652:
cultural impact, or details of any of her notable works), it isn't illustrated by any images (suitably licensed or otherwise), and I have concerns over whether it meets the standard of "reasonably well written". In my opinion the article requires a very significant amount of improvement to reach GA - enough that if were conducting the review, I would fail it rather than place it on hold pending improvement - and I therefore intend to list it for reassessment. Please don't take this as an attack - the work here is good, you just need more of it before the article is GA class - and I think if you compare the article to other GAs about artists the difference between yours and theirs should become apparent. -
500:
357:
717:
lesser-known (yet still remarkably successful) artists such as Josie
Petrick, it is thinner again. On the other matter, I will re-examine the Mbantua page. Perhaps I should explain that, since Mbantua is a commercial gallery (though it tries to present itself somewhat differently), I tried to minimise reliance on it as a source (there is a risk that their text might "oversell" a client artist, so I try to rely on the independent sources where I can). But I accept there may be more on offer there.
298:
21:
371:
330:
181:
236:
212:
381:
478:
350:
558:
540:
519:
454:
568:
246:
697:
Surely you can see the difference in quality between the
Wintjiya Napaltjarri article and this one? Daisy Jugadai Napaltjarri is less good - it only just barely creeps over the GA line - and it's still another exponential in quality about the Kemarre article. See my comments under criterion 3 at my
731:
I had that concern initially, but upon consulting the
Mbantua page I could see no reason why a gallery would not be a reliable source of biographical information on its artists, in the absence of contradictory reports. You'd just have to watch out for anything that talks about her significance,
651:
Hi, I know some people here are probably pretty chuffed about this article being listed as a Good
Article, but it seems to me the assessment is in error. Specifically, the article isn't broad in scope (it doesn't contain any information about the artist's life between 1953 and 2008, about her
716:
I think you may have misunderstood my point: I was linking to the discussion at the
Wintjiya archive as a shortcut for setting out the common issues with the literature in this field. Wintjiya is one of the country's most successful artists, and even in her case the literature is thin - for
797:
After much improvement of the article, I have closed the reassessment as "Keep" and removed the GAR transclusion. A link to the reasseassment discussion remains in the article history banner at the top of the page. -
851:
668:
312:
881:
468:
667:
I'm pretty sure there is no published information about her life between 1953 and 2008 other than that in the article. For commentary on this issue during a (successful) FAC of a similar article, see
886:
846:
876:
307:
222:
463:
340:
856:
160:
671:. I'm not aware of other material you describe, and the absence of a suitably licenced image (there should be none otherwise) is not an issue at GA as I have always read
836:
165:
32:
901:
831:
148:) policy, even if it is not a biography, because it contains material about living persons. Contentious material about living persons that is unsourced or
871:
444:
434:
699:
683:, both GAs reviewed by editors other than Belovedfreak (though there is a greater literature on Tjunkiya, so a comparison should take account of that).
896:
590:
891:
861:
264:
140:
866:
841:
268:
702:, already used in the article as a reliable source, contains further relevant information not included in this version of the article. -
581:
545:
356:
50:
272:
263:, a collaborative effort to create, develop and organize Knowledge's articles about people. All interested editors are invited to
826:
410:
397:
335:
259:
217:
38:
759:
109:
90:
349:
192:
675:. I will be interested to see other specific concerns. As to your suggestion re comparisons, you might want to look at
676:
803:
784:
767:
737:
707:
657:
758:
Apparently reassessments aren't automatically transcluded to the talk page. Therefore please click through
722:
688:
637:
149:
198:
20:
680:
159:. If such material is repeatedly inserted, or if you have other concerns, please report the issue to
499:
799:
780:
763:
733:
703:
653:
589:
on
Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join
718:
684:
633:
406:
163:.If you are a subject of this article, or acting on behalf of one, and you need help, please see
509:
297:
42:
573:
386:
251:
672:
156:
820:
586:
807:
788:
771:
741:
726:
711:
692:
661:
641:
370:
329:
235:
211:
563:
477:
376:
241:
402:
557:
539:
732:
notability, or impact, as it's probably not reliable in those areas. -
490:
669:
Knowledge:Featured article candidates/Wintjiya
Napaltjarri/archive1
628:
For the article's history prior to mainspace, see edits summarised
271:. For instructions on how to use this banner, please refer to the
453:
762:
to read my reassessment of the article, and comment upon it. -
174:
155:
from the article and its talk page, especially if potentially
132:
498:
476:
452:
296:
852:
Low-importance biography (arts and entertainment) articles
882:
Low-importance
Indigenous peoples of Australia articles
629:
102:
83:
887:
WikiProject
Indigenous peoples of Australia articles
847:
GA-Class biography (arts and entertainment) articles
585:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of
877:GA-Class Indigenous peoples of Australia articles
401:, which aims to improve Knowledge's coverage of
409:. If you would like to participate, visit the
48:If it no longer meets these criteria, you can
8:
464:WikiProject Indigenous peoples of Australia
857:Arts and entertainment work group articles
534:
324:
206:
62:
15:
536:
326:
208:
308:the arts and entertainment work group
7:
579:This article is within the scope of
257:This article is within the scope of
180:
178:
837:Biography articles of living people
599:Knowledge:WikiProject Women artists
197:It is of interest to the following
902:WikiProject Women artists articles
832:Art and architecture good articles
602:Template:WikiProject Women artists
485:Need help improving this article?
33:Art and architecture good articles
14:
872:Low-importance Australia articles
41:. If you can improve it further,
647:Good article listing - in error?
566:
556:
538:
517:
379:
369:
355:
348:
328:
244:
234:
210:
179:
138:This article must adhere to the
19:
897:GA-Class Women artists articles
698:reassessment. If nothing else,
439:This article has been rated as
419:Knowledge:WikiProject Australia
281:Knowledge:WikiProject Biography
892:WikiProject Australia articles
862:WikiProject Biography articles
513:can be contacted via email to
422:Template:WikiProject Australia
284:Template:WikiProject Biography
29:has been listed as one of the
1:
642:23:29, 24 November 2010 (UTC)
593:and see a list of open tasks.
525:for non-editorial assistance.
491:National Library of Australia
461:This article is supported by
305:This article is supported by
141:biographies of living persons
808:23:26, 17 January 2011 (UTC)
789:00:46, 12 January 2011 (UTC)
772:00:45, 12 January 2011 (UTC)
742:01:40, 12 January 2011 (UTC)
727:01:34, 12 January 2011 (UTC)
712:00:43, 12 January 2011 (UTC)
693:00:33, 12 January 2011 (UTC)
662:00:11, 12 January 2011 (UTC)
269:contribute to the discussion
867:GA-Class Australia articles
842:GA-Class biography articles
510:Wikimedia Australia chapter
153:must be removed immediately
918:
445:project's importance scale
677:Daisy Jugadai Napaltjarri
582:WikiProject Women artists
551:
518:
506:
484:
460:
438:
364:
304:
229:
205:
123:
110:Good article reassessment
65:
61:
407:Australia-related topics
827:Knowledge good articles
395:is within the scope of
393:Josepha Petrick Kemarre
27:Josepha Petrick Kemarre
605:Women artists articles
503:
481:
457:
301:
223:Arts and Entertainment
187:This article is rated
502:
480:
456:
398:WikiProject Australia
300:
260:WikiProject Biography
39:good article criteria
779:Wait, here it is: -
681:Tjunkiya Napaltjarri
91:Good article nominee
504:
482:
458:
425:Australia articles
341:Indigenous peoples
302:
287:biography articles
193:content assessment
66:Article milestones
621:
620:
617:
616:
613:
612:
533:
532:
529:
528:
323:
322:
319:
318:
173:
172:
131:
130:
119:
118:
57:
909:
607:
606:
603:
600:
597:
576:
574:Biography portal
571:
570:
569:
560:
553:
552:
542:
535:
524:
523:wikimedia.org.au
522:
521:
520:
427:
426:
423:
420:
417:
389:
387:Australia portal
384:
383:
382:
373:
366:
365:
360:
359:
358:
353:
352:
351:
346:
343:
332:
325:
289:
288:
285:
282:
279:
265:join the project
254:
252:Biography portal
249:
248:
247:
238:
231:
230:
225:
214:
207:
190:
184:
183:
182:
175:
161:this noticeboard
133:
124:Current status:
105:
103:January 18, 2011
86:
84:January 10, 2011
63:
46:
23:
16:
917:
916:
912:
911:
910:
908:
907:
906:
817:
816:
756:
649:
626:
624:Article history
604:
601:
598:
595:
594:
572:
567:
565:
516:
514:
487:Ask a Librarian
424:
421:
418:
415:
414:
385:
380:
378:
354:
347:
344:
338:
286:
283:
280:
277:
276:
250:
245:
243:
220:
191:on Knowledge's
188:
101:
82:
12:
11:
5:
915:
913:
905:
904:
899:
894:
889:
884:
879:
874:
869:
864:
859:
854:
849:
844:
839:
834:
829:
819:
818:
815:
814:
813:
812:
811:
810:
800:DustFormsWords
792:
791:
781:DustFormsWords
764:DustFormsWords
755:
752:
751:
750:
749:
748:
747:
746:
745:
744:
734:DustFormsWords
704:DustFormsWords
654:DustFormsWords
648:
645:
625:
622:
619:
618:
615:
614:
611:
610:
608:
591:the discussion
578:
577:
561:
549:
548:
543:
531:
530:
527:
526:
505:
495:
494:
483:
473:
472:
469:Low-importance
459:
449:
448:
441:Low-importance
437:
431:
430:
428:
391:
390:
374:
362:
361:
345:Low‑importance
333:
321:
320:
317:
316:
313:Low-importance
303:
293:
292:
290:
256:
255:
239:
227:
226:
215:
203:
202:
196:
185:
171:
170:
166:this help page
150:poorly sourced
136:
129:
128:
121:
120:
117:
116:
113:
106:
98:
97:
94:
87:
79:
78:
75:
72:
68:
67:
59:
58:
24:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
914:
903:
900:
898:
895:
893:
890:
888:
885:
883:
880:
878:
875:
873:
870:
868:
865:
863:
860:
858:
855:
853:
850:
848:
845:
843:
840:
838:
835:
833:
830:
828:
825:
824:
822:
809:
805:
801:
796:
795:
794:
793:
790:
786:
782:
778:
777:
776:
775:
774:
773:
769:
765:
761:
753:
743:
739:
735:
730:
729:
728:
724:
720:
719:hamiltonstone
715:
714:
713:
709:
705:
701:
696:
695:
694:
690:
686:
685:hamiltonstone
682:
678:
674:
670:
666:
665:
664:
663:
659:
655:
646:
644:
643:
639:
635:
634:hamiltonstone
631:
623:
609:
596:Women artists
592:
588:
587:women artists
584:
583:
575:
564:
562:
559:
555:
554:
550:
547:
546:Women artists
544:
541:
537:
512:
511:
501:
497:
496:
492:
488:
479:
475:
474:
470:
467:(assessed as
466:
465:
455:
451:
450:
446:
442:
436:
433:
432:
429:
412:
408:
404:
400:
399:
394:
388:
377:
375:
372:
368:
367:
363:
342:
337:
334:
331:
327:
314:
311:(assessed as
310:
309:
299:
295:
294:
291:
274:
273:documentation
270:
266:
262:
261:
253:
242:
240:
237:
233:
232:
228:
224:
219:
216:
213:
209:
204:
200:
194:
186:
177:
176:
168:
167:
162:
158:
154:
151:
147:
143:
142:
137:
135:
134:
127:
122:
114:
112:
111:
107:
104:
100:
99:
95:
93:
92:
88:
85:
81:
80:
76:
73:
70:
69:
64:
60:
55:
53:
52:
44:
40:
36:
35:
34:
28:
25:
22:
18:
17:
757:
754:Reassessment
650:
627:
580:
507:
486:
462:
440:
411:project page
396:
392:
306:
258:
199:WikiProjects
164:
152:
145:
139:
126:Good article
125:
108:
89:
49:
47:
43:please do so
31:
30:
26:
821:Categories
37:under the
700:this link
416:Australia
403:Australia
336:Australia
278:Biography
218:Biography
157:libellous
673:WP:WIAGA
189:GA-class
51:reassess
489:at the
443:on the
74:Process
195:scale.
96:Listed
77:Result
804:talk
785:talk
768:talk
760:here
738:talk
723:talk
708:talk
689:talk
658:talk
638:talk
630:here
515:help
508:The
405:and
267:and
115:Kept
71:Date
679:or
435:Low
146:BLP
823::
806:)
787:)
770:)
740:)
725:)
710:)
691:)
660:)
640:)
632:.
471:).
339::
315:).
221::
54:it
45:.
802:(
783:(
766:(
736:(
721:(
706:(
687:(
656:(
636:(
493:.
447:.
413:.
275:.
201::
169:.
144:(
56:.
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
