744:, noted in 1990 that the circumscription theory is applicable for the global system. Since the modern world system, being global, is completely circumscribed, the factor of circumscription is supposed to bring about the political unification of the world as it had done on regional scales on numerous occasions in the past. The thesis was further developed by historian Max Ostrovsky who widely used the circumscription theory in his book. The works of Chase-Dunn and Ostrovsky linked the circumscription theory with Carneiro's other theory of the political unification of the world. In the "Foreword" to Ostrovsky's book Carneiro acknowledges that he unjustly "abandoned" the circumscription theory in the Bronze Age. Carneiro's later interview contains his answer on the intriguing question, "Are we circumscribed now?"
715:, on the ground that considerable contrary evidence can be found to Carneiro's theory. There are also cases of circumscribed environments and violent cultures which have failed to develop states, for example in the narrow highland valleys of interior Papua New Guinea, or the north west Pacific coastlines of North America. Also for example, the formation of some early states in East Africa, Sri Lanka, and Polynesia do not easily fit with Carneiro's model. Hence Claessen's school developed a "complex interaction model" to explain early state formation, in which factors such as ecology, social and demographic structures, economic conditions, conflicts, and ideology become aligned in ways which favour state organisation.
703:
surplus is, under
Carneiro's hypothesis, a causal factor in the origins of the State. For example, the mountainous river valleys of Peru which descend to the Pacific coast were severely environmentally circumscribed. Amazonian populations could always disperse and maintain sparse contact with other, potentially hostile, neighbors, whereas Andean coastal populations could not.
702:
The presumption, under the
Carneiro Hypothesis, is that agricultural intensification, and the social coordination and coercion necessary to achieve this end was a result of warfare in which vanquished populations could not disperse; the coercive coordination necessary for increased production of
683:
If there is no environmental circumscription, then losers in a war can migrate out from the region and settle somewhere else. If there is environmental circumscription, then losers in warfare are forced to submit to their conquerors, because migration is not an option and the populations of the
675:
The theory begins with some assumptions. Warfare usually disperses people rather than uniting them. Environmental circumscription occurs when an area of productive agricultural land is surrounded by a less productive area such as the mountains, desert, or sea. Application of
727:
can act as a lower level impetus for tribal conflict than geographic circumscription. He has also argued that, in addition to the necessities of conquest, a more important reason for creation of chiefdoms was the rise of war chiefs who use their military loyalists to
684:
conquered and conqueror are united. The new state organization strives to alleviate the population pressure by increasing the productive capacity of agricultural land through, for instance, more intensive cultivation using irrigation.
275:
769:
Graber, Robert B., and Paul Roscoe, “Introduction: Circumscription and the
Evolution of Society,” American Behavioral Scientist, vol. 31, no. 4, pp. 406, March/April 1988.
634:
292:
667:
led to warfare that resulted in the evolution of the state”. The more circumscribed an agricultural area is, Carneiro argues, the sooner it politically unifies.
699:
occurred in states that developed from contact with already existing states. Primary state development occurred in areas with environmental circumscription.
562:
280:
782:
582:
323:
695:
occurred in the six original states of the Nile Valley, Peru, Mesoamerican, Yellow River Valley China, Indus River Valley, and
Mesopotamia.
627:
760:
Schacht, Robert M., “Circumscription Theory: A Critical Review,” American
Behavioral Scientist, vol. 31, no. 4, pp. 439, March/April 1988.
1031:
1021:
556:
1026:
1006:
620:
1001:
711:
Carneiro's theory has been criticized by the Dutch "early state school" emerging in the 1970s around cultural anthropologist
418:
257:
1016:
128:
1011:
736:. The theory also has since been applied to many other contexts, such as the Zulu kingdom. One of leading experts on
589:
812:
245:
863:
Carneiro, Robert. (2004). "The political unification of the world: whether, when, and how—some speculations,"
546:
309:
663:. The theory has been summarized in one sentence by Schacht: “In areas of circumscribed agricultural land,
741:
656:
113:
44:
35:
850:
Carneiro, Robert. (1990). "Political expansion as expression of the principle of competitive exclusion,"
677:
610:
398:
824:
Chase-Dunn, Christopher. (1990). "World-state formation: historical processes and emergent necessity."
17:
1036:
923:
712:
403:
378:
133:
737:
664:
606:
947:
799:
660:
541:
443:
373:
162:
99:
49:
939:
813:“Warfare, Political Leadership, and State Formation: The Case of the Zulu Kingdom, 1808-1879.”
368:
353:
348:
931:
779:
513:
503:
483:
473:
733:
652:
551:
508:
463:
448:
393:
143:
75:
70:
927:
729:
498:
488:
478:
423:
216:
995:
723:
Carneiro has since revised his theory in various ways. He has argued that population
493:
428:
388:
383:
363:
251:
211:
206:
192:
182:
177:
80:
951:
468:
458:
453:
413:
408:
358:
157:
138:
969:, Second Edition. Westport Connecticut, London: Bergin and Garvey, pp. 54–55.
783:
Circumscription Theory of the
Origins of the State: A Cross-Cultural Re-Analysis.
935:
438:
433:
986:
890:
330:
123:
118:
800:
The
Circumscription Theory: A Clarification, Amplification, and Reformulation
518:
187:
90:
943:
172:
895:
94:
974:
Structural change; evolution and evolutionism in cultural anthropology
167:
85:
914:
Carneiro, R. L. (1970). "A Theory of the Origin of the State".
962:. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, 2000.
854:, ed. J. Haas, New York: Cambridge University Press.
960:The Muse of History and the Science of Culture
628:
8:
802:. Social Evolution & History 11(2): 5–30
987:Video on Carneiro's Circumscription Theory
680:would bring severely diminishing returns.
635:
621:
563:Network Analysis and Ethnographic Problems
29:
880:, (Lanham: University Press of America).
841:, (Lanham: University Press of America).
967:Political anthropology: An Introduction
753:
688:Primary and secondary state development
651:is a theory of the role of warfare in
583:Political and Legal Anthropology Review
43:
876:Carneiro, Robert. (2007). "Foreword,"
239:Societies without hierarchical leaders
18:Carneiro's circumscription theory
778:For some other criticisms see, e.g.,
7:
25:
557:Political economy in anthropology
878:The Hyperbola of the World Order
839:The Hyperbola of the World Order
719:Later development and revision
419:Numa Denis Fustel de Coulanges
1:
826:Political Geography Quarterly
730:take over a group of villages
590:Journal of Legal Anthropology
258:The Art of Not Being Governed
936:10.1126/science.169.3947.733
837:Max Ostrovsky, Max. (2007).
659:, created by anthropologist
697:Secondary state development
1053:
891:"Profile: Robert Carneiro"
596:Journal of Law and Society
316:Colonialism and resistance
693:Primary state development
270:Non-western state systems
246:African Political Systems
1032:Environmental humanities
1022:Anthropological theories
815:Ethnology 38(4):371-391.
798:Carneiro, Robert. 2012.
965:Lewellen, Ted C. 1992.
865:Cross-Cultural Research
811:Deflem, Mathieu. 1999.
295:and the State in Africa
1027:Political anthropology
1007:Historical determinism
742:Christopher Chase-Dunn
657:political anthropology
649:circumscription theory
537:Circumscription theory
324:Europe and the People
293:Technology, Tradition,
1002:Cultural anthropology
678:extensive agriculture
611:cultural anthropology
399:E. E. Evans-Pritchard
252:Papuan Big man system
976:. Leyden: CNWS, 2000
404:Wolfgang Fikentscher
379:Henri J. M. Claessen
134:Pantribal sodalities
1017:Theories of history
972:Claessen, H. J. M,
928:1970Sci...169..733C
787:7/2 (2016): 187–203
738:world-system theory
713:Henri J.M. Claessen
671:The theory in brief
665:population pressure
547:Left–right paradigm
1012:Political theories
542:Legal anthropology
444:Thomas Blom Hansen
374:Robert L. Carneiro
163:Segmentary lineage
100:Leveling mechanism
50:legal anthropology
922:(3947): 733–738.
828:, 9(2), 108-130).
645:
644:
369:Jeremy Boissevain
354:Georges Balandier
349:E. Adamson Hoebel
16:(Redirected from
1044:
958:Carneiro, R. L.
955:
901:
900:
887:
881:
874:
868:
867:, 38(2):162-177.
861:
855:
848:
842:
835:
829:
822:
816:
809:
803:
796:
790:
776:
770:
767:
761:
758:
734:paramount chiefs
637:
630:
623:
531:Related articles
514:Douglas R. White
504:Jonathan Spencer
484:Marshall Sahlins
474:Sally Falk Moore
30:
27:Political theory
21:
1052:
1051:
1047:
1046:
1045:
1043:
1042:
1041:
992:
991:
983:
913:
910:
905:
904:
889:
888:
884:
875:
871:
862:
858:
849:
845:
836:
832:
823:
819:
810:
806:
797:
793:
777:
773:
768:
764:
759:
755:
750:
721:
709:
690:
673:
661:Robert Carneiro
653:state formation
641:
601:
600:
577:
569:
568:
552:State formation
532:
524:
523:
509:Bjorn Thomassen
464:Elizabeth Mertz
449:Ted C. Lewellen
394:Pierre Clastres
344:
343:Major theorists
336:
335:
326:Without History
325:
294:
230:
222:
221:
144:Paramount chief
76:Achieved status
71:Ascribed status
63:Status and rank
59:
48:
28:
23:
22:
15:
12:
11:
5:
1050:
1048:
1040:
1039:
1034:
1029:
1024:
1019:
1014:
1009:
1004:
994:
993:
990:
989:
982:
981:External links
979:
978:
977:
970:
963:
956:
909:
906:
903:
902:
882:
869:
856:
843:
830:
817:
804:
791:
771:
762:
752:
751:
749:
746:
720:
717:
708:
705:
689:
686:
672:
669:
643:
642:
640:
639:
632:
625:
617:
614:
613:
603:
602:
599:
598:
593:
586:
578:
575:
574:
571:
570:
567:
566:
559:
554:
549:
544:
539:
533:
530:
529:
526:
525:
522:
521:
516:
511:
506:
501:
499:Aidan Southall
496:
491:
489:James C. Scott
486:
481:
479:Rodney Needham
476:
471:
466:
461:
456:
451:
446:
441:
436:
431:
426:
424:Ernest Gellner
421:
416:
411:
406:
401:
396:
391:
386:
381:
376:
371:
366:
361:
356:
351:
345:
342:
341:
338:
337:
334:
333:
328:
320:
319:
317:
313:
312:
306:
305:
303:
299:
298:
288:
287:
284:
283:
278:
272:
271:
268:
266:
262:
261:
254:
249:
241:
240:
237:
235:
231:
228:
227:
224:
223:
220:
219:
217:Ritual warfare
214:
209:
203:
202:
200:
199:Law and custom
196:
195:
190:
185:
180:
175:
170:
165:
160:
154:
153:
151:
147:
146:
141:
136:
131:
126:
121:
116:
110:
109:
107:
103:
102:
97:
88:
83:
78:
73:
67:
66:
64:
60:
58:Basic concepts
57:
56:
53:
52:
41:
40:
26:
24:
14:
13:
10:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
1049:
1038:
1035:
1033:
1030:
1028:
1025:
1023:
1020:
1018:
1015:
1013:
1010:
1008:
1005:
1003:
1000:
999:
997:
988:
985:
984:
980:
975:
971:
968:
964:
961:
957:
953:
949:
945:
941:
937:
933:
929:
925:
921:
917:
912:
911:
907:
898:
897:
892:
886:
883:
879:
873:
870:
866:
860:
857:
853:
847:
844:
840:
834:
831:
827:
821:
818:
814:
808:
805:
801:
795:
792:
788:
786:
781:
775:
772:
766:
763:
757:
754:
747:
745:
743:
739:
735:
731:
726:
725:concentration
718:
716:
714:
706:
704:
700:
698:
694:
687:
685:
681:
679:
670:
668:
666:
662:
658:
654:
650:
638:
633:
631:
626:
624:
619:
618:
616:
615:
612:
608:
605:
604:
597:
594:
592:
591:
587:
585:
584:
580:
579:
573:
572:
565:
564:
560:
558:
555:
553:
550:
548:
545:
543:
540:
538:
535:
534:
528:
527:
520:
517:
515:
512:
510:
507:
505:
502:
500:
497:
495:
494:Elman Service
492:
490:
487:
485:
482:
480:
477:
475:
472:
470:
467:
465:
462:
460:
457:
455:
452:
450:
447:
445:
442:
440:
437:
435:
432:
430:
429:David Graeber
427:
425:
422:
420:
417:
415:
412:
410:
407:
405:
402:
400:
397:
395:
392:
390:
389:John Comaroff
387:
385:
384:Jean Comaroff
382:
380:
377:
375:
372:
370:
367:
365:
364:Fredrik Barth
362:
360:
357:
355:
352:
350:
347:
346:
340:
339:
332:
329:
327:
322:
321:
318:
315:
314:
311:
308:
307:
304:
302:Legal systems
301:
300:
297:
296:
290:
289:
286:
285:
282:
279:
277:
274:
273:
269:
267:
264:
263:
260:
259:
255:
253:
250:
248:
247:
243:
242:
238:
236:
233:
232:
226:
225:
218:
215:
213:
212:Legal culture
210:
208:
207:Customary law
205:
204:
201:
198:
197:
194:
193:Theatre state
191:
189:
186:
184:
183:House society
181:
179:
178:Petty kingdom
176:
174:
171:
169:
166:
164:
161:
159:
156:
155:
152:
149:
148:
145:
142:
140:
137:
135:
132:
130:
127:
125:
122:
120:
117:
115:
112:
111:
108:
105:
104:
101:
98:
96:
92:
89:
87:
84:
82:
81:Social status
79:
77:
74:
72:
69:
68:
65:
62:
61:
55:
54:
51:
46:
42:
39:
37:
32:
31:
19:
973:
966:
959:
919:
915:
908:Bibliography
894:
885:
877:
872:
864:
859:
852:Studying War
851:
846:
838:
833:
825:
820:
807:
794:
785:Cliodynamics
784:
780:Korotayev A.
774:
765:
756:
724:
722:
710:
701:
696:
692:
691:
682:
674:
648:
646:
595:
588:
581:
561:
536:
469:Sidney Mintz
459:Ralph Linton
454:Edmund Leach
414:Morton Fried
409:Meyer Fortes
359:F. G. Bailey
291:
256:
244:
229:Case studies
188:Ethnic group
158:Band society
33:
1037:Geopolitics
732:and become
439:Ulf Hannerz
434:Lesley Gill
996:Categories
748:References
331:Cargo cult
234:Acephelous
124:Matriarchy
119:Patriarchy
106:Leadership
707:Criticism
519:Eric Wolf
91:Age grade
45:Political
952:11536431
944:17820299
576:Journals
173:Chiefdom
150:Polities
36:a series
34:Part of
924:Bibcode
916:Science
896:YouTube
281:Mandala
114:Big man
95:Age set
950:
942:
607:Social
276:Negara
948:S2CID
265:State
168:Tribe
139:Chief
129:Elder
86:Caste
940:PMID
647:The
609:and
310:Kapu
932:doi
920:169
655:in
47:and
998::
946:.
938:.
930:.
918:.
893:.
740:,
38:on
954:.
934::
926::
899:.
789:.
636:e
629:t
622:v
93:/
20:)
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.