393:, of determining something with respect to these objects, before they are given to us. We here propose to do just what Copernicus did in attempting to explain the celestial movements. When he found that he could make no progress by assuming that all the heavenly bodies revolved round the spectator, he reversed the process, and tried the experiment of assuming that the spectator revolved, while the stars remained at rest. We may make the same experiment with regard to the intuition of objects."
389:, by means of conceptions, and thus to extend the range of our knowledge, have been rendered abortive by this assumption. Let us then make the experiment whether we may not be more successful in metaphysics, if we assume that the objects must conform to our cognition. This appears, at all events, to accord better with the possibility of our gaining the end we have in view, that is to say, of arriving at the cognition of objects
81:. No mention of mental states need enter into the explanation. This troubles philosophers because intuitively it seems that mental states are crucial in causing a person to act (for example, their beliefs and desires). But, given that physiological facts are sufficient to account for action, mental states appear to be superfluous; they are at risk of being causally and explanatorily irrelevant with respect to human action (
464:
determine connections about objective events, the specific form of the theoretical construct is a product of subjective activities, and this particular form may well involve the workings of the brain. Perhaps some aspects of the universe's operation can be expressed in terms of mental constructs, but this process is analogous with the expression of a
872:
463:
This work can be taken to suggest that although a physical theory is an intermediary between our observations and our notions of connections between them, it is an elaborate mental construction that is a meld of the way the mind works and objective observations. Although a physical theory is used to
301:
World 3 includes physical theory as a particular case. But World 3 is a creation of the human imagination, and such acts of imagination are a part of World 2. Accordingly, one could argue that the physical notion of causality is a child of the imagination, and although causation has its successes in
42:
are causes of intentional actions. The problem divides into several distinct sub-problems, including the problem of causal exclusion, the problem of anomalism, and the problem of externalism. However, the sub-problem which has attracted most attention in the philosophical literature is arguably the
195:. The major problem that interactionist dualism faces is that of explicating a satisfactory notion of causation according to which non-spatial events, such as mental events, can causally interact with physical events. According to the current mainstream scientific world-view, the physical realm is
117:
Another problem with mental causation is that mental events seem anomalous in the sense that there are no scientific laws that mental states can figure into without having exceptions. There are no "strict" laws, and mental events must factor into strict laws in order to fit respectably into the
55:
cause physical events (and vice versa), but how can mental events have any causal effect on physical events? Suppose that a person, John, orders dessert after dinner. It seems that at least one cause for such a physical, behavioral event is that John desired to have dessert and believed that by
135:
laws (or laws with "all else being equal" clauses), according to which there are exceptions. However, only in the basic sciences (physics) are there strict, exceptionless laws. Thus, although mental states are anomalous, they can still figure into scientifically respectable laws of psychology.
162:. The thought is about water and the fact that it is wet. But, if externalism is true—if some of the contents of one's thoughts are constituted at least in part by factors external to one's mind—then there is yet another difficulty in explaining how mental states can cause physical states (
201:, in that causal relationships only hold among physical events in the physical realm. Given these types of considerations, some argue that it is appropriate to say that the main assumptions in interactionist dualism generate the problem of mental causation rather than solve it (see (
884:
152:
became espoused by many philosophers. Externalism is roughly the view that certain parts of an individual's environment play a crucial role in the meaning of at least some of an individual's words . A thesis about meaning affects the mind insofar as our thoughts are
428:"People do not think in English or Chinese or Apache; they think in a language of thought. This language of thought probably looks a bit like all these languages;...But compared with any given language, mentalese must be richer in some ways and simpler in others."
293:
The mental or psychological world, the world of our feelings of pain and of pleasure, of our thoughts, of our decisions, of our perceptions and our observations; in other words, the world of mental or psychological states or processes, or of subjective
423:
raised the issue of the mind's inherent programming. Chomsky selected as a particular example the acquiring of language by children. Of course, language is indispensable in the formulation and communication of our perceptions of the objective world:
376:
knowledge. In particular, he thought that by introspection some aspects of the filtering mechanisms of the mind/brain/nervous system could be discovered. The following observations summarize Kant's views upon the subject-object problem, called
96:
famously noted that epiphenomenalism treats mental states like the steam coming off a train: it plays no causal role in the train's moving forward, it is merely an "emergent property" of the actual causation occurring in the engine
455:
himself "concluded that language ability is 'an instinctive tendency to acquire an art', a design that is not peculiar to humans but seen in other species such as song-learning birds." This observation is strongly supported by
249:, claims that mental events are individuated (or constituted by) the causal role they play. As such, mental events would fit directly into the causal realm, as they are simply certain causal (or functional) roles.
157:
things in the world. A common view in the philosophy of mind is that at least certain mental states have intentional content in this sense. For example, one's belief that water is wet has the semantic content of
302:
describing World 1, it may not apply to World 2 or World 3. The subjective aspects of theories contained in World 3 are not readily framed within the third-person perspective of science used to explain World 1.
438:
Chomsky marshaled evidence that a child's rapid mastery of the complexity of language indicated an innate ability programmed into the development of the human mind from birth that could not be explained by the
76:
have to go outside human physiology in order to trace the causal antecedents of any bodily movement, intentional action can be fully causally explained by the existence of these physiological antecedents
411:
Although Kant has posed the issue of built-in aspects of mind, the particulars that depend upon the science of his day have become outmoded. A more recent approach to these limitations is proposed by
321:
A still different approach to mental causation is based upon the philosophies of Kant, Chomsky and Pinker. These philosophers stress the impact of built-in aspects of mind, studied in the field of
189:
Some have claimed that while the mental and the physical are quite different things, they can nonetheless causally interact with one another, a view going back to
Descartes . This view is known as
56:
ordering dessert he would be able to soon have dessert. But, how can such mental events as beliefs and desires cause John's mouth to move in such a way that he orders dessert?
313:, invented by World 2 in its creation of the theory of World 3 used to explain World 1, have direct application to Worlds 2 and 3 themselves, and control mental agency.
363:
world as conveyed by our senses, this conveyance processed by the machinery of the mind and nervous system. Kant focused upon this processing. Kant believed in
1155:
479:
From this standpoint, as with the philosophy of Kant, the first-person active actions of mental causation may involve innate workings of the brain itself.
443:
view of the infant mind. Rather, the mind has a built-in propensity to process symbolic representations. The origins of this ability were sought by
92:—the view that mental events or states are causally irrelevant, they are merely after effects that play no role in any causal chains whatsoever.
88:
Many philosophers consider this apparent irrelevance to be a highly counter-intuitive and undesirable position to take. It ultimately leads to
958:
741:
104:
564:
305:
From this perspective, it is hubris to suppose that the methods successful in describing World 1, in particular to suppose the notions of
385:"It has hitherto been assumed that our cognition must conform to the objects; but all attempts to ascertain anything about these objects
1124:
1113:
769:
69:
What follows is a summary of the causal exclusion problem in its simplest form, and it is merely one of several possible formulations.
779:
712:
654:
518:
246:
1043:
984:
904:
1150:
378:
1190:
1180:
594:
241:. Behaviorists, in general, argue that mental events are merely dispositions to behave in certain ways. Another theory is the
1200:
861:
121:
In short, one response has been to deny that psychological laws involving mental states require strict, exceptionless laws.
331:(1724–1804) pointed out that we all shape our experience of things through the filter of our mind, a view sometimes called
245:, according to which mental events are (either type- or token-) identical to physical events. A more recent view, known as
225:
The other major option is to assert that mental events are either (at least contingently) identical to physical events, or
1175:
493:
184:
1195:
754:
237:. But, such views require a particular theory to explain how mental events are physical in nature. One such theory is
1145:
364:
332:
39:
267:
933:
1205:
731:
describing crows as having a vocabulary of over 250 calls and an ability to learn calls from their parents:
513:
448:
242:
616:
1185:
1160:
322:
191:
508:
476:
of the general statement of an algorithm into specific tiny steps that particular computer can handle.
543:
533:
149:
145:
399:
279:
93:
38:. That problem, in short, is how to account for the common-sense idea that intentional thoughts or
966:
1170:
1165:
1140:
1090:
1017:
728:
672:
575:
528:
498:
488:
465:
283:
266:
above, a more general and somewhat differently posed approach to mental causation is provided by
180:
35:
1039:
980:
954:
900:
857:
775:
708:
650:
638:
538:
503:
469:
1082:
1007:
812:
702:
89:
51:
The basic problem of mental causation is an intuitive one: on the face of it, it seems that
707:(Updated reprint of William Morrow and Company 1994 ed.). Harper Collins. p. 72.
598:
131:
451:
that established the survival value of the ability to communicate. According to Pinker,
335:. The mind shapes that experience, and among other things, Kant believed the concepts of
816:
452:
196:
1054:
1134:
444:
416:
328:
226:
591:
420:
412:
129:). In current practice, special sciences (for example, biology and chemistry) have
52:
125:
argues that non-basic (or "special") sciences do not in fact require strict laws (
1033:
974:
948:
786:
1035:
Mind in a
Physical World: An Essay on the Mind-Body Problem and Mental Causation
1029:
440:
271:
238:
234:
230:
214:
122:
17:
297:
The world of products of the human mind, including art, science, and religion.
847:(John Cottingham translated ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
927:
685:
934:
https://science.howstuffworks.com/life/inside-the-mind/emotions/crying.htm
406:(1. edition 1781, April 23, 1787 Immanuel Kant, Preface to the 2. edition)
229:
on physical events. Views that fall under this general heading are called
733:
523:
473:
915:
1094:
1021:
287:
220:
1086:
1012:
995:
1119:
1108:
472:
instructions peculiar to a particular computer, a translation by a
457:
932:
Hoyt A. "How Crying Works" 2 July 2008. HowStuffWorks.com. <
675:. Philosophy on the EServer, Iowa State University(eserver.org)
737:
883:. Cambridge University Press. pp. 215–71. Archived from
343:
were programmed into the human brain, as was the notion of
369:
knowledge arrived at independent of experience, so-called
803:
Burge, Tyler (1979). "Individualism and the Mental".
613:
For a review of recent developments, see for example
704:
The
Language Instinct: How the mind creates language
684:
This and other web resources for Kant are posted by
615:
Samet, Jerry & Zaitchik, Deborah (Oct 1, 2012).
895:Walter, Sven; Heckmann, Heinz-Dieter, eds. (2003).
871:Putnam, Hilary (1975). "The Meaning of 'Meaning'".
617:"Innateness and Contemporary Theories of Cognition"
876:Mind, Language and Reality: Philosophical Papers 2
1073:Yablo, Stephen (April 1992). "Mental Causation".
639:"Chapter 19: Rose-tinted reality: Immanuel Kant"
830:reprinted in Davidson (1980), pp. 207–227.
426:
383:
771:Computing the Mind: How the Mind Really Works
686:Steve Palmquist, Hong Kong Baptist University
8:
926:Kallestrup, J. Philos Stud (2006) 131: 459.
632:
630:
433:Steven Pinker, The Language Instinct, p. 72
144:In the latter half of the twentieth century
118:causal order described by current science .
918:. In James Fieser; Bradley Dowden (eds.).
609:
607:
103:harv error: no target: CITEREFWalter2003 (
27:Conceptual issue in the philosophy of mind
1011:
928:https://doi.org/10.1007/s11098-005-1439-x
696:
694:
574:. The University of Utah. Archived from
359:world, and what we do experience is the
1059:The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
973:Heil, John; Mele, Alfred, eds. (1995).
953:. New York: Columbia University Press.
950:Mental Causation: The Mind-Body Problem
920:The Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
621:The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
555:
274:split the world into three categories:
257:
645:. Yale University Press. pp. 111
398:Immanuel Kant, English translation by
263:
98:
1120:Mind and the Causal Exclusion Problem
899:. Exeter, England: Imprint Academic.
742:The Canadian Broadcasting Corporation
590:The list of lectures is found in the
126:
7:
854:A theory of content and other essays
1125:Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
1114:Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
669:An on-line translation is found at
572:The Tanner lectures on human values
202:
163:
82:
1156:Concepts in the philosophy of mind
817:10.1111/j.1475-4975.1979.tb00374.x
701:Steven Pinker (14 December 2010).
519:Neural correlates of consciousness
25:
897:Physicalism and Mental Causation
258:Popper's three-world formulation
60:Sub-problems of mental causation
1038:. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
845:Meditations on First Philosophy
766:A proponent of this analogy is
643:A little history of philosophy
1:
805:Midwest Studies in Philosophy
563:Karl Popper (April 7, 1978).
34:is a conceptual issue in the
1053:Robb, David (Jan 14, 2013).
836:Essays on Actions and Events
619:. In Edward N. Zalta (ed.).
494:Computational theory of mind
379:Kant's Copernican revolution
185:Dualism (philosophy of mind)
979:. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
774:. Oxford University Press.
404:The Critique of Pure Reason
32:problem of mental causation
1222:
838:. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
355:experience of things, the
268:Karl Popper's three worlds
218:
212:
178:
1057:. In Edward Zalta (ed.).
843:Descartes, René (1986) .
834:Davidson, Donald (1980).
824:Davidson, Donald (1970).
673:"Critique of Pure Reason"
333:epistemological solipsism
72:To the extent that we do
40:intentional mental states
1075:The Philosophical Review
947:Dardis, Anthony (2008).
637:Nigel Warburton (2011).
1151:Concepts in metaphysics
1000:Philosophical Quarterly
994:Jackson, Frank (1982).
768:Shimon Edelman (2008).
623:(Winter 2012 ed.).
514:Model-dependent realism
1191:Philosophical problems
1181:Metaphysics of science
1061:(Spring 2013 ed.)
996:"Epiphenomenal Qualia"
592:Tanner Lecture Library
436:
409:
323:psychological nativism
317:Psychological nativism
278:The world of physical
192:interactionist dualism
140:Problem of externalism
1201:Subjective experience
852:Fodor, Jerry (1980).
209:Physicalist solutions
170:Traditional solutions
740:in association with
544:Vertiginous question
534:Physical determinism
166:, p. §3b.ii)].
113:Problem of anomalism
85:, p. §3b.iii).
1176:Metaphysics of mind
914:Yoo, Julie (2006).
734:"A murder of crows"
400:J. M. D. Meiklejohn
43:exclusion problem.
1196:Philosophy of mind
1055:"Mental Causation"
916:"Mental Causation"
797:In-line references
753:Credits are found
597:2012-11-04 at the
529:Philosophy of mind
499:Intelligent design
489:Cognitive ethology
466:computer algorithm
449:Darwinian struggle
253:Idealist solutions
181:Philosophy of mind
36:philosophy of mind
1146:Cognitive science
960:978-0-231-14417-9
787:Google books link
581:on March 10, 2013
539:Simulated reality
509:Mind–body problem
470:assembly language
458:research on crows
175:Dualist solutions
65:Exclusion problem
16:(Redirected from
1213:
1109:Mental Causation
1098:
1069:
1067:
1066:
1049:
1025:
1015:
990:
976:Mental Causation
964:
923:
910:
891:
889:
882:
867:
848:
839:
829:
820:
790:
785:
764:
758:
752:
750:
749:
725:
719:
718:
698:
689:
683:
681:
680:
667:
661:
660:
634:
625:
624:
611:
602:
589:
587:
586:
580:
569:
560:
434:
407:
351:. We never have
205:, p. §1a).
108:
90:epiphenomenalism
21:
18:Mental causation
1221:
1220:
1216:
1215:
1214:
1212:
1211:
1210:
1131:
1130:
1105:
1087:10.2307/2185535
1072:
1064:
1062:
1052:
1046:
1028:
1013:10.2307/2960077
1006:(127): 127–36.
993:
987:
972:
961:
946:
943:
941:Further reading
913:
907:
894:
887:
880:
870:
864:
851:
842:
833:
823:
802:
799:
794:
793:
782:
767:
765:
761:
747:
745:
732:
726:
722:
715:
700:
699:
692:
678:
676:
671:Immanuel Kant.
670:
668:
664:
657:
636:
635:
628:
614:
612:
605:
599:Wayback Machine
584:
582:
578:
567:
562:
561:
557:
552:
485:
435:
432:
408:
397:
319:
260:
255:
243:identity theory
223:
217:
211:
198:causally closed
187:
179:Main articles:
177:
172:
142:
132:ceteris paribus
115:
102:
67:
62:
49:
28:
23:
22:
15:
12:
11:
5:
1219:
1217:
1209:
1208:
1206:Theory of mind
1203:
1198:
1193:
1188:
1183:
1178:
1173:
1168:
1163:
1158:
1153:
1148:
1143:
1133:
1132:
1129:
1128:
1117:
1104:
1103:External links
1101:
1100:
1099:
1081:(2): 245–280.
1070:
1050:
1044:
1026:
991:
985:
970:
959:
942:
939:
938:
937:
930:
924:
911:
905:
892:
890:on 2013-06-18.
868:
862:
849:
840:
831:
821:
798:
795:
792:
791:
781:978-0195320671
780:
759:
744:. Oct 24, 2010
720:
714:978-0061336461
713:
690:
662:
656:978-0300152081
655:
626:
603:
565:"Three Worlds"
554:
553:
551:
548:
547:
546:
541:
536:
531:
526:
521:
516:
511:
506:
501:
496:
491:
484:
481:
453:Charles Darwin
430:
395:
318:
315:
299:
298:
295:
291:
259:
256:
254:
251:
213:Main article:
210:
207:
176:
173:
171:
168:
141:
138:
114:
111:
66:
63:
61:
58:
48:
45:
26:
24:
14:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
1218:
1207:
1204:
1202:
1199:
1197:
1194:
1192:
1189:
1187:
1186:Open problems
1184:
1182:
1179:
1177:
1174:
1172:
1169:
1167:
1164:
1162:
1161:Consciousness
1159:
1157:
1154:
1152:
1149:
1147:
1144:
1142:
1139:
1138:
1136:
1127:
1126:
1121:
1118:
1116:
1115:
1110:
1107:
1106:
1102:
1096:
1092:
1088:
1084:
1080:
1076:
1071:
1060:
1056:
1051:
1047:
1045:0-262-11234-5
1041:
1037:
1036:
1031:
1027:
1023:
1019:
1014:
1009:
1005:
1001:
997:
992:
988:
986:0-19-823929-7
982:
978:
977:
971:
968:
962:
956:
952:
951:
945:
944:
940:
935:
931:
929:
925:
921:
917:
912:
908:
906:0-907845-47-9
902:
898:
893:
886:
879:
878:
875:
869:
865:
859:
856:. MIT Press.
855:
850:
846:
841:
837:
832:
827:
826:Mental Events
822:
818:
814:
810:
806:
801:
800:
796:
788:
783:
777:
773:
772:
763:
760:
756:
743:
739:
735:
730:
724:
721:
716:
710:
706:
705:
697:
695:
691:
687:
674:
666:
663:
658:
652:
648:
644:
640:
633:
631:
627:
622:
618:
610:
608:
604:
600:
596:
593:
577:
573:
566:
559:
556:
549:
545:
542:
540:
537:
535:
532:
530:
527:
525:
522:
520:
517:
515:
512:
510:
507:
505:
502:
500:
497:
495:
492:
490:
487:
486:
482:
480:
477:
475:
471:
467:
461:
459:
454:
450:
446:
445:Steven Pinker
442:
441:"blank slate"
429:
425:
422:
419:. Like Kant,
418:
417:Steven Pinker
414:
405:
401:
394:
392:
388:
382:
380:
375:
372:
368:
367:
362:
358:
354:
350:
346:
342:
338:
334:
330:
329:Immanuel Kant
326:
324:
316:
314:
312:
308:
303:
296:
292:
289:
285:
281:
277:
276:
275:
273:
269:
265:
252:
250:
248:
247:functionalism
244:
240:
236:
232:
228:
222:
216:
208:
206:
204:
200:
199:
194:
193:
186:
182:
174:
169:
167:
165:
161:
156:
151:
147:
139:
137:
134:
133:
128:
124:
119:
112:
110:
106:
101:, p. §2)
100:
95:
94:Thomas Huxley
91:
86:
84:
80:
75:
70:
64:
59:
57:
54:
53:mental events
46:
44:
41:
37:
33:
19:
1123:
1112:
1078:
1074:
1063:. Retrieved
1058:
1034:
1003:
999:
975:
967:on-line link
949:
919:
896:
885:the original
877:
873:
853:
844:
835:
825:
808:
804:
770:
762:
746:. Retrieved
729:Nature video
723:
703:
677:. Retrieved
665:
646:
642:
620:
583:. Retrieved
576:the original
571:
558:
478:
468:in terms of
462:
437:
427:
421:Noam Chomsky
413:Noam Chomsky
410:
403:
390:
386:
384:
373:
370:
365:
360:
356:
352:
348:
344:
340:
336:
327:
320:
310:
306:
304:
300:
294:experiences.
286:, including
261:
224:
197:
190:
188:
160:water is wet
159:
154:
143:
130:
120:
116:
87:
78:
73:
71:
68:
50:
31:
29:
1030:Jaegwon Kim
262:Related to
239:behaviorism
235:materialism
231:physicalism
215:Physicalism
146:externalism
123:Jerry Fodor
99:Walter 2003
47:Description
1135:Categories
1065:2013-02-03
863:0262061309
811:: 73–121.
748:2013-01-15
679:2013-01-16
585:2013-01-24
361:phenomenal
288:biological
219:See also:
127:Fodor 1980
1171:Intention
1166:Free will
1141:Causality
874:Putnam's
371:synthetic
227:supervene
1032:(1998).
595:Archived
524:Noumenon
483:See also
474:compiler
431:—
396:—
391:a priori
387:a priori
374:a priori
366:a priori
357:noumenal
290:entities
203:Yoo 2006
164:Yoo 2006
150:meanings
83:Yoo 2006
1095:2185535
1022:2960077
504:Dualism
280:objects
264:dualism
1093:
1042:
1020:
983:
957:
903:
860:
778:
727:See a
711:
653:
353:direct
349:effect
311:effect
284:events
272:Popper
221:Monism
148:about
1091:JSTOR
1018:JSTOR
888:(PDF)
881:(PDF)
579:(PDF)
568:(PDF)
550:Notes
447:in a
345:cause
337:space
307:cause
155:about
79:alone
1040:ISBN
981:ISBN
955:ISBN
936:>
901:ISBN
858:ISBN
776:ISBN
755:here
709:ISBN
651:ISBN
415:and
347:and
341:time
339:and
309:and
282:and
183:and
105:help
30:The
1083:doi
1079:101
1008:doi
813:doi
738:PBS
402:of
381::
233:or
74:not
1137::
1122:,
1111:,
1089:.
1077:.
1016:.
1004:32
1002:.
998:.
807:.
736:.
693:^
649:.
647:ff
641:.
629:^
606:^
570:.
460:.
325:.
270:.
109:.
1097:.
1085::
1068:.
1048:.
1024:.
1010::
989:.
969:)
965:(
963:.
922:.
909:.
866:.
828:.
819:.
815::
809:4
789:.
784:.
757:.
751:.
717:.
688:.
682:.
659:.
601:.
588:.
107:)
97:(
20:)
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.