Knowledge

Talk:Papal infallibility

Source 📝

1219:
affirmed as "revealed by God" by the Pope ex cathedra, the universal ordinary magisterium, or a council. The commentary doesn't say if these are dogmas by virtue of a ex cathedra declaration or universal magisterium of a council. Moreover, there are many instances of infallible affirmations by the pope that are not ex cathedra but just ordinary magisterium, i.e. every single time that the pope re-state a dogma, or teaches something that is already teached universally (even if he doesn't know it and doesn't say that it is a dogma), or he explicit a "secondary object of infallibility", i.e. something that is entailed or presupposed by an explicit dogma.
913: 925: 847: 837: 810: 433: 412: 380: 1215:"A 1998 commentary on Ad Tuendam Fidem issued by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith published on L'Osservatore Romano in July 1998 listed a number of instances of infallible pronouncements by popes and by ecumenical councils, but explicitly stated (at no. 11) that this was not meant to be a complete list. The list included as ex cathedra pronouncements Ineffabilis Deus, Munificentissimus Deus, and Benedictus Deus." 551: 304: 277: 965: 443: 314: 215: 246: 1009: 1178: 1139: 1100: 1061: 1218:
This is not totally true. The commentary presents mariological dogmas (ineffabilis deus and munificentissimus deus) and beatific vision after death (benedictus deus) as exemple of truth of the "first comma", i.e. revealed magisterium. The revealed magisterium is made up of the proposition that are
1245:
An important historical context was the secular setback of losing a large section of the Papal States a decade earlier. That was an important source of revenue for the Vatican. One can speculate that declaring papal infallibility in 1869-70 was in part a response to this loss.
781: 153: 1190: 1151: 1112: 1073: 701: 389: 287: 1319: 903: 893: 1284: 394: 147: 1339: 206: 588: 1289: 869: 1329: 1314: 943: 1304: 1274: 494: 370: 360: 1279: 605: 504: 1359: 1354: 1349: 1344: 44: 1294: 860: 815: 79: 1309: 620: 570: 715: 584: 336: 1324: 1269: 190: 1299: 85: 1065: 1186: 1147: 1108: 1069: 666: 1226: 1170: 1131: 1092: 1053: 938: 820: 327: 282: 202: 198: 194: 640: 470: 461: 417: 168: 976: 135: 677: 99: 30: 1334: 719: 104: 20: 74: 694: 577: 563: 257: 650: 627: 65: 129: 214: 185: 753: 225: 125: 912: 613: 1143: 1104: 1230: 743: 109: 1033:] The anchor (#Italian nationalism and the end of the Papal States) is no longer available because it was 175: 1251: 1182: 1034: 749: 448: 769: 736: 263: 1247: 1222: 1193:
until a consensus is reached, and readers of this page are welcome to contribute to the discussion.
1154:
until a consensus is reached, and readers of this page are welcome to contribute to the discussion.
1115:
until a consensus is reached, and readers of this page are welcome to contribute to the discussion.
1076:
until a consensus is reached, and readers of this page are welcome to contribute to the discussion.
865: 683: 658: 654: 245: 1042: 993: 989: 985: 981: 930: 601: 319: 161: 55: 24: 868:
on Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join
465:, an attempt to better organize and improve the quality of information in articles related to the 335:
on Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join
230: 141: 70: 836: 809: 1198: 1159: 1120: 1081: 1041:
Please help fix the broken anchors. You can remove this template after fixing the problems. |
670: 633: 595: 51: 1074:
Knowledge:Redirects for discussion/Log/2021 December 24#Theological definition (Catholicism)
1021: 227: 726: 466: 432: 411: 765: 708: 550: 379: 1263: 852: 662: 1194: 1155: 1116: 1077: 732: 332: 1152:
Knowledge:Redirects for discussion/Log/2021 December 24#Definitions, Theological
761: 1113:
Knowledge:Redirects for discussion/Log/2021 December 24#Theological Definitions
964: 442: 229: 1255: 1234: 1202: 1163: 1124: 1085: 920: 842: 687: 438: 309: 303: 276: 1191:
Knowledge:Redirects for discussion/Log/2021 December 24#Dogmatically defined
971: 313: 1177: 1138: 1099: 1060: 1029:
This article links to one or more target anchors that no longer exist.
646: 757: 1181:
An editor has identified a potential problem with the redirect
1142:
An editor has identified a potential problem with the redirect
1103:
An editor has identified a potential problem with the redirect
1064:
An editor has identified a potential problem with the redirect
1003: 959: 239: 231: 15: 911: 378: 702:
Category:Knowledge requested photographs of Catholicism
539: 534: 529: 524: 160: 970:
A fact from this article was featured on Knowledge's
864:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of 331:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of 1052:"Theological definition (Catholicism)" listed at 589:Category:Unknown-importance Catholicism articles 33:for general discussion of the article's subject. 174: 8: 1320:Mid-importance European Microstates articles 1285:High-importance Christian theology articles 1220: 878:Knowledge:WikiProject European Microstates 804: 558:Here are some tasks awaiting attention: 512: 406: 271: 1340:WikiProject European Microstates articles 881:Template:WikiProject European Microstates 621:Category:WikiProject invitation templates 716:Category:Stub-Class Catholicism articles 585:Category:Unassessed Catholicism articles 806: 408: 273: 243: 1290:Christian theology work group articles 1330:High-importance Vatican City articles 1315:C-Class European Microstates articles 1130:"Definitions, Theological" listed at 7: 1305:High-importance Catholicism articles 1275:Mid-importance Christianity articles 1091:"Theological Definitions" listed at 1066:Theological definition (Catholicism) 858:This article is within the scope of 325:This article is within the scope of 1280:C-Class Christian theology articles 667:American Board of Catholic Missions 262:It is of interest to the following 23:for discussing improvements to the 1360:Selected anniversaries (July 2015) 1355:Selected anniversaries (July 2014) 1350:Selected anniversaries (July 2012) 1345:Selected anniversaries (July 2011) 469:. For more information, visit the 345:Knowledge:WikiProject Christianity 14: 1295:WikiProject Christianity articles 1169:"Dogmatically defined" listed at 479:Knowledge:WikiProject Catholicism 348:Template:WikiProject Christianity 1310:WikiProject Catholicism articles 1176: 1137: 1098: 1059: 1007: 963: 923: 861:WikiProject European Microstates 845: 835: 808: 619:Invitation template needed, see 549: 482:Template:WikiProject Catholicism 441: 431: 410: 312: 302: 275: 244: 213: 45:Click here to start a new topic. 1208:"first comma" and "ex cathedra" 1189:. The discussion will occur at 1150:. The discussion will occur at 1111:. The discussion will occur at 1072:. The discussion will occur at 898:This article has been rated as 499:This article has been rated as 365:This article has been rated as 720:Category:Catholic Church stubs 1: 1325:C-Class Vatican City articles 1270:C-Class Christianity articles 1235:17:22, 22 February 2022 (UTC) 1203:16:32, 24 December 2021 (UTC) 1164:16:32, 24 December 2021 (UTC) 1125:16:32, 24 December 2021 (UTC) 1086:16:32, 24 December 2021 (UTC) 936:This article is supported by 884:European Microstates articles 872:and see a list of open tasks. 387:This article is supported by 339:and see a list of open tasks. 42:Put new text under old text. 1300:C-Class Catholicism articles 1256:14:08, 25 January 2024 (UTC) 655:Bishop Adolph John Paschang 651:Roman Catholicism in Kosovo 50:New to Knowledge? Welcome! 1376: 1185:and has thus listed it at 1146:and has thus listed it at 1107:and has thus listed it at 1068:and has thus listed it at 904:project's importance scale 505:project's importance scale 371:project's importance scale 919: 897: 830: 754:Archbishop of Westminster 511: 498: 426: 386: 364: 297: 270: 80:Be welcoming to newcomers 1187:redirects for discussion 1171:Redirects for discussion 1148:redirects for discussion 1144:Definitions, Theological 1132:Redirects for discussion 1109:redirects for discussion 1093:Redirects for discussion 1070:redirects for discussion 1054:Redirects for discussion 939:WikiProject Vatican City 784:for Catholicism articles 328:WikiProject Christianity 1105:Theological Definitions 462:WikiProject Catholicism 459:is within the scope of 916: 750:Archdiocese of Glasgow 516:Catholicism task list: 449:Catholic Church portal 383: 252:This article is rated 75:avoid personal attacks 1335:Vatican City articles 1212:I quote the article: 915: 770:Westminster Cathedral 737:John Aloysius Maguire 382: 351:Christianity articles 207:Auto-archiving period 100:Neutral point of view 1241:Loss of Papal States 1183:Dogmatically defined 875:European Microstates 866:European Microstates 816:European Microstates 684:Americanism (heresy) 485:Catholicism articles 105:No original research 931:Vatican City portal 602:Blessed Virgin Mary 456:Papal infallibility 390:theology work group 320:Christianity portal 25:Papal infallibility 917: 384: 258:content assessment 86:dispute resolution 47: 1237: 1225:comment added by 1049: 1048: 1035:deleted by a user 1024:in most browsers. 1000: 999: 958: 957: 954: 953: 950: 949: 803: 802: 799: 798: 795: 794: 791: 790: 659:Cum sæpe accidere 634:Cuthbert Tunstall 405: 404: 401: 400: 238: 237: 66:Assume good faith 43: 1367: 1180: 1141: 1102: 1063: 1043:Reporting errors 1011: 1010: 1004: 967: 960: 933: 928: 927: 926: 886: 885: 882: 879: 876: 855: 850: 849: 848: 839: 832: 831: 826: 823: 812: 805: 564:Article requests 553: 546: 545: 513: 487: 486: 483: 480: 477: 451: 446: 445: 435: 428: 427: 422: 414: 407: 353: 352: 349: 346: 343: 322: 317: 316: 306: 299: 298: 293: 290: 279: 272: 255: 249: 248: 240: 232: 218: 217: 208: 179: 178: 164: 95:Article policies 16: 1375: 1374: 1370: 1369: 1368: 1366: 1365: 1364: 1260: 1259: 1243: 1210: 1174: 1135: 1096: 1057: 1045: 1027: 1026: 1025: 1008: 944:High-importance 929: 924: 922: 883: 880: 877: 874: 873: 851: 846: 844: 824: 818: 787: 544: 501:High-importance 484: 481: 478: 475: 474: 467:Catholic Church 447: 440: 421:High‑importance 420: 395:High-importance 350: 347: 344: 341: 340: 318: 311: 291: 285: 256:on Knowledge's 253: 234: 233: 228: 205: 121: 116: 115: 114: 91: 61: 12: 11: 5: 1373: 1371: 1363: 1362: 1357: 1352: 1347: 1342: 1337: 1332: 1327: 1322: 1317: 1312: 1307: 1302: 1297: 1292: 1287: 1282: 1277: 1272: 1262: 1261: 1242: 1239: 1209: 1206: 1173: 1167: 1134: 1128: 1095: 1089: 1056: 1050: 1047: 1046: 1040: 1039: 1038: 1022:case-sensitive 1016: 1015: 1014: 1012: 998: 997: 968: 956: 955: 952: 951: 948: 947: 935: 934: 918: 908: 907: 900:Mid-importance 896: 890: 889: 887: 870:the discussion 857: 856: 840: 828: 827: 825:Mid‑importance 813: 801: 800: 797: 796: 793: 792: 789: 788: 786: 785: 782:recent changes 772: 766:Sanctification 739: 722: 704: 690: 673: 671:Bernard Häring 636: 623: 609: 591: 573: 571:Draft articles 557: 555: 554: 543: 542: 537: 532: 527: 521: 518: 517: 509: 508: 497: 491: 490: 488: 453: 452: 436: 424: 423: 415: 403: 402: 399: 398: 385: 375: 374: 367:Mid-importance 363: 357: 356: 354: 337:the discussion 324: 323: 307: 295: 294: 292:Mid‑importance 280: 268: 267: 261: 250: 236: 235: 226: 224: 223: 220: 219: 181: 180: 118: 117: 113: 112: 107: 102: 93: 92: 90: 89: 82: 77: 68: 62: 60: 59: 48: 39: 38: 35: 34: 28: 13: 10: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 1372: 1361: 1358: 1356: 1353: 1351: 1348: 1346: 1343: 1341: 1338: 1336: 1333: 1331: 1328: 1326: 1323: 1321: 1318: 1316: 1313: 1311: 1308: 1306: 1303: 1301: 1298: 1296: 1293: 1291: 1288: 1286: 1283: 1281: 1278: 1276: 1273: 1271: 1268: 1267: 1265: 1258: 1257: 1253: 1249: 1240: 1238: 1236: 1232: 1228: 1224: 1216: 1213: 1207: 1205: 1204: 1200: 1196: 1192: 1188: 1184: 1179: 1172: 1168: 1166: 1165: 1161: 1157: 1153: 1149: 1145: 1140: 1133: 1129: 1127: 1126: 1122: 1118: 1114: 1110: 1106: 1101: 1094: 1090: 1088: 1087: 1083: 1079: 1075: 1071: 1067: 1062: 1055: 1051: 1044: 1036: 1032: 1031: 1030: 1023: 1019: 1013: 1006: 1005: 1002: 995: 994:July 18, 2015 991: 990:July 18, 2014 987: 986:July 18, 2012 983: 982:July 18, 2011 979: 978: 973: 969: 966: 962: 961: 945: 942:(assessed as 941: 940: 932: 921: 914: 910: 909: 905: 901: 895: 892: 891: 888: 871: 867: 863: 862: 854: 853:Europe portal 843: 841: 838: 834: 833: 829: 822: 817: 814: 811: 807: 783: 779: 777: 773: 771: 767: 763: 759: 755: 751: 748: 746: 745: 740: 738: 734: 731: 729: 728: 723: 721: 717: 713: 711: 710: 705: 703: 699: 697: 696: 691: 689: 685: 682: 680: 679: 674: 672: 668: 664: 663:Altar Society 660: 656: 652: 648: 645: 643: 642: 637: 635: 632: 630: 629: 624: 622: 618: 616: 615: 610: 607: 603: 600: 598: 597: 592: 590: 586: 582: 580: 579: 574: 572: 568: 566: 565: 560: 559: 556: 552: 548: 547: 541: 538: 536: 533: 531: 528: 526: 523: 522: 520: 519: 515: 514: 510: 506: 502: 496: 493: 492: 489: 472: 468: 464: 463: 458: 457: 450: 444: 439: 437: 434: 430: 429: 425: 419: 416: 413: 409: 396: 393:(assessed as 392: 391: 381: 377: 376: 372: 368: 362: 359: 358: 355: 338: 334: 330: 329: 321: 315: 310: 308: 305: 301: 300: 296: 289: 284: 281: 278: 274: 269: 265: 259: 251: 247: 242: 241: 222: 221: 216: 212: 204: 200: 196: 192: 189: 187: 183: 182: 177: 173: 170: 167: 163: 159: 155: 152: 149: 146: 143: 140: 137: 134: 131: 127: 124: 123:Find sources: 120: 119: 111: 110:Verifiability 108: 106: 103: 101: 98: 97: 96: 87: 83: 81: 78: 76: 72: 69: 67: 64: 63: 57: 53: 52:Learn to edit 49: 46: 41: 40: 37: 36: 32: 26: 22: 18: 17: 1244: 1227:151.18.63.38 1221:— Preceding 1217: 1214: 1211: 1175: 1136: 1097: 1058: 1028: 1020:Anchors are 1017: 1001: 975: 937: 899: 859: 821:Vatican City 775: 774: 742: 741: 725: 724: 707: 706: 693: 692: 676: 675: 639: 638: 626: 625: 612: 611: 594: 593: 576: 575: 562: 561: 500: 471:project page 460: 455: 454: 388: 366: 342:Christianity 333:Christianity 326: 283:Christianity 264:WikiProjects 210: 184: 171: 165: 157: 150: 144: 138: 132: 122: 94: 19:This is the 980:section on 977:On this day 762:Saint Mungo 733:Peer review 614:Collaborate 476:Catholicism 418:Catholicism 148:free images 31:not a forum 1264:Categories 1248:Oxfreudian 688:Ensoulment 972:Main Page 606:talk page 604:(see the 88:if needed 71:Be polite 21:talk page 1223:unsigned 628:Copyedit 288:Theology 186:Archives 56:get help 29:This is 27:article. 1195:Veverve 1156:Veverve 1117:Veverve 1078:Veverve 1037:before. 974:in the 902:on the 647:Angelus 596:Cleanup 530:history 503:on the 369:on the 254:C-class 211:60 days 154:WP refs 142:scholar 992:, and 780:Watch 758:Bishop 744:Verify 727:Update 641:Expand 578:Assess 260:scale. 126:Google 776:Other 709:Stubs 695:Photo 540:purge 535:watch 191:Index 169:JSTOR 130:books 84:Seek 1252:talk 1231:talk 1199:talk 1160:talk 1121:talk 1082:talk 1018:Tip: 714:see 700:see 678:NPOV 583:see 569:see 525:edit 495:High 162:FENS 136:news 73:and 894:Mid 361:Mid 176:TWL 1266:: 1254:) 1233:) 1201:) 1162:) 1123:) 1084:) 988:, 984:, 946:). 819:: 768:; 764:; 760:; 756:; 752:; 735:; 718:; 686:; 669:; 665:; 661:; 657:; 653:; 649:; 587:; 397:). 286:: 209:: 201:, 197:, 193:, 156:) 54:; 1250:( 1229:( 1197:( 1158:( 1119:( 1080:( 996:. 906:. 778:: 747:: 730:: 712:: 698:: 681:: 644:: 631:: 617:: 608:) 599:: 581:: 567:: 507:. 473:. 373:. 266:: 203:3 199:2 195:1 188:: 172:· 166:· 158:· 151:· 145:· 139:· 133:· 128:( 58:.

Index

talk page
Papal infallibility
not a forum
Click here to start a new topic.
Learn to edit
get help
Assume good faith
Be polite
avoid personal attacks
Be welcoming to newcomers
dispute resolution
Neutral point of view
No original research
Verifiability
Google
books
news
scholar
free images
WP refs
FENS
JSTOR
TWL
Archives
Index
1
2
3

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.