Knowledge

Talk:Attack on Fatima's house/Archive 1

Source 📝

133:"Umar threatened to set the house on fire unless they came out and swore allegiance to Abu Bakr. Al-zubayr came out with his sowrd drawn, but stumbled and lost it, whereupon Umar's men jumped upon him and carried him off. There is some evidence that the house of Fatima was searched(futtisha). Ali is reported to have later repeatedly said that had there been forty men with him he would have resisted. To what extent force was used in other cases must remain uncertain. In general the threat of it was probably sufficient to induce the reluctant to conform. Isolated reports about the use of force against Ali and the Banu Hashim who according to al-Zhuri, unanimously refused to swear allegiance for six months are probably to be discounted. Abu Bakr no doubt was wise enough to restrain Umar from any violence against them, well realizing that this would inevitably provoke the sense of solidarity of the majority of Ab Manaf whose acquiescence he needed. His policy was rather to isolate the Banu Hashim as far as possible. Aisha's comment that the prominent people ceased to speak to Ali until acknowledged his mistake and pledged allegiance to Abu Bakr is significant. The banu Hashim thus found themselves in a situation strangely reminiscent of the boycott that the pagan Mekkans organized against them in order to force them to withdraw their protection from Muhammad." -- 1108:علي بن أبي طالب رضي الله عنه قال : لمَّا ولد الحسن جـاء رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم فقال : أروني ابني ما سميتموه ؟ قلت : سمّيته حرباً ، قال : بل هـو حسن ، فلما ولد الحسين قال : أروني ابني ما سميتموه ؟ قلت سميته حرباً ، قال : بل هو حسين . فلما ولد الثالث جاء النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم فقال : أروني ابني ما سميتموه ؟ قلت حرباً ، قال : بل هو محسَّن ثم قال : إني سمّيتهم بأسماء ولد هارون شبّر وشُبَيْر ومشبّر Ali bin Abi talib RA said: When al Hassan was born the Prophet PBUh came and said: Show me my boy, what have you named him? I said: I called him Harb, he said: Nay He is Hassan, When al Hussein was born the Prophet PBUH said: show me my boy, what have you named him? I said: Harb, he said: Nay he is Hussein, and when the third was born the Prophet PBUH came then said: Show me my boy, what have you named him? I said: Harb, He said: Nay he is Muhassan, then He said: I have named them after the names of the children of Haroun(Aaron) they are Shibr, Shubeir, Mushabbar. source: مسند أحمد (1/98) إسناده صحيح . Musnad Ahmad 1/98, Isnad is SAHIH. 97:
point. A few weeks later, the fragile Fatima gave birth to a stillborn infant boy. Nobody was sure if the miscarriage was a result of her being knocked down by Omar or whether she was so frail that it would have happened regardless. Either way, some overture might have been warranted from Abu Bakr, or at least from Omar, but there was none. Indeed there was less than none. To add insult to the injury that had already been done her, Fatima would now lose the property she considered hers. Soon asfter her miscariage, she sent a message to Abu Bakr asking for her share of her father's state -date palm orchards in the huge oases of Khaybar and Fadak to the north of Medina. His response left her dumbfounded. The Prophet's estate belonged to the community, not to any individual, Abu Bakr replied. It was part of the Muslim charitable trust to be administered by him as Caliph.»
433: 1008: 206: 31: 107:«she never did recover from her miscariage or from the bitter argument with Abu Bakr. But perhaps most painful of all in those months after the loss of her third son was the ostracism she suffered ordered by Abu Bakr to force Ali into line. When she knew death was close she asked Ali for a clandestine burial Abu Bakr was not to be informed of her death she said. he was to be given no chance to officiate at her funeral.» 92:«Short of actually following through on his threat and killing all of Muhammad's closest family, Omar was left, as he saw it, with only one option. If Ali would not come out, then he, Omar, would have to force his way in. He took a running leap and threw his whole weight against the door, and when the latches and hinges gave and it burst open, all six feet of him came hurtling through, unable to stop as 960: 381: 157: 808:
content has been challenged in the past; their removal should be reverted. You removed five references from the first paragraph of the "Event" section, and you also removed six references, along with relevant quotations from them, later in the article. The mass removal of relevant references, combined with adding an extremely biased statement towards Abu Bakr, led me to undo your changes.
792:. also, I try to support primary source by finding to secondary sources but it is so wonderful that they are removed by you. finally, I remove the list of citation that did not use in the article and were shown in a red link while you reverted them to, so please do not revert again without convincing me. 1041:
The general non-Shi'a consensus is that Umar only threatened that if they don't come out to swear, he would burn the door. While in the article we read that they burned the house, kicked the door open, broke Farimah's ribs, killed a fetus in her womb, kicked Fatimah in stomach, struck her with either
913:
I did not attack to Abu Bakr, that is a quotation which was nominated in reliable sources. the part of the text is quotation directly from the source. according to the sources fadak is apart of this event and for this reason, it is better to mention in the article. in this way, in your opinion how is
807:
I did not revert it simply because of that one change. I reverted it because the edits that you made negatively affect the page in other ways as well. You removed a noteworthy part about Zubayr being attacked. You also removed many, many references from the page. These references are important as the
321:
These sources are all Shi'ah and this whole article needs to be rewritten in a NEUTRAL manner its straight out of a Shi'ah propaganda machine by the looks of it. This story is regarded as a myth by majority of Muslims, only a minority believe it to be true and this must be stated in the introduction.
867:
tag. but I checked them that if they had used in other section in the article, I tried to keep the sources. I did this work with the intention of improved the article and I am sure the ref-list was not used in the article and did not give a good style to the article ( for red lines), I deleted them.
299::These sources are all Shia and this whole article needs to be rewritten in a neutral manner its straight out of a Shia propaganda machine by the looks of it this story is regarded as a myth by over a BILLION Muslims while a minority believe it to be true and this must be stated in the introduction. 887:
completely biased towards Abu Bakr. It also does not summarize material on its own; rather, it just (improperly) quotes a book that exclaims extreme bias towards Abu Bakr. If you would like to discuss Fadak in the "Background" section, then we can do it without including such bias towards Abu Bakr.
96:
Some say she was only badly bruised. Others that she broke her arm as she fell. But all agree that even Omar was stunned by the sight of the Prophet's heavily pregnant daughter doubled over in pain at his feet. As Ali bent over his injured wife, Omar retreated without another word. He had made his
412:
Please re-read the whole article and change Fatimah's gender from male to female. For example, I found at many places it states Fatimah as a male : "Fatima died his husband Ali ibn Abi talib buried him at night." It should be "Fatima died, HER husband Ali ibn Abi talib buried HER at night." Also
267:
Which books "written at the time"? Besides, the article cites multiple Sunni primary and secondary sources on the events, they all only differ on what exactly happened. It seems that the only people saying that the event did not occur are wahhabis, the rest of Sunnis acknowledge the event, just
1094:
The Shias claim that after few days the Prophet(saw) died, Umar(ra) went and beat up Fatima(ra) when she was pregnant and her unborn baby who was called Muhassan died in her womb. But these fabricated stories were created by the Shias which are hard to be accepted by people who are learned and
1052:
Also note that Shahrestani has also included the opposing views (Ranging from Judaism to Jahmiyah to Shi'a) in Al-milal wa al-nihal, according to the link provided in the article and the very name of the book. That means not any piece of text in the book is necessarily perceived as real by the
886:
I left your changes in "Event" section but removed the two paragraphs you added in the "Background" section. The first paragraph is discussed in the next section; its inclusion in the "Background" section breaks the flow of the article. The second paragraph, besides being poorly written, is
928:
We could discuss the history of Fadak and its status prior to Muhammad's death, then discuss the actions of Abu Bakr and Umar without showing such bias towards them. I think that it may be better to do this without making most of this paragraph just a quotation from the book you cited.
322:
I agree with the last statement, and I do not understand why wikipedia allows something to be writen from mythical accounts and other stories, without protecting the integrity of the information, as well of the rights of the reader who is trusting in wikipedia. Shame on wikipedia.
756:
The article includes references from both Shia and Sunni sources. Some of the Sunni sources include Bukhari, Tabari, and as-Safadi (among many others). It also has a combination of primary sources, modern sources, and sources from the time period in between.
685:
The neutrality of this article has been discussed for several years and disputed what changes have I made i resisted from revert you. I have not reverted your blanket edit yet so i do not need to justify any change since I have not made any si far since your
1101:
Doesn’t this seem to be strange that an unborn child has a name before he was born and that his parents even knew he was a boy? Let us show you the reality that from where and why he got his name. And was it before his birth or was it after it.
188:
The entire section that covers the Sunnis view is original research based on primary sources. It has to be entirely deleted probably with only a short statement saying that Sunnis reject the entire incident.
1042:
a whip or a sword or both, then they went in and dragged Ali forcibly out of his house, possibly with a rope tied around his neck (and strangely they were not enemies enough to kill them two and then left).
1135:
this is wikipedia not the personal blog, so all users have to collect any opinion which are supported by RS about the special event. Knowledge is not the court to judge which set is right or not.
91: 1095:
unbiased. That is why not only the scholars of Ahlesunnah declared these stories to be absurd fabrications, but even some of the esteemed and knowledgeable Shia scholars held the similar view.
357:
Beyond doubt it's Shea made up story and far from reality. Umar can not attack the house of Fatima in any way, burning her is out of questions . It's just a propaganda. It must be removed
94:
he slammed full force into the person who happened to be on the other side of the door at that moment. That person was Fatima, several months pregnant with the Prophet's third grandson.
612:
I am the one using the talk page actually and some unrelated moron removes the dispute tags they at least need to stay I do not care much for the pre edit war copy of the articke.
1053:
author, and therefore it only represents a Sunni's description of a Shi'a belief not his record of the matter as misrepresented in the article. That part needs to be deleted too.
1111:
Of course al Muhassan bin Ali RA died as little baby. source:التبيين في أنساب القرشيين لابن قدامة المقدسي 133 Al Tabyeen fi ansab al Qurashiyeen for Ibn Qudamah al Maqdisi p133.
1038:
There has been a wide debate over the issue (as a staple of Shi'a-Sunni dialogue) and non-Shi'a sources almost entirely deny that any corporal clashes happened.
467:
It has to be noted that Tabari is simply a collection of BOTH SHIA AND SUNNI narrations in his historical book so how can this be referred to a Sunni source?
849:
Third: about five removed sources in Event, Not only I did not remove any sources but also I added reliable sources to support primary references such as
1105:
We only know of this “Muhassan bin Ali” through the narration of Hani bin Hani who narrates it directly from Ali bin Abi talib RA with a Sahih Chain:
142: 1015: 829:
I am going to explain by detail about my edits, but it would be better that you presented the link of the edit which is wrong (in your opinion)
440: 329: 701: 627: 521: 482: 314: 284: 190: 245:
Under event, Please remove all the paragraphs starting after 2nd paragraph or else add “Shī’a View” as a sub topic after 2nd paragraph
17: 1014:
it's not clear what changes you want to be made. Please mention the specific changes in a "change X to Y" format and provide a
785: 565: 268:
differ on how it went. The section has to be rewritten as it is misleading. More Sunni sources on the events can be found here
47: 506::::Tabari has collected historical texts from BOTH Sunni and Shia accounts but is paraded as sunni clear manipulation. 264:"According to Sunni books of Hadith and books of history written at the time however, this entire story did not occur" 789: 720: 646: 599: 544: 495: 1073: 934: 892: 813: 762: 38: 863:
Forth: for six sources, It is evident to misunderstand. I deleted the sources that were ref-list and they had the
212:
it's not clear what changes you want to be made. Please mention the specific changes in a "change X to Y" format.
664: 362: 561: 970: 741:
In it's current version, the article presents the Shia POV as fact and does not present the Sunni view at all.
391: 333: 288: 167: 1118: 194: 966: 387: 348: 250: 163: 716: 642: 607: 595: 540: 491: 358: 229: 835:
First: about Zubar, I didn't remember that I “removed a noteworthy part about Zubayr being attacked” and
1130: 1114: 1069: 996: 930: 908: 888: 824: 809: 779: 758: 344: 246: 421: 1058: 691: 680: 660: 638: 617: 511: 472: 451: 325: 304: 280: 1144: 1122: 1077: 1062: 1027: 1000: 938: 923: 896: 881: 817: 801: 766: 750: 724: 695: 668: 650: 621: 585: 569: 548: 515: 499: 476: 455: 425: 366: 352: 337: 308: 292: 254: 239: 198: 119: 1023: 992: 746: 138: 115: 417: 659:, You were bold and you were reverted, now you need to gain consensus for your proposed changes. 79:
The book is a Pen-USA finalist and has been praised by many including Professor Wilfred Madelung
1140: 1049:
thing is represented as factual, which is obviously in contrast with Knowledge's NPOV policy.
213: 1068:
Thanks for pointing about the part about Shahrastani; I removed the mis-quote from the page.
126: 1098:
The reality behind the story of the unborn baby who supposedly died in his mother’s womb.
1054: 919: 877: 797: 687: 613: 581: 507: 468: 300: 71: 1019: 864: 742: 134: 111: 656: 591: 490:
What do you mean Shia and Sunni narrations? What makes a narration one or the other?
1136: 536: 444: 102: 86: 83: 234: 46:
If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the
991:
Most of this page is false and has no basis in Sunni Or Majority Shia Scholars
915: 873: 793: 275: 272: 269: 784:
you committed mass-edit at once if the material about Abu Bakr break the
413:
correct the grammatical errors such as adding commas where necessary.
70:
After the Prophet: The Epic Story of the Shia-Sunni Split in Islam By
590:
You to seem to be on the verge of starting an edit war. Please read
78: 954: 375: 151: 25: 872:
look at the article, does it have an appropriate appearance?
124: 869: 858: 854: 850: 843: 836: 1088:
Did Sheikein(Abubakr and Umar) ever attack Ahlebayt?
1091:
In The Name of Allah, The Beneficent, The Merciful.
1084:
Did Sheikein(Abubakr and Umar) ever attack Ahlebayt?
560:
Do you have a source which says it is Sunni source?
715:The whole point of BRD is to justify any changes. 343:Exactly, the whole article should be rewritten. 129:'s book (The Succession to Muhammad, pp. 43-44) 951:Semi-protected edit request on 8 December 2018 788:, you can put the appropriate tag instead of 443:that support the change you want to be made. 8: 842:Second: about Abu Bakr, why did you delete 372:Semi-protected edit request on 23 July 2017 148:Semi-protected edit request on 5 March 2016 641:who restored to the pre edit war version. 323: 278: 44:Do not edit the contents of this page. 7: 24: 18:Talk:Attack on Fatima's house 1006: 958: 431: 379: 204: 155: 29: 1034:Representing opinions as facts 338:05:19, 24 September 2018 (UTC) 1: 1078:01:23, 12 February 2019 (UTC) 767:01:41, 2 September 2018 (UTC) 602:) 13:16, 1 August 2017 (UTC) 570:14:32, 12 February 2019 (UTC) 367:18:53, 25 February 2019 (UTC) 1145:08:47, 24 January 2019 (UTC) 1123:15:59, 21 January 2019 (UTC) 1063:17:11, 11 January 2019 (UTC) 1028:19:10, 8 December 2018 (UTC) 1001:18:17, 8 December 2018 (UTC) 939:00:06, 17 October 2018 (UTC) 924:07:15, 15 October 2018 (UTC) 897:15:35, 14 October 2018 (UTC) 882:07:51, 14 October 2018 (UTC) 818:13:56, 10 October 2018 (UTC) 802:12:20, 10 October 2018 (UTC) 353:20:54, 6 November 2018 (UTC) 255:20:59, 6 November 2018 (UTC) 143:02:34, 31 October 2013 (UTC) 120:16:36, 17 October 2013 (UTC) 985:to reactivate your request. 973:has been answered. Set the 751:00:35, 22 August 2018 (UTC) 406:to reactivate your request. 394:has been answered. Set the 182:to reactivate your request. 170:has been answered. Set the 1161: 914:the text can be moderated? 725:18:36, 1 August 2017 (UTC) 696:17:42, 1 August 2017 (UTC) 669:17:33, 1 August 2017 (UTC) 651:17:24, 1 August 2017 (UTC) 622:17:01, 1 August 2017 (UTC) 594:before any further edits. 549:17:24, 1 August 2017 (UTC) 516:16:46, 1 August 2017 (UTC) 500:13:12, 1 August 2017 (UTC) 477:13:01, 1 August 2017 (UTC) 293:16:53, 15 March 2016 (UTC) 456:14:41, 23 July 2017 (UTC) 426:13:31, 23 July 2017 (UTC) 309:09:57, 30 July 2017 (UTC) 240:04:19, 6 March 2016 (UTC) 199:21:35, 5 March 2016 (UTC) 971:Umar at Fatimah's house 702:community banned editor 628:community banned editor 522:community banned editor 483:community banned editor 392:Umar at Fatimah's house 315:community banned editor 168:Umar at Fatimah's house 865:list-defined reference 868:now that you removed 786:Neutral point of view 700:CU blocked sock of a 626:CU blocked sock of a 562:Singnora and Monsieur 520:CU blocked sock of a 481:CU blocked sock of a 313:CU blocked sock of a 42:of past discussions. 839:confirmed my words. 539:saying that though? 1018:if appropriate. – 989: 988: 844:this sourced edit 717:Emir of Knowledge 705: 643:Emir of Knowledge 631: 608:Emir of Knowledge 596:Emir of Knowledge 541:Emir of Knowledge 525: 492:Emir of Knowledge 486: 410: 409: 340: 328:comment added by 318: 295: 283:comment added by 238: 186: 185: 67: 66: 54: 53: 48:current talk page 1152: 1134: 1070:Snowsky Mountain 1010: 1009: 993:Omar Ali Ibrahim 980: 976: 962: 961: 955: 931:Snowsky Mountain 912: 909:Snowsky Mountain 889:Snowsky Mountain 828: 825:Snowsky Mountain 810:Snowsky Mountain 783: 780:Snowsky Mountain 759:Snowsky Mountain 699: 684: 655:Read the essay 625: 611: 589: 519: 480: 449: 441:reliable sources 435: 434: 401: 397: 383: 382: 376: 312: 232: 226: 223: 220: 217: 208: 207: 177: 173: 159: 158: 152: 127:Wilferd Madelung 63: 56: 55: 33: 32: 26: 1160: 1159: 1155: 1154: 1153: 1151: 1150: 1149: 1128: 1125: 1086: 1036: 1016:reliable source 1007: 978: 974: 959: 953: 906: 822: 777: 775: 773:avoid to riverd 739: 681:Darkness Shines 678: 661:Darkness Shines 639:Darkness Shines 605: 579: 577: 464: 448:(Jalen D. Folf) 447: 439:please provide 432: 399: 395: 380: 374: 359:Murtaza Khattak 330:190.156.237.246 262: 224: 221: 218: 215: 205: 175: 171: 156: 150: 131: 76: 72:Lesley Hazleton 59: 30: 22: 21: 20: 12: 11: 5: 1158: 1156: 1148: 1147: 1113: 1085: 1082: 1081: 1080: 1035: 1032: 1031: 1030: 987: 986: 963: 952: 949: 948: 947: 946: 945: 944: 943: 942: 941: 833: 832: 831: 830: 774: 771: 770: 769: 738: 735: 734: 733: 732: 731: 730: 729: 728: 727: 674: 673: 672: 671: 653: 576: 573: 558: 557: 556: 555: 554: 553: 552: 551: 535:Do you have a 503: 502: 463: 460: 459: 458: 408: 407: 384: 373: 370: 285:203.220.72.109 261: 258: 243: 242: 184: 183: 160: 149: 146: 130: 123: 101: 75: 68: 65: 64: 52: 51: 34: 23: 15: 14: 13: 10: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 1157: 1146: 1142: 1138: 1132: 1131:Meangristicsh 1127: 1126: 1124: 1120: 1116: 1115:Meangristicsh 1112: 1109: 1106: 1103: 1099: 1096: 1092: 1089: 1083: 1079: 1075: 1071: 1067: 1066: 1065: 1064: 1060: 1056: 1050: 1048: 1043: 1039: 1033: 1029: 1025: 1021: 1017: 1013: 1005: 1004: 1003: 1002: 998: 994: 984: 981:parameter to 972: 968: 964: 957: 956: 950: 940: 936: 932: 927: 926: 925: 921: 917: 910: 905: 904: 903: 902: 901: 900: 899: 898: 894: 890: 884: 883: 879: 875: 871: 866: 861: 860: 856: 852: 847: 845: 840: 838: 826: 821: 820: 819: 815: 811: 806: 805: 804: 803: 799: 795: 791: 787: 781: 772: 768: 764: 760: 755: 754: 753: 752: 748: 744: 736: 726: 722: 718: 714: 713: 712: 711: 710: 709: 708: 707: 706: 703: 698: 697: 693: 689: 682: 670: 666: 662: 658: 654: 652: 648: 644: 640: 636: 635: 634: 633: 632: 629: 624: 623: 619: 615: 609: 601: 597: 593: 587: 583: 574: 572: 571: 567: 563: 550: 546: 542: 538: 534: 533: 532: 531: 530: 529: 528: 527: 526: 523: 518: 517: 513: 509: 501: 497: 493: 489: 488: 487: 484: 479: 478: 474: 470: 461: 457: 453: 446: 442: 438: 430: 429: 428: 427: 423: 419: 414: 405: 402:parameter to 393: 389: 385: 378: 377: 371: 369: 368: 364: 360: 355: 354: 350: 346: 345:Indiewiki0001 341: 339: 335: 331: 327: 319: 316: 311: 310: 306: 302: 296: 294: 290: 286: 282: 276: 273: 270: 265: 259: 257: 256: 252: 248: 247:Indiewiki0001 241: 236: 231: 228: 227: 211: 203: 202: 201: 200: 196: 192: 191:5.232.154.170 181: 178:parameter to 169: 165: 161: 154: 153: 147: 145: 144: 140: 136: 128: 122: 121: 117: 113: 108: 105: 104: 99: 98: 95: 89: 88: 85: 81: 80: 73: 69: 62: 58: 57: 49: 45: 41: 40: 35: 28: 27: 19: 1110: 1107: 1104: 1100: 1097: 1093: 1090: 1087: 1051: 1046: 1044: 1040: 1037: 1011: 990: 982: 967:edit request 885: 862: 848: 841: 834: 776: 740: 676: 675: 603: 578: 575:Edit warring 559: 505: 504: 466: 465: 436: 415: 411: 403: 388:edit request 356: 342: 324:— Preceding 320: 298: 297: 279:— Preceding 266: 263: 260:"Sunni view" 244: 214: 209: 187: 179: 164:edit request 132: 109: 106: 100: 93: 90: 82: 77: 60: 43: 37: 274:, and here 74:, pp. 71-73 36:This is an 1055:NetBSDuser 975:|answered= 688:Ectomorfer 614:Ectomorfer 582:Ectomorfer 508:Ectomorfer 469:Ectomorfer 416:Thank you 396:|answered= 301:Ectomorfer 172:|answered= 1020:Jonesey95 1012:Not done: 837:this edit 743:Edward321 586:Airtiza14 462:Al-Tabari 437:Not done: 233:Please {{ 210:Not done: 135:Kazemita1 112:Kazemita1 61:Archive 1 1045:And the 790:removing 326:unsigned 281:unsigned 1137:Saff V. 870:my edit 637:It was 445:jd22292 418:Rx anon 271:, here 103:page 73 87:page 72 84:page 71 39:archive 1047:entire 657:WP:BRD 592:WP:BRD 230:(talk) 979:|ans= 965:This 916:M1nhm 874:M1nhm 794:M1nhm 686:edit. 537:WP:RS 400:|ans= 386:This 176:|ans= 162:This 125:from 16:< 1141:talk 1119:talk 1074:talk 1059:talk 1024:talk 997:talk 935:talk 920:talk 893:talk 878:talk 814:talk 798:talk 763:talk 747:talk 737:NPOV 721:talk 692:talk 665:talk 647:talk 618:talk 600:talk 584:and 566:talk 545:talk 512:talk 496:talk 473:talk 452:talk 422:talk 363:talk 349:talk 334:talk 305:talk 289:talk 251:talk 195:talk 139:talk 116:talk 977:or 969:to 677:::: 398:or 390:to 277:. 225:Fir 222:een 219:rgr 216:Eve 174:or 166:to 1143:) 1121:) 1076:) 1061:) 1026:) 999:) 983:no 937:) 922:) 895:) 880:) 853:, 846:? 816:) 800:) 765:) 749:) 723:) 694:) 667:) 649:) 620:) 568:) 547:) 514:) 498:) 475:) 454:) 424:) 404:no 365:) 351:) 336:) 307:) 291:) 253:) 237:}} 235:re 197:) 180:no 141:) 118:) 110:-- 1139:( 1133:: 1129:@ 1117:( 1072:( 1057:( 1022:( 995:( 933:( 918:( 911:: 907:@ 891:( 876:( 859:3 857:, 855:2 851:1 827:: 823:@ 812:( 796:( 782:: 778:@ 761:( 745:( 719:( 704:. 690:( 683:: 679:@ 663:( 645:( 630:. 616:( 610:: 606:@ 604:: 598:( 588:: 580:@ 564:( 543:( 524:. 510:( 494:( 485:. 471:( 450:( 420:( 361:( 347:( 332:( 317:. 303:( 287:( 249:( 193:( 137:( 114:( 50:.

Index

Talk:Attack on Fatima's house
archive
current talk page
Archive 1
Lesley Hazleton
The book is a Pen-USA finalist and has been praised by many including Professor Wilfred Madelung
page 71
page 72
«Short of actually following through on his threat and killing all of Muhammad's closest family, Omar was left, as he saw it, with only one option. If Ali would not come out, then he, Omar, would have to force his way in. He took a running leap and threw his whole weight against the door, and when the latches and hinges gave and it burst open, all six feet of him came hurtling through, unable to stop as he slammed full force into the person who happened to be on the other side of the door at that moment. That person was Fatima, several months pregnant with the Prophet's third grandson. Some say she was only badly bruised. Others that she broke her arm as she fell. But all agree that even Omar was stunned by the sight of the Prophet's heavily pregnant daughter doubled over in pain at his feet. As Ali bent over his injured wife, Omar retreated without another word. He had made his point. A few weeks later, the fragile Fatima gave birth to a stillborn infant boy. Nobody was sure if the miscarriage was a result of her being knocked down by Omar or whether she was so frail that it would have happened regardless. Either way, some overture might have been warranted from Abu Bakr, or at least from Omar, but there was none. Indeed there was less than none. To add insult to the injury that had already been done her, Fatima would now lose the property she considered hers. Soon asfter her miscariage, she sent a message to Abu Bakr asking for her share of her father's state -date palm orchards in the huge oases of Khaybar and Fadak to the north of Medina. His response left her dumbfounded. The Prophet's estate belonged to the community, not to any individual, Abu Bakr replied. It was part of the Muslim charitable trust to be administered by him as Caliph.»
page 73
Kazemita1
talk
16:36, 17 October 2013 (UTC)
Wilferd Madelung
Kazemita1
talk
02:34, 31 October 2013 (UTC)
edit request
Umar at Fatimah's house
5.232.154.170
talk
21:35, 5 March 2016 (UTC)
EvergreenFir
(talk)
re
04:19, 6 March 2016 (UTC)
Indiewiki0001
talk
20:59, 6 November 2018 (UTC)

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.