71:
53:
22:
322:
160:
735:
564:, as they are named populations of that species, not certainly classified as subspecies, nor their own species, and are not separately covered at the article as subtopics, but only mentioned in passing. I have other stuff to do, but a cursory inspection suggests that about 85% of the uses of this template should be replaced with another one, usually
827:
774:
301:) be if many or most links led to the genus article? Sometimes those lists are contained in the genus article, so creating binomial redirects to the genus would just loop those blue links back to the article a reader started on. In general practice, species binomials are not redirected to the genus unless monotypic.
358:, the city's regional unit; one is a subset of the other. I can understand the use of maintenance categories, but the benefit of creating such redirects for the sake of editors over the utility to readers doesn't seem worth it. Thanks for your thoughts on my comments, and for the suggestion to see what light
572:. Short analogy: "my pets" is a topic; "my cat" and "my dog" are subtopics; "my cat when sleeping" and "my dog in the back yard" are more specific names, in this case for different states of those subtopics. I'll try to update the documentation to forestall more inappropriate uses of this template.
246:
is more specific and not when the redirect's scope or topic is more specific. For example, this template has been used frequently for redirects created at a species binomial name to an article on the genus when the genus contains many species. Those redirects should be deleted, as redirects are for
411:
should not be used to redirect species articles to genus article unless they're monotypic. Except for that kind of case, species should not redir to genus articles at all, for the link-loop reason given above. If I linked to a species and got a redlink, I would divide that up temporarily like
293:, even stubs with very little information on a species are usually kept in deletion discussions. Genus articles usually have "virtually no information" on the species, other than the fact that it is contained in that genus. What use would a list of species (like
416:, so that there is a blue-link present that goes to the genus, but the species name remains redlinked, since there's a general consensus that such redlinks inspire article creation. Looking through "what links here", I can see some uses that don't make sense.
318:
what the intended usage should be. Another thing to consider is that all of these rcat templates sort redirects to "maintenance" categories, which are set up to be monitored by contributors for reasons they hopefully make clear. So the inclusion of
417:
350:. The intended topic of both titles is the same, whereas when a species binomial redirects to a genus, the intended topics are different in scope, even if they are related. It would be like redirecting
846:
508:
is a good example; it's one of various specific cases of the topic of the general article, but unlikely to become a subtopic with its own section. A borderline case is redirecting
793:
743:
500:
also works, since "military monastic order" is a more specific name for the same thing as "military order" in the monastic sense, which is the primary topic for "military order".
524:, or at least subtopics treated separately, e.g. in their own sections or in a section on Southwestern cuisine. If they were treated separately like that, use
699:, but the labeling is correct for that case, and the template at some point could be converted to a special template and category for that case specifically.
180:. Substantial changes should first be proposed and discussed here on this page. If the proposal is uncontroversial or has been discussed and is supported by
207:
223:
202:
289:#10 says, "If the redirect could plausibly be expanded into an article, and the target article contains virtually no information on the subject." Per
398:
314:, and it may very well be that this rcat was meant for a different usage. The only way to determine that would be to ask the creator of the rcat,
857:
605:; it's a subspecies not covered in any depth and unlikely ever to be. If that changes and we have a whole section for it at some point, then use
874:
247:
articles covering the same concept or topic under a different name. Not quite sure how to present that in the documentation, though. Thoughts?
190:
91:
739:
837:
819:
784:
766:
727:
342:. This template certainly makes sense when a more specific name for an equivalent topic is redirected to a more general name, e.g. when
406:
165:
711:
648:
584:
497:
99:
This banner should be placed on the talk pages of project, template and category pages that exist and operate to maintain redirects.
78:
58:
686:
374:
185:
177:
188:}} to notify an administrator or template editor to make the requested edit. Usually, any contributor may edit the template's
33:
621:
171:
465:
120:
476:
makes no sense at all (and the existence of the redir suggests that the article should be moved, anyway). The redir from
290:
854:
751:
421:
281:
Yes, a binomial is more specific than the more general genus name, but the two are separate taxa unless the genus is
218:
382:
631:
762:
694:
615:
608:
567:
535:
527:
484:
is the same kind of case. I've fixed these bad examples as I go. Good examples of the template's use include
451:
443:
427:
39:
549:
493:
294:
90:
on
Knowledge (XXG). If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the
851:
747:
433:
801:
181:
115:
708:
645:
598:
581:
561:
541:
70:
52:
841:
788:
83:
746:
until a consensus is reached, and readers of this page are welcome to contribute to the discussion.
553:
339:
327:
276:
263:
261:– isn't a species binomial name a more specific name than a genus name? or am I missing something? –
242:
I think it would be nice to clarify in the documentation that this template is for use only when the
815:
545:
492:; the king card has four more specific names, none of which are subtopics from a WP point of view.
489:
481:
860:
808:
755:
720:
667:
657:
593:
366:
333:
305:
269:
251:
664:
625:
557:
363:
311:
302:
258:
248:
521:
343:
744:
Knowledge (XXG):Redirects for discussion/Log/2020 June 29#Template:R from subspecies to species
461:
355:
321:
87:
702:
639:
575:
359:
315:
228:
226:
220:
501:
473:
388:
282:
505:
485:
286:
868:
602:
437:
195:
847:
Knowledge (XXG):Redirects for discussion/Log/2024 September 14 § Template:R specific
794:
Knowledge (XXG):Redirects for discussion/Log/2024 March 4 § Template:R from subtitle
221:
517:
362:
might be able to shine on the use of this template for binomial redirects. Cheers,
509:
457:
371:
I just intended it to be taken at face value, as something more specific than
513:
424:; titles issued by the order are a subtopic of the order, and so should use
469:
826:
773:
734:
477:
392:
351:
347:
663:
Thanks very much for the detailed response! Much appreciated. Cheers,
844:. Readers of this page are welcome to comment on this redirect at
791:. Readers of this page are welcome to comment on this redirect at
520:, since those actually could be articles in their own right, like
418:
Knight
Commander of the Most Excellent Order of the British Empire
325:
genus might be to show where new articles may be generated. –
154:
108:
designed to be placed on the talk pages of most redirects and
15:
225:
219:
832:
779:
211:
738:
A discussion is taking place to address the redirect
840:
to determine whether its use and function meets the
787:
to determine whether its use and function meets the
82:, a collaborative effort to improve the standard of
403:or one of its more specific variants. I agree that
726:"Template:R from subspecies to species" listed at
468:anyway. The use of this template on the redirect
32:does not require a rating on Knowledge (XXG)'s
464:; it's a subtopic, and should really redir to
210:subpage. You can create the testcases subpage
8:
47:
516:(spelled thus, in the New Mexico way) to
200:Any contributor may edit the template's
118:redirects. For more information see the
178:heavily used or highly visible template
49:
456:. The template also doesn't belong on
740:Template:R from subspecies to species
466:Palatalization (sound change)#Mouillé
21:
19:
7:
131:Knowledge (XXG):WikiProject Redirect
38:It is of interest to the following
683:PS: The species cases really need
560:can use this template to redir to
166:Template:R from more specific name
14:
498:Military order (monastic society)
76:This page is within the scope of
825:
772:
733:
691:; that template alias points to
420:isn't a more specific name than
320:
206:. This template does not have a
158:
69:
51:
20:
850:until a consensus is reached.
797:until a consensus is reached.
742:. The discussion will occur at
399:R from specific geographic name
861:20:32, 14 September 2024 (UTC)
622:Long-tailed hermit hummingbird
257:Not quite sure what you mean,
1:
875:Template-Class redirect pages
700:
637:
573:
134:Template:WikiProject Redirect
94:and see a list of open tasks.
597:PS: Another good example is
379:; it's a sister template to
440:; that one should use both
422:Order of the British Empire
891:
809:09:55, 4 March 2024 (UTC)
756:18:46, 29 June 2020 (UTC)
620:. Another bad example is
407:R from more specific name
64:
46:
838:redirects for discussion
820:Redirects for discussion
785:redirects for discussion
780:Template:R from subtitle
767:Redirects for discussion
763:Template:R from subtitle
728:Redirects for discussion
721:14:23, 31 May 2015 (UTC)
668:01:06, 23 May 2015 (UTC)
658:15:49, 22 May 2015 (UTC)
594:15:28, 22 May 2015 (UTC)
367:00:47, 20 May 2015 (UTC)
334:19:15, 19 May 2015 (UTC)
310:You make a valid point,
306:15:55, 19 May 2015 (UTC)
270:06:50, 19 May 2015 (UTC)
252:12:50, 15 May 2015 (UTC)
687:R from species to genus
494:Military monastic order
375:R from alternative name
186:edit template-protected
550:Bannerman's shearwater
434:Weighted harmonic mean
194:to add usage notes or
121:template documentation
599:Western olive sunbird
114:on the talk pages of
562:Audubon's shearwater
554:Mascarene shearwater
542:Baillon's shearwater
532:and if appropriate,
184:, editors may use {{
79:WikiProject Redirect
842:redirect guidelines
836:has been listed at
833:Template:R specific
816:Template:R specific
789:redirect guidelines
783:has been listed at
628:; that's a case of
546:Tropical shearwater
490:King (playing card)
482:Schtick (disc game)
626:Long-tailed hermit
558:Persian shearwater
291:WP:SPECIESOUTCOMES
34:content assessment
748:1234qwer1234qwer4
462:Palatal consonant
432:. Same goes for
383:R from short name
356:Aetolia-Acarnania
235:
234:
153:
152:
149:
148:
145:
144:
125:
882:
835:
829:
804:
800:
782:
776:
737:
719:
698:
690:
656:
635:
632:R from long name
619:
612:
592:
571:
539:
531:
455:
447:
431:
415:
410:
402:
386:
378:
324:
280:
229:
176:because it is a
162:
161:
155:
139:
138:
135:
132:
129:
101:
73:
66:
65:
55:
48:
25:
24:
23:
16:
890:
889:
885:
884:
883:
881:
880:
879:
865:
864:
831:
823:
807:
802:
798:
778:
770:
731:
717:
695:R from subtopic
692:
684:
654:
629:
616:R to subsection
613:
609:R from subtopic
606:
590:
568:R from subtopic
565:
536:R to subsection
533:
528:R from subtopic
525:
522:Jalapeño pepper
502:Fifteenth chord
488:redirecting to
474:Big Jake (film)
460:redirecting to
452:R to subsection
449:
444:R from subtopic
441:
436:redirecting to
428:R from subtopic
425:
413:
404:
396:
391:redirecting to
389:Agrinio, Greece
380:
372:
344:Agrínio, Greece
277:Paine Ellsworth
274:
240:
231:
230:
224:
159:
136:
133:
130:
127:
126:
113:
107:
102:This banner is
12:
11:
5:
888:
886:
878:
877:
867:
866:
822:
812:
806:
803:a smart kitten
769:
759:
730:
724:
715:
681:
680:
679:
678:
677:
676:
675:
674:
673:
672:
671:
670:
652:
588:
506:Extended chord
486:King of spades
239:
236:
233:
232:
227:
222:
217:
216:
163:
151:
150:
147:
146:
143:
142:
140:
137:redirect pages
109:
103:
100:
95:
88:categorization
74:
62:
61:
56:
44:
43:
37:
26:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
887:
876:
873:
872:
870:
863:
862:
859:
856:
853:
849:
848:
843:
839:
834:
830:The redirect
828:
821:
817:
813:
811:
810:
805:
796:
795:
790:
786:
781:
777:The redirect
775:
768:
764:
760:
758:
757:
753:
749:
745:
741:
736:
729:
725:
723:
722:
713:
710:
707:
705:
696:
688:
669:
666:
662:
661:
660:
659:
650:
647:
644:
642:
633:
627:
623:
617:
610:
604:
603:Olive sunbird
600:
595:
586:
583:
580:
578:
569:
563:
559:
555:
551:
547:
543:
537:
529:
523:
519:
515:
511:
507:
503:
499:
495:
491:
487:
483:
479:
475:
471:
467:
463:
459:
453:
445:
439:
438:Harmonic mean
435:
429:
423:
419:
408:
400:
394:
390:
384:
376:
370:
369:
368:
365:
361:
357:
353:
349:
346:redirects to
345:
341:
337:
336:
335:
332:
331:
330:
323:
317:
313:
309:
308:
307:
304:
300:
298:
292:
288:
284:
278:
273:
272:
271:
268:
267:
266:
260:
256:
255:
254:
253:
250:
245:
238:Clarification
237:
215:
213:
209:
205:
204:
197:
193:
192:
191:documentation
187:
183:
179:
175:
173:
167:
164:
157:
156:
141:
123:
122:
117:
112:
106:
98:
93:
89:
85:
81:
80:
75:
72:
68:
67:
63:
60:
57:
54:
50:
45:
41:
35:
31:
27:
18:
17:
845:
824:
818:" listed at
792:
771:
765:" listed at
732:
703:
682:
640:
596:
576:
518:Chili pepper
328:
326:
296:
264:
262:
243:
241:
201:
199:
189:
174:from editing
170:permanently
169:
119:
111:almost never
110:
104:
96:
77:
40:WikiProjects
29:
704:SMcCandlish
641:SMcCandlish
577:SMcCandlish
510:Green chile
360:SMcCandlish
316:SMcCandlish
287:WP:R#DELETE
540:. All of
196:categories
92:discussion
86:and their
514:Red chile
283:monotypic
208:testcases
182:consensus
172:protected
116:mainspace
84:redirects
869:Category
855:1234qwer
852:1234qwer
470:Big Jake
387:, etc.
338:Thanks,
295:List of
128:Redirect
59:Redirect
30:template
478:Schtick
458:Mouillé
393:Agrinio
352:Agrinio
348:Agrinio
319:species
299:species
297:Drosera
203:sandbox
665:Rkitko
624:-: -->
601:-: -->
504:-: -->
496:-: -->
395:needs
364:Rkitko
312:Rkitko
303:Rkitko
259:Rkitko
249:Rkitko
36:scale.
340:Paine
329:Paine
265:Paine
97:Note:
28:This
752:talk
556:and
512:and
448:and
244:name
212:here
799:—
718:ⱷ≼
714:≽ⱷ҅
655:ⱷ≼
651:≽ⱷ҅
591:ⱷ≼
587:≽ⱷ҅
480:to
472:to
414:] ]
354:to
168:is
105:not
871::
754:)
701:—
697:}}
693:{{
689:}}
685:{{
638:—
636:.
634:}}
630:{{
618:}}
614:{{
611:}}
607:{{
574:—
570:}}
566:{{
552:,
548:,
544:,
538:}}
534:{{
530:}}
526:{{
454:}}
450:{{
446:}}
442:{{
430:}}
426:{{
409:}}
405:{{
401:}}
397:{{
385:}}
381:{{
377:}}
373:{{
285:.
214:.
198:.
858:4
814:"
761:"
750:(
716:ᴥ
712:¢
709:☏
706:☺
653:ᴥ
649:¢
646:☏
643:☺
589:ᴥ
585:¢
582:☏
579:☺
279::
275:@
124:.
42::
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
