Knowledge (XXG):Requests for arbitration/Macedonia/Workshop

1639:. I'm not at all sure this is compatible with NPOV; it strikes me as being very much like carving out a special space for the Greek POV, where a specifically Greek standard is used for Greek articles, rather than applying a consistent standard across the board. If it's Knowledge (XXG)'s standard to use "Republic of Macedonia" as the default name (which it is, since the article is at that name and has been for years), it's hard to see why we should defer to the Greek POV in articles on Greek subjects. It seems too much like taking a Wikinfo-style sympathetic point of view (SPOV). I'm not asking the ArbCom to state whether RoM or FYROM should be the standard - that's a content issue - but merely to clarify whether it's acceptable to step back from a consistent NPOV-based approach in order to appease ethnic politics. -- 1612:

particular approach in one article, the logical conclusion is that the same approach should be taken across the board. We can debate what that approach may be, but the point of this proposal is to establish whether or not NPOV requires a uniform and even-handed approach to disputed issues. Personally I think it clearly does (one would not expect, for instance, that articles on evolution would denigrate creationism while articles on creationism would denigrate evolution - a common neutral standard would be expected on both sides of the issue). --

347:

compromise between encyclopedic necessity and social acceptability. The current MOSMAC solution represents a balance between the moderate Macedonian and moderate Greek POVs, basically allowing each POV a distinct space within which to operate. That may not be ideal from an encyclopedic perspective, but it doesn't conflict too much with policy and it's probably the best that can be achieved within Knowledge (XXG)'s social structure. So, pragmatically, I think this rather untidy solution is one that we will just have to live with. --

2462:. The sanctions imposed may include blocks of up to one month in length; bans from editing any page or set of pages within the area of conflict; restrictions on reverts; or any other measures which the imposing administrator believes are reasonably necessary to ensure the smooth functioning of the project. Prior to any sanctions being imposed, the editor in question shall be given a warning with a link to this decision. All appeals regarding sanctions imposed under this provision shall be to the Committee directly. 2817:. The sanctions imposed may include blocks of up to one year in length; bans from editing any page or set of pages within the area of conflict; restrictions on reverts; or any other measures which the imposing administrator believes are reasonably necessary to ensure the smooth functioning of the project. Prior to any sanctions being imposed, the editor in question shall be given a warning with a link to this decision. 2604:. The sanctions imposed may include blocks of up to one week in length; bans from editing any page or set of pages within the area of conflict; restrictions on reverts; or any other measures which the imposing administrator believes are reasonably necessary to ensure the smooth functioning of the project. Prior to any sanctions being imposed, the editor in question shall be given a warning with a link to this decision. 2108:, so we have Greek editors campaigning for Croatian and Albanian linguistic "rights", κτλ. But the purpose for this would be to observe that the wars over Kosovo, and over Italian names in Dalmatia (and for that matter, over the South Tyrol) are just as destructive, and that those matters should also be conducted with civility and decency. 2699:(To Kyrill): I support what you want to do; I am concerned that the way you want to accomplish it will result in the possibility of any editor who edits on Eastern Europe being blocked for a month, with only the slow processes of ArbCom as a remedy, any time an admin misunderstands his action. Perhaps the sanction below will help. 1471:(resp to Kirill) FPaS hasn't proposed the committee rule on the quality of sources; rather he's asked for a restatement of RS tailored to the abuse it has been seeing in relation to Macedonia. Tell us that reliable sources are important; and tell us that sneaking in lousy, fringe, or partisan sources is not acceptable. 56:

in these alliances over number the editors that are on the other side(Macedonian) the status-quo is broken and the opposition is technically eliminated. This allows the Tag-Teams to spread POV without any regulation. A solution for this obstacle must be found in order for an end of this conflict.

2508:

uninvolved and sufficiently familiar with the situation and its backgrounds. This case was brought precisely in order to finally get some uninvolved eyes to look into the case histories. Also, if you don't take out the ringleaders now and leave everything to the admins, we'd probably just end up with

1458:

Proposed. I'm not yet quite certain how the "remedy" to accompany this principle should be worded, but I believe it goes to the heart of the matter in the present case, perhaps even more so than the usual principles regarding civility, edit-warring etc. Bad sourcing is not just a content issue, it is

159:

Oppose. This is a content decision best handled by the community. Other naming conflicts have come up in the past and been settled through negotiation, and I'm not convinced there is any difficulty in the present naming of articles. The purpose of clear naming is to enable readers to find the article

469:

In every article pertaining to history, politics, geography, etc of Republic of Macedonia and its people, the issue of naming dispute, the debate of the people's identity, and the conflicts over its history are delved into time and time again, with the resulting edit warring and debating that ensued

55:

1) As it has been mentioned it the Request for Arbitration, alliances seem to have been formed amongst certain editors that aid each other in spreading their beliefs. Doing so they are able to essentially break the three revert rule without getting caught. Furthermore as the editors that participate

2072:

I understand the desire to preempt a series of broader disputes and cases, but only editors active on Macedonia-related articles are likely to know of this case, and therefore am not sure whether an attempt to formulate broader findings and remedies would be informed by sufficient evidence. Perhaps

1528:

policy must be applied consistently across articles and other encyclopedic content. Editors are not permitted to seek or implement exemptions from the policy or apply specially modified versions of it to particular content or sets of content. This is non-negotiable and expected on all articles, and

474:

and go into each issue, representing both (or all 3) sides of the issue, where evidence can be presented to support all side's respective views. Not only will this clear the articles of needless clutter, edit-warring and tediously lengthy paragraphs (at the expense of delving into the main focus of

375:

disappeared shortly before the opening of this case, and it is likely that he is trying to wait out this case and then come back in a fresh reincarnation. Since this is one of the most persistent long-term edit warriors in this case, and since he has a known habit of switching accounts whenever his

346:

I've been thinking about this issue since the last round of discussions. The difficulty we have is that Knowledge (XXG) is both an encyclopedia and a social project. Our goals as pure encyclopedists are somewhat undermined by Knowledge (XXG)'s anyone-can-edit rationale. Ultimately, our content is a

293:

This is what the Gdansk/Danzig case prescribes. However, it might be a good idea to restate why it's the Greeks who insist. The reason is that article naming in Knowledge (XXG) is heavily biased towards the FYROM view. If the diplomatic guidelines were adopted in Knowledge (XXG) (as they should be)

174:

The inability to handle this by consensus is the reason this has escalated to the highest level. I'm hoping ArbCom's role in this issue will not be limited to policing. It's really easy to hand a couple of bans, revert paroles etc (and does it need an Arbitration Committee really?), but it's harder

136:

I'd like to see the ArbCom make a clear decision that will bind all editors regarding the naming conflict found in every RoM/fYRoM article. It has been the root of all evils. So what has precedence? Country's official name? Name by which it is accepted in International Organizations? Common English

2507:

While I very much welcome rules like this, I'd want to clarify that the committee should not just leave it at that. Now that we are here, we do need some "nickel-and-diming" on your part, regarding specific sanctions for some of the main players. Problem is, there aren't enough admins who are both

1726:

in any Knowledge (XXG) article, before a consensus is reached among editors or before unrefutable evidence is presented. When this consensus is finally reached, the policy must be applied consistently across articles and other encyclopedic content. Editors may seek or implement exemptions from the

1611:

be the best that we can get out of the collaborative process on Knowledge (XXG), but that doesn't automatically mean that it's fully compliant with NPOV. I'm not certain that its endorsement of different names for the same country in different articles meets NPOV's requirements. If NPOV mandates a

1303:

two discussions in the talk pages of two articles (both involving myself). I'm not engaging in revert wars, I am and will continue to engage in debates and I consider these debates to be constructive, no matter how heated they become. I do not mind at all hearing the other's opinion, no matter how

2122:

And yet there is warring over the 'ownership' of the terms "Macedonia" and "Macedonian" which is different from the other sorts of warring mentioned here. The forced disambiguation of almost every non-Greek use of the term reflects a long-term campaign and the numerical superiority of the largest

1593:

And who will decide what is the NPOV on this? This is exactly what I wanted to achieve in my request for clarification on naming conflict guidelines and the response was that this is a content issue and ArbCom will not be involved. So this applies to (both actually) your proposals. Moreover, your

1347:

5.1) The purpose of a Knowledge (XXG) talk page is to provide space for editors to discuss changes to its associated article or project page. Article talk pages should not be used by editors as platforms for their personal views. Personal attacks, incivility and discussion that is not relevant to

2855:

Do you want to tweak this a little? While there are certainly some editors who deserve a year's block, I am concerned that this, as opposed to the progessive blocks in Discretionary Sanctions 2, may lead to much greater sanctions than would be given for the same offense elsewhere. After all, any

1660:

Chris, what language mandates use of "former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia" (as opposed to merely acknowledging that our articles do in fact use it)? I will remove it; no such language can possibly be consensus. It would be really nice if ArbCom would arbitrate this point; no other process ever

1395:

I can see the benefit of this principle in the case. Although 5 above has its merits, we can't risk equating non-violating comments to constructive ones. My humble opinion is that the main drive of Knowledge (XXG) expansion largely relies on the need of people to talk (and moderately "push their

2995:

Proposed: this is a map of the EU, but with all of northern Greece incorporated into the Republic of Macedonia. It is too small for me to see whether the Macedonian areas of Bulgaria are also included; and therefore is unsuitable for illustrating Macedonian nationalist claims. (It also flashes:

2734:

ArbCom severely deprecates lightly reversing another admin's action. Reversing a discretionary sanction taken under this decision without (1) the consent of the admin who imposed it, (2) extensive discussion and clear consensus at arbitration enforcement, or (3) the permission of ArbCom, may be

1418:

6) Editors working in politically sensitive disputed fields have a heightened responsibility to make sure their contributions are based on reliable, non-partisan sources, preferably from reputable academic print sources. Editors must be aware that much seemingly relevant material that is easily

30:

This is a page for working on Arbitration decisions. The Arbitrators, parties to the case, and other editors may draft proposals and post them to this page for review and comments. Proposals may include proposed general principles, findings of fact, remedies, and enforcement provisions—the same

1810:

Another proposal related to a very common argument made in the naming dispute ("Knowledge (XXG) must use this name, because we Greeks/Macedonians have a moral right to it!"). Such an argument is, of course, completely incompatible with NPOV. It would be useful to make this explicitly clear. --

188:

defines the standard as being the self-identifying name of a country/city/entity (essentially the Gdanzig precedent). I'm well aware that some Greek editors wish to overturn this, or at least dilute it by referring to the RoM differently in different contexts rather than applying a consistent

2894:

imposed under the provisions of this decision may be appealed to the imposing administrator, the administrators' noticeboard, or the Committee. Reversing or otherwise interfering with the imposition of a discretionary sanction without (1) the consent of the administrator who imposed it, (2)

1419:

accessible on the web comes from heavily biased sources such as political advocacy and propaganda websites, and is therefore unsuitable for the creation of reliable NPOV articles. Editors who work from poor quality, partisan sources pose a threat to the academic integrity of Knowledge (XXG).

2023:. Many of these conflicts are grounded in matters external to Knowledge (XXG), including long-standing historical, national, and ethnic disputes in the region. It is therefore most useful to consider the area of conflict in this case to be the entire set of Balkan-related articles. 1696:. There is no prospect of consensus on these matters within the small world of the Macedonia disputes; there is no likelihood that the overarching policies will be changed by this small number of editors - for one thing, many editors, even in this discussion, support the present 2620:

I'm more concerned, frankly, with ensuring sanctions against established editors than with ones against new accounts. Experience suggests that allowing other admins to reverse the decision will prevent any useful sanctions from being imposed on the more popular editors.

2091:

users (if that was the argument) will be limited to the countries strictly immediately bordering the user's home-country. Greeks wouldn't edit Kosovo or Dalmatia (as much). Neither would Bulgarians. Nor would ethnic Macedonians edit e.g. Romanian-related articles.

868:

2) Knowledge (XXG) users are expected to behave reasonably and calmly in their interactions with other users, to keep their cool when editing, and to avoid acting in a manner that brings the project into disrepute. Unseemly conduct—including, but not limited to,

1428:

The Committee isn't suited to rule on content. The few times we've been dragged into making specific comments on the quality of particular sources, those rulings have been immediately misused to start edit wars; I'm very wary of going down that path.

1057:

I'd support this. Overly political userpages have been a recurrent theme in the Macedonian case. There have been several prior admin discussions about these and attempts at purging the worst ones. (Give me a bit of time to collect the relevant diffs.)

1875:

8.1) Involved national groups' assertions of "moral rights" in political disputes are to be respected and explicitly mentioned as such in Knowledge (XXG) articles, however, unsupported by any hard evidence, they cannot be considered to represent

294:

and the country's article was named FYROM, then the name used in all articles would be FYROM and the Gdansk/Danzig decision would prescribe that the country be called ROM in articles specifically related to the internal affairs of the country. --

2870:

Meh. I have no particular attachment to a year versus a month; but if we're going to allow appeals to AN, we might as well allow full-length blocks as well. The admin community can be counted on to reverse any that are too draconian, I think.

785:

1) Knowledge (XXG) is a project to create a neutral encyclopedia. Use of the site for other purposes—including, but not limited to, advocacy, propaganda, furtherance of outside conflicts, and political or ideological struggle—is prohibited.

1383:. The misuse of talk pages has been a perennial problem in this area - endless hit-and-run posting of nationalist rants as well as unproductive "we're right, you're wrong" posts by more established editors who should know better. See 303:

Even if the local compromise on the Gdanzig disaster said so, it was not intended as precedent. The guidelines cited were both written after the Gdanzig mess, and are intended as lasting solutions to avoid it arising

1286:

I'm not sure what the point of this is, since it's a statement of the obvious. I'd suggest the alternative below, as it's more tailored towards the specific problem that occurs on Macedonia-related talk pages. --

3010:

It would still be useful to have ArbCom to condemn this sort of thing explicitly. This (and the corresponding provocations of the other factions) are significant irritants. Wording should of course be changed to

242:

Funny that ChrisO mentioned the Gdansk/Danzig case. Let me remind him that it was actually me who brought it up in Macedonia articles after a series of mass renames from Slavomacedonian editors in Greek articles

2654:

than (1). Blocks appealable only to ArbCom should really be limited to well-defined offenses; otherwise there's a chance that an honest misunderstanding will bite a newbie. The periods here are boiler-plate.

39: 1621:

This is not an issue of facts versus fiction, this is an issue of prioritisation of facts when there is conflict, which can only be forged by consensus, since a top-down solution will not be enforced. --

207:

is just a guideline written by yourself that happens to have a few powerful supporters; it was not decided by the community, it was imposed on it, and in any case is not official Knowledge (XXG) policy.

2011:

1) The disputes presented in this case, while focusing specifically on issues related to Macedonia, are part of a broader set of conflicts prevalent over the entire range of articles concerning the

1304:

absurd/unsubstantiated I find it and I will of course respond to it with my view. In fact I consider talk pages a great source for uninvolved observers to see the mindset of all involved parties.--

1071: 3167:

1) Any discretionary sanction imposed under this decision should be logged here. Minimum information includes name of administrator, date and time, what was done and the basis for doing it.

2968: 376:

old block logs get cumbersome, I'd ask for a checkuser to determine whether he has already prepared his new reincarnations, or to save up his checkuser information in case he does so later.

506:

That's another content issue which I guarantee the committee is not going to address. (My personal view: we have these kinds of about-the-dispute articles already, and too many of them:

475:

the article), it will also be easier for the administrators to monitor any subsequent issues, as this one article will contain all the potential contentious issues on the broader topic.

32: 1567:

If at all possible, I'd like this arbitration to address some of the principles that have come up in the course of the endless dispute between Greek and Macedonian editors over the

1727:

policy or apply specially modified versions of it to particular content or sets of content if there is either strong consensus for such action or explicit need for disambiguation.

2685: 1579:- should be applied consistently and editors should not presume that they can carve out their own areas of Knowledge (XXG) where NPOV is applied differently, or not at all. -- 1019:

Yes, it is. But sometimes I find we need to be very explicit in meaning, even to the point of redundancy, to make sure no one could possibly misunderstand. The issue of what,

38:

Any user may edit this workshop page. Please sign all suggestions and comments. Arbitrators will place proposed items they believe should be part of the final decision on the

2104:

Actually some users have campaigned on both fronts; not that it matters particularly. The Macedonian Vlachs do come into this question; and some people edit on the principle

949:

is designed to assist consensus-building when normal talk page communication has not worked. Sustained editorial conflict is not an appropriate method of resolving disputes.

3218:

Proposed. Boilerplate, but a useful record. If User:Stupid is banned from three different articles by three different admins, a more serious sanction may be in order.

2781:

Incorporated in (5) below. The greater number of eyes at AN probably warrants the change; although it may still be worth keeping track of actions under this decision.

1648:

Guys, this case will be closed in a matter of hours, and there was never much of a chance they'd look into this to begin with. No use continuing this discussion here.

2971:. Listed now. But Vlatkoto's page raises another question of interpretation with regard to the currently proposed remedies, see my question on Proposed Decision Talk 2482:"Uninvolved" is the normal standard for admin actions; broadly speaking, anyone who has no substantive participation in the dispute itself is considered uninvolved. 2440:

Note: All remedies that refer to a period of time, for example to a ban of X months or a revert parole of Y months, are to run concurrently unless otherwise stated.

1575:. In stating this principle (which is of course already policy) I'm seeking to underline the proposition that NPOV - and the various subsidiary guidelines, such as 2805:

4) Any uninvolved administrator may, on their own discretion, impose sanctions on any editor working in the area of conflict if that editor fails to adhere to the

2592:

2) Any uninvolved administrator may, on their own discretion, impose sanctions on any editor working in the area of conflict if that editor fails to adhere to the

2450:

1) Any uninvolved administrator may, on their own discretion, impose sanctions on any editor working in the area of conflict if that editor fails to adhere to the

1035:

I suppose that's true. I wonder if there's some neater way of explicitly laying this out as an addendum to the main principle rather than a separate one, though.

21: 1700:. If ArbCom does not arbitrate what is neutrality, and whether the articles on the countries concerned here can float in a bubble of their own reality, who will? 2016: 2543: 2471:

Trying to nickel-and-dime these conflicts hasn't worked in the past; we're going to need sweeping measures if we want to restore some semblance of order here.

2895:

extensive discussion and clear consensus at the administrators' noticeboard, or (3) the permission of the Committee will be grounds for summary desysopping.

2020: 511: 1775:

8) Editors' assertions of "moral rights" in political disputes are to be respected, but such asserted rights are incompatible with Knowledge (XXG)'s

307:

I don't see that this would be the effect of Gdanzig, even if applied literally to this situation. What language are you reading to that effect?

1631:

To be more explicit about my concerns, MOSMAC mandates that the Greek version of the RoM's name be used in articles about Greek subjects (e.g.

893:—is prohibited. Users should not respond to such behavior in kind; concerns regarding the actions of other users should be brought up in the 2550:

of bad manners and invective. (The worst parties seem to have improved since, so I present this as a caution, not a request for sanctions on

17: 2978: 2516: 1652: 1463: 1062: 572: 526: 407: 1001:

is to aid in encyclopedic collaboration. User pages may not be used for displaying religious, ethnic, national, or racial propaganda.

515: 446: 2669:

It would be prefectly reasonable for Arbcom to rule that some of the offenders here have used up some or all of their five chances.

2533:

Questions: 1)Who is uninvolved? and 2) this says "any editor" Your intent is that this will apply to all, not just parties listed?

427:, I beg you not to involve me in any future discussion. Don't treat me as a liar as well. As I have already declared on my former 870: 2123:

group of involved editors. By setting a broader scope I fear ArbCom will be bypassing this serious and hard-to-pin-down issue.

946: 894: 849:

The user page thing is a relatively minor aspect of this; I think it'd be neater as a connected but still separate principle.

2975: 2513: 1649: 1460: 1059: 569: 542:

Yes, that's my point. Too many such articles, can they not be put into one large article about such academic controversies ?

523: 424: 404: 890: 878: 334:

final solution decided by most involved. I don't see why this page here has to be consumed by a content dispute any longer.

2547: 31:

format as is used in Arbitration Committee decisions. The bottom of the page may be used for overall analysis of the

3227: 3191: 3181: 3177:

May be neater to just add the normal logging requirement (as we've used for similar remedies) to the remedy itself.

3024: 3005: 2981: 2908: 2875: 2865: 2830: 2790: 2776: 2717: 2708: 2692: 2678: 2664: 2625: 2577: 2563: 2537: 2519: 2489: 2475: 2132: 2117: 2099: 2082: 2045: 2036: 1904: 1856: 1847: 1838: 1820: 1751: 1709: 1670: 1655: 1643: 1626: 1616: 1602: 1588: 1553: 1507: 1480: 1466: 1433: 1403: 1390: 1336: 1308: 1291: 1272: 1221: 1209: 1177: 1141: 1132: 1099: 1090: 1081: 1065: 1039: 1030: 1014: 962: 910: 853: 844: 799: 575: 551: 529: 484: 454: 440: 410: 356: 341: 323: 298: 284: 250: 235: 217: 198: 179: 169: 145: 122: 74: 1497: 470:

from this. I propose that we should create one article to deal solely with these issues, named something like the

372: 1568: 507: 2568:

To FP: so propose some individual sanctions. ArbCom may refuse; but you know the players better than they do.

3187:

Never mind that; it looks like the logging part has been in the enforcement rather than the remedy recently.

519: 436: 213: 165: 2485:

Yes, "any editor" means exactly that; hence the requirement for a warning before sanctions can be imposed.

2073:

notice of the case should be given more broadly to obtain relevant input, although I am not sure just how.

886: 826: 450: 1157: 998: 160:

containing the information they want to read, not to endorse a particular side in a nationalist dispute.

2078: 1301: 268: 882: 874: 1816: 1584: 352: 194: 109:

2) Define a clear priority on naming conflict issues, which will apply to Macedonia-related articles.

3223: 3020: 3001: 2861: 2786: 2772: 2704: 2674: 2660: 2573: 2559: 2113: 1834: 1705: 1666: 1332: 1113:

Proposed. Several userpages of parties to this dispute are largely devoted to nationalist material -

840: 319: 280: 231: 70: 1297: 1086:

I support it too, however Strich3d's page is not nationalist (as mentioned by Picaroon below). Alex

3188: 3178: 2944: 2905: 2872: 2856:

editor who is so offensive and disruptive that he should be gone for a year can be so blocked now.

2827: 2714: 2622: 2486: 2472: 2042: 2033: 1430: 1174: 1036: 1011: 959: 907: 850: 796: 445:

That could just be a trick so that when he reincarnates himself no-one will suspect anything. Alex

2096: 1825:

These claims of "moral rights" are a claim to a Sympathetic Point of View. That should be done on

1595: 1504: 1400: 1218: 338: 331: 264: 138: 1853: 1844: 1812: 1640: 1613: 1580: 1459:

a behavioural issue, and it is time we begin to treat it as a bannable offense in its own right.

1387: 1288: 1248:, are actually constructive and not disruptive since it is the only way consensus can be forged. 1206: 1138: 1129: 1027: 432: 348: 275:? Several editors, all Greek, insist that this should be done in any article on a Greek subject. 190: 161: 209: 1164:, user pages may not be used for displaying religious, ethnic, national, or racial propaganda. 189:

standard, but that's still essentially an issue for the community at large, not the ArbCom. --

1826: 1087: 1877: 1776: 1723: 1576: 1572: 1525: 1380: 314:

provoke outrage from nationalists on both sides, this arbitration will probably have failed.

226:, which are the product of many editors, even if I've been stuck with maintaining it lately. 223: 204: 185: 2128: 2074: 1476: 1137:

Some of those user pages should be purged on the grounds of sheer aesthetic awfulness... --

547: 480: 1245: 1241: 1237: 3219: 3016: 2997: 2857: 2782: 2768: 2700: 2670: 2656: 2569: 2555: 2109: 2093: 1830: 1701: 1662: 1501: 1397: 1328: 1215: 1078: 1023:, a principle or remedy applies to comes up at arbitration enforcement from time to time. 945:

3) Knowledge (XXG) works by building consensus through the use of polite discussion. The

836: 380: 335: 315: 276: 267:

reveals a lack of consensus on one fundamental question (as it now says): when should the

227: 66: 2608: 1493: 1486: 1485:

I'd see that as a positive principle, and agree it is a frequent problem in the case.

2689: 1901: 1748: 1623: 1599: 1550: 1305: 1269: 1203: 1126: 1122: 1118: 1114: 1096: 1024: 295: 247: 176: 142: 119: 1386:

for an example of the sort of thing that has to be removed on a regular basis. --

137:

use? Google hits? A great initiative has been the Knowledge (XXG) Manual of Style

65:

A possible solution would be to restrict reverting edits to those of other users.

2534: 2124: 1472: 543: 476: 1236:

5) Content debates in article talk pages, although subject to policies such as

1095:

This is not what Picaroon says, he only says it is not copyright infringement.

2611:; after five blocks of no more than a week, blocks of a year may be imposed. 1075: 568:

Just make that proposal on the relevant talk pages. It won't be decided here.

1843:

Strong support for the concept although I think the wording could be better.

175:

and a great challenge to dig deeper and face a possibly systemic issue here.

141:, however in such heated subjects it might need endorsement and enforcement. 1779:

policy and cannot be used as the basis for developing encyclopedic content.

1379:

Proposed as a more specific alternative to proposal 6. The wording reflects

1549:

Oppose until there is clarity on which is the NPOV in Macedonia issues. --

184:

This is a content issue, and it's already been decided by the community -

2012: 1632: 2041:

Somehow I doubt a lack of evidence will be our chief difficulty here.

1852:

By all means, please feel free to suggest a revised form of words. --

1637:

even where those articles have nothing to do with the naming dispute

2651: 2510:

The Race To WP:ANI, Or: Who Can Get Their Opponents Blocked First?

829:

may not display religious, ethnic, national, or racial propaganda.

222:

It is widely quoted; so are the slightly different suggestions of

3404:

Place here items of evidence (with diffs) and detailed analysis

2826:

Allow for longer bans, but leave appeals to a separate finding.

2542:

However, this does need some teeth; even if these are too long.

2713:

Ok, I think something of this sort can be workable; see below.

2087:

Skeptic. I'm sure the evidence on Balkan-wide disputes by the

1160:

is to aid in encyclopedic collaboration. In keeping with the

1070:

I support this, there is some discussion of previous purges

1010:

I would think this is implicit in the first principle, no?

831:? (Although do we want to include the Confederate flag in 1607:

As I've said in an earlier section of this page, MOSMAC

1323:

content debate is constructive. That is patently false.

2972: 1384: 428: 244: 118:

Not a chance. ArbCom doesn't make content decisions. --

1718:

Consistent application of neutral point of view policy

1520:

Consistent application of neutral point of view policy

1396:

POV"), but putting this on record would be dangerous.

2947:

is divisive and inflammatory, and shall be deleted.

2686:

Nullum crimen, nulla poena sine praevia lege poenali

105:

Clarification by ArbCom on naming conflict guidelines

42:page, which only Arbitrators may edit, for voting. 835:ruling? How about the Irish flag/the Union Jack?) 1722:7.1) No specific POV should be considered as the 1300:on the other hand, calls "disruptive outbreaks" 2904:To go with "Discretionary sanctions 3" above. 2512:(a telenovela in 6,666 gripping instalments). 431:I don't want to be part of Knowledge (XXG). - 8: 2891: 1571:. The wording reflects the first section of 1871:Inapplicability of "moral rights" arguments 1771:Inapplicability of "moral rights" arguments 512:Political views on the Macedonian language 2806: 2593: 2451: 1173:Explicitly tie this into the main point. 1161: 35:and for general discussion of the case. 2996:"Well, I think, this is the best way.") 330:Your last sentence (IMO) applies to the 18:Knowledge (XXG):Requests for arbitration 383:, who has also ostensibly disappeared. 2814: 2601: 2459: 2397:8) {text of proposed finding of fact} 2356:7) {text of proposed finding of fact} 2315:6) {text of proposed finding of fact} 2274:5) {text of proposed finding of fact} 2233:4) {text of proposed finding of fact} 2192:3) {text of proposed finding of fact} 2151:2) {text of proposed finding of fact} 1152:Purpose of Knowledge (XXG): user pages 2967:I'm confident this can be handled at 1348:improving an article may be removed. 273:former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia 7: 1296:Thank you for calling this obvious. 1594:proposal renders invalid the whole 51:Prevention of Tag-Team edit warring 46:Motions and requests by the parties 3363:5) {text of proposed enforcement} 3322:4) {text of proposed enforcement} 3281:3) {text of proposed enforcement} 3240:2) {text of proposed enforcement} 2607:Such sanctions should be noted at 2106:the enemy of my enemy is my friend 516:Macedonian language naming dispute 28: 2886:Appeal of discretionary sanctions 1965:10) {text of proposed principle} 2032:Could perhaps be worded better. 1924:9) {text of proposed principle} 1319:This can be read as saying that 465:Request for collation of issues 2811:expected standards of behavior 2598:expected standards of behavior 2456:expected standards of behavior 1500:). Open to further tailoring. 1414:Reliable, non-partisan sources 597:Proposed temporary injunctions 263:The real problem here is that 1: 3228:18:13, 22 November 2007 (UTC) 3192:18:20, 22 November 2007 (UTC) 3182:18:15, 22 November 2007 (UTC) 3121:9) {text of proposed remedy} 3080:8) {text of proposed remedy} 3039:7) {text of proposed remedy} 3025:21:08, 30 November 2007 (UTC) 3006:06:48, 30 November 2007 (UTC) 2982:08:27, 30 November 2007 (UTC) 2909:17:27, 21 November 2007 (UTC) 2876:17:53, 22 November 2007 (UTC) 2866:17:49, 22 November 2007 (UTC) 2831:17:27, 21 November 2007 (UTC) 2791:18:33, 21 November 2007 (UTC) 2777:16:51, 21 November 2007 (UTC) 2718:17:27, 21 November 2007 (UTC) 2709:16:45, 21 November 2007 (UTC) 2693:18:13, 21 November 2007 (UTC) 2679:06:57, 21 November 2007 (UTC) 2665:06:52, 21 November 2007 (UTC) 2626:13:31, 21 November 2007 (UTC) 2578:06:41, 30 November 2007 (UTC) 2564:18:25, 20 November 2007 (UTC) 2546:was followed within weeks by 2538:04:39, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 2520:07:07, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 2490:04:43, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 2476:00:41, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 2133:15:22, 24 November 2007 (UTC) 2118:18:04, 22 November 2007 (UTC) 2100:23:20, 21 November 2007 (UTC) 2083:03:08, 17 November 2007 (UTC) 2046:03:10, 17 November 2007 (UTC) 2037:03:05, 17 November 2007 (UTC) 1848:21:06, 30 November 2007 (UTC) 1839:21:05, 30 November 2007 (UTC) 1821:12:28, 30 November 2007 (UTC) 1710:21:03, 30 November 2007 (UTC) 1603:15:58, 30 November 2007 (UTC) 1589:12:19, 30 November 2007 (UTC) 1554:16:00, 30 November 2007 (UTC) 1508:23:12, 21 November 2007 (UTC) 1481:04:12, 17 November 2007 (UTC) 1467:21:55, 16 November 2007 (UTC) 1434:03:02, 17 November 2007 (UTC) 1404:23:29, 21 November 2007 (UTC) 1391:08:22, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 1337:19:44, 20 November 2007 (UTC) 1309:17:52, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 1292:08:22, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 1273:02:14, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 1222:23:02, 21 November 2007 (UTC) 1210:02:19, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 1178:02:03, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 1142:08:23, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 1133:01:36, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 1100:18:49, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 1091:11:49, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 1082:09:08, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 1066:07:10, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 1040:02:01, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 1031:01:47, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 1015:01:42, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 963:00:41, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 911:00:41, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 854:22:26, 20 November 2007 (UTC) 845:19:52, 20 November 2007 (UTC) 800:00:41, 15 November 2007 (UTC) 576:06:50, 28 November 2007 (UTC) 552:01:56, 28 November 2007 (UTC) 530:09:21, 27 November 2007 (UTC) 485:09:16, 27 November 2007 (UTC) 455:01:19, 29 November 2007 (UTC) 441:18:49, 26 November 2007 (UTC) 411:13:59, 25 November 2007 (UTC) 357:13:59, 22 November 2007 (UTC) 342:22:59, 21 November 2007 (UTC) 324:19:41, 20 November 2007 (UTC) 299:18:47, 20 November 2007 (UTC) 285:18:31, 20 November 2007 (UTC) 251:19:03, 20 November 2007 (UTC) 236:18:31, 20 November 2007 (UTC) 218:16:39, 20 November 2007 (UTC) 199:13:10, 20 November 2007 (UTC) 180:00:49, 20 November 2007 (UTC) 170:15:26, 19 November 2007 (UTC) 146:01:34, 19 November 2007 (UTC) 123:05:50, 22 November 2007 (UTC) 75:04:47, 17 November 2007 (UTC) 2810: 2597: 2455: 1905:11:30, 1 December 2007 (UTC) 1857:11:22, 1 December 2007 (UTC) 1752:11:35, 1 December 2007 (UTC) 1671:22:42, 2 December 2007 (UTC) 1656:07:48, 2 December 2007 (UTC) 1644:07:22, 2 December 2007 (UTC) 1627:11:51, 1 December 2007 (UTC) 1617:11:35, 1 December 2007 (UTC) 1327:would be true, but vacuous. 472:the Macedonian issue/ debate 3725: 2807:purpose of Knowledge (XXG) 2594:purpose of Knowledge (XXG) 2452:purpose of Knowledge (XXG) 1162:purpose of Knowledge (XXG) 947:dispute resolution process 781:Purpose of Knowledge (XXG) 2801:Discretionary sanctions 3 2588:Discretionary sanctions 2 2002:Proposed findings of fact 1529:of all article editors. 1498:very essential part of it 373:User:ForeignerFromTheEast 3013:should have been deleted 2815:normal editorial process 2735:grounds for desysopping. 2602:normal editorial process 2460:normal editorial process 2015:; see, for example, the 879:assumptions of bad faith 766:Questions to the parties 508:Macedonia naming dispute 3680:Comment by Arbitrators: 3642:Comment by Arbitrators: 3604:Comment by Arbitrators: 3566:Comment by Arbitrators: 3528:Comment by Arbitrators: 3490:Comment by Arbitrators: 3452:Comment by Arbitrators: 3414:Comment by Arbitrators: 3368:Comment by Arbitrators: 3327:Comment by Arbitrators: 3286:Comment by Arbitrators: 3245:Comment by Arbitrators: 3172:Comment by Arbitrators: 3126:Comment by Arbitrators: 3085:Comment by Arbitrators: 3044:Comment by Arbitrators: 2952:Comment by Arbitrators: 2900:Comment by Arbitrators: 2892:Discretionary sanctions 2822:Comment by Arbitrators: 2741:Comment by Arbitrators: 2616:Comment by Arbitrators: 2609:arbitration enforcement 2544:the Eastern Europe case 2467:Comment by Arbitrators: 2446:Discretionary sanctions 2402:Comment by Arbitrators: 2361:Comment by Arbitrators: 2320:Comment by Arbitrators: 2279:Comment by Arbitrators: 2238:Comment by Arbitrators: 2197:Comment by Arbitrators: 2156:Comment by Arbitrators: 2028:Comment by Arbitrators: 1970:Comment by Arbitrators: 1929:Comment by Arbitrators: 1885:Comment by Arbitrators: 1784:Comment by Arbitrators: 1732:Comment by Arbitrators: 1534:Comment by Arbitrators: 1492:policy, after all (and 1424:Comment by Arbitrators: 1353:Comment by Arbitrators: 1253:Comment by Arbitrators: 1169:Comment by Arbitrators: 1006:Comment by Arbitrators: 954:Comment by Arbitrators: 902:Comment by Arbitrators: 791:Comment by Arbitrators: 771:Proposed final decision 734:Comment by Arbitrators: 693:Comment by Arbitrators: 652:Comment by Arbitrators: 611:Comment by Arbitrators: 520:Macedonia (terminology) 491:Comment by Arbitrators: 388:Comment by Arbitrators: 114:Comment by Arbitrators: 61:Comment by Arbitrators: 1777:neutral point of view 1724:neutral point of view 1526:neutral point of view 367:Request for Checkuser 269:Republic of Macedonia 3400:Analysis of evidence 3158:Proposed enforcement 1156:4.1) The purpose of 379:Similar request for 3691:Comment by parties: 3653:Comment by parties: 3615:Comment by parties: 3577:Comment by parties: 3539:Comment by parties: 3501:Comment by parties: 3463:Comment by parties: 3425:Comment by parties: 3379:Comment by parties: 3338:Comment by parties: 3297:Comment by parties: 3256:Comment by parties: 3203:Comment by parties: 3137:Comment by parties: 3096:Comment by parties: 3055:Comment by parties: 2963:Comment by parties: 2918:Comment by parties: 2840:Comment by parties: 2767:Proposed as above. 2752:Comment by parties: 2635:Comment by parties: 2503:Comment by parties: 2413:Comment by parties: 2372:Comment by parties: 2331:Comment by parties: 2290:Comment by parties: 2249:Comment by parties: 2208:Comment by parties: 2167:Comment by parties: 2057:Comment by parties: 1981:Comment by parties: 1940:Comment by parties: 1896:Comment by parties: 1795:Comment by parties: 1743:Comment by parties: 1545:Comment by parties: 1443:Comment by parties: 1364:Comment by parties: 1325:Can be constructive 1264:Comment by parties: 1202:Sounds fine to me. 1187:Comment by parties: 1053:Comment by parties: 972:Comment by parties: 920:Comment by parties: 809:Comment by parties: 776:Proposed principles 745:Comment by parties: 704:Comment by parties: 663:Comment by parties: 622:Comment by parties: 502:Comment by parties: 399:Comment by parties: 132:Comment by parties: 84:Comment by parties: 3702:Comment by others: 3674:General discussion 3664:Comment by others: 3626:Comment by others: 3588:Comment by others: 3550:Comment by others: 3512:Comment by others: 3474:Comment by others: 3436:Comment by others: 3390:Comment by others: 3349:Comment by others: 3308:Comment by others: 3267:Comment by others: 3214:Comment by others: 3148:Comment by others: 3107:Comment by others: 3066:Comment by others: 2991:Comment by others: 2929:Comment by others: 2851:Comment by others: 2763:Comment by others: 2646:Comment by others: 2529:Comment by others: 2424:Comment by others: 2383:Comment by others: 2342:Comment by others: 2301:Comment by others: 2260:Comment by others: 2219:Comment by others: 2178:Comment by others: 2068:Comment by others: 1992:Comment by others: 1951:Comment by others: 1914:Comment by others: 1806:Comment by others: 1761:Comment by others: 1563:Comment by others: 1454:Comment by others: 1375:Comment by others: 1343:Talk pages debates 1282:Comment by others: 1232:Talk pages debates 1198:Comment by others: 1109:Comment by others: 997:4) The purpose of 983:Comment by others: 958:Initial thoughts. 931:Comment by others: 906:Initial thoughts. 895:appropriate forums 820:Comment by others: 795:Initial thoughts. 756:Comment by others: 715:Comment by others: 674:Comment by others: 633:Comment by others: 587:Comment by others: 420:Comment by others: 155:Comment by others: 95:Comment by others: 40:/Proposed decision 3226: 3023: 3004: 2864: 2789: 2775: 2707: 2677: 2663: 2576: 2562: 2442: 2434:Proposed remedies 2116: 1837: 1708: 1669: 1335: 941:Editorial process 891:gaming the system 843: 322: 283: 234: 3716: 3222: 3019: 3015:if appropriate. 3000: 2860: 2785: 2771: 2703: 2673: 2659: 2572: 2558: 2438: 2112: 2007:Area of conflict 1833: 1704: 1665: 1496:is definitely a 1331: 871:personal attacks 839: 318: 310:If the solution 279: 230: 3724: 3723: 3719: 3718: 3717: 3715: 3714: 3713: 3676: 3638: 3600: 3562: 3524: 3486: 3448: 3410: 3402: 3361: 3320: 3279: 3238: 3220:Septentrionalis 3165: 3160: 3119: 3078: 3037: 3017:Septentrionalis 2998:Septentrionalis 2941: 2888: 2858:Septentrionalis 2803: 2783:Septentrionalis 2769:Septentrionalis 2730: 2701:Septentrionalis 2671:Septentrionalis 2657:Septentrionalis 2650:Proposed; less 2590: 2570:Septentrionalis 2556:Septentrionalis 2448: 2436: 2395: 2354: 2313: 2272: 2231: 2190: 2149: 2110:Septentrionalis 2009: 2004: 1963: 1922: 1873: 1831:Septentrionalis 1773: 1720: 1702:Septentrionalis 1663:Septentrionalis 1598:discussion. -- 1522: 1416: 1345: 1329:Septentrionalis 1234: 1154: 995: 943: 866: 837:Septentrionalis 783: 778: 773: 768: 727: 686: 645: 604: 599: 467: 381:User:Jackanapes 369: 316:Septentrionalis 277:Septentrionalis 228:Septentrionalis 107: 53: 48: 26: 25: 24: 12: 11: 5: 3722: 3720: 3711: 3709: 3708: 3707: 3706: 3698: 3697: 3696: 3695: 3687: 3686: 3685: 3684: 3675: 3672: 3671: 3670: 3669: 3668: 3660: 3659: 3658: 3657: 3649: 3648: 3647: 3646: 3637: 3634: 3633: 3632: 3631: 3630: 3622: 3621: 3620: 3619: 3611: 3610: 3609: 3608: 3599: 3596: 3595: 3594: 3593: 3592: 3584: 3583: 3582: 3581: 3573: 3572: 3571: 3570: 3561: 3558: 3557: 3556: 3555: 3554: 3546: 3545: 3544: 3543: 3535: 3534: 3533: 3532: 3523: 3520: 3519: 3518: 3517: 3516: 3508: 3507: 3506: 3505: 3497: 3496: 3495: 3494: 3485: 3482: 3481: 3480: 3479: 3478: 3470: 3469: 3468: 3467: 3459: 3458: 3457: 3456: 3447: 3444: 3443: 3442: 3441: 3440: 3432: 3431: 3430: 3429: 3421: 3420: 3419: 3418: 3409: 3406: 3401: 3398: 3397: 3396: 3395: 3394: 3386: 3385: 3384: 3383: 3375: 3374: 3373: 3372: 3360: 3357: 3356: 3355: 3354: 3353: 3345: 3344: 3343: 3342: 3334: 3333: 3332: 3331: 3319: 3316: 3315: 3314: 3313: 3312: 3304: 3303: 3302: 3301: 3293: 3292: 3291: 3290: 3278: 3275: 3274: 3273: 3272: 3271: 3263: 3262: 3261: 3260: 3252: 3251: 3250: 3249: 3237: 3234: 3233: 3232: 3231: 3230: 3210: 3209: 3208: 3207: 3199: 3198: 3197: 3196: 3195: 3194: 3164: 3161: 3159: 3156: 3155: 3154: 3153: 3152: 3144: 3143: 3142: 3141: 3133: 3132: 3131: 3130: 3118: 3115: 3114: 3113: 3112: 3111: 3103: 3102: 3101: 3100: 3092: 3091: 3090: 3089: 3077: 3074: 3073: 3072: 3071: 3070: 3062: 3061: 3060: 3059: 3051: 3050: 3049: 3048: 3036: 3033: 3032: 3031: 3030: 3029: 3028: 3027: 2987: 2986: 2985: 2984: 2959: 2958: 2957: 2956: 2945:Image:ЕUUU.gif 2940: 2937: 2936: 2935: 2934: 2933: 2925: 2924: 2923: 2922: 2914: 2913: 2912: 2911: 2887: 2884: 2883: 2882: 2881: 2880: 2879: 2878: 2847: 2846: 2845: 2844: 2836: 2835: 2834: 2833: 2802: 2799: 2798: 2797: 2796: 2795: 2794: 2793: 2759: 2758: 2757: 2756: 2748: 2747: 2746: 2745: 2729: 2726: 2725: 2724: 2723: 2722: 2721: 2720: 2697: 2696: 2695: 2682: 2681: 2642: 2641: 2640: 2639: 2631: 2630: 2629: 2628: 2589: 2586: 2585: 2584: 2583: 2582: 2581: 2580: 2540: 2525: 2524: 2523: 2522: 2499: 2498: 2497: 2496: 2495: 2494: 2493: 2492: 2483: 2447: 2444: 2435: 2432: 2431: 2430: 2429: 2428: 2420: 2419: 2418: 2417: 2409: 2408: 2407: 2406: 2394: 2391: 2390: 2389: 2388: 2387: 2379: 2378: 2377: 2376: 2368: 2367: 2366: 2365: 2353: 2350: 2349: 2348: 2347: 2346: 2338: 2337: 2336: 2335: 2327: 2326: 2325: 2324: 2312: 2309: 2308: 2307: 2306: 2305: 2297: 2296: 2295: 2294: 2286: 2285: 2284: 2283: 2271: 2268: 2267: 2266: 2265: 2264: 2256: 2255: 2254: 2253: 2245: 2244: 2243: 2242: 2230: 2227: 2226: 2225: 2224: 2223: 2215: 2214: 2213: 2212: 2204: 2203: 2202: 2201: 2189: 2186: 2185: 2184: 2183: 2182: 2174: 2173: 2172: 2171: 2163: 2162: 2161: 2160: 2148: 2145: 2144: 2143: 2142: 2141: 2140: 2139: 2138: 2137: 2136: 2135: 2064: 2063: 2062: 2061: 2053: 2052: 2051: 2050: 2049: 2048: 2008: 2005: 2003: 2000: 1999: 1998: 1997: 1996: 1988: 1987: 1986: 1985: 1977: 1976: 1975: 1974: 1962: 1959: 1958: 1957: 1956: 1955: 1947: 1946: 1945: 1944: 1936: 1935: 1934: 1933: 1921: 1918: 1917: 1916: 1910: 1909: 1908: 1907: 1892: 1891: 1890: 1889: 1872: 1869: 1868: 1867: 1866: 1865: 1864: 1863: 1862: 1861: 1860: 1859: 1802: 1801: 1800: 1799: 1791: 1790: 1789: 1788: 1772: 1769: 1768: 1767: 1766: 1765: 1757: 1756: 1755: 1754: 1739: 1738: 1737: 1736: 1719: 1716: 1715: 1714: 1713: 1712: 1688: 1687: 1686: 1685: 1684: 1683: 1682: 1681: 1680: 1679: 1678: 1677: 1676: 1675: 1674: 1673: 1559: 1558: 1557: 1556: 1541: 1540: 1539: 1538: 1521: 1518: 1517: 1516: 1515: 1514: 1513: 1512: 1511: 1510: 1450: 1449: 1448: 1447: 1439: 1438: 1437: 1436: 1415: 1412: 1411: 1410: 1409: 1408: 1407: 1406: 1371: 1370: 1369: 1368: 1360: 1359: 1358: 1357: 1344: 1341: 1340: 1339: 1316: 1315: 1314: 1313: 1312: 1311: 1298:User:Fut.Perf. 1278: 1277: 1276: 1275: 1260: 1259: 1258: 1257: 1233: 1230: 1229: 1228: 1227: 1226: 1225: 1224: 1194: 1193: 1192: 1191: 1183: 1182: 1181: 1180: 1153: 1150: 1149: 1148: 1147: 1146: 1145: 1144: 1106: 1105: 1104: 1103: 1102: 1084: 1068: 1049: 1048: 1047: 1046: 1045: 1044: 1043: 1042: 994: 991: 990: 989: 988: 987: 979: 978: 977: 976: 968: 967: 966: 965: 942: 939: 938: 937: 936: 935: 927: 926: 925: 924: 916: 915: 914: 913: 865: 862: 861: 860: 859: 858: 857: 856: 816: 815: 814: 813: 805: 804: 803: 802: 782: 779: 777: 774: 772: 769: 767: 764: 763: 762: 761: 760: 752: 751: 750: 749: 741: 740: 739: 738: 726: 723: 722: 721: 720: 719: 711: 710: 709: 708: 700: 699: 698: 697: 685: 682: 681: 680: 679: 678: 670: 669: 668: 667: 659: 658: 657: 656: 644: 641: 640: 639: 638: 637: 629: 628: 627: 626: 618: 617: 616: 615: 603: 600: 598: 595: 594: 593: 592: 591: 584: 583: 582: 581: 580: 579: 578: 559: 558: 557: 556: 555: 554: 535: 534: 533: 532: 498: 497: 496: 495: 466: 463: 462: 461: 460: 459: 458: 457: 416: 415: 414: 413: 395: 394: 393: 392: 368: 365: 364: 363: 362: 361: 360: 359: 344: 327: 326: 308: 305: 288: 287: 271:be called the 260: 259: 258: 257: 256: 255: 254: 253: 240: 239: 238: 182: 151: 150: 149: 148: 128: 127: 126: 125: 106: 103: 102: 101: 100: 99: 91: 90: 89: 88: 80: 79: 78: 77: 52: 49: 47: 44: 27: 15: 14: 13: 10: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 3721: 3712: 3705: 3704: 3703: 3700: 3699: 3694: 3693: 3692: 3689: 3688: 3683: 3682: 3681: 3678: 3677: 3673: 3667: 3666: 3665: 3662: 3661: 3656: 3655: 3654: 3651: 3650: 3645: 3644: 3643: 3640: 3639: 3635: 3629: 3628: 3627: 3624: 3623: 3618: 3617: 3616: 3613: 3612: 3607: 3606: 3605: 3602: 3601: 3597: 3591: 3590: 3589: 3586: 3585: 3580: 3579: 3578: 3575: 3574: 3569: 3568: 3567: 3564: 3563: 3559: 3553: 3552: 3551: 3548: 3547: 3542: 3541: 3540: 3537: 3536: 3531: 3530: 3529: 3526: 3525: 3521: 3515: 3514: 3513: 3510: 3509: 3504: 3503: 3502: 3499: 3498: 3493: 3492: 3491: 3488: 3487: 3483: 3477: 3476: 3475: 3472: 3471: 3466: 3465: 3464: 3461: 3460: 3455: 3454: 3453: 3450: 3449: 3445: 3439: 3438: 3437: 3434: 3433: 3428: 3427: 3426: 3423: 3422: 3417: 3416: 3415: 3412: 3411: 3407: 3405: 3399: 3393: 3392: 3391: 3388: 3387: 3382: 3381: 3380: 3377: 3376: 3371: 3370: 3369: 3366: 3365: 3364: 3358: 3352: 3351: 3350: 3347: 3346: 3341: 3340: 3339: 3336: 3335: 3330: 3329: 3328: 3325: 3324: 3323: 3317: 3311: 3310: 3309: 3306: 3305: 3300: 3299: 3298: 3295: 3294: 3289: 3288: 3287: 3284: 3283: 3282: 3276: 3270: 3269: 3268: 3265: 3264: 3259: 3258: 3257: 3254: 3253: 3248: 3247: 3246: 3243: 3242: 3241: 3235: 3229: 3225: 3221: 3217: 3216: 3215: 3212: 3211: 3206: 3205: 3204: 3201: 3200: 3193: 3190: 3186: 3185: 3184: 3183: 3180: 3175: 3174: 3173: 3170: 3169: 3168: 3162: 3157: 3151: 3150: 3149: 3146: 3145: 3140: 3139: 3138: 3135: 3134: 3129: 3128: 3127: 3124: 3123: 3122: 3116: 3110: 3109: 3108: 3105: 3104: 3099: 3098: 3097: 3094: 3093: 3088: 3087: 3086: 3083: 3082: 3081: 3075: 3069: 3068: 3067: 3064: 3063: 3058: 3057: 3056: 3053: 3052: 3047: 3046: 3045: 3042: 3041: 3040: 3034: 3026: 3022: 3018: 3014: 3009: 3008: 3007: 3003: 2999: 2994: 2993: 2992: 2989: 2988: 2983: 2980: 2977: 2973: 2970: 2966: 2965: 2964: 2961: 2960: 2955: 2954: 2953: 2950: 2949: 2948: 2946: 2938: 2932: 2931: 2930: 2927: 2926: 2921: 2920: 2919: 2916: 2915: 2910: 2907: 2903: 2902: 2901: 2898: 2897: 2896: 2893: 2885: 2877: 2874: 2869: 2868: 2867: 2863: 2859: 2854: 2853: 2852: 2849: 2848: 2843: 2842: 2841: 2838: 2837: 2832: 2829: 2825: 2824: 2823: 2820: 2819: 2818: 2816: 2812: 2808: 2800: 2792: 2788: 2784: 2780: 2779: 2778: 2774: 2770: 2766: 2765: 2764: 2761: 2760: 2755: 2754: 2753: 2750: 2749: 2744: 2743: 2742: 2739: 2738: 2737: 2736: 2728:Wheel warring 2727: 2719: 2716: 2712: 2711: 2710: 2706: 2702: 2698: 2694: 2691: 2687: 2684: 2683: 2680: 2676: 2672: 2668: 2667: 2666: 2662: 2658: 2653: 2649: 2648: 2647: 2644: 2643: 2638: 2637: 2636: 2633: 2632: 2627: 2624: 2619: 2618: 2617: 2614: 2613: 2612: 2610: 2605: 2603: 2599: 2595: 2587: 2579: 2575: 2571: 2567: 2566: 2565: 2561: 2557: 2553: 2549: 2545: 2541: 2539: 2536: 2532: 2531: 2530: 2527: 2526: 2521: 2518: 2515: 2511: 2506: 2505: 2504: 2501: 2500: 2491: 2488: 2484: 2481: 2480: 2479: 2478: 2477: 2474: 2470: 2469: 2468: 2465: 2464: 2463: 2461: 2457: 2453: 2445: 2443: 2441: 2433: 2427: 2426: 2425: 2422: 2421: 2416: 2415: 2414: 2411: 2410: 2405: 2404: 2403: 2400: 2399: 2398: 2392: 2386: 2385: 2384: 2381: 2380: 2375: 2374: 2373: 2370: 2369: 2364: 2363: 2362: 2359: 2358: 2357: 2351: 2345: 2344: 2343: 2340: 2339: 2334: 2333: 2332: 2329: 2328: 2323: 2322: 2321: 2318: 2317: 2316: 2310: 2304: 2303: 2302: 2299: 2298: 2293: 2292: 2291: 2288: 2287: 2282: 2281: 2280: 2277: 2276: 2275: 2269: 2263: 2262: 2261: 2258: 2257: 2252: 2251: 2250: 2247: 2246: 2241: 2240: 2239: 2236: 2235: 2234: 2228: 2222: 2221: 2220: 2217: 2216: 2211: 2210: 2209: 2206: 2205: 2200: 2199: 2198: 2195: 2194: 2193: 2187: 2181: 2180: 2179: 2176: 2175: 2170: 2169: 2168: 2165: 2164: 2159: 2158: 2157: 2154: 2153: 2152: 2146: 2134: 2130: 2126: 2121: 2120: 2119: 2115: 2111: 2107: 2103: 2102: 2101: 2098: 2095: 2090: 2086: 2085: 2084: 2080: 2076: 2071: 2070: 2069: 2066: 2065: 2060: 2059: 2058: 2055: 2054: 2047: 2044: 2040: 2039: 2038: 2035: 2031: 2030: 2029: 2026: 2025: 2024: 2022: 2018: 2017:Dalmatia case 2014: 2006: 2001: 1995: 1994: 1993: 1990: 1989: 1984: 1983: 1982: 1979: 1978: 1973: 1972: 1971: 1968: 1967: 1966: 1960: 1954: 1953: 1952: 1949: 1948: 1943: 1942: 1941: 1938: 1937: 1932: 1931: 1930: 1927: 1926: 1925: 1919: 1915: 1912: 1911: 1906: 1903: 1899: 1898: 1897: 1894: 1893: 1888: 1887: 1886: 1883: 1882: 1881: 1879: 1870: 1858: 1855: 1851: 1850: 1849: 1846: 1845:Sam Blacketer 1842: 1841: 1840: 1836: 1832: 1828: 1824: 1823: 1822: 1818: 1814: 1809: 1808: 1807: 1804: 1803: 1798: 1797: 1796: 1793: 1792: 1787: 1786: 1785: 1782: 1781: 1780: 1778: 1770: 1764: 1763: 1762: 1759: 1758: 1753: 1750: 1746: 1745: 1744: 1741: 1740: 1735: 1734: 1733: 1730: 1729: 1728: 1725: 1717: 1711: 1707: 1703: 1699: 1695: 1692: 1691: 1690: 1689: 1672: 1668: 1664: 1659: 1658: 1657: 1654: 1651: 1647: 1646: 1645: 1642: 1638: 1634: 1630: 1629: 1628: 1625: 1620: 1619: 1618: 1615: 1610: 1606: 1605: 1604: 1601: 1597: 1592: 1591: 1590: 1586: 1582: 1578: 1574: 1570: 1566: 1565: 1564: 1561: 1560: 1555: 1552: 1548: 1547: 1546: 1543: 1542: 1537: 1536: 1535: 1532: 1531: 1530: 1527: 1519: 1509: 1506: 1503: 1499: 1495: 1491: 1488: 1484: 1483: 1482: 1478: 1474: 1470: 1469: 1468: 1465: 1462: 1457: 1456: 1455: 1452: 1451: 1446: 1445: 1444: 1441: 1440: 1435: 1432: 1427: 1426: 1425: 1422: 1421: 1420: 1413: 1405: 1402: 1399: 1394: 1393: 1392: 1389: 1385: 1382: 1378: 1377: 1376: 1373: 1372: 1367: 1366: 1365: 1362: 1361: 1356: 1355: 1354: 1351: 1350: 1349: 1342: 1338: 1334: 1330: 1326: 1322: 1318: 1317: 1310: 1307: 1302: 1299: 1295: 1294: 1293: 1290: 1285: 1284: 1283: 1280: 1279: 1274: 1271: 1267: 1266: 1265: 1262: 1261: 1256: 1255: 1254: 1251: 1250: 1249: 1247: 1243: 1239: 1231: 1223: 1220: 1217: 1213: 1212: 1211: 1208: 1205: 1201: 1200: 1199: 1196: 1195: 1190: 1189: 1188: 1185: 1184: 1179: 1176: 1172: 1171: 1170: 1167: 1166: 1165: 1163: 1159: 1151: 1143: 1140: 1136: 1135: 1134: 1131: 1128: 1124: 1123:User:Vlatkoto 1120: 1119:User:Asteraki 1116: 1115:User:Strich3d 1112: 1111: 1110: 1107: 1101: 1098: 1094: 1093: 1092: 1089: 1085: 1083: 1080: 1077: 1076:Francis Tyers 1073: 1069: 1067: 1064: 1061: 1056: 1055: 1054: 1051: 1050: 1041: 1038: 1034: 1033: 1032: 1029: 1026: 1022: 1018: 1017: 1016: 1013: 1009: 1008: 1007: 1004: 1003: 1002: 1000: 992: 986: 985: 984: 981: 980: 975: 974: 973: 970: 969: 964: 961: 957: 956: 955: 952: 951: 950: 948: 940: 934: 933: 932: 929: 928: 923: 922: 921: 918: 917: 912: 909: 905: 904: 903: 900: 899: 898: 896: 892: 888: 884: 880: 876: 872: 863: 855: 852: 848: 847: 846: 842: 838: 834: 830: 828: 823: 822: 821: 818: 817: 812: 811: 810: 807: 806: 801: 798: 794: 793: 792: 789: 788: 787: 780: 775: 770: 765: 759: 758: 757: 754: 753: 748: 747: 746: 743: 742: 737: 736: 735: 732: 731: 730: 724: 718: 717: 716: 713: 712: 707: 706: 705: 702: 701: 696: 695: 694: 691: 690: 689: 683: 677: 676: 675: 672: 671: 666: 665: 664: 661: 660: 655: 654: 653: 650: 649: 648: 642: 636: 635: 634: 631: 630: 625: 624: 623: 620: 619: 614: 613: 612: 609: 608: 607: 601: 596: 590: 589: 588: 585: 577: 574: 571: 567: 566: 565: 564: 563: 562: 561: 560: 553: 549: 545: 541: 540: 539: 538: 537: 536: 531: 528: 525: 521: 517: 513: 509: 505: 504: 503: 500: 499: 494: 493: 492: 489: 488: 487: 486: 482: 478: 473: 464: 456: 452: 448: 444: 443: 442: 438: 434: 433:Ex-Jackanapes 430: 426: 423: 422: 421: 418: 417: 412: 409: 406: 402: 401: 400: 397: 396: 391: 390: 389: 386: 385: 384: 382: 377: 374: 366: 358: 354: 350: 345: 343: 340: 337: 333: 329: 328: 325: 321: 317: 313: 309: 306: 302: 301: 300: 297: 292: 291: 290: 289: 286: 282: 278: 274: 270: 266: 262: 261: 252: 249: 245: 241: 237: 233: 229: 225: 221: 220: 219: 215: 211: 206: 202: 201: 200: 196: 192: 187: 183: 181: 178: 173: 172: 171: 167: 163: 162:Sam Blacketer 158: 157: 156: 153: 152: 147: 144: 140: 135: 134: 133: 130: 129: 124: 121: 117: 116: 115: 112: 111: 110: 104: 98: 97: 96: 93: 92: 87: 86: 85: 82: 81: 76: 72: 68: 64: 63: 62: 59: 58: 57: 50: 45: 43: 41: 36: 34: 23: 19: 3710: 3701: 3690: 3679: 3663: 3652: 3641: 3625: 3614: 3603: 3587: 3576: 3565: 3549: 3538: 3527: 3511: 3500: 3489: 3473: 3462: 3451: 3435: 3424: 3413: 3403: 3389: 3378: 3367: 3362: 3348: 3337: 3326: 3321: 3307: 3296: 3285: 3280: 3266: 3255: 3244: 3239: 3213: 3202: 3176: 3171: 3166: 3147: 3136: 3125: 3120: 3106: 3095: 3084: 3079: 3065: 3054: 3043: 3038: 3012: 2990: 2962: 2951: 2942: 2928: 2917: 2899: 2889: 2850: 2839: 2821: 2804: 2762: 2751: 2740: 2733: 2731: 2645: 2634: 2615: 2606: 2591: 2551: 2548:this debacle 2528: 2509: 2502: 2466: 2449: 2439: 2437: 2423: 2412: 2401: 2396: 2382: 2371: 2360: 2355: 2341: 2330: 2319: 2314: 2300: 2289: 2278: 2273: 2259: 2248: 2237: 2232: 2218: 2207: 2196: 2191: 2177: 2166: 2155: 2150: 2105: 2088: 2067: 2056: 2027: 2010: 1991: 1980: 1969: 1964: 1950: 1939: 1928: 1923: 1913: 1900:Proposed. -- 1895: 1884: 1874: 1829:, not here. 1805: 1794: 1783: 1774: 1760: 1747:Proposed -- 1742: 1731: 1721: 1697: 1693: 1636: 1608: 1569:naming issue 1562: 1544: 1533: 1523: 1489: 1453: 1442: 1423: 1417: 1374: 1363: 1352: 1346: 1324: 1320: 1281: 1268:Proposed. -- 1263: 1252: 1235: 1197: 1186: 1168: 1155: 1108: 1088:202.10.89.28 1052: 1020: 1005: 996: 982: 971: 953: 944: 930: 919: 901: 867: 832: 825: 819: 808: 790: 784: 755: 744: 733: 728: 714: 703: 692: 687: 673: 662: 651: 646: 632: 621: 610: 605: 586: 501: 490: 471: 468: 447:202.10.89.28 419: 398: 387: 378: 370: 311: 272: 203:I note that 154: 131: 113: 108: 94: 83: 60: 54: 37: 29: 2075:Newyorkbrad 2021:Kosovo case 403:Requested. 3224:PMAnderson 3021:PMAnderson 3002:PMAnderson 2862:PMAnderson 2787:PMAnderson 2773:PMAnderson 2705:PMAnderson 2675:PMAnderson 2661:PMAnderson 2574:PMAnderson 2560:PMAnderson 2554:subject.) 2114:PMAnderson 1835:PMAnderson 1706:PMAnderson 1667:PMAnderson 1333:PMAnderson 1158:user pages 999:user pages 993:User pages 887:harassment 875:incivility 841:PMAnderson 827:User pages 320:PMAnderson 281:PMAnderson 232:PMAnderson 67:Ireland101 2976:Fut.Perf. 2813:, or the 2652:Draconian 2600:, or the 2514:Fut.Perf. 2458:, or the 1650:Fut.Perf. 1596:WP:MOSMAC 1461:Fut.Perf. 1214:Thirded. 1060:Fut.Perf. 570:Fut.Perf. 524:Fut.Perf. 429:talk page 425:Fut.Perf. 405:Fut.Perf. 332:WP:MOSMAC 265:WP:MOSMAC 139:WP:MOSMAC 33:/Evidence 22:Macedonia 3636:Template 3598:Template 3560:Template 3522:Template 3484:Template 3446:Template 3408:Template 3359:Template 3318:Template 3277:Template 3236:Template 3117:Template 3076:Template 3035:Template 2393:Template 2352:Template 2311:Template 2270:Template 2229:Template 2188:Template 2147:Template 2019:and the 1961:Template 1920:Template 1827:Wikiinfo 1698:policies 1204:Picaroon 1127:Picaroon 1025:Picaroon 883:trolling 725:Template 684:Template 643:Template 602:Template 522:, etc.) 210:·ΚέκρωΨ· 120:jpgordon 20:‎ | 3163:Logging 2013:Balkans 1694:Support 1633:Florina 1577:WP:NCON 1573:WP:NPOV 1524:7) The 1381:WP:TALK 1021:exactly 864:Decorum 312:doesn't 224:WP:NCGN 205:WP:NCON 186:WP:NCON 3189:Kirill 3179:Kirill 2906:Kirill 2873:Kirill 2828:Kirill 2809:, the 2715:Kirill 2623:Kirill 2596:, the 2535:Jd2718 2487:Kirill 2473:Kirill 2454:, the 2125:Jd2718 2097:Silver 2043:Kirill 2034:Kirill 1854:ChrisO 1813:ChrisO 1661:will. 1641:ChrisO 1614:ChrisO 1581:ChrisO 1505:Silver 1473:Jd2718 1431:Kirill 1401:Silver 1388:ChrisO 1289:ChrisO 1246:WP:CIV 1242:WP:VAN 1238:WP:NPA 1219:Silver 1175:Kirill 1139:ChrisO 1121:, and 1037:Kirill 1012:Kirill 960:Kirill 908:Kirill 889:, and 851:Kirill 797:Kirill 544:Hxseek 477:Hxseek 349:ChrisO 339:Silver 304:again. 191:ChrisO 2939:Image 1494:WP:RS 1321:every 16:< 2688:. -- 2552:that 2129:talk 2094:Niko 2089:same 2079:talk 1878:NPOV 1817:talk 1585:talk 1502:Niko 1487:WP:V 1477:talk 1398:Niko 1244:and 1216:Niko 1072:here 897:. 833:this 824:Add 729:4) 688:3) 647:2) 606:1) 548:talk 481:talk 451:talk 437:talk 353:talk 336:Niko 246:. -- 214:talk 195:talk 166:talk 71:talk 2969:IFD 2943:6) 2890:5) 2690:Avg 1902:Avg 1749:Avg 1635:), 1624:Avg 1609:may 1600:Avg 1551:Avg 1306:Avg 1270:Avg 1207:(t) 1130:(t) 1097:Avg 1028:(t) 371:3) 296:Avg 248:Avg 177:Avg 143:Avg 2974:. 2732:3) 2131:) 2081:) 1880:. 1819:) 1587:) 1490:is 1479:) 1240:, 1125:. 1117:, 1074:. 885:, 881:, 877:, 873:, 550:) 518:, 514:, 510:, 483:) 453:) 439:) 355:) 216:) 197:) 168:) 73:) 2979:☼ 2517:☼ 2127:( 2077:( 1815:( 1653:☼ 1583:( 1475:( 1464:☼ 1079:· 1063:☼ 573:☼ 546:( 527:☼ 479:( 449:( 435:( 408:☼ 351:( 212:( 193:( 164:( 69:(

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.

Knowledge (XXG)

:Requests for arbitration/Macedonia/Workshop - Knowledge (XXG)

Index