:
This is nothing more than an indiscriminate list of locations
496:
little explanation. Nothing notable, nothing to salvage. –
412:
list of
Fictional elements-related deletion discussions
106:
102:
98:
168:
367:- Utterly unsourced fancruft. Why locations and why
52:. Topic of the article does not rise to notability.
182:
285:Do we really need to have a list of locations for
43:). No further edits should be made to this page.
584:). No further edits should be made to this page.
390:list of Literature-related deletion discussions
8:
432:Note: This debate has been included in the
410:Note: This debate has been included in the
388:Note: This debate has been included in the
212:, I do not know of why this has notability
200:. Now, forgive me about my ignorance about
434:list of Lists-related deletion discussions
431:
409:
387:
309:(the result of which was thwarted) and
349:Wouldn't that be considered fancruft?
18:Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion
7:
73:List of locations in Atlas Shrugged
65:List of locations in Atlas Shrugged
462:where this would be better off. --
24:
232:This is ridiculously detailed
1:
458:There is an Ayn Rand wiki at
198:general notability guidelines
601:
563:02:26, 18 April 2012 (UTC)
543:01:06, 14 April 2012 (UTC)
518:18:57, 13 April 2012 (UTC)
501:11:33, 13 April 2012 (UTC)
486:18:57, 13 April 2012 (UTC)
472:09:53, 13 April 2012 (UTC)
448:01:12, 13 April 2012 (UTC)
426:01:12, 13 April 2012 (UTC)
404:01:12, 13 April 2012 (UTC)
381:20:05, 12 April 2012 (UTC)
356:12:20, 12 April 2012 (UTC)
340:12:17, 12 April 2012 (UTC)
323:11:00, 12 April 2012 (UTC)
294:11:45, 15 April 2012 (UTC)
281:11:41, 15 April 2012 (UTC)
267:10:37, 12 April 2012 (UTC)
251:09:07, 12 April 2012 (UTC)
224:06:39, 12 April 2012 (UTC)
59:16:17, 19 April 2012 (UTC)
206:independent of the source
573:Please do not modify it.
32:Please do not modify it.
236:full of entries like "
460:objectivismonline.net
273:A Quest For Knowledge
194:lengthy discussion
48:The result was
450:
437:
428:
415:
406:
393:
353:Narutolovehinata5
291:Narutolovehinata5
264:Narutolovehinata5
234:original research
192:Through a recent
592:
575:
438:
416:
394:
187:
186:
172:
124:
114:
96:
34:
600:
599:
595:
594:
593:
591:
590:
589:
588:
582:deletion review
571:
129:
120:
87:
71:
68:
41:deletion review
30:
22:
21:
20:
12:
11:
5:
598:
596:
587:
586:
566:
565:
545:
526:Atlas Shrugged
520:
503:
490:
489:
488:
452:
451:
429:
407:
384:
383:
369:Atlas Shrugged
361:
360:
359:
358:
343:
342:
332:LogicalCreator
325:
300:
299:
298:
297:
296:
253:
202:Atlas Shrugged
190:
189:
126:
67:
62:
46:
45:
25:
23:
15:
14:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
597:
585:
583:
579:
574:
568:
567:
564:
561:
558:
553:
549:
546:
544:
540:
536:
532:
531:Life of Riley
527:
524:
521:
519:
515:
511:
507:
504:
502:
499:
494:
491:
487:
483:
479:
475:
474:
473:
469:
465:
464:Colapeninsula
461:
457:
454:
453:
449:
445:
441:
435:
430:
427:
423:
419:
413:
408:
405:
401:
397:
391:
386:
385:
382:
378:
374:
370:
366:
363:
362:
357:
354:
350:
347:
346:
345:
344:
341:
337:
333:
329:
326:
324:
320:
316:
312:
308:
304:
301:
295:
292:
288:
284:
283:
282:
278:
274:
270:
269:
268:
265:
261:
257:
254:
252:
248:
244:
243:Colapeninsula
239:
238:Bar (unnamed)
235:
231:
228:
227:
226:
225:
222:
219:
215:
211:
207:
203:
199:
195:
185:
181:
178:
175:
171:
167:
163:
160:
157:
154:
151:
148:
145:
142:
139:
135:
132:
131:Find sources:
127:
123:
118:
112:
108:
104:
100:
95:
91:
86:
82:
78:
74:
70:
69:
66:
63:
61:
60:
57:
55:
51:
44:
42:
38:
33:
27:
26:
19:
572:
569:
557:Arthur Rubin
551:
547:
525:
522:
505:
492:
455:
368:
364:
327:
302:
286:
255:
237:
229:
213:
205:
191:
179:
173:
165:
158:
152:
146:
140:
130:
49:
47:
31:
28:
156:free images
221:questions?
54:joe decker
578:talk page
440:• Gene93k
418:• Gene93k
396:• Gene93k
214:in itself
210:inherited
37:talk page
580:or in a
498:sgeureka
117:View log
39:or in a
548:Comment
523:Delete.
456:Comment
373:Carrite
162:WP refs
150:scholar
90:protect
85:history
560:(talk)
510:RL0919
506:Delete
493:Delete
478:RL0919
365:Delete
315:RL0919
256:Delete
230:Delete
134:Google
94:delete
50:delete
177:JSTOR
138:books
122:Stats
111:views
103:watch
99:links
16:<
552:book
514:talk
482:talk
468:talk
444:talk
422:talk
400:talk
377:talk
336:talk
328:Keep
319:talk
313:. --
303:Note
277:talk
247:talk
170:FENS
144:news
107:logs
81:talk
77:edit
529:•••
287:one
218:New
184:TWL
119:•
115:– (
541:)
516:)
484:)
470:)
446:)
436:.
424:)
414:.
402:)
392:.
379:)
338:)
321:)
279:)
249:)
164:)
109:|
105:|
101:|
97:|
92:|
88:|
83:|
79:|
539:C
537:–
535:T
533:(
512:(
480:(
466:(
442:(
420:(
398:(
375:(
334:(
317:(
275:(
245:(
188:)
180:·
174:·
166:·
159:·
153:·
147:·
141:·
136:(
128:(
125:)
113:)
75:(
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.