647:@ Vice regent Economic and Political Weekly ref seem to insinuate complicity of some sort but uses word 'killings'. The Tribune ref seem to use word carnage. It seems to be indiscriminate killings so descriptively word 'massacre' may not be entirely wrong. Urdu Knowledge seem to use title September 30 event, but that too is incomplete title and shy to call spade a spade. In RS word Black Friday is used as descriptive and not in the titles. Idk how far coloring of Friday gives justice to Friday and how far to those killed; euphemistic title nor would give idea to readers what the article is all about.
563:
402:
381:
297:
276:
307:
245:
491:
470:
201:
1178:
Thirdly, now that it's evident that this couldn't be done by a dead dictator or the caretaker govt, it most certainly was done during the first
Benazir govt. Which makes sense because MQM had a falling out with the PPP govt in 1989 after spending a year in the coalition govt in Sindh. In May 1990
1174:
Which brings us to the second issue, it couldn't have happened in
September 1988 because it would mean the caretaker govt did it. It's in no historical reference if it was such a case. It's well known that this operation was against MQM but MQM participated in the 1988 elections under the name of
799:
With considerations to the previous discussion that had taken place just a day before this RM is opened, there is a consensus to move the page. However, as raised by several participants, the proposed title will confuse and astonish readers, thus moving to the alternate proposed title.
164:
598:
I'm trying to find if this event is really called "massacre" in RS, but it seems more RS call it as "Black Friday" or simply describe the events without a name. As such, the "massacre" in the title seems POV. Requesting
1186:
627:
Sure. I agree we need solid references before we use terms like ‘massacre’, because usually that implies a complicity of some sort. I’d be fine with using ‘killings’ or something similar too.
158:
55:
961:
Those suggestions are acceptable to me. The reason I didn't propose that was that there was no significant killings (AFAIK) in any other
Hyderabad in 1988. So, for example, we have
803:
1200:
All of the cited sources say 1988. As it happens, I was caught up in the curfew in the city - and 1988 is the only year in which I have ever visited
Pakistan.
506:, individual terrorists, incidents and related subjects on Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the
221:. Feel free to try to improve the article, but don't take it personally if your changes are reversed; instead, come here to the talk page to discuss them.
1259:
541:
531:
90:
1234:
363:
353:
1075:
refers to the city in India. The proposed title gives a false impression/idea that killings took place in Indian city. More appropriate title can be
1264:
1224:
179:
146:
1254:
1249:
1239:
452:
442:
208:
1229:
96:
1116:
507:
969:
is a disambig page that can refer to several different places, but we don't need to disambiguate in that case because (presumably) other
782:
Subsequent comments should be made in a new section on the talk page. Editors desiring to contest the closing decision should consider a
1096:
329:
1244:
1190:
140:
1076:
943:
794:
583:
35:
577:
418:
136:
498:
475:
224:
212:
110:
41:
1014:
1010:
886:
822:
320:
281:
115:
31:
741:
186:
1162:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.
982:
85:
1182:
1180:
256:
962:
409:
386:
76:
924:
773:
569:
152:
1171:
First of all, it couldn't have happened during the Zia regime because Zia was assassinated on August 17, 1988.
1084:
939:
573:
230:
120:
244:
1194:
1024:
974:
912:
842:
783:
686:
614:
262:
931:) one being more prominent; to avoid reader confusion suggested new title would deserve little more
1148:
1124:
1104:
998:
858:
812:
786:
after discussing it on the closer's talk page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.
650:
The title I would suggest is some thing like 'September 30, 1988 killings in
Hyderabad, Sindh '.
172:
66:
17:
1179:
there was a notorious search operation carried out by the same govt in
Hyderabad's "Pucca Qilla" (
417:
on
Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join
328:
on
Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join
1205:
1068:
881:
81:
1209:
1152:
1128:
1108:
1087:
1059:
1028:
956:
916:
890:
816:
690:
670:
642:
618:
832:
724:
676:
218:
62:
1019:
990:
952:
907:
837:
681:
666:
658:
624:
609:
1083:
reliable sources make more use of "killings" than "massacre" (common name). —usernamekiran
1053:
986:
636:
312:
1144:
1120:
1100:
1041:
854:
808:
401:
380:
1218:
1201:
1183:
https://tribune.com.pk/story/1420945/mqm-observes-27th-anniversary-pucca-qila-tragedy
876:
970:
966:
948:
902:
662:
654:
604:
296:
275:
1046:
898:
629:
600:
302:
1185:) so a logical conclusion would be September 1990 instead of September 1988.
727:
1140:
1072:
928:
503:
233:
when adding content and consider tagging or removing unsourced information.
325:
490:
469:
994:
978:
712:
713:"Sindhi vs Mohajir in Pakistan: Contradiction, Conflict, Compromise"
1002:
414:
742:"Dr Qadir Magsi (SOB) acquitted in 1988 Hyderabad massacre case"
502:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of articles on
949:
Bookku, 'Encyclopedias = expanding information & knowledge'
663:
Bookku, 'Encyclopedias = expanding information & knowledge'
655:
Bookku, 'Encyclopedias = expanding information & knowledge'
1009:
city). But we also have examples of very specific titles like
557:
238:
195:
26:
831:– As discussed in the section above, the current name is a
568:
On 30 August 2022, it was proposed that this article be
932:
827:
171:
413:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of
324:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of
973:did not experience shootings in 2013. Same with
675:I think "1988 Hyderabad killings" would be most
44:for general discussion of the article's subject.
1139:. This Hyderabad must be disambiguated from
905:as they participated in the discussion above.
185:
8:
1143:. The proposed will confuse and astonish. —
772:The following is a closed discussion of a
464:
375:
270:
242:
835:. "Killings" was suggested as least POV.
997:refers to several different places) and
703:
466:
377:
272:
1119:has been notified of this discussion.
1099:has been notified of this discussion.
1187:2400:ADC1:194:EA00:C52E:70FE:341:E471
989:refers to several different places),
981:refers to several different places),
935:by including word Sindh in the title.
923:IMHO Since there are more than one
7:
791:The result of the move request was:
496:This article is within the scope of
407:This article is within the scope of
318:This article is within the scope of
261:It is of interest to the following
34:for discussing improvements to the
18:Talk:1988 Hyderabad, Sindh massacre
1067:the proposed title has element of
25:
1260:Low-importance Terrorism articles
1077:1988 killings in Hyderabad, Sindh
944:1988 killings in Hyderabad, Sindh
795:1988 killings in Hyderabad, Sindh
584:1988 killings in Hyderabad, Sindh
36:1988 killings in Hyderabad, Sindh
1235:Low-importance Pakistan articles
1167:Historical accounts don't add up
1158:The discussion above is closed.
861:) 15:31, 11 September 2022 (UTC)
661:) 06:29, 29 August 2022 (UTC)
561:
489:
468:
400:
379:
305:
295:
274:
243:
199:
56:Click here to start a new topic.
940:1988 Hyderabad (Sindh) killings
536:This article has been rated as
516:Knowledge:WikiProject Terrorism
447:This article has been rated as
358:This article has been rated as
223:Content must be written from a
207:The subject of this article is
1265:WikiProject Terrorism articles
1225:Knowledge controversial topics
1153:11:32, 20 September 2022 (UTC)
1129:15:32, 11 September 2022 (UTC)
1109:15:32, 11 September 2022 (UTC)
1015:2021 Sunrise, Florida shootout
1011:2012 Aurora, Colorado shooting
891:17:39, 20 September 2022 (UTC)
823:1988 Hyderabad, Sindh massacre
817:02:06, 29 September 2022 (UTC)
804:closed by non-admin page mover
519:Template:WikiProject Terrorism
338:Knowledge:WikiProject Pakistan
1:
1255:Stub-Class Terrorism articles
1250:Low-importance Death articles
1240:WikiProject Pakistan articles
1088:13:26, 9 September 2022 (UTC)
1060:13:46, 3 September 2022 (UTC)
983:2012 College Station shooting
765:Requested move 30 August 2022
717:Economic and Political Weekly
510:and see a list of open tasks.
421:and see a list of open tasks.
341:Template:WikiProject Pakistan
332:and see a list of open tasks.
53:Put new text under old text.
1230:Stub-Class Pakistan articles
1195:13:40, 25 January 2023 (UTC)
846:03:51, 30 August 2022 (UTC)
1029:13:45, 30 August 2022 (UTC)
963:2013 South Valley homicides
957:04:46, 30 August 2022 (UTC)
917:03:51, 30 August 2022 (UTC)
872:Ceso femmuin mbolgaig mbung
691:03:46, 30 August 2022 (UTC)
671:06:29, 29 August 2022 (UTC)
643:04:43, 29 August 2022 (UTC)
619:00:40, 29 August 2022 (UTC)
427:Knowledge:WikiProject Death
217:When updating the article,
61:New to Knowledge? Welcome!
1281:
1210:17:55, 28 March 2024 (UTC)
925:Hyderabad (disambiguation)
542:project's importance scale
453:project's importance scale
430:Template:WikiProject Death
364:project's importance scale
1245:Stub-Class Death articles
535:
484:
446:
395:
357:
290:
269:
219:be bold, but not reckless
91:Be welcoming to newcomers
1160:Please do not modify it.
779:Please do not modify it.
711:Zaidi, S. Akbar (1991).
828:1988 Hyderabad killings
574:1988 Hyderabad killings
1166:
1017:. I'm fine either way.
1005:primarily refers to a
927:and the other (Indian
251:This article is rated
211:and content may be in
86:avoid personal attacks
1175:"haq parast group".
1117:WikiProject Terrorism
975:2012 Webster shooting
499:WikiProject Terrorism
225:neutral point of view
111:Neutral point of view
1097:WikiProject Pakistan
679:. I'll propose a RM.
321:WikiProject Pakistan
116:No original research
999:2003 Ennis shooting
746:The Express Tribune
1040:more in line with
897:Courtesy pings to
522:Terrorism articles
257:content assessment
97:dispute resolution
58:
1131:
1111:
893:
862:
807:
723:(20): 1295–1302.
591:
590:
556:
555:
552:
551:
548:
547:
463:
462:
459:
458:
410:WikiProject Death
374:
373:
370:
369:
344:Pakistan articles
237:
236:
194:
193:
77:Assume good faith
54:
16:(Redirected from
1272:
1114:
1094:
1056:
1049:
991:Hesston shooting
863:
847:
830:
801:
781:
757:
756:
754:
753:
738:
732:
731:
708:
639:
632:
576:. The result of
565:
564:
558:
524:
523:
520:
517:
514:
493:
486:
485:
480:
472:
465:
435:
434:
431:
428:
425:
404:
397:
396:
391:
383:
376:
346:
345:
342:
339:
336:
315:
310:
309:
308:
299:
292:
291:
286:
278:
271:
254:
248:
247:
239:
203:
202:
196:
190:
189:
175:
106:Article policies
27:
21:
1280:
1279:
1275:
1274:
1273:
1271:
1270:
1269:
1215:
1214:
1169:
1164:
1163:
1054:
1047:
1027:
987:College Station
915:
845:
826:
777:
767:
762:
761:
760:
751:
749:
740:
739:
735:
710:
709:
705:
689:
637:
630:
617:
596:
562:
521:
518:
515:
512:
511:
478:
432:
429:
426:
423:
422:
389:
343:
340:
337:
334:
333:
313:Pakistan portal
311:
306:
304:
284:
255:on Knowledge's
252:
200:
132:
127:
126:
125:
102:
72:
23:
22:
15:
12:
11:
5:
1278:
1276:
1268:
1267:
1262:
1257:
1252:
1247:
1242:
1237:
1232:
1227:
1217:
1216:
1213:
1212:
1168:
1165:
1157:
1156:
1155:
1133:
1132:
1112:
1091:
1090:
1062:
1034:
1033:
1032:
1031:
1023:
946:
936:
920:
919:
911:
841:
820:
789:
788:
774:requested move
768:
766:
763:
759:
758:
733:
702:
701:
697:
696:
695:
694:
693:
685:
651:
648:
645:
613:
607:etc for input.
595:
592:
589:
588:
578:the discussion
566:
554:
553:
550:
549:
546:
545:
538:Low-importance
534:
528:
527:
525:
494:
482:
481:
479:Low‑importance
473:
461:
460:
457:
456:
449:Low-importance
445:
439:
438:
436:
433:Death articles
419:the discussion
405:
393:
392:
390:Low‑importance
384:
372:
371:
368:
367:
360:Low-importance
356:
350:
349:
347:
330:the discussion
317:
316:
300:
288:
287:
285:Low‑importance
279:
267:
266:
260:
249:
235:
234:
204:
192:
191:
129:
128:
124:
123:
118:
113:
104:
103:
101:
100:
93:
88:
79:
73:
71:
70:
59:
50:
49:
46:
45:
39:
24:
14:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
1277:
1266:
1263:
1261:
1258:
1256:
1253:
1251:
1248:
1246:
1243:
1241:
1238:
1236:
1233:
1231:
1228:
1226:
1223:
1222:
1220:
1211:
1207:
1203:
1199:
1198:
1197:
1196:
1192:
1188:
1184:
1181:
1176:
1172:
1161:
1154:
1150:
1146:
1142:
1138:
1135:
1134:
1130:
1126:
1122:
1118:
1113:
1110:
1106:
1102:
1098:
1093:
1092:
1089:
1086:
1082:
1078:
1074:
1070:
1066:
1063:
1061:
1057:
1051:
1050:
1043:
1039:
1036:
1035:
1030:
1026:
1022:
1021:
1016:
1012:
1008:
1004:
1000:
996:
992:
988:
984:
980:
976:
972:
971:South Valleys
968:
964:
960:
959:
958:
954:
950:
947:
945:
941:
937:
934:
930:
926:
922:
921:
918:
914:
910:
909:
904:
900:
896:
895:
894:
892:
888:
884:
883:
879:
878:
873:
869:
868:
860:
856:
853:
852:
844:
840:
839:
834:
829:
824:
819:
818:
814:
810:
805:
798:
796:
787:
785:
780:
775:
770:
769:
764:
747:
743:
737:
734:
729:
726:
722:
718:
714:
707:
704:
700:
692:
688:
684:
683:
678:
674:
673:
672:
668:
664:
660:
656:
652:
649:
646:
644:
640:
634:
633:
626:
623:
622:
621:
620:
616:
612:
611:
606:
602:
593:
586:
585:
579:
575:
571:
567:
560:
559:
543:
539:
533:
530:
529:
526:
509:
505:
501:
500:
495:
492:
488:
487:
483:
477:
474:
471:
467:
454:
450:
444:
441:
440:
437:
420:
416:
412:
411:
406:
403:
399:
398:
394:
388:
385:
382:
378:
365:
361:
355:
352:
351:
348:
331:
327:
323:
322:
314:
303:
301:
298:
294:
293:
289:
283:
280:
277:
273:
268:
264:
258:
250:
246:
241:
240:
232:
228:
226:
220:
216:
214:
210:
209:controversial
205:
198:
197:
188:
184:
181:
178:
174:
170:
166:
163:
160:
157:
154:
151:
148:
145:
142:
138:
135:
134:Find sources:
131:
130:
122:
121:Verifiability
119:
117:
114:
112:
109:
108:
107:
98:
94:
92:
89:
87:
83:
80:
78:
75:
74:
68:
64:
63:Learn to edit
60:
57:
52:
51:
48:
47:
43:
37:
33:
29:
28:
19:
1177:
1173:
1170:
1159:
1136:
1080:
1064:
1045:
1037:
1018:
1006:
967:South Valley
965:even though
933:WP:PRECISION
906:
880:
875:
871:
866:
865:
850:
849:
836:
821:
792:
790:
778:
771:
750:. Retrieved
748:. 2017-05-18
745:
736:
720:
716:
706:
698:
680:
628:
608:
597:
581:
537:
497:
448:
408:
359:
319:
263:WikiProjects
222:
206:
182:
176:
168:
161:
155:
149:
143:
133:
105:
30:This is the
1121:– robertsky
1101:– robertsky
1069:WP:SURPRISE
855:– robertsky
809:– robertsky
784:move review
625:Vice regent
159:free images
42:not a forum
1219:Categories
867:Relisting.
851:Relisting.
833:WP:POVNAME
752:2021-10-14
699:References
677:WP:CONCISE
508:discussion
253:Stub-class
1145:SmokeyJoe
1141:Hyderabad
1073:Hyderabad
1044:per nom.
1007:different
938:May be →
929:Hyderabad
793:Moved to
728:0012-9976
582:Moved to
513:Terrorism
504:terrorism
476:Terrorism
231:citations
99:if needed
82:Be polite
32:talk page
1202:JezGrove
335:Pakistan
326:Pakistan
282:Pakistan
229:Include
67:get help
40:This is
38:article.
1065:comment
1042:WP:NPOV
1038:Support
995:Hesston
979:Webster
653:Thanks
540:on the
451:on the
362:on the
213:dispute
165:WP refs
153:scholar
1137:Oppose
1115:Note:
1095:Note:
1085:(talk)
1001:(when
903:Bookku
605:Bookku
259:scale.
137:Google
1071:, as
1048:Mar4d
1003:Ennis
899:Mar4d
877:mello
631:Mar4d
601:Mar4d
570:moved
424:Death
415:Death
387:Death
180:JSTOR
141:books
95:Seek
1206:talk
1191:talk
1149:talk
1125:talk
1105:talk
1055:talk
1025:talk
1013:and
953:talk
913:talk
859:talk
843:talk
813:talk
725:ISSN
687:talk
667:talk
659:talk
638:talk
615:talk
594:Name
580:was
173:FENS
147:news
84:and
942:or
882:hi!
572:to
532:Low
443:Low
354:Low
187:TWL
1221::
1208:)
1193:)
1151:)
1127:)
1107:)
1081:if
1079:,
1058:)
1020:VR
955:)
908:VR
901:,
889:)
887:投稿
874:,
870:—
864:—
848:—
838:VR
825:→
815:)
776:.
744:.
721:26
719:.
715:.
682:VR
669:)
641:)
610:VR
603:,
167:)
65:;
1204:(
1189:(
1147:(
1123:(
1103:(
1052:(
993:(
985:(
977:(
951:(
885:(
857:(
811:(
806:)
802:(
797:.
755:.
730:.
665:(
657:(
635:(
587:.
544:.
455:.
366:.
265::
227:.
215:.
183:·
177:·
169:·
162:·
156:·
150:·
144:·
139:(
69:.
20:)
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
