1316:
898:
1271:, note that we do not need a parent category when there is just a main article with an albums and songs subcategory because in that case all content is linked by the {{Songs by artist}} and {{Albums by artist}} templates already. The discography article may well be put in the albums category.
429:
So basically, you're saying we should create thousands of "works by" categories for any music artist with "Foo albums" and "Foo songs" categories. This has never been done that way before when there is such minimal content.
183:
are hardcoded to say "lives in", "hails from" and similar phrases, so there's still benefit from this subcategorization. Another possibility, to not disturb the structure of subcategories
530:
1323:
905:
42:
37:
226:
1444:
456:. Not my words, just our usual guideline. There are two categories here and an argument can be made to delete one of them, but you've nominated the wrong one.
470:
There's been a scheme of "albums by artist" and "songs by artist" for years but never one that places the two in a "works by" parent category. Both this and
225:
Thanks for checking out. The two US categories have the same content so they should be merged. Well, that may require a separate nomination after all. See
806:
No objection to a rename. Also, how can this be a reprisal to a nomination that was made after this one? Please don't assume bad faith on my part.
755:. Subcategories already sufficiently interlinked. If this is not sufficient, then we should be using a "works by" category, not an eponymous one.
188:
21:
131:
Userboxes in the category allow customization (advertized on documentations subpages) to include any verb phrase, not just "lives in". —
354:
17:
196:
105:
192:
176:
184:
151:
180:
789:
345:
125:
109:
850:
696:
536:
788:
Note also that this is an obvious and bad faith reprisal to the CfD nomination above (albeit an incorrect CfD), for
362:
1569:
1540:
1513:
1483:
1456:
1432:
1366:
1280:
1253:
1231:
1196:
1173:
1107:
1040:
1013:
948:
862:
841:
820:
801:
769:
703:
632:
615:
593:
570:
544:
520:
491:
465:
447:
420:
401:
336:
269:
246:
212:
163:
140:
97:
1589:
1493:
1440:
1347:
1300:
1088:
1060:
929:
882:
680:
652:
317:
289:
78:
966:
1534:
1477:
1426:
1167:
1007:
814:
763:
721:
609:
564:
540:
1497:
1384:
1125:
957:
471:
1565:
1509:
1501:
1452:
1276:
1227:
1192:
858:
797:
712:
516:
461:
416:
265:
242:
234:
159:
1585:
1343:
1296:
1084:
1056:
974:
925:
878:
676:
648:
313:
285:
74:
729:
1116:
837:
589:
200:
853:, remove the eponymous article from the category and link to it in the header of the category page.
550:"And we certainly shouldn't be giving preference to an eponymous category over a works category per
124:
At the moment, there is no need for specific "of residence" category. It is the only subcategory of
1529:
1472:
1421:
1162:
1002:
809:
758:
604:
559:
1392:
1133:
628:
208:
136:
227:
Knowledge:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2019_July_5#Category:US_city_of_residence_user_templates
1584:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the category's
1561:
1505:
1448:
1295:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the category's
1272:
1223:
1208:
and a "works by" parent to sufficiently interlinked subcategories is still overcategorization.
1188:
1055:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the category's
877:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the category's
854:
793:
647:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the category's
512:
457:
412:
284:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the category's
261:
238:
230:
170:
155:
1342:
Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the category's
1083:
Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the category's
924:
Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the category's
675:
Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the category's
312:
Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the category's
73:
Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the category's
1557:
1523:
1519:
1489:
1466:
1415:
1375:
1268:
1219:
1205:
1156:
997:
752:
551:
508:
500:
453:
833:
585:
411:"Works by ..." is our usual convention for an eponymous category for works by an artist.
1469:, very few people should have eponymous categories. One article is not sufficient.
1187:
Our convention is to use "Works by ..." Deletion would do nothing to achieve this.
624:
204:
132:
783:
Our convention is to use "Works by ..." Deletion would do nothing to achieve this.
533:, the "Works by..." tree works well for other fields, even with just two subcats:
906:
Knowledge:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 July 14#Category:Tiny Tim (musician)
150:, no substantive objection, but it would be better if the other subcategories in
1363:
1104:
945:
700:
333:
94:
531:
Knowledge:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 June 22#Category:Sinéad O'Connor
1336:
The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more categories.
1077:
The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more categories.
918:
The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more categories.
669:
The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more categories.
306:
The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more categories.
67:
The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more categories.
543:
to see how the "works" tree can be correctly and effectively implemented.
1324:
Knowledge:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 July 14#Category:Debby Ryan
474:
should be deleted due to minimal content and established precedent.
1522:
is an eponymous category, which needs to be discouraged per
511:
below), but the guideline is clear as to which is favoured.
203:
already is categorized in both US cities subcategories. —
1578:
The above is preserved as an archive of the discussion.
1289:
The above is preserved as an archive of the discussion.
1049:
The above is preserved as an archive of the discussion.
871:
The above is preserved as an archive of the discussion.
641:
The above is preserved as an archive of the discussion.
278:
The above is preserved as an archive of the discussion.
1400:
1396:
1388:
1380:
1141:
1137:
1129:
1121:
982:
978:
970:
962:
737:
733:
725:
717:
370:
366:
358:
350:
384:
Unnecessary parent. Subcats sufficiently interlinked.
1465:
It doesn't need to go in an eponymous category. Per
1592:). No further edits should be made to this section.
1350:). No further edits should be made to this section.
1303:). No further edits should be made to this section.
1091:). No further edits should be made to this section.
1063:). No further edits should be made to this section.
932:). No further edits should be made to this section.
885:). No further edits should be made to this section.
683:). No further edits should be made to this section.
655:). No further edits should be made to this section.
507:container cats for this much content (although see
320:). No further edits should be made to this section.
292:). No further edits should be made to this section.
81:). No further edits should be made to this section.
1445:List of awards and nominations received by Cardi B
197:Category:Russian city of residence user templates
106:Category:Russian city of residence user templates
60:Category:Russian city of residence user templates
1443:already, where is the nominator suggesting that
601:. "Works by" is the established convention.
193:Category:Russian city of origin user templates
175:issue with that is that a lot of userboxes in
1488:What do you mean by an "eponymous category"?
623:. "Works by" is the established convention.
8:
177:Category:US city of residence user templates
185:Category:Place of residence user templates
152:Category:Place of residence user templates
181:Category:US city of origin user templates
1236:Oh heavens, I forgot to sign one post.
792:(created by the nominator here) above.
195:and just categorize every userbox from
189:Category:Place of origin user templates
41:
549:
534:
496:
110:Category:Russian cities user templates
33:
7:
547:should aim to be as good as those."
154:would be nominated in conjunction.
18:Knowledge:Categories for discussion
28:
1357:The result of the discussion was:
1098:The result of the discussion was:
939:The result of the discussion was:
690:The result of the discussion was:
327:The result of the discussion was:
88:The result of the discussion was:
1314:
896:
1492:presumably, but do you include
1159:. Subcats already interlinked
1439:Although this one does have a
1204:. Pure overcategorization per
790:Category:Works by Bella Thorne
346:Category:Works by Bella Thorne
299:Category:Works by Bella Thorne
191:, would be to create parallel
126:Category:Russia user templates
1:
851:Category:Works by KT Tunstall
697:Category:Works by KT Tunstall
30:
892:Category:Tiny Tim (musician)
537:Category:Works by filmmaker
503:disagrees. We don't need
237:) 10:28, 5 July 2019 (UTC)
1609:
545:Category:Works by musician
1570:10:50, 29 June 2019 (UTC)
1541:09:55, 28 June 2019 (UTC)
1514:09:10, 28 June 2019 (UTC)
1494:Category:Works by Cardi B
1484:08:00, 28 June 2019 (UTC)
1457:16:53, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
1441:Category:Works by Cardi B
1433:12:42, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
1367:15:24, 10 July 2019 (UTC)
1281:06:56, 29 June 2019 (UTC)
1254:18:56, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
1232:18:52, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
1197:16:52, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
1174:12:44, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
1041:17:48, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
1014:12:53, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
949:15:23, 10 July 2019 (UTC)
863:20:16, 10 July 2019 (UTC)
842:19:14, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
821:08:02, 28 June 2019 (UTC)
802:16:52, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
770:14:46, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
704:09:43, 13 July 2019 (UTC)
633:15:00, 30 June 2019 (UTC)
616:08:22, 28 June 2019 (UTC)
594:19:13, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
571:08:20, 28 June 2019 (UTC)
521:19:03, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
492:18:55, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
466:18:50, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
448:17:40, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
421:16:46, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
402:16:40, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
247:10:49, 29 June 2019 (UTC)
213:10:42, 29 June 2019 (UTC)
164:21:40, 28 June 2019 (UTC)
141:17:35, 27 June 2019 (UTC)
98:15:22, 10 July 2019 (UTC)
1581:Please do not modify it.
1498:Category:Cardi B albums
1339:Please do not modify it.
1292:Please do not modify it.
1108:09:13, 5 July 2019 (UTC)
1080:Please do not modify it.
1052:Please do not modify it.
921:Please do not modify it.
874:Please do not modify it.
672:Please do not modify it.
644:Please do not modify it.
541:Category:Works by writer
337:09:12, 5 July 2019 (UTC)
309:Please do not modify it.
281:Please do not modify it.
270:10:29, 5 July 2019 (UTC)
70:Please do not modify it.
1222:, and sign your posts.
1502:Category:Cardi B songs
1412:Nominator's rationale:
1153:Nominator's rationale:
994:Nominator's rationale:
749:Nominator's rationale:
382:Nominator's rationale:
199:into it. For example,
117:Nominator's rationale:
958:Category:Bella Thorne
911:Category:Bella Thorne
497:established precedent
472:Category:Bella Thorne
713:Category:KT Tunstall
662:Category:KT Tunstall
529:As I pointed out at
201:User:UBX/User Toledo
1518:Just the top level
1310:Category:Debby Ryan
51:
50:
1600:
1583:
1537:
1532:
1520:Category:Cardi B
1490:Category:Cardi B
1480:
1475:
1429:
1424:
1405:
1404:
1376:Category:Cardi B
1372:Propose deleting
1341:
1329:Category:Cardi B
1318:
1317:
1294:
1252:
1248:
1245:
1242:
1239:
1170:
1165:
1146:
1145:
1117:Category:Jidenna
1113:Propose deleting
1082:
1070:Category:Jidenna
1054:
1039:
1035:
1032:
1029:
1026:
1010:
1005:
987:
986:
954:Propose deleting
923:
900:
899:
876:
817:
812:
766:
761:
742:
741:
709:Propose deleting
674:
646:
612:
607:
567:
562:
509:Category:Cardi B
499:Then cite it.
490:
486:
483:
480:
477:
446:
442:
439:
436:
433:
400:
396:
393:
390:
387:
375:
374:
342:Propose deleting
311:
283:
174:
103:Propose renaming
72:
47:
36:
31:
1608:
1607:
1603:
1602:
1601:
1599:
1598:
1597:
1596:
1590:deletion review
1579:
1535:
1530:
1478:
1473:
1427:
1422:
1378:
1374:
1348:deletion review
1337:
1331:
1315:
1312:
1307:
1301:deletion review
1290:
1250:
1246:
1243:
1240:
1237:
1168:
1163:
1119:
1115:
1089:deletion review
1078:
1072:
1067:
1061:deletion review
1050:
1037:
1033:
1030:
1027:
1024:
1008:
1003:
960:
956:
930:deletion review
919:
913:
897:
894:
889:
883:deletion review
872:
815:
810:
764:
759:
715:
711:
681:deletion review
670:
664:
659:
653:deletion review
642:
610:
605:
565:
560:
488:
484:
481:
478:
475:
444:
440:
437:
434:
431:
398:
394:
391:
388:
385:
348:
344:
318:deletion review
307:
301:
296:
290:deletion review
279:
168:
79:deletion review
68:
62:
57:
52:
45:
34:
26:
25:
24:
12:
11:
5:
1606:
1604:
1595:
1594:
1574:
1573:
1572:
1550:
1549:
1548:
1547:
1546:
1545:
1544:
1543:
1460:
1459:
1436:
1435:
1409:
1408:
1407:
1406:
1353:
1352:
1332:
1330:
1327:
1311:
1308:
1306:
1305:
1285:
1284:
1283:
1261:
1260:
1259:
1258:
1257:
1256:
1210:
1209:
1199:
1177:
1176:
1150:
1149:
1148:
1147:
1094:
1093:
1073:
1071:
1068:
1066:
1065:
1045:
1044:
1043:
1017:
1016:
991:
990:
989:
988:
935:
934:
914:
912:
909:
893:
890:
888:
887:
867:
866:
865:
844:
826:
825:
824:
823:
785:
784:
773:
772:
746:
745:
744:
743:
686:
685:
665:
663:
660:
658:
657:
637:
636:
635:
618:
596:
578:
577:
576:
575:
574:
573:
527:
526:
525:
524:
523:
424:
423:
405:
404:
379:
378:
377:
376:
323:
322:
302:
300:
297:
295:
294:
274:
273:
272:
254:
253:
252:
251:
250:
249:
218:
217:
216:
215:
144:
143:
129:
121:
120:
114:
113:
112:
84:
83:
63:
61:
58:
56:
53:
49:
48:
40:
29:
27:
15:
14:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
1605:
1593:
1591:
1587:
1582:
1576:
1575:
1571:
1567:
1563:
1559:
1555:
1552:
1551:
1542:
1539:
1538:
1533:
1525:
1521:
1517:
1516:
1515:
1511:
1507:
1503:
1499:
1496:in that too?
1495:
1491:
1487:
1486:
1485:
1482:
1481:
1476:
1468:
1464:
1463:
1462:
1461:
1458:
1454:
1450:
1446:
1442:
1438:
1437:
1434:
1431:
1430:
1425:
1417:
1413:
1410:
1402:
1398:
1394:
1390:
1386:
1382:
1377:
1373:
1370:
1369:
1368:
1365:
1361:
1358:
1355:
1354:
1351:
1349:
1345:
1340:
1334:
1333:
1328:
1326:
1325:
1321:
1309:
1304:
1302:
1298:
1293:
1287:
1286:
1282:
1278:
1274:
1270:
1266:
1263:
1262:
1255:
1235:
1234:
1233:
1229:
1225:
1221:
1218:
1214:
1213:
1212:
1211:
1207:
1203:
1200:
1198:
1194:
1190:
1186:
1182:
1179:
1178:
1175:
1172:
1171:
1166:
1158:
1154:
1151:
1143:
1139:
1135:
1131:
1127:
1123:
1118:
1114:
1111:
1110:
1109:
1106:
1102:
1099:
1096:
1095:
1092:
1090:
1086:
1081:
1075:
1074:
1069:
1064:
1062:
1058:
1053:
1047:
1046:
1042:
1022:
1019:
1018:
1015:
1012:
1011:
1006:
999:
995:
992:
984:
980:
976:
972:
968:
964:
959:
955:
952:
951:
950:
947:
943:
940:
937:
936:
933:
931:
927:
922:
916:
915:
910:
908:
907:
903:
891:
886:
884:
880:
875:
869:
868:
864:
860:
856:
852:
848:
845:
843:
839:
835:
831:
828:
827:
822:
819:
818:
813:
805:
804:
803:
799:
795:
791:
787:
786:
782:
778:
775:
774:
771:
768:
767:
762:
754:
750:
747:
739:
735:
731:
727:
723:
719:
714:
710:
707:
706:
705:
702:
698:
694:
691:
688:
687:
684:
682:
678:
673:
667:
666:
661:
656:
654:
650:
645:
639:
638:
634:
630:
626:
622:
619:
617:
614:
613:
608:
600:
597:
595:
591:
587:
583:
580:
579:
572:
569:
568:
563:
555:
553:
548:
546:
542:
538:
532:
528:
522:
518:
514:
510:
506:
502:
498:
495:
494:
493:
473:
469:
468:
467:
463:
459:
455:
451:
450:
449:
428:
427:
426:
425:
422:
418:
414:
410:
407:
406:
403:
383:
380:
372:
368:
364:
360:
356:
352:
347:
343:
340:
339:
338:
335:
331:
328:
325:
324:
321:
319:
315:
310:
304:
303:
298:
293:
291:
287:
282:
276:
275:
271:
267:
263:
259:
256:
255:
248:
244:
240:
236:
232:
228:
224:
223:
222:
221:
220:
219:
214:
210:
206:
202:
198:
194:
190:
186:
182:
178:
172:
167:
166:
165:
161:
157:
153:
149:
146:
145:
142:
138:
134:
130:
127:
123:
122:
118:
115:
111:
107:
104:
101:
100:
99:
96:
92:
89:
86:
85:
82:
80:
76:
71:
65:
64:
59:
54:
44:
39:
32:
23:
19:
1580:
1577:
1562:Marcocapelle
1553:
1527:
1506:Andy Dingley
1470:
1449:Andy Dingley
1447:be placed?
1419:
1411:
1371:
1359:
1356:
1338:
1335:
1319:
1313:
1291:
1288:
1273:Marcocapelle
1264:
1224:Andy Dingley
1216:
1215:Please both
1201:
1189:Andy Dingley
1184:
1180:
1160:
1152:
1112:
1100:
1097:
1079:
1076:
1051:
1048:
1020:
1000:
993:
953:
941:
938:
920:
917:
901:
895:
873:
870:
855:Marcocapelle
846:
832:, per Andy.
829:
807:
794:Andy Dingley
780:
776:
756:
748:
708:
692:
689:
671:
668:
643:
640:
620:
602:
598:
584:, per Andy.
581:
557:
513:Andy Dingley
504:
458:Andy Dingley
413:Andy Dingley
408:
381:
341:
329:
326:
308:
305:
280:
277:
262:Marcocapelle
257:
239:Marcocapelle
231:Marcocapelle
171:Marcocapelle
156:Marcocapelle
147:
116:
102:
90:
87:
69:
66:
1504:as well?
834:Randy Kryn
586:Randy Kryn
1586:talk page
1558:WP:OCEPON
1524:WP:OCEPON
1467:WP:OCEPON
1416:WP:OCEPON
1344:talk page
1297:talk page
1269:WP:OCEPON
1220:WP:OCEPON
1206:WP:OCEPON
1157:WP:OCEPON
1085:talk page
1057:talk page
1023:per nom.
998:WP:OCEPON
926:talk page
879:talk page
753:WP:OCEPON
677:talk page
649:talk page
552:WP:OCEPON
501:WP:OCEPON
454:WP:OCEPON
314:talk page
286:talk page
260:per nom.
75:talk page
1588:or in a
1536:superman
1479:superman
1428:superman
1346:or in a
1320:Relisted
1299:or in a
1169:superman
1087:or in a
1059:or in a
1009:superman
928:or in a
902:Relisted
881:or in a
816:superman
765:superman
679:or in a
651:or in a
625:Dimadick
611:superman
566:superman
316:or in a
288:or in a
205:andrybak
133:andrybak
77:or in a
20: |
1554:Support
1389:history
1130:history
971:history
726:history
359:history
258:Support
148:Comment
55:June 27
43:June 28
38:June 26
1531:wooden
1474:wooden
1423:wooden
1414:Fails
1360:delete
1322:, see
1265:Delete
1241:cheers
1202:Delete
1185:rename
1164:wooden
1155:Fails
1101:delete
1028:cheers
1021:Delete
1004:wooden
996:Fails
942:delete
904:, see
847:Rename
811:wooden
781:rename
760:wooden
751:Fails
693:rename
606:wooden
561:wooden
479:cheers
435:cheers
389:cheers
91:rename
1397:watch
1393:links
1364:MER-C
1244:peaks
1138:watch
1134:links
1105:MER-C
1031:peaks
979:watch
975:links
946:MER-C
734:watch
730:links
701:MER-C
535:"See
482:peaks
438:peaks
392:peaks
367:watch
363:links
334:MER-C
95:MER-C
46:: -->
16:<
1566:talk
1556:per
1510:talk
1500:and
1453:talk
1401:logs
1385:talk
1381:edit
1277:talk
1267:per
1251:wars
1249:lost
1247:news
1238:Star
1228:talk
1217:read
1193:talk
1181:keep
1142:logs
1126:talk
1122:edit
1038:wars
1036:lost
1034:news
1025:Star
983:logs
967:talk
963:edit
859:talk
838:talk
830:Keep
798:talk
777:keep
738:logs
722:talk
718:edit
629:talk
621:Keep
599:Keep
590:talk
582:Keep
517:talk
489:wars
487:lost
485:news
476:Star
462:talk
452:See
445:wars
443:lost
441:news
432:Star
417:talk
409:Keep
399:wars
397:lost
395:news
386:Star
371:logs
355:talk
351:edit
330:keep
266:talk
243:talk
235:talk
209:talk
187:and
179:and
160:talk
137:talk
35:<
1526:.
1183:or
849:to
779:or
695:to
539:or
505:two
108:to
22:Log
1568:)
1560:.
1528:--
1512:)
1471:--
1455:)
1420:--
1418:.
1399:|
1395:|
1391:|
1387:|
1383:|
1362:.
1279:)
1230:)
1195:)
1161:--
1140:|
1136:|
1132:|
1128:|
1124:|
1103:.
1001:--
981:|
977:|
973:|
969:|
965:|
944:.
861:)
840:)
808:--
800:)
757:--
736:|
732:|
728:|
724:|
720:|
699:.
631:)
603:--
592:)
558:--
556:.
519:)
464:)
419:)
369:|
365:|
361:|
357:|
353:|
332:.
268:)
245:)
229:.
211:)
162:)
139:)
93:.
1564:(
1508:(
1451:(
1403:)
1379:(
1275:(
1226:(
1191:(
1144:)
1120:(
985:)
961:(
857:(
836:(
796:(
740:)
716:(
627:(
588:(
554:"
515:(
460:(
415:(
373:)
349:(
264:(
241:(
233:(
207:(
173::
169:@
158:(
135:(
128:.
119:
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.