Knowledge (XXG):Requests for arbitration/Allegations of apartheid/Evidence

2954:

were well-written. The only outcome I flat-out opposed was having some, but not all, of the relevant countries named in these articles. The example I used was whether I would !vote to delete one non-notable middle school but not another. If it were up to me, they’d all go. But if some have support of the community, than all of them should stay. If I were asked to vote on a random middle school AfD today, I would vote just as I have on the apartheid articles; my first instinct is to delete them all, but if the community feels that they are notable, then keep them all. There is no contradiction here, and no hypocrisy. Indeed, I feel my position has been quite consistent as new articles have been folded in. There was no sense for me of a “bargaining” chip—my feeling was that the Allegations of Apartheid articles were a fait accompli (and that other articles seemed to have wide community support), and that AoIa having survived so many AfD’s, there would be no way to delete it in any case. I would have liked to see an up or down vote on all articles at once, but didn’t think people would go for it, so I did not propose it myself, feeling that all it would do is raise the temperature.

5863: 248:"You clearly don't understand why we created other apartheid articles. All allegations of apartheid articles are meant to antagonize people of that culture; the Israel one included. They are all POV forks. Their existance on wikipedia is proof that WP:NPOV does not apply to article titles or afd's. Since these articles cannot be balanced on their own, the only way to balance them is to create similar articles about other countries, thus making the attack page have less effect since country X isn't the only one being alleged of being an apartheid state. There is nothing encyclopediac about accusing somebody or some culture/country/religion of apartheid. It is all an attempt to push a POV." 2958:

me to task (as part of his group) for “creating” and “developing” the later Allegations of Apartheid articles. I have created none of the articles in question, nor have I “developed” them (or edited them in any way, to the best of my recollection). I have expressed my opinion, and some have doubted the sincerity of my opinions. I am sorry that is so, but not sorry to have expressed those opinions, which I continue to hold. These articles (beginning with the first one that was created by a now-banned sock farmer to disrupt Knowledge (XXG)), have been a huge waste of time, I think, and no reputable encyclopedia would even need a discussion as to whether to include them.

6385:) that it's difficult to do such an analysis, these very results are incomplete and prone to errors, and pressure of time means he will not be changing his contribution "for a few days". I feel that ArbCom members (and regular editors) should have confidence in what we write, and it seems to me unjustifiable - even disrespectful - to leave something faulty out on display. And such behavior risks degrading the work of other contributors, who can apparently produce tabulated results without objection or error. 6783:. The behavior detailed above - creating a series of inflammatory content forks to use as bargaining chips to press for the deletion of an offending article - is the very antithesis of good faith. Given that amnesty was offered in the last Arbitration case and things have reached this juncture, and that a group of editors has blatantly ignored ArbCom's prior injunction to negotiate in good faith, it would seem that stronger sanctions are warranted this time around. 1770: 1798:). Select excerpts include "here are clearly many editors on wikipedia who hate Israel", "will only agree to what is forced upon them", "his article is liked because many wikipedians (the ones who voted keep the Israel one, delete the others in the allegations of apartheid afds) hate Israel", "t is an attack page against Israel, and it was created by anti-zionists to inflame us", and "Israel haters saw that, and want to keep the article bias". 5881: 35: 1479:"Quite honestly, Jay, neither you nor Urthogie are doing yourselves any favours when you pretend that you've suddenly acquired an interest in French social policy; the arrival of the usual clique of (pro-)Israeli partisans all voting in lockstep with you shows rather clearly what's going on here." (running headlong into a violation of AGF that he's persisted with since then). 1487:

this imagined clique of Israeli partisans. And given the volume and vociferous tone of his participation (and dubious admin practices) one could argue that he as much as anyone has disrupted Knowledge (XXG) to make a point. Yet, nobody is doing this, for the simple reason that AGF dictates that we don't leap to such conclusions but rather focus on content. --

1132:"It is very POV to have articles accusing some countries of apartheid while not allowing a similar attacks against others. Allegations of apartheid is an attack against that country, and cannot be written in a neutral manner. The closest thing we can do to make it neutral is allow the allegations against every country. This is the only way to balance it out" 227:

substantial involvement from editors native to the countries under discussion (Ideogram - China, NicDumZ - France, ChrisO (myself) - Northern Ireland/UK, Cerejota - Puerto Rico). Some of these editors (notably Cerejota) have gone on to play significant roles in the development of the other articles after becoming aware of the wider controversy.

2205:

ArbComm also delivered the following ruling in this case: "Editors of articles concerning apartheid are directed to negotiate in good faith appropriate article names using relevant policies and guidelines. If negotiation is unsuccessful, interested parties are required to enter into good faith mediation regarding the matter.") (refer:

1162:"Reguardless of what you think of the sourcing of the Allegations of Israeli apartheid, it is a POV fork, like all allegations of apartheid articles are. It is even more POV to allow the allegation on some articles but not others. This seems like an attempt to delete all allegations of apartheid articles except the Israel one" 677:"As I have said elsewhere, I generally do not like "Allegations of" articles (or articles that amount ot that even when not so-called). However, what I'd like would be cherry-picking which allegations are "true" and deleting the rest. If someone wanted to put all of these articles up for an AfD, I'd be willing to vote yes." 4094:(This analysis is based on extracts that I've made from available AFD discussions. I've parsed the data the best I could, but there may be residual errors. If so, these should be a result of technical problems, not any systematic bias. Anyone who wants to review the raw data is welcome to; feel free to email me). 738:"In my view, and that of many others, the only real solution for the "Allegations of Israeli apartheid" POV-monstrosity is outright deletion, salt the earth, etc. The article is an embarrassment to Knowledge (XXG), a political propaganda-fest that a good encyclopedia (like Britannica) would never put up with." 2804:; Urthrogie and Jayjg get no support, ChrisO gets support. Urhtrogie also declines to discuss the content changes with an uninvolved editor who describes Urthrogie as "removing sourced material and references from this article" while the moving is occurring. Urthrogie never discusses the content changes. 6878:

First, I'm not sure one is intended to comment in others' evidence sections, particularly when I have a finding of fact on this in the Workshop which is open to response. Otherwise, I fully encourage editors to read the diffs, as I believe they are the central issue here (please do explain "ven some

3720:

IronDuke on Jayjg's deletion: "Delete The article is a POV fork, and the majority of !voters favor being rid of it in some fashion or other. I will also note that the loudest cries against Jay as a biased editor seem to be coming from editors with a pronounced (and in some cases acknowledged) bias of

2953:

My first choice was to have all the articles deleted. I believed they all suffered from the same flaw, which basically boiled down to OR. If the community felt that the Allegations articles were somehow not OR, I would disagree, but would then advocate keeping all the ones that had decent sources and

2825:

I'm not sure what's more flabbergasting: that I have been accused of incivility where a brief glance would reveal that not to be the case, or that it's been done by an editor I have never, to my knowledge, encountered before, who has never made any attempt to warn me of my allegedly uncivil behavior,

266:

this one or delete them all per Humus Sapians. These is an obvious POV fork. It is very POV to have articles accusing some countries of apartheid while not allowing a similar attacks against others. Allegations of apartheid is an attack against that country, and cannot be written in a neutral manner.

92:

Be aware that Arbitrators may at times rework this page to try to make it more coherent. If you are a participant in the case or a third party, please don't try to re-factor the page, let the Arbitrators do it. If you object to evidence which is inserted by other participants or third parties please

6554:

as delete. While he had not been involved in editing the article, his previous involvement in other "Allegations of apartheid" articles and the centralized apartheid discussion made it very unlikely that his closure would be perceived as neutral. While the basic rationale for the closure was soundly

6215:

Beyond that, it's been my contention that all articles' existence should be based on the merit of each of them in terms of notability, NPOV, OR, etc. And since we, as a community, have put the title issue to rest, then articles also need time to evolve to a somewhat stable state. I think AoIa is the

3712:

Tewfik on ChrisO's deletion: "Overturn - while I sympathise with some of the rationales for dealing with the Apartheid entries re: WTA, ChrisO should clearly not have taken administrative action in this case. Even if someone else had done it, there is still no way that 50% delete should be closed as

3655:

Jayjg on Jayjg's deletion: "Regarding the various people who are hinting or stating outright that I have some sort of conflict of interest, or shouldn't be able to make administrative decisions on wide areas of article topics, or, most bizarrely, that I have in the past "illegally" deleted articles,

2957:

MastCell also alleges that I have violated a previous arbcom ruling, though he provides no evidence that I have not negotiated in good faith. I can only say that I have done nothing but, and was willing to accept an outcome which I thought fairly odious, as a compromise position. MastCell also takes

1486:

Now, looking at ChrisO's record in opining and writing about all AFDs since the one about alleged French apartheid, an uncharitable editor might assert that the "only reasonable explanation" for his views is that he was so offended by the allegations against France that he went on a vendetta against

3696:

Humus Sapiens on ChrisO's deletion: "Overturn - I question the qualification of ChrisO (talk • contribs • blocks • protects • deletions • moves) to take an admin action because of his clearly one-sided activism on the page in question and in related discussions. Also, I don't see how the discussion

3674:

6SJ7 on Jayjg's deletion: "I endorse Jayjg's action. I will resist the temptation to respond to claims of "bias", but I do not think it is helpful to throw those allegations around. I do think that Knowledge (XXG) is "broken" when it comes to articles about Israel and Israeli-Arab relations, and it

3505:

because of my views. Apparently, he believes I am acting inappropriately for expressing my views in a clear content dispute, and apparently, he feels actions should be taken against me for having a different opinion than his over this content dispute. He further accuses our voting as being based on

2846:

editors (other than the banned ones) who support AoIa are antisemites. It is perfectly possible to agree with me that AoIa smacks of antisemitism, but disagree with me and say WP needs an article on it anyway. My reasoning may be off (though I don't think it is), but to claim that a general comment

1524:

This is a dispute between ChrisO and his opinionated and misinformed gaggle of know-it-all admins in opposition to a bunch of other admins, a number of whom happen to be Jews. This is something that becomes obvious when the relevant discussion is read in full. It is not without cause that there are

226:

Urthogie is the editor most heavily involved (in 7 of 10 of these articles), reflecting his role as the principal creator of the series. Jayjg has the largest number of edits, reflecting his leading role in developing these articles (though he only created one of them). Individual articles have had

44:

in your own section. Please limit your main evidence to a maximum 1000 words and 100 diffs and keep responses as short as possible; a shorter, concise presentation is more likely to be effective. Please focus on the issues raised in the complaint and on diffs which illustrate behavior which relates

3728:

IronDuke on ChrisO's deletion: "Overturn I did not !vote in the original AfD, but this is waaaayyyy out of process, both in terms of numbers, opinions offered, and, most importantly, because it was done by an admin who is deeply involved--indeed, who is a POV warrior on these subjects. I know this

3558:

First of all, I never accused him personally of being an israel hater; I used it more or less in a general context. But he assumes I have a list of Israel-hating editors, making another bad faith allegation, and basically calling me (or my beliefs) "shit"; also asserting that I apparently am a bad

7039:

It seems to me that Sm8900 contacted me after recently encountering my effort to play a facilitating role in another Israeli-Palestinian topic. I see little basis on which Sm8900 would presuppose my support for his position in the Jenin dispute, given my sparse and rather neutral contributions on

6100:

For example, it is a known fact that in the USA today, most fatalities in traffic accidents are wearing seat belts. You could argue then, that seat belts are unsafe. However, this will ignore the fact that in proportion and absolut numbers, much more people people wear seat belts than before laws

3704:

Tewfik on Jayjg's deletion: "This is deletion review, whose sole aim is assessing whether the AfD warrants a deletion or undeletion. It isn't the place for reviewing anyone's actions, and much less for leveling accusations of 'censorship' or 'abuse of powers' (or even for being "completely out of

3590:

Numerous times Cerejota has falsely accused me of may things including 3rr violations by miscounting, disruption by misinterpritations of my comments, etc. Participation in an afd for an article one thinks should be deleted is not disruption. Besides that, Cerejota has been uncivil. First, he/she

2204:

article, Jayjg was "admonished not use administrative tools without prior discussion and consensus, and to avoid using them so as to continue an editing dispute" and "reminded to use mediation and other dispute resolution procedures sooner when conflicts occur". (It may be worth noting that the

1578:

Some editors tried to move the article without any consensus, the article got protected. From that time, every proposal I would do got "all or nothing" answers ("if you act on the French article, you should act the same on the other articles; If you don't want to act on others, then I will oppose

6555:

upheld at deletion review, several editors (including myself) expressed the opinion that ChrisO was not suitably uninvolved to close this debate. ChrisO should reasonably have known that his close would be seen as inappropriate by a significant number of the AfD participants, resulting in drama.

4748:

The editor who has voted most often here is G-Dett's. She has voted on every single issue except allegations of American apartheid and rejected efforts to create articles about allegations of apartheid in a number of non-Israeli countries, while voting to keep articles about alleged apartheid in

3772:

Tarc on ChrisO's deletion: Endorse Closure - Unless someone can point out where the policy is that precludes an admin who is involved in a topic from taking administrative actions in said topic, this sounds like a bunch of sour grapes from those that support the article. Tarc 13:10, 31 July 2007

6224:

Like it or not, most if not all articles about Israel specifically and the Arab-Israeli conflict generally attracts some level of edit controversy. As much as we don't want, and shouldn't encourage, these articles to be battlegrounds for the real-life conflicts, we also rely on the dialectic to

6207:

Much has been written about the meaning of the titles, and indeed the title "Allegations of Israeli apartheid" is a result of much contention and many changes. The article started its life as Israeli apartheid and many have continued to argue for this title, because to them it is a fact beyond

3869:

Your help is vitally needed. Please go to this proceeding and insert your comments indicating support for those who seek to preserve balance at Knowledge (XXG) by applying this method of inquiry equally, by applying the "aparetheid" analigy to a variety of countries equally, instead of only to

2835:

I feel that a reply ought to be unnecessary, since one only has to click on the diffs provided by Picaroon to see that they do not match his interpretation of them. Also, this was not a proceeding I wished to be a party to, and would have happily ignored it but as it appears there's no opt-out

1703:

6956:

Yet he also says that instead of asking these disruptive AfDs be speedy closed, as any good-faith editor would do when faced with disruption, he expresses he will participate in them, even if they are disruptive. This is further evidence in support of him being a specially disturbing case of

4752:

Urthogie is the second busiest voter, but it appears he never weighed in with a vote on Allegations of Israeli apartheid, and he abstained from voting on Saudi Arabia and the US. CJCurrie voted several times to keep Allegations of Israeli apartheid but wanted to delete allegations of French,

3742:

ChrisO is sanctioned for his actions, Jayjg's should come under the same scrutiny. FWIW, my personal opinion is that both actions were inappropriate and that the simplest way for Arbcom to take some heat out of the overall dispute would be to forbid future use of admin tools by all involved

6177:

Now that ChrisO dismisses AFD "vote" patterns as evidence for his accusations against me and others, he says that the deciding factor should be the motivations for the votes and other participation. This is presumably why he has included selected quotes, in the evidence he presents above.

3861:

In response the editors of the Israel-apartheid article are now accusing the editors who worked on articles about all the other countries of POV, when it is the editors of the Israel article who are most guilty of a warped unfair POV focus on one country to the exclusion of others.

7160:

Place argument and diffs which support your assertion; for example, your first assertion might be "So-and-so engages in edit warring", which should be the title of this section. Here you would show specific edits to specific articles which show So-and-so engaging in edit warring.

6090:

Your heading is completely misleading: all it proves is that these things happened in quick succession. However, statistics, when measuring behaviors and their consequences, have to be more rigorous than this: I can prove to you pretty much anything if underlying assumptions are

2236:

My reading of this situation was somewhat different. I don't recall that you made point (1) clear at any point in our discussion. (And, for the record, I was unaware of Kiyosaki's prejudical views when I accepted his barnstar. Once he made his views known, I removed it.)

753:"Article lists notable accusations regarding a significant phenomenon in Brazil, and the Allegations of apartheid article is currently deleted. More material undoubtedly exists, and could be added to flesh out the stub, but we don't delete stubs simply because they are stubs" 1462:"On a personal note, I wish people here would stop misusing the term "apartheid" for POV reasons - it cheapens and degrades the memory of that inquitous system." (which sounds to me like a call for using "apartheid" only in reference to the specific system in South Africa. 6610:, "Editors of articles concerning apartheid are directed to negotiate in good faith appropriate article names using relevant policies and guidelines. If negotiation is unsuccessful, interested parties are required to enter into good faith mediation regarding the matter." 3647:

where ChrisO was criticized. As Mantanmoreland put it, "Given that these "apartheid" articles are involved in interrelated debates, it was very wrong of ChrisO, an active participant, to close this deletion debate. This was an abuse of tools and should not be permitted."

6776:: the resulting disruption is obvious in the contentious deletion discussions, the fact that editors of French and Chinese articles have been drawn into this steel cage match, the attacks on neutral admins in deletion discussions, and the fact that we're here at ArbCom. 3865:

Currently, the ArbCom case has degenenerated to accusation and counter-accusation. This was inevitable, sicne ArbCom refuses to address cointent dispute, and only addresses user conduct, forcing even well-meaning, goodfaith editors to level accusations at each other.

3761:

Update: In response to Mackensen's question on the Workshop page, I could find any editor who clearly applied a double standard in the opposite direction. The closest I could find was Tarc, however it is not clear what aspect of Jayjg's actions he was referring to:

6868:

All I can say, Mackan79,is that you might want to hope that most people (unlike me) don't actually click on the references you provide, as they bear only passing resemblance to the charges. And to those who read this, I would encourage you to please do click them.

5858:

As it turns out, the editors who are accused of single-minded pro-Israeli activism have shown remarkable restraint in their participation in AFDs, while relative newcomers to the debate who are doing the accusing are those who have the highest editing intensity:

3851:

At this moment, a massive conflict is breaking out at the following page, in an arbitration proceeding, at Knowledge (XXG):Requests for arbitration/Allegations of apartheid/Workshop, a subpage of Knowledge (XXG):Requests_for_arbitration/Allegations_of_apartheid.

6211:

The accused editors have all offered different but sometimes related rationale for their views. But what we've all insisted (as far as I can tell) is that if the title is not inherently biased for one country, then it can not be inherently biased for another.

2932:

I should also point out that his tone is in general often combative and sneering on these issues, and there are many, many more instances of unpleasant comments (both general and specific) directed at those who disagree with him, which I can list upon request.

950:"Allegations of Israel human rights violations do merit articles (though one can always wonder the paucity of such articles about other states and regimes who do much worse), but the term "apartheid" is a rhetorical device that distracts from the real issue." 7169:

Place argument and diffs which support the second assertion; for example, your second assertion might be "So-and-so makes personal attacks", which should be the title of this section. Here you would show specific edits where So-and-so made personal attacks.

3982:) was on August 4, 2007, as this arbitration was getting underway. That editor has not participated in the arbitration. There is no indication on the user's user or talk pages of why they are absent. This is highly unusual for that very active editor. -- 2287: 1092: 315: 4086:

I present evidence for this with some misgivings, as I think the evidence will always be circumstantial. But since others have opened the door to this kind of reasoning, there is a much stronger case that one group has voted as a block in order to protect

5887:

By the time the first article was written about allegations against another country than Israel was written, the AFDs about AoIA had run their course. AoIa 3 had closed in August of 2006, and a fourth attempt in April of 2007 gathered much less interest.

1350: 1107: 1031: 713: 618: 497: 421: 330: 1516:) has made incivil comments in relation to the allegations of apartheid articles and the users involved with them and has assumed bad faith, accusing editors with whom he is in disagreement of being motivated by anti-semitism and deletionism. On the 1525:

numerous charges of thinly-veiled antisemitism that have been made in the various relevant discussions, not only against ChrisO, but against a significant number of other editors, including a merry gang of uncharacteristically deletionist admins.

3656:

I note the obvious bias that many (though certainly not all) of them have expressed in these areas themselves, and point out that an interest in a topical area is not a conflict of interest in that area. Jayjg (talk) 21:41, 26 April 2007 (UTC)"

2841:

The first of Picaroon's diffs refers to a point I have made many times, which is that AoIa is similar to "filthy Jew" in that is an epithet meant to smear a specific ethnicity. Nowhere do I suggest or imply, as Picaroon erroneously claims, that

1432:

It seeks to poison the well by asserting at the outset that all subsequent editors are "Israel-focused" editors. If ChrisO thinks this is a relevant fact, he should be prepared to document and prove it. If he can't prove it, he should omit the

6272: 6150:

I agree. I am not trying to prove any causality at all; I'm merely pointing out that voting, or rather "opining" patterns on this issue prove nothing at all, yet this is what ChrisO is submitting as evidence in his very selective table above.

6243:

I would contend that it is difficult to apportion blame for the ruckus about these series of articles. My view is that it is far more questionable to want articles deleted because you are suspicious of the motives of the editors for creating

300:" principle invoked by Sefringle - which has no basis in policy - to tie the other articles' fate to that of AoIa. The following examples illustrate this pattern of behaviour and the block voting dynamic that has been apparent in these AfDs: 1920:

Ideogram offered an apology for his abusive language, which I accepted in good faith. But this behavior only shows what a problem these type of "allegation of XXX" articles are and how heated discussions can get. 16:34, 13 August 2007 (UTC)

101: 3713:

a consensus for deletion. While I respect ChrisO, I would have hoped that he would be more careful with his tools after the last two occurrences of using them in similar, questionable circumstances. TewfikTalk 22:24, 31 July 2007 (UTC)"

93:

cite the evidence and voice your objections within your own section of the page. It is especially important to not remove evidence presented by others. If something is put in the wrong place, please leave it for the Arbitrators to move.

4031:

There is no evidence that the acts of a few editors have disrupted Knowledge (XXG). This debate has surely disrupted Knowledge (XXG) (and the lives of those involved), but it would be unreasonable and practically impossible to allocate

2194:, Jayjg was "reminded that edit-warring is harmful to Knowledge (XXG)'s mission" and "advised to use Knowledge (XXG)'s dispute resolution procedure in preference to attempting to control content through the use of reverts.". (refer: 647:"With a caveat: perhaps there could/should be a discussion about deleting all articles that deal with the subject of Allegations of Apartheid against X, but what we may not do is cherry-pick among them; that creates an inherent POV." 723:"This article was conceived in bad faith, nurtured by POV-pushers and propagandists, and protected by apathy and ignorance. It is inherently POV and unencylopedic, yet people have insisted on keeping it on the flimsiest of pretexts" 86: 6198:

who are being accused of all-or-nothing. And yet, there is not a single proposal in any of the articles that looks like a quid pro quo. The closest we get is a hope that the centralized discussion will resolve the broader issue.

243:

for its sixth and most recent AfD and has participated in the AfDs on the French and Jordanian apartheid articles, voting to keep both. In discussing why the other "allegations of apartheid" articles had been created, he stated:

6271:'s curious pride in deleting things, but anyone who takes a look at his user page will see that it's an accurate assessment. I stand by my assertion that it was decided incorrectly, and I provided a complete analysis of it here: 1395: 1289: 985: 894: 773: 557: 451: 360: 6772:, has developed a series of other "Allegations of apartheid" articles and defended them with the express purpose of using them as a "bargaining chip" to compel deletion of the Israeli article. This is a canonical violation of 69:

As such, it is extremely important that you use the prescribed format. Submitted evidence should include a link to the actual page diff, or to a short page section; links to the page itself are not sufficient. Never link to a

6719:"There is a systemic issue here; there are a series of "Allegations of apartheid in country X" articles... The oldest, and by far the largest, is Allegations of Israeli apartheid. It would make sense to crack that nut first. 1319: 1061: 803: 682: 587: 390: 6239:

The closest we get to an admission is that some editors believe that WP's NPOV is strengthened if allegations of apartheid aren't limited to Israel. This is of course a valid point and I dare say a main driver for many new

6247:

It is indeed a novel idea that the act of creating well-sourced articled about a specific phenomenon (that countries are accused in the media and by pundits of allegations of certain crimes) should be considered an act of

3766:

Tarc on Jajyg's deletion: Endorse Keep, as it was a notable subject matter with sources to verify it. I also sincerely hope that there is an investigation into Jayjg's actions regarding this AfD. Tarc 13:37, 26 April 2007

3735:

I cannot understand how anyone can apply the same code of conduct to both administrators and arrive at this set of conclusions. That this has happened is an indication of the unhealthy level of partisanship that we have.

1997:, without going through AfD and while he was actively involved in the dispute about apartheid articles. With that deletion he also deleted the article history. He later restored the article on August 12 after a short DRV. 6190:"The status of articles on other similar topics has no bearing on a particular article. The process may have been applied inappropriately, people may not have seen the other articles yet, or consensus may have changed." 97: 2949:

MastCell has distorted my involvement in these articles, and my reasoning. I didn’t think, when I was !voting, that my stance was so subtle that I needed to re-explain it, though I now see it is clear that I should.

2878:. "A few editors below -- IronDuke, Avi, JoshuaZ -- make calm and reasonable arguments for reconsideration." These allegations are so manifestly false, I cannot begin to fathom what caused this editor to make them. 1380: 1259: 1213: 1152: 955: 864: 743: 637: 527: 6551: 6531: 6216:

only article that has sufficient content that it can be evaluated fully, and I also think it's trash; the others were so quickly bogged down with AFDs and other noise that the editors have made limited progress.

1934: 1365: 1198: 849: 512: 291:

3) A number of Israel-focused editors have been involved in many of the AfDs on "allegations of apartheid" articles. Notably, they have systematically voted to keep them while voting to delete the older article

6563: 6133:

This, of course, applies to the statistics provided by ChrisO. However, these statistics are accompanied by open admissions of the intent or intentional support for actions. That is much more solid evidence.--

2283: 1791: 1274: 1244: 1183: 1137: 1046: 1016: 970: 940: 879: 834: 758: 652: 542: 436: 345: 6586:

It should also be noted that those screaming the loudest for ChrisO to be desysopped for using his tools in an area where his neutrality is suspect are, coincidentally, largely the same editors who sprang to

1410: 1304: 1122: 909: 788: 667: 572: 466: 375: 6864:, in which he combines the incivility, attempt to enlist editors, acknowledgment that he opposes the entire set of articles, and states that editors "seem to be coming around to a more reasonable approach." 3873:

If you wish, you may also demand that ArbCom or some other body address content disputes, so that this cycle of accusation and counter-accusation will not remaion the only real means of addressing disputes.

1711:

296:(AoIa). They have often based their opposition to AoIa on general principles which they have then set aside for the other articles. The rationales have invariably been non-policy-based, usually citing the " 2855:. I suggested that while it was possible that some supporters of the article had an axe to grind with regards to Israel, that did not nullify their concerns. There isn't even a whisper of incivility there. 2350:

says "You clearly don't understand why we created other apartheid articles. All allegations of apartheid articles are meant to antagonize people of that culture; the Israel one included. They are all POV

4767:

At least 353 distinct editors have voted or commented on the apartheid articles. I count in excess of 1280 different edits in these pages.The 20 most active editors are responsible for 39% of the edits.

2286:(the 3rd AFD on the article; first at the new title), was closed early in part due to a finding of an out of process nomination. Similar accusations were made in the 3rd AFD about the second and in the 1827: 3815:, whose evident focus is Latin American topics, has expressed the opinion that tactics used by Middle East-focused editors has been disruptive to the development of quality articles about Latin America. 7084: 2068:", arguing "that is all the term really means in this context". His proposed course of action was not taken, although the "Apartheid outside of South Africa" article was subsequently redirected to 21: 2413: 662:"As I have !voted before, keep all or delete all articles on this subject. This article has plenty of sources and, per Gzuckier, we could meet some objections by renaming it to Chinese Apartheid." 3689:

Humus Sapiens on Jayjg's deletion: "Changing my vote to Delete. Since WP is turning into a battleground, I'd rather be counted as a "usual suspect". ←Humus sapiens ну? 21:15, 26 April 2007 (UTC)"

1439:, he conceded that it will be difficult to relate articles to each other without clear definitions, yet here he is making an explicit connection among articles on the basis of selective evidence. 6081:

Actually, the table shows that following the speedy keep in AfD 6 of AoIA, a string of articles and accompanying deletions happened within less than two months. They are all bunched up visually.

2765:(#1) to the last version by himself. (Question: how can something be "without consensus" in a problematic way prior to the creation of a talk page? BRD anyone? This undid two user's changes.] 385:"in order to maintain consistency with other articles, pending a "global" resolution of the issue of "apartheid" articles, as discussed in the Arbitration Committee decision almost a year ago." 3637:

where Jayjg was criticized by some for what was, as Cyde put it, "taking controversial actions in a subject matter he knows he doesn't have even the remote appearance of being unbiased in."

7088: 6101:

forcing their use appeared. And it also ignores the fact that in proportion, fatalities in traffic accidents have dropped dramatically from the time before laws forcing their use appeared.

980:"I have many reservations about including specific instances of political rhetoric as articles, but if the consensus is that these are notable topics, then this article should be included" 6264:

I will stipulate that I erred in thinking the AFD was closed early. I have made apologies to the closing admin(s) and hope that the DRV can be reopened when this issue has been resolved.

2184:, Jayjg was admonished for 3RR violations, and prohibited from "remov any adequately referenced information from any article which relates to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict". (refer: 3497:

allegations. Mainly against the people who wanted the Israel apartheid article deleted, specifically bolding the participation of us, and claiming attempts to improve the articles are

2864:, but made it clear that 1) he more than likely wasn't aware that he'd thanked an antisemite for giving him a barnstar and 2) his arguments should be given a fair hearing. See here: 66:. Long, rambling, or stream-of-consciousness rants are not helpful. Over-long evidence (other than in exceptional cases) is likely to be refactored and trimmed to size by the Clerks. 6607: 844:"we do not need articles based on an allegation or based on a viewpoint. Issues related to Israeli internal policy, society, culture, etc, can be explored in the related articles." 2991:

Ideogram has engaged in a long term pattern of disruption involving multiple, abusive sockpuppets. He has admitted operating a number of socks, and several more are suspected.

4015:

Those bringing the accusations here wish to somehow punish editors who have created fully sourced articles with similar titles to an article they previously had wanted deleted.

1254:"any legitimate concerns about human rights violations should be dealt with in the neutral article on the subject, without all of the problems inherent in a title like this one" 6703:

Keep - there is a precedent for keeping "allegations of apartheid" articles. If someone created an AFD for all of these articles, that would have a strong chance of succeeding.

3404:

Note: 02:36, 19 April 2007 Blnguyen (Talk | contribs) blocked "Ideogram (contribs)" (anon. only, account creation blocked) with an expiry time of 48 hours (disrupting arbcom)

2269: 2265: 2261: 2226:, but made it clear that 1) he more than likely wasn't aware that he'd thanked an antisemite for giving him a barnstar and 2) his arguments should be given a fair hearing. 6389: 1284:"Whatever problems editors say exists with the titling is the same one that exists throughout the "series" and should be dealt with comprehensively, and not piecemeal." 340:"If I had to boil it down to one sentence, the problem is that the article is inherently POV and its purpose is to have an attack on Israel in the title of an article." 100:. /Workshop provides for comment by parties and others as well as Arbitrators. After arriving at proposed principles, findings of fact or remedies, Arbitrators vote at 277:

should also be read in its entirety, as it specifically places this dispute in the context of "the zionists and supporters of Israel" battling "the anti-zionists". --

4057:

Those who wanted AoIa deleted but subsequent "allegations of" articles kept, are on solid ground in accepting the decision from one case and applying it to the other

4060:

Conversely, those who wanted AoIa kept but subsequent "allegations of" articles deleted, must morally and intellectually answer what separates one case from another

120:

1) The development of the "allegations" articles has been dominated by a small number of editors, a significant number of whom are actively involved in editing

5862: 2376: 728: 1442:

After having worked constructively on various aoia articles, ChrisO's tone abruptly changed when an article was created about allegations of French apartheid

3597:

And later he/she indirectly called me an enemy editor, saying I shouldn't edit wikipedia, and that none of my contributions to wikipedia have been helpful.

2997: 6623: 1006: 400:"I don't think any of these "apartheid" articles for individual countries should exist, but one country should not be singled out. Let's have consistency." 6907: 6312: 6194:

The examples raised in the section oppose the view that articles that bear a resemblance to other deleted articles should be deleted. In this case, it is

3729:

isn't necessarily the place for it, but a desysopping and/or topic ban for ChrisO is well past due. Enough is enough. IronDuke 16:30, 31 July 2007 (UTC)"

6879:

of the worst of the POV-pushers who defended the inflammatory titles and articles in the past seem to be coming around to a more reasonable approach...."

3858:

In response, a group of more even-handed editors attempted to build a set of article detailing and highlighting alleged "apartheid" in other countries.

6951:

He later "explains" he isn't doing it because it would be "disruption". So he is clearly acknowledging that he knows that multiple AfDs are disruptive.

6583:

admin who closed the AfD in a manner not to their liking. This does not absolve ChrisO of closing the AfD improperly, but does provide useful context.

59:

Anyone, whether directly involved or not, may add evidence to this page. Please make a header for your evidence and sign your comments with your name.

6852:

Substantive editing issues included edits obscuring original synthesis by combining entirely unrelated claims as if they are responding to each other

78:, as those will probably have changed by the time people click on your links to view them. Please make sure any page section links are permanent. See 3682:

6SJ7 on ChrisO's deletion: "This was a clear abuse of administrative powers. Overturning the deletion should be only the first of the repercussions."

281: 6416: 6278:

I think honest people can have disagreements on these issues, but there is nothing that I wrote that would constitute an assumption of bad faith. --

3338: 3180: 1968: 692:"As I have !voted before, keep all or delete all articles on this subject. However, of all the articles, this one is easily one of the strongest." 196: 4066:

But it is those who insist on consistency who are being accused of acting in bad faith, and of conspiracies, and of applying double standards. --

4043:

There has never been any offer of a quid pro quo along the lines of "if you agree to delete article A, I'll agree to delete articles B, C, and D"

3798:

article without including criticisms of the allegations. Never has this article given a single sentence to the point of view that Australia does

628:"I think it's time for all the apartheid pseudo-articles to go. The usable material here can be merged into relevant articles like, for example, 79: 6497:). I've been reluctant to complain when he was doing it to me for fear of ruining what I hoped would be a constructive engagement with others. 3925: 2176:

has been admonished by the Arbitration Committee on three occasions for his behaviour on articles relating to the Israel/Palestinian conflict.

1617: 215: 3129: 3025: 1913: 2871:

I actually pride myself on remaining civil to editors with whom I disagree on this issue. I'd point, as evidence of this, to the remarks of

17: 6592: 3631: 3235: 3073: 2801: 3794:

On March 29, around the same time that Urthogie expressed the above opinion about how NPOV should be interpreted for AoIA, he created the

4102:

The previous analysis was incomplete and selective. Among the most active voters (and I included myself for purposes of full disclosure)

2438:

of 7 January 2005. The current wording, minus the initial "Also, " was there when "not a theatre of war" became "not a battleground" on

7140: 7062: 7049: 7040:

such topics. For these reasons, I would advise against interpreting Sm8900's contact of me, if not others, as an instance of canvassing.

6975: 6965: 6927: 6886: 6873: 6516: 6463: 6379: 6375: 6356: 6282: 6155: 6137: 6073: 4070: 3986: 3897: 3756: 3612: 3574: 3537: 3472: 3455: 2964: 2939: 2884: 2808: 2727: 2644: 2582: 2476: 2458: 2326: 2241: 2162: 2134: 2115:, he added copious amounts of information to "Apartheid outside of South Africa", and sought to merge "Israeli apartheid" on his own. 1807: 1780: 1763: 1547: 1491: 5891:

As a matter of fact, it wasn't until the AFD on China was created that the interest even approached the first AFD on an article titled

2860:

The third diff is also, if I say so myself, entirely polite. I did point out that CJCurrie had supported an antisemitic sock puppeteer

2385:

an involved admin who had closed the Chinese AFD despite being involved in the topic to reverse themselves so an uninvolved admin could

2343:

says "Those articles are only necessary because of the existence of this one . It was important to maintain some semblance of balance."

2222:

The third diff is also, if I say so myself, entirely polite. I did point out that CJCurrie had supported an antisemitic sock puppeteer

2130:

article. I also believe Jayjg's repeated "keep" votes on other "Allegations ..." articles can only be interpreted in the same light.

1299:"any problems with the titling etc. should be dealt with comprehensively among the entire series, and not piecemeal on just one or two" 597:"Of the whole unfortunate "Allegations of apartheid" series, why remove the one where "the apartheid is starkest"? Consistency please." 267:

The closest thing we can do to make it neutral is allow the allegations against every country. This is the only way to balance it out."

6342: 2640:

by Y. Elapsed time, 4 hours on 30 July, commencing roughly 1 hour before the N. Ireland move war and ending roughly 0.5 hours later.

148: 6558:

Mitigating in ChrisO's favor, he requested an outside admin to close the next Allegations AfD. A truly neutral and uninvolved admin,

3552:

I presume I've been included in Sefringle's shitlist of "Israel-hating editors". My Jewish ancestors must be turning in their graves.

3594:

Second, he/she has called me a troll in the afd discussion for expressing the opinion that the afd will unlikely be speedily closed

3332: 3290: 3174: 2154:. His subsequent votes for the retention of other "Allegations ..." articles are, again, difficult for me to interpret except as 3555: 355:"per what I said a few minutes ago on the AfD about Saudi Arabia, and per the comments here by Mantanmoreland, Urthogie and Jayjg" 7096: 6769: 6658: 4088: 1819: 293: 240: 157: 121: 6655:"Once Knowledge (XXG) is ablaze, putting out an individual flame here and there won't work. The whole fire needs to be put out." 4049:

Insisting on consistency across articles is not unreasonable. This is why we have policies and guidelines: to ensure consistency

1360:"There are allegations of Knowledge (XXG) being an encyclopedia -- judging by this breed of articles, they're clearly unfounded" 6749: 6722: 6706: 6690: 6674: 6643:

Multiple editors have explicitly used the Allegations series as a "bargaining chip" to push for deletion of the Israeli article

3752: 2772:

the spelling mistake and fixes the typo in the redirect at Segregation, which also locks against a further move to Segregation.

2669: 2595: 1459:

in French politics or the media who uses the comparison." (in stark contradiction to his opposition to OR and other POV views).

255: 167: 4759:

If anything those who want to keep allegations of Israeli apartheid are more principled in wanting to delete everything else.

3123: 3019: 1736: 1513: 431:"Zleitzen is correct in challenging the notion that just because something is sourced, it meets policy - WP is not a soapbox" 2122:

by merged in highly pruned form with a list page. I believe the only reasonable explanation is that Jayjg was engaged in a

6836:) despite his votes and arguments to keep. This was followed by a continuing refusal to discuss with anyone who mentioned 1990: 1550:) has made incivil comments in relation to the allegations of apartheid articles and the users involved with them. As with 205: 7131: 4003: 3424: 3229: 3067: 3795: 2379:

close noted "a bipartisan consensus that the AfD closer was not the best-positioned person to have taken this decision."

138: 6547: 6486: 6412: 4037:

If Knowledge (XXG) chose to discipline editors based on supposed state of mind, we would be entering dangerous territory

2085: 186: 3641: 2119: 2104: 2061: 2045: 128: 6768:

The evidence presented here and by others clearly shows that a group of editors, unhappy with the outcome of AfD's on

3979: 3961: 3943: 3808:

Tactics used in the dispute have been disruptive to editors and articles which have nothing to do with the Middle East

176: 6779:

Furthermore, the prior Israeli Apartheid Arbitration case explicitly enjoined editors to negotiate their differences

3397:) was used for block evasion numerous times on April 19-20, 2007. The block was placed for disruption of Arbcom. See 7009: 6331: 3394: 3284: 2661: 2629: 2108: 1455:"the creators of this article plainly know little and understand less about French social issues. I can't think of 7099:". AoIA had up to then played absolutely no role in the discussion, and its mention by Humus can only be taken as 2272:(all June 2006) the nominated article was described by the nominator and others as part of a POV series to make a 1329:"Whatever problem one may have with the titling should be resolved comprehensively, and not dealt with piecemeal." 75: 6687:"You might find that the whole series would be deleted if they whole series was nominated in a group nomination." 3651:

Several editors defended Jayjg's decision to use his tools while criticizing ChrisO's decision as inappropriate:

3356: 3198: 2603: 1776:

Threaded dialog removed, response may be made in your own evidence section, the talk page, or the workshop page.

6345:

be renamed "Social apartheid in Brazil". This after I made an effort to involve editors from Wikiproject Brazil.

6167: 3507: 2065: 552:"The same pro/con arguments should be applied across all "Allegations of apartheid" series. Consistency please." 297: 71: 6513: 6460: 6386: 1994: 1147:"considering the existance of Allegations of Israeli apartheid or delete all allegations of apartheid articles" 3465:

Ideogram has been banned from editing Knowledge (XXG) for a period of no less than one year by the community.

2776: 2503:"Social" into the main allegations article, kicking off a war in which 3 editors came one edit from violating 2049: 6945:

Sefringle once again, promises to disrupt Knowledge (XXG) to make a point via misuse of the deletion process

3344: 3186: 1541: 199:- 39% of edits by ChrisO, 19% by Urthogie, 8% by Cordless Larry, 8% by Victor falk, 6.5% by Cerejota, 3% by 3326: 3168: 3510:(which is neither a policy or guideline, but rather an essay), despite the fact that our view is based on 3147: 3043: 1971:

while involved in a move/edit war with Urthogie on that article. He unprotects "for now" when challenged.

1743:

comments in relation to the allegations of apartheid articles and the users involved with them. Examples:

1420:"per Jossi." ("Keep together with all other "Allegations of XXXX apartheid", or better, delete them all.") 1405:"nom is frivolous, again. Knowledge (XXG):Centralized_discussion/Apartheid is the place to deal with this" 222:, 19% by Bless sins, 10% by Lothar of the Hill People, 9% by Victor falk, 8% by Bigglove, 4.5% by Urthogie 1637:

Please notice that this vote on the French article is copied from the one on the Saudi Arabian article :

1314:"per Jossi" ("keep together with all other "Allegations of XXXX apartheid", or better, delete them all.") 3253: 3091: 2371:

ChrisO learned from the American Apartheid Allegations DRV to not close AFDs for articles in this series

2181: 1777: 6500:

He has today barged into another person's Talk and quite deliberately, high-handedly and unnecessarily

3635: 1740: 6541: 6382:

to both his tabulated results and to his conclusions. He admits (comments on another part of this page

3645: 3135: 3031: 2977:

I present evidence that Ideogram is a long term disruptive editor. This evidence was compiled for a

1745:

suggesting antisemitism (via "filthy Jew" reference) on the part of people he is in disagreement with

7054:

Since the aforementioned subsection has been withdrawn, the previous paragraph is now moot. Thanks.

6971:

Cerejota. He writes that "there likely will be an 8th ". He doesn't say he will start this. Cheers.

6938: 6615: 3601: 3563: 3526: 3479: 2927:

incomprehensible, trollish, and clutter, and also implies that greg has nothing useful to contribute

1943: 1828:

Knowledge (XXG):Requests_for_arbitration/Certified.Gangsta-Ideogram#Ideogram_placed_on_revert_parole

1082: 236: 6746:"Keep... if someone wanted to put all of these articles up for an AfD, I'd be willing to vote yes." 3748: 3241: 3079: 6432: 6421:"to disrupt the arbitration process by posting an inflammatory and highly partisan 'call to arms'" 1678: 1173: 7076: 6924: 6903: 6729: 6537: 6440: 3697:

and the vote at the AFD page warrant the deletion. ←Humus sapiens ну? 23:15, 30 July 2007 (UTC)"

3664: 3519: 3487: 3308: 3117: 3013: 2255:

Accusations have floated around the apartheid articles and their deletion discussions for a while

2077: 1986: 1964: 1930: 1804: 1760: 1730: 1606: 1562:(via "Dirty Jew"/"Dirty Gypsy" reference) on the part of people with whom he is in disagreement. 1537: 1507: 487: 278: 109: 7104: 6958: 6846: 6837: 6806: 6795: 6773: 6761: 6228: 6171: 5880: 3663:

Jayjg on ChrisO's deletion: "This was a terrible abuse of process on a couple of levels. First,

3580: 3502: 3498: 3494: 2277: 2273: 2155: 2123: 2013: 768:"Well sourced, well written, relevant information, presented in a neutral and encyclopedic tone" 629: 7095:

on 29 August that "I promise to concede, only on one condition: if you apply your own logic to

4063:

There are intellectually honest answers to this question, and these have been debated endlessly

7124: 5892: 3997: 3802:

practice apartheid. Urthogie removed a POV tag which had been placed on it by another editor:

3418: 3223: 3061: 2616: 2395:

for an admin not involved in the relevant wiki-projects to close the Chinese allegations AFD.

2201: 2127: 7100: 6116: 3855:

A group of editors has been developing an article entitled Alegations of Israeli apartheid."

3786: 3779: 3511: 3265: 3210: 1193:"it has no basis here, it is just pushing propaganda, and does not show an accurate history." 446:"Properly sourced, notable, and entirely consistent with the other articles in the "series"." 6815:

Specific actions then include repeatedly trying to enlist outside editors for deleting AoIa,

6480: 6406: 3321: 3296: 3163: 2488: 1375:"Provided the allegations series is encyclopaedic, and most think so, this article is, too." 1041:"This article is one of the best examples of an article which should not have been created." 476:"The article is properly sourced, and is perfect alignment with the other similar articles." 170:- 39.5% by Jayjg, 16.5% by Cerejota, 12% by NicDumZ, 7% by Lothar of the Hill People, 4% by 6579:). This suggests that those who argued for these articles to be kept would have gone after 2978: 2504: 2409: 7092: 7032: 6456: 6335: 3973: 3955: 3937: 3675:

is not going to be fixed on an article-by-article basis. 6SJ7 23:19, 26 April 2007 (UTC)"

1769: 1093:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Israeli apartheid (Fourth nomination)

316:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Israeli apartheid (Fourth nomination)

6882:) If you can dispute any of the points, I would encourage you to do so on the workshop. 4040:

The expressed reasons by those accused are construed in ways that inherently violate AGF

2392: 1517: 1351:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Israeli apartheid (fifth nomination)

1108:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Israeli apartheid (fifth nomination)

1032:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Israeli apartheid (fifth nomination)

714:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Israeli apartheid (fifth nomination)

619:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Israeli apartheid (fifth nomination)

582:"all Allegations of X apartheid or Delete them all. Per NPOV, no preferential treatment." 498:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Israeli apartheid (fifth nomination)

422:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Israeli apartheid (fifth nomination)

331:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Israeli apartheid (fifth nomination)

45:

to the issues. If you disagree with some evidence you see here, please cite the evidence

6822:

demanding "systemic" solutions from editors not familiar with Israel/Palestine articles

6338:

and me as an "almost-meatpuppets guided by concerns that have nothing to do with Brazil"

4028:

At no point has any editor expressed any wish to make a point by creating these articles

370:"per Tewfik, tickle me and others; and my comments on the last few AfD's in this series" 3825: 3744: 3619: 3469: 3452: 3388: 3278: 2971: 2145: 1340: 4756:

In other words, every single editor and every single article has different patterns.

3626:

Contributors apply a double standard regarding AfD closures by involved administrators

3437:. In the middle of this edit war Galindo left a 3RR warning for the opposing editor 2036:

changed the title of this section to "Allegations of Apartheid in other nations". On

7016: 6972: 6962: 6915: 6896: 6883: 6788: 6740: 6697: 6681: 6632: 6602:

The previous Apartheid Arbitration case mandated that editors negotiate in good faith

6523: 6353: 6327: 6134: 3894: 3812: 3584: 3544: 3112: 3008: 2959: 2934: 2879: 2861: 2238: 2223: 2159: 2131: 1801: 1757: 1726: 1661: 1631: 1551: 1503: 919:"together with all other "Allegations of XXXX apartheid", or better, delete them all" 608: 6637:"I created several allegations articles so that Knowledge (XXG) could be more NPOV." 6618:) indicated that the Allegations series was created to "balance" the Israeli article 6273:

Knowledge (XXG):Deletion review/Allegations of Chinese apartheid/Analysis by Leifern

567:"and speedy keep all future frivolous AFD from this nominator bent on disrupting WP" 7113: 7069: 7059: 7046: 6911: 6870: 6559: 6444: 6367: 6279: 6268: 6186:

In the relevant section on arguments, we can find this illuminating introduction:

6152: 6070: 4067: 3993: 3778:

Urthogie has created at least one article which violates his own interpretation of

3414: 3218: 3056: 2895:

ChrisO has been interested most recently in taunting 6SJ7, who he characterizes as

2805: 2724: 2641: 2579: 2473: 2455: 2428: 2396: 2363: 2323: 2315: 2291: 1912:

Ideogram assumed bad faith throughout my research and editing of that article. See

1657:"I created several allegations articles so that Knowledge (XXG) could be more NPOV" 1567: 1488: 930: 49:

and provide counter-evidence, or an explanation of why the evidence is misleading.

6489:) appears to have a history of disruptive attacks on TalkPages. (eg meaninglessly 2118:

It is difficult for me to reconcile these actions with Jayjg's prior request that

2454:, I don't think there are smoking guns here and it isn't the focus of the case. 2334:

Pro-Israel editors have said that the other articles were created because of AoIa

7028: 6983: 6476: 6469: 6452: 6436: 6402: 6395: 6309: 6289: 4753:

American, and Chinese apartheid and proposed to merge Saudi Arabian apartheid.

3833: 2069: 1674: 1234: 522:"(2nd choice - as long as we keep other Allegations of apartheid in X articles)" 7151:

before using the last evidence template, please make a copy for the next person

3789:

requires due weight to be given to criticisms of Israeli apartheid allegations.

2945:

Contrary to MastCell’s assertion, I have used no “bargaining chips” of any kind

2875:

who closed the Chinese apartheid DRV. He had this to say regarding my conduct.

2578:. All actions/diffs are less than 4 hours from Jayjg's original redirection. 1937:

while being actively engaged in other "Allegations of XXX apartheid" articles.

6990: 6799: 6764:

as well as the previous Arbitration ruling that they negotatiate in good faith

6713: 6588: 6448: 3983: 3969: 3951: 3933: 2872: 2761:

to a misspelling with a summary of "Please stop moves without consensus", and

2191: 2173: 2033: 1642: 1590: 1396:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of tourist apartheid in Cuba

1290:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of tourist apartheid in Cuba

986:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of tourist apartheid in Cuba

895:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of tourist apartheid in Cuba

824: 774:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of tourist apartheid in Cuba

703: 558:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of tourist apartheid in Cuba

452:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of tourist apartheid in Cuba

411: 361:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of tourist apartheid in Cuba

6671:"Keep... pending a "global" resolution of the issue of "apartheid" articles." 6665: 6649: 3908:

Allegations of Saudi Apartheid was at first part of Allegations of apartheid

3518:, all or nothing arguments may actually be legitimate. These assumptions by 3384: 3273: 2092:). The material on Israel, which had recently been the subject of a bitter 2025: 1623: 1598: 1320:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Saudi Arabian apartheid

1269:"and expand this article. There seems to be very much material online alone" 1062:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Saudi Arabian apartheid

804:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Saudi Arabian apartheid

683:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Saudi Arabian apartheid

588:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Saudi Arabian apartheid

391:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Saudi Arabian apartheid

305: 6906:

who may have participated in some of the AfDs mentioned above. Isarig, and

6253:

Leifern did not violate AGF in the DRV for Allegations of Chinese Apartheid

6115: 4771:

Here is an overview of users with more than 10 edits, by type of activity.

5873:

No evidence that new "allegations of X apartheid were made to make a point

1888:

After being reminded of his 1RR parole, Ideogram desisted from reverting.

1862:

reverted by deletion of lead by Ideogram on Aug 5, 9:22 with edit summary

1390:"per Jayjg, else merge to Allegations of apartheid, if it gets undeleted." 6352:

I don't remember having any particular dispute with this editor before. —

3721:

their own. "Usual suspects" indeed. IronDuke 01:18, 27 April 2007 (UTC)"

3630:

On April 25, 2007, Jayjg reversed another administrator's closure of the

3448:

Ideogram admits operating other socks that have not yet been identified.

2299:

Offline canvassing is known to have occurred for some of the related AFDs

1950:

Posting more than sixty messages in user's talk pages about related AfDs

62:

When placing evidence here, please be considerate of the Arbitrators and

6490: 4025:

At no point has any editor expressed any wish to disrupt Knowledge (XXG)

1381:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Brazilian apartheid

1260:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Brazilian apartheid

1214:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Brazilian apartheid

1153:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Jordanian apartheid

956:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Brazilian apartheid

865:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Brazilian apartheid

744:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Brazilian apartheid

638:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Brazilian apartheid

528:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Brazilian apartheid

7055: 7042: 6552:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of American apartheid

6532:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of American apartheid

6512:. This kind of thing makes serious work on articles much, much harder. 3705:

line", even if we think he was). TewfikTalk 05:13, 27 April 2007 (UTC)"

1935:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles_for_deletion/Allegations_of_American_apartheid

1790:

Sefringle made an incivil statement, in which he assumed bad faith, at

1366:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of American apartheid

1199:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of American apartheid

850:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of American apartheid

513:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of American apartheid

6914:

mentorship for a period of 6 months counting from August 29, 2007. --

6608:

Knowledge (XXG):Requests for arbitration/Israeli apartheid#Negotiation

6564:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Chinese apartheid

4018:

This is a spurious and transparent charge, for the following reasons:

3916:. Six subsequent edits were performed, upto and including the edit of 3514:, which is technically a policy. In some cases, like ones to maintain 2447:

Personal attacks have occurred in the DRVs and AFDs for these articles

2284:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Israeli apartheid

1792:

Knowledge (XXG) talk:Requests for arbitration/Allegations of apartheid

1275:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Chinese apartheid

1245:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Israeli apartheid

1184:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Israeli apartheid

1138:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Islamic apartheid

1047:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Chinese apartheid

1017:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Israeli apartheid

971:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Chinese apartheid

941:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Israeli apartheid

880:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Chinese apartheid

835:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Israeli apartheid

798:"Article is well written, encyclopedic, and uses high quality sources" 759:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Chinese apartheid

653:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Chinese apartheid

543:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Chinese apartheid

437:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Chinese apartheid

346:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of Chinese apartheid

3886:

IronDuke has made thinly veiled insinuations against opposing editors

1574:

All or nothing arguments to avoid any treatment on the French article

1472:

ChrisO writes, under the heading "Nobody is being fooled here," that:

1411:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of French apartheid

1305:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of French apartheid

1123:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of French apartheid

910:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of French apartheid

789:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of French apartheid

668:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of French apartheid

573:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of French apartheid

467:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of French apartheid

376:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Allegations of French apartheid

6566:. Despite being uninvolved, ^demon was subjected to a good deal of 6110:

To better illustrate how this fallacy works, in a humorous fashion:

2800:

The move/revert war stops at this point. Discussion occurs on the

2052:). Note that I am not alleging misconduct in any of these actions. 859:"as for all other articles with similar titles "Allegations of "," 5877:

It is worth showing a timeline of the AFDs related to this issue:

124:

or its talk page. (The names of the article creators are bolded.)

7015:

Then at 16:23 he starts editing it; as is described above under

6591:

defense when he unilaterally reversed a neutral admin's close of

3912:

The page "Allegations of Saudi Arabian apartheid" was created at

1925:

ChrisO closes a related AfD while actively engaged in the dispute

287:

Diametrically-opposed positions and non-policy-based block voting

7079:

has used AoIA as a bargaining chip in unrelated content disputes

6735:"Either Keep all Allegations of X apartheid or Delete them all." 3515: 151:- 48% of edits by Jayjg, 8% by Lothar of the Hill People, 6% by 29: 3493:

Above in the evidence, he accused numerous editors of making

1436:

In one of ChrisO's earliest contributions to this discussion

783:"A well referenced article about a broadly known phenomenon." 6812:

compared to his vote now on Allegations of French Apartheid.

4046:

Even if such an offer were made, it would never be sustained

4022:

The accusations are based on a supposition of state of mind

2483:

Four move/merge wars occurred simultaneously on 30 July 2007

1959:

ChrisO protects a page while actively engaged in an edit war

1560:

comments suggesting suggesting overt antisemitism and racism

6267:

I also could have saved myself the editorial comment about

3891:

insinuates that G-Dett believes Israel practices apartheid.

2442:, and remained essentially unchanged for the past 2+ years. 2318:(early on 14 August 2007) (Revised on review per IP editor 6628:"Those articles are only necessary because of this one..." 2404:

Relevant language has long standing in WP:NOT#BATTLEGROUND

7089:

Child suicide bombers in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict

7031:

canvassing a 3rd time"), regarding Sm8900's conduct with

3924:, the section "Saudi Arabia" was replaced with a link to 2750:

ChrisO then moves to Segregation in Northern Ireland and

1873:

I added sources to the lead as requested on Aug 5, 12:36

96:

Arbitrators may analyze evidence and other assertions at

40:

Please make a section for your evidence and add evidence

6829:, and arguing for the deletion of all related articles ( 6126:

Correlation does not equal causation. Never forget that.

1667:(He logged in and signed his comment 20 minutes later : 1346: 1240: 1179: 1088: 1012: 936: 830: 709: 614: 537:"if other Allegations of apartheid in X series are kept" 493: 417: 311: 85:

This page is not for general discussion - for that, see

7108: 7091:. After extensive and fruitless discussion, Humus told 7005: 6997:

This relates to the case made above by CJCurrie under:

6952: 6946: 6880: 6861: 6855: 6853: 6850: 6843: 6841: 6834: 6832: 6830: 6827: 6825: 6823: 6820: 6818: 6816: 6813: 6810: 6745: 6734: 6718: 6702: 6686: 6670: 6654: 6636: 6627: 6596: 6577: 6574: 6571: 6509: 6505: 6501: 6494: 6429: 6426: 6423: 6383: 6348: 6346: 6339: 6305: 6301: 6258: 3921: 3917: 3913: 3890: 3877:

Thank you. --Steve, Sm8900 03:01, 15 August 2007 (UTC)

3844: 3840: 3818: 3816: 3803: 3790: 3730: 3722: 3714: 3706: 3698: 3690: 3683: 3676: 3668: 3667:

has been a highly involved editor in these articles..."

3657: 3598: 3595: 3592: 3560: 3523: 3466: 3449: 3444:

Ideogram continues to operate other, unidentified socks

3438: 3435: 3432: 3430: 3428: 3401: 3398: 3373: 3362: 3350: 3314: 3302: 3269: 3259: 3247: 3214: 3204: 3192: 3159: 3153: 3141: 3097: 3085: 3049: 3037: 2982: 2926: 2919: 2918:

in his edit summary in this arbitration, and calls him

2915: 2908: 2904: 2900: 2896: 2876: 2865: 2853: 2794: 2787: 2780: 2769: 2762: 2758: 2751: 2744: 2740: 2720: 2716: 2712: 2708: 2704: 2700: 2696: 2692: 2688: 2684: 2680: 2676: 2665: 2657: 2637: 2633: 2625: 2621: 2611: 2607: 2599: 2572: 2568: 2560: 2556: 2552: 2544: 2536: 2532: 2528: 2524: 2520: 2516: 2512: 2508: 2500: 2496: 2469: 2439: 2435: 2424: 2420: 2388: 2382: 2359: 2355: 2347: 2340: 2319: 2305: 2206: 2195: 2185: 2152: 2149: 2141: 2112: 2100: 2093: 2089: 2081: 2073: 2057: 2041: 2037: 2029: 2021: 2001: 1975: 1954: 1951: 1906: 1902: 1898: 1880: 1874: 1866: 1857: 1846: 1840: 1834: 1795: 1752: 1748: 1744: 1695: 1691: 1687: 1668: 1665: 1649: 1646: 1638: 1635: 1627: 1610: 1602: 1594: 1559: 1526: 1470: 1443: 1437: 904:"f not, delete all similar articles, as per John above" 889:"all "allegations of XXX apartheid" or delete them all" 274: 269: 249: 3591:

said editors who reverted me should be "congradulated

2270:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Sexual apartheid

2266:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Gender apartheid

2262:

Knowledge (XXG):Articles for deletion/Global apartheid

2169:

Jayjg has been admonished by the Arbitration Committee

1879:...which was reverted a few minutes later by Ideogram 965:"if one set of allegations is notable, so should this" 7087:

I became involved in a content dispute with Humus at

6257:

The exact text of my initial submission can be found

2412:

says in part "Also, do not create or modify articles

2107:

page, with a request that the newly-created article

6595:, calling the closing admin's decision "nonsense" ( 6323:

Cerejota has been incivil and has assumed bad faith

3559:person with the "turning in their graves" comment. 3367:- may be properly identified, probably not abusive. 53:

edit within the evidence section of any other user.

7027:I am mentioned in an evidence subsection, above (" 6809:, first see Jayjg's vote in the last AfD for AoIa, 2464:Ideogram may not be here to create an encyclopedia 2358:admits to creating the articles to balance AoIa. ( 160:- 31.5% of edits by Jossi, 20% by Jayjg, 12.5% by 6993:has used admin tools while engaged in the dispute 2891:ChrisO has made personal attacks and been uncivil 2419:No recognizable form of this sentence was in the 2024:, an anonymous editor added a new section to the 995:"well-documented allegation. Dubious nomination." 6998: 4082:Bloc and unprincipled voting by group of editors 2783:(#1) the combined effect of Urthrogie and Jayjg. 2276:, and the deltion nomination was described as a 2028:page entitled "Apartheid in other nations". On 1786:Sefringle has been incivil and assumed bad faith 1684:Asking users to come to support his views here. 1026:"This article should have been deleted long ago" 729:Knowledge (XXG):Centralized discussion/Apartheid 104:. Only Arbitrators may edit /Proposed decision. 6493:and then broken the threading indentation with 6491:edited into the middle of what I'm saying twice 2998:Knowledge (XXG):Suspected sock puppets/Ideogram 2739:Created by Theo F on 22 July 2007, it was then 2668:. A 12 day break occurred, with discussion at 2434:An early version of the wording appears in the 2126:violation resulting from gamesmanship over the 1892:Ideogram has been uncivil and assumed bad faith 1498:TShilo12 has been incivil and assumed bad faith 1555: 6508:(easily readable and quite interesting) with 6366: 2144:, Jayjg endorsed the following comments from 2084:), and the material on Saudi Arabia added to 2064:"be merged (in highly pruned form) back into 1981:ChrisO deletes an article without AfD process 8: 3461:Ideogram is sitebanned for at least one year 2180:In an Arbcomm case involving User:Jayjg and 208:- 42% of edits by Cerejota, 35% of edits by 3550:In his statement on the talk page, he said 3372:All above have been confirmed by Ideogram. 2847:like that is somehow "uncivil" is just odd. 1056:"how many times do we have to go over this" 6857:, a pattern seen throughout the articles. 6225:eventually result in more NPOV articles. 4011:Accusations are unreasonable and unfounded 2754:. A minor change is made by another user. 2423:to discuss battlegrounds, nor when WP:NOT 1914:Talk:Allegations_of_Chinese_apartheid#Lead 1839:August 4 14:01, second revert by Ideogram 507:"Delete this non-encyclopedic WP:SOAPBOX." 6362:Evidence presented by PalestineRemembered 6208:dispute that Israel practices apartheid. 2852:The second diff is even more of a reach: 2830:uncivil remarks of his own to answer for. 2308:says that he was email canvassed to vote 1845:August 4 14:16, third revert by Ideogram 1749:accusing keep voters of being anti-Israel 5879: 5861: 3820:Zleitzen subsequently left the project. 3785:Urthogie has expressed the opinion that 2914:He refers to Sefringle’s statement as a 2096:, appears to have disappeared entirely. 1905:after being asked to do so by Nandesuka 1864:Remove lead not supported by any sources 1833:August 4 11:23, 1st revert by Ideogram, 18:Knowledge (XXG):Requests for arbitration 6415:) is named and threatened with a block 6296:Correction to Leifern's statement above 3964:) is no longer editing Knowledge (XXG). 3920:(the link is diff for all 6 edits). On 2779:the locked redirect at Segregation and 2076:. Some material was incorporated into 1969:Allegations of Northern Irish apartheid 1753:accusing CJCurrie of assuming bad faith 197:Allegations of Northern Irish apartheid 7146:Evidence presented by {your user name} 6845:while still accusing other editors of 6624:Moshe Constantine Hassan Al-Silverburg 4402:Moshe Constantine Hassan Al-Silverburg 3926:Allegations of Saudi Arabian apartheid 2341:Moshe Constantine Hassan Al-Silverburg 1696:Notice board for Israel-related topics 1618:Social situation in the French suburbs 1587:Discussing about moving the article : 1007:Moshe Constantine Hassan Al-Silverburg 216:Allegations of Saudi Arabian apartheid 6196:the editors that wanted articles kept 3839:The following was posted on both the 3379:Ideogram has engaged in block evasion 2925:He calls greg park avenue’s comments 2165:Modified 03:39, 18 August 2007 (UTC) 2137:Modified 03:39, 18 August 2007 (UTC) 1991:Allegations of Puerto Rican apartheid 206:Allegations of Puerto Rican apartheid 131:- 22% of edits by Mackan79, 19.5% by 7: 6755:all apartheid articles are deleted.) 6593:United States military aid to Israel 6220:No evidence of deliberate disruption 3640:On July 30, 2007, ChrisO closed the 3632:United States military aid to Israel 3409:Ideogram has engaged in edit warring 2723:. Discussion continued throughout. 2066:List of political epithets#Apartheid 1995:Allegations of apartheid#Puerto Rico 212:, 15% by Urthogie, 7% by Victor falk 3796:Allegations of Australian apartheid 2472:, which was not explained further. 1449:where one can find such quotes as: 1427:This evidence has several problems: 189:- 30% of edits by Cerejota, 25% by 139:Allegations of Australian apartheid 6343:Allegations of Brazilian apartheid 6231:explicitly prohibits editors from 3102:- bot account, properly identified 2987:Ideogram has operated sock puppets 2040:, the section was transfered to a 187:Allegations of Jordanian apartheid 149:Allegations of Brazilian apartheid 116:Narrow responsibility for articles 28: 4054:The positions are not equivalent 3642:Allegations of American apartheid 3554:The full statement can be viewed 2571:reverts, and then the article is 2120:Apartheid outside of South Africa 2105:Apartheid outside of South Africa 2062:Apartheid outside of South Africa 2046:Apartheid outside of South Africa 1897:Ideogram used abusive language, 183:, 7% by Sefringle, 9% by Mackan79 129:Allegations of American apartheid 7097:Allegations of Israeli apartheid 6770:Allegations of Israeli apartheid 6659:Allegations of Chinese apartheid 6380:what sound like valid objections 6370:'s evidence threatens to mislead 4089:Allegations of Israeli apartheid 2103:, User:Jayjg re-established the 1820:Allegations of Chinese apartheid 1768: 294:Allegations of Israeli apartheid 241:Allegations of Israeli apartheid 177:Allegations of Islamic apartheid 158:Allegations of Chinese apartheid 122:Allegations of Israeli apartheid 33: 7107:nature of his actions. ( Diff: 6750:Allegations of French apartheid 6723:Allegations of French apartheid 6707:Allegations of French apartheid 6691:Allegations of French apartheid 6675:Allegations of French apartheid 6378:on this issue and has received 6341:apparently for suggesting that 6295: 3845:board for Israel-related topics 2670:Talk:Social apartheid in Brazil 2606:by Lothar of the Hill People. 2596:Allegations of French apartheid 2200:In a prior ArbComm case on the 256:Allegations of French apartheid 168:Allegations of French apartheid 7103:and tacitly acknowledging the 7063:02:43, 11 September 2007 (UTC) 7050:18:49, 10 September 2007 (UTC) 7010:Apartheid outside South Africa 6941:continues to exhort disruption 6933:Evidence presented by Cerejota 6332:User:Lothar of the Hill People 6318:Evidence presented by Ashley Y 4763:Activity dominated by accusers 3881:Evidence presented by Ideogram 3434:along side Ideogram up to 4RR 2907:, asserts that 6S7J should be 2815:Evidence presented by IronDuke 2007:Evidence presented by CJCurrie 1717:Evidence presented by Picaroon 1532:Humus sapiens has been incivil 813:"Well sourced, notable issue." 325:"the article should not exist" 1: 6976:13:28, 4 September 2007 (UTC) 6966:03:59, 4 September 2007 (UTC) 6928:04:25, 1 September 2007 (UTC) 6517:18:00, 5 September 2007 (UTC) 6464:20:40, 4 September 2007 (UTC) 3644:AfD. The closure went to DRV, 3634:AfD. The closure went to DRV, 3613:04:44, 4 September 2007 (UTC) 2820:IronDuke has not been uncivil 2459:03:42, 1 September 2007 (UTC) 2250:Evidence presented by GRBerry 2190:In an ArbComm case involving 1616:When trying to merge it into 254:Similarly, in voting to keep 7141:16:01, 12 October 2007 (UTC) 6908:after a consensus at the CSN 6902:This is a notice concerning 6860:See particularly Jay's edit 6760:These editors have violated 5913: 5908: 5903: 4841: 4836: 4831: 4826: 4821: 4816: 4811: 4806: 4801: 4796: 4791: 4786: 4781: 4776: 4162: 4157: 4152: 4147: 4142: 4137: 4132: 4127: 4122: 4117: 4112: 4107: 2086:Human rights in Saudi Arabia 1818:Edit-warring by Ideogram on 7165:{Write your assertion here} 7156:{Write your assertion here} 6999:Jayjg has violated WP:POINT 6887:13:40, 23 August 2007 (UTC) 6874:03:30, 23 August 2007 (UTC) 6614:Multiple editors (not just 6435:again, this time messaging 6390:13:47, 17 August 2007 (UTC) 6376:analysis of voting patterns 6357:02:18, 17 August 2007 (UTC) 6313:15:56, 17 August 2007 (UTC) 6283:00:31, 16 August 2007 (UTC) 6156:19:28, 19 August 2007 (UTC) 6138:03:51, 18 August 2007 (UTC) 6074:00:17, 16 August 2007 (UTC) 4749:Brazil, Cuba, and Israel. 4071:02:53, 16 August 2007 (UTC) 3987:20:52, 15 August 2007 (UTC) 3903:Evidence presented by Jakew 3898:13:23, 15 August 2007 (UTC) 3757:06:39, 15 August 2007 (UTC) 3575:22:55, 14 August 2007 (UTC) 3538:22:55, 14 August 2007 (UTC) 3473:15:13, 15 August 2007 (UTC) 3456:20:06, 14 August 2007 (UTC) 2965:03:19, 21 August 2007 (UTC) 2940:13:15, 15 August 2007 (UTC) 2885:22:23, 13 August 2007 (UTC) 2809:04:06, 16 August 2007 (UTC) 2728:16:56, 21 August 2007 (UTC) 2645:15:59, 21 August 2007 (UTC) 2583:20:58, 15 August 2007 (UTC) 2477:19:57, 15 August 2007 (UTC) 2327:20:59, 14 August 2007 (UTC) 2242:23:14, 13 August 2007 (UTC) 2163:05:06, 17 August 2007 (UTC) 2135:04:48, 17 August 2007 (UTC) 1901:(which he later refactored 1813:Evidence presented by Jossi 1808:05:28, 13 August 2007 (UTC) 1781:12:08, 14 August 2007 (UTC) 1764:05:11, 13 August 2007 (UTC) 1698:(exactly the same diffs): 1520:, he posted the following: 1518:administrators' noticeboard 1492:19:53, 19 August 2007 (UTC) 282:07:36, 13 August 2007 (UTC) 7187: 6233:disrupting Knowledge (XXG) 2662:Social apartheid in Brazil 2630:Social exclusion in France 2109:Israeli apartheid (phrase) 1688:WikiProject Jewish history 1556:#IronDuke has been incivil 1414: 1399: 1384: 1369: 1354: 1323: 1308: 1293: 1278: 1263: 1248: 1217: 1202: 1187: 1156: 1141: 1126: 1111: 1096: 1065: 1050: 1035: 1020: 989: 974: 959: 944: 913: 898: 883: 868: 853: 838: 807: 792: 777: 762: 747: 717: 686: 671: 656: 641: 622: 591: 576: 561: 546: 531: 516: 501: 470: 455: 440: 425: 394: 379: 364: 349: 334: 319: 230: 80:simple diff and link guide 6203:The question of principle 6182:Nothing to all-or-nothing 3543:Personal attacks made by 3486:Bad faith accusations by 3158:- confirmed by Ideogram. 2604:Urban apartheid in France 2557:Lothar of the Hill People 2431:(early on 14 August 2007) 2399:(early on 14 August 2007) 2366:(early on 14 August 2007) 2314:in the 3rd AFD for AoIa. 2294:(early on 14 August 2007) 2048:(subsequently renamed as 1856:August 4 17:19 - My edit 1722:IronDuke has been incivil 1583:, as ChrisO named them : 1419: 1409: 1404: 1394: 1389: 1379: 1374: 1364: 1359: 1349: 1328: 1318: 1313: 1303: 1298: 1288: 1283: 1273: 1268: 1258: 1253: 1243: 1212: 1197: 1192: 1182: 1161: 1151: 1146: 1136: 1131: 1121: 1116: 1106: 1101: 1091: 1070: 1060: 1055: 1045: 1040: 1030: 1025: 1015: 994: 984: 979: 969: 964: 954: 949: 939: 918: 908: 903: 893: 888: 878: 873: 863: 858: 848: 843: 833: 812: 802: 797: 787: 782: 772: 767: 757: 752: 742: 737: 727: 722: 712: 691: 681: 676: 666: 661: 651: 646: 636: 627: 617: 596: 586: 581: 571: 566: 556: 551: 541: 536: 526: 521: 511: 506: 496: 475: 465: 460: 450: 445: 435: 430: 420: 399: 389: 384: 374: 369: 359: 354: 344: 339: 329: 324: 314: 7023:Evidence presented by HG 6530:ChrisO erred by closing 6495:a third nonsense comment 6166:There is no evidence of 3501:. He also accuses me of 2905:“hysterical” and “funny” 2675:On 12-20 August, Lothar 2360:later signed and revised 2050:Allegations of Apartheid 22:Allegations of apartheid 7105:disruptive point-making 6455:to join him in editing 2929:(see second comment). 2565:4th time, 3rd reversion 2058:18:53, 24 November 2005 2022:00:34, 15 November 2004 1581:Israeli-focused editors 7068:Evidence presented by 6982:Evidence presented by 6910:, is now under my and 6895:Evidence presented by 6787:Evidence presented by 6562:, subsequently closed 6522:Evidence presented by 6510:the jumble he has left 6502:attacked the threading 6288:Evidence presented by 6122: 5884: 5866: 3992:Evidence presented by 3932:Evidence presented by 3824:Evidence presented by 3618:Evidence presented by 3478:Evidence presented by 2970:Evidence presented by 2452:Removed on 1 September 2414:just to prove a point. 2220:IronDuke has written: 2074:20:32, 8 February 2006 2060:, Jayjg proposed that 1946:during AfD proceedings 1714: 1566:Evidence presented by 275:statement in this RFAr 231:Sefringle's statements 108:Evidence presented by 6121: 5883: 5865: 3922:21:48, April 11, 2007 3918:00:08, April 10, 2007 2911:(see edit summary), 2836:clause, I will reply. 2416:" (link in original). 2030:01:32 of the same day 1993:which was redirected 1700: 1469:Then, later that day 6398:has campaigned again 6374:Leifern has done an 6300:Exchange leading to 6118:File:FSM Pirates.jpg 3914:19:52, April 6, 2007 3427:) was edit warring 3413:Admitted sockpuppet 3383:Admitted sockpuppet 2213:Response to IronDuke 2111:be merged into it. 1558:below), he has made 218:- 22.5% of edits by 6849:violations himself. 6514:PalestineRemembered 6461:PalestineRemembered 6387:PalestineRemembered 2672:(several sections). 2656:On 30 July, Lothar 2410:WP:NOT#BATTLEGROUND 2038:18:19, 10 July 2005 2012:Jayjg has violated 461:"yep is frivolous" 47:in your own section 7077:User:Humus sapiens 7006:16:20 5 June 2006 6235:to make a point. 6128: 6123: 5885: 5867: 2909:ashamed of himself 2354:On 12 August 2007 2182:User:HistoryBuffEr 2142:16:50, 30 May 2006 2113:Shortly thereafter 2101:16:23, 5 June 2006 2078:Racial segregation 1822:despite 1RR parole 1692:WikiProject Israel 1579:your edits") from 179:- 55% of edits by 141:- 47% of edits by 102:/Proposed decision 7101:gaming the system 6926: 6748:(Arguing to keep 6721:(Arguing to keep 6705:(Arguing to keep 6689:(Arguing to keep 6657:(Arguing to keep 6472:re-factoring Talk 6124: 6067: 6066: 5893:Israeli apartheid 5856: 5855: 4746: 4745: 3968:The last edit by 2795:reverts and moves 2781:reverts and moves 2743:by Cerejota, and 2617:Exclusion sociale 2339:On 24 April 2007 2202:Israeli apartheid 2128:Israeli apartheid 1424: 1423: 1333: 1332: 1227: 1226: 1223:(no reason given) 1208:(no reason given) 1166: 1165: 1075: 1074: 1071:"How many times?" 999: 998: 923: 922: 817: 816: 696: 695: 601: 600: 480: 479: 404: 403: 145:, 26% by Ashley Y 57: 56: 7178: 7135: 7128: 7120: 7117: 6923: 6920: 6919: 6119: 5901: 5900: 5711:Greg park avenue 4774: 4773: 4105: 4104: 3743:administrators. 3610: 3607: 3604: 3572: 3569: 3566: 3535: 3532: 3529: 3522:show bad faith. 3366: 3339:deleted contribs 3318: 3291:deleted contribs 3263: 3236:deleted contribs 3208: 3181:deleted contribs 3157: 3130:deleted contribs 3101: 3074:deleted contribs 3053: 3026:deleted contribs 2962: 2937: 2882: 2734:Northern Ireland 2489:Social apartheid 2427:in October 2004 2346:On 20 July 2007 2288:4th AFD for AoIa 2042:new article page 2020:Background: On 1942:ChrisO possible 1772: 1347: 1241: 1180: 1117:"Clear POV fork" 1089: 1013: 937: 831: 710: 615: 494: 418: 312: 193:, 15% by Bleh999 164:, 6% by Ideogram 37: 36: 30: 7186: 7185: 7181: 7180: 7179: 7177: 7176: 7175: 7167: 7158: 7148: 7133: 7126: 7118: 7115: 7093:User:Hornplease 7081: 7073: 7033:Battle of Jenin 7025: 7008:Jayjg restored 6995: 6987: 6943: 6935: 6917: 6916: 6900: 6803: 6792: 6766: 6645: 6620: 6604: 6535: 6527: 6474: 6457:Battle of Jenin 6431:. He has just 6419:for attempting 6400: 6372: 6364: 6336:User:Cuchullain 6325: 6320: 6298: 6293: 6255: 6222: 6205: 6184: 6175: 6168:WP:ALLORNOTHING 6117: 5875: 4765: 4100: 4098:Voting patterns 4091:from deletion. 4084: 4013: 4008: 3966: 3948: 3910: 3905: 3888: 3883: 3837: 3829: 3810: 3783: 3628: 3623: 3608: 3605: 3602: 3588: 3570: 3567: 3564: 3548: 3533: 3530: 3527: 3508:WP:ALLORNOTHING 3491: 3483: 3463: 3446: 3411: 3381: 3324: 3276: 3221: 3166: 3115: 3059: 3011: 2989: 2975: 2960: 2947: 2935: 2893: 2880: 2822: 2817: 2757:Urthrogie then 2736: 2653: 2651:Brazil, ongoing 2591: 2492: 2485: 2466: 2449: 2406: 2377:Deletion review 2373: 2336: 2301: 2290:about the 4th. 2257: 2252: 2215: 2171: 2094:content dispute 2017: 2009: 1983: 1961: 1948: 1927: 1894: 1824: 1815: 1788: 1724: 1719: 1682: 1659: 1576: 1571: 1534: 1500: 289: 233: 118: 113: 74:or an editor's 34: 26: 25: 24: 12: 11: 5: 7184: 7182: 7173: 7166: 7163: 7157: 7154: 7147: 7144: 7139: 7080: 7074: 7072: 7066: 7024: 7021: 6994: 6988: 6986: 6980: 6979: 6978: 6942: 6939:User:Sefringle 6936: 6934: 6931: 6899: 6893: 6892: 6891: 6890: 6889: 6802: 6793: 6791: 6785: 6765: 6758: 6757: 6756: 6737: 6726: 6710: 6698:Urthogie again 6694: 6678: 6662: 6644: 6641: 6640: 6639: 6630: 6619: 6612: 6603: 6600: 6534: 6528: 6526: 6520: 6473: 6467: 6399: 6393: 6371: 6365: 6363: 6360: 6324: 6321: 6319: 6316: 6297: 6294: 6292: 6286: 6254: 6251: 6250: 6249: 6245: 6241: 6221: 6218: 6204: 6201: 6192: 6191: 6183: 6180: 6174: 6164: 6163: 6162: 6161: 6160: 6159: 6158: 6143: 6142: 6141: 6140: 6114: 6113: 6112: 6111: 6105: 6104: 6103: 6102: 6095: 6094: 6093: 6092: 6085: 6084: 6083: 6082: 6065: 6064: 6061: 6060: 6057: 6054: 6050: 6049: 6046: 6043: 6039: 6038: 6035: 6032: 6028: 6027: 6024: 6021: 6017: 6016: 6013: 6010: 6006: 6005: 6002: 5999: 5995: 5994: 5991: 5988: 5984: 5983: 5980: 5977: 5973: 5972: 5969: 5966: 5962: 5961: 5958: 5955: 5951: 5950: 5947: 5944: 5940: 5939: 5936: 5933: 5929: 5928: 5925: 5922: 5918: 5917: 5912: 5907: 5898: 5874: 5871: 5869: 5854: 5853: 5850: 5849: 5846: 5843: 5841: 5839: 5837: 5835: 5833: 5831: 5829: 5826: 5823: 5821: 5819: 5815: 5814: 5811: 5808: 5806: 5804: 5802: 5800: 5798: 5796: 5794: 5791: 5788: 5786: 5784: 5780: 5779: 5776: 5773: 5771: 5769: 5767: 5765: 5763: 5761: 5758: 5756: 5753: 5751: 5749: 5745: 5744: 5741: 5738: 5736: 5734: 5732: 5730: 5728: 5725: 5722: 5719: 5716: 5714: 5712: 5708: 5707: 5704: 5701: 5699: 5697: 5695: 5693: 5691: 5689: 5686: 5683: 5680: 5678: 5676: 5672: 5671: 5668: 5665: 5663: 5661: 5659: 5656: 5654: 5652: 5649: 5647: 5644: 5642: 5640: 5636: 5635: 5632: 5629: 5627: 5625: 5623: 5621: 5619: 5617: 5614: 5612: 5609: 5607: 5605: 5601: 5600: 5597: 5594: 5592: 5590: 5588: 5586: 5584: 5582: 5579: 5576: 5573: 5571: 5569: 5565: 5564: 5561: 5558: 5556: 5554: 5552: 5550: 5548: 5546: 5543: 5540: 5537: 5535: 5533: 5529: 5528: 5525: 5522: 5520: 5518: 5516: 5514: 5512: 5510: 5508: 5506: 5503: 5501: 5499: 5495: 5494: 5491: 5488: 5486: 5484: 5482: 5480: 5478: 5476: 5473: 5471: 5468: 5466: 5464: 5460: 5459: 5456: 5453: 5451: 5449: 5447: 5445: 5443: 5441: 5438: 5435: 5432: 5430: 5428: 5424: 5423: 5420: 5417: 5415: 5413: 5410: 5408: 5406: 5404: 5402: 5399: 5396: 5394: 5392: 5388: 5387: 5384: 5381: 5379: 5377: 5375: 5373: 5371: 5369: 5366: 5363: 5360: 5358: 5356: 5352: 5351: 5348: 5345: 5343: 5341: 5339: 5337: 5335: 5333: 5330: 5327: 5324: 5322: 5320: 5316: 5315: 5312: 5309: 5307: 5305: 5303: 5301: 5299: 5297: 5294: 5291: 5288: 5286: 5284: 5280: 5279: 5276: 5273: 5271: 5269: 5267: 5265: 5263: 5261: 5258: 5255: 5252: 5250: 5248: 5244: 5243: 5240: 5237: 5235: 5233: 5231: 5229: 5227: 5224: 5221: 5218: 5215: 5213: 5211: 5207: 5206: 5203: 5200: 5198: 5196: 5194: 5192: 5190: 5187: 5184: 5181: 5178: 5176: 5174: 5170: 5169: 5166: 5163: 5161: 5159: 5157: 5155: 5153: 5151: 5149: 5147: 5144: 5142: 5140: 5136: 5135: 5132: 5129: 5127: 5125: 5123: 5121: 5119: 5116: 5113: 5110: 5107: 5105: 5103: 5099: 5098: 5095: 5092: 5090: 5088: 5086: 5084: 5082: 5080: 5077: 5074: 5071: 5069: 5067: 5063: 5062: 5059: 5056: 5054: 5052: 5050: 5048: 5046: 5044: 5042: 5039: 5036: 5034: 5032: 5028: 5027: 5024: 5021: 5019: 5017: 5015: 5013: 5011: 5008: 5006: 5004: 5001: 4999: 4997: 4993: 4992: 4989: 4986: 4984: 4982: 4980: 4978: 4976: 4973: 4970: 4967: 4964: 4962: 4960: 4956: 4955: 4952: 4949: 4947: 4945: 4943: 4941: 4939: 4936: 4933: 4930: 4927: 4925: 4923: 4919: 4918: 4915: 4912: 4910: 4908: 4906: 4904: 4902: 4899: 4896: 4893: 4890: 4888: 4886: 4882: 4881: 4878: 4875: 4873: 4871: 4869: 4867: 4865: 4863: 4860: 4857: 4854: 4852: 4850: 4846: 4845: 4840: 4835: 4830: 4825: 4820: 4815: 4810: 4805: 4800: 4795: 4790: 4785: 4780: 4764: 4761: 4744: 4743: 4740: 4739: 4736: 4734: 4732: 4730: 4728: 4726: 4724: 4722: 4719: 4717: 4714: 4710: 4709: 4707: 4705: 4703: 4701: 4699: 4697: 4694: 4692: 4689: 4687: 4684: 4680: 4679: 4677: 4675: 4672: 4670: 4667: 4665: 4663: 4661: 4658: 4656: 4653: 4649: 4648: 4645: 4642: 4640: 4638: 4635: 4633: 4631: 4629: 4626: 4624: 4621: 4617: 4616: 4613: 4611: 4609: 4606: 4603: 4601: 4598: 4596: 4594: 4592: 4590: 4586: 4585: 4582: 4580: 4578: 4576: 4574: 4572: 4570: 4568: 4565: 4562: 4560: 4556: 4555: 4552: 4550: 4547: 4545: 4542: 4540: 4538: 4536: 4533: 4531: 4528: 4524: 4523: 4521: 4518: 4515: 4513: 4510: 4508: 4506: 4504: 4502: 4500: 4497: 4493: 4492: 4489: 4487: 4484: 4481: 4478: 4475: 4473: 4471: 4469: 4467: 4465: 4461: 4460: 4458: 4456: 4453: 4451: 4448: 4445: 4442: 4440: 4438: 4436: 4434: 4430: 4429: 4427: 4424: 4421: 4419: 4417: 4415: 4413: 4411: 4408: 4406: 4403: 4399: 4398: 4395: 4393: 4390: 4387: 4384: 4382: 4379: 4376: 4374: 4372: 4370: 4366: 4365: 4362: 4359: 4357: 4355: 4352: 4350: 4348: 4346: 4343: 4341: 4338: 4334: 4333: 4330: 4327: 4324: 4322: 4319: 4317: 4315: 4313: 4310: 4308: 4305: 4301: 4300: 4297: 4294: 4291: 4289: 4286: 4284: 4281: 4279: 4276: 4274: 4271: 4267: 4266: 4263: 4260: 4257: 4254: 4251: 4249: 4246: 4244: 4241: 4239: 4236: 4232: 4231: 4229: 4227: 4224: 4221: 4218: 4215: 4213: 4210: 4208: 4206: 4204: 4200: 4199: 4196: 4193: 4191: 4188: 4185: 4182: 4179: 4177: 4175: 4173: 4171: 4167: 4166: 4161: 4156: 4151: 4146: 4141: 4136: 4131: 4126: 4121: 4116: 4111: 4099: 4096: 4083: 4080: 4078: 4076: 4075: 4074: 4073: 4064: 4061: 4058: 4052: 4051: 4050: 4047: 4044: 4038: 4035: 4034: 4033: 4029: 4026: 4012: 4009: 4007: 3990: 3965: 3949: 3947: 3930: 3909: 3906: 3904: 3901: 3887: 3884: 3882: 3879: 3850: 3836: 3832:Canvassing by 3830: 3828: 3822: 3809: 3806: 3782: 3776: 3775: 3774: 3769: 3768: 3733: 3732: 3725: 3724: 3717: 3716: 3709: 3708: 3701: 3700: 3693: 3692: 3686: 3685: 3679: 3678: 3671: 3670: 3660: 3659: 3627: 3624: 3622: 3616: 3587: 3583:violations by 3578: 3547: 3541: 3490: 3484: 3482: 3480:User:Sefringle 3476: 3462: 3459: 3445: 3442: 3410: 3407: 3380: 3377: 3369: 3368: 3319: 3271: 3216: 3161: 3109: 3108: 3104: 3103: 3054: 3005: 3004: 3001: 2988: 2985: 2974: 2968: 2946: 2943: 2892: 2889: 2888: 2887: 2868: 2867: 2857: 2856: 2849: 2848: 2838: 2837: 2832: 2831: 2821: 2818: 2816: 2813: 2812: 2811: 2798: 2791: 2784: 2773: 2766: 2755: 2748: 2735: 2732: 2731: 2730: 2691:. Cuchullain 2673: 2652: 2649: 2648: 2647: 2590: 2589:France article 2587: 2586: 2585: 2491: 2486: 2484: 2481: 2480: 2479: 2465: 2462: 2448: 2445: 2444: 2443: 2432: 2417: 2405: 2402: 2401: 2400: 2386: 2380: 2372: 2369: 2368: 2367: 2352: 2344: 2335: 2332: 2331: 2330: 2300: 2297: 2296: 2295: 2281: 2256: 2253: 2251: 2248: 2247: 2246: 2245: 2244: 2231: 2230: 2229: 2228: 2214: 2211: 2210: 2209: 2198: 2188: 2170: 2167: 2146:User:Viriditas 2016: 2010: 2008: 2005: 1982: 1979: 1960: 1957: 1947: 1940: 1939: 1938: 1926: 1923: 1918: 1917: 1910: 1893: 1890: 1886: 1885: 1884: 1883: 1871: 1870: 1869: 1850: 1849: 1843: 1837: 1823: 1816: 1814: 1811: 1787: 1784: 1723: 1720: 1718: 1715: 1681: 1672: 1658: 1655: 1654: 1653: 1652: 1651: 1640: 1629: 1614: 1613: 1612: 1604: 1596: 1575: 1572: 1570: 1564: 1533: 1530: 1529: 1528: 1499: 1496: 1495: 1494: 1483: 1482: 1481: 1480: 1474: 1473: 1466: 1465: 1464: 1463: 1460: 1447: 1446: 1440: 1434: 1429: 1428: 1422: 1421: 1418: 1413: 1407: 1406: 1403: 1398: 1392: 1391: 1388: 1383: 1377: 1376: 1373: 1368: 1362: 1361: 1358: 1353: 1345: 1344: 1335: 1331: 1330: 1327: 1322: 1316: 1315: 1312: 1307: 1301: 1300: 1297: 1292: 1286: 1285: 1282: 1277: 1271: 1270: 1267: 1262: 1256: 1255: 1252: 1247: 1239: 1238: 1229: 1225: 1224: 1221: 1216: 1210: 1209: 1206: 1201: 1195: 1194: 1191: 1186: 1178: 1177: 1168: 1164: 1163: 1160: 1155: 1149: 1148: 1145: 1140: 1134: 1133: 1130: 1125: 1119: 1118: 1115: 1110: 1104: 1103: 1100: 1095: 1087: 1086: 1077: 1073: 1072: 1069: 1064: 1058: 1057: 1054: 1049: 1043: 1042: 1039: 1034: 1028: 1027: 1024: 1019: 1011: 1010: 1001: 997: 996: 993: 988: 982: 981: 978: 973: 967: 966: 963: 958: 952: 951: 948: 943: 935: 934: 925: 921: 920: 917: 912: 906: 905: 902: 897: 891: 890: 887: 882: 876: 875: 874:"as per Jayjg" 872: 867: 861: 860: 857: 852: 846: 845: 842: 837: 829: 828: 819: 815: 814: 811: 806: 800: 799: 796: 791: 785: 784: 781: 776: 770: 769: 766: 761: 755: 754: 751: 746: 740: 739: 736: 731: 725: 724: 721: 716: 708: 707: 698: 694: 693: 690: 685: 679: 678: 675: 670: 664: 663: 660: 655: 649: 648: 645: 640: 634: 633: 626: 621: 613: 612: 603: 599: 598: 595: 590: 584: 583: 580: 575: 569: 568: 565: 560: 554: 553: 550: 545: 539: 538: 535: 530: 524: 523: 520: 515: 509: 508: 505: 500: 492: 491: 482: 478: 477: 474: 469: 463: 462: 459: 454: 448: 447: 444: 439: 433: 432: 429: 424: 416: 415: 406: 402: 401: 398: 393: 387: 386: 383: 378: 372: 371: 368: 363: 357: 356: 353: 348: 342: 341: 338: 333: 327: 326: 323: 318: 310: 309: 298:all or nothing 288: 285: 232: 229: 224: 223: 213: 203: 194: 184: 174: 165: 155: 146: 136: 117: 114: 112: 106: 55: 54: 38: 27: 15: 14: 13: 10: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 7183: 7174: 7171: 7164: 7162: 7155: 7153: 7152: 7145: 7143: 7142: 7137: 7136: 7130: 7129: 7122: 7121: 7111: 7109: 7106: 7102: 7098: 7094: 7090: 7086: 7078: 7075: 7071: 7067: 7065: 7064: 7061: 7057: 7052: 7051: 7048: 7044: 7041: 7036: 7034: 7030: 7022: 7020: 7018: 7013: 7011: 7007: 7002: 7000: 6992: 6989: 6985: 6981: 6977: 6974: 6970: 6969: 6968: 6967: 6964: 6960: 6954: 6953: 6949: 6947: 6940: 6937: 6932: 6930: 6929: 6925: 6921: 6913: 6909: 6905: 6898: 6894: 6888: 6885: 6881: 6877: 6876: 6875: 6872: 6867: 6866: 6865: 6863: 6858: 6856: 6854: 6851: 6848: 6844: 6842: 6839: 6835: 6833: 6831: 6828: 6826: 6824: 6821: 6819: 6817: 6814: 6811: 6808: 6805:In regard to 6801: 6798:violation by 6797: 6794: 6790: 6789:User:Mackan79 6786: 6784: 6782: 6781:in good faith 6777: 6775: 6771: 6763: 6759: 6754: 6751: 6747: 6743: 6742: 6738: 6736: 6732: 6731: 6730:Humus sapiens 6727: 6724: 6720: 6716: 6715: 6711: 6708: 6704: 6700: 6699: 6695: 6692: 6688: 6684: 6683: 6679: 6676: 6672: 6668: 6667: 6663: 6660: 6656: 6652: 6651: 6647: 6646: 6642: 6638: 6634: 6631: 6629: 6625: 6622: 6621: 6617: 6613: 6611: 6609: 6601: 6599: 6597: 6594: 6590: 6584: 6582: 6578: 6575: 6572: 6569: 6565: 6561: 6556: 6553: 6549: 6546: 6543: 6539: 6533: 6529: 6525: 6521: 6519: 6518: 6515: 6511: 6507: 6503: 6498: 6496: 6492: 6488: 6485: 6482: 6478: 6471: 6468: 6466: 6465: 6462: 6458: 6454: 6450: 6446: 6442: 6441:Humus sapiens 6438: 6434: 6430: 6427: 6424: 6422: 6418: 6417:in the Arbcom 6414: 6411: 6408: 6404: 6397: 6394: 6392: 6391: 6388: 6384: 6381: 6377: 6369: 6361: 6359: 6358: 6355: 6350: 6349: 6347: 6344: 6340: 6337: 6333: 6329: 6328:User:Cerejota 6322: 6317: 6315: 6314: 6311: 6307: 6303: 6291: 6287: 6285: 6284: 6281: 6276: 6274: 6270: 6265: 6262: 6260: 6252: 6246: 6242: 6238: 6237: 6236: 6234: 6230: 6226: 6219: 6217: 6213: 6209: 6202: 6200: 6197: 6189: 6188: 6187: 6181: 6179: 6173: 6169: 6165: 6157: 6154: 6149: 6148: 6147: 6146: 6145: 6144: 6139: 6136: 6132: 6131: 6130: 6129: 6127: 6120: 6109: 6108: 6107: 6106: 6099: 6098: 6097: 6096: 6089: 6088: 6087: 6086: 6080: 6079: 6078: 6077: 6076: 6075: 6072: 6063: 6062: 6058: 6055: 6052: 6051: 6047: 6044: 6041: 6040: 6036: 6033: 6030: 6029: 6025: 6022: 6019: 6018: 6014: 6011: 6008: 6007: 6003: 6000: 5997: 5996: 5992: 5989: 5986: 5985: 5981: 5978: 5975: 5974: 5970: 5967: 5964: 5963: 5959: 5956: 5953: 5952: 5948: 5945: 5942: 5941: 5937: 5934: 5931: 5930: 5926: 5923: 5920: 5919: 5916: 5911: 5906: 5902: 5899: 5896: 5894: 5889: 5882: 5878: 5872: 5870: 5864: 5860: 5852: 5851: 5847: 5844: 5842: 5840: 5838: 5836: 5834: 5832: 5830: 5827: 5824: 5822: 5820: 5817: 5816: 5812: 5809: 5807: 5805: 5803: 5801: 5799: 5797: 5795: 5792: 5789: 5787: 5785: 5782: 5781: 5777: 5774: 5772: 5770: 5768: 5766: 5764: 5762: 5759: 5757: 5754: 5752: 5750: 5747: 5746: 5742: 5739: 5737: 5735: 5733: 5731: 5729: 5726: 5723: 5720: 5717: 5715: 5713: 5710: 5709: 5705: 5702: 5700: 5698: 5696: 5694: 5692: 5690: 5687: 5684: 5681: 5679: 5677: 5674: 5673: 5669: 5666: 5664: 5662: 5660: 5657: 5655: 5653: 5650: 5648: 5645: 5643: 5641: 5638: 5637: 5633: 5630: 5628: 5626: 5624: 5622: 5620: 5618: 5615: 5613: 5610: 5608: 5606: 5603: 5602: 5598: 5595: 5593: 5591: 5589: 5587: 5585: 5583: 5580: 5577: 5574: 5572: 5570: 5567: 5566: 5562: 5559: 5557: 5555: 5553: 5551: 5549: 5547: 5544: 5541: 5538: 5536: 5534: 5531: 5530: 5526: 5523: 5521: 5519: 5517: 5515: 5513: 5511: 5509: 5507: 5504: 5502: 5500: 5497: 5496: 5492: 5489: 5487: 5485: 5483: 5481: 5479: 5477: 5474: 5472: 5469: 5467: 5465: 5462: 5461: 5457: 5454: 5452: 5450: 5448: 5446: 5444: 5442: 5439: 5436: 5433: 5431: 5429: 5426: 5425: 5421: 5418: 5416: 5414: 5411: 5409: 5407: 5405: 5403: 5400: 5397: 5395: 5393: 5390: 5389: 5385: 5382: 5380: 5378: 5376: 5374: 5372: 5370: 5367: 5364: 5361: 5359: 5357: 5354: 5353: 5349: 5346: 5344: 5342: 5340: 5338: 5336: 5334: 5331: 5328: 5325: 5323: 5321: 5318: 5317: 5313: 5310: 5308: 5306: 5304: 5302: 5300: 5298: 5295: 5292: 5289: 5287: 5285: 5282: 5281: 5277: 5274: 5272: 5270: 5268: 5266: 5264: 5262: 5259: 5256: 5253: 5251: 5249: 5246: 5245: 5241: 5238: 5236: 5234: 5232: 5230: 5228: 5225: 5222: 5219: 5216: 5214: 5212: 5209: 5208: 5204: 5201: 5199: 5197: 5195: 5193: 5191: 5188: 5185: 5182: 5179: 5177: 5175: 5172: 5171: 5167: 5164: 5162: 5160: 5158: 5156: 5154: 5152: 5150: 5148: 5145: 5143: 5141: 5138: 5137: 5133: 5130: 5128: 5126: 5124: 5122: 5120: 5117: 5114: 5111: 5108: 5106: 5104: 5102:Humus sapiens 5101: 5100: 5096: 5093: 5091: 5089: 5087: 5085: 5083: 5081: 5078: 5075: 5072: 5070: 5068: 5065: 5064: 5060: 5057: 5055: 5053: 5051: 5049: 5047: 5045: 5043: 5040: 5037: 5035: 5033: 5030: 5029: 5025: 5022: 5020: 5018: 5016: 5014: 5012: 5009: 5007: 5005: 5002: 5000: 4998: 4995: 4994: 4990: 4987: 4985: 4983: 4981: 4979: 4977: 4974: 4971: 4968: 4965: 4963: 4961: 4958: 4957: 4953: 4950: 4948: 4946: 4944: 4942: 4940: 4937: 4934: 4931: 4928: 4926: 4924: 4921: 4920: 4916: 4913: 4911: 4909: 4907: 4905: 4903: 4900: 4897: 4894: 4891: 4889: 4887: 4884: 4883: 4879: 4876: 4874: 4872: 4870: 4868: 4866: 4864: 4861: 4858: 4855: 4853: 4851: 4848: 4847: 4844: 4839: 4834: 4829: 4824: 4819: 4814: 4809: 4804: 4799: 4794: 4789: 4784: 4779: 4775: 4772: 4769: 4762: 4760: 4757: 4754: 4750: 4742: 4741: 4737: 4735: 4733: 4731: 4729: 4727: 4725: 4723: 4720: 4718: 4715: 4712: 4711: 4708: 4706: 4704: 4702: 4700: 4698: 4695: 4693: 4690: 4688: 4685: 4682: 4681: 4678: 4676: 4673: 4671: 4668: 4666: 4664: 4662: 4659: 4657: 4654: 4651: 4650: 4646: 4643: 4641: 4639: 4636: 4634: 4632: 4630: 4627: 4625: 4622: 4619: 4618: 4614: 4612: 4610: 4607: 4604: 4602: 4599: 4597: 4595: 4593: 4591: 4588: 4587: 4583: 4581: 4579: 4577: 4575: 4573: 4571: 4569: 4566: 4563: 4561: 4558: 4557: 4553: 4551: 4548: 4546: 4543: 4541: 4539: 4537: 4534: 4532: 4529: 4526: 4525: 4522: 4519: 4516: 4514: 4511: 4509: 4507: 4505: 4503: 4501: 4498: 4495: 4494: 4490: 4488: 4485: 4482: 4479: 4476: 4474: 4472: 4470: 4468: 4466: 4463: 4462: 4459: 4457: 4454: 4452: 4449: 4446: 4443: 4441: 4439: 4437: 4435: 4432: 4431: 4428: 4425: 4422: 4420: 4418: 4416: 4414: 4412: 4409: 4407: 4404: 4401: 4400: 4396: 4394: 4391: 4388: 4385: 4383: 4380: 4377: 4375: 4373: 4371: 4368: 4367: 4363: 4360: 4358: 4356: 4353: 4351: 4349: 4347: 4344: 4342: 4339: 4336: 4335: 4331: 4328: 4325: 4323: 4320: 4318: 4316: 4314: 4311: 4309: 4306: 4304:Humus sapiens 4303: 4302: 4298: 4295: 4292: 4290: 4287: 4285: 4282: 4280: 4277: 4275: 4272: 4269: 4268: 4264: 4261: 4258: 4255: 4252: 4250: 4247: 4245: 4242: 4240: 4237: 4234: 4233: 4230: 4228: 4225: 4222: 4219: 4216: 4214: 4211: 4209: 4207: 4205: 4202: 4201: 4197: 4194: 4192: 4189: 4186: 4183: 4180: 4178: 4176: 4174: 4172: 4169: 4168: 4165: 4160: 4155: 4150: 4145: 4140: 4135: 4130: 4125: 4120: 4115: 4110: 4106: 4103: 4097: 4095: 4092: 4090: 4081: 4079: 4072: 4069: 4065: 4062: 4059: 4056: 4055: 4053: 4048: 4045: 4042: 4041: 4039: 4036: 4030: 4027: 4024: 4023: 4021: 4020: 4019: 4016: 4010: 4005: 4002: 3999: 3995: 3991: 3989: 3988: 3985: 3981: 3978: 3975: 3971: 3963: 3960: 3957: 3953: 3950: 3945: 3942: 3939: 3935: 3931: 3929: 3927: 3923: 3919: 3915: 3907: 3902: 3900: 3899: 3896: 3892: 3885: 3880: 3878: 3875: 3871: 3867: 3863: 3859: 3856: 3853: 3848: 3846: 3842: 3835: 3831: 3827: 3823: 3821: 3819: 3817: 3814: 3813:User:Zleitzen 3807: 3805: 3804: 3801: 3797: 3792: 3791: 3788: 3781: 3777: 3771: 3770: 3765: 3764: 3763: 3759: 3758: 3754: 3750: 3746: 3741: 3737: 3731: 3727: 3726: 3723: 3719: 3718: 3715: 3711: 3710: 3707: 3703: 3702: 3699: 3695: 3694: 3691: 3688: 3687: 3684: 3681: 3680: 3677: 3673: 3672: 3669: 3666: 3662: 3661: 3658: 3654: 3653: 3652: 3649: 3646: 3643: 3638: 3636: 3633: 3625: 3621: 3617: 3615: 3614: 3611: 3599: 3596: 3593: 3586: 3585:User:Cerejota 3582: 3579: 3577: 3576: 3573: 3561: 3557: 3553: 3546: 3545:User:Targeman 3542: 3540: 3539: 3536: 3524: 3521: 3517: 3513: 3509: 3504: 3500: 3496: 3489: 3485: 3481: 3477: 3475: 3474: 3471: 3467: 3460: 3458: 3457: 3454: 3450: 3443: 3441: 3439: 3436: 3433: 3431: 3429: 3426: 3423: 3420: 3416: 3408: 3406: 3405: 3402: 3399: 3396: 3393: 3390: 3386: 3378: 3376: 3375: 3374: 3364: 3361: 3358: 3355: 3352: 3349: 3346: 3343: 3340: 3337: 3334: 3331: 3328: 3323: 3320: 3316: 3313: 3310: 3307: 3304: 3301: 3298: 3295: 3292: 3289: 3286: 3283: 3280: 3275: 3272: 3270: 3267: 3261: 3258: 3255: 3252: 3249: 3246: 3243: 3240: 3237: 3234: 3231: 3228: 3225: 3220: 3217: 3215: 3212: 3206: 3203: 3200: 3197: 3194: 3191: 3188: 3185: 3182: 3179: 3176: 3173: 3170: 3165: 3162: 3160: 3155: 3152: 3149: 3146: 3143: 3140: 3137: 3134: 3131: 3128: 3125: 3122: 3119: 3114: 3111: 3110: 3106: 3105: 3099: 3096: 3093: 3090: 3087: 3084: 3081: 3078: 3075: 3072: 3069: 3066: 3063: 3058: 3055: 3051: 3048: 3045: 3042: 3039: 3036: 3033: 3030: 3027: 3024: 3021: 3018: 3015: 3010: 3007: 3006: 3002: 3000: 2999: 2994: 2993: 2992: 2986: 2984: 2983: 2980: 2973: 2969: 2967: 2966: 2963: 2955: 2951: 2944: 2942: 2941: 2938: 2930: 2928: 2923: 2921: 2920:reprehensible 2917: 2912: 2910: 2906: 2902: 2898: 2890: 2886: 2883: 2877: 2874: 2870: 2869: 2866: 2863: 2859: 2858: 2854: 2851: 2850: 2845: 2840: 2839: 2834: 2833: 2829: 2824: 2823: 2819: 2814: 2810: 2807: 2803: 2799: 2796: 2792: 2789: 2785: 2782: 2778: 2774: 2771: 2767: 2764: 2760: 2756: 2753: 2749: 2746: 2742: 2738: 2737: 2733: 2729: 2726: 2722: 2718: 2714: 2710: 2706: 2702: 2698: 2694: 2690: 2686: 2683:. Cuchullain 2682: 2678: 2674: 2671: 2667: 2663: 2659: 2655: 2654: 2650: 2646: 2643: 2639: 2635: 2631: 2627: 2624:by Beit Or. 2623: 2619: 2618: 2613: 2609: 2605: 2601: 2597: 2593: 2592: 2588: 2584: 2581: 2577: 2575: 2570: 2566: 2562: 2558: 2554: 2550: 2546: 2542: 2538: 2534: 2530: 2526: 2522: 2518: 2514: 2510: 2506: 2502: 2498: 2494: 2493: 2490: 2487: 2482: 2478: 2475: 2471: 2468: 2467: 2463: 2461: 2460: 2457: 2453: 2446: 2441: 2437: 2436:major rewrite 2433: 2430: 2426: 2425:became policy 2422: 2418: 2415: 2411: 2408: 2407: 2403: 2398: 2394: 2390: 2387: 2384: 2381: 2378: 2375: 2374: 2370: 2365: 2361: 2357: 2353: 2349: 2345: 2342: 2338: 2337: 2333: 2328: 2325: 2321: 2317: 2313: 2312: 2307: 2303: 2302: 2298: 2293: 2289: 2285: 2282: 2279: 2275: 2271: 2267: 2263: 2259: 2258: 2254: 2249: 2243: 2240: 2235: 2234: 2233: 2232: 2227: 2225: 2219: 2218: 2217: 2216: 2212: 2207: 2203: 2199: 2196: 2193: 2189: 2186: 2183: 2179: 2178: 2177: 2175: 2168: 2166: 2164: 2161: 2158:violations. 2157: 2153: 2150: 2147: 2143: 2138: 2136: 2133: 2129: 2125: 2121: 2116: 2114: 2110: 2106: 2102: 2097: 2095: 2091: 2087: 2083: 2079: 2075: 2071: 2067: 2063: 2059: 2054: 2053: 2051: 2047: 2043: 2039: 2035: 2031: 2027: 2023: 2015: 2011: 2006: 2004: 2003: 1998: 1996: 1992: 1988: 1980: 1978: 1977: 1972: 1970: 1966: 1958: 1956: 1955: 1952: 1945: 1941: 1936: 1932: 1929: 1928: 1924: 1922: 1915: 1911: 1908: 1904: 1900: 1896: 1895: 1891: 1889: 1882: 1878: 1877: 1876: 1872: 1868: 1865: 1861: 1860: 1859: 1855: 1854: 1853: 1852:In addition: 1848: 1844: 1842: 1838: 1836: 1832: 1831: 1830: 1829: 1821: 1817: 1812: 1810: 1809: 1806: 1803: 1799: 1797: 1793: 1785: 1783: 1782: 1779: 1775: 1771: 1766: 1765: 1762: 1759: 1755: 1754: 1750: 1746: 1742: 1738: 1735: 1732: 1728: 1721: 1716: 1713: 1712: 1708: 1706: 1705: 1699: 1697: 1693: 1689: 1685: 1680: 1676: 1673: 1671: 1669: 1666: 1663: 1656: 1650: 1647: 1644: 1641: 1639: 1636: 1633: 1630: 1628: 1625: 1622: 1621: 1619: 1615: 1611: 1608: 1607:Humus sapiens 1605: 1603: 1600: 1597: 1595: 1592: 1589: 1588: 1586: 1585: 1584: 1582: 1573: 1569: 1565: 1563: 1561: 1557: 1553: 1549: 1546: 1543: 1539: 1538:Humus sapiens 1531: 1527: 1523: 1522: 1521: 1519: 1515: 1512: 1509: 1505: 1497: 1493: 1490: 1485: 1484: 1478: 1477: 1476: 1475: 1471: 1468: 1467: 1461: 1458: 1454: 1453: 1452: 1451: 1450: 1444: 1441: 1438: 1435: 1431: 1430: 1426: 1425: 1417: 1412: 1408: 1402: 1397: 1393: 1387: 1382: 1378: 1372: 1367: 1363: 1357: 1352: 1348: 1343: 1342: 1338: 1337: 1336: 1326: 1321: 1317: 1311: 1306: 1302: 1296: 1291: 1287: 1281: 1276: 1272: 1266: 1261: 1257: 1251: 1246: 1242: 1237: 1236: 1232: 1231: 1230: 1222: 1220: 1215: 1211: 1207: 1205: 1200: 1196: 1190: 1185: 1181: 1176: 1175: 1171: 1170: 1169: 1159: 1154: 1150: 1144: 1139: 1135: 1129: 1124: 1120: 1114: 1109: 1105: 1099: 1094: 1090: 1085: 1084: 1080: 1079: 1078: 1068: 1063: 1059: 1053: 1048: 1044: 1038: 1033: 1029: 1023: 1018: 1014: 1009: 1008: 1004: 1003: 1002: 992: 987: 983: 977: 972: 968: 962: 957: 953: 947: 942: 938: 933: 932: 928: 927: 926: 916: 911: 907: 901: 896: 892: 886: 881: 877: 871: 866: 862: 856: 851: 847: 841: 836: 832: 827: 826: 822: 821: 820: 810: 805: 801: 795: 790: 786: 780: 775: 771: 765: 760: 756: 750: 745: 741: 735: 732: 730: 726: 720: 715: 711: 706: 705: 701: 700: 699: 689: 684: 680: 674: 669: 665: 659: 654: 650: 644: 639: 635: 631: 625: 620: 616: 611: 610: 606: 605: 604: 594: 589: 585: 579: 574: 570: 564: 559: 555: 549: 544: 540: 534: 529: 525: 519: 514: 510: 504: 499: 495: 490: 489: 488:Humus sapiens 485: 484: 483: 473: 468: 464: 458: 453: 449: 443: 438: 434: 428: 423: 419: 414: 413: 409: 408: 407: 397: 392: 388: 382: 377: 373: 367: 362: 358: 352: 347: 343: 337: 332: 328: 322: 317: 313: 308: 307: 303: 302: 301: 299: 295: 286: 284: 283: 280: 276: 271: 270: 268: 265: 259: 257: 252: 251: 250: 245: 242: 238: 228: 221: 217: 214: 211: 207: 204: 202: 198: 195: 192: 188: 185: 182: 178: 175: 173: 169: 166: 163: 159: 156: 154: 150: 147: 144: 140: 137: 134: 130: 127: 126: 125: 123: 115: 111: 107: 105: 103: 99: 94: 90: 88: 83: 81: 77: 76:contributions 73: 67: 65: 60: 52: 48: 43: 39: 32: 31: 23: 19: 7172: 7168: 7159: 7150: 7149: 7132: 7125: 7114: 7082: 7053: 7038: 7037: 7026: 7014: 7003: 6996: 6955: 6950: 6944: 6912:User:Avraham 6901: 6859: 6804: 6780: 6778: 6767: 6752: 6739: 6728: 6712: 6696: 6680: 6664: 6648: 6605: 6585: 6580: 6567: 6557: 6544: 6536: 6499: 6483: 6475: 6420: 6409: 6401: 6373: 6351: 6330:referred to 6326: 6299: 6277: 6266: 6263: 6256: 6232: 6227: 6223: 6214: 6210: 6206: 6195: 6193: 6185: 6176: 6125: 6068: 6045:Saudi Arabia 5914: 5909: 5904: 5897: 5890: 5886: 5876: 5868: 5857: 4842: 4837: 4832: 4827: 4822: 4817: 4812: 4807: 4802: 4797: 4792: 4787: 4782: 4778:Concise name 4777: 4770: 4766: 4758: 4755: 4751: 4747: 4163: 4159:Saudi Arabia 4158: 4153: 4148: 4143: 4138: 4133: 4128: 4123: 4118: 4113: 4108: 4101: 4093: 4085: 4077: 4017: 4014: 4000: 3976: 3967: 3958: 3940: 3911: 3889: 3876: 3872: 3868: 3864: 3860: 3857: 3854: 3849: 3838: 3811: 3799: 3793: 3784: 3760: 3739: 3738: 3734: 3650: 3639: 3629: 3589: 3551: 3549: 3492: 3464: 3447: 3421: 3412: 3403: 3391: 3382: 3371: 3370: 3359: 3353: 3347: 3341: 3335: 3329: 3311: 3305: 3299: 3293: 3287: 3281: 3256: 3250: 3244: 3238: 3232: 3226: 3201: 3195: 3189: 3183: 3177: 3171: 3150: 3144: 3138: 3132: 3126: 3120: 3094: 3088: 3082: 3076: 3070: 3064: 3046: 3040: 3034: 3028: 3022: 3016: 3003:Puppetmaster 2995: 2990: 2976: 2956: 2952: 2948: 2931: 2924: 2913: 2894: 2843: 2827: 2826:and who has 2747:by Urthogie. 2707:. Ashley Y 2703:. Cerejota 2699:. Ashley Y 2695:. Cerejota 2687:. Cerejota 2679:. Cerejota 2620:by Lothar. 2615: 2573: 2564: 2548: 2540: 2451: 2450: 2440:9 March 2005 2310: 2309: 2306:Dlohcierekim 2221: 2172: 2139: 2117: 2098: 2055: 2019: 2018: 1999: 1984: 1973: 1962: 1949: 1919: 1887: 1863: 1851: 1825: 1800: 1789: 1773: 1767: 1756: 1733: 1725: 1710: 1709: 1707: 1702: 1701: 1686: 1683: 1660: 1580: 1577: 1544: 1535: 1510: 1501: 1456: 1448: 1415: 1400: 1385: 1370: 1355: 1339: 1334: 1324: 1309: 1294: 1279: 1264: 1249: 1233: 1228: 1218: 1203: 1188: 1172: 1167: 1157: 1142: 1127: 1112: 1097: 1081: 1076: 1066: 1051: 1036: 1021: 1005: 1000: 990: 975: 960: 945: 929: 924: 914: 899: 884: 869: 854: 839: 823: 818: 808: 793: 778: 763: 748: 733: 718: 702: 697: 687: 672: 657: 642: 623: 607: 602: 592: 577: 562: 547: 532: 517: 502: 486: 481: 471: 456: 441: 426: 410: 405: 395: 380: 365: 350: 335: 320: 304: 290: 273:Sefringle's 272: 263: 261: 260: 258:he stated: 253: 247: 246: 234: 225: 219: 209: 200: 190: 180: 171: 161: 152: 142: 132: 119: 95: 91: 84: 72:page history 68: 63: 61: 58: 50: 46: 41: 7085:9 July 2007 6961:. Thanks!-- 6904:User:Isarig 6290:user:G-Dett 6248:disruption. 5915:Total votes 5783:ObiterDicta 5391:Victor falk 3665:User:ChrisO 3520:User:ChrisO 3488:User:ChrisO 3322:Medcabemail 3164:Ilovetaiwan 3107:Sockpuppets 2797:(#2) again. 2790:(#2) again. 2768:Jayjg then 2719:. GDonato 2711:. Cerejota 2636:by Jayjg. 2632:by Lothar. 2563:redirects ( 2555:redirects, 2539:redirects ( 2531:redirects, 2523:redirects, 2515:redirects, 2421:first draft 2070:Segregation 1987:User:ChrisO 1985:On July 29 1965:User:ChrisO 1963:On July 22 1778:Thatcher131 1774:Clerk note: 1739:) has made 1675:User:Sm8900 6800:User:Jayjg 6666:6SJ7 again 6568:ad hominem 6504:. Compare 6433:campaigned 6304:; deleted 6302:correction 5427:Hornplease 3984:John Nagle 3357:block user 3351:filter log 3309:block user 3303:filter log 3254:block user 3248:filter log 3199:block user 3193:filter log 3148:block user 3142:filter log 3092:block user 3086:filter log 3044:block user 3038:filter log 2786:Urthrogie 2715:. Lothar 2610:by Jayjg. 2594:Starts at 2389:Chris asks 2383:Chris asks 2320:suggestion 2192:User:Yuber 2174:User:Jayjg 2034:User:Jayjg 1944:WP:CANVASS 1433:assertion. 1102:"POV fork" 630:filthy Jew 239:nominated 64:be concise 6616:Sefringle 6550:) closed 5968:Australia 5604:Andyvphil 5463:Kendrick7 5319:Sefringle 4833:Undecided 4783:<: --> 4652:Tickle me 4433:Sefringle 4129:Australia 3826:Number 57 3620:Clayoquot 3470:Jehochman 3453:Jehochman 3363:block log 3315:block log 3260:block log 3205:block log 3154:block log 3098:block log 3050:block log 2996:See also 2972:Jehochman 2802:talk page 2721:protected 2664:. Jayjg 2638:Protected 2574:protected 2559:reverts, 2547:reverts ( 2535:reverts, 2527:reverts, 2525:T L Miles 2519:reverts, 2517:T L Miles 2511:reverts, 2497:redirects 2348:Sefringle 2140:Add: On 2044:entitled 2026:Apartheid 1967:protects 1679:WP:CANVAS 1341:Tickle me 1083:Sefringle 237:Sefringle 98:/Workshop 87:talk page 7017:CJCurrie 6973:Alithien 6963:Cerejota 6959:WP:POINT 6918:FayssalF 6897:FayssalF 6884:Mackan79 6847:WP:POINT 6838:WP:POINT 6807:WP:POINT 6796:WP:POINT 6774:WP:POINT 6762:WP:POINT 6741:IronDuke 6682:Urthogie 6633:Urthogie 6548:contribs 6524:MastCell 6487:contribs 6445:Amoruso‎ 6413:contribs 6354:Ashley Y 6240:articles 6229:WP:POINT 6172:WP:POINT 6135:Cerejota 6001:Israel 6 5979:Israel 5 5957:Israel 4 5946:Israel 3 5935:Israel 2 5924:Israel 1 5905:Sequence 5639:FayssalF 5283:IronDuke 5247:unsigned 5210:CJCurrie 5173:Cerejota 5139:Zleitzen 5066:Mackan79 5031:Ideogram 4996:Targeman 4959:Urthogie 4823:Redirect 4464:Cerejota 4369:Mackan79 4337:IronDuke 4235:CJCurrie 4203:Urthogie 4134:Israel 4 4124:Israel 3 4119:Israel 2 4114:Israel 1 4004:contribs 3980:contribs 3962:contribs 3944:contribs 3895:Ideogram 3870:Israel. 3843:and the 3753:contribs 3745:Kla’quot 3581:WP:CIVIL 3503:WP:POINT 3499:WP:POINT 3495:WP:POINT 3425:contribs 3395:contribs 3333:contribs 3285:contribs 3230:contribs 3175:contribs 3124:contribs 3113:Wang C-H 3068:contribs 3020:contribs 3009:Ideogram 2961:IronDuke 2936:IronDuke 2881:IronDuke 2862:Kiyosaki 2770:corrects 2745:expanded 2717:repeated 2713:reverted 2709:repeated 2705:reverted 2701:repeated 2697:reverted 2693:repeated 2689:reverted 2685:repeated 2681:reverted 2677:repeated 2666:reverted 2549:3rd time 2541:3rd time 2470:Ideogram 2356:Urthogie 2278:WP:POINT 2274:WP:POINT 2239:CJCurrie 2224:Kiyosaki 2160:CJCurrie 2156:WP:POINT 2132:CJCurrie 2124:WP:POINT 2014:WP:POINT 1989:deletes 1802:Picaroon 1758:Picaroon 1737:contribs 1727:IronDuke 1662:Urthogie 1632:Urthogie 1552:IronDuke 1548:contribs 1514:contribs 1504:TShilo12 609:IronDuke 262:"either 191:Chesdovi 181:Urthogie 172:Urthogie 162:Urthogie 153:Urthogie 143:Urthogie 133:Urthogie 20:‎ | 7083:Around 7070:Eleland 6871:Leifern 6589:Jayjg's 6570:abuse ( 6453:GHcool‎ 6368:Leifern 6280:Leifern 6153:Leifern 6071:Leifern 5990:Islamic 4818:Neutral 4793:Comment 4788:Abstain 4713:Leifern 4615:Delete 4397:Delete 4265:Delete 4198:Delete 4139:Islamic 4068:Leifern 3994:Leifern 3787:WP:NPOV 3780:WP:NPOV 3512:WP:NPOV 3415:Galindo 3266:WP:DUCK 3219:Galindo 3211:WP:DUCK 3057:IdeoBot 2806:GRBerry 2793:ChrisO 2788:reverts 2777:deletes 2763:reverts 2752:rewrote 2741:tweaked 2725:GRBerry 2642:GRBerry 2580:GRBerry 2537:Beit Or 2529:Beit Or 2521:Beit Or 2474:GRBerry 2456:GRBerry 2429:GRBerry 2397:GRBerry 2364:GRBerry 2351:forks." 2324:GRBerry 2316:GRBerry 2292:GRBerry 2280:attack. 1933:closes 1741:incivil 1704:Israel. 1568:NicDumZ 1489:Leifern 1174:Shamir1 931:Leifern 734:comment 210:Bleh999 7029:Sm8900 6984:Huldra 6753:unless 6560:^demon 6538:ChrisO 6477:Sm8900 6470:Sm8900 6449:Jayjg‎ 6437:Nadav‎ 6403:Sm8900 6396:Sm8900 6310:G-Dett 6269:^demon 6091:wrong. 6023:Jordan 6012:France 5910:Target 5568:Isarig 5355:ChrisO 4849:G-Dett 4798:Delete 4721:Delete 4716:Delete 4696:Delete 4691:Delete 4686:Delete 4660:Delete 4655:Delete 4628:Delete 4623:Delete 4620:Tewfik 4608:Delete 4605:Delete 4584:Merge 4535:Delete 4530:Delete 4499:Delete 4483:Delete 4455:Delete 4444:Delete 4410:Delete 4405:Delete 4392:Delete 4389:Delete 4386:Delete 4378:Delete 4345:Delete 4340:Delete 4312:Delete 4307:Delete 4283:Delete 4278:Delete 4273:Delete 4259:Delete 4256:Delete 4253:Delete 4195:Delete 4190:Delete 4187:Delete 4184:Delete 4170:G-Dett 4149:Jordan 4144:France 4109:Editor 3841:Israel 3834:Sm8900 3268:- see 3213:- see 2981:case. 2979:WP:CSN 2897:stupid 2828:actual 2775:ChisO 2634:Revert 2622:Revert 2608:Revert 2569:Lothar 2545:G-Dett 2533:G-Dett 2509:G-Dett 2505:WP:3RR 2501:merges 2495:Jayjg 1931:ChrisO 1648:& 1457:anyone 1356:Delete 1250:Delete 1235:Tewfik 1189:Delete 1113:Delete 1098:Delete 1037:Delete 1022:Delete 946:Delete 840:Delete 719:Delete 624:Delete 503:Delete 427:Delete 336:Delete 321:Delete 279:ChrisO 201:Theo F 110:ChrisO 51:Do not 7138:: --> 7134:edits 7119:eland 6991:Jayjg 6714:Jayjg 6673:(Re: 6244:them. 6056:China 5675:Armon 5532:Jossi 4885:Jayjg 4843:Votes 4838:Total 4828:Split 4808:Merge 4738:Keep 4647:Keep 4559:Nagle 4554:Keep 4527:Jossi 4517:Merge 4496:Jayjg 4491:Keep 4486:Merge 4477:Merge 4423:Merge 4364:Keep 4332:Keep 4326:Merge 4299:Keep 4293:Merge 4262:Merge 4164:China 4032:blame 3970:Jayjg 3952:Jayjg 3934:Nagle 3773:(UTC) 3767:(UTC) 2922:. 2873:Xoloz 2759:moves 2658:moved 2626:Moved 2612:Moved 2600:Moved 2561:Jayjg 2553:Jayjg 2513:Jayjg 2393:WP:AN 2304:Here 1643:Jossi 1591:Jayjg 1554:(see 825:Jossi 704:Jayjg 412:Armon 220:Jayjg 16:< 7127:talk 7112:< 7060:Talk 7047:Talk 6862:here 6650:6SJ7 6606:Per 6542:talk 6506:this 6481:talk 6451:and 6407:talk 6306:here 6259:here 6059:101 5927:112 5748:IZAK 5498:HOTR 4922:6SJ7 4813:Move 4803:Keep 4674:Keep 4669:Keep 4644:Keep 4637:Keep 4600:Keep 4589:Tarc 4567:Keep 4564:Keep 4549:Keep 4544:Keep 4520:Keep 4512:Keep 4480:Keep 4450:Keep 4447:Keep 4426:Keep 4381:Keep 4361:Keep 4354:Keep 4329:Keep 4321:Keep 4296:Keep 4288:Keep 4270:6SJ7 4248:Keep 4243:Keep 4238:Keep 4226:Keep 4223:Keep 4220:Keep 4217:Keep 4212:Keep 4181:Keep 3998:talk 3974:talk 3956:talk 3938:talk 3749:talk 3556:here 3516:NPOV 3419:talk 3400:and 3389:talk 3385:R1es 3345:logs 3327:talk 3297:logs 3279:talk 3274:R1es 3242:logs 3224:talk 3187:logs 3169:talk 3136:logs 3118:talk 3080:logs 3062:talk 3032:logs 3014:talk 2916:rant 2903:and 2901:fool 2899:, a 2576:by Y 2499:and 2311:keep 2090:here 2082:here 2002:logs 2000:See 1974:See 1953:and 1907:diff 1903:diff 1899:diff 1881:here 1875:here 1867:diff 1858:diff 1847:here 1841:here 1835:here 1826:RE: 1796:diff 1731:talk 1694:and 1690:, 1677:and 1624:6SJ7 1599:6SJ7 1593:] : 1542:talk 1508:talk 1416:Keep 1401:Keep 1386:Keep 1371:Keep 1325:Keep 1310:Keep 1295:Keep 1280:Keep 1265:Keep 1219:Keep 1204:Keep 1158:Keep 1143:Keep 1128:Keep 1067:Keep 1052:Keep 991:Keep 976:Keep 961:Keep 915:Keep 900:Keep 885:Keep 870:Keep 855:Keep 809:Keep 794:Keep 779:Keep 764:Keep 749:Keep 688:Keep 673:Keep 658:Keep 643:Keep 593:Keep 578:Keep 563:Keep 548:Keep 533:Keep 518:Keep 472:Keep 457:Keep 442:Keep 396:Keep 381:Keep 366:Keep 351:Keep 306:6SJ7 264:keep 42:only 7110:). 7004:At 6598:). 6581:any 6443:‎, 6308:.-- 6261:. 6170:or 6048:21 6037:27 6034:USA 6026:20 6015:60 6004:11 5993:32 5982:65 5971:12 5960:24 5949:79 5818:HKT 5278:10 4991:11 4880:11 4683:Zeq 4154:USA 3800:not 3609:gle 3606:rin 3603:Sef 3571:gle 3568:rin 3565:Sef 3534:gle 3531:rin 3528:Sef 2844:any 2660:to 2628:to 2614:to 2602:to 2598:. 2567:), 2551:), 2543:), 2391:at 2322:. 2260:In 2151:, 2099:On 2088:) ( 2072:on 2056:On 1976:log 1805:(t) 1761:(t) 1536:5) 1502:4) 235:2) 89:. 7116:el 7058:| 7056:HG 7045:| 7043:HG 7035:. 7019:. 7012:. 7001:. 6948:. 6922:- 6869:-- 6744:: 6733:: 6725:.) 6717:: 6709:.) 6701:: 6693:.) 6685:: 6677:.) 6669:: 6661:.) 6653:: 6635:: 6626:: 6576:, 6573:, 6459:. 6447:, 6439:, 6428:, 6425:, 6334:, 6275:. 6151:-- 6069:-- 6053:13 6042:12 6031:11 6020:10 5938:7 5895:. 5848:1 5845:11 5825:10 5813:2 5810:11 5778:3 5775:11 5743:3 5740:11 5706:4 5703:11 5670:2 5667:12 5634:3 5631:12 5599:4 5596:12 5563:5 5560:12 5527:0 5524:13 5505:13 5493:2 5490:13 5470:11 5458:2 5455:13 5434:11 5422:2 5419:14 5398:11 5386:4 5383:14 5362:10 5350:6 5347:16 5326:10 5314:6 5311:17 5290:11 5275:17 5242:9 5239:18 5205:5 5202:19 5180:14 5168:0 5165:20 5146:20 5134:7 5131:21 5109:14 5097:6 5094:23 5073:17 5061:2 5058:24 5038:22 5026:1 5023:30 5003:29 4988:31 4966:20 4954:8 4951:34 4929:26 4917:5 4914:55 4892:50 4877:94 4856:83 3928:. 3893:-- 3847:: 3755:) 3751:| 3740:If 3600:-- 3562:-- 3525:-- 3468:- 3451:- 3440:. 3264:- 3209:- 2507:: 2362:) 2268:, 2264:, 2148:: 2032:, 1751:, 1747:, 1670:) 1664:: 1645:: 1634:: 1626:: 1620:: 1609:: 1601:: 632:." 82:. 7123:/ 6840:, 6545:· 6540:( 6484:· 6479:( 6410:· 6405:( 6009:9 5998:8 5987:7 5976:6 5965:5 5954:4 5943:3 5932:2 5921:1 5828:1 5793:2 5790:9 5760:3 5755:8 5727:1 5724:1 5721:1 5718:8 5688:3 5685:1 5682:7 5658:1 5651:2 5646:9 5616:3 5611:9 5581:3 5578:1 5575:8 5545:3 5542:2 5539:7 5475:2 5440:1 5437:1 5412:1 5401:2 5368:1 5365:3 5332:3 5329:3 5296:3 5293:3 5260:7 5257:3 5254:7 5226:1 5223:4 5220:4 5217:9 5189:2 5186:2 5183:1 5118:1 5115:3 5112:3 5079:1 5076:5 5041:2 5010:1 4975:1 4972:8 4969:2 4938:1 4935:3 4932:4 4901:1 4898:2 4895:2 4862:5 4859:6 4006:) 4001:· 3996:( 3977:· 3972:( 3959:· 3954:( 3946:) 3941:· 3936:( 3747:( 3422:· 3417:( 3392:· 3387:( 3365:) 3360:· 3354:· 3348:· 3342:· 3336:· 3330:· 3325:( 3317:) 3312:· 3306:· 3300:· 3294:· 3288:· 3282:· 3277:( 3262:) 3257:· 3251:· 3245:· 3239:· 3233:· 3227:· 3222:( 3207:) 3202:· 3196:· 3190:· 3184:· 3178:· 3172:· 3167:( 3156:) 3151:· 3145:· 3139:· 3133:· 3127:· 3121:· 3116:( 3100:) 3095:· 3089:· 3083:· 3077:· 3071:· 3065:· 3060:( 3052:) 3047:· 3041:· 3035:· 3029:· 3023:· 3017:· 3012:( 2329:) 2208:) 2197:) 2187:) 2080:( 1916:. 1909:) 1794:( 1734:· 1729:( 1545:· 1540:( 1511:· 1506:( 1445:, 135:.

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.

Knowledge (XXG)

:Requests for arbitration/Allegations of apartheid/Evidence - Knowledge (XXG)

Index