User talk:Kildor - Knowledge (XXG)

724:, I oppose the use of stub tags in general. Although I do not like the tags, I do accept and recognize the current guidelines. But as far as I can see, there is no clear definition of a stub. You might think that 8 sentences, 2 images, some facts in a table, and external links are not enough, but I disagree. I think that it is a reasonable amount of information about a rather small subject. One of my concerns with stub tags is that people spend a lot of time adding tags to articles without doing anything at all to improve them. And the only message they bring is that the article is not good enough. I assume that you believe that stub tags will improve the chances for the article to expand. I believe the tags only bring a negative message and bad layout and appearance. With that said, I am happy to see that you decided to make some improvements to the article, and I think I'd rather do the same instead of continuing a edit-war over the stub tags. -- 383:

completly independents of the another traffic, with a frecuency of 3-5 min. The infraestructure is completly like a full metro with 2 surface stations (the fist and the last, with a total tranch of around 200 meters competly segregated with a "trench") 3 elevated in viaduct and 17 underground stations but will use trains like "light rail" or tram model. What do you think?, is a light rail only because "light rail-tram" are used, or is a metro for the rest of the infraestructure?? For me is clear, Seville Metro is a Metro system and will be open like a Metro system, not like a light rail, I think that is more correct to englobe this system in this category that in the light rail, cause is not a light rail, and maybe neither a metro cause the trains are not of heavy metro, but is much more metro than light rail.Thanks!--

563:

the other roads but are totally separated from other rail traffic. I have another question: In the future, the commuter trains of Stockholm (pendeltåg), will be run through a tunnel under the central parts. Further, there have been a discussion to upgrade the Bålsta line to four tracks. Thus the pendeltåg traffic will be more or less independent from long distant rail traffic on almost the entire network. However, some cargo traffic to- and from the port of Nynäshamn will of course share the same tracks as the commuter trains. Do you think this upgrade would qualify the pendeltåg-network as a rapid transit comparable to the S-trains of Copenhagen? Mvh

2655: 2317: 2265: 1750: 1647: 2560: 2472: 2371: 2194: 2121: 1906: 1572: 2334:. However, the image is currently not used in any articles on Knowledge (XXG). If the image was previously in an article, please go to the article and see why it was removed. You may add it back if you think that that will be useful. However, please note that images for which a replacement could be created are not acceptable for use on Knowledge (XXG) (see 2282:. However, the image is currently not used in any articles on Knowledge (XXG). If the image was previously in an article, please go to the article and see why it was removed. You may add it back if you think that that will be useful. However, please note that images for which a replacement could be created are not acceptable for use on Knowledge (XXG) (see 705:

about an article being too short" as you put it, adding a stub template is the correct course of action. I've already improved the article to a small degree, but can't expand on it myself which is why I've added the stub template. How an eight-sentence article can be anything other than a stub is beyond me.

704:

is a stub - it's only eight sentences long. Making edit-summary comments such as "If you are bothered about this article being too short - please add to it!" is childish. The whole point of adding the stub template is to bring other editors' attention to a short article, so if an editor is "bothered

588:

There are also some discussions going on to shorten the commuter rail network and let the regional trains serve the outer stations (i.e. Kungsängen-Bålsta). In this way, commuter trains and regional trains can run more independently of each other. The other alternative is to extend the commuter rail

562:

Hi Kildor and thank you for answering my question about rapid transit systems in Stockholm. I surely missunderstood one of the criteria that the system should be totally separated from other traffic. I confused it with railway traffic. The Roslagsbanan and Saltsjöbanan indeed have intersections with

424:

Thanks for your answer! It's ok. The 1st Metro line will be opened in Septemeber 30 without crossings for pedestrian, road vehicles or another trains. In the first project, a little tranch was completly in surface like a tram, but finally, was this option was rejected and now the line go underground

103:

Hey Kildor, how you doing, in "List of rapid transit systems" not only do we have got Continents, but also Oceans and Seas, folks not only live in Continents but in islands other than Continents, furthermore the Caribbean is not part of North America, just as Oceania is also not a Continent , cheers

1115:

meet #10 of Knowledge (XXG)'s Non-free content criteria as stated in it's copyright tag. The classic Houston Rockets logo for the 1994 & 1995 NBA Finals logo meets #10 as it states on it's page "The significance of the logo is to help the reader identify the organization" as well as the classic

282:

is not correct, needs to be fixed and be more precise, according to all dictionaries, the Caribbean Sea is an arm of the western Atlantic Ocean bounded by the coasts of North, Central and South America, and believe me, I presently reside in this area and by no means do folks in all of the islands

173:

Hi Kildor, here again, technically the Caribbean is not part of North America, just like Hawaii is not part of North America although even though its a state, United States has 50 states, not 51, further more, where not dealing with "geopolitical maps", ask a Jamaican, Dominican, or any Caribbean

797:

Hi! You are probably right about the header. But I have no better idea for the moment. But anyone reading this section will quickly understand that U4 line is in planning stages, and the future tag does not add any information that is not already present in the article. Besides, the tag is (in my

582:

and the four-track Karlberg-Kallhäll is completed, Stockholm commuter rail will indeed be near rapid transit standard. The only remaining shared track parts will then be Kungsängen-Bålsta, Upplands Väsby-Märsta, and Järna-Gnesta. The train frequency to Nynäshamn and Gnesta will perhaps still be a

382:

Hi Kildo! I only want inform you that the Seville Metro is not a light rail metro, because the system is completly independent of any kind of trafic, is not like Oporto Metro or Madrid Light Rail for example. The Seville Metro will be open the next september with a line of 18,2 km and 22 stations

1850:

I believe the Hamburg S-Bahn should be included as a metro in metro list, along the same line of argument as the berlin S-Bahn. Please take a look, this seems to be difficult, please also see discussion List of Metro Systems. Thank you, I have read your contributions to the previous discussions.

1627:

Hejsan, Kildor! Björn här. Finns det någon möjlighet för mig att få komma tillbaka till svwp? Jag kan inte registrera ett nytt anv.konto, jag blir bara blockerad då också, för att jag blir igenkänd. Vad kan vi göra? Har du någon lösning? Besvara detta, så vi kan komma överens om vad vi kan göra.

763:

I have removed the template from articles that clearly indicate the contingent nature of the topic. The template is superfluous in these cases, since it adds nothing to the article that is not already known or already indicated by the lead or title of the article. The template cannot be added to

985:

Yes, I have seen them all. It will be difficult to develop a consensus on its use, and many editors seem to think that the templates must be used as soon there is something about planned or upcoming events. But most tag removals have been accepted so far, which perhaps is an indication on that

205:

Thanks! There is still some work to do - fill in the missing numbers, for instance. And reaching a consensus about the definition and what systems to include. The reason why I chose not to include systems under construction is that it makes it very difficult to determine if the system is rapid

1517:

The convention is on Knowledge (XXG) to sort everything by country, except for matters that are relevant only to sovereign states. Some countries are not sovereign states, and therefore would not appear on List of sovereign states. As for common names, IMHO and ASAIK neutrality comes before

340:

The San Francisco Muni Metro runs underground under Market Street and the SFMTA is currently building the Central Subway. This is why it's known as the "metro" - because of these underground portions. It matters not that they use "light rail" cars instead of "heavy rail", they system runs

2206:

is now open until 23.59 on Sunday, 10 December. All users who registered an account before Saturday, 28 October 2017, made at least 150 mainspace edits before Wednesday, 1 November 2017 and are not currently blocked are eligible to vote. Users with alternate accounts may only vote once.

2383:

is now open until 23.59 on Sunday, 3 December. All users who registered an account before Sunday, 28 October 2018, made at least 150 mainspace edits before Thursday, 1 November 2018 and are not currently blocked are eligible to vote. Users with alternate accounts may only vote once.

1363:

Thanks! I didn't notice the link to the peer review. But I still think that there is no need for having the tag at the top of the article. The lead is good enough for a good article, and suggestions for further improvements are better discussed at the talk page.

782:

is not correct: the first part of the section are abandoned plans and the second part is build now and planned to open in 2011 . I think this article is a translation from the German article with a wrong headdline, but I've got no idea how to change it.

2133:

is open from Monday, 00:00, 21 November through Sunday, 23:59, 4 December to all unblocked users who have registered an account before Wednesday, 00:00, 28 October 2016 and have made at least 150 mainspace edits before Sunday, 00:00, 1 November 2016.

1296:

It is not only about the number of pictures. Pictures should be relevant to the section it is located in. And the pictures should be placed so that a proper layout can be maintained. It does not improve when the editor adds image caption like

1262:

Stockholm has many beautiful and important buildings, but we cannot have a photo on them all in this article. Any reader who wants to see more photographs of Stockholm can follow the link to the Stockholm article at Knowledge (XXG) Commons.

183:. . . by the way, i would like to complement you on the magnificent job you've did on the "new table format", i would have left "under construction systems" perhaps, but it doesn't matter, it looks very encyclopedic and superb!!. - 967:, alas, to rely on, for having a (previous) consensus on use. I think though it's possible to move toward one on the future items, but it's quite late, now that there are 20-odd sister templates, some rather popular. Take a look at 888:

This is quite a strange situation, isn't it? The templates are almost identical, so it is rather confusing that one is bound by certain guidelines while the others are not. Since the other current templates were created out of

406:: it is not yet completed. But when the system is inaugerated, and if it is completely segregated from other traffic, with no crossings for pedestrians or road vehicles, I would say it is a metro system to be included. -- 1278:

I was going to ask you same questions. Stockholm should have as many pictures as other cities, such as Paris, New York, Moscow etc. There are many other cities on wikipedia that has many more pictures than Stockholm

2605: 2515: 2411: 2234: 2161: 206:

transit or not, due to lack of information. And a lot of things can change during the process of construction. But when the list has become "stable", it might be a good idea to add a "Under construction" section.

2076:. It has the authority to enact binding solutions for disputes between editors, primarily related to serious behavioural issues that the community has been unable to resolve. This includes the ability to impose 1185:

I don't think you will be able to gain support for such use. If you look at other sports/projects, you will notice that team logos only appear in the articles about the corresponding teams, and nowhere else.

277:

region, even though its located in the Americas, geographically is a separate distinct region located southeast of North America, east of Central America, and to the north and west of South America, and

252:

Kildor, a continent is a large landmass on Earth, seven areas are commonly regarded as continents – they are: Asia, Africa, North America, South America, Antarctica, Europe and Australia, please see:

2589:. It has the authority to impose binding solutions to disputes between editors, primarily for serious conduct disputes the community has been unable to resolve. This includes the authority to impose 2499:. It has the authority to impose binding solutions to disputes between editors, primarily for serious conduct disputes the community has been unable to resolve. This includes the authority to impose 2395:. It has the authority to impose binding solutions to disputes between editors, primarily for serious conduct disputes the community has been unable to resolve. This includes the authority to impose 2218:. It has the authority to impose binding solutions to disputes between editors, primarily for serious conduct disputes the community has been unable to resolve. This includes the authority to impose 2145:. It has the authority to impose binding solutions to disputes between editors, primarily for serious conduct disputes the community has been unable to resolve. This includes the authority to impose 1167:

Well I do think the the NBA Finals articles do meet that criterion and therefor #8 is not a basis for removal of the logos. And I will be working on the fair use rationale so that they are listed on

1992:

since I didn't think it was a good addition to the article. At that time, I thought it was better to move it to a separate article instead of just removing it. But now I know better. Good call! --

2006:

Huh, interesting! I wasn't around back then, but I will say that that list didn't seem like your "style", so I can't say I'm surprised that you didn't create it in the first place... Thanks! --

451:) on the talk page (and it hasn't been discussed for months) for your changes to remove Merseyrail from the article. If you want to remove it please discuss it further on the talk page first. 2574: 2485: 1345: 174:

country even the United States Virgin Islands and they will tell you that they are Caribbean, it doesn't matter if its a a state, commonwealth or country, hope this it clears up matters!

1221:. Since you closed the deletion discussion for this article, speedy-deleted it, or were otherwise interested in the article, you might want to participate in the deletion review. 744:

Hi, Kildor. Why are you removing future templates? These are not maintenance templates. As I may understand from your previous discussion,you oppose templates as such. However,

2692: 1014:

You have removed Laon because you said it was not listed in Urbanrail, I have checked, Laon is in Urbanrail (while Serfaus is not) ... as well as in the Robert Schwandl book

1149:

As I said on your talk page, the #8 criterion may be debatable (although I doubt the finals articles meet that criterion). But #10c is not. The fair use rationale must list

748:

is not a valid reason for removing. Before taking unilateral actions, please discuss and propose relevant policies concerning overall use of (future) templates. Thank you.

219:

I understand that you want Puerto Rico in a Caribbean section. But I cannot see the arguments for it. There seem to be no objection to the way the countries are divided in

1305:, and adding images with incomplete copyright information. So please, take a look at the changes before reverting. Btw, the Paris article has 27 pictures, Stockholm 30... 313:

I don't see the point taking this discussion any further here. The subject is obviously controversial, but still, Puerto Rico is included in maps and country list of the

1777:

if you think that that will be useful. However, please note that images for which a replacement could be created are not acceptable for use on Knowledge (XXG) (see

1674:

if you think that that will be useful. However, please note that images for which a replacement could be created are not acceptable for use on Knowledge (XXG) (see

1134:

It is my belief that the logos do enhance the articles and add historical value to the articles. Especially the logos that are no longer used by their franchises.--

2687: 1773:, meaning that it is not used in any articles on Knowledge (XXG). If the image was previously in an article, please go to the article and see why it was removed. 1670:, meaning that it is not used in any articles on Knowledge (XXG). If the image was previously in an article, please go to the article and see why it was removed. 223:

and similar lists. Nevertheless, it is not a big deal, and I won't make any changes to it now. There are other way more important things to do here :) Cheers! --

1458: 1448: 583:

little lower than expected for a rapid transit system (30 minutes?). But overall, the commuter rail system will be a transit system of a very high standard.

2671: 625:

systems. Are you unaware of the history of New York's rapid transit, which was a full-blown system in the 1880s? The 1904 date is for the underground IRT

2661:

Hello, I've noticed that you contributed to an article within our project's scope, and would like to formally invite you to join our team of editors at

764:

every article with any little piece of information regarding the future. If so, it would appear on a huge number of articles here on Knowledge (XXG). --

2346: 2294: 1962: 2031: 1941: 2676: 1586: 511:

One technical question, would a Bus System that runs in it's own right of way and crosses no streets and semaphores be considered "Rapid Transit".

1218: 1207: 798:

opinion) rather obtrusive. I simply do not understund why it should be needed. And I also note that the German page does not have a future tag. --

613:

Hello, Kildor. I will revert your reversion of my accurate dating of New York City's rapid transit system. The title of the article specificies

1913: 909:, some users disagree. You got a point, and I should perhaps make it clearer that I want the TFD:d templates removed rather than replaced with 1475: 82: 1388:. I don't know about that; I'm just wondering what source we can cite. Currently, the list has lots of data, but no sources at all. Cheers. 2628: 2538: 2425: 2248: 2175: 2101: 1852: 1247: 348: 848:, is not very interchangeble with any other "current" template, since it has a history and guideline that promotes rather narrow use. See 155:

I am perhaps wrong in this matter. If so, please point me out an article or list where countries are divided in the way you prefer. -- --

852:. Hence it is not a persuasive argument that it might be used in place of another "current" template, such as those under discussion at 2662: 2641: 1385: 1280: 1042: 426: 384: 364: 1988:

Very good! I totally agree with your proposal. Although it appears as I am the creator of that list, I was only moving the list from

1966: 2807: 1024: 2719: 48: 2624: 2534: 2421: 2244: 2171: 2097: 2598: 2508: 2404: 2227: 2154: 43: 2782: 1534: 1021: 279: 220: 135: 2330:. The image description page currently specifies that the image is non-free and may only be used on Knowledge (XXG) under a 2278:. The image description page currently specifies that the image is non-free and may only be used on Knowledge (XXG) under a 2035: 1954: 1917: 1765:. The image description page currently specifies that the image is non-free and may only be used on Knowledge (XXG) under a 1662:. The image description page currently specifies that the image is non-free and may only be used on Knowledge (XXG) under a 150:. And being a commonwealth of the United States, the system it might alternatively be listed as a city in the United States. 2714: 1408: 1404: 1393: 403: 97: 2335: 2283: 1958: 1778: 1675: 1120:

is disputed and is still being debated and discussed. Therefor I don't see #8 as a good reason for removal of the logos.

2752: 26: 2088:

describes the Committee's roles and responsibilities in greater detail. If you wish to participate, you are welcome to

1582: 1214: 53: 2610: 2520: 2416: 2239: 2166: 2093: 2792: 2772: 1547: 745: 516: 288: 188: 109: 812:

Hm, the de:wiki also have no references ;-) no serious : after thinking, you're right, it's just a happy picture.

425:

by all urban nucleus and elevated in the rest: 100% independent for another traffic and pedestrian. Best regards--

2737: 1226: 817: 788: 33: 22: 2777: 2767: 2757: 1633: 1389: 1251: 352: 2586: 2496: 2392: 2215: 2142: 1856: 60: 2326: 2274: 1761: 1658: 1436: 1240:

Why did you remove so many pictures on gallery of Stockholm? They were important for the city! / Mattias NJ

2812: 2762: 2747: 2724: 1284: 1126: 430: 388: 1522: 1243: 710: 344: 146:. So I cannot se why the list of rapid transit systems should be different and have a separate section for 64: 2024: 1070: 903: 2089: 1970: 1629: 721: 448: 76: 68: 1989: 1882: 1028: 866:'s situation, which is rather substitutable with the various related "future" templates, since (so far) 675: 512: 492: 456: 444: 284: 184: 105: 1330: 38: 706: 469:

You have got it completely wrong. It was discussed on the talk page, and there was never consensus to

2729: 2666: 1891: 1483: 1222: 1081: 976: 961: 881: 870: 860: 813: 784: 2568: 2479: 2379: 2202: 2129: 2111: 2065: 2056: 1923:

While all constructive contributions to Knowledge (XXG) are appreciated, content or articles may be

2802: 2680: 2654: 1585:. If you are interested in the deletion discussion, please participate by adding your comments at 1172: 1135: 2582: 2492: 2388: 2211: 2138: 2085: 2069: 1770: 1667: 1326: 538:

is sometime used for certain bus networks. Personally, I think that the article should be renamed

341:

underground over a portion of it's network and is indeed a "subway" or "metro" for that portion.

2797: 1530: 1176: 1139: 634: 29:. I hope you like the place and decide to stay. Here are some pages that you might find helpful: 2449: 1451:

linking to that page which explains why it needs to be used on that page. Can you please check

1171:

the logos are used on along with a reason. Those logos will appear on the NBA Finals articles.--

986:

consensus will change. It will also be interesting to see the outcome of the TfD discussions! --

899:, I believe they should have the same guidelines. But obviously, from the last discussion about 564: 2829: 1937: 1836: 1823: 1733: 1720: 1018: 2594: 2504: 2400: 2223: 2150: 2081: 2073: 1774: 1671: 1444: 75:~~~~; this will automatically insert your username and the date. If you need help, check out 2617: 2527: 2043: 2011: 1978: 1874: 1749: 1646: 937: 913: 893: 849: 842: 753: 660: 488: 452: 88: 2597:, editing restrictions, and other measures needed to maintain our editing environment. The 2590: 2507:, editing restrictions, and other measures needed to maintain our editing environment. The 2500: 2403:, editing restrictions, and other measures needed to maintain our editing environment. The 2396: 2226:, editing restrictions, and other measures needed to maintain our editing environment. The 2219: 2153:, editing restrictions, and other measures needed to maintain our editing environment. The 2146: 2084:, editing restrictions, and other measures needed to maintain our editing environment. The 2077: 1924: 1791: 1688: 1440: 853: 589:

network and have a combined system with local commuter trains and express commuter trains (

2453: 2354: 2302: 1887: 1819: 1716: 1479: 1471: 1353: 1077: 972: 957:

It all has to do with the lack of a fairly well developed previous discussion hisotory on

877: 568: 2331: 2279: 1766: 1663: 593:). I would rather see a separated system that can function as a rapid transit system. -- 2742: 1597: 779: 1111:

The classic Celtics logo for the 1981, 1984, 1985, 1986, and 1987 NBA Finals articles

1526: 630: 399: 314: 143: 1797:

I will remove the request for deletion if the file is used in an article once again.

1694:

I will remove the request for deletion if the file is used in an article once again.

2825: 1832: 1729: 701: 694: 2559: 2471: 2370: 2193: 2120: 2039: 2007: 1993: 1974: 1608: 1551: 1498: 1416: 1365: 1308: 1264: 1187: 1154: 1092: 1046: 987: 944: 920: 799: 765: 749: 725: 679: 653: 594: 543: 474: 407: 368: 318: 224: 156: 139: 1571: 2350: 2298: 1901:

Proposed deletion of List of total rapid transit systems statistics by country

1349: 1153:

the logo is used on, with a specific reason to why it should be used there. --

1076:

has one article use at the moment. It could be added to your recent list. --

1947:

Please consider improving the article to address the issues raised. Removing

1447:. In particular, for each page the image is used on, the image must have an 1593: 1494: 1011: 274: 253: 147: 126:, even if some countries does not belong to a continent shelf. For example, 123: 700:

I've created a user account in the interests of clearer communication. The

122:

I'm fine, thank you! It is quite common to divide the world countries into

1870:

I thought that this conversation might interest you, on the talk page of

2601:

describes the Committee's roles and responsibilities in greater detail.

2511:

describes the Committee's roles and responsibilities in greater detail.

2407:

describes the Committee's roles and responsibilities in greater detail.

2230:

describes the Committee's roles and responsibilities in greater detail.

2157:

describes the Committee's roles and responsibilities in greater detail.

1920:. The proposed deletion notice added to the article should explain why. 1464:

That every article it is used on is linked to from its description page.

2578:

are allowed to vote. Users with alternate accounts may only vote once.

2489:

are allowed to vote. Users with alternate accounts may only vote once.

2072:

is the panel of editors responsible for conducting the Knowledge (XXG)

1493:

Instances of the image on other articles have been removed, except for

1344:

The tag at the top was there because (as referenced in the peer review

127: 1461:

on the image's description page for each article the image is used in.

1403:

I am not the author of the article. I simply moved the table out from

2445: 1443:, but you have not provided an adequate explanation for why it meets 131: 2833: 2632: 2542: 2457: 2429: 2358: 2306: 2252: 2179: 2105: 2047: 2015: 2001: 1982: 1895: 1860: 1840: 1737: 1616: 1601: 1592:

Please contact me if you're unsure why you received this message.

1559: 1538: 1506: 1487: 1424: 1397: 1373: 1357: 1334: 1316: 1288: 1272: 1255: 1230: 1195: 1180: 1162: 1143: 1100: 1085: 1054: 1032: 995: 980: 952: 928: 821: 807: 792: 773: 757: 733: 714: 687: 668: 638: 602: 572: 551: 520: 496: 482: 460: 434: 415: 392: 376: 356: 326: 292: 232: 192: 164: 113: 91: 1578: 1439:. You've indicated that the image is being used under a claim of 72: 2787: 2614:. If you no longer wish to receive these messages, you may add 2524:. If you no longer wish to receive these messages, you may add 2705:

Expand this box to view a list of contests this project covers.

2604:

If you wish to participate in the 2023 election, please review

2572:

is now open until 23:59 (UTC) on Monday, 11 December 2023. All

2514:

If you wish to participate in the 2021 election, please review

2410:

If you wish to participate in the 2018 election, please review

2233:

If you wish to participate in the 2017 election, please review

2160:

If you wish to participate in the 2016 election, please review

1804:

the image is deleted, and you want to restore the image, click

1701:

the image is deleted, and you want to restore the image, click

876:

does not have a history and guideline that narrows its use. --

2483:

is now open until 23:59 (UTC) on Monday, 6 December 2021. All

2032:

Talk:List of total rapid transit systems statistics by country

79:, ask me on my talk page, or ask your question and then place 1818:

If you believe the bot has made an error, please turn it off

1715:

If you believe the bot has made an error, please turn it off

933:

BTW, you are doing a great job maintaining the proper use of

2653: 2315: 2263: 1904: 1748: 1645: 1346:

Knowledge (XXG):Peer review/University of Cambridge/archive2

1116:

76ers logo for the 1980, 1982, and 1983 NBA Finals. Also #8

365:

Talk:List of rapid transit systems#San Francisco Muni Metro

1794:, and will therefore not be able to answer your questions. 1691:, and will therefore not be able to answer your questions. 87:

before the question on your talk page. Again, welcome! --

1914:

List of total rapid transit systems statistics by country

1497:(for which a fair-use rationale already was provided). -- 398:

Hi! So far, there is at least one reason not to include

2585: