Knowledge

User:Jnc/Astronomer vs Amateur

Source 📝

116: 45: 771: 1174: 1141: 826: 277:
OK, after wasting a great deal of my time dredging through documents to find a citation which shows something that everyone who has 1/128th of a clue already knows, here's an old paper by Aleph and Beth which clearly states that the Moon is not made of green cheese.
451: 926: 576: 781: 342: 951: 1036: 996: 526: 246:
OK, after wasting a great deal of my time, time which could have been spent adding a great deal of content on other things, here's a paper by Aleph and Beth which happens to mention that the Moon is not made of green cheese.
253:
That paper's entitled "Everything you ever wanted to know about the Moon, but were afraid to ask". It's clearly a joke, and useless as a citation. Please provide a citation which shows it's not made of green cheese.
571: 896: 991: 1101: 1091: 536: 386: 626: 566: 1001: 851: 636: 441: 1189: 931: 656: 199:
That says it's the composition of rocks at the Apollo 12 landing site. I say the rest of the Moon is made of green cheese. Find me a citation that says it's not made of green cheese.
34: 831: 821: 756: 681: 1235: 1021: 561: 506: 391: 751: 966: 1066: 486: 1081: 1041: 976: 1011: 716: 651: 1096: 936: 881: 766: 516: 1184: 1026: 746: 711: 436: 671: 981: 846: 1225: 805: 761: 476: 1061: 1046: 1016: 861: 1031: 406: 1131: 946: 941: 696: 1111: 956: 731: 621: 591: 586: 134: 1076: 721: 646: 329: 1146: 726: 601: 596: 511: 260:
Look, the title's a joke, but the content is clearly serious; I was there when they gave the paper at a conference, and it's not a joke.
125:
In homage to Professor Steve Ward of MIT, who wrote an incredibly funny parody of his experiences as an expert witness in a civil trial.
786: 381: 1240: 1121: 915: 836: 581: 481: 60:
It contains the advice or opinions of one or more Knowledge contributors. This page is not an encyclopedia article, nor is it one of
1006: 961: 776: 611: 396: 61: 1106: 971: 816: 686: 641: 501: 425: 371: 143: 1179: 856: 736: 701: 546: 496: 741: 676: 551: 531: 471: 1136: 1071: 1051: 666: 661: 541: 466: 461: 456: 691: 376: 176:
It's from a conference which I attended, plus to which I work in this field, so I know darn well what it's a chart of.
1056: 866: 631: 355: 1086: 871: 521: 126: 986: 876: 606: 491: 322: 891: 706: 556: 290:
No it's not, like I said before, it's made (after oxygen) of silicon, aluminium, calcium, magnesium, and iron.
401: 772:
User:Vanished user 909146283013/Follow the WP:EPISODE guideline and make AfD easier for articles that don't
886: 217:
These guys are the principal experts on the Moon's composition, and they say it's made of something else.
193:
OK, here's an email from the person who created the table, which says that I have correctly captioned it.
115: 205:
OK, here's a paper by Alpha, Beta and Gamma that says what the lunar crust as a whole is made out of.
1230: 1205: 446: 315: 129:, much of this dialogue is actually taken from real events here on Knowledge; for example, check out 1126: 338: 235:
Your opinions are irrelevant. Please provide a citation which shows it's not made of green cheese.
65: 301: 75: 1142:
User:MichaelQSchmidt/The general notability guide versus subject-specific notability guidelines
211:
That doesn't say that it's not made of green cheese. So I'm right, it is made of green cheese.
23: 229:
I've worked with them on determining the Moon's composition, and I know they are the experts.
616: 119: 53: 827:
User:ASCIIn2Bme/Verifiability and plagiarism are the hammer and anvil of astute wikilawyers
152:
No it's not, it's made (after oxygen) of silicon, aluminium, calcium, magnesium, and iron.
1116: 266:
I don't believe you. Please provide a citation which shows it's not made of green cheese.
1175:
Assume the assumption of the assumption of the assumption of the assumption of bad faith
452:
User:Aspening/Just because something is unflattering doesn't mean it should be deleted
1219: 366: 927:
User:HowardBGolden/Abuse of the General Notability Guideline in Deletion Discussions
577:
User:HowardBGolden/Abuse of the General Notability Guideline in Deletion Discussions
68:. Some essays represent widespread norms; others only represent minority viewpoints. 170:
How do you know that's what it is? I say it's a chart of the composition of Pluto.
782:
User:ViperSnake151/Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion (Human Readable Version)
182:
Your opinions are biased, irrelevant, and probably wrong. I still say it's Pluto.
164:
Here's a chart I just found in my files and uploaded which gives the composition.
1208:
category page has many more, listed below the subcategories section on the pages.
300:<Repeat from the beginning. After that, repeat several more times, with a 952:
User:Chrislk02/anarticleaboutaschoolthatcantfindagermanteacherisnotnotable
130: 1037:
User:Mike Cline/Imagining a new way to look at the question of Notability
527:
User:Emmette Hernandez Coleman/Deleting redirects to facilitate searching
17: 997:
Knowledge:Don't assume lasting significance for instances of self-harm
897:
User:Vincentvikram/Always keep context in mind when arguing claims
307: 114: 1102:
User:Geo Swan/Evaluating notability for lesser prizes and awards
296:
Find me a citation that says it's not made of Limburger cheese.
33:"WP:CHEESE" redirects here. For the WikiProject task force, see 1163: 913: 803: 537:
User:Geo Swan/opinions/editing Fahd al Jutayli while before Afd
423: 387:
User:Lulu of the Lotus-Eaters/Academic and artistic biographies
353: 311: 992:
Knowledge:Don't assume lasting significance for crime articles
39: 637:
User:NawlinWiki/List of things that will get speedily deleted
442:
User:AleatoryPonderings/Systemic bias in deletion discussions
627:
User:Mike Cline/The Inclusionist's Guide To Deletion Debates
158:
Find me a citation that says it's not made of green cheese.
1092:
User:PorkchopGMX/Popularity doesn’t always equal notability
1002:
User:MalwareSmarts/Don't confuse non-notability with a hoax
932:
User:Philtweir/Academic communities articles and notability
572:
User:Hijiri88/Don't call yourself or others "inclusionists"
223:
Who says they are the experts? It's made of green cheese.
852:
User:SMcCandlish/Discretionary sanctions 2013–2018 review
657:
User:Puzzledvegetable/DINC alone is not a reason to keep
97: 90: 83: 35:
Knowledge:WikiProject Food and drink/Cheeses task force
822:
User:Alexia Death/Community Court for community issues
757:
User:Tothwolf/rescued essays/AfD: formula for conflict
682:
User:Robofish/Thoughts on inclusionism and deletionism
1022:
User:League Octopus/Club notability tables (and test)
567:
User:Hijiri88/Don't call other editors "deletionists"
562:
User:Hiding/Points to note regarding deletion debates
507:
User:Davidwr/Choosing SPEEDY, PROD, or AFD deletion
392:
User:This is Paul/Articles concerning criminal acts
284:OK, the Moon is actually made of Limburger cheese. 967:User:Czarkoff/essays/Businesses are rarely notable 1067:User:Davidwr/No topic deserves to be in Knowledge 1042:User:Davidwr/Inherent Notability as a slang term 977:User:ReaderofthePack/Common notability arguments 832:User:ASCIIn2Bme/What "no consensus" really means 111:The Astronomer and the Amateur meet on Knowledge 1012:User:Anon126/Explaining notability to newcomers 717:User:SoWhy/Ten Commandments for Speedy Deletion 652:User:SMcCandlish/Notability and Deletion policy 1097:User:RoySmith/essays/Presumption of Notability 937:User:Robert McClenon/Acceptance of Biographies 882:User:The Bushranger/Lob a grenade and run away 767:User:Ultraexactzz/Time-delayed Speedy Deletion 517:User:Eire2020/WP:On the subject of deletionism 487:User:The Bushranger/Don't move articles at AfD 1027:User:ArsenalFan700/Indian Football Notability 747:User:Tisane/Allow viewing of deleted articles 712:User:SoWhy/Before tagging for speedy deletion 437:User:Mangojuice/Administrators are not slaves 323: 8: 1236:Knowledge essays about experts and expertise 672:User:Ritchie333/Plain and simple guide to A7 1190:Nomination of Knowledge for speedy deletion 982:User:Lagrange613/Coverage is not notability 847:User:Beeblebrox/The perfect policy proposal 1160: 1082:User:Herostratus/"Notable people" sections 910: 800: 762:User:Ultraexactzz/Sorting Deletion Debates 477:User:Bibliomaniac15/A guide to closing CFD 420: 350: 330: 316: 308: 1062:User:Brainy J/No Exceptions to Notability 1047:User:Robert McClenon/Internet celebrities 1017:User:AliveFreeHappy/Notability (firearms) 862:User:Orlady/Getting your way at Knowledge 1032:User:Phil Sandifer/History of notability 407:User:Steve Smith/Semi-protection of BLPs 1132:User:ReaderofthePack/YouTube notability 947:User:Masem/Alternate Take on Notability 942:User:Alex Noble/AFC is about notability 752:User:Tisane/Don't delete users' résumés 697:User:Simon Dodd/Some AFD considerations 1112:User:Esquivalience/Essay on notability 957:User:ReaderofthePack/Author notability 732:User:Syrenka V/Protection not deletion 622:User:Mike Cline/Archimedes was deleted 592:User:K50 Dude/Essay on Speedy Deletion 587:User:Jh12/School articles and deletion 1077:User:Glades12/Notability is temporary 722:User:Spartaz/Rescuing Deleted Content 647:User:Northamerica1000/Eager to delete 7: 1147:User:voorts/The spectrum of coverage 727:User:Stifle/Delete unless cleaned up 302:variety of different types of cheese 787:User:Yunshui/Deletion for beginners 382:User:Kirill Lokshin/Professionalism 1122:User:Fleets/sandboxWPRL notability 837:User:GTBacchus/A recurring problem 582:User:Isomorphic/Essays/Deletionism 512:User:Davidwr/Deleting GA+ articles 66:thoroughly vetted by the community 62:Knowledge's policies or guidelines 31: 1226:User essays on dispute resolution 1007:User:Basket of Puppies/Editorials 962:User:Gryllida/BiographyNotability 806:User essays on dispute resolution 777:User:Vermont/essay/AfD Filibuster 612:User:Martijn Hoekstra/what is AfD 602:User:Lenticel/Deletion isn't Evil 597:User:KGirlTrucker81/What G1 isn't 397:User:Mattinbgn/BLP considerations 1107:User:RoySmith/Three best sources 972:User:Northamerica1000/Churnalism 817:User:AGK/Arbitration and content 687:User:RoySmith/Three best sources 642:User:NeoFreak/Essays/Deletionism 502:User:Northamerica1000/Churnalism 372:User:Doc glasgow/The BLP problem 144:The Moon is made of green cheese 43: 857:User:Guy Macon/One against many 737:User:Terrariola/Delete the junk 702:User:Seraphimblade/Deletion FAQ 547:User:Ginkgo100/Speedy deletions 497:User:Champion/Deletion is cheap 482:User:Buddy431/AFD isn't cleanup 24:Knowledge:Astronomer vs Amateur 842:User:Jnc/Astronomer vs Amateur 742:User:The Cunctator/Deletionism 677:User:Ritchie333/The Dumpy test 552:User:Graymornings/Have a heart 532:User:Fl/Reports/RevisionDelete 472:User:Balloonman/CSD G10 survey 1: 1137:User:Seraphimblade/sandbox2/3 1072:User:Esquivalience/Notability 1052:User:Joe Decker/IsThisNotable 667:User:RileyBugz/G11 and drafts 662:User:Randy Kryn/Rule of thumb 542:User:Ginkgo100/AFD philosophy 467:User:Balloonman/CSD G1 survey 462:User:Balloonman/CSD A7 survey 457:User:Balloonman/CSD A1 survey 692:User:Sebwite/Mock Afd Series 377:User:JoshuaZ/Thoughts on BLP 1057:User:Trackinfo/sandbox/NHSL 867:User:Robert McClenon/Crisis 632:User:Mr.Z-man/on fixing CSD 1257: 1087:User:Uncle G/On notability 872:User:RGloucester/Sanctions 522:User:Elaragirl/Deletionism 124: 73: 32: 1241:Humorous Knowledge essays 1202: 1170: 1159: 987:User:Bahamut0013/deletion 922: 916:User essays on notability 909: 877:User:Skomorokh/First rule 812: 799: 607:User:Livitup/Deletion FAQ 492:User:Spartaz/Closing AFDs 432: 419: 362: 349: 270:<Even longer wait.> 1185:Letters from the editors 892:User:AGK/AE improvements 707:User:Shereth/Deletionism 557:User:Hellboy2hell/Delete 426:User essays on deletion 402:User:SirFozzie/BLP-Lock 887:Knowledge:Unblockables 122: 118: 64:, as it has not been 447:User:Angela/Deletion 1127:User:Moray An Par/b 356:User essays on BLP 239:<Long wait.> 123: 1213: 1212: 1198: 1197: 1155: 1154: 905: 904: 795: 794: 415: 414: 127:Believe it or not 108: 107: 22:(Redirected from 1248: 1161: 911: 801: 617:User:MBisanz/AfD 421: 351: 344: 332: 325: 318: 309: 100: 93: 86: 47: 46: 40: 27: 1256: 1255: 1251: 1250: 1249: 1247: 1246: 1245: 1216: 1215: 1214: 1209: 1194: 1166: 1165:Humorous essays 1151: 1117:User:Fleets/RLN 918: 901: 808: 791: 428: 411: 358: 345: 336: 138: 113: 104: 103: 96: 89: 82: 78: 70: 69: 58: 44: 38: 29: 28: 21: 20: 12: 11: 5: 1254: 1252: 1244: 1243: 1238: 1233: 1228: 1218: 1217: 1211: 1210: 1203: 1200: 1199: 1196: 1195: 1193: 1192: 1187: 1182: 1180:Avoid headings 1177: 1171: 1168: 1167: 1164: 1157: 1156: 1153: 1152: 1150: 1149: 1144: 1139: 1134: 1129: 1124: 1119: 1114: 1109: 1104: 1099: 1094: 1089: 1084: 1079: 1074: 1069: 1064: 1059: 1054: 1049: 1044: 1039: 1034: 1029: 1024: 1019: 1014: 1009: 1004: 999: 994: 989: 984: 979: 974: 969: 964: 959: 954: 949: 944: 939: 934: 929: 923: 920: 919: 914: 907: 906: 903: 902: 900: 899: 894: 889: 884: 879: 874: 869: 864: 859: 854: 849: 844: 839: 834: 829: 824: 819: 813: 810: 809: 804: 797: 796: 793: 792: 790: 789: 784: 779: 774: 769: 764: 759: 754: 749: 744: 739: 734: 729: 724: 719: 714: 709: 704: 699: 694: 689: 684: 679: 674: 669: 664: 659: 654: 649: 644: 639: 634: 629: 624: 619: 614: 609: 604: 599: 594: 589: 584: 579: 574: 569: 564: 559: 554: 549: 544: 539: 534: 529: 524: 519: 514: 509: 504: 499: 494: 489: 484: 479: 474: 469: 464: 459: 454: 449: 444: 439: 433: 430: 429: 424: 417: 416: 413: 412: 410: 409: 404: 399: 394: 389: 384: 379: 374: 369: 363: 360: 359: 354: 347: 346: 337: 335: 334: 327: 320: 312: 133:and then read 112: 109: 106: 105: 102: 101: 94: 91:WP:GREENCHEESE 87: 79: 74: 71: 59: 50: 48: 30: 15: 14: 13: 10: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 1253: 1242: 1239: 1237: 1234: 1232: 1229: 1227: 1224: 1223: 1221: 1207: 1201: 1191: 1188: 1186: 1183: 1181: 1178: 1176: 1173: 1172: 1169: 1162: 1158: 1148: 1145: 1143: 1140: 1138: 1135: 1133: 1130: 1128: 1125: 1123: 1120: 1118: 1115: 1113: 1110: 1108: 1105: 1103: 1100: 1098: 1095: 1093: 1090: 1088: 1085: 1083: 1080: 1078: 1075: 1073: 1070: 1068: 1065: 1063: 1060: 1058: 1055: 1053: 1050: 1048: 1045: 1043: 1040: 1038: 1035: 1033: 1030: 1028: 1025: 1023: 1020: 1018: 1015: 1013: 1010: 1008: 1005: 1003: 1000: 998: 995: 993: 990: 988: 985: 983: 980: 978: 975: 973: 970: 968: 965: 963: 960: 958: 955: 953: 950: 948: 945: 943: 940: 938: 935: 933: 930: 928: 925: 924: 921: 917: 912: 908: 898: 895: 893: 890: 888: 885: 883: 880: 878: 875: 873: 870: 868: 865: 863: 860: 858: 855: 853: 850: 848: 845: 843: 840: 838: 835: 833: 830: 828: 825: 823: 820: 818: 815: 814: 811: 807: 802: 798: 788: 785: 783: 780: 778: 775: 773: 770: 768: 765: 763: 760: 758: 755: 753: 750: 748: 745: 743: 740: 738: 735: 733: 730: 728: 725: 723: 720: 718: 715: 713: 710: 708: 705: 703: 700: 698: 695: 693: 690: 688: 685: 683: 680: 678: 675: 673: 670: 668: 665: 663: 660: 658: 655: 653: 650: 648: 645: 643: 640: 638: 635: 633: 630: 628: 625: 623: 620: 618: 615: 613: 610: 608: 605: 603: 600: 598: 595: 593: 590: 588: 585: 583: 580: 578: 575: 573: 570: 568: 565: 563: 560: 558: 555: 553: 550: 548: 545: 543: 540: 538: 535: 533: 530: 528: 525: 523: 520: 518: 515: 513: 510: 508: 505: 503: 500: 498: 495: 493: 490: 488: 485: 483: 480: 478: 475: 473: 470: 468: 465: 463: 460: 458: 455: 453: 450: 448: 445: 443: 440: 438: 435: 434: 431: 427: 422: 418: 408: 405: 403: 400: 398: 395: 393: 390: 388: 385: 383: 380: 378: 375: 373: 370: 368: 367:User:DGG/bios 365: 364: 361: 357: 352: 348: 340: 333: 328: 326: 321: 319: 314: 313: 310: 306: 305: 303: 297: 295: 291: 289: 285: 283: 279: 276: 272: 271: 267: 265: 261: 259: 255: 252: 248: 245: 241: 240: 236: 234: 230: 228: 224: 222: 218: 216: 212: 210: 206: 204: 200: 198: 194: 192: 188: 187: 186:<Wait.> 183: 181: 177: 175: 171: 169: 165: 163: 159: 157: 153: 151: 147: 145: 142: 136: 132: 128: 121: 117: 110: 99: 98:WP:ASTRONOMER 95: 92: 88: 85: 81: 80: 77: 72: 67: 63: 57: 55: 49: 42: 41: 36: 25: 19: 841: 299: 298: 293: 292: 287: 286: 281: 280: 274: 273: 269: 268: 263: 262: 257: 256: 250: 249: 243: 242: 238: 237: 232: 231: 226: 225: 220: 219: 214: 213: 208: 207: 202: 201: 196: 195: 190: 189: 185: 184: 179: 178: 173: 172: 167: 166: 161: 160: 155: 154: 149: 148: 140: 139: 51: 1231:User essays 1206:User essays 339:User essays 288:Astronomer: 275:Astronomer: 258:Astronomer: 244:Astronomer: 227:Astronomer: 215:Astronomer: 203:Astronomer: 191:Astronomer: 174:Astronomer: 162:Astronomer: 150:Astronomer: 52:This is an 1220:Categories 1204:Note: The 120:WP:CHEESE 84:WP:CHEESE 76:Shortcuts 294:Amateur: 282:Amateur: 264:Amateur: 251:Amateur: 233:Amateur: 221:Amateur: 209:Amateur: 197:Amateur: 180:Amateur: 168:Amateur: 156:Amateur: 141:Amateur: 18:User:Jnc 341:  304:.> 54:essay 16:< 135:this 131:this 343:(?) 1222:: 146:. 331:e 324:t 317:v 137:. 56:. 37:. 26:)

Index

User:Jnc
Knowledge:Astronomer vs Amateur
Knowledge:WikiProject Food and drink/Cheeses task force
essay
Knowledge's policies or guidelines
thoroughly vetted by the community
Shortcuts
WP:CHEESE
WP:GREENCHEESE
WP:ASTRONOMER

WP:CHEESE
Believe it or not
this
this
The Moon is made of green cheese
variety of different types of cheese
v
t
e
User essays
User essays on BLP
User:DGG/bios
User:Doc glasgow/The BLP problem
User:JoshuaZ/Thoughts on BLP
User:Kirill Lokshin/Professionalism
User:Lulu of the Lotus-Eaters/Academic and artistic biographies
User:This is Paul/Articles concerning criminal acts
User:Mattinbgn/BLP considerations
User:SirFozzie/BLP-Lock

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.