142:
280:– Several issues I hope to address with these proposed moves. First, it makes little sense to have the "second" and "third" sieges as titles but to call the first event a battle; of the three is was the most like a battle, but the distinction is confusing in this case. It does seem that siege of Gerona is the most common manner of disambiguating the various events. If the first segment were to carry the
22:
348:, since the third is not obviously primary and simple disambiguation seems better. Neutral on Battle vs Siege for the first, but yes drop the unneeded year if Battle. And thanks, Mdewman6, for taking this on. I agree that we should find something better than what we've got now, and I don't have a lot invested in a particular outcome, but those are my opinions.
71:
53:
300:
at the plural, but I would also support having the set index in place of the redirect at the singular. Third, while I personally feel "Siege" in these titles is part of the proper noun, use in sources is mixed, and most "siege" articles on enwiki do not take siege as part of the proper noun (in
296:. Second, when used alone without additional context, "Siege of Gerona" does seem to refer to the successful final siege as a primary topic, and currently redirects there. I am proposing to leave this as a primary redirect and turn the disambiguation page into a
371:
of all. The "battle" of 1808 is indeed usually called a siege. But all three sieges should be disambiguated another way, since they are not the first, second and third sieges of Girona in history, but only of the
Peninsular War. (See
321:
spelling. Regardless, the set index/disambiguation page should use the same spelling as the articles. Overall, I am open to discussing and considering any and all variations of this proposal, but the status quo should not be kept.
341:
376:
and the now expanded dab page.) As for spelling, the dab page should use Girona like the city, but the
Napoleonic articles can use whichever. My preferred moves would be:
172:
168:
447:
97:
317:
use this spelling, and that is the criterion upon which we should base our choice. On the other hand, the modern spelling of the city is the
313:), and we should reach consensus here. I am open to either spelling, but am proposing a return to Gerona because it does seem a majority of
93:
78:
58:
171:
within an hour of this tag being placed. The discussion may be closed 7 days after being opened, if consensus has been reached (see the
180:
383:
239:
207:
407:
33:
310:
309:. Lastly, as for the Girona vs. Gerona issue, there has been past move reversions and discussion about this (e.g.
398:
164:
452:
176:
83:
416:
394:
301:
contrast to "Battle of..." which is almost always part of the proper noun; I don't see the distinction) and
248:
195:
149:
252:
21:
403:
257:
412:
268:
39:
243:
281:
293:
353:
327:
318:
306:
184:
432:
357:
331:
302:
285:
289:
428:
345:
373:
441:
349:
323:
297:
314:
424:
284:"Battle" then it should not carry a parenthetical qualifier, being already
344:. Negative on the plural in the disambig title; move the disambig to
70:
52:
288:
disambiguated and the primary topic for the term; the base name
159:
136:
15:
148:
It has been proposed in this section that multiple pages be
388:
273:
262:
228:
224:
220:
88:
96:, where you can join the project or contribute to the
305:is vague, so for now let's go for being the most
86:pages on Knowledge. If you wish to help, you can
76:This disambiguation page is within the scope of
8:
82:, an attempt to structure and organize all
19:
423:But there are other ways to disambiguate.
47:
92:attached to this talk page, or visit the
32:does not require a rating on Knowledge's
311:Talk:Third siege of Girona#Girona/Gerona
49:
7:
106:Knowledge:WikiProject Disambiguation
109:Template:WikiProject Disambiguation
38:It is of interest to the following
408:Siege of Girona (July–August 1808)
14:
163:will list this discussion on the
448:WikiProject Disambiguation pages
384:Siege of Gerona (disambiguation)
240:Siege of Gerona (disambiguation)
140:
69:
51:
20:
340:– Yes, on spelling Gerona, per
292:already redirects there and is
1:
131:Requested move 1 October 2024
175:). Please base arguments on
433:20:30, 1 October 2024 (UTC)
399:Siege of Girona (June 1808)
358:05:31, 1 October 2024 (UTC)
332:04:03, 1 October 2024 (UTC)
469:
79:WikiProject Disambiguation
64:
46:
395:Battle of Girona (1808)
249:Battle of Girona (1808)
112:Disambiguation articles
417:Siege of Girona (1809)
404:Second siege of Girona
263:Second siege of Gerona
258:Second siege of Girona
179:, and keep discussion
413:Third siege of Girona
274:Third siege of Gerona
269:Third siege of Girona
253:First siege of Gerona
208:requested move/dated
196:subst:requested move
177:article title policy
173:closing instructions
167:current discussions
30:disambiguation page
374:ca:Setge de Girona
34:content assessment
367:as proposed, but
236:
235:
231:
214:
150:renamed and moved
128:
127:
124:
123:
120:
119:
460:
391:
315:reliable sources
290:Battle of Girona
276:
265:
244:Sieges of Gerona
216:
211:
199:
190:
162:
144:
143:
137:
114:
113:
110:
107:
104:
91:
73:
66:
65:
55:
48:
25:
24:
16:
468:
467:
463:
462:
461:
459:
458:
457:
453:Requested moves
438:
437:
389:Siege of Girona
387:
346:Siege of Gerona
272:
261:
232:
205:
193:
165:requested moves
158:
141:
133:
111:
108:
105:
102:
101:
87:
12:
11:
5:
466:
464:
456:
455:
450:
440:
439:
436:
435:
421:
420:
419:
410:
401:
392:
378:
377:
361:
360:
278:
277:
266:
255:
246:
234:
233:
215:
189:
155:
154:
145:
132:
129:
126:
125:
122:
121:
118:
117:
115:
103:Disambiguation
84:disambiguation
74:
62:
61:
59:Disambiguation
56:
44:
43:
37:
26:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
465:
454:
451:
449:
446:
445:
443:
434:
430:
426:
422:
418:
414:
411:
409:
405:
402:
400:
396:
393:
390:
385:
382:
381:
380:
379:
375:
370:
369:support moves
366:
363:
362:
359:
355:
351:
347:
343:
339:
336:
335:
334:
333:
329:
325:
320:
316:
312:
308:
304:
299:
295:
291:
287:
283:
282:WP:COMMONNAME
275:
270:
267:
264:
259:
256:
254:
250:
247:
245:
241:
238:
237:
230:
226:
222:
219:
213:
209:
203:
197:
188:
186:
182:
178:
174:
170:
166:
161:
153:
151:
146:
139:
138:
135:
130:
116:
99:
95:
90:
89:edit the page
85:
81:
80:
75:
72:
68:
67:
63:
60:
57:
54:
50:
45:
41:
35:
31:
27:
23:
18:
17:
368:
364:
337:
294:WP:MISPLACED
286:WP:NATURALly
279:
217:
201:
191:
156:
147:
134:
94:project page
77:
40:WikiProjects
29:
229:direct move
221:current log
192:Please use
442:Categories
365:Oppose all
307:consistent
303:WP:MILCAPS
225:target log
98:discussion
298:set index
212:directly.
350:Dicklyon
324:Mdewman6
181:succinct
342:sources
319:Catalan
169:subpage
218:Links:
36:scale.
425:Srnec
338:Mixed
200:. Do
185:civil
28:This
429:talk
354:talk
328:talk
204:use
183:and
202:not
160:bot
444::
431:)
415:→
406:→
397:→
386:→
356:)
330:)
271:→
260:→
251:→
242:→
227:•
223:•
210:}}
206:{{
198:}}
194:{{
187:.
157:A
427:(
352:(
326:(
152:.
100:.
42::
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
