November 20
This is a list of redirects that have been proposed for deletion or other action on November 20, 2014.
Directorate-General for Budget
Relisted, see Knowledge (XXG):Redirects for discussion/Log/2014 December 12#Directorate-General for Budget
Wrestlers who have wrestled under the name Sin Cara
- The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more redirects. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the redirect's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.
- The result of the discussion was keep. --BDD (talk) 19:20, 11 December 2014 (UTC)
Almost comically implausible name for a redirect. There are two "wrestlers who have wrestled" (!!) as Sin Cara, and both are unsurprisingly detailed on the article entitled.... (wait for it....) Sin Cara. ŞůṜīΣĻ¹98¹ 09:10, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
- Keep. This is a standard {{R from move}} and it is consistently getting 20-40 hits each month (I checked all the way back to January) suggesting that this is linked from somewhere external to Knowledge (XXG). It is an unusual name, but that alone doesn't make it implausible, and the target article is the correct one. Deletion would be harmful to the encyclopaedia while bringing no benefits. Thryduulf (talk) 12:33, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
- Keep - bit of a mouthful, but clearly sends readers to what they're looking for. WilyD 15:35, 21 November 2014 (UTC)
- Keep kinda weird but still plausible. Lucha libre masks are a big deal in this sport. --Lenticel 00:34, 24 November 2014 (UTC)
- The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page.
List of islands of North Korea
- The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more redirects. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the redirect's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.
- The result of the discussion was keep. --BDD (talk) 19:24, 11 December 2014 (UTC)
The target currently only covers South Korean islands, I have requested a move at Knowledge (XXG):Requested moves/Technical requests - TheChampionMan1234 07:39, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
Close without prejudice. It is disputed at Talk:List of islands of Korea that the article only covers South Korea, so this discussion should be closed pending the result of the move discussion. Thryduulf (talk) 12:39, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
- Keep - Knowledge (XXG) is a work in progress, this is a SO-FIX-IT problem. Requests to undermine the goal of writing an encyclopaedia are not welcome. WilyD 12:45, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
- Keep - There are at least some North Korean islands included on the target article, and the rest should be added. Neelix (talk) 15:56, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
- Refuse jurisdiction, somewhat per above (which is to say, close without prejudice). If it is discussed elsewhere it does no good to discuss it here. The remedy is to climb down from the bench and discuss it there, inter pares.Si Trew (talk) 14:56, 24 November 2014 (UTC)
- The move discussion closed as no consensus to move, so the North Korean islands have remained on the target list and this redirect remains a valuable one. There is no longer a reason to have this redirect deleted. Neelix (talk) 20:07, 4 December 2014 (UTC)
- The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page.
Internal Audit Service
- The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more redirects. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the redirect's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.
- The result of the discussion was move Draft:Internal Audit Service over the redirect. Thanks, Si! --BDD (talk) 02:37, 12 December 2014 (UTC)
This is a redirect from an extremely generic title to the service of one particular organization. It will not help the reader. DGG ( talk ) 07:34, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
- The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page.
Several redirects that have wiki markup in their titles
- The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more redirects. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the redirect's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.
- The result of the discussion was delete (all). This is a bit unusual, but anyone who feels that Knowledge (XXG) is truly worse off without any one of these should feel free to create that redirect. Within a month or so, it may make sense to discuss it individually. While I appreciate bundled nominations, this one is perhaps too much, and I hope editors will pardon my perhaps too blunt solution. --BDD (talk) 19:29, 11 December 2014 (UTC)
This nomination contains 357 redirects.
|
- '' → Quotation mark (links · history · stats)
- '''Tis the Season'' (Vince Gill and Olivia Newton-John album) → 'Tis the Season (Vince Gill and Olivia Newton-John album) (links · history · stats)
- ''...And Then I Wrote'' → ...And Then I Wrote (links · history · stats)
- ''12'' (2003 film) → 12 (2003 film) (links · history · stats)
- ''ALF'' → ALF (TV series) (links · history · stats)
- ''ANC Today'' → ANC Today (links · history · stats)
- ''A Soldier's Rosary'' → A Soldier's Rosary (links · history · stats)
- ''Aechmea nudicaulis'' 'Parati' → Aechmea nudicaulis 'Parati' (links · history · stats)
- ''Aeromonas aquariorum'' → Aeromonas aquariorum (links · history · stats)
- ''Affluenza'' → Affluenza (disambiguation) (links · history · stats)
- ''Affluenza'' (2014) → Affluenza (film) (links · history · stats)
- ''Afroedura transvaalica'' → Afroedura transvaalica (links · history · stats)
- ''Al-Hidayah'' → Al-Hidayah (book) (links · history · stats)
- ''Aladdin'' (musical) → Aladdin (disambiguation) (links · history · stats)
- ''Alishewanella fetalis'' → Alishewanella fetalis (links · history · stats)
- ''All Hung up in Your Green Eyes'' → All Hung up in Your Green Eyes (links · history · stats)
- ''American Diplomacy'' → American Diplomacy (links · history · stats)
- ''Animal Welfare'' (journal) → Animal Welfare (journal) (links · history · stats)
- ''Appalam'' → Appalam (film) (links · history · stats)
- ''Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.'' → Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (links · history · stats)
- ''Arothron caeruleopunctatus'' → Arothron caeruleopunctatus (links · history · stats)
- ''Asan'' → Asan (disambiguation) (links · history · stats)
- ''Audioscopiks'' → Audioscopiks (links · history · stats)
- ''Auto-Emancipation'' → Auto-Emancipation (links · history · stats)
- ''Back to the Future'' timeline → Back to the Future (franchise) (links · history · stats)
- ''Bakit Hindi Ka Crush Ng Crush Mo?'' → Bakit Hindi Ka Crush Ng Crush Mo (links · history · stats)
- ''Bank Chor'' (film) → Vivek Oberoi (links · history · stats)
- ''Batlló Majestat'' → Batlló Majesty (links · history · stats)
- ''Beautiful Minds (documentary series)'' → Beautiful Minds (documentary series) (links · history · stats)
- ''Bigfoot'' (TV series) → Bigfoot (TV series) (links · history · stats)
- ''Birds of Prey'' (1973 film) → Birds of Prey (1973 film) (links · history · stats)
- ''Black Feminist Thought: Knowledge, Consciousness and the Politics of Empowerment'' → Black Feminist Thought (links · history · stats)
- ''Blade Runner (a movie)'' (novella) → Blade Runner (a movie) (links · history · stats)
- ''Block "FACT" → Block FACT (links · history · stats)
- ''Breach'' → Breach (links · history · stats)
- ''Breach of Peace: Portraits of the 1961 Mississippi Freedom Riders'' → Breach of Peace (book) (links · history · stats)
- ''Breakout Nations: In Pursuit of the Next Economic Miracles'' → Breakout Nations (links · history · stats)
- ''Bright Penny'' → Bright Penny (links · history · stats)
- ''Brooksmith'' → Brooksmith (links · history · stats)
- ''Bubba Ho-Tep'' (novella) → Bubba Ho-Tep (novella) (links · history · stats)
- ''Buildings of the United States'' → Buildings of the United States (links · history · stats)
- ''Burçak Tarlası'' (song) → Burçak Tarlası (links · history · stats)
- ''Burçak Tarlası ''(song) → Burçak Tarlası (links · history · stats)
- ''Byron'' (schooner) Shipwreck → Byron shipwreck (links · history · stats)
- ''C'' California Style (magazine) → C California Style Magazine (links · history · stats)
- ''COL4A1'' → Collagen, type IV, alpha 1 (links · history · stats)
- ''COL4A1'' mutation → Collagen, type IV, alpha 1 (links · history · stats)
- ''Cake'' → Cake (disambiguation) (links · history · stats)
- ''Callyspongia vaginalis'' → Callyspongia vaginalis (links · history · stats)
- ''Canang sari'' → Canang sari (links · history · stats)
- ''Cansumys'' → Gansu hamster (links · history · stats)
- ''Capital in the Twenty-First Century'' → Capital in the Twenty-First Century (links · history · stats)
- ''Cardinal Burns'' → Cardinal Burns (links · history · stats)
- ''Charlebury'' → SS Charlebury (links · history · stats)
- ''Charmed'' (comic book) → Charmed (comics) (links · history · stats)
- ''Chilango'' → Chilango (links · history · stats)
- ''Chlamydera maculata'' → Spotted bowerbird (links · history · stats)
- ''Chlorobium chlorochromatii'' → Chlorobium chlorochromatii (links · history · stats)
- ''Cognitive Neuroscience'' → Cognitive Neuroscience (journal) (links · history · stats)
- ''Colombo Post'' → Colombo Post (links · history · stats)
- ''Contemporary Japan'' → Contemporary Japan (links · history · stats)
- ''Corrupt and Immoral Transmissions'' → Corrupt and Immoral Transmissions (links · history · stats)
- ''Costa Concordia'' disaster → Costa Concordia disaster (links · history · stats)
- ''Crain's Chicago Business'' → Crain's Chicago Business (links · history · stats)
- ''Culrain'' → SS Empire Darwin (links · history · stats)
- ''Cumhuriyet Bayramı'' → Republic Day (Turkey) (links · history · stats)
- ''Curiosity'' (Mars rover) → Curiosity (rover) (links · history · stats)
- ''Curiosity'' rover → Curiosity (rover) (links · history · stats)
- ''Curve'' (design magazine) → Curve (design magazine) (links · history · stats)
- ''Cutters Don't Cry'' → Cutters Don't Cry (links · history · stats)
- ''Cynara'' (Delius) → Cynara (Delius) (links · history · stats)
- ''Dago Red'' (racing aircraft) → Dago Red (links · history · stats)
- ''Dakshina Halasyam'' → Thennangur (links · history · stats)
- ''Dallas Spirit'' → Dallas Spirit (links · history · stats)
- ''Dancer'' (novel) → Dancer (novel) (links · history · stats)
- ''Dark Matters: Twisted But True'' → Dark Matters: Twisted But True (links · history · stats)
- ''Dave's Dream'' (B-29) → Big Stink (aircraft) (links · history · stats)
- ''Deliver'' (album) → Delivery (links · history · stats)
- ''Democracy and Totalitarianism'' (book) → Democracy and Totalitarianism (links · history · stats)
- ''Diana of Dobson's'' → Diana of Dobson's (links · history · stats)
- ''Diary of a Nymphomaniac'' → Diary of a Nymphomaniac (links · history · stats)
- ''Diggs Nightcrawler'' → Diggs Nightcrawler (links · history · stats)
- ''Dolphin'' → Dolphin (disambiguation) (links · history · stats)
- ''Dr. Chris: Pet Vet'' → Bondi Vet (links · history · stats)
- ''Dr. Seuss' How the Grinch Stole Christmas'' (film) → Dr. Seuss' How the Grinch Stole Christmas (film) (links · history · stats)
- ''Dying Light'' → Dying Light (links · history · stats)
- ''E. crebra'' → Eucalyptus crebra (links · history · stats)
- ''E. melanophloia'' → Eucalyptus melanophloia (links · history · stats)
- ''E. polycarpa'' → Corymbia polycarpa (links · history · stats)
- ''Elasmosaurus'' → Elasmosaurus (links · history · stats)
- ''Elevation'' → Elevation (disambiguation) (links · history · stats)
- ''Empress of Ireland'' → RMS Empress of Ireland (links · history · stats)
- ''En Purushan Kuzhandhai Maathiri'' → En Purushan Kuzhandhai Maadhiri (links · history · stats)
- ''Encyclopedia of Library and Information Science'' → Encyclopedia of Library and Information Sciences (links · history · stats)
- ''Epithalamion'' → Epithalamion (poem) (links · history · stats)
- ''Escadrille SPA.57'' → Escadrille SPA.57 (links · history · stats)
- ''Escape From Davao: The Forgotten Story of the Most Daring Prison Break of the Pacific War.'' → Escape from Davao (links · history · stats)
- ''Everything, I Bet You'' → The Honeydogs (links · history · stats)
- ''FIFI'' (aircraft) → FIFI (aircraft) (links · history · stats)
- ''Fight of the Century'' → Fight of the Century (links · history · stats)
- ''Fiji Focus'' → Fiji Focus (links · history · stats)
- ''Finding Fela'' → Finding Fela (links · history · stats)
- ''Flora in Uruguay'' → Flora of Uruguay (links · history · stats)
- ''Food of Love'' (2002 Film) → Food of Love (2002 film) (links · history · stats)
- ''Forgive Me'' (2013 TV series) → Forgive Me (TV series) (links · history · stats)
- ''Frames'' (Lee DeWyze album) → Frames (Lee DeWyze album) (links · history · stats)
- ''Friday or Another Day'' → Friday or Another Day (links · history · stats)
- ''G.R.L.'' → G.R.L. (EP) (links · history · stats)
- ''Gabriele D' Annunzio'' University of Chieti Pescara → Gabriele D'Annunzio University of Chieti Pescara (links · history · stats)
- ''Game Grumps'' → Game Grumps (links · history · stats)
- ''Game of Thrones'' (2014 video game) → Game of Thrones (2014 video game) (links · history · stats)
- ''Gemeindepolizei (Nazi Germany)'' → Gemeindepolizei (Nazi Germany) (links · history · stats)
- ''Girl in Red Tights'' → Girl in Red Tights (links · history · stats)
- ''Girls & Peace'' → Girls & Peace (links · history · stats)
- ''Glee'' Cast → Glee (TV series) (links · history · stats)
- ''Gnomonia fructicola'' → Gnomonia fructicola (links · history · stats)
- ''HYPERPOWER!'' → Year Zero (album) (links · history · stats)
- ''Half-Life: Source'' → Half-Life: Source (links · history · stats)
- ''Halo 4 Original Soundtrack'' → Halo 4 Original Soundtrack (links · history · stats)
- ''Hanggang Ngayon'' → Hanggang Ngayon (links · history · stats)
- ''Hello, world!'' program → "Hello, world!" program (links · history · stats)
- ''Hetty Taylor'' (shipwreck) → Hetty Taylor shipwreck (links · history · stats)
- ''Hibernia'' (ship) → Hibernia (ship) (links · history · stats)
- ''History of the Jews in Morocco → History of the Jews in Morocco (links · history · stats)
- ''Hocutt v. Wilson'' → Hocutt v. Wilson (links · history · stats)
- ''Holy Shit'' → Holy shit (links · history · stats)
- ''Hot off the Wire'' → The Jim Backus Show (links · history · stats)
- ''I Guess I Like It Like That'' → I Guess I Like It Like That (links · history · stats)
- ''I Love Your Glasses'' (2008) → I Love Your Glasses (links · history · stats)
- ''In Bed'' → In Bed (film) (links · history · stats)
- ''In the Family'' (2011 film) → In the Family (2011 film) (links · history · stats)
- ''In the Family'' (film) → In the Family (links · history · stats)
- ''Incident at Victoria Falls'' → Incident at Victoria Falls (links · history · stats)
- ''Indra's Net: Defending Hinduism's Philosophical Unity'' → Indra's Net (book) (links · history · stats)
- ''Infinity Ring'' series → Infinity Ring (links · history · stats)
- ''Isabel Erica'' → Isabel Erica (links · history · stats)
- ''It's A Matter Of... - EP'' → It's a Matter Of... (links · history · stats)
- ''It's Geek 2 Me'' → It's Geek 2 Me (links · history · stats)
- ''Italy 1990'' (Video Game) → Italy 1990 (video game) (links · history · stats)
- ''Jamie Oliver's 15 Minute Meals'' → Jamie's 15-Minute Meals (links · history · stats)
- ''Jesy Nelson'' → Little Mix (links · history · stats)
- ''Jinnah'' (1998 film) → Jinnah (film) (links · history · stats)
- ''Just a baby's prayer at twilight: for her daddy over there'' → Just A Baby's Prayer At Twilight (For Her Daddy Over There) (links · history · stats)
- ''K.Michelle: My Life'' → K. Michelle: My Life (links · history · stats)
- ''Kaç Kaç'' incident → Kaç Kaç incident (links · history · stats)
- ''Kaşık Havası'' → Kaşık Havası (links · history · stats)
- ''Keep Your Head Up, Kid: The Don Cherry Story'' → Keep Your Head Up, Kid: The Don Cherry Story (links · history · stats)
- ''Kill Your Darlings'' → Kill Your Darlings (links · history · stats)
- ''Killing the Black Body: Race, Reproduction, and the Meaning of Liberty'' → Dorothy Roberts (links · history · stats)
- ''Kuni-ezu'' → Kuniezu (links · history · stats)
- ''Kusa Pabha'' → Kusa Pabha (links · history · stats)
- ''L'Oiseau Blanc'' → L'Oiseau Blanc (links · history · stats)
- ''L'isola dei famosi'' → L'Isola dei Famosi (links · history · stats)
- ''L'Équipe'' (TV series) → The Team (TV series) (links · history · stats)
- ''La Bella Principessa'' → Portrait of a Young Fiancée (links · history · stats)
- ''La Perla del Sur'' → La Perla del Sur (links · history · stats)
- ''La leggierezza'' → Three Concert Études (Liszt) (links · history · stats)
- ''La petite Aurore l’enfant martyre'' → Little Aurore's Tragedy (links · history · stats)
- ''Lactifluus vellereus'' → Lactifluus vellereus (links · history · stats)
- ''Leigh-Anne Pinnock'' → Little Mix (links · history · stats)
- ''Leiothlypis virginiae'' → Virginia's warbler (links · history · stats)
- ''Leptanilla japonica'' → Leptanilla japonica (links · history · stats)
- ''Les fleurs dédaignées'' → Les fleurs dédaignées (links · history · stats)
- ''Let's Go'' travel guides → Let's Go travel guides (links · history · stats)
- ''Light in Darkness'' → Light in Darkness (links · history · stats)
- ''Limited Collectors' Edition'' (comics) → Limited Collectors' Edition (comics) (links · history · stats)
- ''Lio'' → Lio (album) (links · history · stats)
- ''List of Episodes of Bob and Margaret'' → Bob and Margaret (links · history · stats)
- ''List of The 13 Ghost of Scooby-Doo'' episodes → List of The 13 Ghosts of Scooby-Doo episodes (links · history · stats)
- ''List of mesivtas → List of mesivtas (links · history · stats)
- ''Little Mary Mixup'' → Little Mary Mixup (links · history · stats)
- ''Look At Me Now'' → Look at Me Now (links · history · stats)
- ''Losing the Race'' → Losing the Race (links · history · stats)
- ''Love Changes Everything (song)'' → Love Changes Everything (song) (links · history · stats)
- ''Love the World'' (Perfume album) → Love the World (album) (links · history · stats)
- ''MSB'' → MSB (album) (links · history · stats)
- ''Mabo'' (TV film) → Mabo (film) (links · history · stats)
- ''Mail Delivery'' (Amateis) → Mail Delivery (sculptures) (links · history · stats)
- ''Malarus melanocephalus → Red-backed fairywren (links · history · stats)
- ''Malarus melanocephalus'' → Red-backed fairywren (links · history · stats)
- ''Malurus cyaneus'' → Superb fairywren (links · history · stats)
- ''Malurus lamberti'' → Variegated fairywren (links · history · stats)
- ''Man Made Language' → Man Made Language (links · history · stats)
- ''Mauritius'' (play) → Mauritius (play) (links · history · stats)
- ''Maybe This Christmas'' → Maybe This Christmas (links · history · stats)
- ''Melanotaenia fluviatilis'' → Melanotaenia fluviatilis (links · history · stats)
- ''Mersinidi'' → SS Empire Darwin (links · history · stats)
- ''Mind Warp'' → Mind Warp (links · history · stats)
- ''Mistakes Were Made (But Not by Me)'' → Mistakes Were Made (But Not by Me) (links · history · stats)
- ''More You Becomes You'' → More You Becomes You (links · history · stats)
- ''Mother Earth Father Sky'' → Ivory Carver Trilogy (links · history · stats)
- ''Mr. Robinson'' → Mr. Robinson (links · history · stats)
- ''Mr. Robinson'' (TV series) → Mr. Robinson (TV series) (links · history · stats)
- ''Mundus Subterraneus'' → Mundus Subterraneus (links · history · stats)
- ''Murder 2'' → Murder 2 (links · history · stats)
- ''My Teenage Wedding'' → My Teenage Wedding (links · history · stats)
- ''Mysterious Rain Jack'' → Mysterious Rain Jack (links · history · stats)
- ''Naughty but Nice'' → Naughty but Nice (links · history · stats)
- ''News of the World'' phone hacking affair → News International phone hacking scandal (links · history · stats)
- ''Night Work'' (film) → Night Work (film) (links · history · stats)
- ''Nine Little Teardrops'' → Nine Little Teardrops (links · history · stats)
- ''Non-Fiction'' (Ne-Yo album) → Ne-Yo discography (links · history · stats)
- ''Northumbria Student'' → Northumbria Student (links · history · stats)
- ''Nosferatu'' (genus) → Nosferatu (fish) (links · history · stats)
- ''Not After Midnight'' → Not After Midnight (links · history · stats)
- ''Notes from No Man's Land'' → Notes from No Man's Land (links · history · stats)
- ''Now The Swell'' → The Union Trade (links · history · stats)
- ''Octacube'' (sculpture) → Octacube (sculpture) (links · history · stats)
- ''Of Men and Mavericks'' (film) → Chasing Mavericks (links · history · stats)
- ''Oh! Carol'' (RCA Camden album) → Oh Carol (1974 album) (links · history · stats)
- ''Old New York'' → Old New York (novellas) (links · history · stats)
- ''One-Trick Pony'' (film) → One-Trick Pony (film) (links · history · stats)
- ''Orang-Outang, sive Homo Sylvestris: or, the Anatomy of a Pygmie Compared with that of a Monkey, an Ape, and a Man'' → Orang-Outang, sive Homo Sylvestris: or, the Anatomy of a Pygmie Compared with that of a Monkey, an Ape, and a Man (links · history · stats)
- ''Oxfordshire Guardian'' → Oxfordshire Guardian (links · history · stats)
- ''Palm Kingdoms'' → Palm Kingdoms (links · history · stats)
- ''Pan'' (magazine) → Pan (magazine) (links · history · stats)
- ''Pan American Unity'' → Pan American Unity (links · history · stats)
- ''Party in the Graveyard'' → Party in the Graveyard (links · history · stats)
- ''Państwowy Korpus Bezpieczeństwa'' → National Security Corps (links · history · stats)
- ''Peace, Love, & Misunderstanding'' → Peace, Love & Misunderstanding (links · history · stats)
- ''Perrie Edwards'' → Little Mix (links · history · stats)
- ''Pestonjee'' → Pestonjee (links · history · stats)
- ''Pick Up Sticks'' → Pick-Up Sticks (novel) (links · history · stats)
- ''Pinoy Big Brother: Double Up'' → Pinoy Big Brother: Double Up (links · history · stats)
- ''Plasmodium falciparum'' cell biology → Plasmodium falciparum biology (links · history · stats)
- ''Polythene: The Video Singles'' → Polythene: The Video Singles (links · history · stats)
- ''Pseudotsuga menziesii'' var. ''glauca'' → Pseudotsuga menziesii var. glauca (links · history · stats)
- ''Q'' magazine → Q (magazine) (links · history · stats)
- ''Random 1'' → Random 1 (links · history · stats)
- ''Red Sings from Treetops: A Year in Colors'' → Red Sings from Treetops: A Year in Colors (links · history · stats)
- ''Regina's Closet'' → Regina's Closet (links · history · stats)
- ''Rhodoferax'' → Rhodoferax (links · history · stats)
- ''Roseodendron'' → Roseodendron (links · history · stats)
- ''S. tawilis'' → Sardinella tawilis (links · history · stats)
- ''Safe Inside the Day'' → Safe Inside the Day (links · history · stats)
- ''Sammy Johns'' → Sammy Johns (album) (links · history · stats)
- ''Santa Maria dei Domenicani'' → Santa Maria dei Domenicani (links · history · stats)
- ''Sare Jahan se Accha'' → Sare Jahan se Accha (links · history · stats)
- ''Seen a Ghost'' → The Honeydogs (links · history · stats)
- ''Selamsız Bandosu'' → Selamsız Bandosu (links · history · stats)
- ''Señora'' → Señora (links · history · stats)
- ''Sh! The Octopus'' → Sh! The Octopus (links · history · stats)
- ''She'll Break Your Heart'' → She'll Break Your Heart (links · history · stats)
- ''She's Living for This'' → She's Living for This (links · history · stats)
- ''Shichisei Tōshin Guyferd'' → Shichisei Tōshin Guyferd (links · history · stats)
- ''Shoumei'' → Shoumei (links · history · stats)
- ''Siegfried'' August Maximilian Maria, Duke in Bavaria → Duke Siegfried August in Bavaria (links · history · stats)
- ''Simon Fowlers Merrymouth'' → Simon Fowler's Merrymouth (links · history · stats)
- ''Small Talk (Twenty Twenty Album) → Small Talk (Twenty Twenty album) (links · history · stats)
- ''Sopwith'' 1½ Strutter → Sopwith 1½ Strutter (links · history · stats)
- ''Southern Seas'' → Lyndonia (1920) (links · history · stats)
- ''Spirit'' rover → Spirit (rover) (links · history · stats)
- ''Star Wars: The Clone Wars'' (2008 TV series) → Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008 TV series) (links · history · stats)
- ''Stonewall Jackson's Greatest Hits'' → Stonewall Jackson's Greatest Hits (links · history · stats)
- ''Street Moves'' → Twenty 4 Seven (links · history · stats)
- ''Suitte d'un Goût Étranger'' → Suitte d'un Goût Étranger (links · history · stats)
- ''Surprise Surprise Surprise'' → Surprise Surprise Surprise (links · history · stats)
- ''Surrey Comet'' → Surrey Comet (links · history · stats)
- ''Swiftsure'' class submarine → Swiftsure-class submarine (links · history · stats)
- ''Switch'' Energy Project (film) → Switch Energy Project (film) (links · history · stats)
- ''Tamil Tigress'' → Tamil Tigress (links · history · stats)
- ''Tesakoviaspis concentrica'' → Tesakoviaspis concentrica (links · history · stats)
- ''Thatched Cottages and Houses'' (van Gogh) → Thatched Cottages and Houses (van Gogh) (links · history · stats)
- ''The American Review'' → The American Review (links · history · stats)
- ''The Battle's Almost Over'' → The Battle's Almost Over (links · history · stats)
- ''The Building of Skadar'' → The Building of Skadar (links · history · stats)
- ''The Cauldron'' → The Cauldron (links · history · stats)
- ''The Crisis of Democracy'' → The Crisis of Democracy (links · history · stats)
- ''The Crusader'' → The Crusader (links · history · stats)
- ''The Cure: "Reflections"'' → The Cure: 'Reflections' (links · history · stats)
- ''The Cure: Reflections' → The Cure: 'Reflections' (links · history · stats)
- ''The Devil & I'' → Lone Wolf (musician) (links · history · stats)
- ''The Due Return'' → Meow Wolf (links · history · stats)
- ''The Family: A Proclamation to the World'' → The Family: A Proclamation to the World (links · history · stats)
- ''The Family Friend'' (magazine) → The Family Friend (magazine) (links · history · stats)
- ''The Fifth Beatle'' (graphic novel) → The Fifth Beatle (graphic novel) (links · history · stats)
- ''The Flame'' → The Flame (links · history · stats)
- ''The Girl With No Shadow'' → The Lollipop Shoes (links · history · stats)
- ''The Glenn Miller Story'' (soundtrack) → The Glenn Miller Story (soundtrack) (links · history · stats)
- ''The Harry Potter Lexicon'' → The Harry Potter Lexicon (links · history · stats)
- ''The Honeydogs'' → The Honeydogs (links · history · stats)
- ''The Impressionist'' → The Impressionist (links · history · stats)
- ''The Jefferson Hour'' → The Thomas Jefferson Hour (links · history · stats)
- ''The Job'' (2013 TV series) → The Job (2013 TV series) (links · history · stats)
- ''The Judge Child'' → The Judge Child (links · history · stats)
- ''The Land of Lost Content'' → The Land of Lost Content (links · history · stats)
- ''The Last Battle'' (Ryan) → The Last Battle (Ryan) (links · history · stats)
- ''The Mercury'' (Pennsylvania) → The Mercury (Pennsylvania) (links · history · stats)
- ''The Message to the Planet'' → The Message to the Planet (links · history · stats)
- ''The Message to the Planet'' (novel) → The Message to the Planet (links · history · stats)
- ''The Mimic Men'' → The Mimic Men (links · history · stats)
- ''The Muleskinner'' → The Muleskinner (links · history · stats)
- ''The Natural History of Ireland'' → The Natural History of Ireland (links · history · stats)
- ''The New York Times'' Best Seller list → The New York Times Best Seller list (links · history · stats)
- ''The Night She Disappeared'' → The Night She Disappeared (links · history · stats)
- ''The Outcasts'' (1982 film) → The Outcasts (1982 film) (links · history · stats)
- ''The Outlaw Bible of American Poetry'' → The Outlaw Bible of American Poetry (links · history · stats)
- ''The Pagan Religions of the Ancient British Isles'' → The Pagan Religions of the Ancient British Isles (links · history · stats)
- ''The Positively True Adventures of the Alleged Texas Cheerleader-Murdering Mom'' → The Positively True Adventures of the Alleged Texas Cheerleader-Murdering Mom (links · history · stats)
- ''The Rite of Spring'' discography → The Rite of Spring discography (links · history · stats)
- ''The Saint'' (film series) → The Saint (film series) (links · history · stats)
- ''The Savage Frontier'' → The Savage Frontier (links · history · stats)
- ''The Search For King Solomon's Mines'' → The Search for King Solomon's Mines (links · history · stats)
- ''The Slim Princess'' (1915 film) → The Slim Princess (1915 film) (links · history · stats)
- ''The Space Report: The Authoritative Guide to Global Space Activity'' → Space Foundation (links · history · stats)
- ''The Star Conquerors'' → Ben Bova (links · history · stats)
- ''The Story of the Little Gentleman'' → Tomas von Brömssen (links · history · stats)
- ''The Universe'' (BYU) → The Universe (BYU) (links · history · stats)
- ''The Very Best of Asia: Heat of the Moment (1982-1990)'' → The Very Best of Asia: Heat of the Moment (1982–1990) (links · history · stats)
- ''The Wars for Asia 1911-1949'' → The Wars for Asia 1911–1949 (links · history · stats)
- ''The Wars for Asia 1911–1949'' → The Wars for Asia 1911–1949 (links · history · stats)
- ''The Way of the Warrior'' (BBC documentary series) → The Way of the Warrior (documentary series) (links · history · stats)
- ''The Wedding'' (play) → The Wedding (links · history · stats)
- ''The Witch's Cradle'' → The Witch's Cradle (links · history · stats)
- ''The Witch of Hebron'' → The Witch of Hebron (links · history · stats)
- ''The Women of Algiers in Their Apartment'' → Women of Algiers in Their Apartment (links · history · stats)
- ''They Call the Wind Maria'' → They Call the Wind Maria (links · history · stats)
- ''Tide''-class tanker → Tide-class tanker (links · history · stats)
- ''Time for Outrage!'' → Time for Outrage! (links · history · stats)
- ''To Walk the Clouds'' → The Walk (2015 film) (links · history · stats)
- ''Toby Alone'' → Toby Alone (links · history · stats)
- ''Tomorrow'' → Tomorrow (links · history · stats)
- ''Tonight Show'' Screengrabs → The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon (links · history · stats)
- ''Tony'' (''Skins'' series 1) → Tony (Skins series 1) (links · history · stats)
- ''Top Gear Australia'' → Top Gear Australia (links · history · stats)
- ''Top Secret'' (2014) → Top Secret (EP) (links · history · stats)
- ''Top Spot'' → Top Spot (links · history · stats)
- ''Treslei'' → Trysull (links · history · stats)
- ''Trial of Mihailović et al'' → Trial of Mihailović et al. (links · history · stats)
- ''Unfamiliar Fishes'' → Unfamiliar Fishes (links · history · stats)
- ''Unfinished Symphony'' (2001 film) → Unfinished Symphony: Democracy and Dissent (links · history · stats)
- ''Unfriend You'' → Hold On 'til the Night (links · history · stats)
- ''Vinayaka Geleyara Balaga'' → Vinayaka Geleyara Balaga (links · history · stats)
- ''Vultures'' → Vulture (disambiguation) (links · history · stats)
- ''WWE '14'' → WWE 2K14 (links · history · stats)
- ''Waging Heavy Peace: A Hippie Dream'' → Waging Heavy Peace (links · history · stats)
- ''War Becomes Academic'' → Human Terrain: War Becomes Academic (links · history · stats)
- ''We Steal Secrets: The Story of Wikileaks'' → We Steal Secrets: The Story of WikiLeaks (links · history · stats)
- ''Western Tradition Partnership, Inc. v. Attorney General of Montana'' → Western Tradition Partnership, Inc. v. Montana (links · history · stats)
- ''Wild Texas Wind'' → Wild Texas Wind (links · history · stats)
- ''XIII'' (Rage album) → XIII (Rage album) (links · history · stats)
- ''Xanthomonas oryzae'' pv. ''oryzae'' → Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae (links · history · stats)
- ''Yeh Hai Aashiqui'' → Yeh Hai Aashiqui (links · history · stats)
- ''Yume Nikki'' → Yume Nikki (links · history · stats)
- ''Zico'' Otieno → Zedekiah Otieno (links · history · stats)
- ''anti-Japanism'' → Anti-Japanese sentiment (links · history · stats)
- ''bodhisattva'' → Bodhisattva (links · history · stats)
- ''editor'' → Editor (links · history · stats)
- ''g''-suit → G-suit (links · history · stats)
- ''hat.'' → Hat. (album) (links · history · stats)
- ''high water mark'' → High water mark (links · history · stats)
- ''new seat'' → Electoral district (links · history · stats)
- ''squadristi'' → Milizia Volontaria per la Sicurezza Nazionale (links · history · stats)
- ''tlamemeh'' → Tlamemeh (links · history · stats)
- ''唐山'' → Tangshan (links · history · stats)
|
After observing recent consensus to delete other redirects that contained wiki markup, including consensus here at another RfD discussion, it seems that these redirects cause problems with coding and other functions of Knowledge (XXG) and links due to containing wiki markup. For example, the first nominated redirect is '', but if it is put into a {{No redirect}} template, this is how it appears between the following parenthesis: (''); it doesn't even appear. Also, the second nomination, '''Tis the Season'' (Vince Gill and Olivia Newton-John album), puts the link in bold when inserted in a template, and makes the first apostrophe completely disappear (the first apostrophe is part of the article's title). These redirects cause more technical harm than good, and if there is ever an instance where two consecutive apostrophes are needed, it will be a non wiki markup-affecting quotation mark ("), not two apostrophes in a row (''). This nomination contains all of the remaining redirects on the English Knowledge (XXG) (as of this moment) that start with at least two apostrophes. (Note to the closer: For the above-nominated redirects that had edit history that has to be retained per Knowledge (XXG):Attribution, I moved the attributions from that title to a similar title that does not have two consecutive apostrophes; I did this since I knew that if these are all by chance deleted, the attributions on these titles would need to be preserved.) Steel1943 (talk) 02:04, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
- Delete all 357 nominated redirects and any others with the same problem. These were typically created by dint of a perfectly understandable mistake about how wikimarkup works. However, they aren't going to be searched for (you would have to search for an inobvious sequence of single quotes in exactly the right places), they aren't going to be linked from off the wiki (ditto), and links on the wiki can be formatted properly - and often better - with correct markup and without the need for these redirects to exist. They all can, and should, go away. 209.211.131.181 (talk) 03:23, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
- I originally considered not nominating '' (two apostrophes); however, after I realized that it is subject to the same wiki markup errors as the other redirects (and even more so when linked in templates, as I discovered with {{No redirect}} with the entire link disappearing), I changed my mind. Also, as you said, " (quotation mark) exists. Steel1943 (talk) 07:04, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
- However, <code>''</code> is a possible search term, so whereas the others are not to be typed and some weird in wikicode linkage, the double-single-quote would be searchable. Double-single-quote would be similar to the double-double-quote "", and not equivalent to a single-double-quote ", as a search using paired entities instead of a single entity, as one might enter as quotes appear in pairs in normal text. -- 67.70.35.44 (talk) 06:27, 21 November 2014 (UTC)
- Keep '' it is a reasonable search term and looking at article traffic stats it has been used 130 times in the last 30 days. Delete all others.--Salix alba (talk): 08:17, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
- Comment & note: With regard to ''Southern Seas'' the redirect is a leftover and can be deleted or moved to a disambiguation page. I created it during clean up of ship references in which civilian, Navy and Army operated the ship named Southern Seas covered in the main article Lyndonia (1920). The italic marking is the problem here. The real need is for disambiguation of the term itself as another, all too limited, redirect of the term goes to Gringo-Gaucho, a naval exercise. Palmeira (talk) 11:44, 20 November 2014 (UTC)
- Delete: Per Nominators comment, which i agree with. Lor 02:04, 21 November 2014 (UTC)
- Delete away, especially any that are not linked to.NiD.29 (talk) 18:06, 22 November 2014 (UTC)
- NOTE I have just discovered that many (possibly all) the links to the usage stats for multiple word redirects nominated here are incorrect. For some reason the space is being replaced with "+" in the link not with "_". As "+" is a valid character in Knowledge (XXG) article titles, the stats shown are for pages other than the ones that have been nominated. Any comments that refer to the usage of these redirects need to be verified. Thryduulf (talk) 20:40, 22 November 2014 (UTC)
- NOTE 2 I have attempted to fix the stats links per my above note. The links I've tested work, but I haven't yet tested them all and I may have accidentally introduced other errors (I haven't spotted any). The note above regarding any mention of usage is still valid. Thryduulf (talk) 20:48, 22 November 2014 (UTC)
- I have so far examined only the first few redirects ("''" to "''All Hung up in Your Green Eyes''"), my recommendation for these is below. I will review the others as I get time:
- Keep the following:
- '' - very well used (>120 hits last month for example)
- ''12'' (2003_film) - well used (50-85 hits every month since May)
- ''ALF'' - {{R from move}}, there was content at this page from 2011 until earlier this month when it was redirect then moved. Incoming links are very likely.
- Keep but review in a few months (at least 3 full calendar months after this discussion is closed) when there is more evidence regarding usage. If the usage dies off to only bot levels (~5/month at most) then they can be nominated again then but if it doesn't they should be kept as being useful to humans (however unlikely that may look to experienced Wikipedians).
- ''A Soldier's Rosary''. Despite being at this title for only a day when it was created in July 2014 this is still getting a greater than bot only number of hits (12-20 each month), which is surprising. Could be external links.
- ''''Aechmea nudicaulis'' 'Parati'. Only one hit in August, but spiked to 13 in October and nearly 20 in the part of November before this nomination, some of that could be related to this nomination but as it isn't replicated in the others listed it is very unlikely to be the whole story (there is nothing in the edit history between 2013 at the nomination). This needs more data (which can only come with time) before a correct judgement can be made, so it should be kept until then.
- ''Affluenza''. This gets uses, over 1000 in Aguust, but only 15 in October. This suggests that it was linked from somewhere internally but no longer is. I'd suggest keeping this and reviewing the usage in a few months to see if the remaining use dies off (in which case we can safely delete it) or not (in which case it should be kept).
- ''Affluenza'' (2014). I fixed a link to this redirect that had been in the article almost certainly since August. This means there are lots of hits, but it is impossible to tell at the moment if there is any traffic from external sites.
- ''Aladdin'' (musical). The traffic stats give the distinct impression that this was linked until late August, but it had an upward spike again in October. The activity on this redirect in November was preceded by views that could have gone either way. Need to reevaluate with more data.
- Other notes
- Delete redirects not mentioned above that being with: ' . AN Ae Al Thryduulf (talk) 21:36, 22 November 2014 (UTC)
- Keep a few - keep the handful that others have asked to keep. These should be discussed in separate nominations. Delete the other 350 or so. Oiyarbepsy (talk) 06:58, 23 November 2014 (UTC)
Keep all. Too much in one go, impossible to go through them. For if not, let those who say "keep a few" or "keep some" list those they wish to keep. Otherwise, keep the lot as stet. I need then to check out 357 stats, 357 page histories, 357 discussion and talk pages, and wotnot? Am I supposed to discuss each by each or just rubber stamp? I am not prepared to rubber stamp so keep all until they are listed appropriately. Thryduulf started and I think gave up. It is bloating the page and every time I go to edit I have 357 redirect listings in front of me (I still edit in raw text so I get the whole dambed lot). Have some consideration. Si Trew (talk) 17:10, 24 November 2014 (UTC)
- Comment: Si Trew, as I stated above, I have already took the liberty of going through all of the redirects' page histories and moved all important attribution (including the ones that were previously articles) to other titles so that the closer would not have to through the redirects' histories with a "fine-tooth comb". However, the page links are another story; I didn't expect there to be any due to the wiki markup in the titles, but per above, it looks as though Thryduulf just destroyed that theory. I may have some time in a few hours to review the redirects' page links, and disambiguate/change their targets when necessary. Steel1943 (talk) 18:07, 24 November 2014 (UTC)
- Comment. Seems like pushing a rock up Mount Olympus, but if you're willing to do it, all power to your oboe. Si Trew (talk) 22:51, 24 November 2014 (UTC)
- Comment: At this point, all incoming links to these redirects that are unintentional (essentially all links that are not on a talk page or an archive unless referring to the page's edit history, with the exception of pages on the merge history "project pages") have been retarget to its proper target, usually the redirect's target itself. Here is a list of the redirects listed above which I fixed incoming links for the record:
- ''
- ''Birds of Prey'' (1973 film)
- ''Black Feminist Thought: Knowledge, Consciousness and the Politics of Empowerment''
- ''Bright Penny''
- ''Cardinal Burns''
- ''Curiosity'' rover
- ''Dave's Dream'' (B-29)
- ''Deliver'' (album)
- ''Elasmosaurus''
- ''FIFI'' (aircraft)
- ''Gemeindepolizei (Nazi Germany)''
- ''Hello, world!'' program
- ''Holy Shit''
- ''It's Geek 2 Me''
- ''Killing the Black Body: Race, Reproduction, and the Meaning of Liberty''
- ''L'Équipe'' (TV series)
- ''Lactifluus vellereus''
- ''List of Episodes of Bob and Margaret''
- ''Man Made Language'
- ''Naughty but Nice''
- ''Party in the Graveyard''
- ''Państwowy Korpus Bezpieczeństwa''
- ''Plasmodium falciparum'' cell biology
- ''Q'' magazine
- ''Siegfried'' August Maximilian Maria, Duke in Bavaria
- ''Small Talk (Twenty Twenty Album)
- ''The Cauldron''
- ''The Glenn Miller Story'' (soundtrack)
- ''The Natural History of Ireland''
- ''The New York Times'' Best Seller list
- ''The Outcasts'' (1982 film)
- ''The Pagan Religions of the Ancient British Isles''
- ''The Wars for Asia 1911–1949''
- ''Top Secret'' (2014)
- ...These redirects had incoming links that needed to be updated. Steel1943 (talk) 01:52, 25 November 2014 (UTC)
- The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page.