852:
377:
805:
757:
733:
21:
967:
937:
926:
907:
892:
876:
794:
164:
140:
109:
430:
409:
226:
301:
274:
238:
311:
587:
174:
547:
Yes, I understand that "some media outlets" have mentioned the "worst call of all time." Well, "some media outlets" also refer to Dave
Pallone's call that sparked Pete Rose's suspension the worst call of all time; if you're in St. Louis, no doubt your local media outlets would note Don Denkinger in
691:
This nomination is going to be failed, as the nominator has asked for and been granted an indefinate block, and there are issues that would prevent the article from being promoted as is. I will, however, provide a full review, for the benefit of anyone that wishes to take this to GAN again.
767:
Content should not appear only in the lead and not in the body text (this is not expressly prohibited, but is strongly discouraged). Information about his jersey number and his stance appear in the lead, but not in the body text. At the very least, that content needs to be
980:
Normally I would kick this back out to the nominator to fix. In this case, however, the nominator has been indefinitely blocked (by request), and there is no indication that another user has taken custody of the GAN. As such, I am failing this review.
494:
The "did in fact not touch the plate" reference is bogus. There is no reference and the play is in dispute. I'm a big McClelland fan, but it's close JUST LIKE HAND GRENADES AND HORSESHOES and no video gives definitive proof.
743:
What makes the third paragraph in the "Notable games" section notable? As someone that's not a fan of
Baseball, I have no idea whether single-game playoffs are inherently notable, and the paragraph lacks context on the games'
551:
Point is, whether or not reputable sources have used the phrase "worst call of all time," that is such a loaded and context-sensitive phrase that it in no way belongs in an encyclopedia's treatment of Mr. McClelland.
1042:
472:
441:, a collaborative effort to improve Knowledge's coverage of Referees. If you would like to participate, you can visit the project page, where you can join the project and see a list of open tasks.
256:
1037:
863:
866:
situation? He would have been active during the time, and even if his was not a resignation that was accepted, he might still have resigned. If so, that needs to be mentioned.
88:
386:
284:
251:
150:
625:
592:
1047:
32:
1027:
615:
93:
76:) policy, even if it is not a biography, because it contains material about living persons. Contentious material about living persons that is unsourced or
1092:
462:
1072:
1062:
391:
367:
357:
1052:
1032:
192:
68:
555:
And if you disagree, I understand... but please update the page of EVERY OTHER MLB UMPIRE who has earned similar criticism over the years. Â :-)
1087:
1082:
1057:
1067:
1022:
196:
597:
664:
333:
200:
52:
502:
191:, a collaborative effort to create, develop and organize Knowledge's articles about people. All interested editors are invited to
680:
620:
187:
145:
38:
532:
437:
414:
324:
279:
517:
2007 wild card video proof. Might want to check out www.hollidaynevertouchedtheplate.com for the conclusive video proof.
120:
562:
1077:
747:
I would mention what his BA and MA are in; those aren't common degrees, and are relevant to his career choice.
108:
999:
707:
658:
643:
77:
43:
506:
639:
558:
528:
126:
520:
498:
87:. If such material is repeatedly inserted, or if you have other concerns, please report the issue to
524:
332:
on
Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join
985:
955:
693:
654:
91:.If you are a subject of this article, or acting on behalf of one, and you need help, please see
48:
179:
851:
316:
84:
804:
756:
732:
376:
772:
566:
1016:
243:
815:
The entire first and third paragraphs of the "Controversies" section are not cited.
966:
936:
925:
906:
891:
875:
793:
818:
The last sentence of the Sosa paragraph in "Notable games" also needs a citation.
225:
163:
139:
306:
233:
169:
646:. The edit link for this section can be used to add comments to the review.
429:
408:
329:
1008:
716:
668:
536:
510:
948:
Additional items not required for a GA, but requested by the reviewer
771:
I don't feel that the lead meets the "Relative emphasis" portion of
300:
273:
199:. For instructions on how to use this banner, please refer to the
102:
83:
from the article and its talk page, especially if potentially
60:
15:
375:
224:
543:"Worst Call of All Time" appelation doesn't belong here.
41:
at the time (April 27, 2014). There are suggestions on
864:
1999 Major League
Umpires Association mass resignation
1043:
Mid-importance biography (sports and games) articles
328:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of
548:this context; Atlantans might bring up Eric Gregg.
47:for improving the article. If you can improve it,
1038:Start-Class biography (sports and games) articles
8:
106:
575:
403:
268:
134:
833:No comment on this, per concerns with 2b.
435:This article is within the scope of the
606:
578:
405:
270:
136:
964:b. general catch all and aesthetics:
20:
7:
1048:Sports and games work group articles
322:This article is within the scope of
185:This article is within the scope of
1028:Biography articles of living people
125:It is of interest to the following
978:Comments after the initial review:
33:Sports and recreation good article
14:
1093:High-importance Referees articles
1073:High-importance Umpires articles
1063:Mid-importance Baseball articles
965:
935:
934:b. relevant/properly captioned:
924:
905:
890:
874:
862:Was this umpire involved in the
850:
803:
792:
755:
731:
428:
407:
309:
299:
272:
236:
172:
162:
138:
107:
66:This article must adhere to the
19:
467:This article has been rated as
362:This article has been rated as
252:the sports and games work group
209:Knowledge:WikiProject Biography
1053:WikiProject Biography articles
1033:Start-Class biography articles
447:Knowledge:WikiProject Referees
342:Knowledge:WikiProject Baseball
212:Template:WikiProject Biography
1:
1088:Start-Class Referees articles
1083:WikiProject Baseball articles
1058:Start-Class Baseball articles
567:01:32, 29 November 2009 (UTC)
450:Template:WikiProject Referees
384:This article is supported by
345:Template:WikiProject Baseball
336:and see a list of open tasks.
249:This article is supported by
69:biographies of living persons
1068:Start-Class Umpires articles
1023:Former good article nominees
923:a. license/tagging correct:
542:
197:contribute to the discussion
954:a. images that should have
537:06:30, 5 October 2007 (UTC)
511:05:45, 2 October 2007 (UTC)
81:must be removed immediately
1109:
1009:16:20, 27 April 2014 (UTC)
717:15:53, 27 April 2014 (UTC)
669:15:50, 27 April 2014 (UTC)
368:project's importance scale
37:, but it did not meet the
825:c. no original research:
466:
423:
383:
361:
294:
232:
157:
133:
849:a. covers main aspects:
802:b. proper citation use:
791:a. provides references:
785:Accurate and verifiable
644:Talk:Tim McClelland/GA1
387:the Umpires task force
380:
229:
115:This article is rated
873:b. focused/on topic:
379:
228:
188:WikiProject Biography
39:good article criteria
730:a. prose/copyright:
438:Referees WikiProject
325:WikiProject Baseball
754:b. MoS compliance:
29:was nominated as a
689:Starting comments:
381:
230:
215:biography articles
121:content assessment
1006:
843:Broad in coverage
714:
684:
676:
634:
633:
539:
523:comment added by
513:
501:comment added by
487:
486:
483:
482:
479:
478:
453:Referees articles
402:
401:
398:
397:
348:Baseball articles
267:
266:
263:
262:
101:
100:
59:
58:
51:; it may then be
1100:
1078:Umpires articles
1005:
1000:
997:
972:
969:
961:
942:
939:
931:
928:
912:
909:
897:
894:
881:
878:
857:
854:
828:
810:
807:
799:
796:
762:
759:
738:
735:
713:
708:
705:
678:
674:
588:Copyvio detector
576:
559:Moishe Rosenbaum
518:
496:
473:importance scale
455:
454:
451:
448:
445:
432:
425:
424:
419:
411:
404:
350:
349:
346:
343:
340:
319:
314:
313:
312:
303:
296:
295:
290:
287:
276:
269:
246:
241:
240:
239:
217:
216:
213:
210:
207:
193:join the project
182:
180:Biography portal
177:
176:
175:
166:
159:
158:
153:
151:Sports and Games
142:
135:
118:
112:
111:
103:
89:this noticeboard
61:
23:
22:
16:
1108:
1107:
1103:
1102:
1101:
1099:
1098:
1097:
1013:
1012:
1001:
994:
990:
986:
970:
959:
940:
929:
910:
895:
879:
855:
826:
808:
797:
760:
736:
709:
702:
698:
694:
673:GAN Quicksheet
638:This review is
630:
602:
574:
545:
492:
469:High-importance
452:
449:
446:
443:
442:
418:High‑importance
417:
392:High-importance
347:
344:
341:
338:
337:
317:Baseball portal
315:
310:
308:
288:
282:
242:
237:
235:
214:
211:
208:
205:
204:
178:
173:
171:
148:
119:on Knowledge's
116:
44:the review page
12:
11:
5:
1106:
1104:
1096:
1095:
1090:
1085:
1080:
1075:
1070:
1065:
1060:
1055:
1050:
1045:
1040:
1035:
1030:
1025:
1015:
1014:
992:
988:
976:
974:
973:
962:
944:
943:
932:
883:
882:
871:
870:
869:
868:
867:
839:
838:
837:
836:
835:
834:
823:
822:
821:
820:
819:
816:
800:
781:
780:
779:
778:
777:
776:
769:
752:
751:
750:
749:
748:
745:
721:
700:
696:
687:
677:
649:
648:
632:
631:
629:
628:
623:
618:
612:
609:
608:
604:
603:
601:
600:
598:External links
595:
590:
584:
581:
580:
573:
570:
544:
541:
516:
491:
490:2007 wild card
488:
485:
484:
481:
480:
477:
476:
465:
459:
458:
456:
433:
421:
420:
412:
400:
399:
396:
395:
382:
372:
371:
364:Mid-importance
360:
354:
353:
351:
334:the discussion
321:
320:
304:
292:
291:
289:Mid‑importance
277:
265:
264:
261:
260:
257:Mid-importance
248:
247:
231:
221:
220:
218:
184:
183:
167:
155:
154:
143:
131:
130:
124:
113:
99:
98:
94:this help page
78:poorly sourced
64:
57:
56:
27:Tim McClelland
24:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
1105:
1094:
1091:
1089:
1086:
1084:
1081:
1079:
1076:
1074:
1071:
1069:
1066:
1064:
1061:
1059:
1056:
1054:
1051:
1049:
1046:
1044:
1041:
1039:
1036:
1034:
1031:
1029:
1026:
1024:
1021:
1020:
1018:
1011:
1010:
1007:
1004:
998:
996:
984:
979:
968:
963:
957:
953:
952:
951:
949:
938:
933:
927:
922:
921:
920:
918:
913:
908:
903:
898:
893:
888:
877:
872:
865:
861:
860:
859:
858:
853:
848:
847:
846:
844:
832:
831:
830:
829:
824:
817:
814:
813:
812:
811:
806:
801:
795:
790:
789:
788:
786:
774:
770:
766:
765:
764:
763:
758:
753:
746:
742:
741:
740:
739:
734:
729:
728:
727:
725:
719:
718:
715:
712:
706:
704:
690:
685:
682:
671:
670:
666:
663:
660:
656:
655:Sven Manguard
653:
647:
645:
641:
636:
635:
627:
624:
622:
619:
617:
614:
613:
611:
610:
605:
599:
596:
594:
591:
589:
586:
585:
583:
582:
577:
571:
569:
568:
564:
560:
556:
553:
549:
540:
538:
534:
530:
526:
522:
514:
512:
508:
504:
500:
489:
474:
470:
464:
461:
460:
457:
440:
439:
434:
431:
427:
426:
422:
416:
413:
410:
406:
393:
390:(assessed as
389:
388:
378:
374:
373:
369:
365:
359:
356:
355:
352:
335:
331:
327:
326:
318:
307:
305:
302:
298:
297:
293:
286:
281:
278:
275:
271:
258:
255:(assessed as
254:
253:
245:
244:Sports portal
234:
227:
223:
222:
219:
202:
201:documentation
198:
194:
190:
189:
181:
170:
168:
165:
161:
160:
156:
152:
147:
144:
141:
137:
132:
128:
122:
114:
110:
105:
104:
96:
95:
90:
86:
82:
79:
75:
71:
70:
65:
63:
62:
54:
50:
46:
45:
40:
36:
35:
34:
28:
25:
18:
17:
1002:
987:
983:NOT PROMOTED
982:
977:
975:
947:
945:
916:
914:
901:
899:
886:
884:
842:
840:
784:
782:
724:Well written
723:
720:
710:
695:
688:
686:
672:
661:
651:
650:
637:
626:Instructions
557:
554:
550:
546:
515:
493:
468:
436:
385:
363:
323:
250:
186:
127:WikiProjects
92:
80:
73:
67:
42:
31:
30:
26:
958:have them:
744:notability.
640:transcluded
519:—Preceding
503:68.34.56.59
497:—Preceding
117:Start-class
53:renominated
1017:Categories
971:Acceptable
941:Acceptable
930:Acceptable
911:Acceptable
896:Acceptable
880:Acceptable
827:No comment
809:Needs work
798:Acceptable
761:Needs work
737:Needs work
593:Authorship
579:GA toolbox
956:alt texts
917:Image use
652:Reviewer:
616:Templates
607:Reviewing
572:GA Review
206:Biography
146:Biography
85:libellous
49:please do
856:Question
681:Criteria
665:contribs
621:Criteria
533:contribs
525:Ifididit
521:unsigned
499:unsigned
444:Referees
415:Referees
339:Baseball
330:baseball
280:Baseball
995:anguard
887:Neutral
773:WP:LEAD
703:anguard
675:1.24 SM
471:on the
366:on the
285:Umpires
902:Stable
768:cited.
123:scale.
642:from
1003:Wha?
991:ven
711:Wha?
699:ven
659:talk
563:talk
529:talk
507:talk
463:High
195:and
960:N/A
946:7.
915:6.
900:5.
885:4.
845::
841:3.
783:2.
722:1.
358:Mid
74:BLP
1019::
950::
919::
904::
889::
787::
726::
667:)
565:)
535:)
531:•
509:)
394:).
283::
259:).
149::
993:M
989:S
775:.
701:M
697:S
683:)
679:(
662:·
657:(
561:(
527:(
505:(
475:.
370:.
203:.
129::
97:.
72:(
55:.
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
