Talk:Forty Hadith of Ruhullah Khomeini

820:: from a group of our teachers, from Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn Khalid, from more than one transmitter, from ‘Ali ibn Asbat, from Ahmad ibn ‘Umar al-Hallal, from ‘Ali ibn Suwayd, from Abu al-Hasan al-’Awwal . ‘Ali ibn Suwayd says, ‘I asked him concerning the utterance of God Almighty: And whoever puts his trust in God, then God suffices him (65:3).’ The Imam said: “There are various degrees of trust in God. Of them one is that you should put your trust in God in all your affairs, being well-pleased with whatever God does to you, knowing for certain that he does not cease in His goodness and grace towards you, and that the command therein rests with Him. So put your trust in God, leaving that to Him and relying upon Him in regard to that and everything other than that! 1466:. The reasoning will be that no Sunni writes books about this subject, and any Sunni who does, cannot have enough information. However in a genre where there is overlap such as this Shias will have one view and Sunnis have another, so the best bet will be to get a neutral source, otherwise there will always be sources claiming the exact opposite and edit warring will occur with well meaning people trying to "improve" the article. 385: 320: 191: 246: 236: 218: 2083: 715:, the chain of narrator is so important. Ayatollah khomeini nominated to Hadith, so it needs to nominated the persons that confirm Hadithes. At the book is nominated to whole persons that transmitted hadithes one by one. I think there isn't problem that at the article is said that Imam khomeini get this Hadith from his teacher. 1674: 1488:

the time). In this particular case, I see no issue in saying something along the lines of 'the most relevant Shia collections are... while Sunni Islam favours...'. To scramble for an outside source, which could again be attacked as being too close to one side, seems a lot of effort to me with little gain. --

2060:

As we read at source, ‘’ The ’40 Hadith’ is in fact Imam Khomeini’s pamphlet which he used to teach his students at Feiziyeh School in Qom Seminary. ‘’ The forty initially had been a pamphlet that Khomeini collect Hadiths in it and taught them to his student, then after years he decided to published

1317:

is collection of Hadiths about ethics, religious beliefs, and other subjects and has more than 1000 Hadiths. Nobody said that Al-Khisal is a book of just forty Hadith and you can not find a source for approving it. In this book, there is a Hadith from Prophet about gathering and memorizing Hadiths by

452:

DYK is a secondary process, article editing is primary. Although the people at DYK might get irritated and fail the nomination if the article changes substantially over a longer period... we're far from that. I'd suggest that before we continue reverting each other, let's bring the contentious issues

1936:

this page is about the book. It's so important about one book that is translated to other language. It is not logical way to nominate to languages that book is translated to them in background part. At the back ground part we explain why Imam khomini authored the frothy Hadith book. Can you explain

1647:

is not a reliable source for a book by Imam Khomeini. The thing is, too, that while Knowledge (XXG) does not require a source in English, I cannot help you with Persian sources. I could stuff them into Google Translate, but the important part: evaluation how reliable and independent it is, cannot be

1596:

Whoever from my Ummah memorizes forty hadith, Allah will raise him on Resurrection Day as a jurisprudent and scholar. Some of the prominent Islamic scholars of the School of Ahl al-Bayt (a) such as Shahid Awwal Shaykh Shams al-Din Muhammad ibn Makki al-Amili, Shaykh Baha al-Din Muhammad al-Amili and

1784:

thank you for clearing that up. We can now remove this mention of al-Khisal as being a hoax. I have already given one source which shows that Al-Khisal has nothing to do with motivating people to write books on 40 hadith, rather it is Imam Nawawi's book that is the first of the genre which inspired

1707:

in Encyclopedia of Islam clearly shows that Imam Nawawi's collection was the one which was the earliest and the most important work in this genre, therefore this work by Nawawi should be the one which will be called as the "work inspiring others" to do the same. We can clearly see that the sentence

1487:

I'm vaguely aware of the differences. My problem is, is it realistic to find a neutral source? If there are conflicting views we can display both. If a topic is only relevant to one side, we can hint at that in the text (although, without a reliable source saying so, it would be OR. We do that all

1004:

is collection of Hadiths about ethics, religious beliefs, and other subjects and has more than 1000 Hadiths. In this book, there is a Hadith from Prophet about gathering and memorizing Hadiths by Muslims. The author of article refereed to the Hadith that mentioned in the Al-Khisal. I think that the

751:

it is better , first read the book then give your opinion! If you take look at the book, you find one part of book is about chain of narrators! if you have a little knowledge of Hadith, you can find that the chain of narrator is important part. so according this reason and also it is important that

1234:

As I said, I am not sure about Khisal being the source of that tradition. But that is a moot point, the sentence that scholars were motivated by this tradition of Khisal is an OR statement or a hoax. For there have been numerous other collections which were never inspired by Khisal, and we have no

730:

It does not matter what you think, your opinion is useless here, as is mine. We will be looking at what Khomeini has written and you can clearly see that he has said nothing about the chain of narration in the entirety of the book, because he knows that discussing chain of narration is useless.

1963:

This sentences, ‘’’In 2009, the book was translated into French with the assistance of Iran's Cultural Center in Paris and the translation was published by the Institute for Compilation and Publication of Ayatollah Khomeini's Works. Four years later, the book was translated into Kurdish by Ali

892:

When there are more things such as pictures in article, we want to clear the topic and content. So, useing one Hadith from the book, help readers understand more about Hadith structure. When we don't use Hadith, readers must go to the book and see one Hadith. I think that one example Hadith is

1174:

So, is the expression "Whoever from my Ummah memorizes forty hadith, Allah will raise him on Resurrection Day as a jurisprudent and scholar" in the Al-Khisal or not? And if yes, is this expression (itself a hadith, I guess) the reason to compile exactly forty of them, or not? Because neither

967:

The motivation for Islamic scholars to compile collections of forty hadith into books goes back to Al-Khisal ("The Book of Characters"), written by Al-Shaykh al-Saduq. He writes that Mohammad said: "Whoever from my Ummah memorizes forty hadith, Allah will raise him on Resurrection Day as a

1597:

Mulla Muhammad Taqi Majlisi, have compiled Arbain Hadith on various topics. Imam Khomeini, however, focused on akhlaq (ethics) and taught his selection of Forty Hadith as part of his lectures on ethics to students in the holy city of Qom. He compiled the Arbain hadith in 1358 AH/1939

1550:

I don't want to be rude here, but what you just wrote is outright hilarious. Believe me, I do not mean to disrespect you, but you have just made me laugh even though I have been moody the entire day. Let me just quickly explain why your view is wrong here. According to

470:

cannot understand my mean, when two copy editor reviewed the article and edited, then you undid that edits, without any reason or acceptable reason. if you want to improve article by edits, there is no problem, but you undid the edits of copy editor!!!please be polite.

1457:

Shia scholars think that Sunni collections are lies, Sunni scholars say that Shia collections are all lies. Now sourcing a claim to a particular sect works quite well when we are in a genre specific to that sect, for example if a Shia writes a book on, lets assume,

922:

The main text of the book containes the interpretations of hadith, so it is better to nominate to interpretation as Hadith, but there is two problem, first the interpretation is too long and second, it is meaningless to use interpretation without appropriate

1875: 498:

is a secondary process. I would suggest, however, that basic editing and the nomination can work as 'hand and glove.' Improve the article, while moving it along so that it qualifies for DYK. That's my opinion. We can work together in common cause.

762:

In the preface to Forty Hadith, Khomeini writes that he had permission to relate hadith on the authority of three Islamic scholars, who he calls his teachers: Shaykh Muhammad Reza Najafi Isfahani, Shaykh Abbas Qummi, and Allamah Sayyid Muhsin Amin

636:

1219:

Somewhat hard to believe a relatively new editor made this up on one fine day. That would be a monster of a hoax, even implicitly backed up by a hadith. Is there no explanation of the number? In other texts? In Khomeini's book? In Nawawi's works?

1318:

Muslims. Muslim scholars use this Hadith for write collection of forty Hadith books. So, the author of the article refereed to the Hadith that mentioned in the Al-Khisal. I think that the sentence has grammar issue and is better rewrite.

735:

he wants to give a controversial hadith he says that the chain is strong, nothing more. Even there he does not discuss the chain. So discussing the chain is useless for this book because the author did not intend for it to be discussed.

1201:

the quote is in itself a tradition and present in many books of tradition. It may be present in the Khisal, but still it does not specify any number etc. So saying that it inspired people to gather hadith in groups of forty is pure

153: 1737: 1704: 1678: 431:

just how is one supposed to know that a DYK is in process? Furthermore there are no rules saying that an article cannot be edited while it is going through DYK. Thirdly anyone can edit this article. Better read the policy at

609:

There is a strong tradition in Islam that any Muslim learns and memorizes at least forty sayings transmitted (Hadith) from the Prophet Muhammad. So, in different period of time, scholars gathered 40 Hadiths in different

409: 377: 535:

There is no problem so far. Due to Knowledge (XXG)'s byzantine editing interface it happens all the time that good edits are eliminated by later, likewise good, edits. Nothing is lost as all versions are in the

479:

about the clarifying the sentence, you are right, he says those scholar confirm the Accuracy of Hadithes! about the quote i have explaned my reason at your talk page, isn't it better to put this on the article

860:

i decided to add one Hadith of the book to the article. we write article to introduce the book, isn't it? so the attaching one Hadith of the book do this job in the best way. I would never do that to decorate

1299:

A source is needed to show that AL KHISAL is a book of just forty hadith and not a book of 1000. Furthermore a source is required to show that Al-Khisal was motivated by the hadith which mentions the number

986:

shows that it is not a book of forty hadith at all, rather it has more than 1000. Furthermore there is no mention of this book being the inspiration behind the said genre of hadith. So this information is a

408:. the article is nominated for DYK, and during this process, the issue of the article is discussed and solved. So if have opinion about article or deit, firs explain it on the talk page of it or here or at 1439:

I don't understand this consequence; you cannot possibly discount all Shia sources? You would, for neutrality, also have to forbid Sunni sources, and who else writes about the popularity of Islamic books?

1536:

I said your information is incomplete. If Shaykh‐i Bahāʾī's book is not most popular book of this genre, who has popular book? It is your opinion and we must the sources based on Knowledge (XXG)'s rules.

710:

is one version of the book. Imam khomeini wrote the book by this style, first explained the chain of narrator, then nominated to Hadith and finally he gathered his personal interpretation. According to

1733:

Thanks for letting me in! Well, what I see here are two reliable sources exactly supporting the claim that the tradition of authoring 40 Hadiths books stems from a Hadith by the prophet of Islam. 1)

1385: 1136: 911:

Imam Khomeini's book contains interpretations of hadith, not just the hadith themselves. I assume the hadith are well-known, why not quote something from the interpretation done by Khomeini?

147: 44: 684:? etc etc. All this will require a person to show a good chain of narration. However this book makes no such claim, rather it is the exact opposite. Khomenie himself says that it is his 1681:

of The Encyclopaedia of Islam, New Edition: Supplement, Parts 1-2. I saw this relation at other sources but they are more reliable. Because you can't read sources in persian, I found

1799:

You're welcome. Although Nawawi's book is a pioneer of the genre, it's not regarded as a motivation for others, rather it is the very Hadith by the prophet motivating the Muslims.

1964:

Husseini and published by the Islamic Republic of Iran’s cultural attaché in Turkey. It has also been translated into English and Urdu’’’ have nothing to do with the background.

1648:

done like that. We're not doubting the hadith itself, of course, but we're looking for a source that relates the '40' in this hadith to the '40' in many hadith collections. --

2121: 571:

I reinstated that explanation, as from my perspective it is not obvious where this number is coming from. Sorry for not bringing it up here on the talk page beforehand. --

292: 1712:

is not present in either of your sources, rather one of the sources given says that this book is not the motivation, rather names another work as the motivation. Regards

2022:

Your questions are clearly showing that, in my opinion. There's no problem with that. Not all users are expert in all subjects! I explain them for copy editor and solve.

1710:

The motivation for Islamic scholars to compile collections of forty hadith into books goes back to Al-Khisal ("The Book of Characters"), written by Al-Shaykh al-Saduq.

1673:

I'm sorry for the late in response. I found thiese source that indicate the '40' in this hadith of Mohammad prophet is related to the '40' in many hadith collections,

1297:

The motivation for Islamic scholars to compile collections of forty hadith into books goes back to Al-Khisal ("The Book of Characters"), written by Al-Shaykh al-Saduq.

979:

The motivation for Islamic scholars to compile collections of forty hadith into books goes back to Al-Khisal ("The Book of Characters"), written by Al-Shaykh al-Saduq.

692:? because he is not debating the authenticity of traditions, he just collected 40 traditions and explained them, the book is about explanation, not narration. Regards 1921:

There is no need for a reception section, as there is nothing to put in there. Translations may be an accurate section heading to use, but reception is just not OK.

2036:

You would have to convince both FreeatlastChitchat and me, or else the arguments continue between us two. I'm happy to help. Let's work towards consensus. Cheers,

1743:(It's the translation of the original text). By the way, please note that "The motivation for Islamic scholars to compile collections of forty hadith into books 79: 1562:

is just not right here. You must provide a source, and a neutral source in this article, which says this. Again, no disrespect, just pointing out the rules.

1820:

I ahve added the information that the very hadith is the motivation, and that Nawawi was the pioneer. I have removed mention of Al-Khisal as it was a hoax.

2131: 2116: 373: 849: 298: 85: 1389: 1381: 1140: 1132: 1115: 752:

prominant scholars like Shaykh Muhammad Reza Najafi Isfahani, Shaykh Abbas Qummi, and Allamah Sayyid Muhsin Amin al-Amil confirmed this Hadith.

168: 1367:

A source is needed which says that these guys collected forty hadith into collections and thier collections are the most popular of this genre.

135: 2061:

it as forty Hadith book. So this sentence is wrong: ‘’ Khomeini also used the book to teach his students at Feyziyeh School in Qom Seminary’’

1616: 30: 1603:

and i wrote this part of article according to this source. I have no time for searching English, but between Persian reliable source like

968:

jurisprudent and scholar". The most popular compilations were collected by Shahid Awwal, Shaykh‐i Bahāʾī, and Mulla Muhammad Taqi Majlisi.

707: 2126: 268: 99: 352: 24: 129: 104: 20: 1600: 766: 412:. why do you edit the article, after copy editor? please stop the editing this article and let the process of DYK is done. thanks 1080:

You are aware that I replied to a previous version of your answer, so first think then type, if you are not able to think, then

825:

I must admit that I do not see how the quote corroborates the article. It is nice to have quotes, but not just as decoration. --

74: 1594:

The incentive behind this work was of course, the famous saying of the Prophet as quoted by Shaykh Saduq in his book al-Khisal:

817: 1741:"This hadith had been the core axis and the most important motivation and factor for muslims to write 'Arbaeen hadith' books. 453:

here to the talk page and discuss. I'm sure everyone had good reasons for their action; maybe we can reach consensus. Cheers,

198: 125: 259: 223: 65: 1870:

The original version of Forty Hadith, written in Persian, was first published in 1980, a year after the Islamic Revolution.

857: 267:-related articles on Knowledge (XXG). If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join 175: 2013: 1926: 1883: 1825: 1790: 1717: 1567: 1517: 1471: 1423: 1350: 1240: 1210: 1089: 1047: 881: 741: 697: 441: 1703:

both of your sources are against the sentences given in the text, thus they are making the case against this stronger.

1063:

Where I said this statement? It is better to see last revision of my answer. First see, then think, and at last answer.

1180: 1166: 1609:

Whoever from my Ummah memorizes forty hadith, Allah will raise him on Resurrection Day as a jurisprudent and scholar

1989:

I can help you for clearing the content. I think that FreeatlastChitchat's information in this topic is incomplete.

511: 109: 2008:

well lets see what your complete information can provide us. Please explain the "hoaxes" present in the article.

645:- not sure if I am correct in this, but if so then it is relevant for the article on the book, in my opinion. As 1365:

The most popular compilations were collected by Shahid Awwal, Shaykh‐i Bahāʾī, and Mulla Muhammad Taqi Majlisi.

1111:

The most popular compilations were collected by Shahid Awwal, Shaykh‐i Bahāʾī, and Mulla Muhammad Taqi Majlisi.

141: 204: 2009: 1922: 1896: 1879: 1821: 1786: 1713: 1563: 1533: 1513: 1482: 1467: 1434: 1419: 1346: 1236: 1206: 1085: 1058: 1043: 877: 737: 693: 467: 437: 403: 1612: 1414:

book of this genre. Secondly For such a claim, the source should be neutral. That means the source should

1418:

be a shia source because the genre of "Forty Hadith" literature is made up of both Shia and Sunni books.

55: 876:

Don't worry we are not blaming you for "decorating" lol. We are just saying that this quote is useless.

769:. what is the problem to adding the sentence to article? thanks for your patient. I'm busy too this day. 760:

this article about the book and we must collect reliable information of the book. i wrote this sentence

505: 335: 70: 1462:. Well we can use Shia sources to say that this book is the best and the most popular in the genre of 2066: 1969: 1950: 1904: 1690: 1632: 928: 866: 795: 774: 720: 590: 485: 417: 1384:

has important book with title of Forty Hadith (in Arabic:الاربعون حدیثا). The cover of this book is

1135:

has important book with title of Forty Hadith (in Arabic:الاربعون حدیثا). The cover of this book is

2097: 1839: 1804: 1768: 853: 161: 1552: 2041: 1878:

it was published in 1940. Furthermore the soruce used for 1980 publication is highly unreliable.

1653: 1493: 1445: 1262: 1225: 1188: 830: 654: 642: 576: 545: 458: 2101: 2070: 2045: 2031: 2017: 1998: 1973: 1954: 1930: 1908: 1887: 1843: 1829: 1808: 1794: 1772: 1721: 1694: 1657: 1636: 1571: 1545: 1521: 1497: 1475: 1449: 1427: 1401: 1354: 1327: 1266: 1244: 1229: 1214: 1192: 1152: 1093: 1072: 1051: 1014: 932: 902: 885: 870: 834: 799: 778: 745: 724: 701: 658: 619: 594: 580: 549: 518: 489: 462: 445: 421: 319: 2027: 1994: 1541: 1397: 1323: 1148: 1068: 1010: 898: 615: 537: 358: 51: 1747:

goe back to Al-Khisal by Al-Shaykh al-Saduq," rather it goes back to a hadith which exist in

366: 672:

the author to have the chain of narration. the simple explanation is that if a writer says

540:. I'm sure FreeatlastChitchat intended to improve the article, just like the rest of us. -- 500: 495: 433: 2076: 2062: 1965: 1946: 1900: 1728: 1700: 1686: 1685:

who know English and Persian very well. I thought he can help you. Thanks for your patiant

1628: 1252: 1034: 924: 862: 791: 770: 716: 668:

This book is not a book of narrations, rather it is a book of interpretation. It does not

646: 586: 481: 428: 413: 1336: 1203: 674:

This is a book which contains hadith that came from the Prophet to me through some people

1560:

If Shaykh‐i Bahāʾī's book is not most popular book of this genre, who has popular book?

1118:'s article we do not find any mention that he is a renowned writer of hadith literature. 2093: 1835: 1815: 1800: 1779: 1764: 1682: 1620: 712: 361:

is a collection of personal interpretations of 40 traditions attributed to the prophet

1392:

section written He composed works on tafsir, hadith, grammar and fiqh (jurisprudence).

1143:

section written He composed works on tafsir, hadith, grammar and fiqh (jurisprudence).

649:

confirms this interpretation above, I would favour to re-add this information, too. --

2110: 2037: 1986: 1940: 1756: 1668: 1649: 1587: 1489: 1454: 1441: 1376: 1309: 1286: 1258: 1221: 1198: 1184: 1127: 996: 960: 841: 826: 787: 755: 665: 650: 604: 572: 541: 474: 454: 2023: 2005: 1990: 1677:

is an article published in a scientific journal indexed in ISC. I can referred to

1537: 1407: 1393: 1332: 1319: 1176: 1162: 1144: 1077: 1064: 1039: 1028: 1020: 1006: 894: 611: 251: 340: 1735:"This type of work has arisen, from one aspect, from the hadith which says..." 241: 1748: 1314: 1024: 1001: 983: 330: 1624: 641:

I read this sentence in a way that Khomeini describes the last part of the

362: 1604: 1031:, who never ever written a book called Forty Hadith. So your statement 378:

Template:Did you know nominations/Forty Hadith (by Ayatollah Khomeini )

790:'s opinion and my reason that explaned at above, I re-added sentence. 952:

Discussion of hoax information that is now summarized in one comment

972:

The following hoaxes have been introduced in this small paragraph.

235: 217: 264: 1558:

must be the one who provides a source for a statement. So saying

1619:

is nominated that this Hadith is seen at books like, al-Khesal,

1644: 314: 184: 15: 1289:

Quite true. Let me put the statements together in one list.

1161:

The accurate information about this will be found by reading

383: 1038:

is just not true. Present to us any source which says that

1410:

Firstly your source does not show that this is one of the

197:

This article has not yet been rated on Knowledge (XXG)'s

2090: 1257:

can you please state the source of this information? --

376:. The nomination discussion and review may be seen at 160: 1751:

and may be found in some other Hadiths collections.

263:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of 1033:Also, author of Al-Khisal has a book with title of 174: 1345:muslims are inspired by the hadith in Al-khisal". 297:This article has not yet received a rating on the 1592:I'm sorry. I'm so busy these days. This sentence 1291:Sources are required for the following statements 1005:sentence has grammar issue and is better rewrite. 1460:The ways one can beat oneself up during muharram 1023:again you are trying to put in hoaxes. The book 943:Hoax information about the first collections etc 33:for general discussion of the article's subject. 1945:what is your opinion?thanks for your patient. 688:of traditions. So no one is going to ask him 374:Knowledge (XXG):Recent additions/2016/January 8: 852:. i picked up Hadith from this book. like 947: 212: 190: 188: 2122:Unknown-importance Islam-related articles 1183:contains an explanation of the number. -- 1169:is the best representation of this genre. 343:). The text of the entry was as follows: 1834:This is in accordance with the sources. 585:There aren't any Hadith at the article! 436:before you land yourself in hot water. 384: 214: 1740: 1734: 676:, then the people around him may ask, 2132:Knowledge (XXG) Did you know articles 372:A record of the entry may be seen at 7: 964:The following information is a hoax 257:This article is within the scope of 731:However when, during the course of 628:The permission to relate the hadith 203:It is of interest to the following 23:for discussing improvements to the 1899:. This sentence should be removed. 1874:is a hoax. Firstly according to a 1611:was confirmed by dominant scholar 14: 2117:Unassessed Islam-related articles 1862:Hoax information about publishing 327:Forty Hadith of Ruhullah Khomeini 277:Knowledge (XXG):WikiProject Islam 50:New to Knowledge (XXG)? Welcome! 25:Forty Hadith of Ruhullah Khomeini 2081: 1108:similarly we see that the claim 690:How did this tradition reach you 318: 244: 234: 216: 189: 45:Click here to start a new topic. 1235:source backing up this claim. 1042:wrote a book on forty hadith. 818:Muhammad ibn Ya'qub al-Kulayni 329:appeared on Knowledge (XXG)'s 1: 271:and see a list of open tasks. 42:Put new text under old text. 2102:05:46, 18 January 2016 (UTC) 2071:05:46, 14 January 2016 (UTC) 1974:05:43, 14 January 2016 (UTC) 1909:05:42, 14 January 2016 (UTC) 1844:13:22, 11 January 2016 (UTC) 1830:07:53, 11 January 2016 (UTC) 1809:07:41, 11 January 2016 (UTC) 1795:07:36, 11 January 2016 (UTC) 1773:07:28, 11 January 2016 (UTC) 1722:05:36, 11 January 2016 (UTC) 1695:05:23, 11 January 2016 (UTC) 976:According to this paragraph 933:19:57, 13 January 2016 (UTC) 848:you can check the Hadith at 800:16:47, 13 January 2016 (UTC) 2046:14:35, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 2032:13:22, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 2018:13:01, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1999:12:31, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1955:19:37, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1931:03:28, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1888:03:28, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1658:20:28, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1637:19:27, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1605:Islamic world Encyclopedia 1572:14:23, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1546:14:15, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1522:13:09, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1498:20:20, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1476:14:42, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1450:14:33, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1428:13:51, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1402:13:39, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1355:14:04, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1328:13:55, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1267:11:31, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1245:11:22, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1230:11:08, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1215:10:47, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1193:10:45, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1153:13:39, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1114:is a hoax. When we look at 1094:13:51, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1073:13:43, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1052:13:30, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 1015:13:17, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 903:12:58, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 886:10:09, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 871:09:24, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 844:, the quote is unnecessary. 835:21:20, 4 January 2016 (UTC) 779:17:52, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 746:10:15, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 725:09:07, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 702:03:28, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 678:Who gave you this knowledge 659:21:20, 4 January 2016 (UTC) 620:12:40, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 595:08:45, 5 January 2016 (UTC) 581:21:20, 4 January 2016 (UTC) 567:Why are there forty hadith? 550:21:00, 4 January 2016 (UTC) 519:20:39, 4 January 2016 (UTC) 490:20:21, 4 January 2016 (UTC) 463:18:54, 4 January 2016 (UTC) 446:18:11, 4 January 2016 (UTC) 422:15:20, 4 January 2016 (UTC) 339:column on 23 January 2016 ( 2148: 2127:WikiProject Islam articles 1343:source that confirms that 1181:Imam Nawawi's Forty Hadith 1167:Imam Nawawi's Forty Hadith 812:The relevant sentence was 632:The relevant sentence was 299:project's importance scale 280:Template:WikiProject Islam 982:However a simple look at 682:Who is the first narrator 296: 229: 211: 80:Be welcoming to newcomers 1897:user: FreeatlastChitchat 1464:Selfharm During Muharram 808:The quote from the book 686:personal interpretation 468:user:FreeatlastChitchat 1872: 1613:Muhammad Baqir Majlisi 1116:Bahāʾ al-dīn al-ʿĀmilī 1113: 981: 970: 823: 639: 389: 283:Islam-related articles 75:avoid personal attacks 1868: 1109: 977: 965: 814: 634: 410:nominated page of DYK 387: 100:Neutral point of view 105:No original research 1390:Imami Jurisprudence 1141:Imami Jurisprudence 2010:FreeatlastChitchat 1923:FreeatlastChitchat 1880:FreeatlastChitchat 1822:FreeatlastChitchat 1787:FreeatlastChitchat 1714:FreeatlastChitchat 1564:FreeatlastChitchat 1534:FreeatlastChitchat 1514:FreeatlastChitchat 1483:FreeatlastChitchat 1468:FreeatlastChitchat 1435:FreeatlastChitchat 1420:FreeatlastChitchat 1347:FreeatlastChitchat 1335:what you wrote is 1237:FreeatlastChitchat 1207:FreeatlastChitchat 1086:FreeatlastChitchat 1059:FreeatlastChitchat 1044:FreeatlastChitchat 878:FreeatlastChitchat 738:FreeatlastChitchat 694:FreeatlastChitchat 643:chain of narrators 438:FreeatlastChitchat 404:FreeatlastChitchat 390: 359:Ayatollah Khomeini 199:content assessment 86:dispute resolution 47: 1917:Reception section 1645:imam-khomeini.com 1282: 1281: 562:Contested content 394: 393: 313: 312: 309: 308: 305: 304: 260:WikiProject Islam 183: 182: 66:Assume good faith 43: 2139: 2089: 2085: 2084: 1944: 1819: 1783: 1761:for notification 1760: 1732: 1672: 1591: 1486: 1438: 1380: 1339:. Please give a 1313: 1256: 1249:In other words, 1165:which says that 1131: 1062: 1000: 948: 759: 608: 517: 507:7&6=thirteen 478: 407: 386: 367:The Twelve Imams 322: 315: 285: 284: 281: 278: 275: 254: 249: 248: 247: 238: 231: 230: 220: 213: 194: 193: 192: 185: 179: 178: 164: 95:Article policies 16: 2147: 2146: 2142: 2141: 2140: 2138: 2137: 2136: 2107: 2106: 2082: 2080: 2058: 1984: 1938: 1919: 1876:reliable source 1864: 1813: 1777: 1754: 1726: 1666: 1599:is referred to 1585: 1480: 1432: 1382:Shaykh‐i Bahāʾī 1374: 1307: 1283: 1250: 1133:Shaykh‐i Bahāʾī 1125: 1056: 994: 953: 945: 810: 753: 630: 602: 569: 564: 504: 472: 401: 399: 388:Knowledge (XXG) 282: 279: 276: 273: 272: 250: 245: 243: 121: 116: 115: 114: 91: 61: 12: 11: 5: 2145: 2143: 2135: 2134: 2129: 2124: 2119: 2109: 2108: 2105: 2104: 2057: 2054: 2053: 2052: 2051: 2050: 2049: 2048: 1983: 1980: 1979: 1978: 1977: 1976: 1958: 1957: 1918: 1915: 1914: 1913: 1912: 1911: 1863: 1860: 1859: 1858: 1857: 1856: 1855: 1854: 1853: 1852: 1851: 1850: 1849: 1848: 1847: 1846: 1724: 1683:user:Mhhossein 1661: 1660: 1643:The thing is, 1625:Kashf al-ẓunūn 1621:Bihar al-Anwar 1601:this reference 1583: 1582: 1581: 1580: 1579: 1578: 1577: 1576: 1575: 1574: 1511: 1510: 1509: 1508: 1507: 1506: 1505: 1504: 1503: 1502: 1501: 1500: 1369: 1368: 1361: 1360: 1359: 1358: 1330: 1302: 1301: 1280: 1279: 1278: 1277: 1276: 1275: 1274: 1273: 1272: 1271: 1270: 1269: 1171: 1170: 1158: 1157: 1156: 1155: 1120: 1119: 1105: 1104: 1103: 1102: 1101: 1100: 1099: 1098: 1097: 1096: 1027:is written by 989: 988: 955: 954: 951: 946: 944: 941: 940: 939: 938: 937: 936: 935: 915: 914: 913: 912: 906: 905: 889: 888: 846: 845: 809: 806: 805: 804: 803: 802: 786:according to 749: 748: 713:Hadith studies 705: 704: 629: 626: 625: 624: 623: 622: 568: 565: 563: 560: 559: 558: 557: 556: 555: 554: 553: 552: 526: 525: 524: 523: 522: 521: 449: 448: 398: 395: 392: 391: 381: 371: 370: 323: 311: 310: 307: 306: 303: 302: 295: 289: 288: 286: 269:the discussion 256: 255: 239: 227: 226: 221: 209: 208: 202: 195: 181: 180: 118: 117: 113: 112: 107: 102: 93: 92: 90: 89: 82: 77: 68: 62: 60: 59: 48: 39: 38: 35: 34: 28: 13: 10: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 2144: 2133: 2130: 2128: 2125: 2123: 2120: 2118: 2115: 2114: 2112: 2103: 2099: 2095: 2091: 2088: 2078: 2075: 2074: 2073: 2072: 2068: 2064: 2055: 2047: 2043: 2039: 2035: 2034: 2033: 2029: 2025: 2021: 2020: 2019: 2015: 2011: 2007: 2003: 2002: 2001: 2000: 1996: 1992: 1988: 1981: 1975: 1971: 1967: 1962: 1961: 1960: 1959: 1956: 1952: 1948: 1942: 1937:your reason? 1935: 1934: 1933: 1932: 1928: 1924: 1916: 1910: 1906: 1902: 1898: 1895:I agree with 1894: 1893: 1892: 1891: 1890: 1889: 1885: 1881: 1877: 1871: 1867: 1866:The sentence 1861: 1845: 1841: 1837: 1833: 1832: 1831: 1827: 1823: 1817: 1812: 1811: 1810: 1806: 1802: 1798: 1797: 1796: 1792: 1788: 1781: 1776: 1775: 1774: 1770: 1766: 1762: 1758: 1750: 1746: 1742: 1738: 1736: 1730: 1725: 1723: 1719: 1715: 1711: 1706: 1702: 1698: 1697: 1696: 1692: 1688: 1684: 1680: 1676: 1670: 1665: 1664: 1663: 1662: 1659: 1655: 1651: 1646: 1642: 1641: 1640: 1639: 1638: 1634: 1630: 1626: 1622: 1618: 1614: 1608: 1606: 1602: 1595: 1589: 1573: 1569: 1565: 1561: 1557: 1554: 1549: 1548: 1547: 1543: 1539: 1535: 1532: 1531: 1530: 1529: 1528: 1527: 1526: 1525: 1524: 1523: 1519: 1515: 1499: 1495: 1491: 1484: 1479: 1478: 1477: 1473: 1469: 1465: 1461: 1456: 1453: 1452: 1451: 1447: 1443: 1436: 1431: 1430: 1429: 1425: 1421: 1417: 1413: 1409: 1405: 1404: 1403: 1399: 1395: 1391: 1387: 1383: 1378: 1373: 1372: 1371: 1370: 1366: 1363: 1362: 1357: 1356: 1352: 1348: 1342: 1338: 1334: 1331: 1329: 1325: 1321: 1316: 1311: 1306: 1305: 1304: 1303: 1298: 1295: 1294: 1293: 1292: 1288: 1268: 1264: 1260: 1254: 1248: 1247: 1246: 1242: 1238: 1233: 1232: 1231: 1227: 1223: 1218: 1217: 1216: 1212: 1208: 1205: 1200: 1196: 1195: 1194: 1190: 1186: 1182: 1178: 1173: 1172: 1168: 1164: 1160: 1159: 1154: 1150: 1146: 1142: 1138: 1134: 1129: 1124: 1123: 1122: 1121: 1117: 1112: 1107: 1106: 1095: 1091: 1087: 1083: 1079: 1076: 1075: 1074: 1070: 1066: 1060: 1055: 1054: 1053: 1049: 1045: 1041: 1037: 1036: 1030: 1026: 1022: 1018: 1017: 1016: 1012: 1008: 1003: 998: 993: 992: 991: 990: 985: 980: 975: 974: 973: 969: 963: 962: 957: 956: 950: 949: 942: 934: 930: 926: 921: 920: 919: 918: 917: 916: 910: 909: 908: 907: 904: 900: 896: 891: 890: 887: 883: 879: 875: 874: 873: 872: 868: 864: 859: 855: 851: 843: 840:I agree with 839: 838: 837: 836: 832: 828: 822: 821: 819: 813: 807: 801: 797: 793: 789: 788:user:Pgallert 785: 784: 783: 782: 781: 780: 776: 772: 768: 764: 757: 747: 743: 739: 734: 729: 728: 727: 726: 722: 718: 714: 709: 703: 699: 695: 691: 687: 683: 679: 675: 671: 667: 663: 662: 661: 660: 656: 652: 648: 644: 638: 633: 627: 621: 617: 613: 606: 601: 600: 599: 598: 597: 596: 592: 588: 583: 582: 578: 574: 566: 561: 551: 547: 543: 539: 534: 533: 532: 531: 530: 529: 528: 527: 520: 515: 514: 509: 508: 502: 497: 494:I agree that 493: 492: 491: 487: 483: 480:again?Thanks. 476: 469: 466: 465: 464: 460: 456: 451: 450: 447: 443: 439: 435: 430: 426: 425: 424: 423: 419: 415: 411: 405: 396: 382: 379: 375: 368: 364: 360: 356: 355: 354: 349:... that the 348: 345: 344: 342: 338: 337: 332: 328: 324: 321: 317: 316: 300: 294: 291: 290: 287: 270: 266: 262: 261: 253: 242: 240: 237: 233: 232: 228: 225: 222: 219: 215: 210: 206: 200: 196: 187: 186: 177: 173: 170: 167: 163: 159: 155: 152: 149: 146: 143: 140: 137: 134: 131: 127: 124: 123:Find sources: 120: 119: 111: 110:Verifiability 108: 106: 103: 101: 98: 97: 96: 87: 83: 81: 78: 76: 72: 69: 67: 64: 63: 57: 53: 52:Learn to edit 49: 46: 41: 40: 37: 36: 32: 26: 22: 18: 17: 2086: 2059: 1985: 1920: 1873: 1869: 1865: 1752: 1744: 1709: 1610: 1598: 1593: 1584: 1559: 1555: 1512: 1463: 1459: 1415: 1412:most popular 1411: 1364: 1344: 1340: 1296: 1290: 1284: 1177:Forty hadith 1163:Forty hadith 1110: 1081: 1040:Ibn Babawayh 1035:Forty Hadith 1032: 1029:Ibn Babawayh 978: 971: 966: 958: 847: 824: 816: 815: 811: 761: 750: 732: 706: 689: 685: 681: 677: 673: 669: 640: 635: 631: 584: 570: 538:page history 512: 506: 400: 397:Stop editing 357:authored by 353:Forty Hadith 351: 350: 347:Did you know 346: 336:Did you know 334: 326: 325:A fact from 258: 252:Islam portal 205:WikiProjects 171: 165: 157: 150: 144: 138: 132: 122: 94: 19:This is the 1607:this Hadith 1082:do not type 856:article or 733:EXPLANATION 341:check views 148:free images 31:not a forum 2111:Categories 2077:Lstfllw203 2063:Lstfllw203 1966:Lstfllw203 1947:Lstfllw203 1901:Lstfllw203 1729:Lstfllw203 1701:Lstfllw203 1687:Lstfllw203 1629:Lstfllw203 1615:. At this 1253:Lstfllw203 925:Lstfllw203 893:necessary. 863:Lstfllw203 792:Lstfllw203 771:Lstfllw203 765:from this 717:Lstfllw203 647:Lstfllw203 587:Lstfllw203 482:Lstfllw203 429:Lstfllw203 414:Lstfllw203 2094:Mhhossein 1836:Mhhossein 1816:Mhhossein 1801:Mhhossein 1780:Mhhossein 1765:Mhhossein 1749:Al-Khisal 1679:this text 1617:reference 1553:WP:BURDEN 1388:. In the 1315:Al-Khisal 1139:. In the 1025:Al-Khisal 1002:Al-Khisal 984:Al-Khisal 767:reference 637:al-Amili. 331:Main Page 88:if needed 71:Be polite 21:talk page 2056:Pamphlet 2038:Pgallert 1987:Pgallert 1941:Pgallert 1785:others. 1757:Pgallert 1753:Pinging 1745:does not 1705:the text 1669:Pgallert 1650:Pgallert 1588:Pgallert 1490:Pgallert 1455:Pgallert 1442:Pgallert 1377:Pgallert 1341:RELIABLE 1310:Pgallert 1287:Pgallert 1259:Pgallert 1222:Pgallert 1199:Pgallert 1185:Pgallert 1128:Pgallert 997:Pgallert 961:Pgallert 861:article. 842:Pgallert 827:Pgallert 763:al-Amili 756:Pgallert 666:Pgallert 651:Pgallert 605:Pgallert 573:Pgallert 542:Pgallert 475:Pgallert 455:Pgallert 363:Muhammad 56:get help 29:This is 27:article. 2024:Saff V. 2006:Saff V. 1991:Saff V. 1982:Comment 1538:Saff V. 1408:Saff V. 1394:Saff V. 1333:Saff V. 1320:Saff V. 1145:Saff V. 1078:Saff V. 1065:Saff V. 1021:Saff V. 1007:Saff V. 923:Hadith. 895:Saff V. 670:require 612:Saff V. 333:in the 154:WP refs 142:scholar 1739:and 2) 1300:forty. 610:books. 501:WP:AGF 496:WP:DYK 434:WP:OWN 201:scale. 126:Google 1337:WP:OR 1204:WP:OR 987:hoax. 854:this 274:Islam 265:Islam 224:Islam 169:JSTOR 130:books 84:Seek 2098:talk 2087:Done 2067:talk 2042:talk 2028:talk 2014:talk 1995:talk 1970:talk 1951:talk 1927:talk 1905:talk 1884:talk 1840:talk 1826:talk 1805:talk 1791:talk 1769:talk 1718:talk 1691:talk 1675:this 1654:talk 1633:talk 1623:, , 1568:talk 1542:talk 1518:talk 1494:talk 1472:talk 1446:talk 1424:talk 1398:talk 1386:this 1351:talk 1324:talk 1263:talk 1241:talk 1226:talk 1211:talk 1189:talk 1179:nor 1149:talk 1137:this 1090:talk 1069:talk 1048:talk 1011:talk 929:talk 899:talk 882:talk 867:talk 858:this 850:here 831:talk 796:talk 775:talk 742:talk 721:talk 698:talk 680:? , 655:talk 616:talk 591:talk 577:talk 546:talk 486:talk 459:talk 442:talk 418:talk 365:and 162:FENS 136:news 73:and 1556:YOU 1416:NOT 293:??? 176:TWL 2113:: 2100:) 2092:. 2079:: 2069:) 2044:) 2030:) 2016:) 1997:) 1972:) 1953:) 1929:) 1907:) 1886:) 1842:) 1828:) 1807:) 1793:) 1771:) 1763:. 1720:) 1693:) 1656:) 1635:) 1570:) 1544:) 1520:) 1496:) 1474:) 1448:) 1440:-- 1426:) 1400:) 1353:) 1326:) 1265:) 1243:) 1228:) 1220:-- 1213:) 1191:) 1151:) 1092:) 1084:. 1071:) 1050:) 1013:) 931:) 901:) 884:) 869:) 833:) 798:) 777:) 744:) 723:) 708:It 700:) 657:) 618:) 593:) 579:) 548:) 503:! 488:) 461:) 444:) 420:) 156:) 54:; 2096:( 2065:( 2040:( 2026:( 2012:( 2004:@ 1993:( 1968:( 1949:( 1943:: 1939:@ 1925:( 1903:( 1882:( 1838:( 1824:( 1818:: 1814:@ 1803:( 1789:( 1782:: 1778:@ 1767:( 1759:: 1755:@ 1731:: 1727:@ 1716:( 1699:@ 1689:( 1671:: 1667:@ 1652:( 1631:( 1627:. 1590:: 1586:@ 1566:( 1540:( 1516:( 1492:( 1485:: 1481:@ 1470:( 1444:( 1437:: 1433:@ 1422:( 1406:@ 1396:( 1379:: 1375:@ 1349:( 1322:( 1312:: 1308:@ 1285:@ 1261:( 1255:: 1251:@ 1239:( 1224:( 1209:( 1197:@ 1187:( 1147:( 1130:: 1126:@ 1088:( 1067:( 1061:: 1057:@ 1046:( 1019:@ 1009:( 999:: 995:@ 959:@ 927:( 897:( 880:( 865:( 829:( 794:( 773:( 758:: 754:@ 740:( 719:( 696:( 664:@ 653:( 614:( 607:: 603:@ 589:( 575:( 544:( 516:) 513:☎ 510:( 484:( 477:: 473:@ 457:( 440:( 427:@ 416:( 406:: 402:@ 380:. 369:? 301:. 207:: 172:· 166:· 158:· 151:· 145:· 139:· 133:· 128:( 58:.

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.

Index