22:
749:– in its current state, the lead of the article states that it is a list of islands of the Republic of Korea (i.e. South Korea). It'd either need to be significantly expanded to include North Korean islands, or moved to a more descriptive title. (The article itself also needs some serious attention, as right now it doesn't really discuss context or geographic locations; it's just a bunch of (mostly) redlinks.) --
149:
131:
233:
215:
159:
71:
53:
894:
Any reason in particular why Korea lists should be treated differently? While I can sort of see the reason for having combined lists of rivers and animals (since North and South Korea are continuous geographically part of the same peninsula), I'm not sure that extends to islands. (If islands were to
959:
There is nothing stopping us from creating a list of islands of the Yellow Sea. Such a list would be valuable in addition to the country-specific lists and the other region lists. What I am arguing is that there is no reason to get rid of the general Korea list just because it isn't well-developed
917:
I'm not suggesting that Korean lists should be treated differently than other lists, but rather the same as other lists. To get rid of the region lists in exclusive favour of the country sublists is the opposite of common practice on
Knowledge (XXG). Consider, for example,
863:
The region of Korea as a whole is used as the primary starting point for most lists rather than individual lists for North and South Korea, which are generally added if there is additional information that would bloat the main list. Consider, for example,
492:
It would be a disservice to our readers to remove encyclopedic information from the article space. Surely maintaining a general Korea list and creating a new South Korea list would be preferable to a move that decreases access to available information.
776:
North Korean content, I argue that it would still be better to have two articles, one for each country. However, if others disagree and such content is added before the closure of this discussion, please disregard my support for a move. —
409:
This article is not exclusively about South Korean islands. "Hwanghaenam-do", the last section before the "see also" section, is a North Korean province (it borders Yellow Sea). No other North Korean provinces are listed here.
944:
Fair point, but that still doesn't address the fact that the most natural geographical groupings of these islands would instead be Yellow Sea / Sea of Japan. This list currently seems closer to a country list to me.
520:, can people from South Korea freely visit North Korean islands. If not and if there's not a profound geological reason for keeping association between islands, I'd support the move.
1017:
923:
1022:
294:
is an impossible name in Korean, though it does sound good! I don't have decent enough maps of the Geoje area, so could anyone who does correct this please?
845:
stub, if loss of information is a concern, but there doesn't seem to be a convincing argument in support of listing the two countries' islands together. --
637:
Even if we have separate articles for North Korean and South Korean islands, there should be a parent article for Korea in general. Consider, for example,
89:
460:
As has already been stated, there are already several North Korean islands listed here. They would have to be removed if this article's title changed.
363:
1042:
1037:
474:
Yes they would. The grand total of three red links in the list that are islands of North Korea can be put on this talk page for future use.
181:
1047:
838:
572:
439:
321:
Subsequent comments should be made in a new section on the talk page. Editors desiring to contest the closing decision should consider a
1052:
1027:
698:
I agree. However, the mammals articles contain a lot of duplicate info. Instead, how about what existed from 2005–2007: a DAB page at
253:
93:
1032:
575:
for inspiration or assistance). This article has been around for nearly 10 years with nothing on North Korean islands added yet.
442:
for inspiration or assistance). This article has been around for nearly 10 years with nothing on North Korean islands added yet.
557:- If there isn't enough coverage of North Korean islands, the appropriate response is to add more of these islands to the list.
172:
136:
927:
374:
33:
842:
646:
642:
353:
97:
960:
yet or because we want a list specific to South Korea. We can have both, and we serve our readers better when we have both.
249:
245:
240:
220:
78:
58:
900:
360:
896:
312:
382:
720:
A disambiguation page is not appropriate in this case; disambiguation pages are not substitutes for parent articles.
919:
873:
699:
638:
349:
999:
322:
39:
865:
357:
21:
877:
869:
378:
769:
540:
Per WilyD. (Gregkaye: S.Korean visiting N.Korean territory is a good reason for jail for lots of years.)
922:, which is a general list for the region with sublists for individual countries. Other examples include
180:
on
Knowledge (XXG). If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join
398:, which also borders North Korea. Are you sure none of them are in North Korean territorial waters?
813:
778:
705:
669:
578:
477:
445:
950:
908:
850:
620:
524:
339:
754:
841:, and there aren't other pages listing islands by peninsula. By all means split and create a
965:
935:
885:
801:
725:
689:
654:
598:
562:
498:
465:
544:
428:
989:
616:
If S Koreans can't go to N Korean islands then this is a good reason to split content.
772:
but an article's title should accurately reflect its contents. If someone wants to add
684:
That such was the case before does not suggest that such should not be the case again.
295:
164:
1011:
946:
904:
846:
617:
521:
411:
335:
969:
954:
939:
912:
889:
854:
822:
805:
796:
Then are we to simply lose the information contained in the
Hwanghaenam-do section?
787:
758:
729:
714:
693:
678:
658:
628:
602:
587:
566:
549:
532:
502:
486:
469:
454:
433:
414:
404:
386:
366:
343:
298:
750:
399:
961:
931:
881:
797:
721:
685:
650:
594:
558:
494:
461:
148:
130:
998:
Subsequent comments should be made in a new section on this talk page or in a
425:
395:
154:
232:
214:
158:
768:. The article has been around in some form for years. I generally oppose
70:
52:
177:
903:.) The airlines list, on the other hand, seems out-right absurd. --
84:
82:, a collaborative effort to build and improve articles related to
96:. For instructions on how use this banner, please refer to the
15:
252:, where you can join the project and/or contribute to the
664:
356:– The article does not cover North Korean islands – -
988:
The above discussion is preserved as an archive of a
176:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of
325:. No further edits should be made to this section.
1002:. No further edits should be made to this section.
930:, which has sublists for individual archipelagos.
895:be grouped geographically, we should instead have
334:the page at this time, per the discussion below.
926:, which has sublists for individual states, and
32:does not require a rating on Knowledge (XXG)'s
924:List of islands of the Northeast United States
394:The article includes a list of islands in the
663:Such was the case here from around 2005–2007
8:
702:with links to respective country articles?
244:, an attempt to structure and organize all
311:The following is a closed discussion of a
209:
125:
47:
248:. If you wish to help, please visit the
88:. All interested editors are invited to
373:This is a contested technical request (
211:
127:
49:
1018:Redirect-Class Korea-related articles
238:This redirect is within the scope of
170:This redirect is within the scope of
76:This redirect is within the scope of
19:
7:
1023:NA-importance Korea-related articles
839:Category:Lists of islands by country
330:The result of the move request was:
901:List of islands in the Sea of Japan
837:. The article is categorised under
190:Knowledge (XXG):WikiProject Islands
38:It is of interest to the following
14:
897:List of islands in the Yellow Sea
262:Knowledge (XXG):WikiProject Lists
106:Knowledge (XXG):WikiProject Korea
231:
213:
157:
147:
129:
69:
51:
20:
928:List of islands of Bothnian Bay
304:Requested move 20 November 2014
843:List of islands of North Korea
647:List of mammals of South Korea
643:List of mammals of North Korea
593:Please see my response above.
424:this is a SO-FIX-IT problem.
354:List of islands of South Korea
1:
970:19:31, 30 November 2014 (UTC)
955:07:26, 30 November 2014 (UTC)
940:16:11, 29 November 2014 (UTC)
913:10:08, 29 November 2014 (UTC)
890:20:17, 28 November 2014 (UTC)
855:05:59, 28 November 2014 (UTC)
823:04:23, 23 November 2014 (UTC)
806:01:38, 23 November 2014 (UTC)
788:20:36, 22 November 2014 (UTC)
759:09:10, 22 November 2014 (UTC)
730:15:25, 23 November 2014 (UTC)
715:04:23, 23 November 2014 (UTC)
694:01:37, 23 November 2014 (UTC)
679:20:36, 22 November 2014 (UTC)
659:15:57, 21 November 2014 (UTC)
629:10:39, 21 November 2014 (UTC)
603:01:37, 23 November 2014 (UTC)
588:20:36, 22 November 2014 (UTC)
567:15:54, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
550:15:36, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
533:15:21, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
503:15:25, 23 November 2014 (UTC)
487:04:23, 23 November 2014 (UTC)
470:01:37, 23 November 2014 (UTC)
455:20:36, 22 November 2014 (UTC)
434:12:47, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
415:10:44, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
405:07:41, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
387:09:24, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
367:07:38, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
246:list pages on Knowledge (XXG)
184:and see a list of open tasks.
1043:Redirect-Class List articles
1038:WikiProject Islands articles
518:Query out of utter ignorance
344:07:16, 4 December 2014 (UTC)
193:Template:WikiProject Islands
1048:NA-importance List articles
1069:
1053:WikiProject Lists articles
1028:WikiProject Korea articles
299:11:12, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
265:Template:WikiProject Lists
109:Template:WikiProject Korea
1033:NA-Class Islands articles
920:List of islands of Africa
874:List of airlines of Korea
226:
142:
64:
46:
995:Please do not modify it.
700:List of islands of Korea
639:List of mammals of Korea
571:Then get to work. (Try
438:Then get to work. (Try
350:List of islands of Korea
318:Please do not modify it.
866:List of rivers of Korea
878:List of birds of Korea
870:List of lakes of Korea
112:Korea-related articles
92:and contribute to the
770:progress by extortion
332:no consensus to move
173:WikiProject Islands
34:content assessment
825:
717:
681:
590:
489:
457:
389:
379:Anthony Appleyard
342:
284:
283:
280:
279:
276:
275:
241:WikiProject Lists
208:
207:
204:
203:
124:
123:
120:
119:
79:WikiProject Korea
1060:
997:
820:
819:
811:
810:Answered above.
785:
784:
712:
711:
703:
676:
675:
667:
626:
585:
584:
576:
547:
543:
530:
484:
483:
475:
452:
451:
443:
431:
402:
372:
338:
320:
270:
269:
266:
263:
260:
235:
228:
227:
217:
210:
198:
197:
196:Islands articles
194:
191:
188:
167:
162:
161:
151:
144:
143:
133:
126:
114:
113:
110:
107:
104:
90:join the project
73:
66:
65:
55:
48:
25:
24:
16:
1068:
1067:
1063:
1062:
1061:
1059:
1058:
1057:
1008:
1007:
1006:
993:
815:
814:
780:
779:
707:
706:
671:
670:
624:
621:
580:
579:
545:
541:
528:
525:
479:
478:
447:
446:
429:
400:
316:
306:
289:
267:
264:
261:
258:
257:
195:
192:
189:
186:
185:
163:
156:
111:
108:
105:
102:
101:
12:
11:
5:
1066:
1064:
1056:
1055:
1050:
1045:
1040:
1035:
1030:
1025:
1020:
1010:
1009:
1005:
1004:
990:requested move
984:
983:
982:
981:
980:
979:
978:
977:
976:
975:
974:
973:
972:
858:
857:
831:
830:
829:
828:
827:
826:
791:
790:
762:
761:
743:
742:
741:
740:
739:
738:
737:
736:
735:
734:
733:
732:
632:
631:
622:
610:
609:
608:
607:
606:
605:
552:
535:
526:
514:
513:
512:
511:
510:
509:
508:
507:
506:
505:
419:
418:
417:
391:
390:
347:
328:
327:
313:requested move
307:
305:
302:
288:
285:
282:
281:
278:
277:
274:
273:
271:
236:
224:
223:
218:
206:
205:
202:
201:
199:
182:the discussion
169:
168:
165:Islands portal
152:
140:
139:
134:
122:
121:
118:
117:
115:
74:
62:
61:
56:
44:
43:
37:
26:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
1065:
1054:
1051:
1049:
1046:
1044:
1041:
1039:
1036:
1034:
1031:
1029:
1026:
1024:
1021:
1019:
1016:
1015:
1013:
1003:
1001:
996:
991:
986:
985:
971:
967:
963:
958:
957:
956:
952:
948:
943:
942:
941:
937:
933:
929:
925:
921:
916:
915:
914:
910:
906:
902:
898:
893:
892:
891:
887:
883:
879:
875:
871:
867:
862:
861:
860:
859:
856:
852:
848:
844:
840:
836:
833:
832:
824:
821:
818:
809:
808:
807:
803:
799:
795:
794:
793:
792:
789:
786:
783:
775:
771:
767:
764:
763:
760:
756:
752:
748:
745:
744:
731:
727:
723:
719:
718:
716:
713:
710:
701:
697:
696:
695:
691:
687:
683:
682:
680:
677:
674:
665:
662:
661:
660:
656:
652:
648:
644:
640:
636:
635:
634:
633:
630:
627:
619:
615:
612:
611:
604:
600:
596:
592:
591:
589:
586:
583:
574:
570:
569:
568:
564:
560:
556:
553:
551:
548:
539:
536:
534:
531:
523:
519:
516:
515:
504:
500:
496:
491:
490:
488:
485:
482:
473:
472:
471:
467:
463:
459:
458:
456:
453:
450:
441:
437:
436:
435:
432:
427:
423:
420:
416:
413:
408:
407:
406:
403:
397:
393:
392:
388:
384:
380:
376:
371:
370:
369:
368:
365:
362:
359:
355:
351:
346:
345:
341:
337:
333:
326:
324:
319:
314:
309:
308:
303:
301:
300:
297:
293:
286:
272:
268:List articles
255:
251:
247:
243:
242:
237:
234:
230:
229:
225:
222:
219:
216:
212:
200:
183:
179:
175:
174:
166:
160:
155:
153:
150:
146:
145:
141:
138:
135:
132:
128:
116:
99:
98:documentation
95:
91:
87:
86:
81:
80:
75:
72:
68:
67:
63:
60:
57:
54:
50:
45:
41:
35:
31:
27:
23:
18:
17:
994:
987:
834:
816:
781:
773:
765:
746:
708:
672:
613:
581:
554:
537:
517:
480:
448:
421:
348:
331:
329:
317:
310:
291:
290:
250:project page
239:
171:
83:
77:
40:WikiProjects
29:
1000:move review
774:significant
361:ChampionMan
323:move review
1012:Categories
835:Move/split
396:Yellow Sea
254:discussion
94:discussion
817:AjaxSmack
782:AjaxSmack
709:AjaxSmack
673:AjaxSmack
582:AjaxSmack
481:AjaxSmack
449:AjaxSmack
375:permalink
296:JPBarrass
947:Paul_012
905:Paul_012
847:Paul_012
618:Gregkaye
522:Gregkaye
412:Kusunose
401:Philg88
336:Dekimasu
30:redirect
766:Support
751:V2Blast
747:Support
614:Support
187:Islands
178:islands
137:Islands
962:Neelix
932:Neelix
882:Neelix
876:, and
798:Neelix
722:Neelix
686:Neelix
651:Neelix
645:, and
595:Neelix
559:Neelix
555:Oppose
538:Oppose
495:Neelix
462:Neelix
422:Oppose
292:Jsindo
287:Jsindo
36:scale.
259:Lists
221:Lists
103:Korea
85:Korea
59:Korea
28:This
966:talk
951:talk
936:talk
909:talk
899:and
886:talk
851:talk
802:talk
755:talk
726:talk
690:talk
655:talk
599:talk
573:here
563:talk
546:Revi
499:talk
466:talk
440:here
426:Wily
383:talk
364:1234
992:.
377:).
358:The
1014::
968:)
953:)
945:--
938:)
911:)
888:)
880:.
872:,
868:,
853:)
812:—
804:)
757:)
728:)
704:—
692:)
668:—
666:.
657:)
649:.
641:,
601:)
577:—
565:)
501:)
476:—
468:)
444:—
410:--
385:)
352:→
340:よ!
315:.
964:(
949:(
934:(
907:(
884:(
849:(
800:(
753:(
724:(
688:(
653:(
625:♪
623:✍
597:(
561:(
542:—
529:♪
527:✍
497:(
464:(
430:D
381:(
256:.
100:.
42::
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
