Talk:March of the Penguins

1619:

have a tendency toward homosexual and bisexual behavior. Other commentators such as Matt Walker have pointed out that many penguin 'adoptions' of chicks are in fact kidnappings, that weak chicks are frequently the victims of infanticide, that alibino penguins are ostracised and attacked and that prostitution is practiced by at least one species of penguins (New Scientist, October 1). In a response to commentary that the penguins were proof of intelligent design, George Will commented, why would an intelligent designer have penguins raise chicks in minus 80 degree Fahrenheit temperatures? Many commentators including Matt Walker and Andrew Sullivan have suggested that trying to compare human behavior with animal behavior is a mistake.

1099: 1610:

shows the intimate relationship between the family members and how they are ready to make sacrifice for the sake of each other. they live the true meaning of love..... i was really astonished when i watched the documentary... and now i do believe in the strenght and ultimate power and love of god who creat us in a really special way to make us different from any other living things in order to thank him every day, and believe in him, god sacrificed his son in order to save us. "i can do every thing through him w gives me strenght"

1335:

924: 2107:"Author Susan Jacoby claims in her 2008 book, The Age of American Unreason (page 26), that the distributors of the movie deliberately avoided using the word "evolution" in order to avoid backlash from the American religious right, and writes, "As it happens, the emperor penguin is literally a textbook example, cited in college-level biology courses, of evolution by means of natural selection and random mutation. ... The financial wisdom of avoiding any mention of evolution was borne out at the box office" 984: 1749:". I know this is just the plot of a film but in real life Emperor colonies can loose the entire years chicks when the ice breaks up early. I have seen it happen in summer 1995/96 on the Weddell sea. If the article was about Emperor penguins I would track down a reference and note this in the main text but as it is just a plot this is probably less important. Maybe the colony they filmed is in an especially safe bay but it is misleading. Should the main text be changed in some way to note this? -- 1039: 1012: 964: 944: 243: 222: 372: 1528:" - is this a special version? Did they release a proper/serious version in French, and then later bring out this "dubbed" version with comedians? If this "as if it was spoken by penguins" version is the only French version, could someone add a one line explanation of how this was doing without making a farce of the film? (or if the original version was a farce, that too should be noted.) Thanks. 854: 818: 734: 713: 864: 1479:

response to climate change. It may have been that the penguin slowly 'moved' southward, perhaps force in that direction by competition. There are other flaws in your arguments. Female and males evolved as seperate sex a LONG LONG LONG time before some bird evolved into being a penguin. Birds, and possibly dinosaurs evolved the joint rearing of offspring long before penguins...

744: 1764:

wings. They often huddle with other chicks but nothing you could call play. I must admit that I have not seen the film but if it does show chicks playing then it is probably carefull filming+editing. I am not suggesting changing the article but given the overly serious nature of this discussion people should remember that it is just a film and they really are just birds. --

191: 253: 1775:

believing that they are not playing when they are "stand around occasionally flapping their wings huddl with other chicks" is that "people should remember that... they really are just birds" then that basically proves irrational anti-bird bias. It may be that the climate they are born into renders their play somewhat subdued and opaque to outsiders.

2116:. This documentary probably didn't mention evolution simply because it's obvious for a French audience. The makers probably didn't expect their documentary to be so successful abroad in the first place. What I'm saying is that the article may be giving too much importance to an analysis that this Susan Jacoby probably pulled out of nowhere.-- 2049:

people who are actually happy for a mild environmental message to be in a kids movie? By only picking three right-wing conservative religious Americans for their views on the environmental message we are placing undue weight on a minority opinion. Also "critics" is used incorrectly, because critics include positive and negative critics.

1663:

I think you mean Matthew Walker. Difficulty of access is not a reason for deleting a reference, though it seems your citation was tampered with between 2005 and 2008. I found a copy of the article in a periodicals database accessible free-of-charge to many people with a college or municipal library

2048:

I don't think this is particularly balanced. There is a paragraph where it is said that there is an environmental message, then there is this paragraph where a few people are cited as being upset about the environmental message in the movie. Where are the (what I would expect to be vast majority of)

1928:

rewrote the subject matter section of the article. After reading it over, it appears to be on the POV side to me. The rewrite has some obvious problems with it, but rather than just revert it, I figured I'd get some second opinions on it to see what others think. Should we keep it, fix it up, and

1652:

I have added a link to a New Scientist commentary by Andrew Walker. Being New Scientist, it is of course subscriber only but I have also listed the issue it came from so you can also look it up in the original magazine. I know many people dislike links to content not publicly available but I feel it

1609:

i really dont know how to express my thoughts and feelings of this documentary but i really think that this film reflects the grace and glory wisdom of God who designed his creature in an amazing way that really shows how God does really exist "for those who believe in the evolution thing", the film

1478:

I haven't studied Antartica in detail but as with Nunh I highly doubt your thesis that there has been no climate change in Antartica. Are you telling me the temperature Antartica during the last ice age was the same as it is now? Also, there is no reason to assume the penguin's evolution happened in

1376:

Bah, just think a little. The argument is simple - how in the world could such a species evolve? From what prior species would they evolve from? There aren't any others that can do what they can do, and it's hard to see how they got started. Loose any trait and they die - they appear to have evolved

1334:

1763:

Just a minor observation, the title on "Marchofthepenguins baby.jpg" is "Penguin chicks playing.", I have spent many hours around emperor penguin colonies at all times of year and I have never seen chicks playing. Once they leave the brood pouches they just stand around occasionally flapping their

1600:

For the DVD release there were three people doing the commentary, a man, representing the male penguin, a woman representing the female penguin and a boy representing the chick. The narration is timed so that it seems to be what the penguins are thinking at the moment of the story. I think they are

1187:

This article is using "summer" for "time when it is warmest in this area". The chicks dive in to the water for the first time at the end of the coldest part of the year, when almost all of the ice has melted. The adults start another breeding cycle in the fall, when summer is over and quite a bit

1138:

Is this article accurate? It says that the breeding ground is closer to the open water at the start of the summer than at the end of it. The only way I know of for that to happen in that part of the world is for ice to form... which is surely going to happen in the winter rather than in the summer.

2043:

This message, and the fact that the film's trailers and promotions do not mention the "green" dimension to the movie, has led to criticism from conservative reviewers for what they see as propaganda, which could in fact be the plot-twist that caps the storyline, films not generally revealing their

1618:

The film has created some political and social anthromorphic commentary. Michael Medved praised the film for promoting conservative family values. This led to responses by others, including Andrew Sullivan, pointing out that penguins are not monogamous from year to year and (at least in captivity)

1191:

It doesn't seem like this discussion reached a conclusion, and the text is still the same. Since common sense says the ice is thicker at the end of winter, and I believe that the movie states incubation is over the winter, I would think this should be changed unless someone has a reference to the

1265:

My vote is to keep it with its English title and redirect the french title here. This is the english wikipedia, not the french version. Most users will look for it as "March of the Penguins". If this was the french wikipedia, i'd change the title myself to the french one. Another example of an

2131:

They talk here about the distributors of the film (not the makers), so I gather that this hypothesis of deliberate avoiding of the word evolution was only targeting the American market. Do not forget that in the original French version, the commentary is made first-person as if the penguins were

2111:

Now, does that Susan Jacoby have any evidence that the makers of this movie "deliberately" avoided using the word evolution? As a Frenchmen, I can tell you that in France there is no evolution/creationism debate. She may be over-analyzing the documentary through the lenses of an American. That's

1774:

I know I'm responding to a decades-old comment, but "they really are just birds" and birds really do play. I haven't spent any time with Emperor Penguin colonies, but I spend a large amount of time photographing baby birds in the spring, and most of them engage in obvious play. If the reason for

1421:

And the father/mother rearing method is yet enother topic: did both a female and a male happen to evolve at the same time, with the same instinct? If not, how did it breed and care for an egg (in the cold) until then? Why would it bother evolving this method if there wasn't a need for it, and if

1971:

Ironically, the production of the film itself also had unforeseen tragic consequences; all the penguins appearing in the documentary were excessively exposed to human pheromones, and were subsequently ostracized from their tribe. This led to the vast majority of the birds failing to survive the

1824:

Have a look at the giant petrels mentioned on wikipedia-if you go to the 'emperor penguin' page, there is a link to the antarctic giant petrel, of which there are similar light and dark phases to skuas. But there's no way that beast is a skua-skuas for a start can land without falling on their

1384:

And to respond to George Will's stupid question of why would God have created such an animal the answer is easy: to prove that he can, to inspire you, and to make you marvel at what he did. Why do you think he created such a plethora of creatures on earth, or so such a huge universe?

1372:"Penguins are a proof of Intelligent Design"? wtf? why penguins in particular? is this some oblique potshot at creationists, or have they really completely lost it now? I know penguins are gods instrument to save the world from the clutches of Microsoft, but that's another story 1879:

How about The Emperor's Journey? It is international English title. How should it be mentioned in the article? I know the film from this title, and I believe many do so outside the US, apart from original French name. IMDB mentions this name as well.

1513:

It appears that the French version has "dubbed" Penguin narration, while the English one has replaced this by more traditional commentary. I've laid hands on the French version and can confirm the former. This should merit a mention in the article.

1292:

Hey, I'm French and I fully agree with Ze Wresteler. The name of the film in English-Speaking countries is "March of the Penguins", so why bother with the French title ? After all, American films released in Europe also have translated titles.

1820:

I honestly dont think that the predator bird in this film could be a skua, it's clearly a tube-nose (procellariiformes) like a petrel/albatross. It also has a similar wing shape to an albatross (which is what I thought it was to start with).

1184:"At the beginning of Antarctic summer, the breeding ground is only a few hundred meters away from the open water where the penguins can feed. However, by the end of summer, the breeding ground is over 100 km away from the nearest open water" 1443:

Most penguins live in warm areas, like New Zealand. Nobody is saying that penguins evolved solely in Antarctica. Much more likely, some populations of penguins gradually spread southward, adapting to the colder temperatures as they did so.

1304:

A discussion on the talk page there ended with using the imdb name as the article title. Redirects from English titles and other titles will all point there as a movie can have several different titles. Also the english title is only

2044:

ending in trailers. Filming a movie that has an environmental message aimed at children has provoked some controversy, although it might be overly emphatic. Critics of the film include Michael Medved , Neil Cavuto , and Glenn Beck .

1629:

I think the original comment must have been parody, because I find it impossible to believe that somebody would have sufficient intelligence to form a coherent sentence yet such inadequate reasoning that they could write such guff.

1352:

The article says Emilie Simon, but I have the CD and it says Alex Wurman. The front cover insert has the credits for the score and doesn't list an Emilie Simon. Did they use two seperate scores for the different language versions?

1993:

Unfortunately I don't have access to either of those databases. I would like to see a full citation and a brief quotation before this is returned to the article, as I think that to do otherwise would not be in the spirit of the

2458: 1405:

If someone did indeed make the argument that penquins pose a problem for evolution, or that they were an example of irreducible complexity, it was indeed a "simple" argument...in the sense of being uninformed or stupid. -

2498: 153: 1222:

The US version is. I believe the native French title is "La Marche de l'empereur" - The. I'm not sure which would be proper for the article title since this is technically a French film. Need more discussion here.. ??

2473: 1418:

How could such an egg instinct evolve? Why would a penguin do it (i.e. be selected for it) if it wasn't cold out. And if it was cold out (to enable natural selection), how could it survive until it started?

1163:

Summer is a season, defined by convention in meteorology as the whole months of June, July, and August, in the Northern hemisphere, and the whole months of December, January, and February, in the Southern

1571:

narration in french with penguin-like accents (whatever that would sound like), talking in the first person ("Oh, I'm cold, but I must walk to the water for food"), which were added (and then removed)

1713:

I've changed the name of the Dutch narrator back from Urbain Servranckx into Urbanus. That's how he's best known in Belgium and the Netherlands, and besides: that's the title of his article, too.

1541:

My understanding is the French version, which is the original version had the penguin 'voices' removed and instead a French language dubbing of what the penguins were supposedly saying

1440:

What gradual climate change? There wasn't any in Antarctica. All climate changes found by core samples have been abrupt and sudden, and none lasted long enough for evolution to happen.

1108: 1022: 933: 828: 1847:

alright, i've been looking around, but i can't find out why the choice was made to remove Émilie Simon's music and replace it with Wurman's. is that information available anywhere?

2079:

Something appears to have gone wrong with the international versions section, launching into what appears to be a synopsis/plot of the film without preamble or a new subheading.

993: 840: 147: 953: 832: 1499:

Antarctica WASN'T always a big mass of ice. In dinosaur times, it was all forest, so perhaps prehistoric penguins just decided to stay put and evolve instead of move out.

2323: 2453: 2351: 2347: 2333: 2229: 2225: 2211: 1415:

And I'm sure they could live in -80 degree weather. It's the cold, and especially the unique method of caring for an egg that is the issue, not the lack of wings.

1276:, but when a search to that title is done on the english wikipedia, the search is redirected to the english title. Therefore, I say, keep the english title. -- 44: 2523: 2493: 1747:... so that there is no danger of the ice becoming too soft to support the colony, or chicks falling into the water before they develop a waterproof coat ... 1113: 665: 394: 2513: 2448: 1089: 1079: 2468: 1978:

P Porter has at least 2 articles in issues of that journal in 2006, available in several online databases. The one mentioning the film in the title is:

79: 2488: 686: 2533: 1431:

Gradual climate change would be a more than adequate explanation. You really need to study evolution before you presume to cry "gotcha!" at it. -

2483: 2463: 2433: 1403: 800: 790: 1653:

summarises several other key arguments against using penguins as moral compasses and in the absence of an alternative, I think it should stay.

321: 2518: 2438: 2418: 1055: 311: 85: 2508: 2086: 1301: 275:, an attempt at creating a standardized, informative and easy-to-use ornithological resource. If you would like to participate, visit the 2478: 2423: 1776: 1445: 2503: 2189: 648: 2329:

When you have finished reviewing my changes, you may follow the instructions on the template below to fix any issues with the URLs.

1192:

contrary. And, the text now specifically says "Antartic summer", so there should be no confusion over northern hemisphere seasons.

1148:

In the southern hemisphere the cold season is the summer while the winter is the warm season. I believe this article is accurate. --

766: 458: 390: 168: 135: 2428: 1046: 1017: 690: 490: 280: 2324:

http://celebritywonder.ugo.com/movie/2005_March_of_the_Penguins_conversation_with_the_crew_jerome_maison_and_laurent_chalet.html

1694:

Partially true. The French soundtrack is more pop than techno, and has vocals. You can listen to clips on the amazon.fr page:

973: 882: 836: 498: 99: 30: 1320:. I'm not sure which way I lean in the foreign title vs English title discussion here, but I know "The March.." is incorrect. 2443: 2413: 104: 20: 1586:

Another question which could make things clearer is: are their two French versions? Thanks for any further clarification.

2528: 894: 886: 74: 1798:

It has been tentatively identified on bird watcher sites as the atartic skua, which does prey on penguin colony chicks.

2394: 1633:

While we're at it, aren't the 'sturdy' eggs which 'prove' Creationism in the religious' eyes actually pretty fragile? --

1098: 757: 718: 384: 202: 129: 432: 276: 270: 227: 65: 2132:

talking, and that it would quite inappropriate for the penguins to talk about evolution or other scientific matters.

2305: 1684:

I've been told that the French version had, in addition to the human dubbing, a techno soundtrack. Is that true?

890: 877: 823: 1987: 125: 2137:

But otherwise, I do agree that this article probably gives too much importance to the different "controversies".

538: 512: 2350:

to delete these "External links modified" talk page sections if they want to de-clutter talk pages, but see the

2228:

to delete these "External links modified" talk page sections if they want to de-clutter talk pages, but see the

2090: 1807:

Does the predator bird section belong like that in the article. i think we can do something else with it. --

1449: 175: 2385: 2297: 1888: 1780: 584: 568: 109: 630: 450: 2064: 644: 508: 1357:

The French version (original version) of the movie as the score written and interpreted by Emilie Simon.

652: 2369:

If you have discovered URLs which were erroneously considered dead by the bot, you can report them with

2357: 2289: 2267: 2247:

If you have discovered URLs which were erroneously considered dead by the bot, you can report them with

2235: 2161: 1317: 614: 208: 24: 2296:. If you have any questions, or need the bot to ignore the links, or the page altogether, please visit 1973:

This was discussed at length in 'Society and Animals' - P Porter , 2006, White Horse Press</ref: -->

1925: 1685: 1461: 1423: 1394: 923: 424: 1500: 576: 2082: 2028: 2006: 1953: 1935: 1909: 1813: 1733: 1669: 1282: 1253: 334: 2138: 190: 2190:

https://web.archive.org/20070927225712/http://www.imago.org/main/public_html/_htm_news/2007/n35.htm

2142: 1866: 1799: 1377:

as a whole complete package, which is contrary to the theory. So only God (Intelligent Design is a

983: 572: 546: 161: 141: 55: 1982: 1054:

on Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join

1038: 1011: 765:

on Knowledge. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join

2317: 1882: 1167: 594: 564: 534: 516: 70: 2354:

before doing mass systematic removals. This message is updated dynamically through the template

2232:

before doing mass systematic removals. This message is updated dynamically through the template

1358: 1176: 1149: 963: 2370: 2248: 2193: 669: 2171: 2121: 2060: 2018: 1601:

trying to make the story more personal, and less of a cold-scientist-studying-penguins thing.

1235: 1215: 402: 51: 2263: 1944: 1834: 1634: 638: 622: 2377: 2255: 2179: 1948: 1930: 1929:

add back material the anon user took out, or revert it back? Any suggestions/comments? --

1893: 1848: 1808: 1728: 1277: 943: 554: 542: 286: 2024: 2002: 1905: 1665: 1526:

The French language release had narration "dubbed" as if it was spoken by the penguins...

1245: 2336:, "External links modified" talk page sections are no longer generated or monitored by 2214:, "External links modified" talk page sections are no longer generated or monitored by 2050: 1862: 1654: 1621: 1542: 1480: 1321: 1224: 530: 524: 472: 412: 371: 2376:

If you found an error with any archives or the URLs themselves, you can fix them with

2254:

If you found an error with any archives or the URLs themselves, you can fix them with

682: 2407: 2113: 1995: 1470: 1432: 1407: 749: 486: 482: 1695: 242: 221: 2117: 1765: 1750: 1268: 1193: 590: 446: 258: 881:. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can 2399: 2343: 2306:

https://web.archive.org/web/20120321185756/http://lemac.com.au/NEWS/Penguins.htm

2275: 2221: 2146: 2125: 2094: 2068: 2053: 2032: 2010: 1955: 1937: 1913: 1869: 1851: 1837: 1815: 1802: 1784: 1768: 1753: 1735: 1717: 1714: 1700: 1688: 1673: 1657: 1637: 1624: 1590: 1587: 1545: 1532: 1529: 1518: 1503: 1483: 1473: 1464: 1453: 1435: 1426: 1410: 1397: 1378: 1361: 1284: 1196: 1179: 1170: 1152: 1143: 1140: 869: 442: 416: 1988:

http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/brill/saa/2006/00000014/00000002/art00005

2342:. No special action is required regarding these talk page notices, other than 2220:. No special action is required regarding these talk page notices, other than 1697: 1515: 1310: 1273: 1257: 1051: 859: 853: 817: 739: 598: 468: 248: 2015:

Note: hoax edits were made to other articles by that IP address today. See:

1861:

Please help add more references to this article so we can achieve GA-Class. —

1390: 1386: 2309: 1727:

I'm curious, does anyone think we can bring this article up to FA status? --

733: 712: 504: 477: 464: 420: 408: 1568:

penguin-like noises which were made by humans and added (and then removed)

1460:

Well anyway I hope this answers the original question posted by unsigned.

1558:

Sorry, I still can't make sense of this. When you say that one version "

898: 626: 560: 438: 2176:

after the link to keep me from modifying it. Alternatively, you can add

1707: 609: 603: 1244:

seems better. That is its original title and other foreign films here(

1966:

This section was added to the article today by an unregistered user:

1252:. On the other hand many foreign language titles here are in English( 1158: 762: 618: 1833:

I would say this is a mid level personally it was a pretty big film

1795:

What was that bird that tried to kidnap and eat one of the chicks?

2184:

to keep me off the page altogether. I made the following changes:

1469:

Yes, I think it makes the quality of the argument quite clear. -

2459:

Core film articles supported by the documentary films task force

1249: 1983:

http://direct.bl.uk/bld/PlaceOrder.do?UIN=187033820&ETOC=RN

2499:

Core film articles supported by the American cinema task force

1402:

Um. They would evolve from, say, birds that can actually fly.

184: 15: 1393:. PS. Would you want to worship a puny unimpressive creator? 2474:

Core film articles supported by the French cinema task force

2199:

When you have finished reviewing my changes, please set the

2194:

http://www.imago.org/main/public_html/_htm_news/2007/n35.htm

2019:

http://en.wikipedia.org/Special:Contributions/98.124.159.213

1381:, if you belive in God then say so) could have created them. 1316:

Well at the very least I think this page should be moved to

1097: 982: 962: 942: 922: 2300:

for additional information. I made the following changes:

1614:

Did you happen to read this part of the wikipedia article:

1947:

I have reverted the article to pre anon editor changes.--

1422:

there was a need how did it survive the cold until then?

2160:

I have just added archive links to one external link on

2293: 2165: 1272:. Its real name in Germany, where it was produced, is 1248:) go by their original langugage title here and on the 360: 355: 350: 345: 1565:

the noises that the penguins make through their beaks?

1341:

Please refrain from personnal opinions about the film.

160: 1050:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of 761:, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of 2346:using the archive tool instructions below. Editors 2224:using the archive tool instructions below. Editors 1234:, so I thought it was odd when I saw the article. 1230:Dunno...it's just that all the posters have it as 33:for general discussion of the article's subject. 897:. To improve this article, please refer to the 672:). Add taxonomic authorities to genus articles. 2332:This message was posted before February 2018. 2210:This message was posted before February 2018. 174: 8: 2288:I have just modified one external link on 1006: 893:. To use this banner, please refer to the 812: 707: 379:Here are some tasks awaiting attention: 329: 216: 2310:http://www.lemac.com.au/NEWS/Penguins.htm 687:Category:Birds articles needing attention 1962:excessively exposed to human pheromones? 1266:article that follows this precident is 1008: 814: 709: 218: 188: 1524:I don't understand the current text: " 1391:and some more, including about ET life 1175:OK, you are right, sorry about that.-- 2454:Documentary films task force articles 7: 1302:Knowledge:Naming conventions (films) 1044:This article is within the scope of 875:This article is within the scope of 755:This article is within the scope of 2524:Mid-importance Adelie Land articles 2494:American cinema task force articles 2105:This is a quote from the article : 1188:of ice has re-frozen. --kd 26mar06 207:It is of interest to the following 23:for discussing improvements to the 2514:Mid-importance Antarctica articles 2449:B-Class Documentary films articles 1206:Isn't the name of this movie just 649:The Institute for Bird Populations 14: 2469:French cinema task force articles 2292:. Please take a moment to review 2164:. Please take a moment to review 991:This article is supported by the 971:This article is on the project's 951:This article is supported by the 931:This article is supported by the 391:Endemic birds of Papua New Guinea 2489:B-Class American cinema articles 1560:had the penguin 'voices' removed 1064:Knowledge:WikiProject Antarctica 1037: 1010: 891:regional and topical task forces 862: 852: 816: 742: 732: 711: 691:Knowledge:WikiProject Birds/Todo 370: 251: 241: 220: 189: 45:Click here to start a new topic. 2534:WikiProject Antarctica articles 1972:subsequent winter. <ref: --> 1900:Which countries used the title 1084:This article has been rated as 1067:Template:WikiProject Antarctica 795:This article has been rated as 316:This article has been rated as 2484:WikiProject Film core articles 2464:B-Class French cinema articles 2434:Mid-importance France articles 2033:14:37, 29 September 2008 (UTC) 2011:12:44, 29 September 2008 (UTC) 283:and see a list of open tasks. 1: 2276:21:08, 13 February 2016 (UTC) 2095:00:23, 15 February 2009 (UTC) 1914:12:49, 8 September 2008 (UTC) 1894:10:47, 24 November 2007 (UTC) 1838:18:53, 19 November 2006 (UTC) 1816:14:41, 9 September 2006 (UTC) 1803:15:27, 8 September 2006 (UTC) 1785:19:51, 28 February 2016 (UTC) 1674:12:41, 8 September 2008 (UTC) 1658:14:20, 30 December 2005 (UTC) 1625:14:25, 30 December 2005 (UTC) 1591:14:20, 30 December 2005 (UTC) 1546:13:58, 30 December 2005 (UTC) 1533:13:11, 30 December 2005 (UTC) 1519:16:20, 23 November 2005 (UTC) 1484:14:14, 30 December 2005 (UTC) 1454:22:34, 15 December 2008 (UTC) 1313:04:33, August 16, 2005 (UTC) 1238:04:13, August 15, 2005 (UTC) 1227:04:05, August 15, 2005 (UTC) 1218:03:58, August 15, 2005 (UTC) 1106:This article is supported by 1058:and see a list of open tasks. 769:and see a list of open tasks. 683:the project's cleanup listing 670:search Flickr for free images 42:Put new text under old text. 2519:B-Class Adelie Land articles 2439:All WikiProject France pages 2419:Mid-importance bird articles 2147:10:15, 25 October 2015 (UTC) 2054:16:59, 13 January 2007 (UTC) 1943:Ok, Per second opinion from 1718:22:57, 7 February 2006 (UTC) 1701:22:19, 25 January 2006 (UTC) 1474:18:08, 2 December 2005 (UTC) 1465:17:10, 2 December 2005 (UTC) 1436:07:36, 2 December 2005 (UTC) 1427:07:33, 2 December 2005 (UTC) 1411:07:01, 2 December 2005 (UTC) 1398:06:54, 2 December 2005 (UTC) 1362:01:22, 3 December 2005 (UTC) 1324:16:05, August 18, 2005 (UTC) 1260:05:02, August 15, 2005 (UTC) 1180:09:13, 6 February 2006 (UTC) 1171:16:35, 2 February 2006 (UTC) 1153:14:04, 2 February 2006 (UTC) 1144:16:17, 31 January 2006 (UTC) 934:Documentary films task force 775:Knowledge:WikiProject France 666:bird articles needing photos 2509:B-Class Antarctica articles 2101:Intelligent design argument 1689:05:47, 3 January 2006 (UTC) 1285:20:55, 15 August 2005 (UTC) 1139:It just seems wrong to me! 778:Template:WikiProject France 296:Knowledge:WikiProject Birds 50:New to Knowledge? Welcome! 2550: 2479:B-Class core film articles 2424:WikiProject Birds articles 2363:(last update: 5 June 2024) 2285:Hello fellow Wikipedians, 2241:(last update: 5 June 2024) 2182:|deny=InternetArchiveBot}} 2157:Hello fellow Wikipedians, 2126:01:21, 31 March 2012 (UTC) 2069:04:14, 21 April 2009 (UTC) 1852:16:52, 10 March 2007 (UTC) 1090:project's importance scale 994:American cinema task force 907:Knowledge:WikiProject Film 801:project's importance scale 681:More outstanding tasks at 322:project's importance scale 299:Template:WikiProject Birds 2504:WikiProject Film articles 1956:18:03, 14 June 2008 (UTC) 1938:16:52, 11 June 2008 (UTC) 1769:12:18, 30 July 2006 (UTC) 1754:12:08, 30 July 2006 (UTC) 1638:15:22, 26 June 2007 (UTC) 1197:18:41, 3 April 2007 (UTC) 1105: 1083: 1032: 990: 970: 950: 930: 910:Template:WikiProject Film 847: 794: 727: 539:Rainbow-bearded Thornbill 513:Abu Dhabi Falcon Hospital 328: 315: 279:, where you can join the 236: 215: 80:Be welcoming to newcomers 2400:21:16, 1 June 2017 (UTC) 1870:12:38, 30 May 2007 (UTC) 1736:13:53, 1 June 2006 (UTC) 1504:18:48, 15 May 2006 (UTC) 954:French cinema task force 2429:B-Class France articles 2281:External links modified 2153:External links modified 1874: 1242:La Marche de l'empereur 569:New Caledonian lorikeet 2075:International Versions 1109:Adelie Land work group 1102: 1047:WikiProject Antarctica 987: 967: 947: 927: 645:Ninox boobook ocellata 509:Driven grouse shooting 197:This article is rated 75:avoid personal attacks 2444:B-Class film articles 2414:B-Class bird articles 2290:March of the Penguins 2162:March of the Penguins 2038:Environmental message 1902:The Emperor's Journey 1875:The Emperor's Journey 1562:", what was removed? 1318:March of the Penguins 1307:March of the Penguins 1254:Shichinin no samurai 1232:March of the Penguins 1208:March of the Penguins 1101: 986: 966: 946: 926: 615:Chestnut-headed tesia 265:March of the Penguins 100:Neutral point of view 25:March of the Penguins 2529:Adelie Land articles 2344:regular verification 2222:regular verification 2207:to let others know. 2168:. If necessary, add 105:No original research 2334:After February 2018 2212:After February 2018 2203:parameter below to 1857:Good article status 1256:), but not on imdb. 1157:Wrong! The article 1070:Antarctica articles 883:join the discussion 573:Operation Migration 2388:InternetArchiveBot 2339:InternetArchiveBot 2217:InternetArchiveBot 1745:The article says " 1648:New Scientist link 1103: 988: 968: 948: 928: 758:WikiProject France 565:Scottish crossbill 535:Semiplumbeous hawk 333:WikiProject Birds 203:content assessment 86:dispute resolution 47: 2364: 2274: 2242: 2085:comment added by 1896: 1128: 1127: 1124: 1123: 1120: 1119: 1005: 1004: 1001: 1000: 885:and see lists of 811: 810: 807: 806: 706: 705: 702: 701: 698: 697: 679: 678: 595:Blyth's frogmouth 271:WikiProject Birds 183: 182: 66:Assume good faith 43: 2541: 2398: 2389: 2362: 2361: 2340: 2321: 2270: 2269:Talk to my owner 2265: 2240: 2239: 2218: 2183: 2175: 2097: 1951: 1933: 1891: 1885: 1881: 1811: 1731: 1280: 1214:in front of it? 1072: 1071: 1068: 1065: 1062: 1041: 1034: 1033: 1028: 1025: 1014: 1007: 915: 914: 911: 908: 905: 878:WikiProject Film 872: 867: 866: 865: 856: 849: 848: 843: 820: 813: 783: 782: 779: 776: 773: 752: 747: 746: 745: 736: 729: 728: 723: 715: 708: 623:Pallid scops owl 385:Article requests 374: 367: 366: 330: 304: 303: 300: 297: 294: 261: 256: 255: 254: 245: 238: 237: 232: 224: 217: 200: 194: 193: 185: 179: 178: 164: 95:Article policies 16: 2549: 2548: 2544: 2543: 2542: 2540: 2539: 2538: 2404: 2403: 2392: 2387: 2355: 2348:have permission 2338: 2315: 2298:this simple FaQ 2283: 2273: 2268: 2233: 2226:have permission 2216: 2177: 2169: 2155: 2103: 2080: 2077: 2040: 2027:(or Hrothulf) ( 2005:(or Hrothulf) ( 1964: 1949: 1931: 1922: 1908:(or Hrothulf) ( 1904:in English? -- 1889: 1883: 1877: 1859: 1845: 1843:Why The Change? 1831: 1809: 1793: 1761: 1743: 1729: 1725: 1711: 1682: 1668:(or Hrothulf) ( 1650: 1607: 1605:how great HE is 1511: 1370: 1350: 1278: 1204: 1136: 1069: 1066: 1063: 1060: 1059: 1026: 1020: 912: 909: 906: 903: 902: 868: 863: 861: 826: 781:France articles 780: 777: 774: 771: 770: 748: 743: 741: 721: 675: 543:Sunda scops owl 365: 301: 298: 295: 292: 291: 257: 252: 250: 230: 201:on Knowledge's 198: 121: 116: 115: 114: 91: 61: 12: 11: 5: 2547: 2545: 2537: 2536: 2531: 2526: 2521: 2516: 2511: 2506: 2501: 2496: 2491: 2486: 2481: 2476: 2471: 2466: 2461: 2456: 2451: 2446: 2441: 2436: 2431: 2426: 2421: 2416: 2406: 2405: 2382: 2381: 2374: 2327: 2326: 2312: 2304:Added archive 2282: 2279: 2266: 2260: 2259: 2252: 2197: 2196: 2188:Added archive 2154: 2151: 2150: 2149: 2134: 2133: 2102: 2099: 2087:86.140.146.240 2076: 2073: 2072: 2071: 2039: 2036: 1991: 1990: 1985: 1976: 1975: 1963: 1960: 1959: 1958: 1921: 1920:Recent rewrite 1918: 1917: 1916: 1876: 1873: 1858: 1855: 1844: 1841: 1830: 1827: 1800:Sandwich Eater 1792: 1791:Predator Bird? 1789: 1788: 1787: 1760: 1759:Chicks playing 1757: 1742: 1739: 1724: 1721: 1710: 1705: 1704: 1703: 1681: 1678: 1677: 1676: 1649: 1646: 1645: 1644: 1643: 1642: 1641: 1640: 1615: 1606: 1603: 1598: 1597: 1596: 1595: 1594: 1593: 1579: 1578: 1577: 1576: 1575: 1574: 1573: 1572: 1569: 1566: 1551: 1550: 1549: 1548: 1536: 1535: 1510: 1507: 1497: 1496: 1495: 1494: 1493: 1492: 1491: 1490: 1489: 1488: 1487: 1486: 1476: 1458: 1457: 1456: 1419: 1416: 1382: 1369: 1366: 1365: 1364: 1349: 1346: 1345: 1344: 1343: 1342: 1332: 1331: 1330: 1329: 1328: 1327: 1326: 1325: 1290: 1289: 1288: 1287: 1263: 1262: 1261: 1210:, without the 1203: 1200: 1135: 1132: 1130: 1126: 1125: 1122: 1121: 1118: 1117: 1114:Mid-importance 1104: 1094: 1093: 1086:Mid-importance 1082: 1076: 1075: 1073: 1056:the discussion 1042: 1030: 1029: 1027:Mid‑importance 1015: 1003: 1002: 999: 998: 989: 979: 978: 969: 959: 958: 949: 939: 938: 929: 919: 918: 916: 874: 873: 857: 845: 844: 821: 809: 808: 805: 804: 797:Mid-importance 793: 787: 786: 784: 767:the discussion 754: 753: 737: 725: 724: 722:Mid‑importance 716: 704: 703: 700: 699: 696: 695: 677: 676: 674: 673: 664:Add photos to 656: 634: 580: 550: 531:Cathartiformes 520: 494: 473:Gouldian finch 454: 428: 413:Vesper sparrow 398: 378: 376: 375: 364: 363: 358: 353: 348: 342: 339: 338: 326: 325: 318:Mid-importance 314: 308: 307: 305: 289:this template. 285:Please do not 263: 262: 246: 234: 233: 231:Mid‑importance 225: 213: 212: 206: 195: 181: 180: 118: 117: 113: 112: 107: 102: 93: 92: 90: 89: 82: 77: 68: 62: 60: 59: 48: 39: 38: 35: 34: 28: 13: 10: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 2546: 2535: 2532: 2530: 2527: 2525: 2522: 2520: 2517: 2515: 2512: 2510: 2507: 2505: 2502: 2500: 2497: 2495: 2492: 2490: 2487: 2485: 2482: 2480: 2477: 2475: 2472: 2470: 2467: 2465: 2462: 2460: 2457: 2455: 2452: 2450: 2447: 2445: 2442: 2440: 2437: 2435: 2432: 2430: 2427: 2425: 2422: 2420: 2417: 2415: 2412: 2411: 2409: 2402: 2401: 2396: 2391: 2390: 2379: 2375: 2372: 2368: 2367: 2366: 2359: 2353: 2349: 2345: 2341: 2335: 2330: 2325: 2319: 2313: 2311: 2307: 2303: 2302: 2301: 2299: 2295: 2291: 2286: 2280: 2278: 2277: 2271: 2264: 2257: 2253: 2250: 2246: 2245: 2244: 2237: 2231: 2227: 2223: 2219: 2213: 2208: 2206: 2202: 2195: 2191: 2187: 2186: 2185: 2181: 2173: 2167: 2163: 2158: 2152: 2148: 2144: 2140: 2136: 2135: 2130: 2129: 2128: 2127: 2123: 2119: 2115: 2114:Americentrism 2109: 2108: 2100: 2098: 2096: 2092: 2088: 2084: 2074: 2070: 2066: 2062: 2058: 2057: 2056: 2055: 2052: 2046: 2045: 2037: 2035: 2034: 2030: 2026: 2021: 2020: 2016: 2013: 2012: 2008: 2004: 1999: 1997: 1989: 1986: 1984: 1981: 1980: 1979: 1974: 1969: 1968: 1967: 1961: 1957: 1954: 1952: 1946: 1942: 1941: 1940: 1939: 1936: 1934: 1927: 1919: 1915: 1911: 1907: 1903: 1899: 1898: 1897: 1895: 1892: 1886: 1872: 1871: 1868: 1864: 1856: 1854: 1853: 1850: 1842: 1840: 1839: 1836: 1828: 1826: 1822: 1818: 1817: 1814: 1812: 1805: 1804: 1801: 1796: 1790: 1786: 1782: 1778: 1777:76.105.216.34 1773: 1772: 1771: 1770: 1767: 1758: 1756: 1755: 1752: 1748: 1740: 1738: 1737: 1734: 1732: 1723:FA suggestion 1722: 1720: 1719: 1716: 1709: 1706: 1702: 1699: 1696: 1693: 1692: 1691: 1690: 1687: 1680:Techno music? 1679: 1675: 1671: 1667: 1662: 1661: 1660: 1659: 1656: 1647: 1639: 1636: 1632: 1631: 1628: 1627: 1626: 1623: 1620: 1616: 1613: 1612: 1611: 1604: 1602: 1592: 1589: 1585: 1584: 1583: 1582: 1581: 1580: 1570: 1567: 1564: 1563: 1561: 1557: 1556: 1555: 1554: 1553: 1552: 1547: 1544: 1540: 1539: 1538: 1537: 1534: 1531: 1527: 1523: 1522: 1521: 1520: 1517: 1509:Narration/Dub 1508: 1506: 1505: 1502: 1485: 1482: 1477: 1475: 1472: 1468: 1467: 1466: 1463: 1459: 1455: 1451: 1447: 1446:80.235.57.239 1442: 1441: 1439: 1438: 1437: 1434: 1430: 1429: 1428: 1425: 1420: 1417: 1414: 1413: 1412: 1409: 1404: 1401: 1400: 1399: 1396: 1392: 1388: 1383: 1380: 1375: 1374: 1373: 1367: 1363: 1360: 1356: 1355: 1354: 1347: 1340: 1339: 1338: 1337: 1336: 1323: 1319: 1315: 1314: 1312: 1308: 1303: 1300: 1299: 1298: 1297: 1296: 1295: 1294: 1286: 1283: 1281: 1275: 1271: 1270: 1264: 1259: 1255: 1251: 1247: 1243: 1240: 1239: 1237: 1233: 1229: 1228: 1226: 1221: 1220: 1219: 1217: 1213: 1209: 1201: 1199: 1198: 1195: 1189: 1185: 1182: 1181: 1178: 1173: 1172: 1169: 1165: 1160: 1155: 1154: 1151: 1146: 1145: 1142: 1133: 1131: 1115: 1112:(assessed as 1111: 1110: 1100: 1096: 1095: 1091: 1087: 1081: 1078: 1077: 1074: 1057: 1053: 1049: 1048: 1043: 1040: 1036: 1035: 1031: 1024: 1019: 1016: 1013: 1009: 996: 995: 985: 981: 980: 976: 975: 965: 961: 960: 956: 955: 945: 941: 940: 936: 935: 925: 921: 920: 917: 913:film articles 900: 896: 895:documentation 892: 888: 884: 880: 879: 871: 860: 858: 855: 851: 850: 846: 842: 838: 834: 830: 825: 822: 819: 815: 802: 798: 792: 789: 788: 785: 768: 764: 760: 759: 751: 750:France portal 740: 738: 735: 731: 730: 726: 720: 717: 714: 710: 694: 692: 688: 684: 671: 667: 663: 661: 657: 654: 650: 646: 643: 641: 640: 635: 632: 628: 624: 620: 616: 612: 611: 606: 605: 600: 596: 592: 589: 587: 586: 581: 578: 574: 570: 566: 562: 559: 557: 556: 551: 548: 544: 540: 536: 532: 529: 527: 526: 521: 518: 514: 510: 506: 503: 501: 500: 495: 492: 488: 487:Avian malaria 484: 483:Cnemophilidae 480: 479: 474: 470: 466: 463: 461: 460: 455: 452: 448: 444: 440: 437: 435: 434: 429: 426: 422: 418: 414: 410: 407: 405: 404: 399: 396: 392: 389: 387: 386: 381: 380: 377: 373: 369: 368: 362: 359: 357: 354: 352: 349: 347: 344: 343: 341: 340: 336: 332: 331: 327: 323: 319: 313: 310: 309: 306: 302:bird articles 290: 288: 282: 278: 274: 273: 272: 266: 260: 249: 247: 244: 240: 239: 235: 229: 226: 223: 219: 214: 210: 204: 196: 192: 187: 186: 177: 173: 170: 167: 163: 159: 155: 152: 149: 146: 143: 140: 137: 134: 131: 127: 124: 123:Find sources: 120: 119: 111: 110:Verifiability 108: 106: 103: 101: 98: 97: 96: 87: 83: 81: 78: 76: 72: 69: 67: 64: 63: 57: 53: 52:Learn to edit 49: 46: 41: 40: 37: 36: 32: 26: 22: 18: 17: 2386: 2383: 2358:source check 2337: 2331: 2328: 2287: 2284: 2261: 2236:source check 2215: 2209: 2204: 2200: 2198: 2159: 2156: 2110: 2106: 2104: 2078: 2061:TotalIssueee 2047: 2042: 2041: 2022: 2017: 2014: 2000: 1992: 1977: 1970: 1965: 1926:68.33.149.36 1923: 1901: 1878: 1860: 1846: 1832: 1823: 1819: 1806: 1797: 1794: 1762: 1746: 1744: 1741:Ice break up 1726: 1712: 1686:24.192.17.34 1683: 1651: 1617: 1608: 1599: 1559: 1525: 1512: 1498: 1462:67.165.96.26 1424:67.165.96.26 1395:67.165.96.26 1371: 1351: 1333: 1306: 1291: 1269:Run Lola Run 1267: 1246:Bande à part 1241: 1236:Thunderbrand 1231: 1216:Thunderbrand 1211: 1207: 1205: 1190: 1186: 1183: 1174: 1162: 1156: 1147: 1137: 1129: 1107: 1085: 1045: 992: 972: 952: 932: 876: 796: 756: 680: 659: 658: 637: 636: 608: 602: 591:Argus (bird) 583: 582: 553: 552: 523: 522: 497: 496: 476: 457: 456: 447:Saker falcon 431: 430: 401: 400: 383: 382: 317: 284: 277:project page 269: 268: 264: 259:Birds portal 209:WikiProjects 171: 165: 157: 150: 144: 138: 132: 122: 94: 19:This is the 2081:—Preceding 1945:John Carter 1635:Safe-Keeper 1501:87.80.28.20 1379:weasel word 1164:hemisphere. 1023:Adelie Land 870:Film portal 829:Documentary 443:Magpie duck 417:Bird flight 267:is part of 148:free images 31:not a forum 2408:Categories 2395:Report bug 1950:ZeWrestler 1932:ZeWrestler 1924:Recently, 1849:Whateley23 1829:importance 1810:ZeWrestler 1730:ZeWrestler 1279:ZeWrestler 1274:Lola rennt 1061:Antarctica 1052:Antarctica 1018:Antarctica 899:guidelines 887:open tasks 599:Nik Borrow 469:Nidicolous 287:substitute 281:discussion 2378:this tool 2371:this tool 2318:dead link 2256:this tool 2249:this tool 2139:Cochonfou 2051:Sad mouse 1998:policy. 1863:Viriditas 1715:Oliphaunt 1655:Nil Einne 1622:Nil Einne 1543:Nil Einne 1481:Nil Einne 1322:K1Bond007 1225:K1Bond007 1134:Accuracy? 974:core list 505:Debeaking 478:Cathartes 465:Phalarope 421:Bird bath 409:Bullfinch 88:if needed 71:Be polite 21:talk page 2384:Cheers.— 2262:Cheers.— 2172:cbignore 2083:unsigned 1664:card. -- 1471:Nunh-huh 1433:Nunh-huh 1408:Nunh-huh 841:American 627:Starling 561:Coal tit 439:Plushcap 433:Copyedit 56:get help 29:This is 27:article. 2322:tag to 2294:my edit 2272::Online 2201:checked 2166:my edit 2118:Munin75 2059:Huh??? 2025:Hroðulf 2003:Hroðulf 1906:Hroðulf 1825:beaks! 1766:Mtpaley 1751:Mtpaley 1708:Urbanus 1666:Hroðulf 1088:on the 799:on the 610:Fregata 604:Pytilia 403:Cleanup 351:history 320:on the 199:B-class 154:WP refs 142:scholar 2314:Added 2180:nobots 1890:ANANAS 1884:KINKKU 1588:Gronky 1530:Gronky 1387:source 1168:Keeves 1161:says: 1159:Summer 1141:Mawich 833:French 772:France 763:France 719:France 689:, and 639:Wikify 619:Darter 585:Verify 555:Update 459:Expand 205:scale. 126:Google 1698:Polpo 1516:Kizor 1359:Lebel 1348:Score 1177:Otije 1150:Otije 660:Other 525:Stubs 361:purge 356:watch 335:To-do 293:Birds 228:Birds 169:JSTOR 130:books 84:Seek 2205:true 2143:talk 2122:talk 2091:talk 2065:talk 2029:Talk 2007:Talk 1910:Talk 1867:Talk 1781:talk 1670:Talk 1450:talk 1389:and 1368:huh? 1311:Case 1258:Case 1250:imdb 1202:Name 1194:Walt 904:Film 889:and 837:Core 824:Film 653:more 631:more 577:more 547:more 517:more 499:NPOV 491:more 451:more 425:more 395:more 346:edit 162:FENS 136:news 73:and 2352:RfC 2308:to 2230:RfC 2192:to 1996:BLP 1835:DPM 1212:The 1080:Mid 791:Mid 312:Mid 176:TWL 2410:: 2365:. 2360:}} 2356:{{ 2320:}} 2316:{{ 2243:. 2238:}} 2234:{{ 2178:{{ 2174:}} 2170:{{ 2145:) 2124:) 2093:) 2067:) 2031:) 2023:-- 2009:) 2001:-- 1912:) 1887:• 1880:-- 1865:| 1783:) 1672:) 1514:-- 1452:) 1166:-- 1116:). 1021:: 839:/ 835:/ 831:/ 827:: 693:. 685:, 647:• 625:• 621:• 617:• 613:• 607:• 601:• 597:• 593:• 571:• 567:• 563:• 541:• 537:• 533:• 511:• 507:• 485:• 481:• 475:• 471:• 467:• 445:• 441:• 419:• 415:• 411:• 156:) 54:; 2397:) 2393:( 2380:. 2373:. 2258:. 2251:. 2141:( 2120:( 2089:( 2063:( 1779:( 1448:( 1309:. 1092:. 997:. 977:. 957:. 937:. 901:. 803:. 668:( 662:: 655:) 651:( 642:: 633:) 629:( 588:: 579:) 575:( 558:: 549:) 545:( 528:: 519:) 515:( 502:: 493:) 489:( 462:: 453:) 449:( 436:: 427:) 423:( 406:: 397:) 393:( 388:: 337:: 324:. 211:: 172:· 166:· 158:· 151:· 145:· 139:· 133:· 128:( 58:.

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.

Index