488:. The few respectable looking sources are either being used to support general information on the prison that has nothing to do with the so-called "legends", or being wildly misconstrued. For example, several of the actual legitimate sources may speak of the prison feeling "haunted" or "sinister" in a metaphorical sense, but it is clear from the context of the actual source that that they are not talking about literal ghosts, which this article intentionally misinterprets to support these "legend" claims. In some cases, the cited sources appear to be outright lies, as the source they are using does not even mention the information that the article claims it does. While the topic of legends regarding the iconic location
274:. Moreover, I think that it is not possible to write a proper encyclopedic article on this topic. Superficially, there is a lot of sourcing, but the book references are pretty much all unusable trash. Omitting WWN, the newspaper references are soft-news puff pieces, many of them published in October (i.e., in the lead-up to Halloween), or book reviews of the kind of trashy books being used as sourcing. Per
267:(!!), and the bibliography is full of such academic tomes as "Ghost Hunting: How to Investigate the Paranormal", "Hell House: And Other True Hauntings from Around the World", etc.; a sentence in the lead about Native American legends is sourced to something titled "Famous Ghosts and Haunted Places". The reality-based content is limited, pushed to the margins, and intentionally framed to minimize its impact.
454:
independent reliable sources with which to construct an encyclopedic article. The most that could be confirmed to be notable by reliable independent sources is that some people believe
Alcatraz is haunted. And that could be accomplished by a line or two at the main
394:
nonsense." The plural of anecdote, as they say, is not data; the fact that if you scour the bottom of the intellectual bucket roughly enough, bits of crud will rise to the surface, does not mean that the bits of crud piled together will make an actual topic.
282:, these sources should all be excluded from any measure of notability in the encyclopedic sense. And at the end that leaves nothing. Probably the content could be trimmed down to one paragraph, to be included in the article
82:
223:
430:
450:"padding" about gruesome deaths, insanity, mistreatment of prisoners, etc. (and Mark Twain's quote that he found the island gloomy and cold falls into this category) -- I doubt if there are enough
77:
363:
323:
217:
343:
176:
183:
303:
108:
123:
544:. I concur, however, with JBL that a couple of paragraphs should be redirected and included in the main article's section dealing with this stuff.---
149:
144:
153:
136:
553:
532:
509:
468:
407:
375:
355:
335:
315:
295:
61:
446:
belief that ghosts exist, can be detected by psychics and ghost hunter gadgets, and the sensational "silly season" stuff, plus all the
103:
96:
17:
442:
independent sources to justify a stand alone article. Once you strip out all the sources (e.g. paranormal themed books) pushing the
238:
388:
but cannot be said to constitute an actual topic. This doesn't even fall under the category of, "We know it's nonsense, but it's
205:
117:
113:
493:
456:
283:
570:
496:
page, this particular article should not be kept, merged, or preserved in any way, as it fails the most basic tests of
40:
199:
384:- No evidence that there is an actual subject matter here; just little bits of poorly-sourced crap which relate to
497:
195:
275:
255:
140:
371:
351:
331:
311:
291:
245:
527:
132:
67:
566:
426:
36:
464:
402:
57:
549:
505:
231:
541:
477:
443:
279:
258:
367:
347:
327:
307:
287:
211:
485:
451:
439:
518:
492:
actually be a legitimate topic that could be discussed somewhere, perhaps as part of the main
481:
263:
92:
29:
The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.
565:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's
35:
Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's
438:
per nom. I fully agree that
Alcatraz haunting legends are notable. But there are not enough
422:
271:
460:
418:
396:
53:
447:
545:
501:
480:
publications, tourist-trap style travel guides, tabloids (as noted by the nom, the
170:
421:. Silly-season fluff is not a solid foundation for an encyclopedia article.
517:
A pleasure to support Orange Mike, a craftsman of the delete discussion. -
385:
561:
The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate.
484:
is cited multiple times as if it were a reliable source), and
476:- Per nom. The article is a mess of "information" sourced to
83:
Articles for deletion/Legends of
Alcatraz (2nd nomination)
166:
162:
158:
230:
270:
At a minimum, the current article content calls for
244:
43:). No further edits should be made to this page.
573:). No further edits should be made to this page.
362:Note: This discussion has been included in the
342:Note: This discussion has been included in the
322:Note: This discussion has been included in the
302:Note: This discussion has been included in the
364:list of California-related deletion discussions
324:list of Paranormal-related deletion discussions
344:list of Mythology-related deletion discussions
261:content: there are multiple citations of the
8:
124:Help, my article got nominated for deletion!
361:
341:
321:
304:list of Crime-related deletion discussions
301:
78:Articles for deletion/Legends of Alcatraz
75:
18:Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion
7:
74:
24:
109:Introduction to deletion process
1:
494:Alcatraz Federal Penitentiary
284:Alcatraz Federal Penitentiary
99:(AfD)? Read these primers!
590:
554:20:56, 23 June 2020 (UTC)
533:11:41, 21 June 2020 (UTC)
510:01:17, 21 June 2020 (UTC)
469:17:37, 20 June 2020 (UTC)
431:15:52, 20 June 2020 (UTC)
408:15:19, 20 June 2020 (UTC)
376:15:03, 20 June 2020 (UTC)
356:15:03, 20 June 2020 (UTC)
336:15:03, 20 June 2020 (UTC)
316:15:03, 20 June 2020 (UTC)
296:15:03, 20 June 2020 (UTC)
62:01:57, 28 June 2020 (UTC)
563:Please do not modify it.
286:, and redirected there.
32:Please do not modify it.
73:AfDs for this article:
97:Articles for deletion
133:Legends of Alcatraz
68:Legends of Alcatraz
524:
500:in its content.
482:Weekly World News
378:
358:
338:
318:
264:Weekly World News
114:Guide to deletion
104:How to contribute
581:
522:
498:WP:VERIFIABILITY
405:
399:
249:
248:
234:
186:
174:
156:
94:
34:
589:
588:
584:
583:
582:
580:
579:
578:
577:
571:deletion review
403:
397:
254:The article is
191:
182:
147:
131:
128:
91:
88:
71:
48:The result was
41:deletion review
30:
22:
21:
20:
12:
11:
5:
587:
585:
576:
575:
557:
556:
535:
523:the elfin dog
512:
471:
433:
411:
410:
379:
359:
339:
319:
276:WP:SENSATIONAL
256:WP:SENSATIONAL
252:
251:
188:
127:
126:
121:
111:
106:
89:
87:
86:
85:
80:
72:
70:
65:
46:
45:
25:
23:
15:
14:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
586:
574:
572:
568:
564:
559:
558:
555:
551:
547:
543:
539:
536:
534:
531:
530:
526:
521:
516:
513:
511:
507:
503:
499:
495:
491:
487:
483:
479:
475:
472:
470:
466:
462:
458:
453:
449:
445:
441:
437:
434:
432:
428:
424:
420:
416:
413:
412:
409:
406:
400:
393:
392:
387:
383:
382:Strong delete
380:
377:
373:
369:
365:
360:
357:
353:
349:
345:
340:
337:
333:
329:
325:
320:
317:
313:
309:
305:
300:
299:
298:
297:
293:
289:
285:
281:
277:
273:
268:
266:
265:
260:
257:
247:
243:
240:
237:
233:
229:
225:
222:
219:
216:
213:
210:
207:
204:
201:
197:
194:
193:Find sources:
189:
185:
181:
178:
172:
168:
164:
160:
155:
151:
146:
142:
138:
134:
130:
129:
125:
122:
119:
115:
112:
110:
107:
105:
102:
101:
100:
98:
93:
84:
81:
79:
76:
69:
66:
64:
63:
59:
55:
51:
44:
42:
38:
33:
27:
26:
19:
562:
560:
537:
528:
519:
514:
489:
473:
435:
417:per nom and
414:
390:
389:
381:
269:
262:
253:
241:
235:
227:
220:
214:
208:
202:
192:
179:
90:
49:
47:
31:
28:
459:article. -
398:Orange Mike
218:free images
461:LuckyLouie
423:XOR'easter
419:Orangemike
54:Malcolmxl5
567:talk page
542:WP:FRINGE
502:Rorshacma
478:WP:FRINGE
444:WP:FRINGE
280:WP:FRINGE
259:WP:FRINGE
37:talk page
569:or in a
486:WP:SYNTH
457:Alcatraz
452:WP:FRIND
440:WP:FRIND
386:Alcatraz
177:View log
118:glossary
39:or in a
391:notable
224:WP refs
212:scholar
150:protect
145:history
95:New to
546:Darius
538:Delete
515:Delete
474:Delete
436:Delete
415:Delete
272:WP:TNT
196:Google
154:delete
50:delete
490:might
448:WP:OR
239:JSTOR
200:books
184:Stats
171:views
163:watch
159:links
16:<
550:talk
540:per
529:wooF
520:Roxy
506:talk
465:talk
427:talk
404:Talk
372:talk
352:talk
332:talk
312:talk
292:talk
278:and
232:FENS
206:news
167:logs
141:talk
137:edit
58:talk
368:JBL
348:JBL
328:JBL
308:JBL
288:JBL
246:TWL
175:– (
552:)
508:)
467:)
429:)
401:|
395:--
374:)
366:.
354:)
346:.
334:)
326:.
314:)
306:.
294:)
226:)
169:|
165:|
161:|
157:|
152:|
148:|
143:|
139:|
60:)
52:.
548:(
525:.
504:(
463:(
425:(
370:(
350:(
330:(
310:(
290:(
250:)
242:·
236:·
228:·
221:·
215:·
209:·
203:·
198:(
190:(
187:)
180:·
173:)
135:(
120:)
116:(
56:(
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.