Knowledge (XXG)

The Black Book: Imbalance of Power and Wealth in the Sudan

Source 📝

60: 583: 305:
Publishing houses were checked and journalists, academics and other known writers were questioned to determine the book's origin. However, the book was already out and being photocopied and spread. One estimate put the total number of photocopies secretly made by individuals at 50,000. An owner of a photocopying shop in Khartoum was quoted as saying, "I made no less that [
738:"the obituary of the Islamic revolution". However, by the time of its publication, the cell members had already decided that internal reform was impossible and that armed resistance was the only course of action. In 2001, they sent twenty of their leaders to begin openly organizing and, in August 2001, Khalil Ibrahim announced the existence of the 730:, and third in Khartoum in 1997. Most of the Khartoum cell were university graduates and most were Islamists. The year that the Khartoum cell was formed, the dissidents decided that their first step should be to inform the populace of the structural problems; a 25-man committee was set up to gather information and begin writing. Julie Flint and 254:
Part II was originally supposed to concentrate on policy recommendations stemming from the analysis in Part I. However, the Sudanese government so strongly attacked the findings of the first part that the writers instead took the opportunity to back up the original publication. Part II thus consists
296:
The fact that the writers identified themselves only as "The Seekers of Truth and Justice", without a place of publication or copyright notice, only added to the mystery. Over three days, 1600 copies were handed out—800 in Khartoum, 500 in other parts of Sudan (except the South) and 300 abroad.
204:
The first of the many charts details the populations of the various regions and number of Federal/National-level representatives, as a percentage of the total, since independence. It pointed out that every single president had come from the North. The book goes on to break down these numbers of
304:
Government newspapers launched attacks on the publication in front page articles, denouncing the authors as "tribalists". Security forces attempted to discover the authors, while it was rumored that several junior government staffers had been fired after copies were found on ministers' desks.
222:
states that the equipment that was to be used for the Western Highway Project was diverted to the Northern Highway Project, which is both widely rumored and believed, but no evidence is provided to back it up. El-Tom further makes the following observations: it has an implicit view of Sudan as
189:, Part I, states its thesis: "This publication unveils the level of injustice practised by successive governments, secular and theocratic, democratic or autocratic, since the independence of the country in 1956 to this date." The main argument of the book, which is demonstrated using simple a 291:
it said nothing to the average Northern Sudanese that they did not know already. What created a shock were not the contents of the book but simply the fact that an unspoken taboo had been broken and that somebody had dared to put into print what everybody knew but did not want to talk about.
706:
The book's critics, mainly government officials connected to al-Bashir, have consistently claimed that it was made at the direction of al-Turabi. Al-Turabi has denied any connection with either the book or with the JEM. In interviews, writers have stated that they, al-Turabi and the ruling
687:, people could solve the political and social problems afflicting the country. Many Muslims from the disadvantaged regions of West, East and Central Sudan flocked to al-Turabi and his message. However, by the mid-1990s, the Islamist project was collapsing due to entrenched 217:
Academic Abdullahi El-Tom, in his critique of the book, states that the latter half is not nearly as well-argued as the heavily statistical beginning, making points that are then not substantiated and sometimes falling into polemical statements. For example, the
319:
by word of mouth. The document, as controversial as it was, quickly became central to Sudanese political discourse. Political factions campaigning for support in the West found that political discussion revolved around the western highway project, salaries for
205:
representation by regime since independence, constitutionally mandated posts, and state governorships, all illustrated through charts. After dealing with the central point about inequality in positions of high office, the
563:
There can be no doubt that the current dictatorship has been pernicious for the human development of the regions outside of the North and Khartoum. There can be no question that the data support the claims made in the
209:
goes on to detail similarly disproportionate results in the number of Attorneys General, executive staff in the Ministry of Finance and the National Council for Distribution of Resources, which allocates
43:
of the rest of the country. It was published in two parts, the first in May 2000 and the second on August 2002. While published anonymously, it was later revealed that the writers had strong ties to the
750:
was put up on the JEM website. Almost all of the authors joined the JEM or secular resistance movements. As of October 2006, the JEM continued its armed rebellion in Darfur in a conflict that had
559:
did a parallel study in 2005, including an analysis of income generation and expenditure by region to determine if there was a pattern of subsidies between regions. He concluded,
214:
wealth, as well to note the cultural domination of the national media by northerners. Practically every major sector of society is analyzed to show a pattern of northern control.
703:, al-Turabi's former follower, defected to the side of al-Bashir and, in December 1999, al-Bashir declared a state of emergency, stripping al-Turabi of his position and power. 651: 623: 630: 637: 600: 619: 311:] 100 copies for our customers. We sometimes charged them more due to the risk involved in duplicating illegal documents." Given the high levels of 593: 792: 275:
after Friday evening prayers were greeted by polite young men passing out thick photocopied stapled versions on A4 paper. Such an activity in
1000: 644: 36: 857: 833: 279:
Sudan was unusual; the fact that the document being passed out was an indictment of the national power structure has been termed "
1005: 975: 608: 947: 939: 739: 235:) over the other marginalized regions; and it has an unforgiving stance towards all the north, rather than just the three 45: 255:
of the listing of every single government official counted in the first part, with their regional and clan affiliation.
990: 743: 696: 692: 985: 683:. Al-Turabi appeared to promise political Islam as a solution; that with hard work and honesty as part of the 995: 943: 568:
that the Sudan has been governed to benefit those regions disproportionately at the expense of all others.
980: 726:
to discuss the possibility of reforming the NIF from within. A second clandestine cell formed in 1994 in
708: 700: 59: 35:), is a manuscript detailing a pattern of disproportionate political control by the people of northern 900: 695:
with the south. In 1998, al-Turabi managed to position himself as Speaker of the House under the new
688: 556: 555:
In an attempt to double-check the book's central conclusion of national inequity, Alex Cobham of the
953: 875: 804: 958: 853: 845: 829: 284: 751: 676: 194: 870: 49: 40: 28: 746:(SLM) already active in Darfur. Exactly a year after the announcement, Part II of the 719: 298: 896: 969: 881: 321: 821: 731: 201:
have a disproportionate amount of political power compared to other ethnic groups.
582: 312: 280: 276: 190: 718:
The writers trace their roots to 1993, when a cell of NIF members, including
723: 244: 727: 673: 272: 240: 232: 198: 325: 301:
and other senior government officials while they were out for prayers.
248: 722:, the former Darfur Minister of Education, began meeting in secret in 268: 228: 53: 742:, a group that would form a minority partner with the secular rebel 684: 224: 58: 793:"The Black Book of Sudan: Imbalance of Power and Wealth in Sudan" 680: 236: 711:, but that al-Turabi had nothing to do with the writing of the 679:
had returned from exile, and in 1989 took power in a military
576: 307: 211: 620:"The Black Book: Imbalance of Power and Wealth in the Sudan" 18:
The Black Book: Imbalance of Power and Wealth in the Sudan
193:
analysis of Sudan's population by ethnicity, is that the
604: 297:
Copies were reportedly left on the desks on President
227:; it emphasizes the grievances of Western Sudan (i.e. 897:"Causes of conflict in Sudan: Testing the Black Book" 871:"The Black Book history or Darfur's darkest chapter" 239:identified as controlling the government (i.e. the 899:. Queen Elizabeth House Working Paper Number 121. 691:and widespread anger at the waste of lives in the 8: 609:introducing citations to additional sources 267:had a dramatic introduction. People leaving 707:government were all connected through the 338:1996–2000 averages (% of value for North) 816: 814: 786: 784: 782: 780: 778: 599:Relevant discussion may be found on the 334: 71: 946:of the Black Book in English, from the 763: 913: 954:Was the Black Book Correct? – Opinion 826:Darfur: A Short History of a Long War 7: 797:Journal of African National Affairs 315:in Sudan, most people heard of the 852:, Cornell University Press, 2005, 14: 336:Regional revenue and expenditure, 828:, Zed Books, London March 2006, 592:relies largely or entirely on a 581: 850:Darfur: The Ambiguous Genocide 1: 948:Justice and Equality Movement 895:Cobham, Alex (January 2005). 740:Justice and Equality Movement 46:Justice and Equality Movement 1001:Anti-black racism in Africa 1022: 803:(2): 25–35. Archived from 48:, a rebel group active in 791:Abdullahi El-Tom (2003). 744:Sudan Liberation Movement 693:Second Sudanese Civil War 259:Distribution and reaction 925:Flint and de Waal, p. 18 73:Population (1986 census) 21:, known commonly as the 1006:Discrimination in Sudan 754:hundreds of thousands. 976:2000 non-fiction books 709:National Islamic Front 701:Ali Osman Mohamed Taha 573:Authorship and context 570: 294: 64: 52:that later erupted in 561: 289: 62: 901:University of Oxford 758:Notes and references 605:improve this article 557:University of Oxford 63:Map of Sudan in 2000 876:The Financial Times 672:In the early 1980s 339: 76: 75:and representation 962:, October 16, 2006 335: 185:The first page of 72: 65: 991:Politics of Sudan 885:), 20 August 2004 820:Flint, Julie and 697:National Congress 670: 669: 655: 553: 552: 183: 182: 33:al-kitab al-aswad 1013: 926: 923: 917: 911: 905: 904: 892: 886: 879:(copy hosted by 869:William Wallis, 867: 861: 843: 837: 818: 809: 808: 788: 773: 768: 677:Hassan al-Turabi 665: 662: 656: 654: 613: 585: 577: 340: 77: 31:: الكتاب الأسود 1021: 1020: 1016: 1015: 1014: 1012: 1011: 1010: 986:Political books 966: 965: 935: 930: 929: 924: 920: 912: 908: 894: 893: 889: 868: 864: 844: 840: 819: 812: 790: 789: 776: 769: 765: 760: 666: 660: 657: 614: 612: 598: 586: 575: 439: 370: 368: 363: 361: 356: 354: 349: 347: 337: 261: 90: 74: 70: 41:marginalization 12: 11: 5: 1019: 1017: 1009: 1008: 1003: 998: 996:Sudanese books 993: 988: 983: 978: 968: 967: 964: 963: 951: 934: 933:External links 931: 928: 927: 918: 906: 887: 862: 846:Gérard Prunier 838: 810: 807:on 2008-05-16. 774: 762: 761: 759: 756: 720:Khalil Ibrahim 668: 667: 603:. Please help 589: 587: 580: 574: 571: 551: 550: 545: 540: 535: 530: 524: 523: 518: 513: 508: 503: 497: 496: 493: 490: 487: 484: 480: 479: 476: 473: 470: 467: 463: 462: 457: 452: 447: 442: 434: 433: 428: 423: 418: 413: 407: 406: 403: 400: 397: 394: 390: 389: 386: 383: 380: 377: 373: 372: 365: 358: 351: 344: 322:civil servants 299:Omar al-Bashir 285:Gérard Prunier 260: 257: 195:riverine Arabs 187:the Black Book 181: 180: 177: 174: 171: 168: 164: 163: 160: 157: 154: 151: 147: 146: 143: 140: 137: 134: 130: 129: 126: 123: 120: 117: 113: 112: 109: 106: 103: 100: 96: 95: 92: 87: 84: 81: 69: 66: 13: 10: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 1018: 1007: 1004: 1002: 999: 997: 994: 992: 989: 987: 984: 982: 981:War in Darfur 979: 977: 974: 973: 971: 961: 960: 955: 952: 949: 945: 941: 937: 936: 932: 922: 919: 916:, p. 10. 915: 910: 907: 903:. p. 17. 902: 898: 891: 888: 884: 883: 882:Sudan Tribune 878: 877: 872: 866: 863: 859: 858:0-8014-4450-0 855: 851: 847: 842: 839: 835: 834:1-84277-697-5 831: 827: 823: 817: 815: 811: 806: 802: 798: 794: 787: 785: 783: 781: 779: 775: 772: 767: 764: 757: 755: 753: 749: 745: 741: 737: 733: 729: 725: 721: 716: 714: 710: 704: 702: 698: 694: 690: 686: 682: 678: 675: 664: 653: 650: 646: 643: 639: 636: 632: 629: 625: 622: –  621: 617: 616:Find sources: 610: 606: 602: 596: 595: 594:single source 590:This section 588: 584: 579: 578: 572: 569: 567: 560: 558: 549: 546: 544: 541: 539: 536: 534: 531: 529: 526: 525: 522: 519: 517: 514: 512: 509: 507: 504: 502: 499: 498: 494: 491: 488: 485: 482: 481: 477: 474: 471: 468: 465: 464: 461: 458: 456: 453: 451: 448: 446: 443: 441: 436: 435: 432: 429: 427: 424: 422: 419: 417: 414: 412: 409: 408: 404: 401: 398: 395: 392: 391: 387: 384: 381: 378: 375: 374: 366: 359: 352: 345: 342: 341: 333: 331: 327: 324:, especially 323: 318: 314: 310: 309: 302: 300: 293: 288: 286: 282: 281:revolutionary 278: 274: 270: 266: 258: 256: 252: 250: 246: 242: 238: 234: 230: 226: 221: 215: 213: 208: 202: 200: 196: 192: 188: 178: 175: 172: 169: 166: 165: 161: 158: 155: 152: 149: 148: 144: 141: 138: 135: 132: 131: 127: 124: 121: 118: 115: 114: 110: 107: 104: 101: 98: 97: 93: 88: 85: 82: 79: 78: 67: 61: 57: 56:to the west. 55: 51: 47: 42: 38: 34: 30: 26: 25: 20: 19: 959:Sudan Mirror 957: 921: 909: 890: 880: 874: 865: 849: 841: 825: 822:Alex de Waal 805:the original 800: 796: 770: 766: 747: 735: 732:Alex de Waal 717: 712: 705: 699:. However, 671: 658: 648: 641: 634: 627: 615: 591: 565: 562: 554: 547: 542: 537: 532: 527: 520: 515: 510: 505: 500: 459: 454: 449: 444: 437: 430: 425: 420: 415: 410: 329: 316: 306: 303: 295: 290: 283:". Scholar 264: 262: 253: 219: 216: 206: 203: 186: 184: 50:the conflict 32: 23: 22: 17: 16: 15: 950:'s website. 914:Cobham 2005 438:Central ex. 371:per capita 369:expenditure 367:Development 364:per capita 357:per capita 350:per capita 348:expenditure 287:notes that 191:statistical 83:Population 970:Categories 771:Black Book 748:Black Book 736:Black Book 734:call the 713:Black Book 689:corruption 631:newspapers 566:Black Book 330:Black Book 328:, and the 317:Black Book 313:illiteracy 265:Black Book 220:Black Book 207:Black Book 170:6,072,872 153:4,407,450 136:4,908,038 119:2,222,779 102:1,026,406 91:sentation 24:Black Book 752:displaced 724:al-Fashir 661:July 2013 601:talk page 360:Effective 245:Jaaliyeen 150:Southern 99:Northern 728:Kurdufan 674:Islamist 528:Kordofan 440:Khartoum 411:Khartoum 393:Central 326:teachers 277:censored 273:Khartoum 247:and the 241:Shaigiya 233:Kordofan 199:Khartoum 167:Western 133:Central 116:Eastern 68:Contents 860:, p. 73 836:, p. 17 645:scholar 362:subsidy 355:revenue 343:Region 269:mosques 249:Danagla 225:Islamic 80:Region 938:Parts 856:  832:  647:  640:  633:  626:  618:  501:Darfur 405:245.5 399:134.1 396:104.0 388:100.0 385:100.0 382:100.0 379:100.0 376:North 243:, the 229:Darfur 89:Repre- 54:Darfur 29:Arabic 685:Ummah 652:JSTOR 638:books 495:17.0 492:43.3 489:43.9 486:44.1 483:West 478:79.5 472:98.4 469:73.7 466:East 431:532.9 421:213.7 416:161.5 402:16.8 353:Total 346:Total 237:clans 197:near 173:32.6 162:16.4 156:23.7 139:26.5 122:11.8 111:79.5 37:Sudan 942:and 854:ISBN 830:ISBN 681:coup 624:news 548:15.5 543:57.5 538:47.6 533:49.9 521:17.2 516:35.1 511:41.5 506:40.6 475:1.6 460:35.5 455:23.8 450:70.9 445:60.6 426:13.3 263:The 231:and 145:2.8 128:1.4 105:5.4 39:and 607:by 308:sic 271:in 251:). 212:oil 159:12 108:58 972:: 956:, 873:, 848:, 824:, 813:^ 799:. 795:. 777:^ 715:. 332:. 179:0 176:0 142:2 125:1 94:% 86:% 944:2 940:1 801:1 663:) 659:( 649:· 642:· 635:· 628:· 611:. 597:. 27:(

Index

Arabic
Sudan
marginalization
Justice and Equality Movement
the conflict
Darfur

statistical
riverine Arabs
Khartoum
oil
Islamic
Darfur
Kordofan
clans
Shaigiya
Jaaliyeen
Danagla
mosques
Khartoum
censored
revolutionary
Gérard Prunier
Omar al-Bashir
sic
illiteracy
civil servants
teachers
University of Oxford

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.