741:, when it was promoted as a Featured Article, is a decent core; while it doesn't quite meet GA standards today, it does indicate that the article is essentially OK if tidied up. The reviews over the years indicate that the article has been prone to editors adding text, media and images without much thought to our editing guidelines and policies, and is indicative of casual editing by inexperienced editors on a popular article. While the edits have not been vandalistic (intentionally bad), the effect has been the same as if it were, as the article has suffered, and become unreliable and off-putting. Looking more closely at the edit history, I see TheRedPenOfDoom has done much to keep the page under control, though various unhelpful edits, such as
195:
407:
387:
347:
322:
299:
283:
258:
242:
226:
159:
427:
745:
escape attention as they are sourced and not vandalistic. Given that the article needs a fair amount of TLC to bring it back up to scratch, I am putting the GAR onhold for the standard initial seven days (though of course will extend that as needed), and putting the article on semi-protection for the
622:
A number of the comments interspersed throughout the article are unsourced and appear to be individual observation and opinion. This is likely due to well meaning additions by inexperienced readers, and is evidence that the article is not maintained.
501:
Focus. There are no details which are overly long or overly detailed, and the article as a whole is not overly large. However, as part of ongoing development, some tightening and trimming could take place to reduce wordage or unessential facts.
818:
I still have some concerns about the lead, which needs further development, and the article could do with some further tightening and cleaning. However, the concerns are not enough to justify a delisting, so I'm closing this GAR as a keep.
644:
Some of the language used, again likely due to unsourced insertions by casual readers rather than experienced editors, is not neutral, such as "The old city has few bakeries known for making very good Naan".
603:. There are also duplicate images of the same locations. I have not checked the copyright status of the images, as that is better done when the current images are reduced.
236:
600:
377:
189:
795:
Well done for that. I'm going to have a closer look at the lead later to see what can be done there. At the moment I feel the article's GA listing is secure.
125:
467:
Prose is clear and readable. I haven't checked for copyvio - there are a wide range of sources, and the information is mainly factual.
66:
252:
153:
737:
There is a decent article at heart here, but it needs tidying up. Looking through the "Article milestones" on the talkpage, the
62:
746:
duration of the GAR and a bit longer, to give some stability. As standard, will let main contributors know what is happening.
47:
381:
484:
Article is stable. There are some minor reverts of IP edits; nothing significant, and not enough to warrant protection.
675:
397:
169:
149:
369:
39:
373:
212:
341:
277:
596:
786:
705:
361:
293:
220:
177:
828:
804:
773:
755:
717:
695:
654:
632:
612:
579:
562:
545:
528:
511:
493:
476:
459:
110:
92:
679:
129:
671:
312:
173:
782:
704:
It has been tagged for referencing concerns since Dec 2013, which is a quick fail criteria
401:
185:
181:
55:
17:
821:
797:
766:
748:
710:
688:
647:
625:
605:
572:
555:
538:
521:
504:
486:
469:
452:
103:
85:
145:
83:
Article has been tagged with sourcing concerns since Dec 2013. Starting GAR.
32:
683:
831:
807:
790:
776:
758:
720:
698:
657:
635:
615:
582:
565:
548:
531:
514:
496:
479:
462:
113:
95:
595:
There are too many images for the article, and some are low quality,
674:
does not appropriately summarise article. There are too many images
764:
No progress has been made. WikiProjects have been contacted.
742:
738:
74:
43:
601:File:View of Sabarmati Riverfront, Ahmedabad.jpg
682:. There are some short paragraphs and sections
570:Possibly biased language has been dealt with.
8:
396:B. Images are provided if possible and are
781:I have added sources wherever necessary.--
7:
519:Main areas of interest are covered.
319:Fair representation without bias:
156:, or spelling and grammar errors:
24:
425:
405:
385:
345:
320:
297:
281:
256:
240:
235:B. Citation to reliable sources
224:
193:
157:
426:
450:There is a reference section.
1:
221:appropriate reference section
553:Citing has been sorted out.
406:
386:
346:
321:
298:
282:
257:
241:
225:
194:
158:
848:
96:20:21, 30 April 2014 (UTC)
739:article as of August 2006
378:valid fair use rationales
365:to illustrate the topic?
832:21:37, 28 May 2014 (UTC)
808:09:30, 28 May 2014 (UTC)
791:06:56, 27 May 2014 (UTC)
777:07:49, 26 May 2014 (UTC)
583:09:29, 28 May 2014 (UTC)
566:09:29, 28 May 2014 (UTC)
549:16:41, 27 May 2014 (UTC)
114:21:37, 28 May 2014 (UTC)
759:14:26, 6 May 2014 (UTC)
721:10:24, 6 May 2014 (UTC)
699:10:21, 6 May 2014 (UTC)
658:13:59, 6 May 2014 (UTC)
636:13:59, 6 May 2014 (UTC)
616:10:42, 6 May 2014 (UTC)
532:11:03, 6 May 2014 (UTC)
515:10:52, 6 May 2014 (UTC)
497:10:39, 6 May 2014 (UTC)
480:10:36, 6 May 2014 (UTC)
463:10:25, 6 May 2014 (UTC)
440:Comments on GA criteria
400:to the topic, and have
139:reasonably well written
678:. Images squeeze text
597:File:Chandola lake.jpg
271:broad in its coverage
253:No original research
676:WP:IMAGE RELEVANCE
208:factually accurate
402:suitable captions
380:are provided for
839:
824:
800:
769:
751:
728:General comments
713:
691:
650:
628:
608:
575:
558:
541:
524:
507:
489:
472:
455:
429:
428:
409:
408:
389:
388:
382:non-free content
374:copyright status
349:
348:
324:
323:
301:
300:
285:
284:
260:
259:
244:
243:
228:
227:
197:
196:
161:
160:
106:
88:
79:
70:
51:
847:
846:
842:
841:
840:
838:
837:
836:
822:
798:
767:
749:
735:
730:
711:
689:
648:
626:
606:
573:
556:
539:
536:Images now OK.
522:
505:
487:
470:
453:
442:
237:where necessary
172:compliance for
122:
104:
86:
60:
37:
31:
29:
27:GA Reassessment
22:
21:
20:
12:
11:
5:
845:
843:
835:
834:
815:
814:
813:
812:
811:
810:
734:
731:
729:
726:
725:
724:
701:
667:
666:
662:
661:
639:
619:
591:
590:
586:
585:
568:
551:
534:
517:
499:
482:
465:
447:
446:
441:
438:
437:
436:
435:
434:
433:
432:
424:Pass or Fail:
416:
415:
414:
413:
412:
394:
393:
392:
368:A. Images are
356:
355:
354:
353:
352:
331:
330:
329:
328:
327:
308:
307:
306:
305:
304:
290:
289:
288:
267:
266:
265:
264:
263:
249:
248:
247:
233:
232:
231:
204:
203:
202:
201:
200:
182:words to watch
166:
165:
164:
121:
118:
117:
116:
80:
28:
25:
23:
18:Talk:Ahmedabad
15:
14:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
844:
833:
830:
829:
826:
825:
817:
816:
809:
806:
805:
802:
801:
794:
793:
792:
788:
784:
780:
779:
778:
775:
774:
771:
770:
763:
762:
761:
760:
757:
756:
753:
752:
744:
740:
732:
727:
723:
722:
719:
718:
715:
714:
707:
702:
700:
697:
696:
693:
692:
685:
681:
677:
673:
669:
668:
664:
663:
660:
659:
656:
655:
652:
651:
642:
641:
638:
637:
634:
633:
630:
629:
620:
618:
617:
614:
613:
610:
609:
602:
598:
593:
592:
588:
587:
584:
581:
580:
577:
576:
569:
567:
564:
563:
560:
559:
552:
550:
547:
546:
543:
542:
535:
533:
530:
529:
526:
525:
518:
516:
513:
512:
509:
508:
500:
498:
495:
494:
491:
490:
483:
481:
478:
477:
474:
473:
466:
464:
461:
460:
457:
456:
449:
448:
444:
443:
439:
431:
430:
423:
422:
420:
417:
411:
410:
403:
399:
395:
391:
390:
383:
379:
375:
371:
367:
366:
364:
363:
357:
351:
350:
343:
339:
338:
336:
332:
326:
325:
318:
317:
315:
314:
309:
303:
302:
295:
291:
287:
286:
279:
278:Major aspects
275:
274:
272:
268:
262:
261:
254:
250:
246:
245:
238:
234:
230:
229:
222:
218:
217:
215:
214:
209:
205:
199:
198:
191:
187:
183:
179:
175:
171:
167:
163:
162:
155:
151:
147:
144:A. Prose is "
143:
142:
140:
136:
135:
134:
133:
131:
128:review – see
127:
119:
115:
112:
111:
108:
107:
100:
99:
98:
97:
94:
93:
90:
89:
81:
78:
77:
73:
68:
64:
59:
58:
54:
49:
45:
41:
36:
35:
26:
19:
827:
820:
803:
796:
772:
765:
754:
747:
736:
716:
709:
703:
694:
687:
670:MoS issues.
653:
646:
643:
640:
631:
624:
621:
611:
604:
594:
578:
571:
561:
554:
544:
537:
527:
520:
510:
503:
492:
485:
475:
468:
458:
451:
418:
359:
334:
311:
270:
211:
207:
138:
132:for criteria
124:
123:
109:
102:
91:
84:
82:
75:
71:
57:Article talk
56:
52:
33:
30:
783:Skr15081997
372:with their
152:", without
44:visual edit
219:A. Has an
213:verifiable
342:edit wars
823:SilkTork
799:SilkTork
768:SilkTork
750:SilkTork
712:SilkTork
706:WP:GANO?
690:SilkTork
684:MOS:BODY
680:WP:MOSIM
649:SilkTork
627:SilkTork
607:SilkTork
574:SilkTork
557:SilkTork
540:SilkTork
523:SilkTork
506:SilkTork
488:SilkTork
471:SilkTork
454:SilkTork
398:relevant
360:contain
358:Does it
154:copyvios
130:WP:WIAGA
120:Tick box
105:SilkTork
87:SilkTork
733:On hold
672:WP:Lead
419:Overall
344:, etc:
313:neutral
294:Focused
186:fiction
150:concise
67:history
48:history
34:Article
376:, and
370:tagged
362:images
335:stable
333:Is it
310:Is it
269:Is it
206:Is it
188:, and
178:layout
137:Is it
101:Keep.
589:Query
190:lists
146:clear
76:Watch
16:<
787:talk
743:this
665:Fail
445:Pass
210:and
174:lead
148:and
63:edit
40:edit
340:No
292:B.
276:A.
251:C.
170:MoS
168:B.
789:)
708:.
686:.
599:,
421::
404::
384::
337:?
316:?
296::
280::
273:?
255::
239::
223::
216:?
192::
184:,
180:,
176:,
141:?
126:GA
65:|
46:|
42:|
785:(
72:·
69:)
61:(
53:·
50:)
38:(
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.