User talk:Buidhe/Archive 1 - Knowledge (XXG)

594:. I gave you the broader page for context (and in case you speak any other languages or have friends that do), but there is plenty to do in Spanish, and each language is separated into its own list. Are you a native speaker? I have done some of the Spanish but haven't made a formal study of the language let alone the grammar, simply been around it a lot, and could well be missing nuances. I would welcome a review of my work or some help with some of those not yet done. Feel free to ask any questions about this or anything else. Probably best to start with reviewiing unreviewed articles in terms of the project priorities, but as always in wikipedia nothing is compulsory. Ping 3454:"Europa Plan aimed to rescue all European Jews, but historians are unanimous and most contemporaries (even a majority of the Working Group) agreed that this was hopeless from the start" Certainly not correct. Historians are not unanimous. Also, the Working Group would not have asked Jewish organizations in the free world for the large down payment if they felt the plan was hopeless. Any statement about the likelihood of the plan succeeding or being hopeless is mere speculation since the down payment was not made and no one can tell with certainty (one way or the other) if the Nazis would have adhered to the ransom condition. 474:, sometimes by users with no knowledge of the source language. The config problem that allowed this to happen has since been fixed, but this has left us with a backlog of articles whose accuracy of translation is suspect or unknown, including some articles translated from Spanish. In many cases, other editors have come forward later to copyedit and fix any English grammar or style issues, but that doesn't necessarily mean that the translation is accurate, as factual errors from the original translation may remain. To put it another way: 3451:(b) Yad Vashem states that Kastner rescued large number of Jews by negotiation. For purpose of tis note suppose it is so. He learned the "invention" of negotiating with the Nazis from the Working Group (Rabbi Weissmandl) and he and others in Budapest were also advised by the Working Group (probably Rabbi Weissmandl) to trust Wisliceny in negotiations. Thus, according to this, many Jews outside Slovakia were rescued due to the Working Group. They didn't have to stand by the departing transports in Hungary to save Jews.... 418:

would seem that many new speakers (i.e. those who don’t come from Gaelic speaking homes) stop using Gaelic actively on a daily basis. But it does not mean that they don’t use it! The same goes for many people who learnt a foreign language in an immersion environment at some stage (Erasmus students for instance). They may not use the language on a daily basis, but that does not mean the learning has been useless and that these new speakers won’t use it anymore in their life. Bit of a quick conclusion in my view.

3465:

no chance of success are consciously or subconsciously apologists for the organizations who could have helped, but did not. Noteworthy that even the Spring 1942 ransom money was obtained with great difficulty after Rabbi Weissmandl had to threaten the Budapest Orthodox community with meeting in the "courts above" in the after-life. Of course there are historians who claim the Spring 1942 negotiations were useless - had no impact. There are, as usual, many opinions.

3181:

is or if his presentation is referenced anywhere. Still, based on understanding the math and common sense I'd surely use the video as a reference in an article on the topic. The second reference is by a very bright postdoctoral physics student at Cambridge U. I don't know if her presentation is reviewed anywhere, but would certainly assume she is worth quoting solely because of the quality of the presentation and the fact that she was accepted to be at Cambridge.

3351:, probably the highest calibre historian who has written about the Working Group, wrote that "According to all the documentation we have, especially the book Weissmandel wrote after the war, testimonies by Steiner, Kovdfc, and Neumann, and Fleischmann's letters, it is clear that Fleischmann headed the Working Group." Bauer, Rethinking the Holocaust p. 178. She was not involved in the spring 1944 activities because she was under arrest at the time (Bauer 182). 31: 3413:. Yes, it's true that the Europa Plan aimed to rescue all European Jews, but historians are unanimous and most contemporaries (even a majority of the Working Group) agreed that this was hopeless from the start. The Working Group did not save any Jews who were not Slovak Jews, but they may have helped to save some Slovak Jews. So, I think it's best not to overemphasize the scope and importance of the later negotiations. 151:

general references only or the sources may not be available in English. In some cases I have left proper nouns (organizations or individuals) in Gaelic if I am unsure of the English equivalent, or which name is used more commonly in English. Also, my Gaelic is not perfect so I may have mistranslated something. Please be aware of this when reviewing my translations and leave a message here if there is an issue. Thanks!

1828: 964: 4086:, 152,940 Italian civilians died during the war, far more than the 22,000. A fair share of those would have been killed through causes directly related to German activities (Civilian casualties of German bombing raids, food & medicine shortages in the occupied areas, e.t.c.) that weren't classified as war crimes. If I can think of a good hook I will put it up as a suggestion on the nomination page. 3448:(a) The Auschwitz Report reached with immense delay Mantello in Switzerland who immediately publicized it. It had great impact in Switzerland with very loud echo world-wide. Was one of the main reasons why the transports from Hungary stopped after Horthy was threatened by free world leaders...Thus many Jews were saved outside of Slovakia as a result of the Working Group distributing the report. 1675: 4082:(and discovering some really interesting articles in the process) I found the whole process far to bureaucratic to appeal to me. As far as the two hooks go both are a little ambiguous. The first one could be amended with the word "soldier" or "military personnel" (it wasn't German tourists with their beach towels after all), the second one is probably not quite correct as, according to 2702: 1961: 3325:

very diverse from ultra-observant to secular and Communist. They worked in unusual harmony, which can be attributed to Mrs. Fleischmann's personality. She was well connected with established Jewish organizations like Joint, WIZO, etc and Rabbi Weissmandl with the observant world internationally. She was more of an administrator and he the brilliant idea person of the group.

2544: 2138: 4235: 2800: 1916: 4184: 2354: 1566: 3131:

a very important point for anyone editing Knowledge (XXG) pages. Suggest carefully considering the implications. Huge number of pages would need automated or manual edits to remove YouTube links not substantiated in the same page by an external reference. By the way, independent of the issue suggest you listen to the songs. ...

1382: 3754:

Hi Catrìona, I have removed the rebuttal of the criticisms from the "Controversy" section, and also removed the reference link to material produced by the creator of the subject, and resubmitted the page for review. Does this mean it goes back into the queue for another few months before somebody can

3709:

Could you provide some more information on how you arrived at your decision? How many more independent/reliable/published references would be needed in addition to the 32 already provided? If I simply remove the one link to the material produced by the creator of the subject, will that be sufficient?

3464:

The only thing we know for certain is that the free world organizations were not willing to risk the down payment. We also know that, in contrast to the Europa Plan, significantly more money was risked for the Kastner train. My impression is that some of those historians who claim the Europa Plan had

3180:

More to the point, this is an important principle independent of the Wallenberg page. For example I recently saw two excellent explanations about "Quaternions" involving 3 distinct imaginary numbers i, j and k which have important applications in physics. and . I have no idea who the first presenter

3130:

Thanks. You are saying that based on Knowledge (XXG) rules songs. movies, testimonies, how-to and science explanations, etc. on YouTube, Vimeo, etc. which are not reviewed by external source(s) substantiated on the same page can't appear in a Knowledge (XXG) reference - regardless of quality? This is

122:

My suspicion is that you are utilizing a sort of synthetic thinking (something others have been guilty of when editing that page, including yours truly) that assumes a direct correlation between ESL features and phonological differences, grammatical differences, or even loanword phonology. This would

3320:

Probably not correct to state that the Working Group was ESPECIALLY focused on rescuing Slovak Jews, although their activism certainly started with that focus. They were very active warning the world about the immense tragedy and asking for help, trying to save much of European Jewry with the Europa

3161:

From what I've read on the reliable sources noticeboard, a YouTube video from the CNN official channel would be evaluated the same way that a CNN article would (a generally reliable secondary source). But any 3rd grader could write a song about Wallenberg and post it to YouTube—the fact that someone

2452:

Thanks for the feedback. I agree what I said to the first person was misleading. There seem to be a lot of AfC submissions which are somewhat promotional and somewhat reminiscent of a resume/CV, and I'm not really sure what to say to nudge the person in the right direction. As for the second one, it

118:

series of edits, you added a section utilizing three sources to make claims about pronunciation tendencies of non-native speakers of English. The one source I could access, the web site, said nothing about non-native speakers and was instead about borrowings into English. This has made me suspicious

3366:

I have also extensively researched the subject for many years. My understanding of the subject is as I wrote, especially that after the Spring 1942 ransom negotiations the Working Group tried to save as many Jews as possible at least in Europe anywhere. Don't know if they they were aware the danger

2429:

I agree that the declined drafts need work, but please nudge the submitters in the right direction. Otherwise they tend to flail around making things worse and clogging up AfC. Including in your comments a link to the relevant policy or guideline (if different from those in the boilerplate decline)

3324:

Leadership of the group is unnecessarily disputed. Many feel Gisi Fleischmann was the leader and the same for Rabbi Weissmandl. Among Jews the choice depends mostly on how/if observant is someone. This unfortunate dichotomy is divisive and reflected in books, articles, documentaries. The group was

3145:

Please note that reference to a song, image and similar is very different than justifying a historical, political, etc. point based on a possibly unreliable source on YouTube etc. Also reference to a song, etc. on Internet is not necessarily an endorsement for its quality - it merely indicates its

2653:

Could you please help me understand why this article reads like an advertisement and not an encyclopedia entry? While I agree that this was true of earlier drafts which were written by a non-native English speaker, I have completely re-written the article and feel like it is written from a neutral

1757:

Hi, welcome to DYK reviewing! Just a note that the template thread should be in chronological order. Please put your final approval tick at the bottom of the nomination, not at the top. If the hook reference can be verified, it's a green tick; if the hook ref is offline or foreign-language, it's a

150:

I have translated some articles from the Scottish Gaelic Uicipeid. They have different standards for citations than the English Knowledge (XXG) and many sources are in Scottish Gaelic. I've tried to add inline citations to English language websites when I translate; however, some articles may have

3438:

Yes, Bauer is widely cited and as far as know also received the Israel Prize. Still, anything Bauer or any historian states about what could have happened (e.g. with the Europa Plan) is not fact based history, but truth seeking or otherwise motivated speculation. I learned that one must know the

3408:

Excerpt of a review: "Rethinking the Holocaust is not only a book on Holocaust history but also a meditation on the writing and implications of this history by one of its most influential interpreters, Yehuda Bauer." If you are able to find another source which is as respected as that one, I will

2811:. There is a full seven-day period before the original oversized image will be hidden; during that time you might want to consider editing the original image yourself (perhaps an initial crop to allow a smaller reduction or none at all). A formula for calculation the desired size can be found at 1927:. There is a full seven-day period before the original oversized image will be hidden; during that time you might want to consider editing the original image yourself (perhaps an initial crop to allow a smaller reduction or none at all). A formula for calculation the desired size can be found at 1635:

Thank you for the compliment! I'm happy to be the first person to review one of your articles for a GA. You've done a fantastic job so far and I have to say, you're quite skillful when it comes to obtaining Czech-related sources. Having been to Prague once about 14 years ago, it's awesome seeing

417:

I think it’s a bit harsh to say that « few pupils in primary Gaelic education will continue to use the language as adults », especially since the source you quoted clearly states that « few former GME pupils who did not come from Gaelic-speaking homes are now using their Gaelic FREQUENTLY ». It

2806:

Hi, I'm RonBot, a script that checks new non-free file uploads. I have found that the subject image that you recently uploaded was more than 5% in excess of the Non-free content guideline size of 100,000 pixels. I have tagged the image for a standard reduction, which (for jpg/gif/png/svg files)

1922:

4139:

Hi, Your changed was reversed in order to bring back the "Review Waiting" column - back to the end of the article. Your comment removal wasn't intended. Now, you seem to have reverted the draft back to your own revision, undoing 3 different changes made during the period.It would indeed be a

3385:

Of course if you have a reference where as you write Rabbi Weissmandl states that Gisi Fleischmann was the only head of the group then I'd put all other considerations aside and go by what Rabbi Weissmandl writes. I'd do the same if there is anything of this sort written by Gisi Fleischmann.

3381:

I saw in documentary "Among Blind Fools" Andrew Steiner explaining that it was Rabbi Weissmandl who initiated the Spring 1942 negotiations to ransom Slovak Jewry and instructed Steiner on exactly how to behave when in Wisliceny's office. As far as I know the Europe Plan initiative was Rabbi

3370:

The Europa Plan activities were in late 1942 while Gisi Fleischman was not arrested. The same for preparation and dissemination of the Auschwitz Report around April 1944. Despite what Bauer may state in his work per Yad Vashem she was arrested on October 15, 1944 not during the Spring ....

3146:

existence. I'd venture to say that an article in a newspaper/video channel, even as well known as the NY Times, Fox News, CNN, Wall St Journal, the old Soviet Pravda... etc., is not necessarily noteworthy or even factual - but may well be politically or otherwise biased, or simply in error.

976:

is now open until 23.59 on Sunday, 10 December. All users who registered an account before Saturday, 28 October 2017, made at least 150 mainspace edits before Wednesday, 1 November 2017 and are not currently blocked are eligible to vote. Users with alternate accounts may only vote once.

2936:

It looks like another user has cleaned up your draft and promoted it. I encourage you to keep working on the issues that were addressed by the other reviewer, and if you have any questions they can probably answer them better than I could—I'm very new to Articles for Creation.

3497:

Frankly, I'm not sure that further discussion on this topic is going to be helpful. You are operating under a fundamental misunderstanding of accepted Knowledge (XXG) consensus about reliable sources and which sources should take precedent in an article. I suggest you read

2557: 1599:

Have you promoted an article to GA status yet? I'm just curious. I'd also like to say that I've been following the edits you've made to Prague uprising and I'm loving the work you've put into this. I'm very confident this is going to pass when it's all said and

2808: 1924: 3389:

Having written all this, the formal leadership issue is less important (to me), but suggest emphasizing that the Working Group's strategy was at least Europe-wide after the early 1942 Slovak focus. This what makes their activism especially

3377:

Bauer is knowledgeable, but that is not sufficient. In some cases he is highly point of view (vs. cold facts) driven and in such cases less than reliable, in my humble view. Some or many others may not agree. I will not elaborate.

940:

has good examples of what spellings produce which phones. Short /e ~ ɛ/ and /o ~ ɔ/ is not contrastive and while the long versions are contrastive, long ɛ: and o: are extremely rare with fewer than a dozen roots that employ them.

3584:

Thanks for your comment. I ended up creating a new wikidata item for the escape and linking the new wikidata item with both participants. This doesn't really help with interwiki linking, but it's at least an OK solution for now.

1524:

Thanks for contributing to the criticism of religion article. Your claim definitely needs to be backed up with a/some good references. If you can find reliable sources and document them on the page, it would be helpful. Cheers

123:

technically be original research. Could you take a second look at your two sources and corroborate whether these sources really do talk about ESL learners or if their utility as sources depends upon this synthetic thinking? —

1733:

No problem. It was a pleasure reviewing this article! Let me know if you'd ever like to take this article to a higher level (such as ACR or eventually FAC). I'd be more than happy to help you get there. Congrats again on the

3346:

Since I wrote the article and shepherded it through the GA process, I researched the subject extensively and thus I'm convinced that the phrasing in the list article is an adequate summary of the Working Group's activities.

3321:

Plan, asked for bombing a rail tunnel leading to Auschwitz and for bombing the crematoria, warned Hungarian Jewry of its imminent destruction in 1944 and distributing the Auschwitz Report to warn Jews and others in general.

3091:

The songs on YouTube (or anywhere) are their reference. They obviously exist. By the way, the song writer/singer is a friend of the Wallenberg family and one song, Louise and Mary, was written for two of Wallenbeg's nieces.

655: 2387:

Thanks for pitching in to review drafts at Articles for creation. Supplementing the boilerplate declines with custom comments is encouraged, but I noticed a couple of your comments steer submitters in the wrong direction.

1245:"). We need to decide whether we want to say there are "six levels of endangerment", "five levels of endangerment" (not counting "safe", or not counting "extinct"), or "four levels of endangerment" (counting neither "safe" 1004: 1146:

regarding military policy on homosexuals, Matlovich then reached out to him. After this incident he became briefly famous which led to the interview with Time Magazine and also the NY Times Magazine apparently.

3200:

By the way, I frequently watch CNN and Fox News. Neither is fully reliable since unfortunately they are both highly politically/point of view motivated. As are some or many of the major newspapers theese days.

3973:

I tried to carry out your excellent suggestion for a clearer photo of Boelcke, but could not straighten out the wiki coding involved. If you could return and dub in the photo you suggested, it would be most

3925:, who has not edited since creating this article. In any case, I hope my admittedly tough review does not discourage you or the author from making the needed improvements so it can be featured as a DYK. -- 2815:, along with instructions on how to tag the image in the rare cases that it requires an oversized image (typically about 0.2% of non-free uploads are tagged as necessarily oversized). Please contact the 1931:, along with instructions on how to tag the image in the rare cases that it requires an oversized image (typically about 0.2% of non-free uploads are tagged as necessarily oversized). Please contact the 1762:, so if it's not yet approved, it will be in the wrong place and may confuse prep promoters like myself. If you have any questions about the review process, please drop me a note on my talk page. Best, 2425:. The reviews need not contain significant biographical information (although in this case reviews are available that do). The submitter should be citing more coverage of the subject's works, not less. 988:. It has the authority to impose binding solutions to disputes between editors, primarily for serious conduct disputes the community has been unable to resolve. This includes the authority to impose 3777:

The oldest articles in the queue are 7 weeks old, but articles are reviewed in random order, so on average it will take about a month. Unfortunately, AfC is constantly backlogged with lots of spam.

3738:

One issue is that the "Controversy" section reads as if you are trying to rebut the criticisms of the company. If you would like a second opinion on the review, feel free to submit it to AfC again.

2973:

to the Italian Knowledge (XXG) article. I don't speak Italian but English language sources do exist for the massacre. It surprises me that there isn't an article yet, given that it is, according to

3457:

They kept their word with he Kastner train, but further ransom was needed later to release the people from Bergen-Belsen. According to the above link of Andre Steiner (found on Yad Vashem Web site

3275: 1142:

cover to notice that the letter actually referred to a separate interview. From the Wiki article (although I note the paragraph had no inline citations) I gather that Kameny did an interview with

659: 459:

This would involve evaluating a translated article on the English Knowledge (XXG) by comparing it to the original Spanish article, and marking it "Pass" or "Fail" based on whether the translation

3849:

Every afd discussion about one there has ever been in the last 11 years, which ,admittedly, have been very few because almost nobody has ever nominated one. If you have doubts, nominate it.

1751: 1249:"extinct"). And whichever wording we choose, we should only list the levels once. The article currently lists them twice (counting them differently each time), in the two sentences starting " 2312:

The thank was genuine appreciation for your clarification of the effect of the Arbcom case on the content dispute, not some nefarious attempt to involve you in the FAR proceedings. Regards,

2008: 3331:

Recommend writing for poor Gisi "A leader", not to diminish her stature but out of great respect and gratitude to both of them. To keep their memory together in harmony vs. separating them.

4303:

Hi bookku, I don't think the issue with the draft is the prose rather its due to lack of encyclopedic language as it reads as an essay taking the point of view of ex-muslim activists. (

2548: 528:

may be useful). (Naturally, if you feel like fixing an inaccurate translation and then assessing it, that's even better, but it isn't required.) Also please note that we are assessing

1844: 328:

a collection of song lyrics is one of the things Knowledge (XXG) is not supposed to be. Perhaps one stanza would be sufficient for fair use purposes and in keeping with the article.

3479:

Not a coincidence that a Czech documentary about Rabbi Weissmandl and the Working Group is titled "Among Blind Fools" (referring to free world Jewish leaders during the Holocaust).

2408:

encourages complete lists of works for artists and specifically says, "The individual items in the list do not have to be sufficiently notable to merit their own separate articles."

1891: 119:

about the other two source you cite, which I was unable to access. From the previews I was able to make of these on Google Books, they do not seem to be talking about ESL learners.

1758:

gray tick. Also, please don't give the final tick until all criteria are met, including the QPQ. We have a bot that automatically moves templates that have an approval tick to the

1501: 3461:) the Nazis kept their word regarding release of 1,000 children from Teresienstadt.... It is a fallacy to assume that the evil Nazis would by definition never keep an agreement. 1462: 1476: 1443: 1400: 2290:

I don't think that thanking me for my edit on the Molders FAR is helpful. I do not intend to comment further on the page. Please respect my right to withdraw from the matter.

1161:

Oh, I see. I was loath to try and fix it because I just wasn't sure. I may have a book source to use for an additional citation, if I can find it. Thanks for clearing it up!

3507: 1621:

No, I have never been a GA reviewer or nominator, this is all new for me. Thanks for the reassurance. By the way you have the coolest username that I've encountered so far.

1455: 208: 4110: 3700:

The page does refer to a wide range of independent, reliable, published sources including Forbes, Reuters, The United Nations, CNBC, Bloomberg, Nasdaq, MIT and the BBC.

2745: 2151: 1451: 2912:. You said "Knowledge (XXG) is not a how-to guide". I am confused and do not know how to revise the article. Can you give me further suggestions? Thank you very much. 2909: 2868: 564:

I'd definitely be willing to help out with that project but those articles have already been evaluated, where can I find a list of articles that still need attention?

1447: 3007:

Thanks for your work on the article and your ALT hook. I don't have time to write a full article on the massacre, but I might create a stub of it just for this DYK.

298:) are in public domain by now, so there is no copyright issue with them on Knowledge (XXG). Are there any other arguments not to have them published in the article? 222:. Last but not least, you are highly encouraged to continue improving the article; just be sure not to remove the tag about the deletion nomination from the top. 4242:, but there are some minor changes or clarifications needing to be addressed. If these are fixed within 7 days, the article will pass; otherwise it may fail. See 4075: 1488: 1428: 4106: 3382:

Weissmand's possibly jointly with Rabbi Fischer. The idea that it is possible to negotiate with the Nazis to save large number of lives was Rabbi Weissmandl's.

3706:

Also, I don't believe the article reads like an advertisement since it is written from a neutral point of view and includes several criticisms of the subject.

141:

Thanks for letting me know. I have taken down the section and will repost if/when I am able to find better sources for it. Alázhlis 01:46, 4 January 2017 (UTC)

2978: 1909: 1061: 261: 3830: 2764:

if the total is over 5,000. Finally, if you know of an interesting fact from another recently created article, then please feel free to suggest it on the

2027:

if the total is over 5,000. Finally, if you know of an interesting fact from another recently created article, then please feel free to suggest it on the

3482:

Rabbi Weissmandl wrote that after the war those who did nothing (or worse) to save the Jews of Europe will rewrite history. How right he was (again) ...

2807:

normally happens within a day. Please check the reduced image, and make sure that the image is not excessively corrupted. Other files will be added to

1923:

normally happens within a day. Please check the reduced image, and make sure that the image is not excessively corrupted. Other files will be added to

3797:

Please clarify the need for footnotes in the Draft. At present, the Draft has 10 footnotes. Thank you.Autoctono~enwiki 22:27, 13 August 2018 (UTC)

3251: 3235:

Thanks. The issue is not Wallenberg specific, but is of general interest. What is the mechanism for a way to have a general resolution to the issue?

1469: 1439: 1682:

for comments about the article. Well done! If the article has not already been on the main page as an "In the news" or "Did you know" item, you can

4243: 1504:

or any other experienced member of the project, and we'll be happy to help you. Again, welcome, and we are looking forward to seeing you around!

1192: 535:

If you can help, please let me know. You can add your pass/fails above, right next to each link, or you may indicate your results below. Thanks!

3996:

No problem. I've overwritten the existing Commons file and reverted the local Knowledge (XXG) copy to a different version that's not on Commons.

1204: 2982: 532:

not completeness, so if the English article is much shorter that is okay, as long as whatever has been translated so far is factually accurate.

3288:

The tags can be removed by you or another editor once the issues they mention are addressed. If you have questions, you can leave a comment on

1838:, which you created, has been nominated for possible deletion, merging, or renaming. A discussion is taking place to see if it abides with the 1297: 4114: 3374:

Thus as The Leader, Co-Leader or member of the group she was certainly involved in matters relating to dissemination of the Auschwitz Report.

2270:. It's clearly unacceptable in its current form and, although it might pass GNG, I have no interest in improving it or opposing the deletion. 1849: 1057: 257: 4229: 1669: 1309: 4141: 2885: 2877: 2859: 1018: 4283:

since I am not a native English language speaker, Idk whether I can change predicament of the draft with my limited linguistic skills.

3409:

reconsider my position. According to Bauer, she was arrested in May 1944, released at some point, and arrested again in October after the

2761: 2024: 1794: 1392:! As you may have guessed, we're a group of editors working to improve Knowledge (XXG)'s coverage of topics related to military history. 802: 95:

As the above-mentioned discussion could use some more input, I'm inviting all the active members of the phonetics project to participate.

2969:

Thank you for moving the article and creating a DYK for it. I added another alternative suggestion to it. I also noticed that you linked

2654:

point of view. Could you give me specific suggestions on what to change or delete to get it in alignment with Knowledge (XXG) standards?

425: 4225: 4218: 4170: 4163: 3022: 915: 2839: 2820: 2581: 1936: 447:

Would you be able to help evaluate the accuracy of translations of Knowledge (XXG) articles from Spanish to English Knowledge (XXG)?

3697:"should refer to a range of independent, reliable, published sources, not just to materials produced by the creator of the subject" 3612: 3565: 2570: 909:

Hi is there any orthographical way to express these distinctions or is it impossible to distinguish this way? Thanking in advance —

3703:

There is only one single link to material produced by the creator of the subject, and this link is simply a technical description.

207:

I wanted to let you know that there's a discussion about whether Gath (magazine) should be deleted. Your comments are welcome at

3107:

A secondary source would establish that the songs are important enough and relevant enough to be included in the article without

2419:

Coverage of the subject's works do not grant notability to the author unless there is significant coverage of the author himself.

1782: 1480: 1418: 1407: 1200: 812: 764: 4187:

This process may take up to 7 days. Feel free to contact me with any questions or comments you might have during this period.

3672: 2974: 2357:

This process may take up to 7 days. Feel free to contact me with any questions or comments you might have during this period.

1994: 1569:

This process may take up to 7 days. Feel free to contact me with any questions or comments you might have during this period.

875: 4083: 2266:

First, thanks for reviewing all of my new pages, splits and redirects. I did not create this article, but simply split it from

2098: 1014: 3282: 997: 2783: 2619: 2601: 2046: 550: 254:. Such links are almost always unintended, since a disambiguation page is merely a list of "Did you mean..." article titles. 3406: 2421:

Coverage of the subject's works in the form of multiple independent reviews is one of the primary ways of demonstrating the

2190: 2072: 1351: 1305: 344: 1790: 3503: 2812: 2709: 1968: 1928: 4308: 4280: 2627: 2610: 3875:

I am trying to know what are the expectations precisely and how can I improve this article in a Neutral point of view:

350: 3458: 3442:

Suppose Gisi Fleischmann was arrested per Bauer in May 1944. The Auschwitz Report was disseminated earlier, in April!

3217: 1196: 1009: 937: 3900:

https://en.wikipedia.org/search/?title=Shentalinsky_District&type=revision&diff=854859874&oldid=785036041

1839: 4045: 3945: 2230: 4079: 3088:

Didn't see your message. YouTube not a reliable source for what/in what way? How do you suggest referencing them?

2765: 2751: 2028: 2014: 1683: 848: 508:

All you have to do, is compare the English article to the Spanish article, and mark it "Pass" or "Fail" (templates

246:

Hi. Thank you for your recent edits. Knowledge (XXG) appreciates your help. We noticed though that when you edited

79: 71: 66: 38: 4214: 4159: 3552:

I don't know the solution myself, but you did not get an answer to your help desk question. Have you found help?—

2329: 1654: 1541: 3285:

tools, as having some issues to fix. Consider providing reliable sources to strengthen the page's verifiability.

2204:, for deletion because I don't think it meets our criteria for inclusion. If you don't want the article deleted: 2090: 798:

Thanks for your help so far. We have a lot of Spanish articles, see what you think of these if you get a chance:

361: 3108: 2793: 2454: 828:

If any of them is just not something you want to do or is just too bad too verify, don't hesitate to say so....

3410: 2919: 2853: 2340: 2333: 2201: 2194: 2094: 1989: 1980: 4145: 1047: 985: 467: 354: 2555:

has been reviewed, and some issues with it may need to be clarified. Please review the comment(s) underneath

2483:

I have improved the citations and has address the controversies in a hopefully acceptable encyclopedic tone.

2149:

has been reviewed, and some issues with it may need to be clarified. Please review the comment(s) underneath

429: 4015: 3979: 3538: 2729: 2566: 2068: 1702: 1585: 1347: 247: 4133: 2414: 1051: 538: 421: 219: 4262: 4203: 4122: 2064: 1899: 1857: 1509: 1493: 1472:

that cover article structure and content, template use, categorization, and many other issues of interest.

1339: 1273: 1234: 933: 922: 902: 898: 100: 2970: 2401: 3606: 3559: 2714: 1973: 1842:

guidelines. If you would like to participate in the discussion, you are invited to add your comments at

1834: 1819: 232: 4001: 3876: 3838: 3782: 3743: 3590: 3515: 3418: 3356: 3293: 3259: 3225: 3167: 3120: 3078: 3012: 2942: 2684: 2527: 2462: 2317: 2275: 1724: 1626: 1237:, I think you should carefully read through the changes in that diff: the version you reverted back to 1152: 946: 910: 623: 569: 380: 333: 218:

is a group discussion (not a vote!) that usually lasts seven days. If you need it, there is a guide on

156: 3922: 2726:, which you recently created, substantially expanded, or brought to good article status. The fact was 1985:, which you recently created, substantially expanded, or brought to good article status. The fact was 4140:

discomfort making back those changes. Requesting you to act more wisely from now onwards. Thank You.

3884: 3880: 3289: 2435: 2393: 1679: 1170: 1116: 1034:

Hi. Thank you for your recent edits. An automated process has detected that when you recently edited

394: 372: 357: 303: 179: 175: 4041: 3499: 1389: 972: 498: 4091: 3953: 3903: 3760: 3721: 3162:

has done so does not merit inclusion if it has not been covered by independent, secondary sources.

3030: 2990: 2931: 2915: 2849: 2816: 2674: 2658: 2591: 2295: 1932: 1876: 1138:

thanks for bringing my attention to this issue; I've now corrected it. I was distracted by the big

1103:. To further complicate matters, earlier in the paragraph our article mentions an interview in the 2422: 981: 4011: 3991: 3975: 3907: 3532: 2777: 2662: 2595: 2562: 2512: 2493: 2237: 2040: 1735: 1714: 1698: 1693: 1637: 1616: 1601: 1581: 1576: 1530: 867: 833: 822: 781: 691: 607: 546: 128: 4178: 3829:

Could you please point me to the page that says that? There is nothing about court decisions in

3689:

Regarding your rejection of the Skycoin page, I'd like to better understand your comment below:

2977:, "one of Italy's worst wartime atrocities". Other English language sources exist as well, like 2348: 1759: 1560: 471: 3439:

personality of historians, including biases and affiliations, and know what to filter out etc.

3184:

How can we have the issue arbitrated in order to establish the principle for the general good?

485:

If you can help out, that would be great. Here's a sample of the articles that need checking:

450: 4258: 4253: 4239: 4199: 4194: 4118: 4060: 3930: 3661: 2552: 2373: 2146: 2122: 1895: 1853: 1809: 1767: 1505: 1414:

if you are interested, or you can add it directly to your user page by copying the following:

1366: 1324: 1219: 1077: 1043: 277: 96: 3673:

http://www.yadvashem.org/yv/en/exhibitions/communities/bratislava/working_group_activists.asp

993: 737:

Here are two new ones, feel free to evaluate them, and then just mark them up right here and

4304: 4293: 3997: 3834: 3778: 3739: 3600: 3586: 3579: 3553: 3511: 3414: 3352: 3255: 3221: 3163: 3116: 3074: 3008: 2955: 2938: 2828: 2680: 2523: 2458: 2313: 2271: 2178: 2161: 1998: 1944: 1720: 1622: 1148: 942: 619: 565: 376: 375:, I believe so, that's probably what I was looking at when I originally moved them. Thanks! 329: 228: 152: 89: 47: 17: 3112: 2648: 996:, editing restrictions, and other measures needed to maintain our editing environment. The 989: 325: 215: 3487: 3470: 3395: 3336: 3299: 3240: 3206: 3191: 3151: 3136: 3097: 3052: 2738: 2721: 2447: 2431: 2200:

Hello, Catrìona. I wanted to let you know that I’m proposing an article that you started,

2142: 1665: 1658: 1552: 1545: 1281: 1262: 1162: 1133: 1108: 817: 390: 313: 299: 198: 190: 4174: 3070: 2344: 2060:

An automated process has detected that you recently added links to disambiguation pages.

1556: 1241:

claims that "extinct" is one of the "levels of andangerment" (in the paragraph starting "

769: 618:

Thanks for the link! Unfortunately I'm not native, but I am fluent enough for this task.

287: 3445:"The Working Group did not save any Jews who were not Slovak Jews". That is incorrect. 3216:

Since the Wallenberg article is currently under review, you could post a comment to the

1054:, since a disambiguation page is merely a list of unrelated topics with similar titles. 4087: 4033: 3963: 3949: 3772: 3756: 3733: 3717: 3026: 3002: 2986: 2307: 2291: 2079: 1872: 1039: 807: 174:! Unfortunately, I can't add more because I have no knowledge of the subject, sorry. -- 2748:. You are welcome to check how many page hits the article got while on the front page 2155:

and respond there as soon as possible. Thank you for contributing to Did You Know! ›

2011:. You are welcome to check how many page hits the article got while on the front page 3856: 3812: 2773: 2508: 2489: 2267: 2261: 2243: 2036: 2002: 1526: 1068:

It's OK to remove this message. Also, to stop receiving these messages, follow these

882: 855: 829: 777: 750: 741: 720: 710: 687: 663: 648: 638: 603: 597: 585: 561: 542: 522: 512: 268:

It's OK to remove this message. Also, to stop receiving these messages, follow these

124: 4078:

for DYK. I read your suggestion a few days a go but, frankly, after reading through

2809:

Category:Knowledge (XXG) non-free file size reduction requests for manual processing

2561:

and respond there as soon as possible. Thank you for contributing to Did You Know!

2172:

PS - many congratulations on your Good Article. It's an impressive piece of work. ›

1925:

Category:Knowledge (XXG) non-free file size reduction requests for manual processing

4249: 4190: 4056: 4052: 3926: 3459:

http://www.yadvashem.org/yv/en/exhibitions/communities/bratislava/working_group.asp

3348: 2733: 2369: 2364: 2360: 2118: 2114: 2083: 1805: 1801: 1763: 1719:

Thanks so much for your helpful feedback, it really helped me improve the article.

1689: 1674: 1572: 1362: 1358: 1320: 1316: 1215: 1211: 1073: 1069: 754: 681: 667: 273: 269: 127: 3177:

There are some talented 3rd graders. Mozart composed many pieced by that age. :-)

2755: 2018: 963: 686:

Mea culpa, insufficiently clear template instructions. Please see your talk page.

654:

templates don't go in the actual articles themselves, but on the lists at either

4319: 4313: 4297: 4289: 4266: 4207: 4149: 4126: 4095: 4070:

Template:Did you know nominations/German war crimes in Italy during World War II

4064: 4019: 4005: 3983: 3957: 3934: 3911: 3888: 3860: 3842: 3816: 3786: 3764: 3747: 3725: 3618: 3594: 3571: 3542: 3519: 3491: 3474: 3422: 3399: 3360: 3340: 3304: 3263: 3244: 3229: 3210: 3195: 3171: 3155: 3140: 3124: 3101: 3082: 3056: 3034: 3016: 2994: 2946: 2923: 2832: 2824: 2787: 2701: 2688: 2666: 2574: 2531: 2516: 2497: 2466: 2439: 2377: 2321: 2299: 2279: 2253: 2183: 2173: 2166: 2156: 2126: 2050: 1960: 1948: 1940: 1903: 1880: 1861: 1813: 1771: 1742: 1728: 1706: 1644: 1630: 1608: 1589: 1533: 1513: 1370: 1328: 1285: 1266: 1223: 1178: 1156: 1124: 1081: 1022: 950: 926: 892: 837: 785: 695: 670: 627: 611: 573: 554: 433: 398: 384: 365: 337: 307: 281: 236: 183: 160: 135: 104: 46:

If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the

3879:

Either you (or point me to the resource) can seek help and point the sections?

466:

There are a number of articles on English Knowledge (XXG) that were created as

4037: 3650: 3639: 3483: 3466: 3433: 3391: 3332: 3236: 3202: 3187: 3147: 3132: 3093: 3064: 3048: 2543: 2137: 1277: 1258: 3405:

With due respect, Bauer's book has more than 600 citations on Google Scholar.

1255:

UNESCO's Atlas of the World's Languages in Danger categorises 2,473 languages

1243:

UNESCO's Atlas of the World's Languages in Danger categorises 2,473 languages

2405: 656:

Knowledge (XXG):Administrators' noticeboard/CXT/Pages to review/By language

4169:

Hi there, I'm pleased to inform you that I've begun reviewing the article

2538:

DYK nomination of The Mass Extermination of Jews in German Occupied Poland

2398:

Also, Knowledge (XXG) is not a CV. Non-notable works should not be listed.

2339:

Hi there, I'm pleased to inform you that I've begun reviewing the article

1551:

Hi there, I'm pleased to inform you that I've begun reviewing the article

936:

I thought I had replied to you earlier but apparently forgot to post. OK,

3851: 3824: 3807: 1786: 1107:. Can you shed some light on this? Were there three separate interviews? 1035: 634:

Hi there, and thanks for helping out. I do have a request, though - the

489: 4234: 2799: 1915: 1636:

folks who are eager to improve articles about the history of the city.--

1000:

describes the Committee's roles and responsibilities in greater detail.

3530:

Thank for picking up Parkala Massacre. I will work on the suggestions.

251: 4183: 3805:

I think consensus is that all US Supreme court decisions are notable.

3270:

Ways to improve List of "return unwanted" concentration camp prisoners

2353: 1910:

File:Manufacture of Bf 109 wings at Flossenbürg concentration camp.jpg

1565: 349:

Although the poem was written during WW1, were the collected poems of

1343: 449: 3877:

https://en.wikipedia.org/Krishnamacharya_Healing_and_Yoga_Foundation

726:

right here on your talk page, and then let one of us know by adding

3898:

Thanking for editing the Shentalinsky article. Please look at this

1500:

If you have any questions, please don't hesitate to ask any of the

1381: 2522:

I've mainspaced it. The article still needs copy editing, though.

2105: 1301: 843:

A page you started (History of Scottish Gaelic) has been reviewed!

171: 320:

during WWI but I have not been able to find evidence that it was

4113:

for speedy renaming but they are not (or not anymore) listed at

4032: