314:. It's been almost a week and no reply to my concerns raised above. I did some more digging and found nothing to make me more confident in Brandt as a source. Apparently his 2004 documentary on Manos is based around an outright false claim (that everyone involved in the movie died or disappeared mysteriously, except a lone stuntman). As it stands, this article is based heavily on a fanzine article by a questionable person... it's not really FA material and could need a total rewrite if I'm right. I know I could be wrong, but someone needs to clear things up... and that doesn't seem to be happening. Sorry... I know people worked hard on this article... and don't doubt they did so thinking they were using a trustworthy source. --
221:, but his story seems rather unlikely... he decided to write an article about the movie, then by shear coincidence learned that two people who made the movie are poker buddies of his good friend? It's not even clear the article isn't just a joke. I'd like to see some kind of corroboration that Brandt is to be believed before we report his claims as facts. This issue doesn't seem to have been raised in the FAC or on the talk page. --
191:
research. The source only quotes Nayman saying "Everyone worked real hard, and the only ones who got paid were me and Shanka. I got a new bicycle, and Shanka got a fifty-pound bag of dog food" - the
Knowledge (XXG) article appears to draw from that that the movie didn't break even. Yeah it probably didn't... but it still seems like a claim that runs afoul of
254:
The more I dig, the stranger this is. Everything about the production of Manos seems to trace back to Brandt as the source. People have pointed out various claims of his seem more intended to be interesting and funny than factually accurate (for instance, his claim that Harold Warren was a fertilizer
239:
job of summarizing the production and reception of an obscure film... those sections read like a textbook featured article. If the information in them proves not to be BS, and the plot section is trimmed (its length caused me to skip over it to more interesting sections), this could be salvaged as a
259:
that he's a fertilizer salesman, but it seems like it was purely a joke). Furthermore, even the 1966 newspaper article someone scanned in is problematic. Maybe I'm just being overly paranoid here, but I find the last sentence "Someone is spoofing us" to be very strange... it has nothing to do with
190:
The claim "Reports that the only crew members who were compensated for their work in the film were Jackey Neyman and her family's dog, who received a bicycle and a large quantity of dog food, respectively, would seem to indicate that the film failed to break even financially" seems like original
133:
I am nominating this featured article for review because I do not believe it is up to FA-class standards. For example, the plot section is too long, and there are too many one- and two-sentence paragraphs. Honestly, I do not feel as if this article was ever up to FA-class standards.
83:
76:
213:, a fanzine of some sort. It is cited 17 times for core information about the movie. Both articles are written by Richard Brandt (almost certainly not the
40:
99:
209:
A broader problem is that, in tracking down the source for the above issue, it seems this article is heavily based on 2 articles that ran in
30:
17:
342:
323:
303:
269:
249:
230:
204:
183:
168:
147:
125:
104:
53:
319:
265:
245:
226:
200:
142:
64:
296:
315:
261:
241:
222:
196:
255:
salesman has no non-Brandt source, and many people claim it's not true... in the MST3K episode they
282:
Suggested criteria are citations, original research/verifiability. Also note the recent changed to
164:
135:
283:
288:
260:
the article, as far as I can tell... and could be a clue that the whole thing is a prank. --
156:
179:
192:
338:
214:
160:
218:
175:
333:
39:
Further comments should be made on the article's talk page or at
210:
109:
84:
Featured article review/Manos: The Hands of Fate/archive1
217:
there's a WP article on). Brandt's source appears to be
57:
77:
Featured article candidates/Manos: The Hands of Fate
350:The above discussion is preserved as an archive.
43:). No further edits should be made to this page.
356:No further edits should be made to this page.
29:The following is an archived discussion of a
8:
41:Knowledge (XXG) talk:Featured article review
235:I will say that this article still does a
88:
91:
81:
74:
18:Knowledge (XXG):Featured article review
7:
219:interviews with 2 production people
24:
286:requiring "high-quality sources"
304:03:25, 30 September 2009 (UTC)
250:21:04, 28 September 2009 (UTC)
231:20:59, 28 September 2009 (UTC)
205:20:59, 28 September 2009 (UTC)
184:22:47, 10 September 2009 (UTC)
155:. Images need alt text as per
1:
169:21:47, 9 September 2009 (UTC)
148:19:47, 9 September 2009 (UTC)
343:21:10, 8 October 2009 (UTC)
324:01:35, 4 October 2009 (UTC)
270:00:36, 6 October 2009 (UTC)
373:
331:, concerns not addressed.
353:Please do not modify it.
65:Manos: The Hands of Fate
36:Please do not modify it.
56:04:32, 20 October 2009
31:featured article review
54:YellowAssessmentMonkey
174:I'm working on it. --
146:
126:WikiProject Films
117:
116:
71:Review commentary
364:
355:
299:
291:
140:
138:
89:
48:The article was
38:
372:
371:
367:
366:
365:
363:
362:
361:
360:
351:
316:Sancho Mandoval
297:
289:
278:
276:FARC commentary
262:Sancho Mandoval
242:Sancho Mandoval
223:Sancho Mandoval
197:Sancho Mandoval
136:
73:
68:
34:
22:
21:
20:
12:
11:
5:
370:
368:
359:
358:
346:
345:
326:
308:
307:
277:
274:
273:
272:
252:
233:
215:Richard Brandt
207:
187:
186:
137:Dream out loud
131:
130:
129:
128:
115:
114:
113:
112:
110:External links
107:
102:
94:
93:
87:
86:
80:
79:
72:
69:
67:
62:
61:
46:
45:
25:
23:
15:
14:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
369:
357:
354:
348:
347:
344:
340:
336:
335:
330:
327:
325:
321:
317:
313:
310:
309:
306:
305:
300:
295:
293:
292:
285:
280:
279:
275:
271:
267:
263:
258:
253:
251:
247:
243:
238:
234:
232:
228:
224:
220:
216:
212:
208:
206:
202:
198:
194:
189:
188:
185:
181:
177:
173:
172:
171:
170:
166:
162:
158:
154:
150:
149:
144:
139:
127:
124:
121:
120:
119:
118:
111:
108:
106:
103:
101:
98:
97:
96:
95:
90:
85:
82:
78:
75:
70:
66:
63:
60:
58:
55:
51:
44:
42:
37:
32:
27:
26:
19:
352:
349:
332:
328:
311:
301:
298:bananabucket
290:YellowMonkey
287:
281:
256:
236:
152:
151:
132:
122:
105:Citation bot
49:
47:
35:
28:
237:fantastic
161:Eubulides
123:Notified:
284:WP:WIAFA
211:"Mimosa"
100:Analysis
153:Comment
92:Toolbox
50:removed
329:Delist
312:Delist
240:FA. --
157:WP:ALT
193:WP:OR
176:Moni3
16:<
339:talk
334:Cirt
320:talk
266:talk
257:joke
246:talk
227:talk
201:talk
195:. --
180:talk
165:talk
143:talk
52:by
341:)
322:)
302:)
268:)
248:)
229:)
203:)
182:)
167:)
159:.
59:.
33:.
337:(
318:(
294:(
264:(
244:(
225:(
199:(
178:(
163:(
145:)
141:(
134:–
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.