Knowledge

Talk:Factorial/GA2

Source 📝

573: 547: 513: 460: 437: 415: 394: 358: 337: 308: 287: 228: 206: 42: 906:
include the not in Z as stated in other sources? I think it might be possible also to state the line before slightly more clearly took me a short second to understand. Perhaps something like "This definition can be extended to the rest of the complex plane by solving Euler's reflection formula (EQN).
1048:
The code in "Computation" section, to my mind, could be formatted better - currently it's in a bi template, I see no reason for it not to be a code block. Granted - it's pseudo code - but to my eyes it's strange to have it in text style like that. Makes article flow less well
588:
Overall this article seems to pass the GA criteria to me without too much bother. Have left some suggestions below for mild improvements but I don't think any preclude this from GA status. This is significantly improved from the last nomination - well done all!
998: 907:
However this fails to assign a value to the gamma function: the reflection formula only holds for non-integer values of z to avoid division by 0" though I recognise that's getting very clunky
739: 328:, except for plot summaries and that which summarizes cited content elsewhere in the article, must be cited no later than the end of the paragraph (or line if the content is not in prose). 663: 325: 866: 815: 777: 1053:
only permits monospaced typewriter text. That would make the variables in the code inconsistent in appearance with the same variables in the article text, undesirable. —
886:
Yeah - just feel a computer science user would recognise that better, and absolutely right you don't wanna get into omega/big o/theta etc... will continue review today
215: 913: 253: 80: 70: 530: 47: 257: 249: 241: 263:
Well set out, appropriate sections, lead is very clear covering main topics at an introductory level. Layout is good, guiding user well
560: 126: 479:
Article seems stable - good discussion about improvements and article development in talk page does not seem overly contentious.
245: 52: 447: 183: 122: 75: 367: 346: 156: 522: 107: 1026: 534: 317: 99: 671: 321: 237: 602: 1058: 1037: 1010: 873: 1022: 526: 424: 272: 473: 403: 820: 782: 371: 1054: 1033: 1006: 869: 167: 903: 891: 556: 150: 993:{\displaystyle \Gamma (z)\Gamma (1-z)={\frac {\pi }{\sin \pi z}},\qquad z\not \in \mathbb {Z} .} 744: 295:. it contains a list of all references (sources of information), presented in accordance with 499: 495: 503: 170:
has put in a lot of work to bring this up to standard (thanks!), article does indeed seem
451:: it represents viewpoints fairly and without editorial bias, giving due weight to each. 296: 115: 17: 887: 146: 566:
Properties section is enhanced with use of graphs - appropriate and well captioned
92: 423:. it stays focused on the topic without going into unnecessary detail (see 599:
In Applicatios (computer science) might it be worth explicitly mentioning
472:: it does not change significantly from day to day because of an ongoing 1062: 1041: 1014: 895: 877: 160: 817:
but I don't want to take the space here to explain Omega and anyway
166:
Taking this on as part of the January Drive. Previous reviewer
430:
Good level of detail - I think pretty well pitched throughout
134: 103: 916: 823: 785: 747: 674: 605: 779:is incorrect; if written in that form it should be 992: 860: 809: 771: 733: 657: 216:understandable to an appropriately broad audience 540:Images all appropriately licensed from commons. 665:given that form would be more commonly known 8: 741:(but because this is a lower bound, writing 734:{\displaystyle \log _{2}n!=n\log _{2}n-O(n)} 658:{\displaystyle O(\log _{2}n)\in O(n\log n)} 30: 983: 982: 950: 915: 831: 822: 784: 746: 704: 679: 673: 616: 604: 176: 61: 33: 7: 218:; spelling and grammar are correct. 214:. the prose is clear, concise, and 1029:over ... degree" could be clearer 929: 917: 786: 24: 861:{\displaystyle n\log _{2}n-O(n)} 810:{\displaystyle \Omega (n\log n)} 571: 545: 511: 458: 435: 413: 392: 356: 335: 306: 285: 226: 204: 595:Other comments / improvements: 944: 932: 926: 920: 855: 849: 804: 789: 766: 751: 728: 722: 652: 637: 628: 609: 326:could reasonably be challenged 1: 974: 531:valid non-free use rationales 572: 546: 512: 459: 436: 414: 393: 357: 336: 307: 286: 227: 205: 1063:18:54, 5 January 2022 (UTC) 1042:18:54, 5 January 2022 (UTC) 1015:18:54, 5 January 2022 (UTC) 896:10:12, 5 January 2022 (UTC) 878:18:29, 4 January 2022 (UTC) 161:17:48, 4 January 2022 (UTC) 1081: 904:Euler's reflection formula 772:{\displaystyle O(n\log n)} 297:the layout style guideline 483: 380: 267: 192: 182: 1052:<syntaxhighlight: --> 902:Should the equation for 179: 1023:greatest common divisor 559:to the topic, and have 236:. it complies with the 221:Well written and clear 994: 862: 811: 773: 735: 659: 995: 863: 812: 774: 736: 660: 385:Broad in its coverage 1027:primitive polynomial 914: 868:is more accurate). — 821: 783: 745: 672: 603: 476:or content dispute. 368:copyright violations 347:no original research 278:no original research 1025:of the values of a 402:. it addresses the 324:. All content that 990: 975: 858: 807: 769: 731: 655: 583:Overall assessment 527:copyright statuses 490:, if possible, by 258:list incorporation 969: 593: 592: 561:suitable captions 533:are provided for 366:. it contains no 89: 88: 1072: 999: 997: 996: 991: 986: 970: 968: 951: 867: 865: 864: 859: 836: 835: 816: 814: 813: 808: 778: 776: 775: 770: 740: 738: 737: 732: 709: 708: 684: 683: 664: 662: 661: 656: 621: 620: 575: 574: 549: 548: 535:non-free content 515: 514: 462: 461: 439: 438: 417: 416: 396: 395: 360: 359: 339: 338: 318:reliable sources 310: 309: 289: 288: 230: 229: 208: 207: 177: 139: 130: 111: 43:Copyvio detector 31: 1080: 1079: 1075: 1074: 1073: 1071: 1070: 1069: 955: 912: 911: 827: 819: 818: 781: 780: 743: 742: 700: 675: 670: 669: 612: 601: 600: 240:guidelines for 238:Manual of Style 188:Review Comment 120: 97: 91: 85: 57: 29: 22: 21: 20: 12: 11: 5: 1078: 1076: 1068: 1067: 1066: 1065: 1055:David Eppstein 1046: 1045: 1044: 1034:David Eppstein 1021:The line "The 1019: 1018: 1017: 1007:David Eppstein 989: 985: 981: 978: 973: 967: 964: 961: 958: 954: 949: 946: 943: 940: 937: 934: 931: 928: 925: 922: 919: 909: 908: 899: 898: 883: 882: 881: 880: 870:David Eppstein 857: 854: 851: 848: 845: 842: 839: 834: 830: 826: 806: 803: 800: 797: 794: 791: 788: 768: 765: 762: 759: 756: 753: 750: 730: 727: 724: 721: 718: 715: 712: 707: 703: 699: 696: 693: 690: 687: 682: 678: 654: 651: 648: 645: 642: 639: 636: 633: 630: 627: 624: 619: 615: 611: 608: 591: 590: 586: 576: 568: 567: 564: 550: 542: 541: 538: 516: 508: 507: 481: 480: 477: 463: 455: 454: 452: 440: 432: 431: 428: 418: 410: 409: 407: 406:of the topic. 397: 389: 388: 378: 377: 375: 361: 353: 352: 350: 345:. it contains 340: 332: 331: 329: 311: 303: 302: 300: 290: 282: 281: 265: 264: 261: 250:words to watch 231: 223: 222: 219: 209: 201: 200: 190: 189: 186: 181: 168:David Eppstein 165: 140: 87: 86: 84: 83: 78: 73: 67: 64: 63: 59: 58: 56: 55: 53:External links 50: 45: 39: 36: 35: 28: 25: 23: 18:Talk:Factorial 15: 14: 13: 10: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 1077: 1064: 1060: 1056: 1051: 1050: 1047: 1043: 1039: 1035: 1031: 1030: 1028: 1024: 1020: 1016: 1012: 1008: 1004: 1003: 1002: 1001: 1000: 987: 979: 976: 971: 965: 962: 959: 956: 952: 947: 941: 938: 935: 923: 905: 901: 900: 897: 893: 889: 885: 884: 879: 875: 871: 852: 846: 843: 840: 837: 832: 828: 824: 801: 798: 795: 792: 763: 760: 757: 754: 748: 725: 719: 716: 713: 710: 705: 701: 697: 694: 691: 688: 685: 680: 676: 668:Ok, expanded 667: 666: 649: 646: 643: 640: 634: 631: 625: 622: 617: 613: 606: 598: 597: 596: 587: 584: 580: 577: 570: 569: 565: 562: 558: 554: 551: 544: 543: 539: 536: 532: 528: 524: 520: 517: 510: 509: 505: 501: 497: 493: 489: 486: 482: 478: 475: 471: 467: 464: 457: 456: 453: 450: 449: 444: 441: 434: 433: 429: 426: 425:summary style 422: 419: 412: 411: 408: 405: 401: 398: 391: 390: 386: 383: 379: 376: 373: 369: 365: 362: 355: 354: 351: 348: 344: 341: 334: 333: 330: 327: 323: 319: 315: 312: 305: 304: 301: 298: 294: 291: 284: 283: 279: 275: 274: 270: 266: 262: 259: 255: 251: 247: 243: 242:lead sections 239: 235: 232: 225: 224: 220: 217: 213: 210: 203: 202: 198: 195: 191: 187: 185: 178: 175: 173: 169: 163: 162: 158: 155: 152: 148: 145: 141: 138: 137: 133: 128: 124: 119: 118: 114: 109: 105: 101: 96: 95: 82: 79: 77: 74: 72: 69: 68: 66: 65: 60: 54: 51: 49: 46: 44: 41: 40: 38: 37: 32: 26: 19: 910: 594: 582: 578: 555:. media are 552: 521:. media are 518: 491: 487: 484: 469: 465: 446: 442: 420: 404:main aspects 399: 384: 381: 363: 342: 322:cited inline 313: 292: 277: 271: 268: 233: 211: 197:Well-written 196: 193: 171: 164: 153: 143: 142: 135: 131: 117:Article talk 116: 112: 93: 90: 81:Instructions 1032:Reworded. — 1005:Reworded. — 525:with their 488:Illustrated 104:visual edit 372:plagiarism 273:Verifiable 174:improved! 48:Authorship 34:GA toolbox 184:Attribute 144:Reviewer: 71:Templates 62:Reviewing 27:GA Review 888:Vogon101 557:relevant 494:such as 474:edit war 157:contribs 147:Vogon101 76:Criteria 448:Neutral 254:fiction 127:history 108:history 94:Article 529:, and 523:tagged 496:images 470:Stable 256:, and 246:layout 504:audio 502:, or 500:video 492:media 276:with 180:Rate 136:Watch 16:< 1059:talk 1038:talk 1011:talk 892:talk 874:talk 320:are 172:much 151:talk 123:edit 100:edit 957:sin 829:log 796:log 758:log 702:log 677:log 644:log 614:log 427:). 370:or 1061:) 1040:) 1013:) 963:π 960:⁡ 953:π 939:− 930:Γ 918:Γ 894:) 876:) 844:− 838:⁡ 799:⁡ 787:Ω 761:⁡ 717:− 711:⁡ 686:⁡ 647:⁡ 632:∈ 623:⁡ 585:. 581:. 563:. 553:6b 537:. 519:6a 506:: 498:, 485:6. 468:. 445:. 421:3b 400:3a 387:: 382:3. 374:. 364:2d 349:. 343:2c 316:. 314:2b 299:. 293:2a 280:: 269:2. 260:. 252:, 248:, 244:, 234:1b 212:1a 199:: 194:1. 159:) 125:| 106:| 102:| 1057:( 1036:( 1009:( 988:. 984:Z 980:∉ 977:z 972:, 966:z 948:= 945:) 942:z 936:1 933:( 927:) 924:z 921:( 890:( 872:( 856:) 853:n 850:( 847:O 841:n 833:2 825:n 805:) 802:n 793:n 790:( 767:) 764:n 755:n 752:( 749:O 729:) 726:n 723:( 720:O 714:n 706:2 698:n 695:= 692:! 689:n 681:2 653:) 650:n 641:n 638:( 635:O 629:) 626:n 618:2 610:( 607:O 579:7 466:5 443:4 154:· 149:( 132:· 129:) 121:( 113:· 110:) 98:(

Index

Talk:Factorial
Copyvio detector
Authorship
External links
Templates
Criteria
Instructions
Article
edit
visual edit
history
Article talk
edit
history
Watch
Vogon101
talk
contribs
17:48, 4 January 2022 (UTC)
David Eppstein
Attribute
understandable to an appropriately broad audience
Manual of Style
lead sections
layout
words to watch
fiction
list incorporation
Verifiable
the layout style guideline

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.